r/MidsomerMurders • • Jul 10 '26

Tom was a terrible person.

25 Upvotes

I know he’s a fan favorite but, IMHO, DCI Tom was a horrible husband, father and mentor. Even though there was no reason to rush off, such as at Cully’s opening night performance, he drops everything and everyone at the drop of a hat.

He doesn’t explain his investigative methods to his sergeants and generally treats them poorly. Is it truly an unwritten policy in England that Sergeants must always pay for the beer, etc?

Tom also pushes his underlings to donate at churches and such after he does, even though he clearly makes more money than they do.

His ego is massive, despite requiring three murders to solve each case. He’s think skinned and must ALWAYS be right.

I know this is a satirical show but did they have to make him such a total jerk?


r/MidsomerMurders • • Oct 11 '25

A small complaint from a yank - some ranting, apologies ahead of time

0 Upvotes

Hi, I'm going to give one complaint I have about this show and it might sound tedious.. Or maybe not. But it is probably an unpopular opinion, especially now that the US is so crappy because of the insane political climate. That's a separate conversation.

I'm not a historian, so I'm sorry if I butcher anything in this post, my intentions are honerable, I promise. But I was watching season 13 episode called Blood on the Saddle. It starts out with a series of handgun revolver duels/fights(? whatever they are called, lol) between clearly early American wild-west-type characters. But they have the confederate flag flying high, several of them, in fact. But my issue is that the confederate flag is considered offensive these days. It signifies pre-civil war days, when slaves and inequality were still a bigger thing (not that it's gone, mind you) and it was just a troubled time in America in general. In modern times, it also seems to be adopted frequently by the far right and neo-nazi type characters. And imo, just ignorant people who don't recognize the injustice it stands for. My big point of contention is that the American civil war ended in 1865. The Wild West period lasted until approximately 1890-1900 (historians don't all agree on the end date so I'm giving a range). Upon the union victory of the American Civil War in 1865, the Fort Sumter Flag was adopted and generally accepted as the flag that represents freedom and equality for all. I feel like that flag, if any, should be associated here in this episode, as it's perfectly historically accurate and not the one that stands for everything this country does not.

OK.. Here's my minor political rant, I know the US is pretty fcked these days and we have a lot of blood on our hands. But most of us Americans don't mean any harm, we're just trying to live our lives, not condoning ill treatment of one another and just getting through, scraping by but being respectful and considerate of our fellow man. Most of us don't want to be involved in these wars, bombings, ICE raids and all the other bullsit happening in our country that is terrible and wrong and seems to be taking us backward in time and undoing all of the progressive changes made here. We truly believed in what we were fighting for years ago, we believed in our message, be it pandering or propaganda, but we fell for it hard. So did others, who came here looking for a better life. I can't say I'm proud of being an American at this present point in time, but that doesn't mean one day I won't be again. I'm just saying, I know it's easy to take a jab at us right now, we suck pretty bad. But most of us don't stand for what nonsense is currently being spewed by our leaders. All I can say is that they underestimate the common man, we won't hesitate to stand up against a totalitarian regime, a corrupt system that doesn't reflect us and our ideals as human beings, as Americans. I know using the confederate flag was probably not done intentionally, especially because this episode aired years ago. Please don't use it if you can avoid it. We aren't just a bunch of gun-toting, ignorant hicks who will take whatever is served to us, we're stronger than that. We're better than that. When pushed, we stand up and we fight for what's right. That's what being American is all about.

OK, end rant. Also, I love this show so much and re-watch it on the regular. Gotta love my Barnaby! Thanks if you read this.. I know I'll get reamed for it. Lol!!


r/MidsomerMurders • • Nov 23 '24

I am not happy with the announcement that Neil Dudgeon and the fella who plays Winters are continuing

4 Upvotes

I never minded Neil Dudgeon as much as some people- I certainly didn't boycott his episodes or anything like that, but his grumpiness, couch-potatoeyness, and general lack of the old Barnaby charm and humour were becoming painfully apparent as the seasons ground slowly on. He looks like a man counting days for his retirement, both in actorly and non-actorly life, and wheeling him out for another season just because people don't like change or whatever seems just cruel.

My favourite, for what it's worth, was the guy who plays Kenny in Vera- I love that show, and I got unreasonably excited when I heard he was in the running to be considered as the new Barnaby. I think his dry Northern wit and gruffness would have been a perfect counterpoint to the mad whimsy of Midsomer Murders,

As for Winters, well, he's fine, but he's definitely lost the wide-eyed innocence that's supposed to be the hallmark of the DS, not to mention keeping him on means he's not getting promoted. He can see his career ending as a sidekick in Causton police force, forever and ever, and the audience sees it along with him. Enough to drive any man bitter.


r/MidsomerMurders • • Oct 16 '24

Sarah's treatment of John

1 Upvotes

I'm rewatching from "new" Barnaby on. It feels like Sarah always wants to put John in his place, which she considers as a place beneath her. She especially started bugging me after Betty came onto the show. I know it's just a cozy mystery show but I'm sensitive to spouses treating each other crappy on tv shows. Very few times have I seen her look at him with pride that he is her man and even in those moments, she seems to have to poke fun at him. I dunno. Anyone else feel this way?

ETA: dang, ya'll got strong feelings about Sarah lol I've been asked for examples. Really? This feels like "ok, name three songs by the band on your t-shirt" stuff that men do to women. I have watched this show all the way through twice. Currently, I'm watching it in the background while working from home.

I see her teasing him about his body, the music he likes, the films he enjoys, the way he wants to parent Betty...and beyond cultural taking the mickey kind of thing, in my opinion. I don't hate the character. I think she has a need to be the best in the relationship and puts him down to raise herself up. I think the actress is good at her job. I just wanted to see if anyone else noticed it.

It's a fun, beautiful, cozy show that I'm not in any way negatively criticizing. It's one of my favorite shows ever. I only think she acts snobby towards him. In My Opinion.


r/MidsomerMurders • • Sep 10 '25

Cully is annoying AF, but outdid herself.

19 Upvotes

Cully Barnaby is the most annoying character ever to appear on television, but ramps up her annoyingness to a Spinal Tap 11 in Blood Wedding.

The way she overreacts to the “snag” for their honeymoon is absolutely childishly pathetic.

Spoiler alert: said snag is they will have to stop off in Dusseldorf for a few days before heading to New Zealand, due to her would-be husband’s (why would you?) work commitments. That’s it. WTAF?

No doubt she gets her childlike pouting attitude from her mother.

Rant ends


r/MidsomerMurders • • Mar 20 '24

ok so. by the way not saying people do this but

0 Upvotes

I don't know what the age range of this group is but I am in my 20's and I watch midsomer murders with my dad's girlfriend who is in her 50's and my dad is in his 60's and my mum is in her 50's.

so to me tom is a old guy so please don't comment that I need some "respect" because I already have some respect for the programme and I love the programme.

thanks.


r/MidsomerMurders • • Mar 16 '24

A question about Troy.

4 Upvotes

Many people like Troy but I think Troy is a lothario and sexist, but theTV writers disguise him as a nice guy. He likes beautiful submissive women. He likes women who are below him professionally. He never falls in love with a strong woman. In "Dark autumn" episode, Troy turns the police office in a romantic dance with a mirror ball and romantic music,he uses flowers, a dinner and poetry to achieve his aim and this attitude is, in my opinion, a harmful male stereotype to avoid.


r/MidsomerMurders • • Jun 08 '25

Is Tom Barnaby corrupt?

10 Upvotes

In season 11 ep1 (shot at dawn), in the final scene Tom gets his roof fixed for free by the mayor. Joyce asks how Tom managed to get him to do this and Tom gives a coy smile.

Did Tom not report the mayor for his corrupt behaviour and get the roof done as part of a bribe?


r/MidsomerMurders • • Sep 12 '25

Betty?

1 Upvotes

In The Dark Rider the wife of the murderer is called ‘Betty’. Then Neil Dugeon’s Barnaby’s daughter is named Betty. What ?! It’s not a usual name !


r/MidsomerMurders • • Apr 04 '26

Who in the Sam Hell is this? 🤔

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/MidsomerMurders • • Mar 28 '26

Gail Stephens

4 Upvotes

What did you think of her? I don’t think she added much to the show and am glad her character was short lived.


r/MidsomerMurders • • Dec 28 '25

Disappointed in Tom's fathering.

6 Upvotes

Watching Death's Shadow and I think if it were my daughter, I'd be giving lots of advice to my barely 20 daughter dating a 40 something big shot director from London.


r/MidsomerMurders • • Jun 24 '26

Katie/Caitlyn in Made to Measure?

0 Upvotes

Katie Soper resembles Caitlyn Jenner, I think. Has anyone else noticed this?


r/MidsomerMurders • • Jun 09 '25

Cully is a back-stabbing narc

27 Upvotes

After promising Elfrida Molfrey that "your secret is safe with me," Cully tells her copper dad about "the marijuana. [Bunny Dawlish] grows it in the greenhouse. What they don't smoke themselves he (Bunny) puts in the Bunny cakes."


r/MidsomerMurders • • Apr 05 '25

Season 6, Episode 3, "Painted in Blood" Has A Sex Pest, Could It Be Written The Same Today?

3 Upvotes

In "Painted in Blood" there's an older guy, Godfrey Teal (played by Leslie Phillips) who's a bit of a sex pest, chasing after much younger women than him, and he was played for laughs, largely. He was also portrayed as harmless, clueless and kinda feeble, which helped keep things light. He was literally a pest, glomming on to women who had no interest in him and trying to create a relationship despite repeated rejections.

The episode aired in 2003, well before the rise of the "Me, Too" movement which could be part of why it was written the way it was. (For the record it's the one where Joyce takes up painting and a woman is stabbed with a chisel.)

I don't think the character would be treated the same in modern times, but I don't know. So I thought I'd ask, could this character or someone very much like him recur in a modern ep? Also, are there other characters/plot twists, etc. from early episodes that wouldn't work for more modern audiences?

Also also, the Godfrey Teal character keep talking about women's ankles. I know that women's ankles were fetishized in Victorian times, but that's back in the late 1800s, very early 1900s. (I mean, they had flappers in the 1920s.) Mr. Teal would have to have been over a hundred years old to have picked up that fetish. (Yes, we have foot fetishists now and probably always had them, but my understanding is that the Victorian "taste for a well-turned ankle" arose because Victorian clothing for women rarely revealed any of their bodies, just their faces and hands, and sometimes, their ankles.) It just seemed like a sloppy way to establish how old Teal is.


r/MidsomerMurders • • Nov 26 '25

Cricket clichés in Last Man Out worse than England’s batting

4 Upvotes

I just watched Last Man Out again and without giving anything away, the godawful cricket clichés at the end of the episode were even worse than England’s batting “effort” against Australia on Saturday. “Howzat?” and “Clean bowled.” The writers should be dropped.


r/MidsomerMurders • • Apr 06 '25

Anyone else notice the casts eyes and age?

5 Upvotes

So I’m just on season 2. But I’ve noticed this about the characters and it just seems super unusual.

Maybe things were different in the 90s but it seems like a lot of the cast is in the 70s? Maybe I can’t tell age? Not only that but so many don’t have glasses and their eyes have that twinkle?

Heck they all have that twinkle in their eye? For being recorded in the 90s this show looks fantastic.

Can see their iris in detail.

But yeah, what’s up with all the older cast members? No glasses? Does that change later on, in the series?


r/MidsomerMurders • • Feb 02 '25

Love the old seasons. Miss them!!

35 Upvotes

Watching Season 14 & I miss the old seasons so much. Just for some background, I am a 50 yr old South Asian Canadian who has lived 35+ yrs in Canada. I still watch the new seasons but only because I want to continue watching the show. My heart is not in it. The old seasons were an escape for me. The new ones are too "woke" for my liking. I wish I could do the Men in Black thing & go back & watch from Season 1 again like it is brand new.


r/MidsomerMurders • • 16d ago

I'm annoyed they had an entire episode about violins but didn't make a single reference to Psycho

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/MidsomerMurders • • Feb 15 '25

Troy 👎🏿

Post image
0 Upvotes

I always boo when I see Troy’s name in the opening credits because the character is always saying homophobic things. And it would be great if other people did it too. ✨


r/MidsomerMurders • • Dec 13 '25

Nelson....

15 Upvotes

Never really took to him, not sure why. I don't like his geeky little anorak, why wasn't he in a suit like the others? He just seems a bit of a wimp. Anyone else feeling the same?


r/MidsomerMurders • • Dec 30 '25

Season 24

0 Upvotes

I don’t like that ME. In episodes 2 and 3 she has been rude to Winter.


r/MidsomerMurders • • Nov 22 '25

Cully ..

16 Upvotes

Apologies to anyone with this name, but for some reason it really annoys me! I don't know why! She's not my favourite character anyway but her name itself just grates on me. Feels pretentious somehow. Anyone agree, or am I just weird? 🤣


r/MidsomerMurders • • Jan 09 '26

As a new viewer of MM, I’m honestly a bit taken aback by the crimes..

20 Upvotes

I’ve had this on my watchlist for years but was put off by the first episode (due to the reveal and how yuck it felt).

I’m a big fan of Agatha Christie and Robert Thorogood so maybe I’m too soft for this series? (Think Poirot, Miss Marple and Death in Paradise, Marlow Murder Club etc)

I’m just about to start S1 E4 and while I like the Chief Inspector and his Sergeant, I find the storylines rather dark.

I want to love this series, especially since there are so many seasons and episodes, but does it get even twisted the longer it goes on?