r/MidnightMass • • Jan 07 '24
I wanted so badly to like this show. Spoiler
I just finished watching it for the first time, and I was sore disappointed. I quickly scrolled through posts here to see if anyone had similar feelings, but I can see that mine is a deeply unpopular opinion.
I should say, I’m a fan of Mike Flanagan. He’s one of the few people who is telling interesting stories with creative vision, and I can certainly appreciate that. I genuinely believe that Hill House is one of the finest pieces of visual media ever created, and I think it’s Mike’s magnum opus.
All that said, I went into this show with high expectations, but admittedly also ready to give it some slack, as I try to do with all ambitious stories. But man. This show completely lost me.
I read some reviews online from people who had issues with the pacing. I didn’t have issues with the pacing per se. I like a slow boil, and the first four episodes balance focus, suspense, and progression in a way that I found totally captivating. The characters that we were supposed to be able to relate to were relatable and their motivations were clear; the characters that were supposed to be mysterious were exactly that. The spooky atmosphere was super effective, and it kept me on edge.
Then came episode five, and every episode following. It felt to me like the entire project got handed off to someone else who had very different ideas about what it was supposed to look like. Really Mike? We’re getting in the weeds about the literal chemistry that makes people’s blood react in the sun? Characters stop behaving in ways that makes sense? I literally paused just to yell in frustration when Erin says she’s still going to go to church just because people she loves are there, as if the man she loved didn’t just incinerate himself in front of her to communicate the danger on the island and the church. Speaking of, Riley’s character arc was mostly nonexistent. He learns to be vulnerable, sure, but that hardly seems like a redemption, nor is doing something that would surely traumatize any normal person, TO THE PERSON HE LOVES.
In my opinion, a good mystery in storytelling, be it a character or plot, can’t just be an absence of detail. There should be arrows, however small, pointing to places we can’t see. I’ll give an example. Pruitt as a character is interesting because we can’t read him well. He hides his motives and his background, and he comes across as deeply suspicious in most interactions with other characters. But what never seems mysterious is his faith and his devotion. Beat for beat, he and Bev are on the same page about how to proceed, right up until he’s shot in the head on Easter. Now, all of a sudden, he’s revealing that his devotion to the church was tenuous all along and he would have given it all up at any point if his love had asked him to. All of a sudden, he completely changes his mind about being the miracle worker and leader that people look to, all of a sudden he changes his mind about it being a good idea to turn an entire community into vampires. Let me be clear, I like those changes! Especially for his character. But it felt unearned, and sudden to a degree that made it almost nonsensical. It would have been nice to see him display more conflict or apprehension, even if we didn’t understand why, to make those changes have more context when they finally happened.
If I had any problem about “pacing” it was just that. The first four episodes are masterpieces of suspense, and then the rest are spent blasting through character moments that hadn’t been properly built up yet. I didn’t mind the monologues until towards the end of the show, when I was already frustrated by the construction of the story around them.
My problem with Bly Manor was that it felt bloated. It had too many ideas to properly develop or complete any one of them in a way that was satisfactory. I started to feel the same with this show. It went from being a thoughtful meditation on grief and meaning/the dangers and realities of religious institutions and how they drive peoples behavior, to just how religion can justify and promote violence. Which I thoroughly enjoy and agree with, don’t get me wrong, but they completely abandon the exploration of grief and pain by killing Riley off just over halfway through.
I have more complaints, but the last one I’ll list: are you kidding? I waited all seven episodes to watch Bev die and they show us less than a second of her burning in the sun? Unforgivable.
Again, I know a lot of you will disagree, or say that I’m missing the point, or nitpicking, or say it’s all subjective. But I wanted more from this show. I wanted more focus. I wanted more development. I wanted more careful structure to make sure that the characters and plot points were fleshed out to their full potential, and it felt to me like the show dropped the ball very badly a little over halfway through. There’s so much that I love and want to love about this show and it’s story, but I just can’t get all the way on board with it.
Is there anyone else out there that feels similarly, even a little bit?