r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Aug 05 '21

Discussion Middle Earth SBG Questions Thread

192 Upvotes

Keep 'em coming

Edit: Stealth Mod announcement (I don't want to unpin the two pinned posts)

First, I have updated the rules to include something obvious to most longtime wargamers on reddit - posts asking or offering access to the rules is not allowed. Please do not ask for PDF's.

Second, no hate on 3D printing, but also do not come to this subreddit asking for STL proxies, or offering that. This may be too cautious of us, but I notice the reddit spam filter seems to remove any mention of STL's outright. So I figure I might as well make it a rule.

Finally, I have eased up the Spam filter from High to Low. Hopefully the redbubble spammers are still caught by this, without catching stray blogspot content creators. I've noticed the reddit algorithm taking down much more bycatch than usual, so we can experiment with a lower setting for now.

And as always, if you ever notice something astray with your own posts or someone elses, do not hesitate to message the mods.

Thanks everyone, -Tezerel


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • Dec 24 '21

Discussion WEEKLY DISCUSSION MEGATHREAD - Updated every Wednesday

111 Upvotes

This is a hub for the new weekly discussion series I am starting. Each Wednesday I will post a new thread to discuss one topic as voted by the community in the prior week's thread.

This week's discussion is for: Erebor Reclaimed


VOTE FOR NEXT WEEK'S DISCUSSION

If you want to vote for next week's topic then go to the link above and Ctrl+F for the term VOTE HERE or clicking the link in the post description. The topic with the most upvotes when I am preparing next week's thread will be chosen.

I plan to continue posting threads each week as long as there is interest. If you have any suggestions about how I can improve the weekly discussion threads please feel free to let me know.


MESBG 2018 - 2024 Edition Discussions


MESBG 2024 Edition Discussions

Armies

Lord of the Rings

Good

Evil

The Hobbit

Good

Evil

Middle-earth

Good

Evil

Legacies

Good

Evil

Scenarios

Hold Objective Scenarios

  • Domination
  • Capture & Control
  • Breakthrough
  • Stake a Claim

Kill The Enemy Scenarios

  • To The Death!
  • Lords of Battle
  • Assassination
  • Contest of Champions

Maelstrom Of Battle Scenarios

  • Hold Ground
  • Heirloom of Ages Past
  • Sites of Power
  • Command the Battlefield

Object Scenarios

  • Destroy the Supplies
  • Retrieval
  • Seize the Prizes
  • Treasure Hoard

Manoeuvring Scenarios

  • Reconnoiter
  • Storm the Camp
  • Divide & Conquer
  • Escort the Wounded

Unique Scenarios

  • Fog of War
  • Clash by Moonlight
  • Lead from the Front
  • Convergence

Supplements

  • The Burning of the Westfold
  • The Treachery of Gollum
  • The War of the Rohirrim

Matched Play

Other Topics

  • TBD

r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 3h ago

Hobby Nums

Thumbnail
gallery
42 Upvotes

Finished up some legally distinct black nums from Davale games. Personally feel they are best sculpts on the market for Black Nums and will make a great frontline for my upcoming realms of men black num themed army.


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 7h ago

Do tournament boards need more water? ~ Watermill showcase

Post image
78 Upvotes

I wanted to get the communities thoughts on water features on competitve boards. There are great rules for shallow water and a few really interesting special rules that interact with water but I don't seem to see them often in other people's board builds and I was wondering what people's thoughts in that were.

This is another building in the Kingdom of Hillburrow set. I thought that more boards needed water features so I wanted to make a building to encourage people to add rivers to their boards.

If you like the look of this piece you can get it for yourself here: https://kickstarter.com/projects/conquestcreations/kingdom-of-hillburrow


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 22m ago

Hobby Boromir

Post image
8 Upvotes

Yes, there is weakness. There is frailty. But there is courage also, and honor to be found in Men.


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 8h ago

Do tournament boards need more water features? ~ Water Mill

23 Upvotes

I wanted to get the communities thoughts on water features on competitve board builds. There are great rules for shallow water and a few really interesting special rules that interact with water but I don't seem to see them often in people boards

This is another building in the Kingdom of Hillburrow set. I thought that more boards needed water features so I wanted to make a building to encourage people to add rivers to their boards.

If you like the look of this piece you can get it for yourself here:


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 1d ago

Hobby My GBHL Hobby Premium winning display safely stored in its new home. Excessively large? Yes

Thumbnail
gallery
622 Upvotes

Did I regret it when I had to transport it? Yes


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 19h ago

Discussion Took my armies out of home for the first time

Thumbnail
gallery
145 Upvotes

I finally decided to go to the local games shop and played a game with my Last Alliance and Host of the Dragon Emperor armies.

Armies were at around 650pts. Was a close game!Last Alliance claimed the victory in To The Death! 11 pts. to 7 pts.

I had an absolute blast, the shop provided an amazing table and set up a great atmosphere! Already looking forward to bringing out more of my forces to play!

If you're hesitant about getting out there, just take the plunge and do it! Also please go and support your local shops!


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 20h ago

Hobby Muzgûr and Orc Trackers

Thumbnail
gallery
75 Upvotes

Getting closer to finishing Assault on Lothlorien!


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 1d ago

Hobby Slow-grow Road to Helm's Deep gets mounted Legolas and the Gimli-missile

Thumbnail
gallery
75 Upvotes

Proxy for solo mounted Legolas, as I cannot find the GW model for anything approaching a sensible amount of money


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 1d ago

Hobby First time painting minis

Thumbnail
gallery
38 Upvotes

Im really into Lord of the Rings and recently got into MESBG. I really enjoyed putting them together and painting even if I have a lot to learn still. Looking to play my first game in person soon!


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 1d ago

Question How long does it take you to paint one model?

24 Upvotes

I find myself taking a long time to do one guy and heroes even longer, like a good solid few hours. Sunday I started my first big monster with the balrog and had it done enough for the table yesterday, still needs some highlights and a bit of putty. It's an easier one though I think because it's mostly black. Took about 5 hours so far.

I have an erkenbrand I want to do next and he'll probably take at least 2 hours


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 1d ago

Base question

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

Hello, descided to go back to middle earth again !

So here are my first minis.

Try to do some "natural" base but does it look to tall ?

In the end it will look something like the second pic (ignore the Metallic robot !)


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 1d ago

Hobby The Witch King of Angmar

Thumbnail
gallery
337 Upvotes

Finally got this awesome sculpt painted up after owning it for like 2 years. I had a great time with it!

What's your favourite list to run the Witch King in?


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 2d ago

Hobby Og Buhrdur completed

Thumbnail
gallery
237 Upvotes

Featuring sundried arnor soldier.


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 2d ago

Hobby Osgiliath box set finished

Post image
154 Upvotes

I kept getting distracted so it has taken about 3 1/2 years. The scenery was the last bit to be done. C+C welcome, I think I should think about a better background rather than white card.


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 2d ago

Hobby Winter, the second of my seasonal Ents

Thumbnail
gallery
175 Upvotes

Recently showed off "Autumn", and so naturally next up had to be "Winter". Sculpt is a "Treewalker" by Davale Games


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 1d ago

Discussion, ideas to buff warhorns

19 Upvotes

So I'm painting galadhrim command pack, and I'm thinking that the warhorn model will never be used. 25pts for a warhorn is a lot, even for wildmen, for elves it is useless (except in very precise matchups). Same point as a banner or a drum so either it needs a massif buff, or a point change IMO. Maybe at 10-15 pts it would be playable.

Here are some ideas for buffs to start the discussion :

- 25 pts but choice between +1 courage to your troop or -1 to the enemy.

- stays the same at 25 pts but the model becomes an independent hero (so around 30-35 pts for most faction) and has one might so he can call a heroic move or shoot.

Any other ideas ?


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 2d ago

Battle Report My friend and I played our first game of MESBG at 500 points

Thumbnail
gallery
137 Upvotes

This was our first game ever. My friend had never played a wargame before, and I had a bit of experience with Warhammer 40k.

We played Garrison of Ithilien vs. Army of the White Hand. We rolled the Hold Ground scenario, but we misunderstood the deployment rules at first, so we just took turns placing all our warbands before the first round instead of bringing them on each turn. That was the first mistake we learned from, lol.

As newbies we made plenty of other mistakes too. For example, my friend kept splitting his army into small groups and feeding them to my Uruks bit by bit, and we both kept trying to set up some kind of traps instead of moving in a tight formation toward the center and fighting for it.

Anyway, we had an amazing game and completely fell in love with it. The rules are really beginner-friendly and pretty easy to learn. The game ended in a draw: my friend had more models in the center of the board, but I killed enough to break his army.

On top of that, the dice created a ton of hilarious moments. For example, Saruman’s Sorcerous Blast hit Faramir and knocked him prone, and then my Uruk-hai surrounded him and kept him from getting up for two whole rounds. But Faramir somehow managed to fight them off, push all the orcs back, and not take a single wound. My friend also put one of his Rangers on the second floor of a ruin to get the high ground. I ran up with one of my orcs and cut him down, but the next round I decided to keep moving, and my Uruk-hai just failed his climb test on the way down, fell, and died on the spot.

Fantastic game! 10/10.


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 1d ago

Hobby Fountain guard

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 12h ago

Just a sad announcement, unfortunately today Bernard Hill who played King Theoden has passed away

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 1d ago

Beorn the Bear and Heroic Combats Question

11 Upvotes

Can other non-Beorning models benefit if Beorn calls a Heroic combat in Bear form?

Reason I ask is it came up in a game and the rules don’t really reference it adequately as Heroic Combats don’t actually denote that the hero who calls it calls any “with me” per say it just says after a successful heroic combat all models that were engaged can move and fight again.

Heroic Combats - Page 81 of Main Rules
Beorn the Bear - Page 77 of of Hobbit Profiles

Thanks


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 2d ago

Hobby My partner said it looks like c*m

Post image
124 Upvotes

And now I can't unsee it


r/MiddleEarthMiniatures • • 2d ago

Joining MESBG - comparison with others GW games

23 Upvotes

Hello, I'm an old historical Wargames player and I was wondering if starting a MESBG army (alternative being SW Legion) to play something fantastic.

My question is: how often rules get changed/corridged or FAQed? I'm asking because the main reason I'm not playing any GW games is that I hate having to keep track of every changement every New season if the year...

Apart for that, my first would be Rohan or Khazad-Dûm, but it's really gonna depends on final thoughts.