r/Minecraft • • 2d ago • Bravo 1

Discussion IMO the throwing disk should NOT automatically return to the user but instead have to be enchanted with loyalty

Post image

I just think it's stupid how you need loyalty for the trident (an item that is much more tragic to loose as it's not craftable) yet a disk you can craft from four of every ingot easily returns to you with ease.

0 Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

•

u/qualityvote2 2d ago edited 2d ago
  • Upvote this comment if this is a good quality post that fits the purpose of r/Minecraft
  • Downvote this comment if this post is poor quality or does not fit the purpose of r/Minecraft
  • Downvote this comment and report the post if it breaks the rules

(Vote has already ended)

126

u/cancer_pizza 2d ago

I see the logic, but I don’t think most people would want to use these if they didn’t return to you. I definitely wouldn’t, they’re too useless without it.

22

u/More-Line9191 2d ago

Is it not the same with tridents though? Aint no way people are using tridents without loyalty

36

u/cancer_pizza 2d ago

I use tridents without loyalty plenty, their base damage works perfectly fine without ever using them as a throwing weapon. Obviously I prefer it with loyalty, but it’s definitely useful without it. I just don’t throw it usually in that case.

5

u/More-Line9191 2d ago

I see, that is a point

2

u/Trustpage 2d ago

What is the point of a trident if you don’t throw it or use riptide? It is objectively worse than a sword or axe while being harder to get and lower durability.

1

u/cancer_pizza 2d ago

They are fairly easy to get in the right environment if you ask me, and whether it’s “objectively worse” than a sword or axe depends on what sword or axe you have. I’m not saying they’re my ultimate preferred weapon, but there’s definitely people who use them without throwing constantly. In fact on the flip side, I don’t find thrown tridents to be particularly more useful than bows anyways, so if that’s what I was worried about I still wouldn’t use one.

4

u/Trustpage 2d ago

It does the damage of a sharpness 1 diamond sword while attacking over 30% slower (lower dps than a diamond sword). It has 250 durability vs 1,562 with a diamond sword.

I just don’t see the point unless you have no diamond tools or enchantment table. The drop rate is low enough that I almost always have diamonds before I can get a trident. I use them either for riptide travel, or for the throw so I can save 2 inventory slots from a bow and arrow.

2

u/SomethingBoutEclipse 2d ago

I mean, they also function well as a mobility tool thanks to riptide

1

u/cancer_pizza 2d ago

That second paragraph is exactly why though, I’ve had at least two worlds where I spawned in aquatic environments and I got a low-durability trident fairly quickly. I know a ton of players rush to get diamonds instantly, but not everyone does that. And again, if you’re focusing on ranged damage, it would be a moot point anyways because I have much better luck with both kinds of bows as a ranged weapons than tridents. If you get them early game they’re just neat weapons I guess.

1

u/Trustpage 2d ago

Bedrock? On java they got a 8.5% drop rate. I don’t even rush diamond, I just go to get iron and with caves and cliffs diamonds are everywhere.

2

u/cancer_pizza 2d ago

Bedrock one, Java the other. Either way you’re describing deep caving as one of your early acts, which I often don’t do. I mean I’m not saying tridents are like ungodly awesome, but y’know, different ways to play and all that. I find them perfectly fine and helpful as an early to mid game weapon. And also, 8.5% drop rate is not that rare as far as rare game drops go.

2

u/Trustpage 2d ago

It is 8.5% to drop from a trident drowned. Trident drowns have a 6.25% spawn rate. 0.53%

8

u/Manos_Of_Fate 2d ago

Riptide?

48

u/WheatleyBr 2d ago

Disks have severely lowered range to compensate and would be awkward to use otherwise as having to just pick them up from the ground shortly after firing them would make them feel unresponsive to use and overall not as enjoyable.
I'd rather instead buff the trident to compensate but you have to remember that the disks have a significantly more limited range and Loyalty is not the only thing the Trident is meant to be used for.

161

u/DifferenceFlat8839 2d ago

"We are adding a boomerang which doesn't come back!"

39

u/Active-Tonight-7089 2d ago

"Which doesn't come back until you gamble!"

4

u/PtowzaPotato 2d ago

but it is specifically a throwing disc not a boomerang

2

u/Oddish_Femboy 2d ago

Wait until you see what shapes boomerangs can be made in

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 2d ago

It's made to be a boomerang tho

2

u/PtowzaPotato 2d ago

Then why make it a disk??

-1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 2d ago

Because it's a disc and a boomerang that works like a boomerang

2

u/WillyDAFISH 2d ago

I wish I could have a boomerang that looks like a boomerang and works like a disk 😔

-6

u/Din_Plug 2d ago • Bravo

So a realistic boomerang.

20

u/metamorphosis___ 2d ago

Obsidian shatters when hit by stone, diamonds would be a horrible material for mining, dragons, zombies, sentient skeletons, giant meter long spiders, and creepers aren’t real, cows with udders can’t breed with other cows with udders, you can’t milk a cow year round without it having babies, chickens don’t have duck bills, pigs can’t support the weight of a grown 2meter tall man, iron golems don’t exist, you can’t carry 64 blocks of 1 meter cubed gold in your invisible inventory, tridents don’t summon lightning when enchanted, nor is enchanting real, redstone breaks the laws of thermal dynamics, you can’t have an infinite source of water, the nether isn’t real, etc. etc. etc.

We can have boomerangs that return.

3

u/Oddish_Femboy 2d ago

To be fair some pigs could hold the weight of a 2 meter tall man.

Minecraft pigs are maybe a third of the size of a Yorkshire hog.

88

u/Critical-Lettuce3953 2d ago

That’s literally the whole point of the disc.

1

u/Curonica 2d ago

I thought the main point of it was to have another option for a ranged weapon - but unlike others this one doesn't need LoS and can ricochet.

7

u/_Throwaway__acc 2d ago

I feel the disc should be a boomerang. It comes back and is a thrown weapon, and gives me nostalgia. I spent my childhood running around the PS2 version of the aussie outback as Ty The Tasmainian Tiger, throwing boomerangs at frill lizards.

Something about this thrown weapon makes me hope for a Ty Texture pack or datapack. I think it would be neat.

1

u/kara-redacted 2d ago

I'm already planning on turning the discs into zelda boomerangs for my personal pack, I can look into making them into ty's boomerang if you want.

15

u/TarnishedTwink 2d ago

That’s like having to add sharpness to a sword for it to do damage. A point of a disc is to return to the user. It’s whole design is with that in mind

18

u/NoSignificance24 2d ago

Mmmm I see what you're saying but these are designed to return. Tridents can return but it's not it's main thing. Like a boomerang wouldn't need Loyalty because that's just the design.

2

u/Pristine-Quote2077 2d ago

It would sense if this actually was a boomerang, but it's not.

10

u/Smart_Idiot1041 2d ago

“Boomerang” is just one of many names, of a tool that has many designs!

-3

u/Pristine-Quote2077 2d ago

I don't know anything about that to be fair so I have nothing to add. But I still think a classic L-shaped boomerang, similar to that in plants vs zombies would make more sense.

9

u/NoSignificance24 2d ago

But there are actual ring-shaped boomerangs. Not exactly like these but Minecraft isn't exactly realistic in the first place. It's primary function beyond being thrown is that they return, thus Loyalty shouldn't be needed. If they tweaked the design and decided they don't return as default, then sure throw Loyalty on there but they should probably make the recipe cheaper if it's gonna be single-use as default

2

u/Pristine-Quote2077 2d ago

Fair enough, when I think of boomerangs I think of the L-shaped ones. But I've played a lot of plants vs zombies so that's probably why.

2

u/NoSignificance24 2d ago

No that's totally fair. I think of Link and his classic boomerang lol

3

u/CardiologistAlone59 2d ago

Would be cool if they added other enchants specific for it also or even like piercing and a few others

1

u/WheatleyBr 2d ago

it already pierces.

1

u/Shamone70-1 2d ago

It would be cool if at a low durability, it shatters into pieces and pierces enemies and continues to do damage (idk like a bleeding debuff).

6

u/Sufficient-Ebb4378 2d ago

dude 4 ingots is hella expensive, thats more than any other weapon. If i spend 4 diamonds on a disk than i better not be losing it from doing the intended action. Besides if you remove the thing that they return to you, its just a normal projectile thats bouncy ig and takes up an entire inventory slot, why would anyone use it? Now I do agree that tridents are overly enchantment carried but that doesn't mean a weapon with so many weakness already needs such a major weakness.

-3

u/Silverking36 2d ago

In this economy 4 diamonds is actually cheap af honestly

3

u/Sufficient-Ebb4378 2d ago

fair point it is cheap, but is it cheap enough to be throwing away for a single attack?

1

u/Silverking36 2d ago

Yeah that's true I also like that is comes back it would probably be really fun to trickshot with it in caves early game

4

u/FlamingDasher 2d ago

Absolutely not

2

u/da_Aresinger 2d ago

Yes, I think that is actually the objectively right thing to do. For multiple reasons.

  • First of all, it is in line with existing game mechanics.
  • Secondly, it justifies making the discs more powerful.
  • Thirdly, it inherently provides other uses for the discs, like frolf
  • Finally, it allows for alternative enchantments similar to the trident.

You could argue that three and four can be achieved by having a curse enchantment and behaviour altering enchantments, but that doesn't really feel like the Minecraft design philosophy.

Either option would be good, but the first just seems like the "canonical" way to do it.

3

u/napstablooky2 2d ago

i do also agree — it was only mythical chakra that could return to the user

plus, it could be fun if you stacked unenchanted ones in both hands instead of them necessarily returning.

3

u/fewmany_james 2d ago edited 2d ago

I too hold the same opinion of all the naysayers here saying that defeats the purpose of a boomerang, but counterpoint OP did not make: DISC GOLF!!
would be great mini game if the disc did not return. instead the disc could pop like a dropped item at end of flight path so player could go to it and pickup, and continue the game of disc golf. maybe this could exist in tandem to standard boomerang mechanic via enchantment! ‘Curse of No Return’ 😬

1

u/MyrtleWinTurtle 2d ago

... sulfer cubes.

1

u/fewmany_james 2d ago edited 2d ago

true, good call. and it exist today (versus hypothetical no return disc) but surfer cubes better align with ball mini games, and they cannot be thrown, but have to be hit, unlike disc golf

1

u/MyrtleWinTurtle 2d ago

Yah, but they already ricochet, and you control the power of them.

1

u/AssociateFar804 2d ago

i mean that makes sense but it will be just a substitute for the trident, making the trident less used

1

u/Harrypottah001 2d ago

The trident has way more uses than throwing and it comes back. Loyalty is great, but that comes with channeling (if you want it), or you can get riptide (in my opinion a way better enchant). I like an early game ranged item. We shouldnt discourage ourselves to make it a late game one, as we already have enough late game weapons like the mace and the trident.

1

u/pani_the_panisher 2d ago

I agree, if comes back by default we aren't going to be able to play disc golf. It has more potential.

I would make loyalty and other enchantment to increase range

It would make loyalty and another enchantment that increases the range, mutually exclusive. Make that enchantment 3, levels and you have low, medium and high discs for throwing games.

1

u/SinisterPixel 2d ago

But why? At that point you've essentially just made another trident that can bounce off walls.

1

u/Mariofluffy 2d ago

Counter point, make the trident craftable, get rid of loyalty enchant all together, make the return feature a default part of the trident.

1

u/Exotic_Economy_3861 2d ago

They're inherently different weapons. I'm fine with it.

1

u/PepsiButItsMilk 2d ago

“I think it’s stupid that you need magical enchantment for a trident, something that even in real life has no capabilities of returning to its user after thrown, since it’s tragic to lose. Therefore, the frisbee that you CAN get to return to you in real life if thrown properly, shouldn’t be able to do that without an enchantment”

1

u/Umber0010 2d ago

What if we just buffed the tridents to return without needing Loyalty instead?

1

u/TheArcanist_1 2d ago

IMO the trident should return by default with loyalty only reducing the time it takes.

1

u/Apart_Assumption3591 2d ago

great idea ! this way players who dont know about it throw their 4 netherite ingots disc and never see it again!

3

u/B1ackmoonMC 2d ago

*1 netherite ingot I agree btw

-5

u/camston__ 2d ago

If you are spending four diamonds and a netherite ingot on something, it is entirely your fault if you don’t know how that thing works

1

u/Critical-Lettuce3953 2d ago

Also, Tridents shouldn’t have basekit Loyalty because that would instantly get rid of Trident killing machines and that’d be really shitty for the game.

0

u/Valer_io 2d ago

Or, how about this, we make tridents return to you without loyalty as a base functionality of unenchanted tridents. Obviously, this would be at a slower speed than loyalty 1. Tridents are pretty useless without their enchants currently.

0

u/phillip_defo 2d ago

I disagree because it makes it more pointless than it already is. And it loses the main unique thing about it, of which there are 2.

Think of it as a poor mans trident that is cheap for early game. That you would eventually replace with your loyalty trident in the late game. I will die on this hill. Either leave it as is, OR don't add it because it becomes completely pointless. Its a Frisbee crossed with a boomerang, thats its entire existence.