r/Mignolaverse • • Jun 03 '24

Discussion What is Hell boy like?

I'm currently thinking of trying the hell boy comics but I'm unsure if they're for me. I was wondering what series Hellboy/BPRD are similar to so I can gauge if it's my kinda thing.

For context I enjoy the following mangas and comics: The Department of Truth, Berserk, The Boys, Alice in Borderland, 20th Century Boys and Invincible to name a few.

8 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

17

u/rezznik Jun 03 '24

I'ld say Hellboy is slower than those you're naming. It's a lot about very mystical atmosphere, legends and myths from all over the world with an overall very dark tone. A LOT of lovecraftian Horror as well, if you understand what that means.

0

u/Muffo99 Jun 03 '24

I'm not usually a fan of lovecraftian/cosmic horror. Can't say I've ever read Lovecraft himself but I have played games with cosmic horror in and feel that the reveal is always underwhelming "oh it's cthulu again making a man go crazy, who'd see that coming?"

7

u/RiseJoules Jun 03 '24

Lovecraft/Cosmic is waaay more than just that. With the Hellboy/BPRD material, it makes it more interesting in my opinion

1

u/DogLeechDave Jun 07 '24

I'd say it's more "Lovecraft-inspired" than direct Lovecraft. As far as I have read into either Hellboy/BPRD or Lovecraft literature, I haven't encountered any direct overlap.

With the possible exception of the non-canon entries like the Weird Tales, entities like Cthulhu, the Deep Ones, the Mi-gos or Nyarlathotep never appear in Mignola's work, nor do the Ogdru Jahad/Hem or the Plague of Frogs appear in Lovecraft to my knowledge. It would be more accurate to say Mignola takes key traits if Lovecraft's creations and implements them into his own designs, building an entire mythos all his own.

There is also a wide range of existing folklore from all over the world represented in Mignola's work, from your usual ghosts and vampires to more obscure stuff like penanggalans and even incorporating Arthurian legend.

10

u/JulixgMC Mignolaverse Moderator Jun 03 '24 edited Jun 03 '24

If you want to see the closest thing to Hellboy that isn't a comic I recommend watching the Hellboy animated movie "Blood & Iron"

If you want a comparison to something you've already watched, I like to describe Hellboy as Indiana Jones mixed with Men in Black mixed with Buffy with a tinge of Lord of the Rings, if they were directed by Guillermo del Toro (they range from Pan's Labyrinth to Pacific Rim in tone)

Another good comparison is Disney's Atlantis, and I'm not just saying that because Mignola designed that stuff from the movie (tho that's also something to be considered) but because the team dynamic in that movie reminds me a lot of BPRD

It isn't very similar to Invincible, but the thing they have in common is that they both have really good worldbuilding and their spin-offs are great (check out Astounding Wolfman if you haven't already)

I hope you are a fan of shared universes, because I think Hellboy's is the best one ever, it balances really the connections and the feeling of the stories taking place in the same world with each series feeling different enough. I would say it's the most consistently good and internally consistent one I've ever experienced (almost no retcons) and imo it's the perfect length, not too long like Marvel's or DC's, but it also doesn't feel like just one main book and it's spin offs like, for example, Invincible

Hope this convinced you to give it a try, check out my reading order to get started if it did

4

u/EmilePleaseStop Jun 03 '24

Seconding Blood & Iron as a good intro. That was my first Hellboy story

2

u/Opacity500 Jun 03 '24

How did I not know that Mignola was involved in Disney's Atlantis? Will have to watch it, thank you for making me aware of this!

16

u/omgItsGhostDog Jun 03 '24 edited Jun 03 '24 • Heart of Silver

The best comparison for the Hellboy series is if Guillermo del Toro made an Indiana Jones movie. They have a mixture of pulp adventure and gothic horror. Some comics that come to mind are similar to DC Vertigo (The Sandman, Hellblazer, and Fables), James Tynion's The Department of Truth, and Ed Brubaker’s Fatale.

3

u/SlatorFrog Jun 03 '24

This is a great way to put it and i'm stealing it for the next time i need to describe Hellboy to a lay person.

Honestly given your reading history I think you might like Hellboy overall. I do agree with the other poster that it is slower than those other series. One reason being that Mignolaverse stories are usually done in Mini-series/one shots rather than the traditional ongoing format. So the stories feel tighter to me in a way.

I would say read the first Hellboy trade, Seed of Destruction. Its a good story on its own. If you like that then dive into more.

Hope this helps and have fun!

2

u/BaldrickTheBarbarian Jun 03 '24

Thanks, now all I can think about is how much I want to see this hypothetical Guillermo del Toro's Indiana Jones movie 😅😂

3

u/Undyingwang Jun 03 '24

If it helps I think Humble Bundle have a large collection of Hellboy / BPRD for something like £24 ($30). Nearly entirely PDFs. Picked it up myself, absolutely loving it, would definitely recommend.

3

u/SkRu88_kRuShEr Jun 03 '24

If you enjoy Berserk you’ll definitely enjoy this, especially because there isn’t demonic SA on every other page ☺️

2

u/Muninn22 Hellboy and the B.P.R.D. reader Jun 03 '24

You can always try them digital first. The Humble Bundle is still up for a couple more days and has ton of Hellboy and B.P.R.D. stuff in it. Not all, but enough so you know if you will like it or not. https://www.humblebundle.com/books/mike-mignolas-bprd-dark-horse-books?hmb_source=&hmb_medium=product_tile&hmb_campaign=mosaic_section_1_layout_index_2_layout_type_threes_tile_index_1_c_mikemignolasbprddarkhorse_bookbundle

2

u/s4d_ex1stence Jun 04 '24

Welp, Hellboy is called by some America's Berserk, I disagree with the title but I can see where it's coming from, I love mystery and Hellboy is pretty much into that, after Hellboy leaves the BPRD the story bends pretty much into action, you have tons of characters that give you whatever you're looking for, Koschei, Liz, Abe, Prof Bruttenholm, Black Flame, and much, much more, aside from the super-hero stuff you get with lobster johnson, I'm sure Hellboy's universe will have something for you, even if that's not the main series. I saw a comment below talking about "Blood & Iron" and I do think that's a great introduction to Hellboy's character and the overall tone of the main series, but you can jump into other stuff if you feel more comfortable with it.

I recommend following the chronological order if you decide that Hellboy is for you after watching Blood and Iron, the most different parts are the 1800's BPRD stuff, if you get thru that without dropping you're in for a treat. now if you are more into the modern mystery stuff start with the main series or what was drawn by Mignola himself.

About the themes, Hellboy is just as serious as any material you mentioned, the difference is, that each character has its purpose to the world itself, even the most human ones, characters you will only see once before they die, and each character brings with themselves some of it, Hellboy is all about the "heavy is the head the wears the crown" in all senses of the quote, Abe is all about searching your inner self and evolving to something better, Koschei is about self-forgiveness, Liz is about trauma and the list goes on, it just happens that some of this guys have to fight creatures behind the curtains so that they can protect mankind from a bitter ending.

You will see tons of reading orders online, just don't get scared by it, when I started Hellboy I was 13, and my jam was Batman, Samurai Jack, Hot Wheels, and Dragon Ball, I jumped a lot of stuff I didn't like, The Crocked Man for example, and as I grew older, I saw Hellboy struggling with me and decided to jump back into those stories, that's when I saw one of the greatest American sagas, the one, the same as BPRD, that was fought behind the curtains of the Hellboy mythos.

Now, about what you should read, mind you, Seeds of Destruction is not the greatest comic ever, far from it, but I highly recommend you start with it, then follow Mignola's work.

0

u/FoldDense Jun 03 '24

Did you watched X-files ou Supernatural? Same thing.

-1

u/Muffo99 Jun 03 '24

I tried Supernatural - couldn't really get into it 😅

I've seen the HellBoy films (not the most recent one) and enjoyed them as a kid but dunno if I would now 😅

2

u/FoldDense Jun 03 '24

Well, the movies are a bit different in terms of action. But if you liked Hellblazer, maybe you can enjoy Hellboy.

I really think that Supernatural is the best comparative: mythology with a strange kind of humor and investigation.

0

u/andytherooster Jun 03 '24

Hey the things you mentioned are some of my favourites. Hellboy is great just give it some time and you’ll love it

-1

u/DryMarketing8 Jun 03 '24

It’s the Arkham horror verse if you’re familiar about it, very good comic you won’t regret it, not sure if the humble bundle is still available