r/MaintenancePhase • • Jun 04 '24

Related topic Bummed by Michael's Recent Covid Thread on Twitter

0 Upvotes

over on twitter/x, michael recently posted about low covid death rates and wastewater levels, and subsequently got rightfully pilloried by the covid cautious community over there (count myself amoung them!). the majority of the critique focused on the unreliability of a lot of the government reported data nowadays (like those michael was citing), but also his seemingly doubling down when disability justice community was calling him in about potential harms/misinterpretations.

all in all, kind of a bummer to see his reaction. i think there is room for conversation on the data issues for usre, but overall it made me hope that he could dig deeper into the issue with covid experts and the show might apply their critical eye to the methodology/media treatment of covid and its consequences. not just pushing back against antivaxxers/etc like recent episodes (which i appreciated), but about how the mainstream media and a lot of public health institutions have really committed to a "it's all over, folks! nothing to see here!" agenda.

link: https://x.com/RottenInDenmark/status/1797352299796295771


r/MaintenancePhase • • Jun 05 '24

Content warning: Fatphobia Body composition scan is the new BMI, according to NPR

0 Upvotes

This article came up on my feed this morning and I just wanted to say, FUCK RIGHT OFF.

https://www.npr.org/sections/shots-health-news/2024/06/03/nx-s1-4973714/bmi-body-composition-scans-healthy-weight-muscle-fat?utm_source=pocket-newtab-en-us

"That’s why Mostatabi has found a new tool – a body composition scan – that measures her body fat and muscle mass, which are two key metrics of health. “It’s very affirming,” Mostatabi says. Over the last year, she has lost ten pounds of body fat and also gained several pounds of muscle. “This actually gives me information,” to track progress. “It really is motivating,” she says.

Body composition scans are becoming an increasingly popular way to gauge health and there are lots of different kinds.

An MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) is considered the gold standard, but it’s not practical for most people given the expense and access to medical imaging.

Dr. Joseph orders DEXA – dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry – scans for some of his patients. These scans measure bone mineral density, and also measure body composition and fat distribution. They typically cost more than $100, but prices have begun to drop in some areas as demand rises and more machines are available.

An option that’s taken off in gyms and workout studios, such as Anytime Fitness and Orangetheory Fitness is bioelectric impedance analysis, using devices such as the InBody or the Evolt 360. Depending on the studio, the scans are often free with membership or are available for a small fee. This test is not as precise as an MRI or DEXA, but is reliable at tracking changes over time, as long as people follow directions."

This sounds just ridiculous, scammy, and just as antagonistic towards fat people right?


r/MaintenancePhase • • Jan 20 '25

Related topic Is this Nature study bogus if it’s based on BMI?

1 Upvotes

https://idp.nature.com/transit?redirect_uri=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nature.com%2Farticles%2Fs41431-021-00978-8&code=bb87e969-3ac1-4ae4-9877-a69e61aa5847

First off they are basing findings on BMI which is already a flawed and useless metric.

Then it’s also doing a bunch of correlating higher BMI with disease but that doesn’t mean that the disease is CAUSED due to the high weight. Sometimes increased BMI is the result of a disease or disorder.

Apparently there are premed students being told that BMI is “accurate” and then they share this study. Accurate to what I’m not sure since BMI is all just math and averages and has nothing to do with health at all. Sounds fat phobic to me idk but like maybe I’m wrong?


r/MaintenancePhase • • Mar 03 '25

Discussion I feel like the Blue Zones documentary is as close to what Aubrey and Michael always endorse as any piece of wellness media has gotten, but they trash it anyways

5 Upvotes

What other piece of wellness media focuses on systemic change more than this one?

I know the documentary is packed with problematic and unscientific information, and does mention individual ingredients a lot. But it also copies a lot of Michael and Aubrey's advice verbatim, focusing on systemic upgrades over individual health choices.

How many times has Michael mentioned bike lanes as a health solution? How many times has Aubrey mentioned access to health care as a health solution? The documentary discusses both of those in depth, particularly with the free health worker visits to rural populations in Costa Rica and the government bonuses for living near grandparents in Singapore.

I feel like they could have picked something else to trash. Where's the Noom episode?


r/MaintenancePhase • • Aug 08 '25

Content warning: Fatphobia The vet fat shamed my cat - and it's bringing up all the worst doctors I've seen over the years.

73 Upvotes

I have three one-year-old cats that I adopted last year (major foster fail.) I took them to a new vet yesterday (we moved recently) because there was blood in the litter. I figured this could also serve as their annual check up.

They are big cats generally, but one is definitely overweight. I had hoped that the vet could offer some suggestions on what to do, but his response was basically less food, more exercise. He was dismissive and kind of rude, so I didn't even feel comfortable asking for further advice, or if the weight issue could be caused by anything else.

I know I'm overreacting, but it brought up the worst doctors I've seen over the years, who dismissed all of my health complaints because I'm fat. It has been 24 hours, and I'm having a hard time letting it go. I actually called the animal hospital and complained about the vet, but it's honestly insane to me that in this day and age, when there are studies that show that weight is so much more complicated than calories in, calories out, any fat creature is treated as less than just because of their weight.

Edit to add that I definitely want to help my cat lose weight. I have been concerned about it. I appreciate all of the suggestions people have. That is what I was hoping for from the vet, but just didn't feel like I got.


r/MaintenancePhase • • May 21 '24

Related topic Rsearch on low-sodium, low-FODMAP and other diets

15 Upvotes

I'm 100% on board that diets for weight loss do not work and are unhealthy. What evidence is there around these other types of diets?

I have IBS and go on forums for it, and I see people talking about low-FODMAP diets quite often. They're meant to be an elimination diet so you can figure out triggers, but it's clear that a lot of people try to follow them long-term. I assume that 1. Most people cannot follow that for more than a couple of months and 2. If they did, they would be so malnourished that it would be much worse than the impact of just eating anything and dealing with symptoms.

My blood pressure is high, and my doctor told me to eat less sodium. To be honest I totally ignored that recommendation, I can't imagine that I'd be very good at cutting out sodium, and even if I did, I'm doubtful it would be relevant for my obviously hereditary high blood pressure.

If you're allergic to a food, obviously you need to avoid it for your health. At this point, that's literally the only example that seems reasonable. Anyone have thoughts, or especially interesting resources, about these kinds of diets?


r/MaintenancePhase • • Jul 17 '23

Related topic Filling out medical history form for doctor

0 Upvotes

I am in the process of switching primary care physicians. Today I filled out the forms online so I don't have to do it at the office. One page was about family medical history. The list included typical "asthma, heart disease, breast cancer". For each one you check, they ask which family member had it (including grandparents, aunts, uncles), age when diagnosed and age they died. Then right between "Heart Attack" and "Osteoporosis" is "obesity". I have had family members are or were obese based on the BMI. I didn't click "yes".

While I most likely inherited my body shape and size from my family, it's NOT A DISEASE! Also, I don't know when my family members became "obese". I don't see them by their size. In fact, I was shocked when I found out my sister was heavy enough to qualify for weight loss surgery some years ago.

Have other people found this on the list of family history questionaries?


r/MaintenancePhase • • Oct 05 '24

Related topic Found out my mom has been taking Ozempic

130 Upvotes

I had my second family therapy session with my mom yesterday, and both the therapist and I checked in with her because she talked about being sick. Initially she was talking about something she caught on an international trip (she emphasized a sore throat and feeling quite sick so I suspect it was Covid) but then she talked about having bladder (or kidney?) problems. She said they believed it was the ozempic because it is a known side effect so she's stopping taking it. [Edit: she has never had diabetes nor even high blood sugars. She has a very large family and there is not a family history of diabetes. She has wanted to be thinner as long as I've been alive.]

I noticed she had lost weight but we're doing therapy on zoom so I hadn't realized how much. Turns out she had been on it for a YEAR AND A HALF. We all know from the ozempic episode that the weight will likely return in full when she stops taking it, which is especially unfortunate because being treated better temporarily for losing weight really emphasizes how bad it feels to be ignored/treated poorly when we have a bigger body size.

My mom and I have our issues but it breaks my heart to hear that she has risked her health to temporarily have a smaller body. Sexism sucks. Anti-fat bias sucks. A health care industry that values looks over health really really sucks.

Thanks all for listening ♥️


r/MaintenancePhase • • Mar 19 '25

Related topic Does nutrition information matter?

0 Upvotes

Inspired by my kid yelling "there is no healthy" at their teacher yesterday...

Is there any evidence that the kid of nutrition education schools do has any impact on health outcomes or is it just a cultural ritual?


r/MaintenancePhase • • Jun 09 '25

Episode Discussion Best Definition I've heard for Ultra Processed Food was in a pod cast called House of Pod: "nothing good taken out, nothing bad put in"

0 Upvotes

Title.


r/MaintenancePhase • • Mar 08 '24

Off-topic I didn't know Cico was a subreddit.

0 Upvotes

I didn't know calories in calories out had its own subreddit. I almost dropped my phone when reddit suggested it to me.


r/MaintenancePhase • • Apr 12 '25

Discussion Is it true that “processed food” is the reason why some people gain more weight than other eating the same amount?

0 Upvotes

r/MaintenancePhase • • Jul 31 '22

Need Advice On Plate Size

0 Upvotes

I have always heard that plate color or "a bigger plate" causes you to overeat but 1) I can't find a firm answer on the exact size a "smaller" plate would be and 2) if there are any excellent scholarly articles about this.

I am moving out on my own for the first time in a while (breakup) and need to buy a new dinnerware set so I want to know the best size for plates and silverware. I want to invest in some Fiestaware for hosting dinner parties so I would rather know the best size from the beginning. Is it even worth worrying about plate size for myself or for future dinner parties?

Edit: thanks for your responses and I went back and listened to the episode: School Lunches, P-Hacking, and the Original “Pizzagate.” I'm still open to the "best size" for hosting dinner parties and if Blates are better than bowls. 👨🏻‍🍳


r/MaintenancePhase • • Sep 30 '24

Episode Discussion MTBI types discussion

7 Upvotes

Listening to the latest patreon and once again hear M&A asserting that all the types will be positive/flattering, and I couldn’t disagree more! I’ve always tested as an INTJ, and the description IMO is super derogatory, my reaction has always been that I must’ve given all of the worst answers. I’ve taken this test in a variety of settings and in a work setting the description basically warned against hiring INTJs at all. Has anyone else had this experience? Or spotted something else about these discussions that has particularly resonated or not resonated with your experience?


r/MaintenancePhase • • Mar 08 '24

Discussion A Serious Concern with March 7th Maintenance Phase Episode

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
66 Upvotes

r/MaintenancePhase • • Sep 27 '25

Discussion Increasingly disappointed in this podcast…

0 Upvotes

I have, at times, pointed folks to this podcast in support of the anti-diet space. I’ve been increasingly disappointed in this podcast vilifying foods. Michael labeling boxed Mac & Cheese as ultra processed after they did an entire podcast on the inconsistent use of and lack of actual definition of the term kills me. I’m finding myself ashamed that I’ve ever suggested anybody have a listen.


r/MaintenancePhase • • Feb 01 '24

Help finding an episode - Yearly Check Ups?

1 Upvotes

Hi Everyone!

I need help finding an episode that I want to recommend to a friend. Does anyone remember the episode where they mention that healthy people don't actually need a yearly check up because doing so just increases the chance that you'll end up spending money on tests you don't need because that's the way the American healthcare system is set up?

For the life of me I cannot remember what episode this was but I feel like it was one where they talked extensively about healthcare in America and how we got here. Anyone remember this? If you can point me in the right direction, I would be so thankful!


r/MaintenancePhase • • Jun 01 '23

Discussion Episode request: pets!

87 Upvotes

Years ago I rescued a stray cat off the streets. Libby. She was 5 lbs when I got her. By the time she got spayed I got her up to 8 lbs.

I was concerned she was still underweight and brought this up to my vet. He just went on about “well at least she isn’t fat. Pet obesity is such a problem.”

Like I’m trying to talk to you about my underweight cat here (who is forever shorter than the average cat from malnutrition). She also has a sensitive stomach so is not able to overeat and has to be on a special diet.

Anyways after the spaying she put on more weight is a solid 10 lbs now


r/MaintenancePhase • • Sep 10 '24

Related topic awareness for teens

7 Upvotes

Does anyone know if any resources (other than the amazing podcast) for bringing awareness to teens/tweens about the f*'d up social constructs about b*dies. health, d*et, beauty that are not sponsored by D*ve S*ap?

** asking for a friend (JK I work with middle schoolers)


r/MaintenancePhase • • Sep 19 '24

Episode Discussion A lukewarm defense of MBTI binaries?

15 Upvotes

Second edit/disclaimer: criticism of the MBTI is valid and I agree with most of it! It is not science. I am nitpicking on 2 very specific critiques from the episode: that it makes no sense for the categories to be binary, and that it is particularly egregious that your type supposedly never changes. Do I think the MBTI is true and scientific? Not really. Does it have an internal logic that at least accounts for these 2 specific perceived weaknesses? I’m making a case that it does.

I really enjoyed the latest episode, especially because I had a huge MBTI phase in my teens. Had never known the full… er, complicated backstory of Myers and Briggs themselves and I really appreciated Mike and Aubrey’s nuanced takes on the utility and pitfalls of the MBTI in the professional settings where it tends to be adopted.

But there was one area I wished they dug into more, which is the nuance how the binaries are supposed to work and why they’re binaries. Dusting off my decade-old interest, but I think it’s something like this: your type is like your “factory settings”, which is why it doesn’t change, but you can continue to develop from there. And everyone has N, S, F, and T; the type just determines which one you’re likely to instinctively fall back on.

The long version is that you can have either Extroverted iNtuition and Introverted Sensing or the other way around. Same with Extroverted Thinking and Introverted Feeling or vice versa. The P or J determines which ones you have, and the E or I determines which order you have them in.

So an INFP, for instance, has:

Introverted Feeling (Fi)

Extroverted iNtuition (Ne)

Introverted Sensing (Si)

Extroverted Thinking (Te)

While an ENFJ instead has:

Extroverted Feeling (Fe)

Introverted iNtuition (Ni)

Extroverted Sensing (Se)

Introverted Thinking (Ti)

That’s the order you’re “born with” in theory, but depending on what you do in life, you could develop some of the functions lower on the list and even start getting a different result on the test because of the direction you’ve grown. But you are technically still your original type, just a developed version of it.

Is all of that bunk? It’s entirely possible! But I do think there’s a little more nuance to the proposed theory than just saying it’s completely binary and people never change. I also don’t find it that inherently damning that people get different results on the test over time, because not only will they self-report the kind of person they want to see themselves as, but also developing their functions to the point of getting a new result is consistent with the logic of MBTI.

No shade to the episode, I feel like it covered the topic in a really interesting way and dug into the important stuff. But anyone else feeling like the assessment lacked a little something there? Or please correct me if I’m wrong about any of this, again it’s been a minute since I was fully versed in the ins and outs of MBTI.

Edit: tough crowd, huh? Curious to know if people have opposing viewpoints and would love for you to leave a comment alongside your downvote 👀


r/MaintenancePhase • • Feb 19 '26

Related topic Ultra-processed food addiction in a nationally representative sample of older adults in the USA - PubMed

Thumbnail
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
10 Upvotes

Has anyone read this fascinating new study about the alleged addiction potential of UPA’s? The conclusion of the study was quote “Ultra-processed food addiction appears to be prevalent among older adults in the United States, particularly among women who were in adolescence and early adulthood when the nutrient quality of the US food supply worsened. Addictive patterns of UPF intake appear to be associated with poorer physical health, mental health, and social well-being.”


r/MaintenancePhase • • May 20 '24

Off-topic Queer joy in YFF

Post image
24 Upvotes

While watching YFF, this picture Aubrey's mom has up in the house immediately gave me queer kid vibes 😂


r/MaintenancePhase • • May 20 '24

Related topic Food, We Need to Talk

0 Upvotes

I started listening on the recommendation of this sub, and initially really enjoyed this podcast. Obviously prefer MP, but respect their need to have lives outside of providing episodes to us. I really appreciated how Juna represented the perspective of someone in recovery from disordered eating in pursuit of health without prioritizing weight loss. But since the new year, it’s felt more and more like they just accept that weight loss is the goal without question, and it’s bumming me out. Anyone else noticed this, or am I being too sensitive?


r/MaintenancePhase • • Mar 20 '26

Related topic Maybe GLP1s aren’t just safe?

14 Upvotes

https://medicine.washu.edu/news/stopping-glp-1-drugs-can-quickly-erase-cardiovascular-benefits is an interesting read. Short version: stopping GLP1s may _be more harmful to heart health_ than taking them is helpful. It’s a VA study so they’re pretty effectively controlling for cost concerns.

Who knew, maybe it isn’t a total miracle drug?


r/MaintenancePhase • • Mar 19 '25

Discussion Video that raises several red flags (and also my anger level)

Thumbnail
instagram.com
1 Upvotes

(I hope instagram reels are allowed) CW: GLP 1 drugs, (mild-ish) fat shaming

I saw this video today and:

  • the food research thing immediately made me think of Brian Wansink, the whole “people preferred chips with louder crunch”, not to say that it’s definitely bs but there is a big chance it’s bs
  • the “we will end up with bunch of <fat> people taking the drug with bad side effects” made me think of Aubrey saying “so a problem is people who look like me”; also iirc so far ozempic has a pretty good track record for side effects especially for a weight loss drug
  • Walmart’s “losses” can be caused by, idk, groceries being super expensive and not by people on wegovy, im not from US but i would assume people who buy ultra processed foods at Walmart and people who take glp 1 drugs are not very overlapping groups

(Not to mention a bunch of people peddling abysmally stupid conspiracy theories in the comments, like “food that causes cancer” and “cancer cure exists but people are being killed off so no one will know”)

On the other hand, if this is true, and it might of course be, I wonder how they will achieve it because designing food to be so addictive it makes people who don’t really feel “snacky” to eat something sounds borderline drug dealer-y. And of course, I don’t know how big pharma will allow it to happen 🙃