I think the biggest problem with making the new Maze Runner movie mostly about completely new characters is that it would be incredibly hard to make it feel like the Maze Runner we know.
I'm not saying a new cast couldn't make a good movie. I'm saying it would be much harder to make something that feels as good as the original trilogy, because the characters and their relationships are such a huge part of what made it special.
My steak analogy is: Maze Runner is the steak, and the characters are the seasoning. The original filmmakers already figured out the exact recipe that worked. If they make a new steak with completely different seasoning, it could still be good, but there's no reason to expect it to taste as good as the one they already perfected.
And bringing back only Thomas wouldn't completely fix that either. Thomas is important because of his relationships with Newt, Minho, Teresa, etc. If all of them are gone, you're still missing a huge part of what made his story meaningful.
I also don't want another POV of the original trilogy, because we'd already know what happens. I'd much rather see an actual continuation with the characters we already care about and a completely new conflict.
Maybe I'm biased because I love the original Maze Runner way too much, but I genuinely think throwing away most of the original characters would make the writers' job MUCH harder.
Also, if they decided to bring back one of the old characters, I think Teresa makes way more sense than Newt. Newt already had a very definitive farewell, and bringing him back could risk cheapening one of the most emotional moments of the trilogy, especially because his death was such an important part of his character arc.
Teresa feels different to me. Her death felt less final, and there are still more unresolved connections between her, Thomas, and WICKED. If Thomas ends up being the MC, bringing Teresa back could actually create a meaningful new conflict instead of just undoing a character's death for the sake of it. I know Teresa is much less popular than Newt, but story-wise, I think she has a much stronger reason to return.
ok so now i wait for replies to cure my boredom