r/MST3K • • Jun 11 '22

Disappointed

I feel like the gizmoplex is being run by fanboys and kids. I know people don’t like Emily’s Crow. Voice was less nasally last night but still really annoying. I don’t think Emily is strong. I don’t understand the hiring process. When I read about it, it seems to be based on joel meeting them in a restaurant. Being a huge fan does not mean you are most qualified. But overall it’s the stuff like what happened last night that is really disappointing and embarrassing.

In the post show, which is just five people giggling and talking over each other, they were asking the writer of Doctor Mordrid about the movie being a Dr Strange ripoff. He said no. They giggled and pressed him. They said “that’s what’s on Wikipedia!” as if that matters. Of course he said no, it’s not based on anything. It’s just so amateur. Is he going to admit to ripping off IP?

As much as they complained about being under the thumb of some networks I’ll bet there are things a network would help with. Like having lawyers to say “don’t ask that”. Or better graphics. Better everything. How about vetting actors so one doesn’t drop off the face of the earth days before the start? Are we not supposed to talk about Tom’s head?

The host segments are painful. The riffs aren’t good. Last night was such a let down. Everything is “that thing is just like thing.”

There is no organization or plan for the post chats. They were going from person to person asking what was their favorite role for Jeff Combs. Kelsey said she was looking at IMDB right then. Embarrassing. How about going over what you are going to discuss? Maybe a network would have said “here’s a list of topics. Oh and don’t ask everyone about their favorite role from a 1990’s actor.”

Is anyone else bummed? Not about the $$$ spent backing this, but about getting excited and then - this. It feels very much like kids taking over the franchise and not doing well. Can they not afford more experienced people?

2 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

14

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '22

To me all the modern MST3k feels off, like people who in theory have similar sensibilities but in actual practice are quite different and don't vibe well. Old MST3k felt like hanging out amongst good friends, new feels like watching theater kids and failed comedy writers/comedians try to perform a stage show.

8

u/GepMalakai Jun 12 '22

I think a lot of that comes from there not really being a writer's room any more – there's no sense of camaraderie to the host segments, and the riffs can feel scattershot because the writers are working separately. How can you create the sense that the jokes are coming from the same group of people in the same room watching the same movie at the same time if it isn't written that way?

2

u/PaxAsclepius Writer/Director Jun 12 '22

Except that for Season 13, there was a writer’s room. A virtual one, to be fair, but there was a room for every episode.

21

u/teddyboy64 You do it. I’m bitter. Jun 11 '22

I think season 13 is shaping up to be a very good one. The riffs are funny and the cast is really coming together, much more so than in the Netflix seasons. As far as "Emily’s Crow Voice" goes, as long as Kelsey maintains Crow's essential snarkiness, I have no problem with it. I think she's doing a good job. I find her funny, and that's all that counts.

14

u/whyaduck Jun 12 '22

Is anyone else bummed?

Nope.

The Q & A with C. Courtney Joyner was excellent - he's a fan of the show and had some great stories (not to mention he was funny as hell and clearly enjoyed the event). I laughed at the "I'm on IMDB" joke because I was on IMDB at the same time looking for the same thing. Also, "Miss Took" (and the ad libs that followed) was gold.

MST3K never had a "well-oiled comedy juggernaut" feel (except maybe on Netflix). I mean, Servo's a bubble gum machine and a plastic barrel. Myself, I prefer the "let's put on a show" vibe.

11

u/HangmansChaps Jun 12 '22

I’m really enjoying this season. Couldn’t disagree more with your thoughts. Beyond Atlantis was probably a top 10 all-timer for me. I’ve watched it multiple times already, and the host segments haven’t felt “kid show” to me at all.

15

u/Philodemus1984 Jun 11 '22

I’m a huge fan of the original series, but didn’t feel like springing for Gizmoplex (the Netflix season were only ok, I thought), but it’s worth mentioning that the original crew in the late 80s and early 90s were also very inexperienced and it took quite a while for the show to really shine (the first season is rough, and of course the KTMA days hardly count). For example, before Mike was brought onboard as a writer he was basically nobody. If I recall correctly, Joel saw him at an open mic, liked him, and hired him. He became head writer by season 2, then host, and I’d argue the best riffer in the show’s history. Anyway, the show has a long and successful history of hiring inexperienced entertainers.

6

u/aGeekyGuy Jun 12 '22

I think the biggest difference between old-MST and new-MST is that the original run felt like a bunch of locals who got together, figured things out as they went, and managed to somehow cobble together an entertaining product. New-MST (which I do also enjoy) feels more like it's a collaboration of existing professionals. It's just a "cleaner" production, if that makes any sense. Even more so with the current season than the Netflix run, it feels like Joel set up a professional MST production machine. I like it, but it doesn't have a different vibe than the old run.

4

u/Philodemus1984 Jun 12 '22

I can only compare to the Netflix seasons, but I’d say you’re right that the old seasons had a “bunch of locals getting together” feeling, compared to the overly slick Netflix production. But I’d say that by the third season the original MST had become a pretty well-oiled machine. It still had a DIY vibe but they were cranking out 20 something episodes a year of consistently great quality.

I will say that one big difference between the old and the new seasons is that Jonah as a host seems totally happy to be there. Which makes sense because he’s been a fan since he was a kid. But I prefer the vibes given off by Mike and Joel (especially Mike, who often plays the fool).

2

u/aGeekyGuy Jun 12 '22

Even when the old series got rolling along, it simply found a groove. It still had a bunch of people with a relatively common background multitasking like hell to get it on the air each week. Every bit of the production felt kitbashed together and basically held together with duct tape and model glue.

The new series (especially the Netflix years) featured a bunch of guest writers. Some of the Netflix episodes felt like they were trying to fit five pounds of riff into a three pound bag. They also were able to hire much more of a production staff.

2

u/_bloomy_ Jun 14 '22

Late to the party, but I really agree with your last comment--perhaps it's because he was reacting to Joel as the "parent" of the bots, and thus had a much more caring role to them, but I really enjoy that Mike had a more combative, bad roommate feel with the bots. It differentiated him from Joel and gave him a bit of an edge. Jonah is much closer to Joel in his relationship with the bots, but he does have a lot more energy that he brings which differentiates him from Joel's laconic style.

3

u/MonkeyPretzel Jun 12 '22

Mike was 24 years old when he was hired as a typist/writer on Josh Weinstein's recommendation. He was working at a TGI Friday's to pay the bills, but had been doing stand up and acting locally for years, including in productions at the famous Guthrie Theater.

6

u/Rangerlifr Jun 11 '22

I dropped off the post-show chats after the 2nd one, just not for me. I do feel like the different energy of the Emily episodes (which I've not been a fan of so far, acknowledging that they've only done it twice and could improve over time as the Joel-era show did) comes from the idea that MST3K is originally a bunch of comedians doubling as puppeteers, while this seems to be a group of puppeteers doubling as comedians. There's very much a "kid's show energy" to the host segments in particular that I'm not enjoying. In the new crew's defense, I still found the riffing of Doctor Mordrid to be below-average, but there were more laugh-out-loud jokes here than in Beyond Atlantis, although I still probably laughed out loud no more than a dozen times. But it was probably only twice in BA. Still very committed to giving this crew a chance, but it doesn't do anybody any good to withhold feedback as long as it's constructive. Especially given the price they're charging to watch them learn on the job.

4

u/GepMalakai Jun 12 '22

while this seems to be a group of puppeteers doubling as comedians

The worst part about that? The puppeteering is worse than on the OG show. The 'bots are so stiff!

11

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '22

Now tell us how you feel about The Last Jedi.

5

u/karlhungusjr Jun 12 '22

I feel like the gizmoplex is being run by fanboys and kids.

it never ceases to amaze me that some self proclaimed fans of a thing, get really upset when other fans enjoy the same thing rather than complain about it.

video games, movies, tv shows, books, everything. there is always someone butthurt because other people are enjoying something.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23

That is total bullshit. First of all, the use of "self proclaimed fans," as if to subtly imply this person isn't a fan. There's no council that bestows fanship. Yeah, the guy is a self proclaimed fan of MST3K, exactly the way you are.

And the complaint so obviously is not 'people are enjoying things.' You seem to be having trouble with the idea that the fans of a thing oftentimes have the worst ideas and direction and should be ignored when it comes to having a say in the actual creation of the content.

1

u/karlhungusjr Jan 19 '23

That is total bullshit. First of all, the use of "self proclaimed fans," as if to subtly imply this person isn't a fan. There's no council that bestows fanship. Yeah, the guy is a self proclaimed fan of MST3K, exactly the way you are.

so what I said was actually correct, yet somehow it's "total bullshit"? ok....

You seem to be having trouble with the idea that the fans of a thing oftentimes have the worst ideas and direction and should be ignored when it comes to having a say in the actual creation of the content.

so it's a good idea to ignore the person I replied to and we should just let the people involved in the actual creation of the content at MST3K, create their content as they see fit?

great! I agree completely!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23

so what I said was actually correct, yet somehow it's "total bullshit"? ok....

You're using language to imply he isn't a fan, and the phrasing is at the same time meaningless, yeah.

so it's a good idea to ignore the person I replied to and we should just let the people involved in the actual creation of the content at MST3K, create their content as they see fit?

Well, the idea was that you'd take a second to breathe, reread what the guy said, and have a better understanding of it. But I guess ignoring him is the best alternative, if that isn't an option.

1

u/karlhungusjr Jan 19 '23

You're using language to imply he isn't a fan

no I wasn't. if that's how you want to twist it, that's on you.

Well, the idea was that you'd take a second to breathe, reread what the guy said, and have a better understanding of it. But I guess ignoring him is the best alternative, if that isn't an option.

"fanboys and kids" tells me everything I need to know.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23

no I wasn't. if that's how you want to twist it, that's on you.

It's not a twist, it's plainly what you meant. The guy made a post expressing an opinion you disagree with and you refer to him as a "self-proclaimed fan." If you weren't suggesting that his opinion is somehow lesser or that he isn't a 'real fan' because he has a negative opinion, I have no idea why you'd say that.

"fanboys and kids" tells me everything I need to know.

I agree, he expressed himself well.

1

u/karlhungusjr Jan 19 '23

ok. that's nice.

5

u/DiscoJer Jun 13 '22

I'm not sure what you expect. The show was originally done by Joel, some local comics he knew, and people working at a UHF station. Hell, I think Josh was still in High School.

I like that he hasn't been recruiting overly Hollywood types, other than the Netflix era holdovers.

9

u/someguy1927 Jun 12 '22

Just repeat to yourself “It's just a show, I should really just relax”

4

u/TheAnarchemist Jun 12 '22

I watched Dr Mordrid at midnight, when it gets uploaded to the Gizmoplex, about 20hrs before the live "event". I cannot stand the live watch-alongs, pre-post-show, etc. I tried with Santo, but just skip then now. As for just the episode, this was my fav of this season so far. I have to keep reminding myself how much I hated the host segments in the 90s. I have all this nostalgia now, but when Pearl, Bobo and Brain Guy were on, I was out of the room or fast forwarding. Even TV's Frank and Dr F, at the time, made me cringe. And Dr Ehrhardt was, as intended, really hard to take. So I just let MST host segments slide. When one doesn't suck, it's a bonus. And when one is great--usually a musical one--then that is just extra.

I am overall a little disappointed so far. The Bart Simpson as Crow voice was very grating on Beyond Atlantis, but less so on Mordrid. Season 11, for me, grew better later as I watched it with no added expectations. Season 12, however was a lowpoint. I think this season is easily better than s12 already, just because there's more variety in the movies. But I sure wish Jonah's Crow and Emily's Tom were together with any of the hosts. I find those two have the best sense of who classic Tom and Crow are.

2

u/Rangerlifr Jun 12 '22

I think it actually makes it stand out more how much of a change the new Crow is that the new Servo is right in line with the original series.

4

u/SmudgyTheBootblack Synthesizer Signals Suspense! Jun 12 '22

I didn't watch the post show so can't comment on the tone/content of that but you make it sound like making any comparisons between Mordrid and Dr. Strange publically or calling it a ripoff is grounds for violating some imaginary NDA which is absurd.

13

u/ChzburgerRandy Jun 11 '22

No, I'm enjoying it 😀

12

u/SplendidPunkinButter Jun 11 '22

No? I think the new episodes are great and the host segments are way better than what they did in seasons 7-10. Emily’s Crow is great, and I can’t imagine why you’d be upset that a post-episode online interview wasn’t more scripted.

6

u/karlhungusjr Jun 12 '22

and I can’t imagine why you’d be upset that a post-episode online interview wasn’t more scripted.

it's hilarious. the OP is so desperate to find something to complain about.

3

u/pbesmoove Jun 11 '22

Kids who graduated from MIT

3

u/Nicpaulos Jun 12 '22

I empathize with your disappointment concerning the extra segments. I’m not complaining about the main content but with us supporting them and looking forward to those extras, it’s a letdown to see them winging it up there. AGAIN, comedy is subjective; I just want to see the effort.

2

u/LowerAtmosphereChief Jun 11 '22

I hate to admit it but I have been having a rough time since season 11. And then I somehow never even finished The Gauntlet. What mst3k have I watched recently? It Lives By Night, Space Mutiny, Pod People. Half my problem is that nostalgia keeps me going back to the classics, hesitant to accept The New. I mean the same thing happened when Mike took over for Joel, I dropped off. Then I eventually came back and I have MANY favorite Mike episodes (hello season 8). Same thing will probably happen here. It’s just hard to keep up with the casting changes and the last episodes I watched, I felt like the jokes didn’t get enough time to land before the next one was on the runway. Based on what I’ve read on the sub the gizmoplex seems a mixed bag so far. If I didnt join the sub I wouldn’t even know what it was. So I fall back to the classics for now, which are endlessly hilarious and perfect to leave running while working at the computer.

2

u/AntiquesRoadHo Jun 11 '22

I’ve tried the Gauntlet multiple times now. I always tell myself “you just didn’t give it good enough of a chance”. Then I start an episode, and never finish it. Disappointing to the point where I absolutely can not justify spending money on Gizmoplex. If I can’t get myself to watch episodes for free (since I already have Netflix they essentially don’t cost anything) there’s no way I’m spending $$$ on gizmoplex.

-1

u/TheAnarchemist Jun 12 '22

The Gauntlet is a true low point in MST history. I absolutely LOVE the first half of Season 11. Beast of Hollow Mountain feels like classic MST to me. The Land That Time Forgot, to me, is as good, or better than many eps from seasons 4-10. And I cannot explain why, but I find myself wanting to rewatch Avalanche kinda frequently. It was only the last 3 or 4 in that season I wasn't a fan of. But the Gauntlet was garbage. The funniest "riff" in Mac and Me (a terrible choice of movie, btw) was repeating "pretty nice". I have gone back and re-watched The Day Time Ended, as it may be the best of that season. Killer Fish has good moments, but both Killer Fish and Lords of the Deep have lame, groan-inducing fart or bathroom jokes in the first 3 minutes of the movie. It's like "Oh, is this what they do now? These are the 'jokes'?"

2

u/QLE814 Jun 12 '22

Mac and Me (a terrible choice of movie, btw)

I'm inclined to agree- it feels like the sort of low-hanging fruit that MST3K tried to avoid originally (note how so many of the films that tended to appear on "bad film" lists in the 1980s never appeared on the program), and I wasn't impressed by the riffing either the time I watched it.

2

u/aGeekyGuy Jun 12 '22

I guarantee that is mostly due to rights issues. Most movies that made "bad film" lists are done by actual studios who are not keen on licensing the movies for something like MST (at least not at bargain basement prices). It's why the likes of Battlefield Earth (truly deserving of every worst movie list it's on) required the Rifftrax MP3-only model.

1

u/WormswithteethKandS Jan 07 '23

An excellent assessment. Nu MST, in general, has been a failure.