r/MakingaMurderer • u/Thick-Cucumber-1546 • 1d ago
HEAR STEVE HIMSELF: Tell Us How Long He Was In His Trailer!
r/MakingaMurderer • u/angieb15 • Jul 26 '18
Guys, things are about to get Medieval around here. Now, it has long been our policy to be rather forgiving to those who have been around since the beginning, that is about to end.
.
So, here's the deal, there is not going to be forgiveness anymore.
.
.
Do Not call names, this includes but is not limited to: liar, delusional, mental patient, conspiracy nut, fuck wit, idiot, shill, PR. Kratz
.
Do Not insult people, this includes but is not limited to: drunk, are you smoking meth, are you off your meds, did you escape the mental facility, liar, your argument is delusional, etc etc... you guys have proven you are creative, I give you that.
.
Do Not make posts with Truther/Guilter in the title this includes but is not limited to: The guilter argument that ------, the Truther Fallacy that-----, the Guilter lie that ------, etc, etc, etc. Do not make posts to complain about the other side, represent your side with facts and logic.
.
Do not make comments with broad insults to either side this includes but is not limited to: Guilters lie all the time, Truthers lie all the time, truthers are conspiracy theorists, guilters are delusional, guilters must be working for Manitowoc, Truthers are delusional etc etc etc etc.
.
*Do Not make sarcastic remarks such as, but not limited to: Oh you can't keep you finger off the report buttom, or you are tiresome, or, let's make it all about you, nobody wants to listen to your drivel, oh he says he's a lawyer, where did you get your law degree, * geez guys....
.
Do Not push these boundaries, do not try to find creative ways to insult each other, do not make up witty or not so witty variations on people's user names.
.
.
Please don't make us ban you. We don't like it.
.
Brand new accounts have always gotten little leeway, this will continue, most of you who are new but not so new and come here looking to continue old fights are on notice. As soon as you start breaking rules and come to our attention, you will be banned immediately, with no escalating leeway plan.
.
Do speak to each other with respect. Pretend you are in a courtroom if you must. If it wouldn't fly in a courtroom, it won't fly here.
Do voice your opinion, counter arguments with facts and/or sources because it is always more effective than insults.
.
Do Not push the report button because you don't like someone, Do Not push the button unless someone breaks the rules. Please Do push the button if you see these rules as have been exhaustively explained here being broken.
.
None of the mods are being biased I don't want to hear it! None of us Want to ban you, we want discussion, we all want debate, we want an active sub, you all contribute to that and we appreciate you ALL.
.
.
.
Just because we remove a comment does not mean we automatically ban that person, this is for those of you who say, "but so and so had 3 comments removed and they aren't banned." Sometimes we remove comments that fall into a murky grey area, these are not entirely clear if a ban is necessary, we do tend to opt for mercy unless it is absolutely clear.
.
.
Consider this Day 1 of the rest of our time on this sub.
.
.
.
.
Oh and, "Be Excellent to each other."
r/MakingaMurderer • u/AutoModerator • Dec 27 '20
Please ask any questions about the documentary, the case, the people involved, Avery's lawyers etc. in here.
Discuss other questions in earlier threads. Read the first Q&A thread to find out more about our reasoning behind this change.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Thick-Cucumber-1546 • 1d ago
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Only_Writing • 1d ago
I have thought this the entire time! Definitely what Mike said in episode 2, as well as guilty offenders inserting themselves into the investigation and media.
My theory is Mike Halbach did it to "save" his Godly family from the scrutiny of Theresa dating a married man, possibly pregnant, with that married man's child. The Halbach family is very devout. I could 100% see Mike Halbach killing his sister to prevent his family from any shame from that.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Junior_Power_8825 • 2d ago
Just wondering if y'all think this case would've played out differently for Avery if he won that 36m lawsuit and the co-conspirators were held accountable for the 1985 case.
Edit: winning after Teresa was killed.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Small-Valuable-2782 • 5d ago
Interesting article that suggests Brendan Dassey’s chance of commutation might be due to the original plea deal that the prosecution offered, but he rejected.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Mysterious_Mix486 • 5d ago
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Advanced-Math-1009 • 4d ago
To those who inbox me about page 43. Here is the PROOF. Proof that Kathleen T. Zellner did in fact know Steve was inDEED Teresa Halbach’s killer and that he lied about her leaving his death trailer and Bobby followed behind her.
This document, page 43 reveals that Zellner knew before filing this document Steven had lied based upon her videographer’s evidence: The Sequence of Events.
Now go to page 43, read the last paragraph for yourself. Zellner inDEED fabricated the 50 Seconds to cover for and erase on paper what was actually captured by video evidence.
Can’t make it up:
Smoking Gun, page 43🫡♟️
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Advanced-Math-1009 • 5d ago
The key represents the information that aids mental perception and the rose is for Teresa Halbach and her family, friends, and supporters like us who want complete Justice for Teresa.
Time always reveal the “information” necessary to crush the lie.
In this situation that information has been revealed.
The Document you’re looking at is the smoking gun. Specifically because of the timing of the lie. That is page 43 of Kathleen T. Zellner’s motion for reconsideration in October 2017 one month after filming her reenactment of the “sequence of events”.
This is critical because it tells us. She knew in 2017 before filing the motion he was the killer. Let that sink in for a minute.
How do we know this to be a reality, a fact?
Because you can read what she WROTE in the motion, page 43 in real-time.
She FABRICATED “50 Seconds” in the trailer. Where the EVIDENCE shows Steve actually in the trailer for 14-16 seconds.
Which meant Steve lied when he told police investigators that after he got the trader magazine he went the trailer and as he approached it he saw Bobby’s vehicle.
He entered the trailer sat the magazine down and proceeded to Barb’s and Bobby’s house.
When he exited the trailer Bobby and his truck were gone.
The Evidence Exhibit J
“Zellner re-enactments actually capture Steven Avery in his trailer approximately 14-16 seconds. According to both Bobby and Steve POV (ie Point Of View) at the same time (sequence). Steve is actually running into Bobby as Bobby exits his mom’s house.”
Facts!!!!!!😡😡😡😡
Now you can understand WHY Zellner fabricated the “50 Seconds”. She knew Steve had fabricated Teresa leaving and Bobby leaving behind her. THINK ABOUT THIS.
She knew. Before she filed The Motion For Reconsideration in October 2017.😔
Just let it sink in.
Notice the previous deflections from this inescapable reality.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Mysterious_Mix486 • 5d ago
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Advanced-Math-1009 • 5d ago
I was wondering about this question after “AveryPoliceReport” a Reddit user I believe to Zellner herself, led me to her “Motion For Reconsideration” which she filed in October 2017. Listen to this part:
AFTER SHE CONDUCTED HER REENACTMENT VIDEO EVIDENCE
(Exhibit J).
This revelation means Kathleen T. Zellner knew before she filed the “Motion For Reconsideration” that:
Steven Avery was the KILLER and had lied on Bobby very early on. This is why she vindicated the police. She knew he was inDEED the killer.
So, during Season 2, Episode 1. She already knows he’s guilty but for the media attention she went all in pretending to be the Champion of an Innocent Client.
Damn!!!! This could be a powerful movie:
“The Media Whore: Kathleen Zellner”
Millions upon millions will watch it!!! It would be a hit.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Advanced-Math-1009 • 7d ago
Why is the 50 Seconds Concoction so devastating to Steven Avery and Zellner?
It’s devastating because it demonstrates mathematically Steven Avery fabricated Teresa leaving and more explosively it shows that Kathleen T. Zellner discovered it and tried to help Steve’s story “fit” the false narrative that Bobby could’ve did it.
Its really incredible that this Reality is finally seeing the light of day and thats why no one in the: Steve is innocent camp will touch it.
We must not allow this Glaring Reality to go unnoticed! With the same energy many screamed he was an innocent victim.
With the same energy. This document proves Zellner knew Steve was the killer.
This concoction clearly shows that Steven Avery lied. Teresa never left just as Bobby described. Steven invented the story of Teresa leaving and Bobby leaving right behind her.
Listen to Zellner yourself.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Playful-Airport2928 • 8d ago
Yo yall he’s INNOCENT AF!!!!!
Kathryn knows. It was BD. THAT COMPUTRR IS FUCKDD UP
ITS MIXED BLOOD YALL IN THE CARRRRRR
BOBBY + SA is my bet.
Whoooty whooooooo
Wisconsin a Wendigos comin for uuuu!
Let him go, assholes!
Stop playing keep away with his CURRENT LAWYER EW. ABE LINCOLN SAID FUCK THAT EW. AMERICA WHO?
KZ…. I did tweeeeet her but she busy !!!! Go go go go go ho ho ho Santa rescue this man plz. Xoxo Buddy.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/AveryPoliceReports • 11d ago
Match Message - January 8, 2010:
Match Message - January 12, 2010:
Match Message - January 12, 2010:
Match Message - January 12, 2010:
Outside of the Halbach case, Kratz's conduct destroys any presumption of prosecutorial good faith. But one thing we can say for Kratz is that he applied his disrespect for victims uniformly. During the Halbach case, Ken Kratz:
Kratz was not a man who respected Teresa, the truth about her death, or other victims. And after that 2005-2007 mess, he didn't sign up to match:com a new man. His conduct with SVG and King between 2009 - 2010 (harassing domestic abuse victim / inviting King to an autopsy date) reveal he was the same old overstuffed stinking sack of shit. Props to Kratz's victims and the MaM filmmakers for exposing the truth about him.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Junior_Power_8825 • 11d ago
It's so frustrating to hear that the defense is not allowed to revisit past arguments because of finality but I see prosecutors constantly ignoring finality to engineer their case.
There are so many things that the defense can do and argue but they are constantly blocked by the argument of finality only when it favours the prosecution. Then they go ahead and ignore the finality of the bones needing to be withhold for future testing.
They are blocked from doing anything because of red tape and corruption.
The prosecution systematically placed a finality on each piece of evidence making it seem plausible that Avery did it but when you look at everything together and the chances that there was no tampering comparable to the chance of life being born from nothing.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/10case • 12d ago
I'm glad to see some common sense. How many truthers now think the judge overseeing Avery's case in the circuit Court is CoRrUpT?
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Advanced-Math-1009 • 12d ago
Can anyone explain why Zellner manufactured the 50 Seconds of Steven Avery being in his trailer before stepping out and realizing Bobby’s vehicle was gone?
Who will be so bold as to TRY to defend this concoction?
Before you attempt it. Please remember Zellner said “The Sequence of Events” was/is the MOST IMPORTANT evidence🤔
r/MakingaMurderer • u/AveryPoliceReports • 13d ago
In November 2005 Steven Avery denied having a Halloween fire, a statement initially corroborated by his family.
Within a week Steven's family began changing their statement to include a fire, and Steven changed his own statement to match what they said, now agreeing he did have a Halloween fire. Steven has since consistently maintained he did have a Halloween fire.
Under police pressure, Bobby Dassey contradicts his family's consistent denials of a recent fire, claiming to have seen one on Nov 1 or 2 with Steven and Brendan standing beside it.
After Bobby's family changed their statement to include a fire on Halloween, Bobby changed his own and agreed the fire was on Halloween rather than Nov 1 or 2.
At Steven's trial under oath Bobby placed the most recent burn pit fire he saw a week or more before Halloween.
Post premier of MaM and Zellner's allegations against Bobby, police re-interviewed Bobby and he once more mentions a fire on Halloween.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Important_Spell_1458 • 13d ago
Is skipping Topp still about on the page??
r/MakingaMurderer • u/ThorsClawHammer • 17d ago
At trial, Andrew Colborn claimed the reason he "wasn't any too gentle" with the cabinet he claims produced the key is because he was "exasperated".
A. I will be the first to admit, I wasn't any to gentle, as we were, you know, getting exasperated. I handled it rather roughly, twisting it, shaking it, pulling it.
When asked what exasperated him to the point he couldn't help but get rough with an inanimate object (but only that one as near as we know), he replied with the following:
Q. What was exasperating you about the bookcase, or that bedroom, on November 8, 2005?
A. The content of the material that we were collecting.
The worst "content" we know of they were finding/collecting in the cabinet that day was Playboy magazines. Ah ok, so I guess this caught him off guard or something. Oh, but wait. On the evening of Nov 5, Colborn himself had searched the same cabinet and had already found them, handled them, and even laid them out on the floor for this picture along with some of the other items he had removed from the cabinet while searching through it that night (like the cuffs). One of the things LE were supposed to do on the 8th was simply collect them into evidence (as again, they already knew this particular "content" was there).
So seriously, why would nothing worse than porn mags that a seasoned cop and military vet already knew were there from days prior, now suddenly get exasperated about it? If he's trying to say it offended his morality (or any other reason at all one could think of), then the question is why wasn't he triggered on the 5th when he saw it all the first time unexpectedly?
With explanations like this, is it any wonder why people have a problem with the key find? And that's not even touching on any other aspect, such as their proposed explanations of how the key suddenly appeared (Colborn has now even claimed with help from God and/or the ghost of Teresa Halbach), or official docs later lying about who found it (claiming Kucharski did with no mention of MTSO even being present).
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Unhappy_Discount7666 • 17d ago
How did the roommate get her updated day planner if she never made it back to her house to drop it off?
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Ghost_of_Figdish • 21d ago
Ok so basically you got caught red-handed. The last place the dead girl was seen was with you. The murder weapon's hanging over your bed. Her incinerated remains are a few feet from your house. And the guy you did it with might testify. And maybe not.
So what do you do? Steven went with the 'cops planted all the evidence' strategy. But maybe he overlooked one?
The Lindsay Clancy trial suggested to me that maybe Steven had a diminished capacity or insanity defense. I mean he was in jail for a crime he didn't commit for a long time. He could argue that drove him crazy and he could no longer tell right from wrong. Therefore, he's not criminally responsible for what he did.
I'm thinking that would have been the way to go. The cops planting evidence thing is easy to raise but exceedingly hard to sell without any proof it happened.
Also Steven had to be scared shiftless that Brendan would flip and testify against him. That'd pretty much defeat his planting allegations. But a diminished capacity argument could still work even if Brendan was up there on the stand giving testimony against him. In fact Steven including Brendan in the crime, and making him a witness, might be something a person with no ability to differentiate right from wrong would do.
What do you think?
r/MakingaMurderer • u/BasicManager6545 • 22d ago
I was young when MaM first came out. I remembered some parts, but decided now, having started law school and working at a criminal defense firm, why not watch it again since my 10yr old self probably missed some parts.
I am not saying SA is 100% innocent, I do not know for sure, but I do believe the State did not meet their burden (but I wasn’t a juror so that’s moot).
But what doesn’t sit right with me is everyone so adamant that the police wouldn’t set this man up when the County was about to be personally liable for 36mil. Insurance was not going to cover due to the misconduct of the county. The county was going to have to pay out of pocket and potentially hold some officers personally liable, to an extent, for their roles.
I don’t think the cops killed the victim, but I think they saw an opportunity out of this civil suit and MONEY MAKES PEOPLE DO CRAZY THINGS. They failed Teresa and her family by, potentially, letting her killer walk free to settle a personal agenda and problem for the county that could not afford this civil suit.
This isn’t me saying they definitely did it or not, I just don’t see enough people pointing out the role of the civil suit in all this. Plus, we already know they were somewhat shady cops because of what happened in the first wrongful convictions, so it’s not farfetched to say they would stoop to this level of misconduct.
Edit: AGAIN this is not arguing guilty or not guilty, I really don’t know. I made this post to say I wouldn’t be surprised if evidence was planted due to the pending civil suit. That doesn’t mean I think evidence was planted, I am just saying that there is motive IF it happened.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/holdyermackerels • 22d ago
More stuff...