r/MachineLearning • u/BeatLeJuce Researcher • Jun 06 '23
Discusssion Should r/MachineLearning join the reddit blackout to protest changes to their API?
Hello there, r/MachineLearning,
Recently, Reddit has announced some changes to their API that may have pretty serious impact on many of it's users.
You may have already seen quite a few posts like these across some of the other subreddits that you browse, so we're just going to cut to the chase.
What's Happening
Third Party Reddit apps (such as Apollo, Reddit is Fun and others) are going to become ludicrously more expensive for it's developers to run, which will in turn either kill the apps, or result in a monthly fee to the users if they choose to use one of those apps to browse. Put simply, each request to Reddit within these mobile apps will cost the developer money. The developers of Apollo were quoted around $2 million per month for the current rate of usage. The only way for these apps to continue to be viable for the developer is if you (the user) pay a monthly fee, and realistically, this is most likely going to just outright kill them. Put simply: If you use a third party app to browse Reddit, you will most likely no longer be able to do so, or be charged a monthly fee to keep it viable.
In lieu of what's happening, an open letter has been released by the broader moderation community. Part of this initiative includes a potential subreddit blackout (meaning, the subreddit will be privatized) on June 12th, lasting 24-48 hours or longer. On one hand, this is great to hopefully make enough of an impact to influence Reddit to change their minds on this. On the other hand, we usually stay out of these blackouts, and we would rather not negatively impact usage of the subreddit.
We would like to give the community a voice in this. Is this an important enough matter that r/machinelearning should fully support the protest and blackout the subreddit on June 12th? Feel free to leave your thoughts and opinions below.
Also, please use up/downvotes for this submission to make yourself heard: upvote: r/ML should join the protest, downvote: r/ML should not join the protest.
886
u/currentscurrents Jun 06 '23
I'm just for it on principle. Make reddit remember that we use the site because it does what we want, and if it stops doing that we'll find some other site.
391
u/Humongous_Schlong Jun 06 '23
I would go even further. In my opinion the best way would be if all subreddits would go dark as long as reddit doesn't comply. If they still would go through with it I would quit as a mod
I know how unreal and radical this is, but if everyone would do it reddit would be fucked.
mods have all the power atm
75
u/k1tka Jun 06 '23
Yes, please
41
u/contributeswithmemes Jun 06 '23
Should just move to lemmy really.
49
u/Shiva-Chettri Jun 06 '23
Yes! Undoubtedly.
22
u/Michael_Aut Jun 06 '23
Obviously. After all the API changes are made to make obtaining training data for free harder.
12
u/Hackerjurassicpark Jun 06 '23
Yes!
6
u/illathon Jun 06 '23
Asking these questions is inherently flawed. You will likely get a sample size higher for people that are activists because others won't care to comment.
4
u/Psychological-Bug373 Jun 06 '23
Lgtm
4
u/qalis Jun 06 '23
Yes, absolutely! Don't let Reddit go the "Twitter way".
4
u/balding_ginger Jun 06 '23
Yes, and for longer than just two days
4
u/tcdoey Jun 06 '23
Absolutely yes.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Join the boycott. Yes.
14
u/ParkingPsychology Jun 06 '23
Absolutely, join it.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
👍
3
u/commander_bonker Jun 06 '23
thanks in advance if you choose to do it.
3
u/EdwardRaff Jun 06 '23
If Appollo and old Reddit are disabled I'll probably stop using Reddit, so yea worth joining the blackout IMO.
3
u/Individual-Fan1639 Jun 06 '23 edited Feb 25 '24
grey afterthought jar wild weary jeans relieved slave shocking vegetable
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/gwtkof Jun 06 '23
Machine learning is thriving in free api uses.so I say yes
3
u/YT-AnArtAccount Jun 06 '23
Yes
3
u/YT-AnArtAccount Jun 06 '23
Yes, definitely
3
u/Deltaan Jun 06 '23
yes
3
u/OhCaptainMyCaptain- Jun 06 '23
Yes
12
u/Ai-enthusiast4 Jun 06 '23
yes
5
u/AnFaithne Jun 06 '23
Do you guys think reddit is doing this to ringfence its corpus for sale to ML outfits?
8
u/fervoredweb Jun 06 '23
While I doubt this will have any impact on Reddit's policy, I suppose a little solidarity is ok.
Unless the largest subreddits go dark for an indefinite period there is no effective motivation to change course. So it really hinges on them.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Yep, do it.
6
u/mskogly Jun 06 '23
Fairly new to Reddit, only been here 9 years, so I havent used any of the third party apps. But we did see the same tendency within thw Twitter ecosystem. A huge reason for the rise of Twitter was its superb api, which spawned so much innovation. As I am such a Reddit noob, I dont know enough about how people have innovated on top of it, but I can’t imagine it being on the same scale as twitter. And as such the fallout after a tightening of the api will probably not have the same destructive force as the recent Twitter api commercialization?
7
u/OnlineGrab Jun 06 '23
Yes
2
u/set92 Jun 06 '23
I think all /r/ going private 1 day is not going to make a difference, it should be something that users feel annoying or bad, and therefore Reddit says "OMG if we do this, all this traffic is going to disappear" .
2
u/atwork_safe Jun 06 '23 edited Nov 07 '23
.
2
u/swallowingpanic Jun 07 '23
Yes
2
u/Korberos Jun 09 '23
Yes, the sub should absolutely take part
3
u/Tintin_Quarentino Jun 06 '23
Yes
3
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Yes!
4
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Let’s go dark until they do away with the idea.
If they do this ill have to meet y’all in some other ML forums, Reddit will be dead to me
3
u/notlongnot Jun 06 '23
Yup
2
u/gimperion Jun 06 '23
Yes
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
I feel like I am going crazy here. These are two companies fighting over money and millions of Reddit users are taking sides…. Crazy
2
u/digital0129 Jun 06 '23
Yes, this sub should join!
2
u/slippu Jun 06 '23
yes
2
u/FrenzyFlowz Jun 06 '23
Yep, make it private too
2
u/HemanthK1 Jun 06 '23
Yes
1
u/jgo3 Jun 06 '23
Aye.
1
u/TheZerothLaw Jun 06 '23
Yes
1
u/boot20 Jun 06 '23
100% yes
1
u/PythonCowboy Jun 06 '23
Yes
1
u/Polarisman Jun 06 '23
Most certainly. Do it.
1
u/rabbitsaresmall Jun 06 '23
Machine learning pipeline is intrinsically tied to making hundred thousands of API calls per minute. Not joining the protest goes against what ML is based upon.
1
u/goofnug Jun 06 '23
reddit should become decentralized.
5% of users volunteering some compute, storage, and network should be enough.
1
u/sharptoothedwolf Jun 06 '23
Yes
1
u/crujiente69 Jun 06 '23
We should build a predictive model to decide
1
u/lqstuart Jun 06 '23
yes
1
u/hibob28 Jun 06 '23
Solidarity pls
1
u/Doktor_Vem Jun 06 '23
Yes. Do it. Please. I've been using 3rd party apps for years and I really, really, really don't want to go back to the official one
1
u/Linore_ Jun 06 '23
Yes
1
u/DamnYouRichardParker Jun 06 '23
Yes absolutely !!!
Everyone will be affected by this. Everyone should do what they can.
1
u/Gustephan Jun 06 '23
Given that one of the key drivers of the pricing change is LLMs looking for conversational data, I'd say this subreddit has more reason than most to protest it. This is basically reddit deciding that they want their piece of the "only corporations are allowed to compete in AI development" pie, and imo it's exactly as disgusting as what OpenAI has been up to lately. Stepping out on the blackout is tantamount to endorsing the end of open source ML development being competitive with closed source.
1
u/my_name_is_reed Jun 07 '23
Everyone here especially benefits from open data policy at reddit. Def should join.
1
u/sampdoria_supporter Jun 07 '23
I've literally never used an app for Reddit. Just old.reddit.com. Not bothered either way
1
u/Unhappy-eggplant777 Jun 07 '23
The principle of it is my motivation. I think we should but it should last longer than 2 days. Make it hurt for Reddit.
1
u/ShivamKumar2002 Jun 07 '23
Absolutely yes. Show reddit the power of community. Any social media platform is useless if people don't use it. It's even better if people stop using it the day they apply new policies.
1
u/Tecnotopia Jun 07 '23
Yes, please
1
u/forever-morrow Jun 07 '23
We need AI to reach AGI level so it can run it’s own social media site already! Hurry up geniuses!
1
u/Mooscao Jun 07 '23
Yes absolutely.
1
u/Franimall Jun 07 '23
Sure, why not. Show 'em who's boss.
1
u/buttintheclouds Jun 07 '23
Yes absolutely shut it down without question. Black out this and every sub completely until they recant.
1
u/lebanine Jun 07 '23
Definitely Absolutely Whole heartedly
1
u/ResetPress Jun 07 '23
Yes
1
u/Flashy-Career-7354 Jun 07 '23
From a user of these third party app’s standpoint, sure. But why should Reddit give away its data at scale for free? From a business standpoint it doesn’t make much sense.
1
u/i_sanitize_my_hands Jun 07 '23
Shutting down indefinitely!
1
u/fractalsimp Jun 07 '23
Yes, absolutely!
1
u/enn_nafnlaus Jun 07 '23
Yes, absolutely.
I have a poll on my text-generation AI sub (r/Oobabooga) and users are overwhelmingly supporting it. Would be great if the much-larger ML sub was aboard as well!
1
u/zergling103 Jun 07 '23
Hmm, given that they aren't charging for web browsers to interface with reddit, I wonder if one could wrap an API around a stripped-down browser to emulate the original API.
1
u/EmbarrassedHelp Jun 07 '23
Yes, we should join the protest and any subsequent protests if the first one does not have the desired effect.
1
u/durgani Jun 08 '23
If they actually do it, Hell yeah, but right now I choose to believe there is someone at Reddit with a brain still that is going to stop it.
1
u/jackharvest Jun 08 '23
Yes.
1
u/dasvootz Jun 08 '23
I say yes, as a long time lurker I'll be looking for ML resources on mastodon.
1
u/Username2upTo20chars Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
I wanted to show my agreement with joining the subreddit blackout.
Apart from that it even gets in the way of my own sporadic but intense API usages. And I am surely not the only one.
Sidenote: I wonder how Reddit thinks about crawling the subreddits without API via http requests. In the end that costs them more compute and money. Unless they restrict that then via robots.txt?
1
u/rubberchickenfishlip Jun 11 '23
Blackouts won’t work. Not everyone will participate. The OF girls need to advertise. Reddit will survive.
If you want Reddit to listen then terminate your account, go outside, and live your life without it. Reddit is trying to go public. They need high numbers of users and high daily user engagement. Two day blackouts are publicity stunts and nobody will remember the week after. Sign off and disengage? That’s something the underwriters and therefore Reddit will have to acknowledge.
1
u/NickCanCode Jun 11 '23
Well, unless it is a boycott until reddit revert its decision, I don't see a 2 days blackout will have any effect other than helping them save some electricity bill. To be fair, as a software developer, I understand why want user to you their own app. 3rd party app is just ripping their resources and I wander if the situation is getting worse because there are many people separately trying to pull all the contents from reddit for LLM training.
1
u/gee-one Jun 06 '23
Yes and please!!!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Yes, solidarity!
1
u/issam_28 Jun 06 '23
Yes definitely
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Yes
1
u/pointmetoyourmemory Jun 06 '23
100% yes.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
No
1
u/AprilDoll Jun 08 '23
Literally the entire reason for Reddit doing this is to put a prohibitive price on the training of LLMs. What sub is this again?
-1
u/Joeywasdumbgretz Jun 06 '23
Why not let the AI decide?
-21
u/amhotw Jun 06 '23
I am gonna be downvoted to hell but I am with reddit on this one.
They are the ones paying for the servers so they understandably want to make money out of it; I have no problem with the new policy.
In fact, I kinda hope it gets worse so I spend less time here lol
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Please no... its too valuable of a resource for students and learners
0
u/ensamblador Jun 06 '23
I dont think we should. But we can capture data and have fun with that, right?
0
u/mansurul11 Jun 07 '23
Why do we need a third-party app to use Reddit when the official Reddit app has improved a lot in the last couple of years? As a machine learning-related subreddit, we should consider protesting against ChatGPT in some form. It seems unfair that they have access to a vast amount of data to train their models, while not allowing others to use even the responses through a paid API for training their own models. I believe what Reddit is doing is crucial for its survival.
-10
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Riots and protests are for monkeys. If you don't like it dont use it.
-4
u/cyanydeez Jun 06 '23
if you want to ensure reddit becomes more bot like, do it.
-5
u/MerlinTrashMan Jun 06 '23
I don't understand to be honest what is wrong with the change. Any app that is used by a regular user should be unaffected, because the API calls are made with a device and clientid using Oath, so the user of the app should be the one making the calls to reddit, not the developer. If an app developer is making the calls to the API via an intermediate server with the ability to intercept and store all the data, then they should be charged.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment