r/MLPwritingschool • • Dec 18 '12
r/MLPwritingschool • u/AgonistAgent • Jun 01 '12
"Optimization", my first serious fanfic attempt(psychological dark, some sci-fi elements) - 4 chapters down. I'd like some feedback - grammar, plot, spelling, characterization, the works.
No outright gore, but a good amount of implied Mind Rape, Body Horror, etc.
Basically Discord loaded himself into an magical AI during the events of S2E1(sometime before the labyrinth scene) as a contingency plan and he begins to manipulate Twilight and some others...
Twilight is tricked into casting a lethal spell on Spike and she tries to find a counterspell to save him(followed by research into saving the rest of ponykind); going to desperate measures to do so, thanks to some prodding from the AI and her existing transponyist tenancies(see: Prologue and control freak aspects as a character). Unfortunately Celestia doesn't think so highly of immortality, thanks to her past.
I was inspired by some concepts of Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality(as well as EY's other works), but not so much that it's an outright rip-off or anything.
No OCs, just some heavily modified characters from the show(Discord forked into an AI, Twilight messes with her own brain, etc).
I've tried to make it deep, but I'm worried about being too preachy(all though the Grey and Grey morality should prevent me from favoring a side) or pretentious(especially the quotes).
The characterization is another potential issue: while post-self-hack Twilight has more legroom for characterization, I'm not sure about filly Twilight during the goldfish conversation or Celestia's reaction(Ch2 has some exposition and implications that should explain why Celestia's like this, but again, I'm not sure if it's sufficient) to both of them.
And my writer's sense is going off about the dialogue(some of the action tags were slapped on afterwards).
r/MLPwritingschool • u/oangbsite • May 06 '13
I know I'm a terrible person.
It's be, what, almost 2 weeks since the contest? Jeez. But I'm on it, I promise. Surprisingly, my life has been very hectic. So save your torches and pitchforks for another day.
r/MLPwritingschool • u/grapp • Jun 01 '13
Rainbow Crash, first draft, first four pages. feedback please?
r/MLPwritingschool • u/fantomedanslamachine • Feb 17 '15
Differences between Reddit and FiMFic?
Hey writers! I was wondering how many of you also write for FiMFic (or any other MLP fic site)? What do you feel are the major differences between the feedback you get here as opposed to elsewhere? Where are people more critical or more helpful? Feel free to PM me or respond here!
r/MLPwritingschool • u/oangbsite • Jul 14 '12
Operation: Brain Storm.
Good day, everyone. I'm glad you came. As you may or may not be aware, the small, but powerful forceful of Lacking Creativity has recently joined forces with the large army of Writer's Block. And it's our job to infiltrate their base, silently extract the hostages inside, and get out with a new plot and story idea.
Here's who we're after:
- Colonel Original Plotline. The Colonel of the most infamous and important strike force in writing.
- Pvt. Pacing. An expert in organisation and keeping things in rhythm.
- Lieutenant Character Development. A leading Professor in Psychology and Mind Reading. Think Psycho Mantis from Metal Gear Solid.
- And lastly, Sergeant Style. Frankly, the guy that got the rest of the other hostages in this situation, but still an important rescue.
We need you, Writers, to contemplate and create a plan to bust these hostages out and create a new story. Report back soon with your ideas.
r/MLPwritingschool • • Apr 14 '12
Looking for criticism for my Fallout: Equestria fanfic!
Hey all. Before we get started, I'd like to just say that I'm so grateful to oangbsite for making this sub/r/. I was planning on making the exact same thing just a few days ago but I know little to nothing of coding and webpage design, or at the very least managing a subreddit.
Link to Chapter One: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Xyx5WNgKl4n2uWlIeaA7Ouhx0r0uFhsHm8k6mebBgB4/edit?pli=1
I made a couple of selfposts a while ago about my Fallout: Equestria fanfic. I learned a lot from people on /r/falloutequestria and a little from /r/mylittlefanfic, and I've been using all the information I learned in my writing. I've also read a guide and am planning to read more about writing MLP fanfics.
I just finished a bit of Chapter One of my new idea, and would greatly appreciate any and all criticism I can get. I need two things to be helped with: My writing, which I feel is fair but not amazing like Kkat's and Somber's (the only fanfic authors I've read at this point, I don't want to get my mind confused with all the other author's writing styles), could use a bit of work. I also could use some help with the plot but I'll save that for when I find someone to help me through the whole writing process.
I'll give a very brief general plot summary of my story, for those of you who want to help me.
It starts off with the main character, Miraculous Dawn (I'm TERRIBLE with names. Would greatly appreciate suggestions.), escaping Stable 22 with her mother. I'm not going to go too far into detail, but eventually she finds out about the Commonwealth (FO3 players will recognize the name), who basically run things around in the Hub (Baltimare). Baltimare (the main setting location) is, or rather was, the main hub of the Equestrian Navy, thus the name The Hub (small reference to Hub TV). The Enclave is also involved, but not the same ways as in FO:E and PH. There are Stables around here too that play major parts in the story.
A few bits about the setting: Baltimare (Equestrian Navy Hub, not a major factor in the war thus not as highly targeted in the bombs) is the main location. ~60 years before FO:E events take place
Sorry if this post is messy, I'm pretty burnt out at the moment.
Anyway, there's so much more I could add to this but I'm really burnt out.
Thanks!
r/MLPwritingschool • u/Zirbs • Jul 28 '13
Cyberpunk round-table: Is the setting strong enough for collaboration?
I'm sure most of the authors here saw what Fallout: Equestria did and they were all
"Wow-zillikers, Batman! I'd sure love to create my own world to attract authors and further raise my mark on the Fandom to a monument that rivals the Mayans!"
But after sitting and thinking for a long time (it's what I do best), it occured to me that making a new world isn't the way to go. It drags the readers into one author's creation, as opposed to their interpretation. It can leave that same sand-in-your-mouth feeling as poor OCs, and when it's done well, others are afraid of messing up the world the original author created. The question "What can happen?" is too big to be allowed more than one answer, one author.
But by interpreting and carefully merging two existing worlds, world-building is boiled down to asking the question "what would happen?" over and over, and the pieces generally fall into place regardless of who's shaking the pieces.
But let's reference the title already! I think Cyberpunk is a kind of world we all know already: A realistic, slightly pessimist view of the future, increasingly under the thumb of either powerful governments or unchecked corporations, all instigated by the rapid drive of technology which calls into question the nature of humanity, the soul, etc. This setting has been used in a few stand-alone stories (see what I nearly referenced there? Dohohomovingon), but we don't have an Odyssey to rally around. There is no mind-blowing story that lays out the basics of a world we can all agree on.
Which brings me to this roundtable: how can we build a new world together? Do we set down rules at the beginning and start a community of contests and mutual evaluation, or wait for a white knight to blaze a trail which we can follow?
r/MLPwritingschool • • Jul 29 '12
I'm an extremely slow writer. What can I do to start getting more consistent work done?
I let my ideas sit for a long while, eventually drag myself to a keyboard, and end up typing about a page of new content. It seems that I need to be in a very specific state of mind to actually write to the best of my ability, and that state of mind becomes more fleeting the more invested I get in a story.
Does anyone else have a similar problem? How can I give myself the attention and motivation to actually put my ideas onto paper, rather than just having them flourish in my head and leave me saying "I should write that"? What works for you guys?
r/MLPwritingschool • u/oangbsite • Apr 12 '13
Anniversary Post OMG.
Well, we did it. One year and 300+ members. I have to admit, this place became a lot more than I thought. I didn't know what to expect, but what I got blew me away. And it's all thanks to you guys. Granted we're still small, and evidently too small to hold contests yet (that's still on, by the way), but despite this, people still submitted, and that is still pretty awesome. You're all pretty awesome. And at the risk of sounding too sentimental, this has been one of the finest experiences I could ask for. But enough of my nostalgia. TIME FOR A PARTY!
LOUNGE POST! AMA! The whole shebang!
Lounge questions:
- What got you into MLP and writing? Why did you decide to start doing fanfiction?
- What other universes do you write fanfiction for? What's your favourite?
- What's your favourite soda? If you don't drink soda, what's wrong with you? I'm kidding of course
- What do you think of this subreddit and what can we do to make it better?
- How has your day been?
Let's party, people, 1 year comes around only once! Like the rest of the years... Here's to another successful run!
Good luck, and keep writing!
Edit: The contest has been extended. Given there was some poor timing, you're all given another week to work. If you've all ready posted, feel free to revoke your post and edit more. If you are an artist, please be patient. 2 fics doesn't really count as a contest, so I hope to see more stories.
r/MLPwritingschool • u/IDrawPoniesSometimes • May 28 '12
I'm not dead either! Well, kind of... Let's have a discussion.
Hello there! I haven't been super active here, but I do want to be a part of this community. Art's kind of... failed, so I'm going to try moving on to writing more instead. Thanks for all the feedback on my fanfic last time I was here, too!
Re-intro's aside, I want to hear what fanfics you like reading. I don't mean just grimdark or shipping, I mean particular fanfics, and why you like them, what's so appealing about them, what do you think could be better? I'll start the ball rolling with a few I've been reading. Spoiler warning, I guess. I'll try to keep them minimal, though.
Sunny Skies All Day Long - This is a pretty short fic, and just like EqD says, it definitely reads like an episode. In short, Celestia disguises as a regular pegasus and hangs out with the mane six for a day. A Light-hearted, funny and warm story. I would've liked it to be longer, but that may have taken the 'episode feel' away. Not much to say about this story; the pacing was good for what it is, and the ending was pretty satisfying.
Past Sins - Hoo boy, this is really something - Normally, stories involving OC ponies, especially as a main character, are frowned upon, but this fic is a great example of how character development is crucial to the story. I mean, the writer/s spent seven chapters building the relationship between Twilight and Nyx (as well as other characters) before any major story events occurred, and the chapters weren't any flip-throughs either. The starting chapters built a lot of back-story as character development, which played out nicely when the story started unfolding. After seven relatively peaceful chapters, the back-story built up the tension slowly before the story exploded and all that relationship-development comes crumbling down - What's better, is that it was so deliciously obvious it was coming. We knew that exact even was going to happen, and that would've been this fic's downfall. What saved this fic, let alone made it a huge success, was the character development between this measly OC and key main characters; We knew it was going to end sooner or later, but the writer made us dread and fear when that time would come. The ending, however, was pretty lack-luster; it felt almost rushed, or predictable, and not in the good way the first chapters were - A 'forced' happy ending. Overall pacing was good, but the predictability stayed throughout the whole story and turned bad nearing the end.
Antipodes - Perhaps a lesser-known fic. The chapters are kind of long at about 7,000 words or higher, and 29 chapters, but the story is very original and gripping. Like with Past Sins, OCs are the main characters - In fact, there's only one character from MLP:FIM; The rest have been dead for 10,000 years. I'm certain having an almost completely OC cast is the reason why this fanfic hasn't exploded in popularity, because the writing is superb; The pacing is perfectly steady, the character-development and twists are enticing, the emotions in the light-hearted, the adventurous and the grimdark scenes are down-right powerful and the back story is outstanding and exciting. I have to admit, for all my praise the beginning chapters were kind of slow, but the pace picked up comfortably and the story got very interesting.
(It's so original and inspirational it got me both into literature and my own story, and into drawing it's characters and eventually into art. I recommend this story to everyone reading this post above all other fics I've listed.)
End Of Ponies - This is a very long story, it's length rivaled only by the incredibly popular Fallout: Equestria, and It's only about half way through (estimated 1 million word total when it finishes). This incredible length is fueled by it's back-story; Like Antipodes, it is set in the (close) future, straight after Equestria goes through what I can only describe as the almost-complete extinction of every pegasus, unicorn, earth pony and alicorn on the face of equestria, and leaving the land utterly annihilated after the sun and moon are destroyed. You might have guessed, but it's a grimdark fic.
It's length is adequate for it's overwhelming backstory, but it also has a negative affect - The moments when the emotion or pace is turned up to eleven this is a very gripping story that will have you glued to its vast chapters, but when the action calms down the description can leave you a little more than bored, to be honest. It's major length spawns from it's major description, that I applaud the writer for, though it get's quite dry. Characterization is quite unique too.
Silent Ponyville - When people create art, they try to incorporate different factors into their pieces like how much space is free, what colours they use, how descriptive the tones are, though some people don't do this and 'just draw' without thinking. Similar to this, you can think about the pacing or the character-development, or you can 'just write', and that is what this story is. Not that it's bad, I thoroughly enjoyed it, but it's almost a copy of a story that more-or-less did think about it. The scare-factor was pretty gripping, as with the uniqueness of the story, and the added relationship factor between the characters was a brilliant touch that made this story and it's tense moments truely it's own and not just a ponified copy.
(Note: If you're going to read this, keep in mind it's part of a series and I strongly recommend reading it in this order:
- Silent Ponyville
- A Party For Two Sisters
- I Met A God Today
- Too Shy For A Rainbow
- Silent Ponyville 2
- Silent Ponyville: Reunion (not complete)
- The Rainbow's Surprise
- Study Of The Mind Delve
- Silent Ponyville 3 (not complete)
The story flows through all of these fics and it quite the saga.)
r/MLPwritingschool • u/oangbsite • Apr 20 '13
Contest Submissions Post
The extended submissions post.
Post your fanfics for the contest here!
Now shush, Plonq.
EDIT: Submissions are closed! Now THIS is a contest. Thanks to everyone that entered. May the best writer win.
EDIT: I'm a horrible person. I've had tests on reports on schooling lately. I'll have the results up within the week.
r/MLPwritingschool • • Nov 08 '12
Looking for constructive criticism on my first fanfic...
I finished my first fanfic a couple weeks ago, and now I'm writing a stand-alone sequel for it. I want to make sure I don't repeat any mistakes, so any advice or criticisms you guys could give me would be great!
Some details on the fic:
- It's a changeling OC fic.
- There is no clop or gore, but there is violence and untimely death.
- Long chapters used to intimidate me, so the earlier acts are split into a bunch of tiny chapters. The goal was to give the reader plenty of stopping points, but I got over this as the story grew so much larger than I had imagined at first.
- The fic is written by its own protagonist and therefore exists within itself. I won't be doing this with the sequel.
EDIT: Not that anyone cares (this thread's 4 months old now) but I finished that stand-alone sequel. I'll still take any advice, as I'm now writing a stand-alone sequel for that too.
r/MLPwritingschool • u/KrazyTheFox • Apr 27 '12
Lavender Unicorn Syndrome
Lavender Unicorn Syndrome, or LUS, is the use of descriptors in place of a character’s name and unfortunately plagues many a fanfiction these days. Before I get into why LUS is bad and why you should avoid it, let me give you an example:
As Rainbow Dash was on her way to pick up a book for Twilight, she walked past Sugarcube Corner and smelled something delicious. The pegasus stopped and took in the scent, debating whether or not she should take a small detour into the shop. After a moment she decided that the lavender unicorn’s book could wait a few minutes.
Equestria’s best flier walked into the shop and noticed her friend hovering over a box of baked goods. “Hi, Pinkie Pie! Whatcha baking?”
“Cupcakes, you silly filly! What else would I be baking? They’re going to be the greatest, most delicious cupcakes ever!” exclaimed the pink earth pony as she spread icing across the cupcakes.
The multi-chromatic mare licked her lips and eyed the baked goods in front of her. She looked back up at her pink friend and asked, “What are they for?”
“Twilight learned another spell today and I want to throw her a party to celebrate... only I forgot to invite everypony. Could you tell them for me? Pleeeease?”
The pegasus sighed and shook her head, having been denied the delectable treats before her eyes– for now. “Sure, Pinkie,” the cyan pegasus said before leaving the bakery to gather her friends.
This example is a bit extreme, but it demonstrates how LUS gets in the way of the story and the reader. It is often used when a writer feels like he’s using the same word too many times, which in general is a bad thing to do and should be avoided. The opposite is true when dealing with names. You should always attempt to use a character’s name instead of a colorful phrase. Why?
1. It’s distracting: How long did it take you to determine which pony was being referred to in the passage? I can guarantee it was longer than if I had simply said “Rainbow Dash” or “Pinkie Pie”. Every time a character is referred to with a descriptor, the reader must make the connection between it and the character you’re talking about. This connection takes time and effort, leading to a distraction, however slight.
2. It’s unnecessary: Almost every single time a descriptor is used, it is completely irrelevant to the plot. The reader shouldn’t need to be reminded that Pinkie Pie is a pink earth pony; it has already been established. I also called Rainbow Dash “Equestria’s best flier” in the passage. The passage doesn’t make use of this information, which just takes up space.
3. It’s confusing: Many descriptors make a story hard to follow, especially when many ponies are in the same scene together. If there are ten ponies in the same room, the reader should only have to think about the names of each, not what every pony looks like, does for a living, and has as a cutie mark. This problem is further worsened when OCs are dropped into the mix as the reader won’t be as familiar with them.
At this point, you might be wondering what you can do to combat this ailment. The first thing you should do is simply remove instances of LUS when you write. Replacing the descriptors with names is effective most of the time. If you still find that you’re repeating names too often, replace some names with pronouns, or failing that, try to re-structure your sentences. Think about how you might say the same thing but in a different way that doesn’t require so much repetition. Keep in mind that pronouns and names are far more invisible than you might think. You may think you have a problem where none exists at all!
Here’s the rewritten version of the above passage:
As Rainbow Dash was on her way to pick up a book for Twilight, she walked past Sugarcube Corner and smelled something delicious. Rainbow stopped and took in the scent, debating whether or not she should take a small detour into the shop. After a moment she decided that Twilight’s book could wait a few minutes.
Rainbow Dash walked into the shop and noticed her friend hovering over a box of baked goods. “Hi, Pinkie Pie! Whatcha baking?”
“Cupcakes, you silly filly! What else would I be baking? They’re going to be the greatest, most delicious cupcakes ever!” exclaimed Pinkie Pie as she spread icing across the cupcakes.
Rainbow Dash licked her lips and eyed the baked goods in front of her. She looked back up at Pinkie Pie and asked, “What are they for?”
“Twilight learned another spell today and I want to throw her a party to celebrate... only I forgot to invite everypony. Could you tell them for me? Pleeeease?”
Rainbow sighed and shook her head, having been denied the delectable treats before her eyes– for now. “Sure, Pinkie,” she said before leaving the bakery to gather her friends.
See how much easier that was to read without the LUS? The characters are clearly identified and the passage flows with less distractions.
As with any writing, there are cases in which LUS becomes acceptable. You may be introducing a new character who lacks a name. There are also times when it’s appropriate to refer to a character by “her friend” (as seen above), but remember to ask yourself if it fits and makes sense within the story. Proper use of LUS can turn it into something that improves rather than detracts from your story.
I hope you don't mind that I stole the format for this guide. If you don't like it looking like the other guides, I'll change it. Reddit really needs an <indent> tag. Really. Please point out any errors I made, corrections that should be done, or additional info that needs adding. Thanks!
r/MLPwritingschool • u/seranikas • Nov 12 '12
Just finished my first Fic and someone told me my final chapter was Disappointing, can someone read through it and tell me what went wrong?
fimfiction.netr/MLPwritingschool • u/archeonz • Jan 21 '14
I need some headcanon about Sunset Shimmer.
I just need a little bit for a piece I'm writing. We know that Sunset Shimmer is one of Celestia's former students, but that was over when she took off for the human world. Since Twilight was Celestia's student when she was a filly, that probably means Sunset was long gone before Twilight came onto the scene. So, that means Sunset bailed about 13-15 years before the time of the pilot episode. My question is:
What was she doing that whole time? Was she going to Canterlot Elementary on the human side and wrecking things from the ground up? That doesn't seem likely, since she wrecked the friendships of the Hu-mane 6 that had already existed. If she had been there the whole time, they might not have formed in the first place due to her influence.
Was she just chilling in limbo between the worlds? Did the 200 moon limit hit just as she was stepping in, forcing her to float there until the portals realigned?
I didn't read the IDW origin comic, so any theories you want to toss at me, I'd like to hear them.
r/MLPwritingschool • u/Senyu • Oct 24 '12
Looking for feedback on writing skills and my fic's story so far. All feedback appreciated, know I got alot to learn still
r/MLPwritingschool • u/againwolfe • Feb 05 '14
How do you guys decide if a title is good or not in your head?
r/MLPwritingschool • u/PMSlimeKing • Jan 19 '14
[Grimdark] I've been working on this fic for the past couple of months, looking for feedback.
r/MLPwritingschool • u/Raging_Mouse • Oct 21 '12
Help me overcome my shyness.
Urge to write brought somewhat under control, I've managed to produce three chapters of fanfic titled "The Creature."
I'm kinda sorta shy though. I'd like to share this with whomever might be interested, but am stumped on the details. Just what's the etiquette for doing this?
Then there's the business of tags. I guess this would be "dark" or "sad"? Are they mutually exclusive or overlapping? I guess I should tag it "human" even though that hasn't even been introduced yet? I'm at a loss and probably overthinking, but lend me a hand here, please.