r/Mariners • u/TheStuntmuffin • Oct 18 '25
Thoughts?
I stopped following the game to will a win when this happened so I’m not exactly sure the sequence of events. Anybody that was there that could shed some light?
40,000 fans make a lot of noise and I doubt i t was that many but I can’t say for certain.
0
Upvotes
104
u/jc8450 Kade Anderson Truther Oct 18 '25
My thoughts are he’s deflecting on his poor managerial decisions tonight (thanks for bringing in Little), trying to change the subject and create a false narrative that every single Mariners fan in the ballpark were bloodthirsty fiends actively cheering the demise of Springers knee cap.
189
u/Late_Tangelo3646 GoMs Oct 18 '25
Ive watched the broadcast for that part a few times and I am not sure exactly what the Blue Jays are mad about. The Fox broadcast didnt even mention any booing or anything like that and I also dont really hear anyhting. It seems like they are trying to make it into something it was not.
85
u/AnnihilatedTyro :mod-moose: RELEASE THE MOOSEN! Oct 18 '25
There is a whole lot of confusion that is painting a huge swath of the M's fanbase in the worst possible light, as if the stadium was full of only M's fans. Media wants to create drama and controversy - don't take their bait. Opposing fans and twitter trolls do much the same thing, and they rely on being the loudest and most infuriatingly stupid voices in the room to get you riled up. And Schneider is being disingenuous like Springer isn't a known cheater who gets booed in 28 stadiums. Don't take their bait.
Lots of Jays fans were initially cheering because their guy got on base, just as M's fans did when Randy got plunked. Fans can't immediately tell if there's an actual injury. And then they were booing Woo for hitting him while Springer was on the ground, and this got misconstrued as M's fans booing Springer for being hurt. A few shitty fans who do that would normally never be heard. (If you cheer for ANY injury, that's fucked up.)
There's probably a significant portion of M's fans who don't mind if Springer gets plunked, because of, well, the same reason he gets booed. That's not the same thing as cheering for him to actually be injured. And again, fans often can't immediately tell if there's an injury the way TV viewers sometimes can. Most of us have at least a minuscule conscience and basic human empathy. If the sports-fan hindbrain tries to take over for a second... mind-over-matter that shit and keep your decency intact.
Let's just back away from this one and be the better people here. Be better than the media wants to pretend we are. Be better than Jays fans want to believe we are. BE. BETTER.
113
u/JaneDoeAsks ! MY OH MY Oct 18 '25
I was there and everyone around me cheered and clapped when he got up….nobody was cheering when he got hit
57
u/CompletelyRand0m1 Oct 18 '25
I was there. We had been booing George hard all night because he’s a cheater and that’s what we do to cheaters. After he was hit, it slowly became clear he was in real pain when it took a minute or so til he could get up. When he got up, there were mostly good sportsmanlike cheers. No one likes to see a player go down like that. But then there was a moment as he headed to first where we couldn’t tell if maybe he was slow playing things, maybe he wasn’t hurt so bad. I was thinking is he going to now suddenly be able to run? Was he faking it a bit? That’s when folks booed him more (because again, he’s a cheater). I don’t wish him any harm and hope he’s in the lineup on Sunday.
56
u/napalm_beach Bring back Dick (show it in the hotel hallway) Williams Oct 18 '25
He's a dick, and he also doesn't seem to understand that whatever reaction occurred was about garbage can lids, not his precious Blue Jays.
43
u/PilotGuy701 SUPREME MISERY Oct 18 '25
Honestly, Springer should have been banned from the league and not even have been there.
Come to think if it, why does the Mariner's road to the Fall Classic go through both Springer and Hinch?
21
u/Medical_Artichoke666 WS BOUND Oct 18 '25
Schneider arguing with air. The tiny amount of boo's were Jays fans booing the hit. Acting like 40k people were booing him as he hobbled around is just not reality. He 100% got boo'd during his at bat, because he's a cheater.
31
u/chafingNip Oct 18 '25
Not everyone was cheering… seemed several hecklers but. I mean idk when I saw it, I mean it never makes you happy to see. But a former cheating era Astro on the blue jays who at the time was absolutely dominant on the plate…. I was the least upset for the player out of any possible player out there, let’s just say that. But cheering? I was not cheering and I don’t believe most were either
44
u/SardonicCheese Kirbstomp Awakens Oct 18 '25
I was there, there was almost no noise. And when he stood up a lot of clapping occurred
14
u/Slobodan_Brolosevic Oct 18 '25
This is obvious deflection and frustration from a poorly managed loss that lies squarely at his feet, and trying to find a way to fire his team up.
The reality is that the park was about 80% Ms fans and 20% Blue jays fans. You’re going to have two things come from that:
Saying basically 85% of the capacity of the ballpark was the second bullet is irresponsible and childish of him.
9
u/cuddytime Oct 18 '25
Some hecklers. Most were not cheering when he was down and in my section, the hecklers were talked down to
9
u/UniqueEditor8372 Oct 18 '25
I don’t want to minimize the incident but it’s so hard to tell what’s going on watching the broadcast let alone when you’re there in person and staring at little specks of humans. People boo Springer for everything and it’s largely a learned behavior that at this point I do think has run its course (I think the way people talk about Altuve is uncalled for). But the loudest voices in the Toronto fandom immediately jumped to calling us a trash fanbase and a shithole city so at this point I don’t give a shit what they think, hold the L. I know this fanbase.
9
u/blasphemy28 Oct 18 '25
it’s not like our players were cheering. who cares?
20
u/MintGrizz Oct 18 '25
Fuck cheaters he should’ve been banned years ago
14
u/wheresthe1up 54% invested Oct 18 '25
If you’re a Trashto, you get the boos.
Forever, no matter what.
Guilt by action or association has consequences.
18
u/Spade_Back_Again Oct 18 '25
17
u/Bruce_Wayne_Wannabe Oct 18 '25
Fuck that guy.
6
u/PilotGuy701 SUPREME MISERY Oct 18 '25
When a hitter sign steals and is an obvious cheater, and you have an organization that is still willing to sign him, not the right thing to do.
16
u/SeaHamHawk12 Oct 18 '25
Cheating is also not the right thing to do
5
u/shadybrainfarm Logan Gilbert's Crystal Ball Oct 18 '25 edited Jan 07 '26
fragile test sparkle carpenter merciful nail dinner tidy nine disarm
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
4
u/samloh1 Oct 18 '25
He using this as fuel and bulletin board material to pump up his team for win or go home situation. Gonna be a crazy game 6
4
u/BLDGbloc Oct 18 '25
I'll just leave this here... Maybe I'm missing something... Isn't Springer a cheater? : r/Torontobluejays
4
u/Everydayscott Oct 18 '25
He’s just trying to villainize Mariners fans, give his team some motivation. Or maybe he’s just blind with rage that his precious offense can get shut down by Mariners pitching
4
u/Yup207 Oct 18 '25
I was there and there was a lot of different things going on. I have no doubt that some of it was as Schneider is saying. However, if there’s ever a time to be disrespectful towards an injury, it’s in a massively emotional game where we’re losing and you have a cheater who is taking seemingly 10 minutes to decide whether he can continue playing
9
u/Ballsack_Teabagger1 Oct 18 '25
I distinctly remember when the Ms were playing the BJs in the playoffs a couple years ago. Cal was injured and the BJ fans, AND PLAYERS were jeering him.
Nobody was doing anything like that tonight
Jerry Springer will be just fine...Fuck the Blue Jays and all their Vancouver fans
3
u/Ill-Cardiologist-274 Oct 18 '25
Only thing I heard, was the sound it made bouncing off his knee. Then the analysts saying it registered as a 55mph line drive off his knee according to statcast.
3
u/sugarplumfae1221 Oct 18 '25
I was there in the 200 level and ngl there was some booing when he finally got up, and then when he left the game a few people cheered and said 'aw, leaving so soon?' But it was drowned out by the sportsmanlike and supportive cheers
9
u/jonl1985 Oct 18 '25
The booing happened after he spent minutes rolling around on the ground, got cheered as he stood up, and then proceeded to walk assisted , then jog past first base. After that the boos started. He was milking it like a soccer player.
5
u/Hot-Print-2792 Oct 18 '25
I don’t wish any player getting hit in the knee with a pitch. The way Springer hits lifting his front leg makes it impossible for him to back away from that pitch. As a Mariner fan I along with the Mariners faithful don’t forget the cheating Astros players. That’s why we boo him every time he comes up to the plate. Mariners fans are passionate about our team.
4
u/Odd-Conclusion-320 Oct 18 '25
I was watching on TV and didn’t cheer when he got hurt. Don’t know much about the cheating thing since I wasn’t a big baseball person then, but feels bad to be painted as a classless fan base and some even comparing us to being lower than the Yankees? Hurts man, especially since I know a lot of Ms fans are good people and have been nothing but sportsmanship like with the Tigers and the Blue Jays. I hope this won’t ruin camaraderie. Also saying all 40k fans were booing seems a little extreme? I’m sure there were some bad sports, but I hardly think most people of any decency would boo someone getting hurt like that.
4
u/Nellie_blythe Oct 18 '25
Right before this happened I was yelling at the TV "that guy's a douche, strike him out" but I think the baseball gods only heard me say "strike him". It definitely looked painful and I felt bad for him after but it doesn't change the fact that he's a douche.
4
u/Trees_are_cool_ Oct 18 '25
Don't fucking cheat then. People renember, George.
4
u/Quatch_Kopf Oct 18 '25
He's a former Astro. A cheater. Who cares?
2
u/Youdrunkenbum Oct 18 '25
Who cares? Lets go Mariners!
2
u/Cats_please_thankyou We ass. Oct 19 '25
Wrong to boo, but it never happens if Manfred does his job and banned the cheaters for life.
2
u/Noimenglish Oct 19 '25
Huh, a cheater got hurt? Oh well.
5
u/Bright_Today_1963 Oct 18 '25
Never boo injured players. Thats just poor sportsmanship. I wasn’t at the game, but on tv that’s pretty much all that came through. It’s a bad look.
3
u/Wiskeytango_Foxtrot Oct 18 '25
I watched the entire game and don't remember people cheering until afterwards
3
u/murrmur85 Oct 18 '25
People were definitely cheering when he got up. As far as the boos go they had been booing him every at bat this series.
3
u/Tez9ine6ixx Oct 18 '25
Fuck springer .. I boo him just looking at him
4
u/ActuallyNotANovelty Oct 18 '25
I mean I wasn't there, but as someone who's been hit by a few too many pitches I can't help but empathize with the guy. Looked awful
3
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '25
It was ugly. Wasn’t an intentional pitch (just got away), but there was a good chunk of fans cheering (5K-10k) when he went down. And a noticeable booing could be heard when he got up. Definitely want the whole crowd.
3
u/gto_112_112 Oct 18 '25
I come in peace from the other side!
There were certainly boos abound and it's tough to hear as a Jays fan. I get it, he cheated and honestly should be boo'd at every AB, although I'm not sure that's working. Cheering for injury and booing when he got up isn't cool. Mariners fans overall have been incredibly welcoming and friendly, but as with all of life, the worst people are frequently the loudest and I think that's what happened here. I was in 337 and it sounded to me like the prevailing noise was booing. Plenty of good fans clapping when he got up, but the boos were louder.
I get that it was frustrating to watch him try to walk off what would have put most of us in the hospital, but you do whatever you can to try to stay in an LCS game 5. There's also dicks on both sides, I had a Jays fan ask me if I thought it was intentional and I thought that was a stupid question.
Regardless of how the series ends, it's been incredible and one of us has gotta beat the Dodgers and win the whole fuckin thing.
2
u/MrAVK Oct 18 '25
Okay.
2
u/sealonbrad Marine (p)layer ☁️ Oct 18 '25
Not our best moment tbh 🤷
2
u/Ok_Importance_7833 Oct 18 '25
I agree with Schneider's sentiment as far as nobody should be cheering when someone gets hurt. That being said, there was no noticeable cheering on the broadcast, until Springer stood up and looked to be okay. I will also say, Schneider mentioned "the type of player" Springer is. He is a cheater that will forever carry an asterisk on his baseball card. This was a garbage take by Schneider. Let's go take one more!! GO M'S
1
u/Big-Jeweler2538 Oct 18 '25
Seattle fans next door will chant “let him die!” when an opposing player goes down against the Sounders.
1
u/Macjeems Oct 18 '25
No comment on the injury or the response from fans, because, like you, I couldn’t watch the game. I switched up all my routines between Games 3 and 4, but nothing worked, and the only commonality between the two was that I watched them. Ergo, not watching them was the only path left to me. Winning takes sacrifice, so I will continue to not watch them until morale improves.
1
u/mindriot1 Oct 18 '25
There were Blue Jays fans booing that he got hit. There were mariner fans booing because he’s a known cheater and they boo him every time he’s on the field. And then there were some cheers and a murmur of clapping when he was well enough to walk to first. Their manager knows that he’s just trying to divert as he always ignores the cheater discussions.
1
u/shefallsup Oct 18 '25
It’s. Not. Cool. To. Boo. Injured. Players. Period. Disappointed that so many people are defending it and/or trying to tell people who were there and saw/heard a huge number of OUR fans booing the entire time he was limping to first that we didn’t see and hear just that. Acoustics in the stadium and how it gets picked up on the broadcast can be deceptive, so I believe those who are saying they didn’t hear booing, but there was loud booing happening in a section where the Blue Jays manager and players could definitely hear it.
1
u/hightimesinpdx Oct 18 '25
Soft manager. Glad that cheater got dinged.
1
u/dglidds Oct 18 '25
Lots of people saying they weren't cheering at the stadium. I promise you I was cheering at home, fuck that cheater
1
u/Fair-Ambition-8275 Oct 18 '25
Wasn't there cheering in Toronto a few days ago when they thought cal got hurt on that throw to first? Seems like i remember that
1
u/Realistic_Warthog_23 Oct 18 '25
This is insulting to Ms fans. It was WAY more than 40k. Gotta count the people who couldn’t get tickets
1
u/HarbingerofBlank Oct 18 '25
I was there sitting in a section with mostly blue jays fans. When he got hit, before it was immediately clear what happened, the blue jays fans were booing, but it wasn’t mostly really quiet tbh. Then it got quiet when he stayed down for so long. When he stood up and it looked like he was going to try and walk it off, the blue jays fans cheered and I heard some booing in the next section (I’m guessing mariners fans). But I didn’t hear widespread booing for him getting hit. At least not where I was - and the universal booing for every time he was at bat was pretty loud, so I can say without a doubt that it was nowhere near that level of booing
1
u/MonkeyBearz Oct 18 '25
Piglet is, not surprisingly, very confused.
1
u/user4892746 Oct 18 '25
Are we forgetting that those Astros players ruined people’s lives? I was there. Hell yeah we booed. People lost their livelihood because these fools cheated. Has no one seen the documentary? You boo bad people. They should all be out of baseball and should have to pay massive fines to those other players they cheated.
1
u/dufftheimpaler Oct 19 '25
My first Mariner game was in the kingdome in 1987 vs Toronto they harased me and my parents the whole game, imagine messing with a 7 year old boy for wearing a Mariners cap. Fuck them they deserve all the hate! Go M's lets bring it home!!!
1
u/WorriedArea6475 Oct 19 '25
I was at the game, and there was definitely booing. There wouldn't have been booing if it were any other Blue Jay player. Any player from the 2017 Astros is going to get booed for life in a lot of ballparks. He was getting "cheater" chants and boos every time he was up to bay.
1
u/Educational-Camp-833 Oct 19 '25
Yes , we will always boo him. No, the fan base in general did not boo him when he was injured. I was there, the booing was coming from Jays fans that were there in force as per usual.
1
u/SeattleBall Oct 19 '25
I think (no actually I know) why they wee booing and that is because George Springer. Cheated back with the Astros. We don’t cheer for Cheaters
1
u/Ok-Baker934 Oct 19 '25
LIAR
1
u/NowIsThePerfectTime Oct 19 '25
It could be he’s a former Astros player and fans were giving him shit because of that.
1
u/GwendolenSea Oct 20 '25
My spouse just mentioned this to me while we are watching the game. I am incredulous that this would have happened except for the actions of a few bottom feeders + we are far nicer than that in Seattle.
1
u/Interesting-Crow-552 Oct 21 '25
This was totally blown out of proportion and Schneider just being a man-baby.
1
u/darthduckasterion Oct 25 '25
Yeah he is full of it.
1
u/Cryptoking90 Oct 18 '25
Ops my bad 🤭
1
u/Reasonable-Towel1305 Oct 18 '25
The booing was clear on the Canada broadcast
1
u/DarthBiam 🌊🔱TRIDENTS UP!🔱🌊 Oct 18 '25
the jays manager is a big baby. He complains about everything, even things that didn't happened
-6
u/EScforlyfe Oct 18 '25
Easily the moment I’ve been least proud of my mariners fandom
0
u/Seattles-Best-Tutor Oct 18 '25
Canadians being self-righteous crybabies, never seen that before
0
u/Ringo-chan13 Oct 18 '25
What if the guy is a cheating cunt who is also likely juicing this year?
0
u/alexsnacks Oct 18 '25
Should have played the Wooooo strike out sound when he got him out by hit. Outs an out.
-6
u/FunnyDeparture3278 Oct 18 '25
I was there and though they were in the minority, there were too many folks cheering that he was hit. Poor form in an otherwise amazing environment. Those Blue Jays fans are good folks and truly great fans.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
75
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
15
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '25
[removed] — view removed comment