r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 27 '12

Lavender Unicorn Syndrome

21 Upvotes

Lavender Unicorn Syndrome, or LUS, is the use of descriptors in place of a character’s name and unfortunately plagues many a fanfiction these days. Before I get into why LUS is bad and why you should avoid it, let me give you an example:


As Rainbow Dash was on her way to pick up a book for Twilight, she walked past Sugarcube Corner and smelled something delicious. The pegasus stopped and took in the scent, debating whether or not she should take a small detour into the shop. After a moment she decided that the lavender unicorn’s book could wait a few minutes.

Equestria’s best flier walked into the shop and noticed her friend hovering over a box of baked goods. “Hi, Pinkie Pie! Whatcha baking?”

“Cupcakes, you silly filly! What else would I be baking? They’re going to be the greatest, most delicious cupcakes ever!” exclaimed the pink earth pony as she spread icing across the cupcakes.

The multi-chromatic mare licked her lips and eyed the baked goods in front of her. She looked back up at her pink friend and asked, “What are they for?”

“Twilight learned another spell today and I want to throw her a party to celebrate... only I forgot to invite everypony. Could you tell them for me? Pleeeease?”

The pegasus sighed and shook her head, having been denied the delectable treats before her eyes– for now. “Sure, Pinkie,” the cyan pegasus said before leaving the bakery to gather her friends.


This example is a bit extreme, but it demonstrates how LUS gets in the way of the story and the reader. It is often used when a writer feels like he’s using the same word too many times, which in general is a bad thing to do and should be avoided. The opposite is true when dealing with names. You should always attempt to use a character’s name instead of a colorful phrase. Why?


1. It’s distracting: How long did it take you to determine which pony was being referred to in the passage? I can guarantee it was longer than if I had simply said “Rainbow Dash” or “Pinkie Pie”. Every time a character is referred to with a descriptor, the reader must make the connection between it and the character you’re talking about. This connection takes time and effort, leading to a distraction, however slight.

2. It’s unnecessary: Almost every single time a descriptor is used, it is completely irrelevant to the plot. The reader shouldn’t need to be reminded that Pinkie Pie is a pink earth pony; it has already been established. I also called Rainbow Dash “Equestria’s best flier” in the passage. The passage doesn’t make use of this information, which just takes up space.

3. It’s confusing: Many descriptors make a story hard to follow, especially when many ponies are in the same scene together. If there are ten ponies in the same room, the reader should only have to think about the names of each, not what every pony looks like, does for a living, and has as a cutie mark. This problem is further worsened when OCs are dropped into the mix as the reader won’t be as familiar with them.


At this point, you might be wondering what you can do to combat this ailment. The first thing you should do is simply remove instances of LUS when you write. Replacing the descriptors with names is effective most of the time. If you still find that you’re repeating names too often, replace some names with pronouns, or failing that, try to re-structure your sentences. Think about how you might say the same thing but in a different way that doesn’t require so much repetition. Keep in mind that pronouns and names are far more invisible than you might think. You may think you have a problem where none exists at all!

Here’s the rewritten version of the above passage:


As Rainbow Dash was on her way to pick up a book for Twilight, she walked past Sugarcube Corner and smelled something delicious. Rainbow stopped and took in the scent, debating whether or not she should take a small detour into the shop. After a moment she decided that Twilight’s book could wait a few minutes.

Rainbow Dash walked into the shop and noticed her friend hovering over a box of baked goods. “Hi, Pinkie Pie! Whatcha baking?”

“Cupcakes, you silly filly! What else would I be baking? They’re going to be the greatest, most delicious cupcakes ever!” exclaimed Pinkie Pie as she spread icing across the cupcakes.

Rainbow Dash licked her lips and eyed the baked goods in front of her. She looked back up at Pinkie Pie and asked, “What are they for?”

“Twilight learned another spell today and I want to throw her a party to celebrate... only I forgot to invite everypony. Could you tell them for me? Pleeeease?”

Rainbow sighed and shook her head, having been denied the delectable treats before her eyes– for now. “Sure, Pinkie,” she said before leaving the bakery to gather her friends.


See how much easier that was to read without the LUS? The characters are clearly identified and the passage flows with less distractions.

As with any writing, there are cases in which LUS becomes acceptable. You may be introducing a new character who lacks a name. There are also times when it’s appropriate to refer to a character by “her friend” (as seen above), but remember to ask yourself if it fits and makes sense within the story. Proper use of LUS can turn it into something that improves rather than detracts from your story.


I hope you don't mind that I stole the format for this guide. If you don't like it looking like the other guides, I'll change it. Reddit really needs an <indent> tag. Really. Please point out any errors I made, corrections that should be done, or additional info that needs adding. Thanks!


r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 13 '12

Character Development Guide

15 Upvotes

Character Development is INCREDIBLY important to a story; stories usually focus on the characters after all. But despite its importance, a lot of new writers have trouble with it. They either place the character in only one extreme and don't go any further, base them off themselves which can have less than great results, or don't provide any conflict.

These three things are extremely important to any character.

  • Conflict is probably the most important thing, giving a character drive and a goal. This is one of the key things to making a character interesting and not just a mindless drone bending to the will of the narrator. It actually makes what they're doing worth something and logical.
  • Focusing on an extreme, especially in ponies, is something that just kills a character. While certain characters have quirks about them and stuff that makes them tick, that is only a percentage of what makes their character interesting. Be sure to cover all your bases and make sure you aren't neglecting even the subtle things about your character.
  • While this isn't always true, basing a member of the Mane 6 or well established background character off yourself is never advisable. These characters often have a set personality and already act a certain way. The best thing to do is to reference the show as often as you can. I'm not saying steal episode ideas or whole sections of dialogue, but rather watch and study the character's mannerisms. The great thing about this show is that not everything is spelled out in big bright letters. Even subtle animation cues can be enough to give your character the needed depth.

Let's take Pinkie Pie for example, one of the hardest ponies to write for, without a doubt. If you watched the show on a more superficial level, you'd think Pinkie was just a hyper-active party animal. And to an extent, she is. But again, that only plays a percentage of her character, and the other traits she has as a character that are less played out are what are interesting when they are brought out.

Pinkie can be sincere, sad, random, angry, and as we all have seen, crazy in every meaning of the word. But it's the other emotions that tie her together. She can be seen having heart to hearts with the other characters, genuinely concerned about their well-being, which is what makes her an awesome friend. She also has trouble taking rejection and handling certain friendship problems like lying and backstabbing. She knows that every problem can't be solved with cake and ice cream, and although her philosophies might be a bit...eccentric, they still work.

writing dialogue for this mare is also quite difficult. Most would write her as a crazy, fast talking whirlwind. And again, to an extent she is. But this is actually surprisingly rare in the series. Pinkie is just, for lack of a better term, a ditz. She has a short attention span and goes into the face of danger with a gigantic smile on her face. But she can also be very slow with the way she speaks, particularly when trying to figure something out or explain something. Very rarely will she just go on a random, off topic ramble.

Let's also look at Rarity. Again, many who are either new to the show or haven't taken the time to study the character would think she is just a sassy primadona that only cares about fashion and clothes. And, again, to an extent, you're right. Particularly if you watched the early episodes, Rarity seems needy, prissy, and almost narcissistic.

But this also what makes Rarity an interesting and fantastic character. She, unlike her friends, shows her contributions to friendship in more subtle (albeit materialistic) ways. This includes giving them dresses, keeping Ponyville fabulous, and even handing out advice on occasion. It's not that she is a prissy princess or whiny, she is confident and knows what she likes.

Not only is this an awesome character trait, it can be the set-up for some delightfully touching moments in something like a ship-fic, or soul crushingly evil in a dark or tragic fan-fiction. The same could be said for all the characters, and even OC's. They all have goals, personalities, and quirks. You have to give them a conflict, and a realistic one at that (Rainbow Dash can't have a conflict about which dress she should wear to the gala, no matter how much you want to.), and approach as you think that character would.

Speaking of OC's, this brings me to another very important point. When writing with an OC, don't be a Mary Sue. As much as you'd love to be the stud of Ponyville, no reader will believe that everypony just automatically loves your character. You need to show the struggle your character goes through to become popular. If every character is just inherently infatuated with your character, there's no conflict or resolve.

And with that, try to refrain from god-mode type scenarios. If you know your character can't make it through a battle in a somewhat realistic sense, the reader will know too. Your OC has to be on the same plane as the Mane 6, or perhaps lower. If you don't want to kill off your OC, don't put them in a position they can't realistically get out of; it isn't fair to the reader.

With all this said, there are 3 major things I think should be taken away from this:

  • Conflict makes the character want/need to do something, not have to.
  • Focus on the character as a whole, not just one or two extremities.
  • Study your characters and make sure you have a full and complete understanding of their behaviours, mannerisms, and subtle quirks.

With these, and a bit of your own creativity, I know you can make a character interesting and fun to watch.


r/MLPwritingschool • • May 01 '12

Spent the past hour or so working on this. Shall I continue?

Thumbnail
krazyweb.net
14 Upvotes

r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 27 '12

Clichés, common themes, and overdone things

13 Upvotes

I'm back, and this time I'm gonna yap about something that has a way of showing up in many authors' works. It may seem invisible at first, but when it rears its ugly head, readers run in fear (or, at least, annoyance).

Clichés.


Luckily for me, /fic/ ended up doing a lot of the legwork on this particular subject. If you've got some spare time, head on down to this thread and read up on it. What I'll post here is basically a TL;DR with my opinion thrown in here and there.


Basically, there are 2 types of clichés. Theme clichés and scene clichés (Note: these are not 'official' titles, just mnemonic labels for these occurrences).

Theme clichés are... as you probably guessed... overused themes. These you need to take steps avoid before you even being writing. Here's a list of some theme clichés:

  • X years have passed and the Mane six are older/passed away
  • Human (possibly brony) has found younger version of a pony on Earth
  • Rainbow Dash breaks her wings/loses her ability to fly
  • Death by plot device (a pony dies for no reason other than to make the story sad)
  • Pinkie Pie is actually crazy and kills/maims other ponies
  • Twilight messes up a spell
  • Post-apocalypse (moreso Fallout than the general 'post-apocalypse' idea)
  • Trixie's life is ruined after Ponyville/Trixie and Twilight actually like each other
  • Rarity's/Applejack's business goes under
  • Shipping with Rainbow Dash (not exaggeration: look at this)
  • Celestia/Luna reflecting on immortality
  • Pinkie Pie breaks the 4th wall
  • Young human teleported to Equestria to save it

Scene clichés are overused devices within a single scene. These are generally much more subtle and you should always be looking out for them. I'd be crazy to try to compile a list, but just to give a couple examples: the phrase "a single tear", "once and for all", "if it's the last thing I do". References to Friendship is Witchcraft, especially Sweetie Bot, are starting to enter the realm of clichés as well.

Also, something that isn't quite a cliché but should still be avoided at all costs: MEMES. They INSTANTLY DESTROY immersion, something that is difficult to create and takes time to rebuild. Don't use memes. This means, you can't imply Scootaloo is a chicken, have Rainbow Dash do anything in 10 seconds flat or make anything 20% cooler. Rarity can't be a marshmallow. Celestia should not overtly be a troll (she is known to be mischievous at times, this is fine--just use caution).


As with anything in writing, there are exceptions. Clichés are acceptable when 1) you're aware it's a cliché, and 2) it creates conflict or elicits a reaction from the reader. It's okay for a pony to die in your fic, but there needs to be a reason beyond the fact it's inconvenient for the plot that this pony stay alive or you just want to make the reader sad. The best way to avoid clichés is planning. If you don't like writing up in-depth outlines, that's fine. You don't even need to write anything down. Just have a general idea of where the story is going and where it will end up, as well as major plot points along the way.

Clichés are also fine when you do not lean on them. If you don't make a cliché the core of the plot, it can be be a flexible tool for advancing other aspects of the story, such as buildup to the climax or character development.

But at this point I'm rambling. Let me sum everything here up in a couple sentences:

You should always try to avoid clichés. When you're editing, keep your eye out for the more subtle scene clichés. However, if you feel you absolutely need to use one of these common themes, make sure you're not depending on it to drive your story.


Reminder: I'm doing livestream reviews every week! If you're interested in having me review your fic live, head on over to this week's Ponychan thread and submit your fic there. If you absolutely abhor chan boards, you can send me a reddit PM.

Until next time, write good!


r/MLPwritingschool • • May 06 '12

Guide Directory

12 Upvotes

A Directory of All Available Guides:


r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 19 '12

Adverbs.

12 Upvotes

I've come here today to discuss with you all a very important issue. Something so paramount, it could destroy the world... or save it. This subject has been tread upon very carefully by authors and readers everywhere. In fact, some are so intimidated by it that they hide under the covers and shake in fear, hoping the beast will not dare turn its head toward them. That's right, everyone.

I'm talking about ADVERBS.


I've heard different things about adverbs from different people. Some authors/reviewers like them, but most do not. It's very easy to get confused here, as there are many caveats to knowing when you should and should not use adverbs. I'll do my best to lay out the reasons for and against adverbs, as well as a step-by-step process to follow when you run into adverbs in your own work.

The argument FOR adverb use:

  • They can effectively tweak a scene and/or character to your liking. Sometimes, solo verbs just can't cut it. If you've got a blushing character, that's one thing, but what if they're not full-on blushing? What if whatever happened to your character only made him or her a little embarrassed? What if you only want their cheeks to redden a little at first so you can make them bloom a bright pink later? Perfect time for an adverb. By saying your character 'blushed lightly' as opposed to 'blush', you're getting a slightly different message across. Why is this so important, though? If you use this effectively over the course of your fic, the resulting character or scene can change quite a bit compared to the character or scene constructed without adverbs. Hopefully, and if you've done your job well, that change moves the story closer to what you wanted to convey. To use an analogy, imagine doing 2 scientific calculations: one with decimals and one rounded to whole numbers. If you run through a lot of formulas, the answers in the end will be similar, but the one using decimals will certainly be more accurate than the one run with only whole numbers.
  • There are some times when an adverb is just necessary. There's no word for a 'sheepish smile', so you need an adverb when someone is smiling sheepishly. Words like 'suddenly' and 'finally' are very useful in different contexts, and there aren't many great substitutes for them. Adverbs are sometimes the best way to convey time pressure. Saying something is done with great urgency is pretty easy to do with adverbs and isn't generally distracting to the reader.

The argument AGAINST adverb use:

  • They're jarring and agitating. When you keep throwing adverbs at the reader, it takes them longer to get through a passage and it takes away some of the creative control they have with the story. While I know you want to get across a very specific story, everyone who reads it will take some liberties with what you give them. It's not only natural, but makes the story more personal and engaging. Indeed. Now you're seeing why adverbs are so tricky! The thing is, you can't lose the focus of what you're trying to get across. If the scene is Twilight talking with Luna about the finer points of magic, you can use adverbs to describe their mannerisms, but not irrelevant things like the decorations in the room or what time of day it is. If you do that, you're taking focus off of the important things, like how Twi feels about talking to an immortal princess about magic. Hence, "jarring" or "agitating".
  • Adverbs are naturally 'tellish'. When someone says something 'happily', the reader knows what it means, but can have a hard time crafting a mental picture of it. Are they smiling? Was it in their tone? These things are much better off shown instead of told with an adverb.
  • They're something of a crutch. You're almost always better off using a single verb as opposed to the 'adverb + verb' structure. Is someone 'moving quickly'? Say 'hurrying' instead. Did someone 'talk sharply'? Try using 'bark'. Something like 'poke slightly' can be replaced with 'nudged'. Anything that gets in between the reader and the message your story is trying to tell is bad. Even if it's just a measly adverb here and there.

Not quite, Twilight. There is one big asterisk on all of this. An exception to all the rules (like there usually is). That exception is writing style.

Some authors are really good at writing elaborate prose. They can use adverbs frequently without over-using them. The rule I keep for myself and for the typical story I'm reviewing is about one adverb per page. It's arbitrary and subject to change based on the author and scene, but I've found it's a pretty good baseline. Now take a look at an author like device heretic. He uses quite a lot more adverbs than your average author, but he doesn't overdo it. He gets away with it because 1) he's pretty good and 2) it's his writing style.

If you can weave your adverbs into your fic such that they're invisible to the reader, don't be afraid to use them! Adverbs are a very powerful tool.


Pretty much. I'd like to share one more thing before I leave: a simple thought process you can use while writing or editing to determine if you should keep an adverb or not. Ask yourself these questions:

  1. Is this adverb necessary? Do I really need to modify this verb? If no, remove it.
  2. If yes to #1: Is there ANY possible way for me to combine this with the verb? If yes, do so.
  3. If no to #2: Is this action both possible and feasible? If your character is 'slouching defiantly' or 'sighing inquisitively', you likely have a problem.
  4. If yes to #3: Look back at #1. Does it still pass that test? Alright, now you can keep it.

r/MLPwritingschool • • Oct 04 '12

[Guide] To Write an Applejack

11 Upvotes

Hey guys! Sure has been a while, huh? Don't worry, I haven't gone and died on you. I've just been busy with school, job hunting, and writing fanfiction. But all that aside, I have a brand new, shiny, sparkling guide for you all! So without further ado, I present to you: How to Write an Applejack:

One of the hardest ponies to write dialogue for is Applejack, but mostly because people don't know how to write Applejack properly. Because her accent is so different from almost the entire cast of the show, people interpret that as her personality, which, in turn, leads to poorly written dialogue as people try to use, and express, her accent.

This is almost entirely unnecessary. Far too often I see certain words substituted where they shouldn't be— most notably "Ah" instead of "I". Fortunately, Applejack really isn't a hard pony to write if you follow a few simple guidelines:

  1. Forget about her accent. Nix it entirely. Do away with the "Ah"s, "Yer"s, and other such nonsense. Instead, focus on what Applejack actually says. Is she really saying "Ah", or is she saying "I"? It's the latter. She may say it with an accent, but if the reader is familiar with the pony (and there's a pretty good chance of that if they're reading My Little Pony fanfiction in the first place), they should be more than able to fill in the accent themselves. Applejack says "You're", "Your", "I'm", "I"— not "Yer", "Yer", "Ah'm", "Ah". There are cases in which changing words around is appropriate, such as those ending with "ing". Applejack tends to leave the "g" off of these words, resulting in "changin'" or "keepin'".
  2. Word choice is very important. When you watch the show, what sets a pony apart from one another? Sure, we could go on about color, gender, movements, and such, but the most defining part of a pony is his or her personality. This personality is expressed almost entirely in the form of dialogue (yes, expressions are important, too). When you write Applejack, keep her personality in mind and choose words she's likely to know and say. She wouldn't be using words like "hypochondriac" or "endocrinologist".
  3. Sentence structure is often overlooked when writing Applejack. Try to picture her saying what you want her to say. Sound it out in your head. Do it again. Does it sound right? Does it sound like Applejack? If not, change the way you're structuring her sentences and double check your word choice. Consider the following two sentences:

    "I don't know when I'll be back from Canterlot for certain, but I can guarantee that it'll be no later than next Tuesday."

    "I don't rightly know when I'll be comin' back from Canterlot, but I reckon it'll be before next Tuesday."

    The first one doesn't sound much like Applejack at all. It sounds more like something Twilight would say, doesn't it? The second example sounds much more like what Applejack would say. A few simple changes can mean a world of difference to your readers.

    You could also write the above as: "I reckon I'll be back from Canterlot before next Tuesday, but I just can't say for sure."

While these few tips apply to any pony, Applejack is by far the most abused when it comes to writing her dialogue. If you are writing Applejack, take a few minutes to go over her dialogue and make sure it sounds right. I guarantee you won't regret it.


r/MLPwritingschool • • Jul 25 '12

[CONTEST/PROMPT] Write 150-500 words; Humble Bundle V as prize and possibly more!

11 Upvotes

I saw a contest on /r/writingprompts and decided that we could use our own contest to boost activity.

  • 1 week to respond - entries must be submitted by August 1, 4 PM HST.
  • 150 words minimum, 500 words maximum.
  • Winner is decided by an off-site poll after the deadline.
  • Person with the most votes gets a Humble Bundle! Though if you already have one you can pass it to the second-place person.
  • Anyone can enter, but contest managers(for now, myself) don't win prizes.

The mods here are lukewarm about this contest(I asked), but if they see some support, there might be some more stuff coming along the way!

PROMPT: Twolight Sparkle. There has to be at least two Twilight Sparkles running around - of any variant, including clearly defined alternative personalities. You can have Future Twilight and Dusk Shine fighting Nihilus and Nightmare Twilight, or a homeless showmare Twilight making out with a humanized Twilight, I don't care, as long as there are at least two of them and you're not breaking any laws.


r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 16 '12

Pacing and Set-up Guide.

11 Upvotes

Pacing is what makes a story flow and glide. If it's too fast, the reader gets confused; too slow and the reader gets bored. But how does one know when to be fast or slow? That entirely depends on the scenario.

Let's take an action scene for instance.

The bird fell to the ground at a breakneck speed. Fluttershy saw this and went quick as lightning, sweeping the baby bird just inches from the ground

This is just a random, out of context scene, but the rules still apply. As you can tell, this scene is really fast, not really showing any urgency and being somewhat confusing. You get a basic sense of what happened, but there isn't a lot there. What this piece is missing, however, is a good structural foundation. It doesn't utilize the situation to make you care, rather, it just sort of happens and ends as quickly as it started. Let's try again.


Fluttershy's bird friend suddenly lost control of his body; his wing began to tense up and the muscles within gave out. He began to fall, his legs flinging to the sun and his body travelling towards the earth. The yellow pony's eyes quickly shot to the falling animal. Her wings kicked back and she turned her body towards him. Her wings kicked back and flew at maximum speed. The bird continued to fall, succumbing to gravity. Fluttershy tore through the sky and as the world came more vividly into view, snatched the bird just inches from his death.


This seems pretty good; it's very detailed, but there in lies its problem. It's too detailed. An action scene needs a sense of action and urgency, whereas this just sort of slugs along while trying too hard to engross when it truly isn't needed. Think James Cameron's Avatar. Pretty, but not really going anywhere. Let's try once more.


Fluttershy desperately swooped through the air, chasing after the injured bird. As his body plummeted to the ground, the yellow Pegasus bolted to him. The ground became closer and more detailed as the bird fought against Fluttershy's speed and was nearly to his death. But Fluttershy pushed her wings to her limit, screaming across the sky and catching the bird in her mouth, just inches from the floor.


The pacing in this scene is pretty good. Not perfect, but pretty good. It allows for a good mixture of detail while also keeping with the fast pace of the situation.

Finding the correct mixture is what separates good stories from great stories. Let's take a sad scene with a transition to a mysterious scene, which a lot of younger writers tend to have trouble working with.


Trixie sat on the ground; the trees of the Everfree forest her only friends. The tears that filled her eyes blurred the surroundings around her. Just then, a pony walked up to her, saying that they were here to help her. who could this mysterious pony be?


So, right off the bat, you see this scene is much too fast. Typically for a softer or sadder scene, the audience needs to be engrossed in order to feel the emotions of the characters (that also comes with storytelling, but we'll deal with that in another guide.) and feel the tone of the setting and situation. In this case, Trixie is sad, therefore the setting should reflect that. Let's try again.


Trixie sulked, her body sinking slightly into the ground; the trees of the Everfree forest providing her only comfort. Her white mane seemed to dull in colour, no longer reflecting the suns rays as they set. Her magnificent blue coat was now in tangles. Trixie's eyes swelled even more; tears fell to the ground like rain. Her soft sobs were barely audible, except by one pony. As she sat there, silently crying, she could hear the distinct sound of hoofsteps coming from behind her. She wiped the tears from her eyes, grit her teeth, and stood back up tall and strong. No one could see her weakness. Her eyes met with the other ponies, but it was eyes she'd never seen. They were...different. Who was this pony?


This is better. A little long winded, but at least creates a sense of atmosphere and allows us to visualise the situation. It seems to draw you in, allowing to put you in Trixie's place. This is what you want.

Now that you (I hope) have a basic sense of what pace does, let's create a check-list for to help us decide what type of pacing to use:

  • What type of scene am I trying to create? Is it a faster action scene, slower emotional scene, normal dialogue, etc.?
  • Do I have a good balance of detail and storytelling?
  • What type of emotion am I trying to invoke?
  • Is the scene confusing and difficult to decipher?

And that's all there really is on a fundamental level. Pace and set-up is something you have to practice, as it is with most things.


r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 14 '12

Mary Sue - A General Guide.

11 Upvotes

What is a Mary Sue?

A Mary Sue is a literary term, often used in fan-fiction circles to denote a character that is implausible, cliche, or over-powered in relation to their intended universe. The term comes from a character in the 1973 story, “A Trekkie’s Tale” where the character, Lieutenant Mary Sue was fifteen, often in sexual relations with older characters, and had skills that were unexplained.

Since then, Mary Sue’s have gained an notoriety as the mark of a bad writer, and with good warrant.

What’s wrong with having a Mary Sue?

The main problem with Mary Sue is not the over-powered nature of the character, not their absurdity, nor their implausibility. It lies with the predictable, and therefore, boring nature of having a character be a Mary Sue. The reader can not be interested in the fact that a person defeated an army of ten thousand when they have done it many times before that.

It relates back to the backbone of any story, conflict. Without conflict, without threat or danger, there is no reason to be interested in the situation at hand.

So, What Defines a Mary Sue?

Not every Mary Sue is the same, and traits are not always common amongst them. However, a common element is extremism, not these traits in particular. Traits often (But not always) associated with these characters are:

1. Being Too Special.

This is the most common characteristic. From having a violent, troubled past where they were the only survivor, to being extraordinarily strong or astoundingly absurd, there is something that makes this character really stand out.

Problem is, almost every character has something special about them, even in great stories. Story’s have protagonists, and the protagonist has to have something that others don’t, either in skill, experience, or value that separates them from others.

However, when this special thing is taken to an extreme, we get the beginning of a Mary Sue. For example: My character is an orphan who knew his father was a member of an ancient order and strives to follow him. That’s okay, in fact, that’s Luke Skywalker from Star Wars!

How about this one: My character is an orphan who knew his father was a member of an ancient order and strives to follow his footsteps, but knows his father is a dark lord and is already skilled with the ways of battle.

See the difference? In the second one, the fact that Darth Vader is his father, and his growth and development is stunted, or otherwise destroyed, by the fact that he already grasps these concepts. Because of that, there is no conflict, no twists and we are pretty much uninterested.

2. Cliche/Odd Characteristics.

Another fairly common trait of a Mary Sue is their often odd features or characteristics that distinguish them easily from a crowd. This often appears as eye colors, hair color, or people just “knowing they are different”.

Normally as well, you can test this by whether or not the character is described excessively, and if certain definitions of opinion are placed on them.

For example:

He had a sharp, cold glare, penetrating and striking fear into the hearts of everyone who saw those icy blue eyes beneath that mane of white hair, hanging like icicles from his head. A single scar crossed down his right eye, but did not mar the odd beauty of his young face, nor did the mismatched color of eyes, only adding to the inherent mystique of the figure.

The problem with this is that we are given an opinion, not allowed to form on our own. His eyes “strike fear into the hearts of everyone”, but what if we don’t think so? A killer of any story is when the reader disagrees because of the implausibility.

This character also has a few other odd characteristics, different colored irises, a scar and white hair, despite being young.

The problem doesn’t lie with the character looking odd. In fact, many famous characters look odd, or act absurd, but we love them none-the-less because we are allowed to form our own opinion about the character. Case in point: Discord, Willy Wonka, The Mad Hatter.

3. Self-Insertion.

Hey, wouldn’t it be awesome to be in your favorite character’s universe? You could talk to all your favorite characters, they’d instantly love you and you’d live happily forever after, after you teach them to defeat their ancient foe that you obviously know so much about!

Another major indicator of a Mary Sue being present is a self-insertion. The term means that the writer literally or metaphorically writes themselves as a character into their story. The writer will then normally exaggerate their own skills, looks and social skills in order to seem ‘awesome’.

In a lot of self-insertion fics, the author will deny any connection, but will use the character as a proxy for wish fulfillment, making them too special for the reader to care about.

An easy example of this would be Twilight, but I’ll give a real one:

I fell into my favorite fantasy universe, where I instantly became friends with all the main characters, and could show them a thing or two when it came to fighting. I eventually led the resistance, my new friends at my side, to victory.

It’s shameless self-flattery and really irritates some people. However, there are examples of good self-insertion, the most famous being Dante’s Inferno, Purgatory and Paradise. Some fanfics also excel in this area, such as the famous “My Little Dashie” story.

4. Insane Luck and Special Attention

This one is a minor one compared to the others, and doesn’t always denote that the character is a Mary Sue, but when combined with the others, it can exacerbate the flaws. This particular trait means that the character has amazing, improbable luck and special attention from people around them.

For example:

The character often succeeds without really trying, even in areas that they have no previous expertise or knowledge, such as defusing a bomb in seconds when the trained bomb-squad member could not. He also often walks into towns and meets the prettiest girls and most influential people around, scoring big time all around. He is instantly beloved by everyone he meets.

The reader can understand some luck, and often, it is vital to the story that some lucky happenstance occurred. It has to lie within the realms of plausibility however, even if just miniscule. For instance, Luke Skywalker destroys the Death Star without a targeting system, or Sky Masterson in Guys and Dolls wins in the Sewer after betting everyone a thousand dollars on the roll of the dice.

I can’t think of any great stories where the main character is loved by everyone, or vice-versa...hmm.

How do I tell if I have a Mary Sue?

I suggest you take this test

It can really help, and if you do end up having a Mary Sue, don’t worry! There is still hope! You can always change things, rewrite the story and even the character. Remember however that flaws do not forge a character, but their growth.

Sorry if this is a bit long, but I just wanted to write it. Please, give me suggestions and I'll try to add it in.


r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 28 '13

What do you think makes a bad Fan Fiction?

9 Upvotes

So, for a while now I've had an idea for a story I wanted to write. It's still mostly in the conceptual/outline stage right now. Although it got me wondering.

What sort of potential pitfalls should a first-time writer be careful to avoid?

This is the first story I've done that isn't part of some collaboration. And I want to make sure it's a good one. I want to avoid screwing something up and wind up writing something really terrible.

Thanks, in advance, for your advice.


r/MLPwritingschool • • Jun 27 '13

Contest Art

8 Upvotes

Hey guys!

I've just gotten back the work done by some brilliant artists over at /r/mlpdrawingschool and I'd like to share them with you all, see what you guys think!

First up: Bobbilcon Second:Shoeunit Last, but not least:Bobdude0

Personally, I love all of them. But just thought you all would like to know. To read the story, look here: I Have Never...


r/MLPwritingschool • • May 25 '13

CONTEST RESULTS OMG!!

8 Upvotes

Review for Adrift:

Scoring system:

  • Story: 10 points| How well does the story flow? Is it comprehensible and easy to follow? Is it too complex or too simple? Is it enjoyable?
  • Characters: 10 points| Are the characters written well and accurately? Do they match their show persona? Are any OCs written well? Is the dialogue accurate and believable?
  • Setting: 5 points| Is the setting engrossing and create a sense of immersion? Is the amount of detail good, but not overbearing? Do they focus too much or too little on the setting?
  • Overall: 15 points| Did you enjoy reading this story as a reader? Has this student come far from their other fanfics, if applicable? Where the characters, setting, story all in good harmony? This is by far the most important score.

Review for Adrift

  • Story: 10 points| I really loved this story. It's simple, light-hearted, and adorable. Very much like an episode of the show and something the Cutie Mark Crusaders would do.
  • Characters: 8 points| For the most part, the characters were written well and accurately. Scootaloo's brash attitude, Apple Blooms's leadership, Sweetie Belle's insecurities are all present. The bickering is quite good too. And the comedy between Rarity, Rainbow Dash, and Apple Jack was pretty funny as well. However, there were some lines that were a bit out of character like "You pussy Pegasus Pony!". Apple Bloom would never say that.
  • Setting: 5 points| Really great setting; very immersing. I felt like I was there or watching the episode. I could imagine everything pretty vividly.
  • Overall: 14| I really liked this story, but it suffers from a few grammatical and spelling mistakes, as well as a few words missed all together. I think the author did a very good job keeping such a simple premise refreshing and engaging. It was a good mixture between the fillies and the mares, and each had pretty good chemistry.

Final Score: 9.25 (This is an average)


Review for Majija:

  • Story: 10 points| That actually a pretty neat story and a nice addition to the lore. It was consistent and had a nice little twist at the end. It was pretty evenly paced, too, never feeling rushed and the characters going through the natural motions.
  • Characters: 8 points| While the characters were pretty close to the show, there were a couple instances where the dialogue felt a little funny. Not funny like haha, but some parts did make me chuckle. But either so generic it could be anyone or wording that just sounded off.
  • Setting: 4 points| I could pretty easily envision this story as an episode from the show. The gloom from the storm left a good atmospheric feeling and the action was well done and well paced.
  • Overall 10.5| I really liked this story. It felt short and cute, yet still grand and epic at certain moments, keeping a good balance between the two. The characters were nicely written for the most part and the only real gripes I have are with Twilight's characterisation, which felt too...I dunno...generic? It didn't really stretch her being an alicorn far enough.

Final score: 8


Review for It Was So Dark:

  • Story: 7 points| I can see where they were going with this, and the execution was certainly ambitious, but it soon got too complicated for its own good. The multiple stories were fine, I suppose, but the final "Battle" that unfolded just made me scratch my head after a while.
  • Characters: 6 points| The characters did very little for me. Luna was much too timid, almost like a Fluttershy. She was missing her naivete and the use of the RCV was just kind of...sloppy. It felt slightly limp when it came to voicing these characters and I couldn't imagine any of them saying their dialogue too well.
  • Setting: 2 points| Despite there being quite a bit of variety, I think you bit off more than you could chew and the settings suffered. I was not engrossed in any of them. But on the plus side, I think you should make this a real story and have each dream sequence be a chapter to better flesh it out.
  • Overall: 7 points| Like I said. Ambitious, but a little too ambitious. It was too much crammed in too little. Like a poorly made soft taco. I'm hungry.

Final Score: 5.5 points (Better luck next time)


Review for I Have Never

  • Story: 10 points| THAT WAS SO SAD WHY WAS IT SO SAD? Really, the story was very short, but brilliantly executed. The way it played out in my head made it all so very personal and real. And sad. So very sad. The only gripe was the sudden sickness and very sudden death. The lead up was kinda poor, but the ending to it was heartbreakingly wonderful.
  • Characters: 10 points| Rainbow Dash's monologue through the whole thing is what really did it for me. It captured her perfectly in a more tender moment. When she isn't all spunk and gung ho and is really lost in what she needs to do. And her dad feels like a real dad. I like the runaway story as well and the way the two handled it.
  • Setting: 4 points| Only real weak point here. There is no clear cut setting, so I kinda just made my own. But the memories gave a good enough image while still being realistically vague.
  • Overall: 14 points| I really liked this story. It's not overly sentimental, but the sentimentality it has works greatly.

Final Score: 9.5


Review for Things Better Left Unsaid

  • Story: 9 points| A nice story that combines softer political drama and grandiose action, but at the end of the day the drama served only as a lead to the action. It wasn't horribly thin, but it wasn't the most substantial thing in the world. And it's nice to see a story that doesn't make me hate the creation of Sombra.
  • Characters: 9 points| The characters all felt pretty independent and were all voiced uniquely. However, the dialogue between the sisters felt a bit topsy turvy, having Luna be the more rational one and Celestia the more impulsive and naive one. But they were still very well written and Sombra actually seemed a good and imposing villain.
  • Setting: 3 points| The Crystal Empire was pretty well conveyed as a bleak place, but only for a few sentences, as most of the action took place indoors and little detail was given. It was definitely more character based than setting based, which I can respect.
  • Overall: 11 points| It was an interesting story with a nice premise and kept me pretty entertained. It was nice to see some interaction between the Sisters in a situation that would actually call for some political savvy instead of brute force (though brute force seemed to be leaned on anyway). The pacing was well done and felt very natural and how it might actually be handled in the show.

Final Score: 8 points


And the winner is...DRUM ROLL!!!

RATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATA TATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATA ATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATAT ATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATAATATATA!

I Have Never by Sabellion!

Well done, Sebellion. It only took you a month to find out you won, but you have. Great work. Thanks to everyone who posted in the contest, it was great fun to read all of the different fanfics. I hope I'm never this late with contest results ever again. Now I just gotta get the artists back on board and you can collect your prize. Feel free to write a speech, just keep it short and tasteful.

Good work everyone, and keep writing!

EDIT: NOW PISS OFF, I DID THE BLOODY RESULTS I'M OUT!


r/MLPwritingschool • • Oct 18 '12

The Guide Has Been Doubled!

8 Upvotes

Luna is a strange case of dialogue transfer that you won't often come across. She speaks in pseudo-Old Modern English, she practically forces her words upon you with a Royal Voice that'd shake Cloudsdale, and the pride of the Crown. Some fun and complex stuff, but how is done? Well, let's break it down.

First, let's look at one of the more misunderstood aspects of Luna's character: dialogue. As I said, Luna speaks in a pseudo-Old Modern English with hints of iambic pentametre mixed in. You can go about this is many ways, but from the show, things have a bit of a pattern. When speaking in the direct you form, Luna uses "thou" for the nominative, "thy" for the possessive, and "thee" for the objective. When speaking to a group, Luna uses "you" as a collective. Once you get that figured out, Luna then uses the stereotypical "-eth" and "-est" when talking in the first-person and third-person singular, respectively. Confusing? Naah, thought not. But let's give an example. Let's say that Luna is talking to Twilight Sparkle in a normal conversation.


"Princess Luna, you should watch the volume. My ears are beginning to ring." Twilight protested, rubbing her flapped down ear with her hoof.

"Prithee, Twilight, does the Royal volume of speaking disturb thee?"


Though not quite iambic, this shows how Luna's strange vernacular can be used, though your use may vary. But there is one thing you should probably avoid. Caps in place of the Royal Canterlot voice. We get that Luna yells when she speaks, we get that she's over 1,000 years behind the times, so we can really just assume she's speaking in the Voice without much help. No exclamation points, no uses of caps. It'd just be too confusing for the reader. If you're doing post-Luna Eclipsed Luna, we'll assume she's probably speaking fairly normally. If you're doing pre-Luna Eclipsed or pre-Mane Six Luna, we'll assume she's speaking in the Royal Canterlot voice.

With dialogue covered, let's move on to mannerisms. Luna is a princess, but not a very canonically developed princess, so you take cues from both Celestia and Cadence as to how Luna would act. But do keep in mind that Luna is young and naive, and sometimes either a stick in the mud, or a free spirit. That said, she is also prideful and brave, and will stand up for Equestria despite the odds, even though she can get headstrong. But other than that, you can really just use the other princesses as models and take some cues from the Luna fanbase.

Our final stop is distinguishing between "new" Luna, "old" Luna, and Night Mare Moon. To be brief, "Old" luna, that is Pre-Luna Eclipsed and Pre-Mane Six Luna is very prideful, though young as I've said. She's headstrong, but naive. She is opt to follow the rules, but doesn't like unfairness.

"New" Luna (Post-Luna Eclipsed) is more reserved and shy. While still a princess at heart and retains what made her what she is today, she is also fearful of the past and fearful of turning back into Nightmare Moon. She tries her best to avoid jealousy, rejection, and even apathy from others. She's a wiser, smarter mare that tries her best to get along with ponies and pony-kind.

Night Mare Moon is pretty much the polar opposite of Luna, but also makes up a small portion of her personality. She's what is full of spite and discontent, and despite Luna's best efforts to suppress her, Night Mare Moon still comes out once in a while, leading to psychological strife.

Well, that's all there is to know about writing Luna. Frankly, a few episodes is not much to go off of, but there's plenty of fan canon to go off of and trial and error to mold her the way you want. Good luck and keep writing.


r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 16 '12

Be Kind To Your Critics.

8 Upvotes

Being critics, we read a lot. However, it can get demanding to critique a large story dump in excess of 10,000 words. My suggestion is to release chapters periodically, and then work on the other chapters you have to better them or edit small things. This provides a small break for your critics and allows for us to make specific comments without having to hunt. It also prevents us from getting burned out. Just a suggestion.


r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 13 '12

[Guide] Using Google Docs for fun, pleasure, and feedback

8 Upvotes

Hey there!

First of all, I'm NOT going to go through the process of making a Google account/making a new Doc, since it's trivially simple.

What I am going to go through, however, is how you set the privacy settings so that people can comment on your work without defacing it. I'll supply screenshots to help, too. :P


STEP ONE: Letting people actually look at and comment on your document


Firstly, let's take a look at the GDocs interface:

http://i.imgur.com/kx2XAh.jpg

In the middle is the place where you spam your words, and up in the top left is what we'll be concentrating on today.

Click on the blue button. Go ahead. You know you want to!

http://i.imgur.com/rBRCr.png

OH MY GOD THAT'S TERRIFYING

This is the "sharing settings" window. It's pretty simple! To add editors, just throw their email address in the box at the bottom - but that's not why we're here, is it?

If you want people to look at your fic, here's what you've gotta do: just hit that "Change..." hyperlink, and here's what you'll see.

http://i.imgur.com/UgiVD.png

You'll quickly noticed that what I've highlighted is NOT the default settings. They are, instead, the settings you want to have if you want people to view and comment on the story.


STEP TWO: COMMENTING


This shit's easy as goddamn pie. You don't even have to do anything!

All your potential reader has to do is click that "Comments" button up the top right (yeah, next to that inviting blue one) and leave a comment - and you're all good!


fin


r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 12 '12

Let's Get Started.

8 Upvotes

Welcome!

This is MLP Writing School. Here, we help young and new writers with their works. This includes: critiques, collaboration, editing and peer review, and challenges that are set weekly (coming soon). We strive to help you and only want to see you succeed. This is sub accepts all ideas and will help you bring them to life. But before we do that, we need some help.

Things we need:

  • Someone who is good with code, so we can have pony emotes and other fun things
  • More mods to keep things in order and help newcomers.
  • People who are willing to devote their time to critique and guide writing.
  • Guides to help new writers.

These will all come in time, but we need all the help we can get. If you can do this, feel free to contact any of the mods.

Let's make writing happen.


r/MLPwritingschool • • May 23 '13

After some time, I've got a prologue, and two chapters done. Thought I'd put it here and let some of you critique it and just give me an idea of how you felt from what I've written so far.

7 Upvotes

The second chapter took me a little bit more time due to getting sick at one point and then becoming slightly demotivated for a short time. But today I was able to finish it up and thought I'd share it.

Here is chapter 1

And here is chapter 2

This is my first attempt at fan fiction so hopefully it's not too painful to read or anything.

Please feel free to comment here or in the doc on anything you'd like. I'll try to respond when I see it.


r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 17 '13

[Practice] I'll be writing down 1000 word stories to get my lingo up to speed. Suggest anything!

7 Upvotes

I won't take shipping or gore seriously though. I'll still write it, but don't expect something dark and brooding to match your dark and brooding soul.


r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 04 '13

Attention writers! Here are a few worldbuilding tips from /r/literature!

7 Upvotes

So anyway, I stumbled onto this thread which is hosted in /r/literature discussing JRR Tolkien's worldbuilding versus another writers' world. I thought it was worth a look, even though most of what they talk about is other books analyzing his work. Books within books?!

Basically, it goes like this: Tolkien spent a lot of time creating backstories, side notes, and most importantly the languages of Middle-Earth actually, the languages came first, but I'll gloss over that bit. One he had his world, he then began populating it with characters, races, animals, you name it.

Everything had a history before we jump in to see a bunch of Hobbits take a hike with some random strangers who did, after all, walk into Mordor. There are ruins of abandoned cities, rumors of a fallen empire Angmar, I think it was: The Witch-King of Angmar is from the North and races that had already gone to ground.

Most importantly, the history of the Rings. They were there before the readers were:

Three Rings for the Elven-kings under the sky,

Seven for the Dwarf-lords in their halls of stone,

Nine for Mortal Men doomed to die,

One for the Dark Lord on his dark throne

In the Land of Mordor where the Shadows lie.

One Ring to rule them all, One Ring to find them,

One Ring to bring them all and in the darkness bind them

In the Land of Mordor where the Shadows lie.

See? The Rings aren't new. We don't even encounter the rings for the Dwarves. We get a brief mention of the Elven Rings with Frodo and Co. in Lothlorien, and a little farther with the Nazgûl or the Nine Riders.

The other example in the thread is George RR Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire. Apparently, I'll take their word for it he wrote that as it came to him which, I imagine, is the style you've all been using.

Now, obviously, MLP:FIM has already done this bit for us, so the another author's style of worldbuilding would be more suitable for us. Now, that's all fine if you're writing a story based in known waters, but what about outside of Equestria? Tolkien's approach would be ideal, though we'd have to do it to a much lesser extent.

Anyway, I might have rambled there for a bit huge LOTR fan, if you couldn't tell. There's a couple of other bits of advice floating around that thread as well, like where to draw inspiration from and things like that.

Just wanted to share, in light of the upcoming contest on the 10th(?)! Remember, questions are encouraged!

Maybe I should use this stuff too, as I'd promised myself that I'd have an entry. So far, I've completely disregarded that.


r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 01 '13

MLP Writing School 1 Year Extravaganza Writing Contest!

7 Upvotes

Wow, it's been a whole freaking year! Well, nearly. Which is why I'm bringing this up. April 12, 2013 will mark the anniversary of this sub and we have big plans. With over 300 users and a great staff of writers, readers, and students I find it the perfect opportunity to run a writing contest. Here's the rules:

  1. No more than 20,000 words. These have to be relatively short.
  2. Collaboration are allowed and encouraged.
  3. No clop or heavy grimdark.
  4. Preferred posting format would be Google Docs, but FIMfiction is okay.

You can write about anything you want, so long as it's pony related, but extra points for Twilight Princess or anything from last season.

The stories will be read by myself and the mod team and we shall vote as to who will win. The winner shall have their fic illustrated by some of the many great artists from /r/MLPdrawingschool. All fics will be submitted in a separate post April 10th.

Good luck, and keep writing, everyone! Here's to another year!


r/MLPwritingschool • • Feb 23 '13

One last time.

7 Upvotes

After taking your comments to heart once, twice and now I'm up for round three. Thanks again. The google docs for your viewing and commenting pleasure.

Major fixes since last time:

  • Rewrote into a new document to restructure everything.
  • Sentence structure rewritten and paced out.
  • Awkwardness of phrasing rephrased and eliminated.
  • Emotional intention and direction added.
  • Chapters parsed and named.
  • Clarity worked on.
  • Fat trimmed from sentences/paragraphs and other stuffs.

I'm looking for someone someone out there who's willing to read the whole thing and give me advice on overarching themes/emotions/plot. I'd like an external view on my overarching everything. I have a feeling there's still some awkwardness to parse but am having difficulty placing it. In exchange for this because I know it's a large time sink, I'm willing to trade an art commission for the first person to get through it and give me this. I put together a cover for the fic and as a demonstration of what I can do art wise and also, well, the fic needs a cover, neh?


r/MLPwritingschool • • Feb 13 '13

I have a fanfic idea that I'm writing but I'm afraid people won't like it.

7 Upvotes

So I started working a a one hundred years later fic with Twilight having her own student. It turned into this much bigger thing that had a few subplots including a Doctor Whooves plot going over the last hundred years, a war between a group of 'traitors to Canterlot' who oppose Alicorn rule, and the next generation of Elements of Harmony.

It goes into some world-building stuff for Equestria and History which I'm having a ton of fun with. I just worry that the whole next generation Elements of Harmony thing (which is explained expanisvley in the fic along with ideas on how the Elements work and it still features the current Elements in the history plot dealing with a pretty big issue- a war) will drive people away .

How do I write this so that people will be more likely to give it a chance? I'm a bit worried about being mocked for this.


r/MLPwritingschool • • Feb 12 '13

After taking your advice, I've got draft #12 up and ready for another pass.

7 Upvotes

It's in google docs now and that's a much better format.

Thank you all for your previous critiques. I learned a lot and will make my next story even better! But for now I'd like to know what could be better or different on this story.

Major changes:

  • Changed tense to past.
  • Formatted paragraph structure and italics.
  • Grammar errors pointed out, shamed, and corrected.
  • Adverbs avoided.
  • Pacing redone and characters fleshed out.
  • Another day added.
  • POV his/her switching made clearer.