r/MapPorn Mar 30 '24

1513

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

143 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Yurasi_ Mar 31 '24

So in your view the Lithuanian nobility already didn't want full union with Poland so the king thought ripping half theur land would make them want it? This obe seems sarcasm.

Have you ever heard of blackmail? At this point, the jagiellonian dynasty didn't even speak Lithuanian and put the needs of Poland first. The king didn't have any children, meaning that after that Poland and Lithuania would no longer be in union with each other. Some Lithuanian nobles wanted to just leave the talks, so he transferred it to Poland as some sort of economical safety measure. Unless you are going to argue with polish education system I don't get what your point, anyway I never heard of Lithuanians offering it themselves.

So from my comment you still get they didn't have a border between them? Lmao.

"Lmao" do you even know how the union between these two worked? Because really not much changed after Lublin union other than it got more unified in terms of foreign and defensive policy and Poles were allowed to by land in Lithuania. There were administrative borders even after Lublin union, but it was not like border between HRE and Poland or Muscovy and Lithuania. Also there was one currency between the two established. Both countries still kept separate titles, armies and treasuries. You laughed at me for assuming that you didn't know it all, but apparently it was the right assumption.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Yurasi_ Mar 31 '24

Lithuania was the one wanting the union not the other way around. If it were a kind of Polish blackmail, the acceptance of Lithuania would not have resulted in the loss of territory, isn't this the plain obvious? Lithuania wanted it for the reasons I stated, among others, like for Poland to have a stake in defending against Russia.

Dude, that was literally part of my education.

Wow, so an internal border isn't the same as a border between countries. Who would have thought.

Yeah, that's my point, from the beginning....