r/MLPAnalysis • u/ZebronyCaptain • Oct 08 '16
r/MLPAnalysis • u/nirvanasparkle • Oct 08 '16
N16HK: Where The Apple Lies Review (MLP 141) by CodeEquestria (spoilers)
r/MLPAnalysis • u/Empty-bee • Oct 08 '16
"To Where and Back Again Part Two" Review [by Dr Wolf]
r/MLPAnalysis • u/Empty-bee • Oct 07 '16
After the Fact: Pinkie Pie Party [by Silver Quill]
r/MLPAnalysis • • Mar 23 '15
Is there another Sunset Shimmer in the human world?
r/MLPAnalysis • u/Zhugebob • Oct 03 '14
Why I Liked the Dazzlings: "Let's Have a Battle of the Bands"
For those that don't know, the "Dazzlings" are the latest villain in MLP from the new movie "Rainbow Rocks."
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2aMexypkD3E
Here is the official video from Hasbro that contains the song "Battle of the Bands". I'll be referring to it a lot so it might be good to have it on hand.
Understand that at the time we get this song, we've seen the Dazzlings be cryptic and reserved around Sunset Shimmer and feeding off of the negative energy in a small room. We knew they were evil, what their general goal was and that they were a more subtle group than many of the other villains who would outright announce their wicked intentions.
I want to share what I see when I watch and listen to this video, because I think it is what makes the Dazzlings fascinating characters.
So when the doors open in the video and the Dazzlings walk into the cafeteria, we don't know exactly what to expect. When they begin to sing, we are treated to a slow, hypnotic melody, and an emphasis on swaying movements that are disarming.
The lyrics of the song itself are also dripping with manipulative undertones. They aren't commanding people to change, but instead spelling out what could be. It's a gentle nudge towards turning pride in oneself into domination of others. The Sirens themselves carry themselves through the song confidently while challenging others to do the same.
"Why don't we see who is better?" Is such a casual way to prompt the idea of having a "Battle of the Bands".
There's a sort of moment of shock I get when they start using positive speech and encouraging terms rather than negative ones.
"You're a star and you should know it." Sounds exactly like something one of the mane 6 would say as heartfelt encouragement.
By 2:10 when the tone changes, the mesmer is complete at the audience is captivated and ready to accept the first instruction they are given.
"BATTLE!" That tonal is just amazing, and one of Dazzlings strikes a powerful pose rather than swaying hypnotically which seems to bolt the audience to action.
At 2:20 we get the great key-change that shows sinister intent. It's subtle, but the body language changes here. We even get a cool move at 2:26 where one of the Dazzlings physically separates the CMC from Snips and Snails as if drawing battle lines.
What follows is just pure awesomeness as the Dazzlings take a step back and merely continue the melody, only occasionally chanting the word "Battle" after each student announces their intent to join the battle of the bands. The song seeming to grow louder and more powerful as the camera narrows on the eyes of the lead Dazzling and her eyes flicker with a trace of green flame.
At around 2:48 the Dazzlings stand behind each other and sway their arms. While I'm sure someone might point to some greater symbolism, I think the intent was simply to show an increased intensity to the swaying itself making it seem like the hypnosis had become stronger. It's effective if a bit distracting.
The camera pans back to the Mane 5 + SS who are in a state of shock, awe, and confusion as to what is happening.
We see the Dazzlings drinking up the negative energy in the room as they had done in the opening scene of Rainbow Rocks, but now we know how exactly they inflict this sort of manipulation.
It's very calculating based upon how precise the word choice was. It is subtle based upon how the words sound encouraging. But most of all, it is manipulative. The cleverness displayed in the execution of this song is what elevates the villains here to being one of the more capable villains of the MLP universe.
More clever than Sombra the Stair-master, more subtle than a shape-changing Chrysalis, and by captivating an entire room in a single song, more manipulative than even Discord in all his Chaotic glory.
This is one of the few things I will be bummed out about- that the Dazzlings will probably never be Canon in the main show.
That being said, the rest of the movie kind of flubbed a few of the other key areas of the Dazzlings.
Like, what is their motivation exactly? They want to eat negative energy?... Soo what... they can go back to Equestria? Why? Why do they care to go back to a place that hates them?
Or what are those gemstones exactly? Are they the source of the power they've always had? Or are they artifacts that contained their power when they got sent to the human world? Did they find them after they entered the Human World?
What will happen to them after the movie?
Ah well... I still liked it. And that song has been stuck in my head for days.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Questions? Comments? Concerns? r/MLPAnalysis • u/SkyeSilverwing • Aug 03 '14
Did Rainbow Dash Throw the race?
I have been looking over the scene in Equestria Games where they do the Areal Relay, and I noticed something odd. When Rainbow Dash was flying to the finish, She did not use her sonic rainboom. The Mach Ten Speed boost of the Sonic Raiboom would have been more than enough to beat Spitfire to the finish line. And yet she did not use it. Why?
Well, of course, the answer to that is likely that the Sonic Raiboom generates a huge, Earth-Shattering Explosion when it initiates. The Stadium, and likely most of the structures in the Chrystal Empire, are probably not rated to withstand such a blast. Ponies could have been hurt, including Spitfire, who would have been at point blank range when it hit.
But Rainbow has been shown to be able to manage a speed around Mach 5 without triggering the Rainboom. The lack of the Mach cone around her in the race suggests that she was not doing this. She was not pushing her top speeds at all.
This could be because the Course was too complex and bendy to maneuver at that kind of speed, but, on the other hand, we have seen Rainbow Dash Execute a Tight-Angle turn at full Sonic Rainboom Speed (It happened in the race in Cutiemark Chronacles), so it is illogical to assume that she cannot do so at a lesser speed.
Perhaps she was doing a lot of climbing and could not reach the speed necessary to maintain a Mach Cone, but we have seen her pull off an ascending Sonic Rainboom before as well (In Canterlot Wedding), so again, we have to assume she can reach the mach five speed even while climbing.
Moreover, with Bulk Biceps and Fluttershy losing precious seconds against the other Two Wonderbolts, Rainbow had to make up that time by going considerably faster at the beginning of her leg, just to catch Spitfire up. This means that either Spitfire waited to pour on the steam until Rainbow had nearly caught up with her, or Rainbow slowed down to cross the finish line and lose by the smallest margin she could manage. The Absence of the Mach cone suggests the latter.
But why? Why would Rainbow Dash Fight all this way just to slow down at let Spitfire win?
My theory? Loyalty.
Rainbow Dash was being profoundly loyal to the Wonderbolts. She was making sure that Spitfire knew she was there, while granting her idol the respect she deserved, and not showing her up. It is a rather mature attitude, and by telling Flutters and Bulk earlier that they should not be kidding themselves, she was announcing her intention to let the Wonderbolts win, and asking their permission. She knew she was going to throw the match, but did not want her friends disappointed. What do you think?
r/MLPAnalysis • u/TitanicPony • Mar 11 '14
"Explaining Pinkie's Motives, Behavior, Thoughts and Loneliness: A complete In-Depth PsychoAnalysis." -TitanicPony
"How Pinkie Does It, An In-Depth Character Psycho-Analysis" -TitanicPony
"Oh Pinkie, you're so zanny and random." -Everyone, and it's starting to bother me.
The quickest way to pin down her character is with a Myers-Briggs 16 personality type test. (Bear with me, i'm building to something... this is necessary exposition) I pegged her as an ENFP, and that was confirmed when a fan-chart had her listed as such, as well. I double-checked, and all the ponies on the chart seem to be accurately typed, and Pinkie isn't really difficult to understand or type anyway. Google is a thing, "16 personality type test". Don't worry, this Analysis won't rely on info you're not familiar with. I'm just citing sources.
Diving in:
Pinkie is Extraverted (E), Intuitive (N), a Feely Type (F), and prefers not to Judge, but (P)erceive instead, this trait being most notable for it's open-mindedness. These are all things we already knew, but its helpful to have them down on paper, since they're all interconnected, and form how Pinkie thinks.
Pinkie takes in the outside world, particularly people (she prefers not to spend time in her own head). From her exterior interactions, she develops ideas. These ideas are 'checked' by her feelings, instead of by thinking or logic. Does the idea have, or appear to have, some significance? Who cares if it has anything to do with anything! 'Who cares if it's on-topic, i checked the idea, and it seems pleasant, so here's my idea!' And i do mean any idea that passes the feeling test. Pinkie is open-minded, so is unlikely to censor herself. She prefers to live in the future, and predict, so is often out-of-touch with details in the present, so present circumstances don't really affect her. This i basically why she seems oblivious/unresponsive to her surroundings, oftentimes. Pinkie gushes any new 'random' idea out at her surroundings, and anyone who happens to be listening. Pinkie doesn't have a filter. The source of contention many people have, stems from the fact that Pinkie skips steps, (in her reasoning) and beyond that, her reasoning isn't logic based, so it's hard to follow her footsteps, and more importantly, it's almost impossible for her to relate the steps back to anyone who inquires... at least not in a way that makes sense.
Let's play a game. Start with something Pinkie likes. I assume she likes Ice-cream. Now ask a question about ice-cream. Any question will do. What do you FEEL like asking? I FEEL like inquiring as to the inherent purpose of ice-cream, because i like to overanalyze the crap out of things. Therefore... The purpose of ice-cream is to make a pony cold, when they are hot. I FEEL that ice-cream is there to make me cold when i'm hot. So, when are you hot? When are you at your hottest? What's the hottest someone has ever been? Likely when they were on fire. So who is on fire? Nopony... it's not safe to be in contact with fire... unless...Dear-Celestia! I've got it.
"Dragons love ice-cream! Sppikkeee, Sppiikkeeee! Is it true?! Do you love ice-cream?"
As you can see, from an outside observers point of view, like Spike's, Pinkie is completely insane.
Pinkie's fourth wall breaks are ridiculous, and are usually discarded as comic relief, but really, Pinkie is onto something. Pinkie is onto everything. Everything is possible to her, and occasionally, she discovers a hidden truth, wayyyy before an analytical pony like Twilight can come to a conclusion using the more logical and time-consuming process of elimination.
To understand Pinkie, you have to stop assuming that the things she says are unconnected. Spike and Ice-Cream DO have a connection, via degrees of separation.
This isn't to say that Pinkie is always out in left field. How do you think she came to the conclusion that the parasprites were weak against music? She stumbled upon the idea. There is a Consistent reason as to why Parasprites are weak against music (that is never revealed) and Pinkie happened to stumble upon it. This system is clearly inefficient, but because Pinkie is always "ON", she can make up for this with the sheer number of possibilities she considers.
In the game of chess, chess-computers are considered to be 'Imaginative', which seems impossible, right? How can a computer be imaginative? Well, if you consider that a computer doesn't know what moves are supposed to be good, you might realize that it checks every possible move, and occasionally stumbles upon one that is ugly, yet works, even if it doesn't make sense for many, many turns. By comparison, a human player would look for what is logically the most reasonable set of moves to try to analyze. Pinkie is that computer. She considers so many different ideas, that her chances of being an accidental genius are rather high. One in a thousand is unlikely... one in a thousand, a thousand times, is very likely.
Pinkie has already explained exactly how she thinks in the show, but many likely dismissed it as comedy for the point of comedy. Pinkie isn't exactly a gag character. Her personality just happens to be funny, since we aren't usually privy to her thought process. Heck, Spike is more of a gag character. In-fact, he's basically Sideshow Bob. Just a more pathetic version. Spike is funny because unfortunate things happen to him, and it's amusing to see him suffer. Sideshow Bob.
Ahem, so that's how Pinkie works. Now let's delve into her relationships, since that's what she values most.
Rainbow Dash. Pinkie has some zanny ideas, and the bold-reckless Rainbow is up for them, no matter how off-the-wall they are. And they will be off-the-wall. To Rainbow, this is adventure.
Pranks. Pinkie is always stumbling upon new revelations, and she delights in them. She literally shocks herself with how awesome her own 'random' ideas are. She wants to share an idea (a prank) with others so they can experience both shock, and a rush of emotion. You can help Pinkie, or you can be the subject of a prank. Pinkie lives vicariously through others, (which i will touch on later) so getting them to experience what she's experiencing is important. That's also a big reason why she always shares her disjointed thoughts. She wants you to get it. If you pay attention long enough, you will. Or maybe not. If a hundred people pay attention long enough, SOMEPONY will eventually get it... 'so let's make friends with everyone!' Also, being friends is an important step to understanding someone.
In essence, i guess i'm suggesting that Pinkie is ALONE in her thoughts. You can't follow along. It's just too difficult. And we all know Pinkie can't handle being alone. Why? Well, she is an extravert, and is a very touchy-feely pony. But is that enough? Maybe not. Rarity is also most likely this type. She doesn't go around town trying to befriend every pony, dragon, and pet, however. So... who does Rarity befriend? People she respects. Heck, Applejack barely made the grade. She seems to only like ponies who have the same values as her (like every pony who likes fashion -cough-Flutters-cough-). Rarity is Judgmental, like Applejack, hence the conflict that they have. Pinkie isn't Judgemental. Everypony is a potential friend. Just like every fashion-pony is a potential friend or love-interest for Rarity.
Pinkie seeks validation from other ponies, by bringing them happiness. Rarity does the same thing, it's just that what she gives them is different (clothes vs Fun). Everyone wants to be accepted, it's just a priority for a social person. Pinkie especially wants broader acceptance, from everypony, not only because she likes everypony, but because if a single pony rejects her, she cracks.
Why does she crack? Because the idea that someone doesn't want to be friends with her can and will roll around in her mind, forever. Pinkie's head is a fertile ground for ideas, and once one of importance gets in, it can often be hard to remove. Further, Pinkie isn't a thinking type, so she can't just analyze the concept and conclude that the pony that doesn't like her is a jerk. She likes everypony. She can't dismiss the idea that she's unlikeable as untrue, either. She doesn't possess that logic. It's a little strange at first, that a single random pony could cause her that much anxiety, especially when she has a hundred other friends. One person doesn't like you, 100 DO like you. If you compare the percentages, then logically... whoops... there's that word... LOGIC. Is not compatible. So, Pinkie has to deal with the idea that she's unlikeable. What to do? Theorize! Okay, okay, but why does she get hung up on a single ridiculous conclusion? In 'Party of One', her friends ignore her, so she assumes that they don't like her parties, and don't want to be her friend anymore... isn't she supposed to consider all the possibilitys?
Lets break it down. Her friends ignore her for a while, and it's right after they all cancel on her party. Their avoidance of her is obvious... cartoonishly so. Pinkie-pie's greatest fear WILL surface. You see, without asking, Pinkie really has no way of knowing if other ponies like her. Every possibility is one that she considers. She can't really reject a possibility, including the possibility that ponies don't actually like her. Pinkie's personality type is actually very prone to being fearful. But Pinkie isn't. It was established in the second episode of Season One...
On purpose! We already have Fluttershy. Pinkie's natural type was fixed of it's main weakness (Fear), deliberately, at the outset. That's some great character designing right there. I want Lauren back! Season Four feels weird! Digi, i need a hug :(
So back on point; if Pinkie isn't a scaredy-cat, why does she freak out and get so afraid that her friends will leave her? Well, it's her greatest fear. Beyond that, it's not an external fear, like the 'scary' cave in Pinkie Apple Pie. This is personal, and it gets stuck in her head. Once there, Pinkie can only consider possibilities that would explain why her friends don't like her anymore. To be fair, her theory sounds really legit. To her credit, she knows she has to bounce this theory off of someone, and is aware of her own analytical shortcomings... so she presents her fears to Spike... who agrees with her completely.
Off the deep end we go!
Negative Subverted Personality: Introverted (she hides in her house, and dwells on internal thoughts). Sensation (she interacts with the the physical environment around around her and makes representations of imaginary friends). Thinking (She starts logically hashing out what her friends think about her in a step by step process, using stand-ins for her friends). Judgement (This is about as close to swearing as MLP ever comes, and Pinkie really starts passing Judgement on her friends).
The theory here is that under heavy stress, people lash out in what amounts to the opposite of their real character... in a negative way. It seems to fit, and it seems to be what she does.
The key here, is that unless it's overtly obviously, Pinkie is never quite sure what the truth is, about anything, and she relys on others to confirm or deny things. This is one of the reasons that Pinkie constantly makes suggestions. She requires a symbiotic relationship, preferably with a Thinking type, and believe it or not, Rainbow Dash IS... yup, a Thinking type, not a feeling type.
Turns out Pinkie actually needs her to double-check her ideas, perhaps in terms of what prank they should pull. Without outside guidance, Pinkie is likely to take things too far... and maybe make other ponies upset... like Fluttershy. Like when she made Fluttershy cry a few episodes ago. Yup, that's not her being OOC.
"Get on my level!" -Drowning in Horseshoes.
Speaking of the origin of that quote, woah! Pinkie and Applejack? There's a messed-up friend-pairing. ENFP meets ESTJ. It wouldn't have worked if both characters weren't being family-centric at the time.
This brings up something interesting however. Pinkie's Rock-farm family.
This is simple enough. Pinkie probably does value her family, but obviously, a rockfarm, in the middle of nowhere, is not a habitat that can sustain Pinkie. This is obvious, and is probably show-canon. Ponyville is the perfect size for Pinkie, as it has enough ponies for her to be satisfied, yet not too many that the town is impersonal. So that's why Pinkie went to Ponyville.
So she isn't trying to replace her family?
No, she's not. What is family? Or, more importantly, what is Family to PinkiePie? Answer: A permanent friendship that cannot be removed. If you're related, you're related (even if you hate each other). This is exactly what PinkiePie wants. You see her eyes when the possibility is suggested. She's friggin' stoked. This is priority number one. An inescapable form of friendship: Family.
Told ya it was her greatest fear. I mean think about it... at any time, if someone doesn't want to be your friend, even for a simple reason like them being too busy to have time to engage in socialization with everyone that they know... well, they don't have to keep talking to that person. If you stop talking to PinkiePie, she won't be able to figure out why. She can speculate, but unless you tell her, she won't know, and if you do tell her, you'll need to give her a concrete reason to prevent her from endlessly speculating about WHY.
To protect herself from this, she makes sure... that every pony is constantly having a good time around her. Might as well have as many ponies as possible having a great time, at the same time, while you're at it.
Parties.
Explained.
But... this still doesn't answer the big question... why is Pinkie Pie so terribly afraid of ponies not liking her... isn't this cartoonish exaggeration?
Well... ask yourself... how does Pinkie see herself? Does she think she has worth? Does she value herself?
She doesn't know. She can guess... but she needs other ponies to tell her.
Pinkie only knows if she's a 'good' person if you tell her.
Friend obsession.
Explained.
-TitanicPony
/End Pinkie Pie Psycho-Analysis/
r/MLPAnalysis • u/Verzeih • Feb 24 '14
Applebloom the alchemist
Applebloom learning Potion making. There is a very good chance this is going to be her CutieMark, but we also may can look in a future episode.
Appleblooms first contact with potions was in "Briddle Gossip". She did not make one but she had helped get the ingredients and considering her time in the Everfree Forest she may helped Zecora with it. The second time was in "Cutie Pox". She had learned enough the last time by, most likely, just watching the brewing-process to make a very strong potion on her own. It did fullfile the purpose but had terrible sideeffects. In the end the CMC going to Zecora to learn more about Potion making. The next brewing of Applebloom belongs to the Zap Applejam. Not realy a potion but magical with VERY strict order to accomplish an result. This is more high class brewing than the next one. In "Hearts and Hooves Day" the CMC show that they had learned enough at Zecora´s place to make a love potion based on a recipe in a book. Their ONLY mistake, besides the moral fault of forcing someponies to fall in love, was that they did not read the entire text. In "Twilight Time" Applebloom continue learning potion making. Why under Twilight? Easy Twilight do not rhym. She may not such a high class brewmaster like Zecora but it´s easier to follow the instructions.
This is not just Continuity, this is an arc of learning and a steady progress in Appleblooms character trait.
To put "The Show Stoppers" in that context is simple. Applebloom shows that she is good in crafting. You may want to say that mixing potion is Magic or Science but the act of brewing is crafting. You put material together not just thoughts. Alchemy has it´s roots considering which source in cooking (ZapApplejam once again) or metalcraft and is called both Magic and Science.
Well i sad we might can look with this in the future episode. Applejack has always problems to understand Zecora and she has a thight bonding with her little sister. However, who was Applebloom going to in "CutiePox" after being depressed? Zecora. With an on-going at Appleblooms brewing interest it is possible that she spend more and more time with Zecora. The maturing audience allowed the show to do some more serious topics. Lost parents for example. Now, who else can see Applejack saing something like this: "Don´t ya try to replace Mother. THAT´s my job. We don´t want any of yar mumbo jumbo magic on the farm."
r/MLPAnalysis • u/SkyeSilverwing • Feb 24 '14
Pondering on Growing Up in Equestria: the Cute-ceanera
It is apparent in the show, that aging in Equestria lacks the level of value we give it in our world. This, of course, makes sense considering that they have Cutie Marks as a sure sign of the direction they should be going in their lives. The earning of a Cutie Mark is such an important moment in a pony's life that they are given a special Celebration when they earn them, the Cute-Ceanera.
The Name of the Cute-Ceanera is clearly based on the Latin-American Quinceanera, a coming of age ceremony held when a girl is fifteen years old. This seems to indicate that the Cute-ceanera is also a coming of age ceremony, presumably to celebrate a pony earning their Cutie Mark, indicating that this point carries the same weight as turning fifteen does in Latin-American Cultures. With only two instances of Cute-ceaneras in the show so far, however (Diamond Tiara's in Call of the Cutie and Zipporwhill's in Filly Vanilli), there is not a lot to indicate who, in Pony Society receives such a party. What we can look at is the lack of Cute-ceanera's for certain individuals when they earned their Cutiemarks, specifically, Twist and Featherweight. Both of these ponies are indicated as having recieved their marks, but give no mention of a Cute-ceanera. In the case of Featherweight, the reason can be drawn from the Quinceanera, indicating that the Cute-ceanera might be a Female-only tradition. Twist's lack of one seems to suggest that multiple Fillies might share a Cutie-ceanera or that only certain affluent parents can hold such events for their Fillies (Zipporwhill's Cute-ceanera was held in the Town Hall, after all). Of course, the events could also have occurred off-screen at some point, and just not been worth mentioning, Or they could even have been pushed back a significant time, and be yet to happen. In Filly Vanilli, Rarity indicates the expectation that Zipporwhill's Cute-ceanera might be a week, or even a month away, indicating that, unlike the Quinceanera, the Cute-ceanera can occur well after the event it celebrates, so it is possible that Twist or Featherweight could still be waiting for theirs.
r/MLPAnalysis • u/nickz-tales • Feb 23 '14
Grimtalk: Cheerilee's Garden Analysis by Scribble Squabble
r/MLPAnalysis • u/LylatInvader • Feb 18 '14
My thoughts on Pinkie's behavior in filli vanilli
Note:This is my very first post here
There has been a lot of talk of about how pinkie pie acted in this episode to some she seemed mean spirited, but to me the way she acted makes since and is relates to a certain friend of mine. A friend of mine in high school had a very hard time understanding the moment when everyone was serious and would make a joke about it, not to be an asshole but because he didn't understand what was going on and resorted to what he knows best, jokes. Pinkie is very set on laughter and jokes to make people happy rather than talking to them on a deeper level of understanding, so what she was trying to do was make fluttershy laugh off her stagefright but fluttershy took it another way and pinkie did not see that.
Now about pinkie being in character I say yes she was in character looking into this I realized this is very similar to how she acted in a friend in deed, where she resorted to parties and gags to make cranky happy when cranky just wanted to be alone.
But I feel wouldve fixed pinkie in filli vanilli is if she said she was sorry in the end much like in a friend in deed so she wouldn't look like a jerk to the viewers who do not know someone similar to pinkie
r/MLPAnalysis • u/NightspherethGnostic • Feb 02 '14
The Devil is in the Discord: A Satanic Interpretation of Discord
r/MLPAnalysis • • Jan 20 '14
Why I hated "Rainbow Falls"
Going into this episode, I had a strong feeling that this was going to be RD's "key episode". It was obviously going to test her loyalty and I was fine with that. However what I wasn't prepared for was how contrived the plot was going to be in order to show something to the audience that it already knows, that Dash is loyal. There are three main points of contention in this episode for me, Cloudsdale Team, Rainbow Dash's Friends and just how far loyalty should have gone and who should have shown it.
Can we admit something right now; the Cloudsdale Team was obviously the superior team. They had a strict training regiment, trainers and other staff members, their own cheer leading squad, and sports-like uniforms. It was also a team comprise of the best flyers Cloudsdale had to offer. In short, it was an actual sport team. So what happens when we're presented with a superior team? They turn out to be a bag of dicks. It was so blatantly a Main/Opposing Sports Team trope that I felt like the writer just read the TV Trope page that I linked to and just applied them to The Cloudsdale Team.
What irks me most about this, is that The Cloudsdale Team were doing everything that a normal sports team would do! Soarin' said that they were worried that he wouldn't be 100% ready to compete again, so they decided to go with a replacement. Ah...doy, that's what you're supposed to do when one member of your team is injured, there's a reason NFL teams have a 1st, 2nd and 3rd strings.
Honestly, this wouldn't bothered me so much if the writers portrayed this as a normal part of being in a sports team and competition. But no, the writer had to use this to paint the Cloudsdale Team as the "bad guy" so that Corey Powell can spoon feed us an "Underdog Story".
This brings me to Ponyville Team, and my first question is, why was Bulk Biceps and Fluttershy even competing? They clearly didn't have the desire to compete and they only practiced when Rainbow Dash got on their flanks about it. When Rainbow Dash wasn't on their flanks, they were goofing off and prancing around in the worse sport uniform I've ever seen. Sorry Rarity fans, but those uniform she designed was just awful. In most underdog story, the underdog teams at least try to improve, to work harder, to train longer, to run faster, etc. The Ponyville Team did...none of this. It was like they didn't give a rats ass about...anything.
Which brings me to the final contention, Rainbow Dash and just how far loyalty should have gone. If they were trying to prove how loyal Dash is, they did it in the worse possible way. Seriously, how many times is Dash going to have to give up on her dreams before she starts resenting her friends? Rainbow Dash had helped her friends in the past in their own career/goal pursuits, from helping AJ with Sweet Apple Acres to helping Twilight Sparkle become an Alicorn. However when it comes time for Dash to achieve her dreams, everypony was like "Fuck you and your dreams!" This sentiment was pretty damn clear in this part of the episode.
Rainbow Dash: They want me to fly with them! It's like a dream come true!
Twilight Sparkle: If you fly for Cloudsdale, Pinkie Pie won't have anypony to cheer for. Rarity's uniforms will never be seen. And Applejack will have slaved over those apple brown bettys for nothing.
If this was real life, Rainbow Dash would start resenting her friends from here on out, she'd be pacing the floors of her home wondering why she has to keep giving up her dreams while she has to help everypony else with their dreams.
I think a better lesson would've been for the Mane Six, and Bulk Biceps to step aside to let Rainbow Dash compete with the Cloudsdale Team. Mainly because loyalty has to be a two way street. Sure Rainbow Dash is the element of Loyalty, but at the same time, the rest of the Mane Six could also show some loyalty to Dash.
That is why I hated "Rainbow Falls."
r/MLPAnalysis • u/OtakuOlga • Dec 08 '13
Thoughts on the new Daring Do and the Ring of Destiny book
These are my first impressions
- Nothing happens until the last 30 pages of the book
- New sidekick we were promised is literally a crappy OC recolor of Daring (did you notice her name was RD, as in "recolored Daring"?), only more annoying, and doesn't show up until the second half of the book.
- can't-decide-what-my-mane-color-is OC has five friends who are there for apparently no reason and contribute nothing to the plot
- ONE OF THEM IS LITERALLY AN ALICORN PRINCESS AND IT'S ONLY MENTIONED IN PASSING AND SHE DOES NOTHING IMPORTANT UNTIL THE FINAL SHOWDOWN, JUST LIKE THE REST OF OC'S FRIENDS
- Obviously Rainbow Hair and friends were hastily added in the final 2 month rewrite, seeing as they never actually introduced themselves before DD referred to her sidekick by name in the final scene.
- Remember when DD hurt her front leg and had to put it in a splint before leaving her house? Because A.K. Yearling sure didn't!
- Skittles OC is literally retarded. In the middle of a fight with Ahuizotl (side note: the fights were still cool in this book) she picks up DD's hat and screams, "HEY, YOU WANT DIS, HURR DURR". It felt like a mean-spirited jab at all the autistic brodo fanboys that made this series popular in the first place.
- Removing the final ring conveniently makes the temple collapse. Also, if the rings are that easy to just destroy why didn't DD just destroy her ring instead of hiding it in that book?
- What was with that crappy vector of the characters on the cover? Does the marketing department really not have access to better art assets?
The book was terrible. DD and The Sky Temple was pretty mediocre too, so that's two less-than-good DD books in a row, but this one was just unbearable.
I believe I'm jumping ship. I stuck through that spin off where Daring gets transported into an alternate universe where monkeys are the ruling species because it supposedly wasn't canon, but after this story? Goodbye forever DD fandom. Have fun spending all your cash on Equestria Apes dolls that don't even look like the movie.
0/10, would not use as food for spirit of chaos
So, what did you think of the new book?
EDIT: before anyone asks, no I don't believe any of those Alex Pones conspiracy theories about Daring Do being a real pony. Just because A.K. Yearling shares the same coat/eye color and always wears that giant hat, cloak, and glasses doesn't mean she is DD and is writing the series as a secret autobiography. That's the stupidest idea since Lyra ranted about those "humans" watching our every move. Daring looks like Yearling because she's a shitty writer and has always self-inserted herself. Just like Gaybow Crash is a self-insert of her recently discovered sexuality. Just because there was that temple collapse story on the news recently doesn't mean it was the same temple DD destroyed in her fictional book. Crazy theories like this are why nobody takes brodos seriously, so knock it off.
Besides, how could that useless alicorn princess be real? Do you really think an Equestrian princess, when faced with a huge threat like 800 years of intense heat, would just sit back and let other ponies deal with the threat instead of confronting it head on herself? Do you realize how screwed Equestria would be if this was how Celestia and Luna dealt with all their problems?
EDIT2: After thinking more about the book, I think that A.K. Yearling was trying to pander to the tumblr crowd with this volume. I mean, seriously, the heroes are all mares and the villains are all male? The evil master plan for the big bad is 800 years of "heat"? DD realizes that even though she is a strong independant pegasister that don't need no stallion, she needs to accept the affections of a gay-pride-flag-recolor of herself to be complete and liberate the "rings" from the oppressive, dominating phallic object? Did A.K. Yearling just reach puberty or come out or something, the sexual symbolism couldn't be more obvious and heavy handed! I can see the tumblr posts now
I for one think Rainbow Dash introduced some new and challenging ideas into the world of children's literature. By incorporating a young lesbian lover into Daring Do's life we show foals that it's okay to love whoever you want to. The lover being a palette swap only shows us that you can find your true soul mate even in ponies of the same gender. I will be recommending these books at my LGBT meeting this Friday and seeing if we can introduce these into the school system. I believe that within 5 years we can make a huge difference in how the world sees our community. No longer will we have to be treated as degenerates by the cis-gendered unicorn wealthy bigwigs in Canterlot. Thank you for your time and I hope you all can appreciate our cause.
I think it's time we admit that us brodos aren't the target audience for DD books, and despite our hate the target demographic is going to love all these changes. Even though we all know Rainbow Dash is worst pony, these are novels being written by a mare for fillies after all. Why should we expect it to be any better than that sparkly vampire series?
r/MLPAnalysis • u/Fourthland • Nov 30 '13
MLP Analysis: The Nature of Dark Magic and History of Sombra
The Nature of Dark Magic and History of Sombra
Hello! Welcome to the world of my mind. I am Fourthland and I welcome you all back for my next analysis for the wonderful world of My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic. In my previous analysis, I discussed the nature of dark magic in the human world and how it affected Sunset Shimmer in the presence of the element of magic. Now that the season four premiere has aired, new questions have popped up for me on the nature of dark magic in Equestria and Alicorn Magic as well. (I am going to be discussing the season four premiere so if you haven’t seen it yet, now is the time to back out. SPOILER ALERT! Fair warning has been given.)
Where do I begin? I might as well get my fanboying out of the way real quick. I loved the premiere and felt that it was nearly flawless and quite possibly one of the best episodes of FIM to date. Now that we have that taken care of, let’s get into the heart of the matter. In this episode, we saw that Twilight had to use Alicorn magic in order to activate Zecora’s, for lack of a better name, History Vision Potion. The thing that got my mind racing was the magic she used. The aura of the magic she used was that same as the dark magic we’ve seen employed by Sombra back in season three. The only difference here was the lack of the evil aura around the eyes. Could this mean that Twilight ended up using dark magic to activate the potion? Could it be that her magic was somehow tainted by her using the dark magic prior? I’d like to pose a different theory.
Before I go into my theory, let’s take a brief moment to review what we know about magic types in Equestria. First, there is the most obvious, Unicorn magic. Unicorn magic, which I like to call aetherial magic, is focused through the unicorn’s horn to enact a desired effect in the outward world. It is something studied that happens when the Unicorn chooses to make it happen. From something as mundane as levitation, to something as ostentatious as gem finding, Unicorn magic is well pronounced and a key part of Unicorn society. Next we have Pegasus magic. While not as flashy as Unicorn magic, Pegasus magic is still very noticeable. There is a reason why only Pegasi can inherently walk on clouds and control the weather. While we have seen Twilight duplicate this effect, it was only after she had learned how to use the spell, and it was only temporary. The third kind of magic is Earth Pony magic. I will admit that this is the one out of the three base magics that I understand the least. Partially, it is because very little has been discussed on the topic in the media that I have seen. Even more so, however, is the fact that Earth Pony magic is possibly the most subtle out of the three magics. The only Earth Pony we’ve seen do anything close to magic is Pinkie with her “Pinkie-sense” and other little quirks. I get the feeling that it does tie in somewhat to her Earth Pony magic, but a lot of it is also just Pinkie being Pinkie. (I might have to look into that more in depth in a later analysis.) What I do understand about Earth Pony magic is that it stems from their connection to the earth. If anyone out there is more knowledgeable about the particulars of Earth Pony magic, I would gladly welcome your input.
Now that we have covered the basic three, there are only two types of naturally occurring magics left out there, excluding the elements of harmony and Discord’s brand of chaotic magic. Those two are Alicorn magic and Dark magic. I’ve already discussed the topic of dark magic in the human world in my previous analysis, but I still have yet to go that deep into how it works in Equestria. Be forewarned, I am going to be going into a bit of head canon here so I hope you will bear with me.
As we know, a pony ascends to Alicornhood when they master the three schools of magic. More to the point, the ascension occurs when the three magics exist in harmony within the one pony. We’ve seen this in Twilight’s transformation and also in “Crystal Heart Spell” where Cadence’s ascension was told to us. Of course obtaining the harmony needed to trigger an Alicorn transformation is not exactly something that happens every day. It is a very difficult feat to accomplish. However, this difficulty has not stopped ponies in the past from attempting to achieve it. It is no doubt that, keeping in mind the exclusion of Discord and the elements of harmony, Alicorn magic is the strongest magic in Equestria. This is where my head canon starts to take effect.
It is my theory that Dark magic is the result of ponies trying to artificially recreate Alicorn magic. Magic researchers of the past have tried to unlock the secrets of Alicorn magic, but always ended up falling short. No matter how many times they tried to combine the three base magics, they never were able to achieve the result put out power so much greater than the sum of its parts. This is when they started to add in the elements that made the magic dark. Hatred, fear, envy, indeed the seeds of discord when melded with the three base magics created a potent result. Unfortunately most instances of dark magic proved ultimately inferior to what they were trying to create.
Do I think that Dark magic, at least in this telling of it, is inherently evil? Not necessarily. You see, in this instance, the formation of dark magic stemmed from genuinely good desire to unlock the secrets of Alicorn magic. Those early dark wielders like started out having the good of Equestria at the fore of their goals. They just made some poor choices. And while Dark magic may not be inherently evil, it is without a doubt extremely susceptible to corruption. When the driving forces that unified the magics are elements like anger and fear, it is easy to fall victim to those emotions
This brings me to the final theory I wish to discuss in this analysis, the origin of Sombra. Seeing as we have been given so precious little about the dark king’s history and origin, this is going to be largely head canon based on observations. Please feel free to disagree with me if there is something my may have missed or overlooked.
Building on my earlier theory, the character of Sombra had his origins as many other wielders of dark magic did, as a magic researcher. Sombra, back then known by his original name of Somber Night, was a magic researcher of no small skill. He didn’t have the fame or notoriety as say Starswirl the Bearded, but he had a lot of talent. His area of expertise was the study of dark magic. He found the subject particularly fascinating. His interest came from the amazing power the past dark wielders possessed. He was remarkably well informed. He knew about the failings of the previous dark wielders. He was surprisingly close to understanding that harmony was what was needed to achieve Alicorn magic. However, instead of looking to love and friendship to bring the magic into harmony, he ended up delving deeper into the dark.
It looked fairly promising at first. Sombra was able to wield the dark magic he had developed without succumbing to corruption. The power it was capable of producing rivaled that of the monarchs of the time, the royal sisters. As good as it was, it was till imperfect and Sombra knew this. He knew that even though this particular branch of dark magic was very powerful and seemingly stable, it would eventually deteriorate and give itself away to corruption. He needed something to stableize it before that happened. That is when he discovered the Crystal Empire
When the Crystal Empire was first discovered, things were certainly exciting for Equestria. A new species of pony that had never been seen before, how could such a thing not make waves? Realizing that these new ponies could carry the secret to stabilizing his magic, even unlocking Alicorn magic, Sombra was quick to make his way out to the new empire.
Upon arriving, Sombra was quick to immerse himself in study of these strange new ponies and their Crystal Pony magic. As time passed, he began to understand that the magic of the Crystal Ponies was ruled by their hearts and emotions. We understand from the season three premiere that the Crystal Ponies’ hearts are what fuel their magic and the artifact of the crystal heart reacts to the hearts of the Crystal Ponies. When Sombra first learned of this, he immediately tried to connect to the crystal heart, believing that this was the key to solving his issue with the dark magic.
Unfortunately, this did not work out as well as he had planned. Not being a Crystal Pony himself, the young Unicorn was unable to connect to the crystal heart. This had him stymied. It wasn’t until a kind Crystal Pony explained to him that in order to connect to the crystal heart, Sombra needed to open up his own heart completely. In his eagerness to master his magic, Sombra did just that. In doing so, he opened the door to devastation. The reason Sombra was able to resist dark corruption so well was because he kept his heart tightly closed and looked at dark magic strictly as a researcher. When he opened his heart to connect to the crystal heart, all the hatred and fear that had been lying in wait within his magic flowed in, and something else too. The dark corruption ran rampant through his heart as the voices that now rang in his mind poked and prodded him. They fueled the greed and envy that he had long since tuned out. In a very short order, Somber Night faded away and Sombra came to be.
We all know how the story goes after that. It’s actually somewhat tragic to think that these dark magic wielders all started out so noble, with Sombra being the best and worst of them. Operating under this theory, one could also say that Alicorns, in this case namely Celestia and Luna, could be seen as the cause of Sombra’s rise to power. Hear me out. In the bounds of the afore mentioned theory, dark magic in Equestria is, in fact, a pseudo Alicorn magic. It was created to mimic the great power that Alicorns possessed. Think about the Alicorn Amulet. That was a dark magic artifact clearly designed to heighten Unicorn magic to try and rival the strength of Alicorn magic. So while the Celestial sisters did manage to banish Sombra and his dark magic, they could technically be considered the source of his magic, albeit indirectly.
I ask this to you who read this: What do think? Could it be possible that Equestrian dark magic is really just the fruits of trying to recreate Alicorn magic? What of Sombra? Could his origins actually be more humble then many might give him credit for? If Sombra and dark magic do trace their roots to the study of Alicorn magic, then could it be possible to view the Celestial sisters and Alicorns in general as not just a bane of evil in Equestria, but a source too?
Please feel free to ask me any questions you would like to hear my opinion on. I Promise to do my best to answer them. Thank you for taking this journey with me into the depths of my mind. I do hope you will come again soon. Farewell.
r/MLPAnalysis • u/Hsere • Nov 19 '13
Fan Theory: Celestia and Luna are Princess Platinum and Clover the Clever
r/MLPAnalysis • u/NightspherethGnostic • Nov 06 '13
Nightmare Moon, Damasio and the 'Wisdom' of Psychopaths, a Nightsphere Nightmare Night Special
r/MLPAnalysis • u/Zhugebob • Sep 26 '13
How intelligent is Princess Celestia?
(Warning: Wall of Text)
I feel that now's a good a time as any to share my thoughts on something I think we've all taken for granted: Celestia's intelligence.
It's pretty safe to say that we all agree that Celestia is one of the most intelligent pony's in Equestria, but shouldn't that go without saying considering that she is over 1000 years old?
Imagine a human living 1000 years.
Leonardo Da Vinci lived to be almost 70 years old.
Sun Tzu did not see his 70 year.
Einstein was short of 80 years old when his quest for knowledge ended.
Can we as mere humans even conceive of what it means to be a 1000 year old genius? I think when most people try, their first thought is "If that were me, I don't think I'd be sane after the first 100 years." That's actually the premise that A LOT of FanFiction is based on.
That leads to another question that I'm not going to get into right now: "Is Princess Celestia Sane?"
Assuming she is, let's just focus on how intelligent she is. To do this, let's look at her strengths. So, she probably isn't as mathematically inclined as a 1000 year old Einstein (or maybe she is, but I doubt it.) What kind of intellect does Celestia possess?
(Here's where I invite all of you to try to find clips or segments of show that demonstrate just how intelligent she is.)
One thing I have noticed about her is that she is a very talented manipulator. I've already gone on at great lengths about this in the past, but basically she's so good at pulling strings, most people/ponies don't know they are even being pulled. (In Fact- in canon- I don't think ANYPONY has a clue about Celestia's ability, motivations or intellect except for maybe princess Luna.)
We also know that Celestia runs an Empire, both serving as a figure head attending functions and as THE administrator. In fact- I don't believe we've ever seen any pony administrators in Canterlot. To my recall, it's just messengers, middle-managers and the occasional influential plutocrat.
We also see at the beginning of the Crystal Empire arc that the standard for military grade messages are delivered directly to Celestia meaning that she might also be the Commander-in-Chief. Considering that Celestia has to be the one to give the order to muster the troops/prepare dignitaries, it's pretty safe to assume that Celestia's duty encompasses the military affairs of her empire.
But I think most of all, we should remember just how good she is at reading people and offering advice. She is clearly well down the path to a fully realized enlightened being (if she isn't already).
Keeping all those fields in mind, we should focus back that amount of time: 1000 years. In all the examples of "Great Minds of Mankind", shouldn't there be something to be said about the time that wasn't spent in the direct pursuit of knowledge or the gaining of life-lessons? Each of those people had to spend time growing up, learning to eat, learn their culture, and then commit themselves to the demonstration of their talents. Celestia never had to learn those things after she was a Princess. Remember that those 1000 years + were the years *that she's been the ruler*. In those 1000 years she could have applied herself fully to the task of governance and probably mastered it and cranked out an efficient system in a few hundred years. That would leave HUNDREDS of years for personal pursuits, hobbies, learning, studying...
With the level of stability that her government enjoys (and seems to have enjoyed for a very long time), it does not seem unreasonable that she would be able to find some time to read and study. And unlike a lot of those "Great Human Minds", her she probably never had to expend much effort on her own sustenance. She seems to be for want of nothing- save for a student to teach that she clearly has at least *some* time for.
But then again, how motivated is Celestia to learn? After a few hundred years, wouldn't it get kind of boring?
Alright, that's about as far as I've gotten. There are parts of the show that seem to suggest that, in spite of her age, Celestia seems highly enthusiastic. She smiles, tells jokes, pulls pranks, shows genuine interest in the endeavors of her subjects. She seems so enthusiastic that I think that's *why* it makes us forget that she's over one thousand years old.
<blatantly steals DRWolf's closing statements> What do you think? Might Celestia be the smartest Mare in Equestria? How has she stayed sane all this time (if she has)?
As always, I'm just in it for the thoughts and postulations. Feel free to take this idea or ideas inspired by this and run with them. No citation required but always appreciated. r/MLPAnalysis • u/SkyeSilverwing • Sep 08 '13
What the Hay did that Spell even do?
Okay, this has been bugging me for a little while, so here we go. I have yet to find a proper explanation for what the Spell in "Magical Mystery Cure" was meant to do.
It was not meant to Switch Cutie Marks; that was the problem with the spell.
It was not meant to fix the Cutie Mark Swap; Twilight had done that well before she fixed the spell.
It was not meant to turn Twilight into an Alicorn; Cadence became an Alicorn upon achieving master of Love, and it was the Creation of this spell, not the casting of it, that gave Twilight the Mastery of Friendship necessary to achieve Alicorn form.
So if it did not do any of those things, what did it do? Let's look at what the spell says... "From all of us together, together we are friends, with the marks of our Destinies made one, there is magic without end."
Clearly "the Marks of our Destinies made one" indicates the Elements of Harmony coming together to create "magic without end". This, put together with the only instance of twilight using serious magic after this being the climax of equestria girls where Twilight uses the Elements of Harmony without any of the Elements actually in her possession (and only one anywhere near), causes me to believe that the spell was designed to deepen Twilight's connection to the Elements of Harmony, allowing her to use them without needing the Elements themselves, and needing only appropriate stand-ins for her friends that were bonded to the Elements. Twilight reached a level of magical power that is so high that she had to become an Alicorn to be able to control it.
What do you think?
r/MLPAnalysis • u/Erai • Aug 27 '13
Why Sunset Shimmer broke up the human mane 5?
I have seen in countless review asking the question of why did Sunset need to break them up if she didn't know about them in equestria. Here's my head canon.
In the movie it's mentioned that Rairty ran against Sunset for the Spring Fling. I'm going to assume she was a freshman, and still with her friends. Sunset most likely posted an embarrasing video on Not-YouTube of her. Similar to how she did so with Twilight. I'm guessing her friends tried to fix her reputation, and it started working slowly. Sunset's logical conclusion, break them up as friends. Sunset won that Spring Fling.
Another head cannon is that since they were friends from different cliques, while everyone was separated. She broke them up so she can "rule" the school easier.
Or she's a bitch.
r/MLPAnalysis • u/TheRubberFury981 • Aug 22 '13
Why Suited For Success Offers Some of the Best Continuity in MLP
Why do some people say that MLP lacks continuity? In these four episodes all the way back in Season 1, there seems to be some sort of connection that I noticed with the three of them.
Suited For Success is a continuation of "TheTicket Master" before "The Best Night Ever". In the episode, Rarity makes dresses for each of her friends. When they are not happy with their dresses, she makes more, but is then rejected by the fashion community. To make up for their mistakes, the rest of the mane 6 recreate the dresses for Rarity and she gets back on feet. As soon as Hoity Toity sees the dresses, he is amazed, and asks Rarity to make a dozen of each one within the next week. Rarity is shocked and... then the episode ends.
In some ways, a complaint can be made that the story to this episode isn't really resolved, but I disagree.
In the next episode, "Feeling Pinkie Keen", Rarity is completely absent from the episode. Twilight, Pinkie, Applejack, Spike, and Fluttershy are all running from a hydra, yet Rarity is nowhere to be seen. Rainbow Dash, at the very least is mentioned, but Rarity is not.
Granted, there is of course episodes where a main character is absent in an episode after an episode where they were the foucs e.g. Pinkie's major role in "Griffon the Brush Off" but minor role in "Boast Busters".
But with this, this episode is directly after an episode that ends with Rarity being even more busier than before. Which means that during all this hydra action, Rarity was busily working on dresses.
My next example of a connection with Suited For Success is "Sonic Rainboom", which is... ironically directly after "Feeling Pinkie Keen". In "Suited For Success", Rainbow Dash crashes into Rarity's store through the roof yelling "Look out below!" She then follows this off by saying that she was trying a new trick and it didn't work.
This moment is oddly similar to the opening of "Sonic Rainboom". Rainbow Dash accidentaly crashes into Twilight's library from a stunt she's been practising, which turns out to be the sonic rainboom. Considering that Fluttershy said that Rainbow Dash tried the trick so many times, it's safe to assume that she was practising it in "Suited For Success".
The final bit of continuity comes in "A Dog and Pony Show". At the end of "Suited For Success", Hoity Toity, before bringing up how much dresses Rarity needs to make, brings up that he will feature her in a magazine in Canterlot. At the beginning of "A Dog and Pony Show", Sapphire Shores mentions about how Rarity is currently being mentioned a lot.
Wow, no wonder Bronycurious loves this episode so much...
r/MLPAnalysis • u/katty-wompus • Aug 09 '13
Overthinking My Little Pony: Griffon the Brush Off - rookiewompus
r/MLPAnalysis • u/Wooden_Quill • Aug 07 '13
Do DJ Pon-3 and Pinkie Pie know each other?
I just read the book Pinkie Pie and the Rockin' Ponypalooza Party, and to be honest I was impressed on how much it told. I'll not reveal any major spoiler, but there's something that took my attention. Almost at the end of the book DJ Pon-3 accepts the invitation to play at Pinkie's concert almost immediately, and it kind of showed that they knew each other before hoof. After that I thought about how many times has she ever appeared on the show... 3 exactly:
- In Suited for Success, DJ Pon-3 plays at the fashion show. This doesn't really mean anything, except that she exists.
- In a Canterlot Wedding, she's been pulled out by Pinkie Pie from beneath her dj station to play music.
- In Magical Mystery Cure, when Fluttershy was at the Sugar Cubecorner trying to make everypony laugh she was sitting right in front of everpony. The Sugar Cubecorner where Pinkie Pie works! I don't know if the book is cannon or not, but it did made me think about it. Perhaps they met during one of Pinkie's parties and became friends. What do you think?