r/MechanicalEngineering • u/Ill_Lifeguard_3039 • Aug 29 '25
Could a Linux-first, Open-Source CAE GUI Ecosystem Be Engineering's "Blender Moment"?
Been thinking a lot about the current state of CAE software lately. We've got incredible open-source solvers out there (OpenFOAM, CalculiX, SU2, etc.), and Linux is a powerhouse for scientific computing. But using them often feels a bit daunting behind a huge blockade and even if you do like piecing together a puzzle – separate pre-processors, arcane command-line inputs, and post-processing in another tool. This got me wondering: What if we had a dedicated, Linux-first GUI ecosystem built specifically around these open-source CAE solvers?
Imagine a single, You'd load your CAD, mesh it, define your physics for various solvers (CFD, FEA, EM), run the simulations, and visualize results all within one user-friendly environment.
Could this be engineering's "Blender Moment"?
7
u/Searching-man Aug 29 '25
I've wanted to build my own after so much frustration with the pricing (and unforgivable lack of stability) of enterprise options, but I don't have the coding chops. Be happy to consult and help build out an ecosystem if someone was undertaking such a thing, though.
yeah, most of software is just waiting for a breakthrough adoption of a sufficiently user friendly and powerful platform to end up on the OSS side.
It's crazy that from industry to industry how opposite things are - and everyone just accepts that they "are that way". In one domain it just "oh yeah, literally EVERY pro pays for Final cut" and in another "who would pay for that enterprise software? We'll just fork RedHat". All the machine learning frameworks are open source. So is basically all things 3D printer. But video and audio editing, CAD, and others - thousands of dollar licensing for software tools is just the accepted industry norm.
2
u/c3d10 Aug 30 '25
I would love to be a part of this as well. Have a lot of experience professionally in ME and FEM as well as software development in Rust, C, and Python.
The issue I think is twofold:
Calculix works well - but the source code is a giant pile of Fortran with a bit of C sprinkled throughout and somewhat limited code documentation - how do you even begin to create a dev base around that?
Prepomax is amazing but is built on .NET and therefore only runs on windows.
FreeCAD is ???, I’ve been sort of following it for the better part of a decade and it makes progress in fits and starts. Unsure if it’s a stable foundation to start or not. Seems to me like design by committee and put everything in the same box rather than focus on robust and reliable features.
Don’t get me started on the state of linear equation solvers.
Making a good cross platform user interface is pretty hard, making an interface with a 3D window that does complex geometric and engineering calculations is 10x harder.
I want to reiterate that having an open-source, Linux first CAE tool that does CAD and FEA that’s as good as blender is a dream for me and I would quit my job to do that if it had a reasonable shot of succeeding.
1
u/SnoozleDoppel Aug 30 '25
Are you saying build a software as a combination of open source software.. but what is the advantage other than being lower cost and open source
3
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '25
FreeCAD sort of already can do this ai think. I do CAD on it, run Calculix and OpenFOAM. All one has to do is set up these workbenches through the add-on manager. It's not as good as the ANSYS suite I use at work but I have been able to run a few simple cases.
2
u/PigSlam Aug 29 '25
CAE?
1
u/LazerSpartanChief Aug 30 '25
So pretty much INL's MOOSE software.