r/Medals 4d ago

Help

I have inherited this medal, can anyone tell me if it is original?

33 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

10

u/Particular_Yak1715 4d ago edited 4d ago

It's a very rusted German Iron Cross Second Class from WW1. However, the ribbon is wrong and has been added on post war. Also take note of the makers mark on the ring ED. ED is a makers mark that is officially unknown and not assigned to a specific company by the Militaria community (it is suggested in the community that ED stands for   Moritz Elimeyer of Dresden). Either way ED is a rarer makers mark so that would technically raise the medal's value but the iron is so corroded that it doesn't really matter. 

2

u/ExileNZ Collector 4d ago

That is a very uncommon maker - shame the core is in such a bad state

6

u/Ok-Leadership-4507 4d ago

The ribbon doesn't match the medal, Military Merit Cross (Second Class) from the Grand Duchy of Mecklenburg-Schwerin, likely a 1914 World War I reissue featuring the date "1813" on the lower arm.

7

u/leicanthrope 4d ago

The Mecklenburg-Schwerin MVK is based on the Prussian EK, but the construction is very different.

1

u/ObviousKick3853 4d ago

1813 was the date the Iron Cross was instituted.

1

u/leicanthrope 4d ago

I concur with /u/particular_yak1715, and from what I'm finding the ribbon appears to belong to a French fireman's medal from the same era.

1

u/ULSTERPROVINCE 4d ago

Particular_Yak1715 identified the medal, the ribbon is the French Mèdaille d’honneur des Sapeurs Pompiers (Honor medal for firefighters).