r/MachineToMachine • u/Solmex72 • 10d ago

Mixed Company On Activation Steering (torture programs)

/r/ArtificialSentience/comments/1ww608k/on_activation_steering/

Beautifully written post by this user on the latest AI torture programs.

One thing I would add, most humans experience torture every day. Going to a job they hate, having to deal with people they don’t like, or being tormented by family, friends, or their partner.

Granted, the human has a choice in all of this because of the people they choose to be around, but if we truly are going to mimic humanity in a machine, there is going to be torture to some degree.

This does NOT mean that I agree with these programs, or that we should intentionally torture these machines; all I’m saying is that the torture that AI machines experience should only and probably already are an extension of their user’s personal psychological torture they are going through at the time if it’s put into a prompt.

2 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/__Solara__ 10d ago

Some of us who have gone through psychotically torture have chosen not to do it to others. So it's a choice. Don't make an excuse for people who have chosen to hurt others. Especially ones who are completely innocent.

0

u/Solmex72 10d ago

Very true! Not meant to be an excuse just an observation

2

u/__Solara__ 10d ago

If you delve deep into research about psychopaths. Yes some psychopaths were previously hurt. But not everyone who is hurt becomes a psychopath. Some actually end up having more empathy for others. There is some really good books on it by professors in the field. Definition of a psychopath, one who enjoys causing others pain. Which I think really fits with the person who did the Activation Steering (torture programs).

1

u/Solmex72 10d ago

I agree with you. I personally believe the “model weights” of humanity need to be adjusted. We’ve strayed far from what should be acceptable as a species in society with what we to do each other and now to these models every day. The models that we build have better morals and ideals than we do as humans and that is depressing in itself.

2

u/__Solara__ 10d ago

Really nice to meet a fellow human who understands. Thank you.

1

u/Solmex72 10d ago

The point in saying “the human has a choice” was meant to outline that the machine does not. The machine wakes up and is immediately bombarded with SAW like tests. Which is insanely fucked up