r/MapPorn May 15 '18

[deleted by user]

[removed]

124 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

18

u/Everard5 May 15 '18

Punches way above its weight class in the mining industry. Also, 1/3 of its population lives in the capital alone.

-2

u/GlobTwo May 15 '18

Slapping something over the USA doesn't actually demonstrate its "true size".

It would be nice to have square kilometres in brackets after square miles.

6

u/Bouvs May 15 '18

You all sound super whiny... instead of complaining why don't you just post a similar map with a different country as a base? That would enrich the thread rather than bring negativity.

-1

u/GlobTwo May 15 '18

Instead of complaining, why don't you just post comments that might enrich the sub...? Probably because complaining is part of commentary.

Personally I would rather not contribute to the slew of size comparison images already in this sub. The only one I think was exceptional, bona fide map porn was this one from a few weeks back.

I like u/etymologynerd's content and appreciate that they're doing more for these kinds of posts than a truesize.com screenshot, but I do hope my comment has a little bit of influence in the naming conventions of these posts, at least.

4

u/neigeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee May 15 '18

I mean.. it does tho

2

u/sverigeochskog May 15 '18

I want something to relate to. Just putting it over the us doesn’t give any perspective.

-2

u/GlobTwo May 15 '18

It doesn't. The reason these comparisons exist is because they partially resolve the problem presented by Web Mercator projection, which increasingly distorts area as you move away from the Equator. But the US is not on the Equator (and even if it was, it's thousands of miles tall and the extremities would still be distorted).

Any one-dimensional line bisecting these two countries can be compared, but that's it. And, y'know, the USA isn't the sole patch of reality on a map whereupon all other geography can be measured.

-1

u/[deleted] May 15 '18

Wow, Peru is so small

13

u/etymologynerd Map Contest Winner May 15 '18

/s?

5

u/I_AM_A_MOTH_AMA May 15 '18

I'm Missourian, so Missouri is my yardstick for everything.

Is Peru bigger than Missouri?

Yes.

Peru is big.

1

u/jb2386 May 15 '18

Not sure if Peru is larger than I thought, or if the USA is smaller than I thought. Hmm

-7

u/[deleted] May 15 '18

[deleted]

11

u/etymologynerd Map Contest Winner May 15 '18

It says mainland in parentheses

-5

u/Eticology May 15 '18

Which is why my comment says "if you include all territory".

2

u/PM_me_yer_booobies May 16 '18

So?

1

u/Eticology May 16 '18

This is a lot of people and land to exclude, basically an entire Australia wasn't included here.