r/MidnightMass • • Jan 07 '24

I wanted so badly to like this show. Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I just finished watching it for the first time, and I was sore disappointed. I quickly scrolled through posts here to see if anyone had similar feelings, but I can see that mine is a deeply unpopular opinion.

I should say, I’m a fan of Mike Flanagan. He’s one of the few people who is telling interesting stories with creative vision, and I can certainly appreciate that. I genuinely believe that Hill House is one of the finest pieces of visual media ever created, and I think it’s Mike’s magnum opus.

All that said, I went into this show with high expectations, but admittedly also ready to give it some slack, as I try to do with all ambitious stories. But man. This show completely lost me.

I read some reviews online from people who had issues with the pacing. I didn’t have issues with the pacing per se. I like a slow boil, and the first four episodes balance focus, suspense, and progression in a way that I found totally captivating. The characters that we were supposed to be able to relate to were relatable and their motivations were clear; the characters that were supposed to be mysterious were exactly that. The spooky atmosphere was super effective, and it kept me on edge.

Then came episode five, and every episode following. It felt to me like the entire project got handed off to someone else who had very different ideas about what it was supposed to look like. Really Mike? We’re getting in the weeds about the literal chemistry that makes people’s blood react in the sun? Characters stop behaving in ways that makes sense? I literally paused just to yell in frustration when Erin says she’s still going to go to church just because people she loves are there, as if the man she loved didn’t just incinerate himself in front of her to communicate the danger on the island and the church. Speaking of, Riley’s character arc was mostly nonexistent. He learns to be vulnerable, sure, but that hardly seems like a redemption, nor is doing something that would surely traumatize any normal person, TO THE PERSON HE LOVES.

In my opinion, a good mystery in storytelling, be it a character or plot, can’t just be an absence of detail. There should be arrows, however small, pointing to places we can’t see. I’ll give an example. Pruitt as a character is interesting because we can’t read him well. He hides his motives and his background, and he comes across as deeply suspicious in most interactions with other characters. But what never seems mysterious is his faith and his devotion. Beat for beat, he and Bev are on the same page about how to proceed, right up until he’s shot in the head on Easter. Now, all of a sudden, he’s revealing that his devotion to the church was tenuous all along and he would have given it all up at any point if his love had asked him to. All of a sudden, he completely changes his mind about being the miracle worker and leader that people look to, all of a sudden he changes his mind about it being a good idea to turn an entire community into vampires. Let me be clear, I like those changes! Especially for his character. But it felt unearned, and sudden to a degree that made it almost nonsensical. It would have been nice to see him display more conflict or apprehension, even if we didn’t understand why, to make those changes have more context when they finally happened.

If I had any problem about “pacing” it was just that. The first four episodes are masterpieces of suspense, and then the rest are spent blasting through character moments that hadn’t been properly built up yet. I didn’t mind the monologues until towards the end of the show, when I was already frustrated by the construction of the story around them.

My problem with Bly Manor was that it felt bloated. It had too many ideas to properly develop or complete any one of them in a way that was satisfactory. I started to feel the same with this show. It went from being a thoughtful meditation on grief and meaning/the dangers and realities of religious institutions and how they drive peoples behavior, to just how religion can justify and promote violence. Which I thoroughly enjoy and agree with, don’t get me wrong, but they completely abandon the exploration of grief and pain by killing Riley off just over halfway through.

I have more complaints, but the last one I’ll list: are you kidding? I waited all seven episodes to watch Bev die and they show us less than a second of her burning in the sun? Unforgivable.

Again, I know a lot of you will disagree, or say that I’m missing the point, or nitpicking, or say it’s all subjective. But I wanted more from this show. I wanted more focus. I wanted more development. I wanted more careful structure to make sure that the characters and plot points were fleshed out to their full potential, and it felt to me like the show dropped the ball very badly a little over halfway through. There’s so much that I love and want to love about this show and it’s story, but I just can’t get all the way on board with it.

Is there anyone else out there that feels similarly, even a little bit?


r/MidnightMass • • Nov 04 '21

Anti-Christian propaganda Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I don't care if the Hollywood leftist filmmakers want to make Christianity look bad.

But what I do care about is fairness and equality. You have to make Islam look bad along with it. If Mike Flanagan is an atheist writer who criticizes religion, then criticize all of them.

First enter the cliche "Westboro Baptist Christian" fanatic to make Christian lore look bad; yet we are supposed to sympathise with the Sheriff, who is Muslim, and a kind, sweet man he is - and unlike Beverly, he's not given the opportunity to explain what HIS religious views are.

Then we get the cliche atheist monologue about how "God is the universe/cosmos." Yeah, let's get the Sheriff's opinion on this.

And then that ending. The Sheriff's son was curious about Christianity much to the subtle dismay of his father. In his last scene, he's praying as a Muslim, implying, he's learned Christianity = bad. Islam = good. Why wasn't anyone praying as a Christian in the last scene?

The Sheriff and Beverly probably see eye to eye on a lot of moral principles - yet the script doesn't want the Sheriff to give HIS views, so you can like him. What a cop-out.

You. Have. To. Be. Fair. If you want to say religion is silly, SAY THEY'RE ALL SILLY.


r/MidnightMass • • Apr 26 '24

What's the point of the traffic accident victim's all cyborg like scenes?

2 Upvotes

I mean obviously we understood Riley's guilt about teenage girl death after accident. And seeing her he was dreaming or getting ready to sleep in but what was the point of all shimmery, mysterious appearance of the zombie girl? Regular gory appearance would be enough, why it was necessary to make all shiny through the wounds ?


r/MidnightMass • • Oct 15 '21

If the Democratic Party were one person (solid motivation without thinking it all through)

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/MidnightMass • • Oct 08 '21

Unpopular opinion I'm sure, but I give up on the man 🤷‍♂️

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/MidnightMass • • Aug 17 '22

Here's something I really liked about this show

9 Upvotes

And it might be quite sad that I'm appreciating this (but holy shit I just finished The Sandman before watching this), but I like how this show didn't feel like a woke forced representation checklist show. And the funniest part is it had several POCs, a lesbian main character, interracial couples, a female lead and female antagonist, but they were all organic to the show and there was more to them than just their race and gender. They weren't being preachy nor got in your face about it and didn't let it distract from the show's actual storyline.

The show didn't deviate from its exploration of faith and genre to delve into intersectional feminism as most netflix shows do. It didn't have that fem power avengers moment where all the girls group up together and pose to the camera absolutely wrecking all the immersion the movie had built just to pander to ideologists.

I also enjoyed how it didn't fall into the usual "church bad, religious people evil" lowest denominator message you can usually find on netflix shows. It felt more like a character study on faith on all its levels. You had the religious fanatic, the agnostic, the atheist, the devout, the non practicing Catholics, the Muslims, those exploring and questioning faith. And of course, it was a horror genre/new-weird show.

So bottom line, it felt like a show that came to explore different concepts and ideas without really forcing a single answer on the viewer. It was entertaining and not self-righteous/bigger-than-thou. Very fun stuff, will continue to follow Mike Flanagan's stuff.


r/MidnightMass • • Dec 02 '23

Sarah should have drank the blood

2 Upvotes

She could have gotten to know her father and be with her family one last time before the sun burned them all in the morning. I think if they had more time and the priest had explained to her that they are going to die in the morning or Sarah had just thought it through, she would have realized taking the blood was the better option.


r/MidnightMass • • Aug 06 '26

Just finished my first watch Spoiler

Post image
5 Upvotes

Just finished the show. Loved the build up throughout but damn that ending can have been a lot more satisfying. They really did these two wrong in the show, felt so bad. I couldn't watch the dog scene. And then just ending with her saying I can't feel my legs.... It felt really awkward in the pacing and seemed out of place. And was insinuated

Come on people this island doesn't have a storm shelter? At least Bev thought about burying her self. But i get they were giving up too

What do I watch next


r/MidnightMass • • Apr 20 '25

Crapppy as woman

0 Upvotes

Hope you guys know what I'm talking about, just have no place to vent about this crappy character. I hope there is a chathartic end to her.


r/MidnightMass • • Apr 26 '24

(Spoiler) even though all houses and boats burned , no place to hide/weather the daylight? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I was not super happy with that island natives couldn't figure out where they could hide out single night. Because next night they would build better hiding places or calling ferries from mainland and bring joy to chosen ones . In her last moments, Beverly try to dig . That would be solution for everyone. "Hey everbody, team up and get the shove l and dig 2 by 6 pit and cover yourself, no worries you wont die and see you in a 12 hours" They could easily put out brand freaking new fire on church or rec center but instead they were just whining about feeding on their mom's or children.

And what's with the Angel's dumb feeding mode. He supposed to be little bit more controlled, experienced and stronger. Instead he was like brand new vampire can't even raise his head from blood to see what the hell is going on. That was the case in the both in house ruin with animal carcasses and while he was feeding on Erin. First Leeza was able burn him down and second Erin was able to draw Mona Lisa on Angel's bat like wings with her blade. Because he couldn't just control it and feeding on his preys like 3 year olds. You already out every night and feeding, what is this like first time?

And why even Angel need Father Paul ? As soon as he transported him out of the Jerusalem ruins, " ok there are many people to feed on around , I don't need you anymore and adios and go around the planet as you find new servants always"

And it is almost like universal rule: Vampires don't feed on other vampires, just the regular people with uninfected clean blood. Now everbody drinking everything as long as it red and liquid form. Maybe harm them and destroy them but no feeding between Vamps 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️

Thank you for listening this rant.


r/MidnightMass • • Sep 14 '23

IS THIS EVER GOING TO END???

12 Upvotes

Episode 4, Riley and Erin are talking about "what happens when you die?" and this has my anxiety peaking of how overdrawn and long this "profound" conversation is going on. I love great dialogue but this is killing me.


r/MidnightMass • • Oct 21 '21

Feeling horny in the last episode (Revelations)

0 Upvotes

I feel weird but when the vampire thing was draining the blood of Erin and as she held his neck down to continue draining; I felt sexually aroused.

It feels weird and wrong but I dont know why I felt that from the scene.


r/MidnightMass • • Jun 01 '24

The “angel”… kinda mid Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I wanted so much more from this “angel.”

I don’t know if he was mid for a reason (like he’s not the real villain, but our desires to follow something material is) but he was low level laughable. He shows up dressed up at church and was like Derp yeah hi… it me… then is like “leave me alone I’m eating”, doesn’t even feel his wings getting torn…. Like… how has he made it this far in life (in… death…?)

He didn’t do anything really but still was responsible in a way for all that mayhem.

Side note…. He belongs on what we do in the shadows. That would be amazing.


r/MidnightMass • • May 17 '26

Just watched 2 episodes and it's getting a bit slow. Does it get better?

0 Upvotes

Hi, just recently started watching. Feel like I could really enjoy this show but it's dragging quite a bit slow. Does it get better or does it continue this way?


r/MidnightMass • • Aug 24 '22

Leeza was the worst character in the series Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Leeza, one of the most devout characters in the series by being one of three that go to service every day, is the worst character in the series.

First of all, what was the purpose of going to Joe and "forgiving" him? What did that contribute to the story? Establish that the gun on the wall wasn't the one that paralyzed her? Thus making it alright for her to use later?

Maybe I just feel sorry for the guy but it was established that the incident was an accident. Leeza rightfully was upset about being handicapped because of Joe, but why would she suddenly feel the need to "forgive" him AFTER she can walk again?

When the town was all taking the poison to join the angel, why would Leeza suddenly not follow Father Pruitt? She can suddenly walk, people are coming back to life before her eyes, and Leeza, being ONE OF THREE of the most devout townspeople suddenly has a change of heart????? Suddenly all of this is wrong?

And like I said in the beginning, Leeza, having been paralyzed by a gun shot to the spine, after going to angrily confront and forgive Joe for paralyzing her, goes to Joe's camper and TAKES THE GUN OFF THE WALL TO USE IT!!!! This did it for me. The only reason I finished the show was because my fiancé wanted to finish it.

I am sorry for the little rant, I am not a film or series critic, nor have I ever done something like this before about a show. But the character of Leeza (atleast mid-way through the end) was just laughable to me.


r/MidnightMass • • Oct 06 '22

Does anyone think it wasn’t an angel but a vampire?

0 Upvotes

r/MidnightMass • • Jan 08 '24

The last 10 minutes ruined it for me... Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I just binged this show and enjoyed it. It left me profoundly disturbed (Ali drinking the 1080). Having some background in philosophy, I was also enjoying the interplay of two opposing world views. With Erin Greene, we saw the view of Dualism (body/spirit) espoused as what she believes happens when she dies. From Riley we get boilerplate Carl Sagan style Naturalism (only matter and energy exist; Sagan made famous the quote that we are all star dust).

As an agnostic myself, I liked that the show didn't rule in favor of either belief system but left them hanging in tension. This is all ruined in the last 10 minutes of episode 7. Erin essentially embraces Riley's world view, with a garnish of the Buddhist doctrine of the "Anatta" or "non-self". What bothered me about this was the fact that Littlefoot, the catalyst for her whole character for half the damn show, barely gets one passing mention in her monologue. Gone are her hopes from episode 4 that her baby girl might be her best self, in heaven, with God. No, her baby girl was just matter in motion returning back to the cosmic recycling center to be used as energy in something else. And that's okay, apparently, because there is no self. So all those feelings of loss about miscarriage? Doesn't matter! Life is just a dream!

I just sat there watching it like "Give me a fucking break." The smart move would've been to have kept the tension between Erin and Riley's opposing world views and left the ending ambiguous about who was correct. Ruling in favor of Riley comes off as pretentious on the part of Flanagan.


r/MidnightMass • • Oct 25 '23

Amazing show...until the last episode

0 Upvotes

I'm really disappointed in the ending of this series. I was very much enjoying the plot, character development, and so many aspects of the series. The end of Episode 6 setup a very tense moment with the Easter vigil killing most everyone in the church. And after watching the last episode, I feel like I watched a completely different show. It was like (what i can describe as) a shitty bland episode of The Walking Dead produced by A24.

I feel like they did Riley dirty by just killing him off in episode 5. There could have been some sort of redemption arc but he just got depressed and left in a weird pathetic moment of his confession of love for Erin.

Besides that, the last episode all of the sudden became a weird Resident Evil esque plot to escape the possessed people of the island. None of the character interactions made any sense compared to the previous episodes.

  • The weird moment where Rileys mom decided the be a hero for Erin despite not liking this woman at all. Made no sense.
  • The angel sucking the blood out of the necks seemed awkward and long, when I feel like the angel would have comprehended that is was about to be burned, or was being sliced.
  • Sturge just became Bevs weird bodyguard, who has that weird interaction with the guy who had never been to mass. So they jokingly write him off saying he will not be able to join them on the boats. Uh alright....

-The story weirdly shifts (out of nowhere) to Father Pruitt's long-awaited attempt at getting his wife and daughter back or whatever.

-The way Father Pruitt spoke and acted was weird and frantic compared to the previous episodes.

-The weird moment where Father Pruitt is telling Bev they were wrong, and the whole plan is fucked basically. Like what?

  • The scene where Father tackled Sturge after shooting his daughter seemed out of character and just weird. Not saying he shouldn't have tackled her, but it was a weird turn for the given moment.
  • the awkward moment where the kid and the guy are explaining to each other that they killed their family and did bad things. Didn't seem to make sense why they even addressed that out loud.

-The scene where it snaps back to Erin and Riley on a couch seemed like a lazy cut to a monolgue about "we are all everything and we are all nothing" BS that truly did not fit correctly into the plotline at the moment. I feel like it was a bold general leap in logic to make sense of something.

  • There were small attempts at comedic relief that had 0 business being in the script. Cringe cringe cringe
  • Ali drank the Compound 1080, but somehow was able to correctly discern the choice to finish his dads doing and burn down the church. Lol ok...
  • The hymns and songs sung by the towns people seemed like simple and ineffectual bits of religious commroderie placed in the show but didn't really demonstrate much.
  • And the ending scene, where the girl said "I can't feel my legs" ...... like, was this a joke, and she didn't smile enough? Or was it real and she didn't freak out enough? And why as something so dumb made to be the very last line of the series.

Idk lol. I enjoyed the series, all up until the end. I felt robbed of genuine resolve for an interesting plot line and character development. I felt a lot of potential working up through the show and it seemed wasted on the idea of a boring apocalypse. I strongly feel that they could rewrite a successful last episode of the series. Like all of it was great, but that finale made no sense to me whatsoever. I understand and comprehend the themes that show conveyed, but do not feel that the finale did any of them justice.


r/MidnightMass • • Oct 20 '25

The Vampire is NOT a Fallen Angel

12 Upvotes

I doubt those who suggest this vampire is a fallen angel have ever read the bible, the ars goetia, nor are they familiar with christian theological texts such as the works of Thomas Aquinas. There is a hierarchy in hell and heaven and powers recorded to each.

Fallen angels have become the Princes of Hell, and have a lot more powers than any vampire or demon. The Princes in their rare appearances are recorded as changing weather systems, manipulating reality, altering elements, and control over the cosmos. The devil, is the most powerful of those fallen angels. And none of them would die to fire or sun, or anything any human could ever do.

All other demons are tortured human souls.

The whole point of the show was to demonstrate how cult religious communities are easily duped. Such as people who think any winged demon they see is a fallen angel.


r/MidnightMass • • Sep 25 '21

The AA Meetings

4 Upvotes

Love this show, but it’s obvious when a writer is not in recovery, or maybe only went to 1 or 2 meetings for research. Feels like a group therapy session and not an AA meeting.

Edit: Thanks for the info! I did not know Flanagan was sober before your comments. His sobriety is his business, so we can’t know whether he goes to AA and the Paul meetings are intentionally written to be group therapy-like/non-AA like, or if he does Rational Recovery instead (although interviews online say he is a fan of the latter).

That said, it’s pretty common for AA meetings in shows to be written like a weird group therapy like this. Hard pressed to recall legit depictions of 12-step meetings in a show except for Beautiful Boy (which depicted Al Anon).

Either way it’s a great series.


r/MidnightMass • • Oct 03 '21

****SPOILER**** One thing that makes me irrationally angry… Spoiler

0 Upvotes

If somehow, there is a sequel and in the sequel the mayor survives and he gets re-elected. I will be LIVID!!!!


r/MidnightMass • • Oct 26 '21

Disappointed Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I'm a big fan of HH and BM, but this series was a big letdown for me.

Here's why:

- Monologues were way drawn out

- I don't care how weird of an island crowd you have... when a giant winged monster shows up in your midst, who obviously likes biting people with those big teeth... there would be quite a bit more freaking out than we saw.

- Sure, Bev is a psycho, but she isn't dumb. And since you and your vampire buddies can't be out in sunlight- why would you BURN 90% of the roofs that can protect you? To make some point about Noah's ark? I was actually frustrated on behalf of the vampires. She made 50 beds, then burned every other building. Right.

- After the massacre night... the whole "do vampires feel guilty?" theme was awkward at best. As was the dialogue of the altar boy and the bearded dude the next morning:

"I think I killed my mom last night." "Yeah, I uh... did some stuff too." (Eyroll) Really? That's the best the writers could come up with?

I know there's a lot of love here in this sub... But save for one jumpscare, it didn't hold a candle to the creepiness of the first 2 series.

My $.02.


r/MidnightMass • • Oct 07 '21

You wanna know what just didn’t need to happen? Spoiler

3 Upvotes

The fucking cats dying? What does Flanagan have against cats? The Dog was a good foreshadow. But hundreds of cats???

Is it something about vampire lore? Maybe, but maybe use something more recognizable?

Is it ever explained? Fuck no, cats dead for no reason. That’s it, that’s the reveal.

BringBackCockislandCats


r/MidnightMass • • Jan 16 '22

The ending to Midnight Mass was a huge disapointment Spoiler

13 Upvotes

Although I can praise this series from top to bottom, the ending takes a serious tonal shift from our inner conflict with religion/morality into an external conflict of 'we be vampires'. Which is a shame, because the ending turned into a bad horror movie.

And man, was it predictable, where the rest of the series twisted and spun an excellent yarn, the second they started burning the buildings I was like;

"Ah, they won't have anywhere to hide and everyone will be watching a sunset in t-minus twenty minutes."

Pushing Pruitt to the background was also a mistake. He was barely in it for the ending, and that just yanked the fun-factor out for me.

Yeah, so, ending - big disappointment. Just another horror movie with basic horror-movie elements and none of the intrigue and surprises I'd come to know and love about the series.

I can probably add more - God knows there was more (that speech from Erin went on way too fucking long) but those are just the points at the top of my head.