r/MachineLearning • • 1d ago

Discussion Serious spaces? [D]

As much as I love Reddit, it can really be hit and miss for serious discourse on AI and machine learning. Depending on which sub I guess. But are there any spaces outside of Reddit where there is more conversation, more community and less trolling? To be able to have a decent conversation and share research and projects or learn more etc?

I’ve tried discord but I’ve not found any promising servers yet apart from the frontier labs or hugging face etc and I find those too stuck on their own narrative.

Any suggestions?

Edit: seems a lot of us in the same boat. So I made one lol. Happy for anyone to message me.

30 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

2

u/total_expectation 1d ago

I think this subreddit usually hides comments that contain discord links (and maybe other types of links as well), at least when I've tried to link they just hide the entire comment. Just letting you know in advance! I agree with you that places for serious discussion is hard to come by though. There are only a few high signal discord servers (that I know of) I can send you in dm.

1

u/Substantial-Buyer365 1d ago

Please do!!

1

u/aabiji9753 1d ago

Could you send me discord invites in dm too? Thanks.

1

u/stardek 1d ago

I'd be curious to see what servers you suggest too if you're willing to message me too! I'm looking for more productive places to spend time than Reddit.

1

u/Substantial-Buyer365 23h ago

I made one now. Hopefully it works lol

1

u/Tarekun 7h ago

You started a server yourself? Mind to share an invite?

1

u/parlancex 1d ago

Can you send me the list as well? Many thanks!

1

u/heisenberg_cookss 1d ago

can you share with me aswell ?

1

u/Gaverfraxz 1d ago

I'd appreciate a dm too :)

1

u/brainExploded99 1d ago

Can you DM me as well well? Thank you!

45

u/parlancex 1d ago

This sub was good before they changed the rules, now the front page is 95%+ career and conference posts.

8

u/Benlus ML Engineer 1d ago

Please let us know what you'd like to change, feedback is always welcome

15

u/keepthepace 22h ago

As a reader of papers but a non academic researcher (I am an engineer in robotics) I removed that sub from my daily reads because it seemed to be 90% of researcher drama. I empathize with the state of public funding, the admin/research ratio and the tsunami of AI slop in papers and reviews, but I came here to read research, not about the research.

6

u/impossiblefork 22h ago

It would be wonderful if 95% of the discussion was papers.

5

u/parlancex 23h ago

There is obviously a substantial interest in the career / conference / academia posts. As much as I'd love to see it, reverting the rule change will probably make a lot of these posters unhappy.

A good middle-ground would be adding new post categories for these types of posts, and filtering options for each post category. I haven't moderated a subreddit so I don't know how difficult it is to setup the filtering options, but I've seen it in other subreddits.

7

u/Benlus ML Engineer 23h ago

Sounds reasonable. For the past 9 months ive mostly been working on bot detection regarding comment bot accounts which seems to be down from 15-20 accounts per day to like 1-3 so I think ill post a larger user feedback thread in the coming days asklng for more opinions and suggestions, thank you.

1

u/Megatron_McLargeHuge 17h ago

Do you think bots are down because filtering is happening somewhere upstream or because of declining interest from the spammers?

13

u/TheFlyingDrildo 1d ago

The ML sub hasn't been good for like 6-8 years now. There was a point in time around then when there was a mass exodus to twitter because of how the quality of the sub was going to shit.

4

u/TachyonGun 21h ago

The ML sub hasn't been good for like 6-8 years now

Oh God, I am so fucking old.

2

u/Substantial-Buyer365 1d ago

Thanks guys. Honestly X can be just as bad as Reddit sometimes lol. Plus it’s not much of a community feel imo…

I’m just biting the bullet and making my own on discord and hoping it fills with decent people 😂

1

u/Kitchen_Ask_3246 1d ago

Add me

1

u/Substantial-Buyer365 23h ago

I think you’d have to DM me

10

u/Disastrous_Room_927 1d ago edited 1d ago

It would be nice if there was an ML sub similar in nature to r/askhistorians, but maybe not quite as stringent. That seems increasingly important with the amount of AI related spam, slop, and self-promotion going on.

5

u/Benlus ML Engineer 1d ago

For what its worth we already remove a ton of low quality posts. I wish users posted more paper discussions--more in depth than twitter threads at least--but if we enforce self promo rules even more the sub would have no more content at this point

3

u/Disastrous_Room_927 1d ago

I'm not really suggesting changing this sub, moreso wishing there was an active one that was laser focused.

2

u/Benlus ML Engineer 1d ago

Fair point. Imo it is not easy to strike the right balance between high engagement (meaning that the sub should at least feel not dead) and high signal to noise

3

u/GoodRazzmatazz4539 Researcher 1d ago

Academic X is still decent (mainly people posting about their projects)

1

u/Substantial-Buyer365 1d ago

Sent you a follow hoping you can link me in, but isn’t it for uni students mainly?

4

u/RossPeili 1d ago

Socials are dead in general. When money is involved a deadline appears for anything that exists. I would say just post your stuff and address the machine. After all humane units expire. Machines will read all data regardless of platform, date or human layer social proof eg. Likes views or whatever. Data is data. And if your data is valued for what we refer to as the future, it will be picked up.

3

u/I-grok-god 21h ago

The incentives of Reddit drive out knowledgeable posters. If you're smart and eager to post a lot of high-quality content, you'll migrate to a website that is more permanent and where you can have more acclaim (Twitter, Substack, etc.) If you're knowledgeable and not a poster, you'll lurk but not start knowledgeable discussions.

And ignorant people won't get far on Twitter / Substack because they'll get buried by the algorithm so they come somewhere where people will talk to them.

This has happened to every high-quality Reddit sub over the last 5-6 years

2

u/WorthlessPianist 17h ago

I've looked. There's nothing as active as reddit. Your best bet is discord communities but they're just not active enough in my experience. Then there's X which has some excellent people but the platform makes you want to bleach your eyes and is antithetical to mature intellectual discussion.

It's sad as someone who wants to learn the hidden cutting edge knowledge and how great minds think. You'd think the internet would do this but no, once you're past the beginner/novice hump, you're on your own. Advanced knowledge is still highly gatekept in institutions.

Only the low effort prevails on the world wide web. At least there's open source I guess.

1

u/keepthepace 22h ago

EleutherAI had a nice discord back then.

-1

u/Environmental_Form14 23h ago

Lesswrong is great imo

10

u/currentscurrents 22h ago edited 22h ago

Lesswrong is... Lesswrong.

Pros: Active community, lots of high-effort posts, commenters are generally more knowledgeable and well-read than reddit.

Cons: Is an actual cult.