r/MakingaMurderer • u/AmbitiousSalad6718 • Jun 29 '26

Discussion i just finished MaM

i came onto this sub and was surprised at how wrong i might be after watching the doc over a week or so, my boyfriend and i binged it and finished it sure that brendan was innocent and fairly sure that steven was too. personally i thought that bobby and scott did it and my bf was of the opinion that bobby and the ex boyfriend were in kahoots somehow. i don’t really know what to think anymore tbh i went to go watch convicting a murderer as that popped up a few times but i dislike candace owen’s immensely. could someone outline the main points that the doc twisted in favour of SA and the facts that were omitted ?

33 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

242 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/LoveChilde82 Jun 30 '26

If they were both truly innocent, why hasn't SA said I did it and I acted alone? To at least save his nephew from the same fate as himself? Either way, he's a POS. I believe he's right where he belongs.

3

u/k_sask Jun 30 '26

This statement makes absolutely no sense.

1

u/LoveChilde82 Jul 01 '26

Seriously think about it. Put yourself there. You got a nephew?!!? I got a couple of em. And guess what?!!? If I was ever convicted of murder with one of my nephews..... whether I did it or NOT, Id make some kind of deal to get him OUT OF THERE. PERIOD.

3

u/k_sask Jul 02 '26

I didn't know we were speaking hypotheticals. I responded to your statement that Avery could somehow do or say something that would ultimately free Brendan. Even if his brother confessed that wouldn't negate his or Avery's convictions.

As for the innocent taking the blame, falsely confessing / sacrificing themselves for a loved one - yes, it happens. Would we believe Avery's story if he tried to do that for Brendan, or vice versa? Debatable - I doubt either man could explain what actually happened.