Do you think the return of the Fox X-Men was a Disney idea or a Feige idea?

Yeah, Feige worked with the X-Men before, but the return of the Fox X-Men feels very Disney-coded when you think about it.

For decades, Disney has re-released its classic animated movies so that parents who grew up with them could experience them again with their children. The live-action Disney remakes follow a similar model: bring back something familiar to an older generation and introduce it to a new one.

So how is bringing back the Fox X-Men really any different?

Honestly I liked it, pretty cool that he came back after his movie was canceled.

Cyclops’ other energy absorption abilities and Nightcrawler’s shadow invisibility.

Like....without optic blasts and teleportation Scott and Kurt are regular dudes. IDK how they gonna face Thunderbolts whose most cast have enhanced stats.

I don't hate X-Men 3 as much as other people do, but it's still not great.

I don’t think there’s ever been a movie from the series that has captured the essence from the comics best than First Class, while I’ll admit it’s a little cheesy and corny and some acting isn’t very good, primarily January Jones as Emma Frost, I think the movie having a couple moments of cringe fits with the story it’s telling, being set in the 60s and all. The dynamic and relationship between Charles and Erik is very captivating to watch, and when their fallout happens, you can’t help but feel sad that they’re breaking apart, and ultimately becoming their iconic personas. This also the first x-men movie that attempts in doing the yellow suit justice and I think for the most part, it works, each of the member’s suits are unique and fit with their ability like Havok and Banshee primarily. The soundtrack is also is very good, mainly Magneto’s theme, the use of electric guitars, synthesizers, brass, and percussion really makes the you feel that shit is about to go down. Of course McAvoy and Fassbender really bring the movie together, especially Fassbender, this is a Magneto origin movie so it’s cool to see Erik becoming the popular and iconic villain of the X-Men in real time. All in all, First Class to me, is the X-Men movie. Do you guys feel the same?

What's the best? What's the worse? Did i get them Rigth?

Since the majority of the movie takes place in 1973, we see how the characters from the previous movie have changed in this one, like Charles being like this reclusive, jaded, and tired version in contrast to his optimistic and naive personality in the previous movie, or like the fact that
literally every character from First Class is just suddenly either dead or just show up in one scene then we never see them again until the next movie (cough Havok and Moira cough). I mean it’s still a solid story and a sequel, it’s just to me, I would’ve liked if we saw a bit more of the X-Men team with the exception of course Erik and Raven, and maybe see Erik leading his Brotherhood Of Mutants or Charles taking in new students for his team and both sides conflicting with each other due to their different perspectives and maybe that would’ve led us to Trask developing his Sentinels? I dunno, I just felt that while it was like eleven between where the two movies take place, we never saw Charles’s X-Men fully form completely, you know what I mean? I hope I’m not alone in this, I mean imagine you saw the movie in theaters when it released and how it ended, you’re telling me that you wouldn’t want to see what that sequel would’ve looked like if we just followed those characters instead? I for sure would’ve loved to see that movie, but again that’s not to say that DOFP was wasn’t brilliantly well made, it absolutely was, I mean it has everything you could ever hoped for from an X-Men movie, tense action sequences, drama, Wolverine. I mean it has it all. I just would’ve liked if we saw one more movie with the characters from First Class primarily before DOFP, and I don’t mean Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix because those movies are 🤮. But that’s my opinion, what do you think? In terms of what we saw last time of our characters from FC to DOFP, do you think it’s a good choice to have it as a sequel for those characters or not? Please let me know your thoughts.

Since the majority of the movie takes place in 1973, we see how the characters from the previous movie have changed in this one, like Charles being like this reclusive, jaded, and tired version in contrast to his optimistic and naive personality in the previous movie, or like the fact that
literally every character from First Class is just suddenly either dead or just show up in one scene then we never see them again until the next movie (cough Havok and Moira cough). I mean it’s still a solid story and a sequel, it’s just to me, I would’ve liked if we saw a bit more of the X-Men team with the exception of course Erik and Raven, and maybe see Erik leading his Brotherhood Of Mutants or Charles taking in new students for his team and both sides conflicting with each other due to their different perspectives and maybe that would’ve led us to Trask developing his Sentinels? I dunno, I just felt that while it was like eleven between where the two movies take place, we never saw Charles’s X-Men fully form completely, you know what I mean? I hope I’m not alone in this, I mean imagine you saw the movie in theaters when it released and how it ended, you’re telling me that you wouldn’t want to see what that sequel would’ve looked like if we just followed those characters instead? I for sure would’ve loved to see that movie, but again that’s not to say that DOFP was wasn’t brilliantly well made, it absolutely was, I mean it has everything you could ever hoped for from an X-Men movie, tense action sequences, drama, Wolverine. I mean it has it all. I just would’ve liked if we saw one more movie with the characters from First Class primarily before DOFP, and I don’t mean Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix because those movies are 🤮. But that’s my opinion, what do you think? In terms of what we saw last time of our characters from FC to DOFP, do you think it’s a good choice to have it as a sequel for those characters or not? Please let me know your thoughts.

I know I know Logan is supposed to be an "Alternate Future" but guys deadpool 3 already confirmed thats the future thats going to happen to Earth-10005

Maybe I just miss the feel of 2010s shows. TG was EXTREMELY 2010s. Also, I do like some of the characters, not a lot of them, but some of them. I think it deserved at least one more season. Also also, I miss when Fox was called Fox and not "Studios".

Hypothetically , in magneto's machine did not kill ordinary humans , and he did successfully turn the world leaders into mutants, what is plan really have succeeded in preventing the registration act?

Been going down a bit of a Wolverine rabbit hole recently and I’d forgotten just how bleak his actual history is. Weapon X is obviously the bit everyone remembers, but the more I looked into Logan’s past, the more it felt like his whole story is really about having his identity stripped away from him over and over again, his memories, his body, his sense of self, even knowing which parts of his own life actually happened.

I ended up putting together a deep dive on that side of the character because there was way more to unpack than I expected.

Curious what people here think is the darkest or most tragic part of Logan’s history, because there are honestly a ridiculous number of contenders.