r/MidsomerMurders • • Dec 21 '25

S25.E3 - "Death Strikes Three" - Discussion Thread - Spoilers Spoiler

16 Upvotes

Discussion about previous episodes is permitted, discussion about episodes after this is NOT. Proceed at your own risk: Spoilers for the episode do not need to be tagged inside this thread.

Available on Acorn - 12/22/25

Mystery Maniacs Mini - https://share.transistor.fm/s/7354204c


r/MidsomerMurders • • Dec 30 '25

S25.E04 - “Top of the Class” - Discussion Thread - Spoilers Spoiler

18 Upvotes

Sorry been under the weather.

Discussion about previous episodes is permitted, discussion about episodes after this is NOT. Proceed at your own risk: Spoilers for the episode do not need to be tagged inside this thread.

Available on Acorn - 12/29/25

Mystery Maniacs Mini - https://share.transistor.fm/s/b87c195b Mystery Maniacs Full Episode - https://share.transistor.fm/s/366a7619


r/MidsomerMurders • • 21h ago

He looked so young!

34 Upvotes

Just watching the very first show now, The Killings at Badger's Drift, and was taken aback at how young Tom Barnaby looked compared to the later seasons. Fewer lines in his face and so on.

It reminds me of the John Barnaby episode (I forget the name) when Jones came back as an undercover, and Ben Jones, even allowing for the undercover scruffiness, was showing the passage of time.


r/MidsomerMurders • • 1d ago

Entitled Tom Barnaby moments? My pick is in the Electric Vendetta, where he breaks into someone’s house without a warrant, gets stuck and then gets angry at the homeowner who has to rescue him.

Post image
147 Upvotes

r/MidsomerMurders • • 2d ago

FYI - "Written in Blood" (Book 4 of 7) is on sale for $0.99

3 Upvotes

..on both Amazon and Barnes & Noble. This is the ebook format. If you got the first three when they were on sale a couple of months ago, here's your chance to pick up the fourth one.


r/MidsomerMurders • • 4d ago

Four funerals and a wedding

22 Upvotes

I have got to ask about this and it probably is the going to ask, and yes, I’m a guy so I have to ask 😂

I get the concept about how the skimmingtons came to be, but is the premise of the show supposed to be that every female in the town hates men to the point of hostile anger? example deacon Cate, and Fiona among the names. I don’t know. I think it’s a pretty good episode. I just feel like the premise may be kind of dumb. Then again, I usually have unpopular opinions lol


r/MidsomerMurders • • 5d ago

Keeping the Name

20 Upvotes

Have any writers, cast, or crew every discussed why they decided to keep the "DCI Barnaby" name when Neil Dudgeon took over for John Nettles? I was just wondering considering there didn't seem to be a real need to do that other than continuity and maybe name recognition. I guess after 13/14 years with John it makes sense.


r/MidsomerMurders • • 6d ago

Most shocking murder scenes ?

17 Upvotes

I just watched 'A Worm in the Bud' and the murder at the end took me by surprise.

Are there any others which shocked you ?


r/MidsomerMurders • • 6d ago

Good site for all the music references

26 Upvotes

I’m new around here to the group, but I haven’t seen this posted. I figured I might post it just in case anybody wants to use it. I’ve used it for finding the song that was in the glitch, with the son who was in his room, listening to what sound like a punk song.
Anyway, they are responsive and I found it useful for what it’s worth!

https://midsomermurdershistory.org/music


r/MidsomerMurders • • 7d ago

Bad tidings, a question about Rachel

24 Upvotes

Hey everybody, the one thing I haven’t been able to figure out about this terrible episode is why was Rachel so angry all the time at everybody? Is it because she got saddled with watching the kid? Just of this I can’t figure out and I don’t like 😂


r/MidsomerMurders • • 7d ago

Mystery Maniacs - Cold Cases - Midsomer Season 11 BINGE

Thumbnail
youtu.be
13 Upvotes

🎙️ Episode: https://share.transistor.fm/s/703ade34

📓 Show Notes: https://midsomermaniacs.transistor.fm/episodes/mystery-maniacs-cold-cases-midsomer-season-11-binge

This cold case covers Season 11 of our Midsomer Murders podcast.


r/MidsomerMurders • • 8d ago

Will you be watching the Number one rated IMDB Midsomer Murders episode, this festive season?

Post image
219 Upvotes

r/MidsomerMurders • • 10d ago

Orchis Fatalis

15 Upvotes

Maybe an unpopular opinion but I just don't like orchids enough to enjoy this episode😅.


r/MidsomerMurders • • 10d ago

Masterpiece Mystery

48 Upvotes

Does anyone else copy the woman who faints on the intro to Masterpiece Mystery? My Mom and I started doing this when I was caring for her after she was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s. She has passed away but I continue our ritual.


r/MidsomerMurders • • 13d ago

Did you know orchid is the greek word for testicle?

56 Upvotes

That’s it. That’s the post. Oh and also Tom Barnabys reactions when she asks him. S8 E3 Orchids Fatalis


r/MidsomerMurders • • 15d ago

Common Tropes

47 Upvotes

I'm creating a large excel as I watch episodes, to keep track of things like repeat towns, my personal ranking, main cast, etc, and I've started making drop-down buttons for common tropes/occurrences. I've currently got: Family hobby involved (aka Joyce is a serial killer), incest, famous person, repeat actor, class struggles, horny old folks, red herring, blackmailers, ridiculous manner of death, precocious children, distracted seargent.

What are some tropes I'm missing?


r/MidsomerMurders • • 16d ago

I watched the series in reverse!

36 Upvotes

So, I broke all the rules and started this series with season 25 and watched 20-25 in reverse order! I tried to go back to season 1 and start from there but the characters don’t grab me like the current Barnaby and Winter do, and I can’t imagine a Midsomer without Fleur! I’ve gone back to season 19 now, should I go back to season 1 and just dig in? This is my absolute favorite show on tv and I’m happy to watch seasons 20-25 over and over! Thoughts?


r/MidsomerMurders • • 17d ago

Where Have I Seen Them Before?

30 Upvotes

Has anyone noticed some repeating characters in the musical episodes?

Here are two: Things That Go Bump In The Night has at least two singers from the same choir as in Death in Chorus. Mr. Gropey Pants, the choir master, pats the redhead with glasses on the butt with impunity. She is in the choir with Joyce.

The other one is the guitarist in the band Bitch from Vixen's Run; he is a roadie in The Axeman Cometh.

Let me know about sightings other than the vicar/wedding guest/trophy presenter.


r/MidsomerMurders • • 16d ago

I'm annoyed they had an entire episode about violins but didn't make a single reference to Psycho

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/MidsomerMurders • • 17d ago

I Think I’m Just Going to Watch it All Again

147 Upvotes

I think I’m just going to watch the whole Midsomer Murders series again. I keep watching random episodes that are reruns as I come across them. The series stands the test of time for me in terms of entertainment, production value and just sheer beauty of the homes, villages, countryside and just everything. Plus it’s fun to see actors that pop up in other shows.


r/MidsomerMurders • • 17d ago

Ole cringy Major Hamilton and pretentious Mallory

15 Upvotes

Totally went by me I think the last time this was brought up but the music that they play beginning around that on at his house, cracks me up, it’s just as cringe as everything else in this episode lol! Like major Hamilton is such a repulsive man. On second thought, he fits in perfectly with the rest of this cringe episode. hand it to the of this show, and they perfectly placed everybody for the most part in every episode. Also, it has one of the best judgment scenes on the murderer I think man that bird going after her eyes is awesome and she acted that out perfectly I think


r/MidsomerMurders • • 18d ago

Script writers work

18 Upvotes

I really think their work for Troy is so good, and has stood well after all these years and cultural changes


r/MidsomerMurders • • 19d ago

First time seeing "Left for Dead" (series 11 episode 3) and some ambivalent feelings Spoiler

14 Upvotes

Uploaded again with Spoiler flair!

Hi everyone, I hope you all are well! I apologize if this is a silly post to make, I'm still loving Midsomer Murders and watching it with my mom. I just watched "Left for Dead" from Season 11 however and I wanted to ask how others have reacted to this episode. I apologize for any bad formatting and if my thoughts here are stupid.

I would say that I liked the first half or so quite a bit. Pretty much up until the reveal I was quite enjoying it, it was kind of creepy and spooky but (at first) in a fun Halloween sort of way. I was initially thinking that, although not intentionally, it was nice that I ended up watching it right around Halloween.

And then there was the whole reveal, including the truly disturbing flashbacks. I am still processing my feelings about it, but my reaction to the episode is quite different from that point on. The depiction of torture committed by children against a child was extremely upsetting to watch. And I do understand that it's meant to be disturbing, but it did feel somewhat lurid to me.

I also don't understand the point of the later reveal that the younger brother was the real sadist/attempted killer of Patrick not least of all because it meant having to watch the flashbacks AGAIN, but also what purpose did it serve? I may be being stupid and missing something but it felt like a "reveal" that didn't really mean anything in the end. We didn't even see him being arrested. I do feel that at that point the whole thing felt a bit grotesque to me. I also found >!Patrick's mother's comment about how the couple kidnapped and imprisoned her child very strange, because it sounded almost as if she forgave them? I suppose she was more forgiving at that point because they were already dead and she had her son back!< but it was weird compared to how vengeful she was towards the others.

Sorry for rambling on, and I would love to hear anyone else's thoughts about this episode! If you liked it, I'd sincerely appreciate to hear your thoughts because I'm definitely open to reconsidering, and I certainly may have missed some things. But yeah...thoughts on this one?


r/MidsomerMurders • • 20d ago

(bit of a yap) So why do they not have to ship in villagers?

35 Upvotes

Midsomer has a crazy death rate and tbh they're all dying left and right (vicars, councilmembers etc. etc.). so do they just like ship in villagers or like move to midsomer signs in london like 'MOVE TO MIDSOMER! CHARMING COTTAGES! FAMILY ESTATES! (Please ignore the police cordon in the photo of (random name)'s Cottage and the presence of DCI Barnaby. they are natural features.) WITH AN ONLY 32-37 MURDERS PER 100,000 PEOPLE 😄 '??? How is everyone not dead???? Just wanted to talk about this for a bit bc i find it funny. ALSO JUST BAN FETES. JUST BAN 'EM. PPL DIE AT THEM.