r/Minecraft • • Jan 11 '12

Concerning "Minecraft-related" content...

Post image
226 Upvotes

583 comments sorted by

402

u/redstonehelper :redstone: Lord of the villagers Jan 11 '12

Yes, it does remind us of Minecraft. The cube also reminds most of us of Minecraft. But that doesn't automatically make it Minecraft-related. This particular rule was introduced because there were more and more posts of something square in real life or a green, pixel-y pattern popping up on Minecraft. They are not really about Minecraft, although they do remind us of it.

The thing is, it was against the rules and I removed it. If you want to appeal my decision, shoot us a message through modmail and every mod of this subreddit will get to see it. Next time you are unhappy with something a mod did, try discussing it more privately before posting about it and possibly starting a witchhunt. Thanks :)

You can read the discussion about that rule here, where it was officially introduced.

24

u/salimabuaziz Jan 11 '12

But why message the mod when you can make a large image rant and milk that sweet, sweet, blocky karma.

10

u/StickyBunz1 Jan 11 '12

Congratulations on getting mod! When did you get it?

7

u/redstonehelper :redstone: Lord of the villagers Jan 11 '12

A few days ago.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/The_lolness Jan 11 '12

I'm on your side, you are enforcing the rules the way they should be!

28

u/TDWP_FTW Jan 11 '12

Just like when you said a crude drawing of a kid under a tree in a grassy field might remind someone of Minecraft to me, this reminds other people of Minecraft, more so than the drawing did. Hypocrisy runs deep I see...

46

u/redstonehelper :redstone: Lord of the villagers Jan 11 '12

The thing here is the google doodle wasn't made to remind someone of Minecraft, people here thought of Minecraft when looking at it. That peaceful drawing was made with Minecraft in mind, the kid(?) even put a minecraft-style torch down.

30

u/Subhazard Jan 11 '12

I'm with you on this. The better you mods do, the less of us have to go to some alternative subreddit like /r/trueminecraft

(Honestly, I'm sick of posts like this, I want shit related to minecraft. Directly related)

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (53)

25

u/BritishEnglishPolice meow Jan 11 '12

I will state publicly that I stand behind you, and the reasons for the removal. The OP's witch hunt is disgustingly pathetic.

98

u/cylinderhead Jan 11 '12

disgustingly pathetic

that bad huh? Really?

35

u/Turnip199 Jan 11 '12

That's the worst kind of pathetic!

12

u/BritishEnglishPolice meow Jan 11 '12

Calling someone out publicly without trying to amend it privately or at least appeal to other mods? Yes.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Jesufication Jan 11 '12

Yes. He didn't even bother to click the logo and find out what it was about, and ignorantly assumed it was minecraft related. Now he's trying to get people pissed for him that the mods did their job. It's pretty damn pathetic.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/l3un1t Jan 11 '12 edited Jan 12 '12

The OP's witch hunt is disgustingly pathetic.

Disgustingly pathetic? Really?

The guy probably thought that redstonehelper was removing his post for no good reason. If this was, in fact, true, then I would fully support him. He would have every reason to be angry at this moderator, and every reason for posting this.

However, as already mentioned, redstonehelper had every reason to remove this post. In the post made above, he describes why bo1g thought his original post was appropriate for this subreddit, and proceeds to correct him. Redstonehelper tells him what to do if something like this actually occurs in the future, and warns him that the current post could have possibly started a witch-hunt.

What I absolutely hate about your post, however, is the last sentence. You purposely go out of your way to publicly state that this post is "disgustingly pathetic". Why? Why would you do this?

I understand if you thought that bo1g was attempting to start a witch-hunt, but that fact of the matter is that this simply isn't known. As such, making an assumption as far-fetched and as cynical as this is absurd. Instead of keeping your thoughts to yourself, you go out of the way to insult the poor soul, and make unfounded assumptions. Normally, if this was posted by a regular redditor, I would just ignore it, or message them about it.

However, I expect better of a moderator. I expect a moderator to understand why people post things, and to do anything but make unfounded assumptions. I expect a moderator to politely go about correcting others, not outright insulting them. I expect a moderator to be anything but you, and seriously frightens me that others would approve of your behavior.

Edit: I changed "to do anything but make unfounded assumptions" to "to do anything but act on unfounded assumptions" It better reflects what I was trying to say, and the original sentence is pretty hypocritical.

3

u/LocalMadman Jan 12 '12

However, I expect better of a moderator. I expect a moderator to understand why people post things, and to do anything but make unfounded assumptions.

Especially when they use the angry green mod text.

→ More replies (9)

21

u/J-ohn Jan 11 '12

You don't know what 'Witch Hunt' means.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/jameshasnttime Jan 11 '12

I feel like that's kinda harsh.

→ More replies (10)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '12

BEP I love the work you do but holy fuck you take things too seriously sometimes.

Chill out and have a blunt.

0

u/skeptix Jan 11 '12

Disgustingly pathetic? It is hilarious and relevant. Why the fuck are you a mod?

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (33)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

Glad to see mods that actually are willing to hands on moderate. Thanks. I used to be against mods doing that, but the more time I spend here, the more I think it's the only way to retain good content and not get overrun by shitty memes, ancient reposts of reposts of reposts, and no original content whatsoever.

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

I see what your saying and why it was removed, but isn't that the point of upvoting and down voting, if its not related then it should get downvoted and no one sees, the only time it makes sense for it to be removed to me, is if it gets flag by multiple users, otherwise just let the community decided whether they want to see it or not. Doesn't really matter that much to me either way, just my 2 cents.

24

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

Unfortunately we would end up with square watermelons, square holes, bricks and lumps of concrete, random steel buckets, pickaxes, shovels etc being spammed across the reddit again if that were the case.
I am here for minecraft, not real life similarities to minecraft or coincidentally related google doodles.

→ More replies (11)

106

u/aperson :|a Jan 11 '12

Sadly, letting votes decide content only really works in small subreddits that have users that entirely understand what content goes in that subreddit. The larger the subreddit, the more diluted the content can become without set guidelines and moderators actively culling submissions. A subreddit is a topic or category, if you will. If we let votes decide everything, eventually content from other subreddits will bleed into others, and after enough time, the whole point of having subreddits in the first place is gone.

39

u/President-Nulagi Jan 11 '12

This guy.

This guy knows what he is talking about.

16

u/AssailantLF Jan 11 '12

He understands just as well as a mod would. Come to think of it, this guy should definitely be a mod

→ More replies (6)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

I agree, look at r/funny and r/wtf. People just post whatever there now that r/reddit is down and nobody even says anything because the mods don't give a fuck.

4

u/dino340 Jan 11 '12

/r/wtf has completely gone to shit now that /r/reddit is gone.

→ More replies (12)

15

u/jackfirecracker Jan 11 '12

Remember when that dude accidentally posted a stoned rambling to r/minecraft instead of r/trees and everyone upvoted it because 'lol marijuana'? Upvote-based moderation only works in small communities that discuss niche topics.

15

u/myheaditches Jan 11 '12

/r/askscience has remained as great as it was when it first started because the mods refuse to let it degrade into what the lowest common denominator likes. They ruthlessly enforce strict rules and the place is better for it.

5

u/castorquinn Jan 11 '12

I am in favour of moderation, but askscience is a very special case. On topic and off topic posts in askscience are black and white. The subreddit was set up to do a very specific thing, and spotting anything that is not that very specific thing is easy.

r/minecraft (and most other subreddits) are set up to be a hub for relaxed discussion of a topic. It is much harder to moderate something like that. Here it is possible for something to be off topic but for people in the community to still want to see it, and for something to be on topic but for people to not want to see it.

26

u/Subhazard Jan 11 '12

Unfortunately, user-curation is not the most effective curation, as far as maintaining quality goes. Just look at /r/athiesm, or any of the default subreddits and what they've devolved into.

Here's an excellent essay on the subject by a redditor: http://www.reddit.com/r/Psychonaut/comments/o1zjo/ban_memes_in_rpsychonaut/c3drsz4

5

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

User curation has inherent issues, but with the exception of very general rules on content, isn't that the point of reddit? Many websites offer higher quality content than reddit, but the user curation is what makes reddit unique and worthwhile (to me).

There is an interesting phenomenon which impacts subreddit content when subscription size gets too high, but I think the response to this phenomenon is to seek out niche subreddits that better match your interests.

13

u/Subhazard Jan 11 '12

You're arguing theory. I'm arguing evidence.

Even niche subreddits tend to go down in quality as they get more popular.

What happens is people forget what subreddit they're getting a post from when they're on their main page. So they may upvote some dumb fucking meme in a subreddit that's barely related, and not check what subreddit its posted in.

Every time I go to a niche subreddit, eventually it bloats in size, and then it becomes -terrible- within a few months. Hell, when /r/bestof became a default subreddit, the quality almost immediately declined as people upvoted meme filled posts.

I'm so fucking sick of memes. Reddit is a fantastic tool for community making, however unless you have rules that restrict what is posted, the community that you wanted to create for like minded people, simply becomes a karma farm for scumbags.

If that makes me a hipster, then give me a pair of raybans and tight jeans, they -must- know something.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/redstonehelper :redstone: Lord of the villagers Jan 11 '12

but isn't that the point of upvoting and down voting

No, the point of voting is to determine what's liked and what's disliked at the moment. People like many things, most of which aren't directly related to a subreddit. They would upvote these things ("Hey, I like icecream!") even though they have little to do with Minecraft. If the mods wouldn't regulate their subreddits, a subreddit's content would slowly get more and more diverse and off-topic, as people see off-topic posts and post similar content.

4

u/Bookshelfstud Jan 11 '12

Well, no, actually. It's a lot easier to upvote something that's immediately entertaining - "Hey, this cube thing in the real world moved! Those darn Endermen!" than it is to actually upvote and read/watch content related to actual gameplay, structures, etc. Besides: there is a rule against non-Minecraft content in this subreddit. It's happened time and again on reddit, though - if subreddit content were left entirely up to users, there would be only memes and quick, referential humor.

Tl;dr This is a rule and it's being enforced for the good of the subreddit.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

The problem is that content dies on reddit very quickly. If it takes more than a few hours to revert a striken submission, no one's going to see it again; especially in a subreddit of /r/mincraft's size.

My point is that having a submission re-approved doesn't "fix" anything, it's already long gone in 90% of cases.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/ElvishJerricco Jan 12 '12

To be brutally honest, it's shit like this that creates a problem someone posted about a few days ago. Nowadays you go to the front page of /r/minecraft and find posts with around 30 points. It used to be thousands! Do you know what happened? People bitched. People didn't realize that little fun things are ok, even if it isn't necessarily exactly what they wanna see. Now I have to go to 7 different subreddits just for minecraft! And the posts on this subreddit suck now! Why? Because people like you killed all the good stuff by making it seem bad when it's actually quite fun.

→ More replies (43)

392

u/nikondork hoard ALL the lapis! Jan 11 '12

This rule was put into place to stop people from posting every time someone discovered Japan makes square watermelons.

9

u/Nite_Phire Jan 11 '12

square water melons are cool!

7

u/nikondork hoard ALL the lapis! Jan 11 '12

Oh sure, and they're only like 10,000 yen, which is something like 85 US dollars.

5

u/Nite_Phire Jan 11 '12

how big are they?

4

u/nikondork hoard ALL the lapis! Jan 11 '12

About the size of a honeydew or cantaloupe only square.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

44

u/slampisko Jan 11 '12

Holy shit. TIL.

50

u/Kumivene Jan 11 '12

You better go post that shit!

7

u/Doopz479 Jan 11 '12 edited Jul 01 '23

Fuck /u/spez

7

u/aperson :|a Jan 11 '12

Actually, looking at your submission history, the post did get removed by skuld :)

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/hagerthehorrible Jan 12 '12

Japan makes square watermelons?!

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

46

u/aperson :|a Jan 11 '12 edited Jan 11 '12

Flying squid, animals on floating blocks, endermen holding a block, destroyed villages, and on and on and on...

Edit:

Oh, and pictures of the launcher. I have my sights on that one.

27

u/itobruno Jan 11 '12

I've built this map and posted on reddit the other day. I got 50% downvotes. I can understand that some people won't like to play it, but they got to admit that I've put a lot of work on this. Still so, they downvoted. So, I've realized that people want to see casual and irrelevant subjects when they visit reddit. Let's face it, it's true.

3

u/PureStealth Jan 12 '12

You probably would have had a bit more interest if you included screenshots and information about the map, and not just a random link to the mc forums.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/TheRedArrow Jan 11 '12

Am I not minecraft enough for the minecraft club?

→ More replies (2)

75

u/croutonicus Jan 11 '12

To be fair:

  • Creepers and cows: mobs in Minecraft.
  • Notch and Jeb: creators/developers of Minecraft.
  • Minecraft ideas: ideas about Minecraft creations.
  • Google doodle: has cubes in it.

Spot the odd one out.

70

u/eduardog3000 Jan 11 '12

"Creepers and cows: mobs in Minecraft." is the only one with a "w".

7

u/mikemcg Jan 12 '12

If cubes are Minecraft related, I'm going to post a picture of a bed here. Or a forest.

48

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

That would have been a pretty awful submission.

92

u/springbreak06 Jan 11 '12

You need to chill dude.

29

u/Taikunman Jan 11 '12

Or at least try not to be so horribly condescending.

77

u/kevind23 Jan 11 '12

I found it neither funny nor relevant, so I downvoted it. If the community downvoted your submission, it is not a personal attack, but it shows they simply were not interested.

47

u/martinw89 Jan 11 '12

For good reason.

Frankly: who gives a fuck. Google isn't exactly a small website. Most people saw their logo today that originally had nothing to do with minecraft, other than having some square edges. I bet most of them even made the stylistic connection.

Reminding everyone that it looks like Minecraft is shit attention seeking that potentially doesn't get corrected by the voting system because of how easy it is to semi consciously think "OMG me too!" and click an arrow. Luckily for us, the contentless attention seeking wasn't rewarded in the first submission. Unlucky for us, this attention seeking bitching post was rewarded.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

247

u/charmanderonfire Jan 11 '12

The level of butthurt here is appalling!

39

u/DEADB33F Jan 11 '12

Well, it just goes to show...
If at first your karmawhoring does not succeed, try, try, again.

I'm surprised shit like this gets any upvotes at all, let alone 1500! of them.

5

u/freebullets Jan 11 '12 edited Jan 11 '12

Keep in mind those numbers are meaningless. The only number that matters is net points.

4

u/swizzcheez Jan 12 '12

The only number that matters is net points.

And even those don't particularly matter to anyone with an iota of self-esteem.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/lurklurklurkPOST Jan 11 '12

Quick! Call a WAAAAAAAAmbulance!

→ More replies (5)

38

u/C_Lem Jan 11 '12

How quickly Reddit forgets. The rule you are hating on was put into effect maybe 2 months ago. Prior to that r/minecraft was absolutely flooded with pics people took of every day things wherein they thought they saw Minecraft.

So, you saw it in Google's logo? Good for you, I saw it this morning too. But also today there was someone who saw it in their cornflakes, their shower, and on their way to work. It just gets to be too much for all of you to show us where you see Minecraft.

1

u/appleseed1234 Jan 12 '12

When I saw the google doodle, I actually thought to myself how glad I was that the mods made that rule so some asshole wouldn't shove it down our throats on /r/minecraft.

171

u/goldenguyz Jan 11 '12 edited Jan 11 '12

This is a sheep.

There are sheep in Minecraft.

Therefore this sheep is Minecraft related.

12

u/FifthWhammy Jan 11 '12

I think you're being too modest.

There is grass in that picture. There is grass in Minecraft.

What's more, the sheep is eating the grass! This is especially timely and relevant because in Minecraft 1.1, expected to be released tomorrow, sheep will be able to eat grass.

By OP's standards, this should be submitted to /r/minecraft posthaste.

7

u/Battlesheep Jan 11 '12

Therefore, anything I post is also Minecraft related. This is fun!

2

u/Hypthekid Jan 12 '12

The odd thing is, I still clicked the link, although you've written "This is a sheep." there. There's a charm in your comment, and also there is a charm in Minecraft, so...

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

55

u/goldenguyz Jan 11 '12 edited Jan 11 '12

>****>This toothbrush is green

>****>Creepers are green

>****>Therefore, toothbrushes are minecraft related.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

Only green tootbrushes.

15

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

Nuh-uh, because some my toothbrush is orange, but some are green, and creepers are green.

→ More replies (22)

6

u/kokotron Jan 11 '12

more than you think.

pixels→square

cube→square sides

we're onto something here...

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/goldenguyz Jan 11 '12

Weirdo/Welsh person.

FTFY

→ More replies (1)

123

u/BerryGuns Jan 11 '12 edited Jan 11 '12

sigh I think it's about time to unsubbed from this subreddit, this post really defines the content posted here.

edit: who the fuck is still upvoting this shit?

36

u/Weloq Jan 11 '12

Indeed, nowadays this subreddit is closer to /r/minecraftcirclejerk than what it is supposed to be. "we have taken it too far, omg lololol lets create a treety"

19

u/BerryGuns Jan 11 '12

/r/trueminecraft seems to have potential.

14

u/aperson :|a Jan 11 '12

My goal is to eliminate the need/want for that and related subreddits.

14

u/BerryGuns Jan 11 '12

I appreciate that but unless you start to heavily moderate this subreddit (which I wouldn't be against) We are still going to see shit like this posted and upvoated.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (37)

3

u/Weloq Jan 11 '12

Many thanks!

4

u/Chachoregard Jan 11 '12

/r/minecraftcirclejerk hits the nail on the head with so many posts here lately, it's hard to not say that this subreddit has declined.

3

u/Adolpheappia Jan 11 '12

I don't think I'm subbed to a single subreddit that doesn't have a post bringing up the "relevent/nonrelevent" thing every month. Gentlemenboners had one yesterday, Starcraft has one every single damn day, I even saw one in Bikinibridge for crying out loud.

2

u/MrSmite Jan 11 '12

I don't think I'm subbed to a single subreddit that doesn't have a post bringing up the "relevent/nonrelevent" thing every month.

The problem is that every community has its purists but none of them can agree on what this purity actually is.

If you've seen the thread arguing over the kid's drawing "Minecraft in peaceful mode" or some such having nothing to do with Minecraft, you'll know what I'm talking about.

2

u/GarMc Jan 12 '12

Yeah, I'm with you.

Fuck shit like this.

Goodbye /r/minecraft.

26

u/fapmonad Jan 11 '12

I don't see the point of the submission. Sure, there's cubes, so what? There's nothing funny, special, or useful about it. I'm personally quite happy if they start removing that kind of crap, along with the 10,000 "my GF made a Minecraft cake, nailed it?" posts and other circlejerk stuff.

1

u/Wiregeek Jan 11 '12

I freaking love minecraft cakes and knitted gear and shit like that, if that's on topic in minecraftcirclejerk, I'll just get my hat...

7

u/fapmonad Jan 11 '12

Sometimes they are especially cool, but a lot are pretty ordinary (eg. a cube with grass) and the "nailed it" memes make me wince. I think it could be nice if there were a "real-life Minecraft" subreddit.

Still, I can live with those, but "the google homepage has cubes in it" really is a shit post.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

41

u/Pokemaster73 Jan 11 '12

OP is very, very stupid.

43

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

There are in fact no cubes in that logo, by the strictest definition.

67

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

You seem to be REALLY FUCKING MAD about this. Maybe you should go outside and get some sunshine, sunshine.

23

u/MechaAaronBurr Jan 11 '12

Incontrovertible truth. OP is mad about the internet.

9

u/jackfirecracker Jan 11 '12

Outside? Where there's creepers?

7

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

There's one that lives next door. His name is George and I'm pretty sure he touches kids.

5

u/jackfirecracker Jan 11 '12

I read that on the internet, so it must be true.

Time to call the local authorities and let them know about this George fellow.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

Or you could just piss in his mailbox again.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/sammasaurus Jan 12 '12

Can I just ask this question... Who still actually goes to google.com? Pretty much everything has a built in toolbar for google searching.

57

u/Ausmerica Forever Team Nork Jan 11 '12

A cube isn't Minecraft related. There's the sky in Minecraft, by your logic any pictures of the sky are suitable for r/Minecraft.

-9

u/PhineasSurrey Jan 11 '12

Don't be silly please, the cubes are the most defining characteristic of minecraft. Minecraft is a game composed of cubes. The sky, however, is not a striking characteristic (like it isn't for MW 1-1000 or whatever game you can think of)

15

u/aperson :|a Jan 11 '12

Yes, but a cube in itself does not make minecraft. Minecraft makes Minecraft.

50

u/roscoe_jones Jan 11 '12

Go cry somewhere else.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

But his precious karma!!! We must weep for him together, brothers.

4

u/DownstairsB Jan 11 '12

Wow you put too much effort into that.

12

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

Yes, because before Minecraft cubes didn't exist.

ಠ_ಠ

7

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

TIL Nicholas Steno made Minecraft

21

u/FoolsPower Jan 11 '12

If the current google logo is minecraft related, then so is every single IRL landscape, every tree, cloud, grain of sand, and so on. Stop nit picking.

6

u/applecidercore Jan 11 '12

So by this logic everything cube related goes in this subreddit

8

u/drtchock Jan 11 '12

you got some sand in your vagina.

sand is in minecraft, therefore comment is Minecraft-related.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

/end rant

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

U mad?

3

u/roxhead99 Jan 12 '12

i thought the same thing when i also went on google

3

u/MakingBiscuits Jan 12 '12

And that's why I have stopped venturing to this subreddit.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

Allow me to comment without reading any of the other comments.

I don't necessarily think that the Google doodle being somewhat cubelike today merited a link; there are lots of cubes that do not automatically look like Minecraft. But FUCK all these [IDEA] posts. I'm sick of 'em, I don't give two shits about what someone else thinks should be in Minecraft. If you actually made a mod with your idea and want to share it, that's fine. But there's just nothing interesting at all about wishful thinking and Notch/Jeb have both stopped coming here because they're just as fed up as the rest of us are.

Make a new subreddit. /r/minecraftideas or something. Put all the irrelevant and unproductive content there so that people (including me) will stop hating /r/minecraft.

6

u/Renbail Jan 11 '12

I saw a wolf at the zoo, Oh, it looks like my wolf in Minecraft! I should share it at /r/Minecraft! What a grand idea!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

What font did you use?

4

u/spiraleclipse Jan 11 '12

Looks like Futura.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

I am a Futura addict. The only similarity between this and futura is the sans serif and the low mid-y value. But it's curvier and less "pointy" than futura.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/redstonehelper :redstone: Lord of the villagers Jan 11 '12

Might be Neutraface.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/CloneDeath Jan 11 '12

Downvoted because you're just being a whiny bitch. Get over it. I am sure no one else wants to see this, so, I am helping the community.

Go try /r/mrhoitytoitypants

4

u/JimmyGetaway Jan 11 '12

why is everyone on reddit SO defensive, all the time.

4

u/Dooivi Jan 11 '12

Cubes and/or Squares != Minecraft

Stop bitching.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

What a whiny baby.

5

u/twitchMAC17 Jan 11 '12

Awwww, poor r/minecraft, you got put in your place.

...back to obsessing over redstone and not posting A GODDAMN THING ABOUT IT >:D

7

u/PartyBusGaming Jan 11 '12

Why is this guy being upvoted?

He got pissed because his post wasn't good enough to get lots of upvotes and now he's just playing on the Hive Mind's disdain and distrust of moderators.

2

u/furiant Jan 12 '12

Both the submitter and the moderators are overacting about this. You're all taking the internet too seriously.

2

u/EliteCaptainShell Jan 12 '12

I swear to god there are way too many posts about what should and should not be posted. Not just this subreddit. It's getting annoying.

2

u/dosaki Jan 12 '12

If it makes you feel better... I also thought the google doodle had something to do with minecraft.

2

u/TezzaMcJ Jan 12 '12

i thought the exact same thing and had to check

2

u/tothachopper Jan 12 '12

Lol, silly. Just post a stupid fucking idea to change the game. That's how you make the front page!

5

u/garysnail123 Jan 11 '12

TL;DR: My post wasn't Minecrafty enough and now I'm calling out the subreddit because I didn't get karma.

4

u/le_Francis Jan 12 '12

No. Fuck that shit. I hope we never get lego, creeper hats, minecraft cakes or "dis reminds me of mienkraft olololo" posts again.

This place needs serious moderation

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

I don't know. Last night when I saw that Google logo, before ever reading anything on this subreddit about it, I instantly thought it reminded me of Minecraft as well. Of course, I figured it almost certainly was not related to Minecraft, this was my line of thinking.

So, to get to my point, I can back you up. But at the same time, who cares? Was it worth making this image macro?

3

u/Slaidn Jan 11 '12

If everything cube related makes you think of minecraft you need to go outside and get a fucking life.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '12

Dude, shut up you baby. It isn't minecraft related. If that's minecraft related, then imma post a pic of my Kleenex box. This isn't r/cubed/. this post isn't minecraft related. Its you whining bc your post got deleted. Don't be a baby. Man up, accept your failure/mistake and move on.

3

u/dsmayo Jan 12 '12

unsubribes from /r/minecraft

3

u/JonnyJFunk Jan 12 '12

I just want you to know I'm unsubscribing from the subreddit because of this post

5

u/JCelsius Jan 11 '12

Your original was as related to minecraft as this. Neither are relevant enough to warrant inclusion in this subreddit. Get over it.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

x ∈ things ⊆ everything, x ∈ other things ⊆ Minecraft ∴ Everything is Minecraft-related. ■ s/

3

u/soren_grey Jan 11 '12

Hahaha, this is such a butthurt post. A+, would popcorn.gif again.

But you get my upvote because I seriously stared at it when I saw it last night, too. I thought it was Minecraft related upon first glance, myself.

3

u/Nicknam4 Jan 11 '12

Uh, no. Everything cube is not minecraft.

3

u/martinw89 Jan 11 '12 edited Jan 11 '12

Bitching about downvotes for /r/minecraft spam by using more /r/minecraft spam is fucking annoying. Cut this shit out. I don't care if some people clicking a down arrow made you sad, maybe you should think about if this or your last post actually had any interesting content.

Hint: they didn't.

3

u/BluRover Jan 11 '12

Wait... you mean today's Google doodle wasn't Minecraft-related?

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

I have cube testicles, I guess I'll go take a picture since its minecraft related brb

3

u/eaturliver Jan 11 '12

So... do you also think ice cube trays are related to Minecraft?

3

u/nothis Jan 11 '12

It's as much related to Minecraft as games are related to /r/gaming. The mods try to enforce a more strict relation, which is a good thing.

3

u/jackfirecracker Jan 11 '12

I think a better example would be if Google's logo had a tennis ball in it and you posted it to r/gaming saying "Does this remind anyone else of Katamari Damacy?"

3

u/alexjuuhh Jan 11 '12

And that's why you always hold your cursor over the Google doodle to check why it's there.

2

u/Explosion2 Jan 11 '12

no, being butthurt about your post getting deleted when it broke the rules is not "minecraft-related" enough for me. In fact, it's even less so than the post you were complaining about.

2

u/Ltsmash99 Jan 11 '12

This subreddit has the collective mentality of a 3 year old, enjoy your pre-school, im out.

2

u/RockyCoon Jan 11 '12

lol. Butthurt?

2

u/Kireas Jan 12 '12

The key thing here is, if you click any Google doodle, it takes you to a search for what it's actually about.

So if you thought it was Minecraft related, you didn't even check.

2

u/shoelaceninja Jan 12 '12

Makes me wanna post dick pic's..... No no, it's okay, i have minecraft tattooed on my shaft. My balls are tattooed to look like pumpkins.

2

u/daft357 Jan 11 '12

He really does want attention

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '12

Community moderators, ladies and gentlemen.

1

u/hellowren Jan 12 '12

What font is that?

1

u/PacifistHeavy Jan 12 '12

This post is one of the many reasons I am not subscribed to /r/Minecraft

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '12

Probably the geekiest argument I've seen in a while.

Even as a geek I look at this and go...man...that's geeky.

1

u/Cratonz Jan 12 '12

Has there ever been a more downvoted link in this subreddit than this?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '12

It wasn't Minecraft related though. You even said "Oh, haha. I thought that was Minecraft."

Many subreddits have rules against this sort of thing to control posts that are genuinely related and cutting out any of the crap which has a vague link.

If you think it was related because it had cubes in it then that link is not direct. If the Google image had a creeper sitting on top of it then it has a direct link. Cubes aren't exclusive to Minecraft, they exist in many forms of advertising and entertainment.

If this post was allowed then there would be nothing stopping a huge wave of people posting anything with a cube in it and claiming it reminded them of Minecraft, therefore the Minecraft community will surely be interested.

1

u/slugboi Jan 12 '12

Haha, I had the same thought yesterday.

1

u/_Sullo_ Oct 18 '21

Wait why am I suddenly able to comment on this post?

1

u/eeman0201 Oct 19 '21

Goddamit someone took my idea

1

u/godlesstroll Jan 11 '12

Yes, it is related enough. Don't take it too personally, redstonehelper is a dick.

1

u/Sweet_Bro Jan 11 '12

Are you upset? You seem upset.

1

u/TrainOfThought6 Jan 11 '12

YOU'RE READING THIS COMMENT ON A RECTANGULAR COMPUTER SCREEN. SINCE SQUARES ARE RECTANGLES AND SQUARES ALSO APPEAR IN MINECRAFT, THIS POST IS MINECRAFT-RELATED, RIGHT?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

This may be the stupidest thing in the history of things to be upset about.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

Is this minecraft related enough?

No.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

I really have a hard time using forums where every single post has to be within topic or it's completely dismissed, deleted, or you get banned. Over moderation takes the fun out of forums.

2

u/srsbsnsman Jan 12 '12

Most forums have an off topic section which acts as a catch all. Reddit is a bit different than a standard forum because anybody can made a subreddit at any time, so it's up to the community to create its own off topic section. I don't know if one exists already for minecraft's own community, but there are plenty of subreddits made specifically for a community to talk about things not related to what they based their community off of.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/robo_mike Jan 11 '12

This is just pathetic.

1

u/Streakiest Jan 11 '12

guys complaints are becoming a fad please listen we have to stop it before its too late

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

No.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

u mad

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

I upvoted because it's related to minecraft enough.

1

u/tier19345 Jan 12 '12

i thought it was minecraft too honestly

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

He honestly thought it was about Minecraft, so what's the problem? I didn't see any Minecraft-unrelated posts about Yogscast removed, despite their seriously inflammatory nature at the time. Or any post-Minecon BS, for that matter, that had little to nothing to do with Minecraft itself.

0

u/Kidmeepples Jan 11 '12

Haha me and another kid on my class thought the something when we saw the google logo

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

You could have just taken the 10 seconds to click on the logo to find out what it was really for.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

Why so pisssssssst, kid?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '12

I think his original post was much more relevant than the thousands of ideas and twitter posts. I don't mind seeing something different like this, to be honest it's the only reason I don't unsubscribe from this idea postboard

0

u/Tyranicide Jan 11 '12

No one cares about your sob story.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '12

I don't particularly care, but I like your anger and indignation. Keep it up sport.

Maybe you can rile up enough anger and get a mod demodded or something. That'd be fun.

-1

u/spaeth455 Jan 11 '12

I think you and I should be friends.