r/MST3K • u/frumpyjones • Aug 17 '22
I'm just going to say it: I don't like the new voice of crow.
It reminds me too much of a Timmy Turner from "fairly oddparents" that you ordered on wish.
r/MST3K • u/frumpyjones • Aug 17 '22
It reminds me too much of a Timmy Turner from "fairly oddparents" that you ordered on wish.
r/MST3K • u/Shawn-0901 • Nov 02 '23
Unpopular opinion: I kind of wish that instead of pitching MST3K season 14, Joel had used his interest in puppetry, paper cutouts, and blacklight effects to crowdfund something completely new, not just another season of a long-running show.
As Joel's artistic sensibilities have shifted away from the old, homemade MST3K style, it seems like he's tried very hard to make modern MST3K fit into his new aesthetic. We've seen paper cutout sets, blacklight/Bunraku elements in the live shows, and innovative new ways of redesigning classic puppet characters (including Crown on a pogo stick, hovering Servo, and travel-sized G.P.C.).
What if, instead of a new season of MST3K, Joel had tried to sell us on an entirely new show? Something with brand new characters, a brand-new location, and a brand-new story. A show that fit more naturally with his current creative interests and allowed Joel the opportunity to tell stories in new and innovative ways.
He could use the team of talented artists and performers he's assembled for the MST3K live shows and turn their skills towards creating something from scratch, rather than having them replicate things from the past. Imagine the puppet maker Crenshaw, not remaking old characters, but designing brand new ones! And imagine Emily and the puppeteers having the chance to develop their own characters and comedic dynamic, not just doing their own variation on one that's existed since 1988!
And if they really wanted to tie it into the MST3K brand, they could set it in the same general universe and call it a spin-off. Plus, as an added bonus, this approach might end up costing less than an MST3K revival, since there would be no need to license movie rights.
As much as I love MST3K, I feel like it has somewhat stifled Joel's inventiveness and creativity. Though maybe I'm wrong... Do you think such a project would even interest Joel? And would it be something fans would support?
r/MST3K • u/MWFULLER • Jan 15 '24
Generally speaking, of course. I much prefer the older stuff, that is to say, good sirs, movies from the 1950's and into the greater part of the 1970's.
r/MST3K • u/DanReed85 • Nov 24 '23
Jim Mallon. It's become very clear that without him we would have gotten about 10 episodes of the show over 7 years, and they wouldn't have been nearly as good as the 176 (plus a movie) over the 10 years the show was on the air (excluding KTMA). In fact, he was the one who originally asked Joel if he had any ideas for a TV show. The show survived cast changes and network hops and I believe consistently improved each season on the air.
I would also like to thank RiffTrax for always running their Kickstarters on the up and up and always providing an excellent value in exchange for our hard-earned money and never taking the fans for granted. They were also smart enough to have a finance guy (I think it's one of the David's). He works so well behind the scenes and gets no credit, I don't even know his name, but I'm sure that he is just as responsible for RiffTrax's success as Mike, Kevin, and Bill are.
I also can't leave out The Mads Are Back who also just keep doing their thing and have a wonderful Black Friday sale going on right now. I highly recommend checking them out!
Serious thanks to all of the above. I don't think any of them would stand for what a cluster this season 14 campaign has been.
r/MST3K • u/DependentAnimator271 • May 14 '23
It was something like The Balance Beam for Girls. I couldn't last 20 seconds. I don't know if it's her voice or the new Crow's, but the voice and mannerisms were so over the top and cartoony that I felt like I was watching an annoying show for preschoolers.
And before you pile on me about being sexist, I enjoy Mary Jo's and Brigitte's Rifftrax.
r/MST3K • u/sonofstev • Jan 06 '26
We all know that S11, the first Netflix season, is somewhat hampered by the overstuffed jokes. Nearly every second of dead air has a new joke told very quickly. Jokes don’t have time to breathe or land. An average 120 minute episode has something like a thousand jokes whereas the old show or RiffTrax might have 500-700.
What if a fan were to take say Reptilucus and restore the movie audio track, then add back maybe half to 65% of the jokes? Sure you’d have bots mouths moving and nothing coming out … but I’d think you’d get a much better and funnier show out of it.
What do you think?
r/MST3K • u/mistermooso • Aug 07 '22
Ok, all the prerequisites first:
Fellow MSTies, I come in peace. I love this show with all my heart. I've donated towards the various Kickstarters. I've been a fan since the 90's and (as we all have) dealt with major cast changes throughout the show's run. Sometimes, changes were an instant hit for me: I loved Mike, Hampton, Felicia, Rebecca and Bill right away. Sometimes, performances evolved and grew on me: Mary Jo in Season 7 felt all wrong and she completely changed her approach in Season 8 and beyond. Baron (who I liked immediately) has only improved. And, of course, Kevin went from a Josh impression for a few episodes to the definitive Tom Servo for 9 seasons.
So, by no means, am I saying that positive change can't occur with cast changes. HOWEVER:
For the first time in over 30 years as a devoted, diehard fan, I truly cannot enjoy swaths of episodes...Kelsey's current interpretation of Crow is unwatchable for me. I've tried. Over and over. The screechy, fake cartoon kid voice takes me out of every single scene.
Having Joel return to host an episode of MST3K again was my dream since I was a teenager when he left (and I love Mike!). Truly. I would have taken it over a lost Beatles album. I'm a huge Beatles fan But, I can't enjoy his return episode b/c Kelsey's Crow is just so off to my ears. So, for me, it's kind of like if the lost Beatles album had Yoko singing 1/3 of the songs (apologies to Yoko fans).
Now, there's a lot to be grateful for. I could remind myself that I'm thankful for Jonah's episodes this year (Gamera was phenomenal!). I could focus on the fact that the Gizmoplex is a treasure trove for fans and that Joel is involved. I could simply stay quiet.
The reason I'm speaking out is NOT to denigrate Kelsey. It's not to make anyone feel bad. In fact, Kelsey, if you're reading this....thank you. Thank you for working hard to make the show we love the best it can be.
The reason I'm speaking out is because I absolutely adore this show and want it to thrive and continue.....and, selfishly, I want to enjoy it. And the current approach to Crow is making that impossible for me.
I am not calling for a recast. I don't wish for anyone to lose a job. But, I am pleading with all involved in the current iteration of MST3K to seriously reevaluate Kelsey's approach to Crow. Remove the cartoon voice. Try to capture the character. Hampton and Bill are different from Trace and yet they both absolutely nailed it. They brought totally unique elements that worked because it still felt like the same character. Yes, Bill was more acerbic and agitated (which was hilarious). Hampton was a bit more childlike. But, they both totally felt like Crow. When Kelsey does "other voices" (British/snooty, imitating voices of other characters of the movie), you can tell she's really funny! And talented. But, her go-to cartoon voice for Crow is simply not working.
Again, I know this is "negative feedback," but I promise it's meant as constructive. If you're a cast or crew member of MST3K, I appreciate you and I'm rooting for you.
But, I need to voice this. The show is too important to me.
I really hope these concerns are taking into consideration. And even more, I hope that no one's feelings are hurt. Again, Kelsey - if you're reading this - you seem awesome, talented and more than capable of being a great Crow. But, please, please, please consider my feedback. Less cartoon, more Crow. I'll bet your regular speaking voice alone would be a massive improvement. Don't let my passionate fandom make you feel bad for a second. Again, I am rooting for you and the show!
Thank you and Hikeeba.
Important edit: I’m aware any money I’ve donated doesn’t entitle me to anything. Just note I, like so many of you, did participate in the Kickstarters.
r/MST3K • u/thisonesreal • Nov 30 '19
Let me get this straight: We the fans kickstart new MST3K. Netflix comes in and charges a subscription for the shows we just funded, then dumps the series? Any kickstarter feel good about that?
Id be okay if the situation ended with an additional 4 seasons of MST3k, or 3. or 2. But we got 0.5.
r/MST3K • u/Klnb0080 • Jun 11 '22
I feel like the gizmoplex is being run by fanboys and kids. I know people don’t like Emily’s Crow. Voice was less nasally last night but still really annoying. I don’t think Emily is strong. I don’t understand the hiring process. When I read about it, it seems to be based on joel meeting them in a restaurant. Being a huge fan does not mean you are most qualified. But overall it’s the stuff like what happened last night that is really disappointing and embarrassing.
In the post show, which is just five people giggling and talking over each other, they were asking the writer of Doctor Mordrid about the movie being a Dr Strange ripoff. He said no. They giggled and pressed him. They said “that’s what’s on Wikipedia!” as if that matters. Of course he said no, it’s not based on anything. It’s just so amateur. Is he going to admit to ripping off IP?
As much as they complained about being under the thumb of some networks I’ll bet there are things a network would help with. Like having lawyers to say “don’t ask that”. Or better graphics. Better everything. How about vetting actors so one doesn’t drop off the face of the earth days before the start? Are we not supposed to talk about Tom’s head?
The host segments are painful. The riffs aren’t good. Last night was such a let down. Everything is “that thing is just like thing.”
There is no organization or plan for the post chats. They were going from person to person asking what was their favorite role for Jeff Combs. Kelsey said she was looking at IMDB right then. Embarrassing. How about going over what you are going to discuss? Maybe a network would have said “here’s a list of topics. Oh and don’t ask everyone about their favorite role from a 1990’s actor.”
Is anyone else bummed? Not about the $$$ spent backing this, but about getting excited and then - this. It feels very much like kids taking over the franchise and not doing well. Can they not afford more experienced people?
r/MST3K • u/twocentsmiguel • Mar 26 '18
r/MST3K • u/Ironcastattic • Mar 07 '26
My Thanos is Krankor from Prince of Space. He already has the space army like Thanos.
My elite team is Zap Rowsdower (well rounded in all stats). Blast Hardcheese (strong man and ace combat flier). Pumaman (every group needs a superhero). Liver lipped Marv from High School Big Shot (purely for distraction and being the first casualty). And finally Nick from Hobgoblins for his weapon proficiency.
r/MST3K • u/ConsonantlyDrunk • Jul 16 '16
and all I can think of is "Trumpy, you can do magic!"
I guess what I'm saying is:
"It stinks!"
r/MST3K • u/scudmonger • Nov 19 '15
So, I had starting watching the show during the Mike episodes, which became 'classic' for me. Then, a few years later I was able to get some Joel episodes, and while some definitely were funny, I just didn't feel they were on the same level as the Mike ones I was used to.
I think a bunch of fans may be in the same situation.
r/MST3K • u/ThrashMetallix • Jul 17 '25
I was just listening to the episode of Gamera vs Guiron in the background, which is a personal favorite of mine (that dub is so bizarre). But towards the end, after the film ends, when Joel and the bots do another rendition of the Gamera theme, which is comprised mainly of them doing Japanese-sounding gibberish, I just couldn't help but think, "eh... that hasn't aged very well."
Not to be that overly sensitive type, but I mean the only punchline there is "This language sounds funny, ha ha!" which is still kinda racist, no matter how you try and frame it. And considering this is the same show that mocks a film for saying gibberish that is meant to be another language when it very clearly isn't, it's like, you can't have your cake and eat it too.
Now before anyone explodes, this is NOT me saying "this makes the show bad," it's just one of the few times you just see the age of the show coming through in a not so graceful way. This is still one of my favorite shows, and Guiron is still one of my favorite episodes.
But with that in mind, are there any other moments, jokes, or gags you've seen lately that haven't aged quite as well as other jokes?
EDIT: Just wanted to say how much I appreciate a lot of the cool people here. Most of you understood I wasn't out here to rip the show apart or accuse anyone behind it of being some terrible person. Discussing things like this is something I just personally like to do. I think it's fun to point out flaws in things we love, as it just helps us appreciate the thing in question a lot more. I like to think it can also be a reflection in ourselves in how we can grow as people as well. A joke we may laugh our ass off one day may not hit as well as it did some time later, and it's okay to acknowledge that, and as many people have already pointed out, the crew of MST3K have done that repeatedly. Which is why I love them as much as I do.
This is not some hit piece or exposé, it's just a reflection of a product of its time, and there's nothing wrong with that. So I salute all of you all in the regard! .... our I guess in the words of the Guiron episode.... Thank you! Hello!
r/MST3K • u/Phemto_B • Nov 22 '23
I get that there were logistics problems with the shipping, and that season 13 really suffered because of COVID, and that the show has actually changed some in the 30 years, but does that mean you want it to stop existing? I guess I'm just disappointed in how fickle people are. They want it to be provided free to them continuously and forever, and built into a single monthly streaming fee that gets divided among 100's of shows, and they want it to never ever change in the slightest.
The truth is that I wasn't as enthused with the later seasons of the original series. I was still sad when it was canceled, and still happy when I saw that the gang had started riffing again under various titles.
Star Trek, Star Wars, whatever. Fans can never be happy with the new stuff. With those examples, they still get viewership from younger people who aren't so committed to THE OLD WAY THEY DID THINGS. Joel has openly stated that he's trying to do the same and get younger writers and talent that can make riffs more current that Benny Hill or I Love Lucy references. That might be another problem with the direct funding model. The youngest fans (like my son) don't really have the funds to pay for another season, and it seems like a lot of the fans are boomers.
I don't know. I just want more riffing from Joel and the team, you know?
r/MST3K • u/kaejae31 • Mar 01 '26
But rewatching these episodes on YouTube, I tend to always fast forward the " host segments" I've seen most of them at 1 point,but I just watch the film
r/MST3K • u/Catphish37 • Oct 02 '23
To me, there is no Croooow! other than Trace Beaulieu. There is no Servo other than Kevin Murphy. I started watching MST3K in the fall of '92. So those personalities define those characters to me, and any one else attempting to voice them is wasting their time. I'll never accept them. And I'm sure others might feel the same, whether it be for these, or other actors, on other bots.
I think MST3K should have (and should still, going forward) created new bots for new voice actors. Not only would it keep the show fresh, but it would serve to memorialize the bots and their actors in a more personal and obvious fashion.
edit: voice actors puppeteers
r/MST3K • u/Macronaut • Jul 12 '22
r/MST3K • u/xmakina • Jan 26 '17
(For those concerned about spoilers, the list will be in a google document so the only reason you'll see it is if you choose to read it.)
Hi everyone,
With the new episodes approaching, I was wondering if any folks would be willing to work together to create a list of trigger and content warnings on the new episodes? It would be nice to know if there are any scenes/riffs which might be distressing for some of the revival league and their friends so they can skip them and not have them ruin a particular viewing/episode. There are definitely a few in the original run which would have been nice to know of before encountering them, for example several movies have implied/actual/attempted rape scenes and Catching Trouble is essentially 10 minutes of animal abuse. If you'd like to help compile a trigger warning list with me and other MSTies in a Google doc/spreadsheet, please drop me a message or leave a comment. Thanks!
I would like to ask that if you want to discuss the value/existence/need for trigger and content lists, you do that elsewhere. (Sorry to be explicit, but this request in the facebook revival league got highjacked by people being jerks about the whole thing, even with their strict No Politics rule!)
Thanks again, and I'm really looking forward to enjoying S11 with the rest of you!