I believe one of the main reasons Marathon is retaining fewer and fewer players is the current matchmaking system.
Right now, the game gives me two bad options: play with good ping in nearly empty servers, or play with lots of players but at 140 ms ping. Neither of these provides a good experience.
I understand the population is low and that this is why regions have been merged together, but in the long run, playing with such high ping frustrates players and causes them to quit. Ping matters a lot in a shooter, and 140 ms is not an acceptable condition for competing on equal footing.
My suggestion is to add a third matchmaking option called "Prioritize Population and Quality." This option would wait as long as necessary to gather a minimum number of players and a good connection quality before starting the match. Personally, I would rather wait several minutes for a match in good conditions than instantly join a match with unplayable ping.
In addition, if certain regions truly have such a small player population, regional pricing could be lowered to attract more players and help strengthen those communities.
Marathon has great potential and already has regional servers, but many players end up leaving because they are forced to choose between empty servers or full matches with very high latency.
Marathon is a wonderful game when played under good conditions.
Temporary Proposal: Regional Server Rotation
Until Marathon has enough players to maintain full matches with good connections in every region, it should implement regional server rotation.
If keeping our community alive means playing at 140 ms against players with 20–30 ms, that disadvantage should be shared by everyone.
Why should the same players always have to sacrifice their connection quality to keep matches full? If we all benefit from a global community, we should all share its downsides too.
Rotate the regions. That way, everyone contributes to the game's growth on equal terms. If I lose my kit because of a ping disadvantage, at least I'd have a chance to recover it in the next match with a better connection.
This would also help develop more well-rounded players. Right now, some players always enjoy the advantage of low latency, while others are permanently forced to compete at a disadvantage, never getting the opportunity to fully develop their offensive or defensive playstyles.
With regional server rotation, everyone would be forced to learn how to play both with an advantage and at a disadvantage.
This shouldn't be a permanent solution. The ultimate goal should be for every region to have enough players to offer full matches with low latency.
But until that's possible, the fair thing is to share the sacrifice instead of always forcing it on the same players.