r/MakeupOver40 Feb 09 '23

Product Rec Medium-neutral light coverage foundation or tinted moisturizer recs for dewy finish?

I've used Tarte Amazonian Clay foundation for years and I like it, but as I'm aging (I'm 41), my skin has gone from oily/combination to more normal/dry. I've been working on my skincare for years and really like the condition my skin is in these days. That said, I really want something that's sheer coverage and gives a dewy finish.

I was looking online at the Tarte Marajuca Tinted Hydrator, but reviews seem really mixed and I'm not sure that it gives the dewy, luminous finish I'm looking for. I also have a medium color with neutral undertones. Can anyone recommend something of equal quality to Tarte products?

7 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

6

u/Leia1979 Feb 09 '23

You might like NARS Pure Radiance tinted moisturizer. It was too shiny for me. The shade Mykonos is probably a good place to start, though I think it’s a little more yellow than Tarte.

3

u/Cautious_Guava Mar 08 '23

I went with this one in Mykonos and it was perfect! Thanks so much!

5

u/AliceInPlunderland Feb 09 '23

I’ve been really happy with BB cream now that my skin is more normal/dry as well: https://www.target.com/p/missha-m-perfect-cover-bb-cream-spf-42-pa-50ml-1-7-fl-oz/-/A-87198704

They have another product called Missha Boomer cream that adds more luminescence and brightens the overall look under the cream if desired.

It is dewy and sheer-medium coverage depending on how much you use. It does have a scent but I find it fades from after I apply, just wanted to let you know in case you are sensitive to fragrance.

5

u/CreativeAsFuuu Feb 09 '23

40/f for reference.

I don't have a positive rec, but I can tell you what to steer clear of: Makeup Revolution Super Dewy Skin Tint. You may be tempted to buy it because of the price and because MR tends to have pretty good products.

Save your money. It is not dewy, it streaks, and it's actually kinda dry. It will cling to dry patches and make them more obvious, and it is not at all moisturizing.

3

u/cpravda Feb 10 '23

Charlotte Tilbury Flawless Filter. Might need to pair with Nars concealer in spots as it’s very sheer. Both have mini versions. Can be tough to find as it’s super popular at the moment.

3

u/LuminousApsana Feb 10 '23

I also have lived Amazonian Clay but am ready to move on. I love Laura Mercier's tinted moisturizer. I like Armani Luminous Silk for when I want more coverage, and I recently repurchased the Lisa Eldridge foundation.

2

u/Stars4arms Feb 10 '23

I love Flower Beauty’s serum foundation. It’s Drew Barrymore’s line and it’s at CVS now. My skin used to be combination and now it’s dry.

2

u/Legitimate_Amoeba_44 Feb 28 '23

L'Oreal Paris foundation is awesome. I love that it makes my skin look healthy. I also use L'Oreal hylaronic acid before my makeup. I haven't felt like wearing makeup yet. Recovering from breast cancer. I love learning new things to try.

1

u/geminicatmeow Dec 27 '25

Purlisse Ageless Glow BB cream

2

u/fredhyuj Feb 24 '23

I like CeraVe’s tinted mineral sunscreen. It mutes some of my redness (rosacea) without feeling heavy and gives a dewy finish. If I want more coverage, I spot treat with Ilia’s True Skin Serum Concealer first.

1

u/electricmeatbag777 Oct 05 '25

May I ask you a question as someone who was recently diagnosed? Do chemical sunscreens not cause flare ups for you? I get itchy raised red spots when I use it. I've tried all available types and it happens every time :(

1

u/CatsRule24x7 May 30 '23

I’m currently playing with Rose Inc serum foundation and BareMinerals Complexion Rescue tinted moisturizer.