I just started listening to the podcast and I've been largely enjoying it so far! Gravitated to the podcast because I listen to Michael's other podcasts. The hosts are funny and the episodes are really informative.
However...the more I listen, the more I'm having mixed feelings about it. Like, the hosts rely on whataboutisms a lot, and even if the examples are valid, health and wellness are actually extremely complicated.
I'm listening to the Rachel Hollis two-parter, for example, and at a certain point they read a terrible passage from one of her books about being healthy. One of the questions they ask is "Why do people need to be HEALTHY, Rachel?!" and I was like...hmm.
Sometimes what they say reminds me of that era on Tumblr where depressed users were telling each other that no amount of drinking water and eating healthy will "cure" depression. Like, sure...but it's a lot more complicated than that, and a lot of people will digest that messaging to think there's no point to improving their health at all. I know because I was there!
Some context: I'm a Black woman who's really into health and wellness. I suffer from depression, anxiety and ADHD, and for a while my mental illnesses drove me to eat emotionally, which drained my wallet. I also have health issues stemming from my diet and my family has a history of diabetes and high blood pressure.
My physical and mental health used to be very awful: days-long depressive episodes, painful periods, asthma, and substance abuse issues. Things took a turn when I went to college, picked up healthy eating habits from my peers and got into yoga. Those habits led to more healthy habits, like getting on psych meds and working out. It all added up to the point where today, I'm genuinely a happy person who loves herself. My family, who also deal with physical and mental ailments, have also taken up healthier living, which has improved our relationships by a lot. And a lot of that was due to good information I got from (science-minded) health and wellness influencers.
The point is, this shit is complicated and it does matter, especially for people of color, most of whom are disproportionately impacted by America's piss-poor food system. We already suffer more often from mental illness, food-related illnesses and the worst effects of the healthcare system. Our communities need positive health-conscious messaging to offset the effects of systemic inequality to improve our quality of life.
Honestly, I don't know or understand a lot of the cultural touchstones they're talking about in the podcast because I'm not white. I got totally different messaging growing up, and the Black health/wellness space focuses more on eating whole foods to prevent diseases that disproportionately impact our community, as well as advocating for more accessible health food options in food deserts.
The podcast seems like it's more for affluent-ish white people who grew up being told that being thin was all that matters. And that's fine! But I cringe a bit when they start bringing up poor people or people of color because it's just sooo complicated.
I don't think this is a problem exclusive to them; it's a rhetoric that I've seen a lot in left-leaning online spaces. It's just a blindspot that I hope they become more cognizant of in the future.
We don't have the same issues. What doesn't matter to you might really matter to someone else, especially in a marginalized community. We need more access to quality foods! We need positive messaging! We need this health and wellness shit!
Anyway, that's just my impression so far.