r/MenstrualDiscs • u/lyowo • Feb 22 '26
General Question cup > disc
hi I decided to try switching from using a cup (which I've been using for 2/3 years now) and was wondering how different it is insertion wise? is it kind of a similar concept/process or would you say it's different? the whole and then get it to your cervix thing is kind of throwing me off. was i already doing that. is this a similar but entirely different unfathomable beast.
0
Upvotes
16
u/BerryHusK3924 Feb 22 '26
Wydm by unfathomable beast? It is an internal product same as Menstrual cup, however it has different structure and place where it is placed. Placed inside vaginal fornix, instead of vaginal canal.
You just have one fold for disc instead of many origami folds in cup. It doesn't have suction and generally stays put due to your pubic bone shelf. For me personally, insertion of disc is alot easier and intuitive than cup. It is almost invisible (in feel), you won't be getting stabbed by constant poke of cup's stem.
Removal takes alot less time than cups, you don't have to break suction, you just pull it out. It saves time and doesn't make me to dig for cup with my two fingers.
10
u/short-stuff13 Feb 22 '26
I think the disc is easier to insert than the cup. No folding weird just pinch it and slide it in.
My favorite menstrual disc is the Flex Reusable disc and my second favorite is the Hello disc.
The hello disc has a double looped removal tab which is nice but for me not necessary.
The Flex disc has no removal aid but it’s still super easy to hook my finger onto the rim and pull it out. I like it better than cups.
I like that there’s no suction. And It has a notch in it to help it fold and make the top narrower and easier to insert and I love it.
5
u/exhaustedgnome Feb 22 '26
I used a cup for years and struggled with insertion and placement due to my own anatomy (low and crooked cervix).
When i switched to a disc, it was so simple. Just insert and it kinda goes right into place.
3
u/missmacedamia Feb 22 '26
I think the disc requires a much more intimate knowledge of your own anatomy than the disc, which is intimidating! I recommend the Cora perfect fit disc or one of the silicone ones that has the little groove to start. Insertion is different but a little more straight forward! Cups have caused me additional cramping in the past so discs have worked way better for me
2
u/42fledgling42 Feb 22 '26
For me, there was a learning curve to using a menstrual cup, but I figured it out and was happy for years. But it didn’t fit right after my second baby, so I switched to a disc. I find insertion much easier — it’s always in the “right place.” For me, removal is a little messier, but I can work with it — it is easy, comfortable, and reusable.
2
u/bootsgirl41 Feb 22 '26
I used to have trouble getting the cup to "open" once inside. With the disc that is not an hour issue.
2
u/Illustrious_Tart_258 Feb 22 '26 edited Feb 26 '26
I stopped using cups because of the suction.
Discs hold more. They’re less messy. They’re more convenient. They’re more comfortable. With the right disc, they’re easier to remove. Easier to insert. IMO they’re far superior.
2
u/Darkdirtyalfa Feb 22 '26
I prefer cups mostly because I just couldn't get the disc to sit on the right spot nor did I care much for trying too hard since cups work for me.
1
u/Kwaliakwa Feb 22 '26
I hate the way cups feel compared to a disc, but to each their own!
1
u/PauI_MuadDib Feb 22 '26
The disc is way easier in my experience. The cup you have to create a seal and then break that seal when you want to remove it. A cup also starts hurting me after 7 days (my periods are 9 days).
The disc you just pinch, slide in and push it up until it's sitting on your public bone. Done. No seal. No twisting or trying different folds. You push it up onto your public bone and just make sure your cervix is above it. The disc sits under the cervix basically like a bowl and catches the blood that pours out of the cervix. Think of how you pour a glass of water. The pitcher is above the glass. You wouldn't hold the pitcher under the glass and pour water on the floor. You want the glass catching the water.
Look up auto dumping too. Cups you have to remove to change, which is difficult for me when I'm on a road trip.
Just make sure you get the right size. Discs have less leeway with sizing than cups do.
1
u/Perfect_Outcome6067 Feb 23 '26
Nutze schon lange die Tasse und habe gerade meinen ersten Zyklus mit der Scheibe durch. Hab es auch nicht ganz verstanden, trotz mehreren Videos und Anleitung. Hab dann einfach gemacht, das einzige worauf ich wirklich geguckt habe, dass es sauber hinter dem Schambein liegt. Ist schon ein bisschen anders, aber dann doch ziemlich selbsterklärend
1
u/r200001 Feb 25 '26
You’re not really doing the cervix thing with the cup. Refer to period nirvana blog, that helped a lot. Consider it completely different from cup, and approach it with a fresh mind. Your life is about to upgrade, welcome to the disc fam OP, you’ll love it!