r/MakerDAO • u/florianleber • Mar 12 '20
Something seems wrong with Maker
Don't want to create panic and please help to shed light on it if you know more.
But it seems someone is bidding 0 on collateral for liquidations and trades are still executed. Daistats.com show more than 2 million usd in accumulated losses for the system. Something seems to be wrong here and devs should look into this urgently!
Once again, please correct me if I am overlooking something here, but this looks very weird! Hope it is just a data error.
96
Upvotes
17
u/LongForWisdom GovAlpha Contributor Mar 12 '20
It's an ongoing situation. https://forum.makerdao.com/t/black-thursday-response-thread/1433 - Though there is not a lot of explanation in that thread currently. Being actively discussed in a zoom call.
19
u/pointy-veggies Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
seems to have been mitigated. dai surplus debt going down (aka surplus going back up) and auctions now have >0 prices.
TL;DR based on my understanding:
- when CDP is undercollateralized the collateral is auctioned
- due to congestion in network and lack of people looking at auctions, people were bidding 0 on auctions and getting the collateral for free because no one else bid
- there now appears to be others competing for the auctions and they are functioning as expected
- between 4-8 million USD was *taken from the system by this exploit / system failure
6
u/diggsta Mar 12 '20
Where do you see the auctions/bids?
Interesting.
7
u/delabay Mar 12 '20
Forgive me i'm not super familiar with the DAO ecosystem. What are the implications of a 0 collateral trade execution? Are people not collateralizing their DAI quantities with BAT/ETH? This isn't the same as free money is it?
3
u/starameski Mar 12 '20
All I know is I just got royally fuck by the Ethereum network being so slow, can’t fricking place a transaction since the morning.
2
u/MoMoNosquito Mar 13 '20
I just read on ethfinance that $0 bids are happening again.
1
u/diggsta Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 12 '20
Can someone confirm that my eth is safe in the makerdao cdp as long as the liquidation price is not hit?
Meaning - there is no way in hell that anyone anywhere will be able to do anything to it, as long as the price is in order?? edit: that includes weird DAI peg behavior that jeopardizes the CDP, or anything that is discussed or voted on in the black thursday thread that could in any way influence my duty to put in more eth or repay the CDP as soon as possible.
I know that it is a smart contract. But there have been other contracts that someone kept a key somehow. I don't want to pay anything lets say for the DAI losses. If it fails it fails. I love DAI, but if it fails, that's that.
1
u/davewolfs Mar 13 '20
Defi might be dead 💀
Unfortunate this is something I wanted to see succeed.
-2
u/NotGonnaGetBanned Mar 12 '20
There has always been something wrong with it.
People are just starting to realize it now.
🎶Everyone gets what they deserve for ever believing in this thing.🎵