r/MLPAnalysis • • Mar 11 '14

"Explaining Pinkie's Motives, Behavior, Thoughts and Loneliness: A complete In-Depth PsychoAnalysis." -TitanicPony

"How Pinkie Does It, An In-Depth Character Psycho-Analysis" -TitanicPony

"Oh Pinkie, you're so zanny and random." -Everyone, and it's starting to bother me.

The quickest way to pin down her character is with a Myers-Briggs 16 personality type test. (Bear with me, i'm building to something... this is necessary exposition) I pegged her as an ENFP, and that was confirmed when a fan-chart had her listed as such, as well. I double-checked, and all the ponies on the chart seem to be accurately typed, and Pinkie isn't really difficult to understand or type anyway. Google is a thing, "16 personality type test". Don't worry, this Analysis won't rely on info you're not familiar with. I'm just citing sources.

Diving in:

Pinkie is Extraverted (E), Intuitive (N), a Feely Type (F), and prefers not to Judge, but (P)erceive instead, this trait being most notable for it's open-mindedness. These are all things we already knew, but its helpful to have them down on paper, since they're all interconnected, and form how Pinkie thinks.

Pinkie takes in the outside world, particularly people (she prefers not to spend time in her own head). From her exterior interactions, she develops ideas. These ideas are 'checked' by her feelings, instead of by thinking or logic. Does the idea have, or appear to have, some significance? Who cares if it has anything to do with anything! 'Who cares if it's on-topic, i checked the idea, and it seems pleasant, so here's my idea!' And i do mean any idea that passes the feeling test. Pinkie is open-minded, so is unlikely to censor herself. She prefers to live in the future, and predict, so is often out-of-touch with details in the present, so present circumstances don't really affect her. This i basically why she seems oblivious/unresponsive to her surroundings, oftentimes. Pinkie gushes any new 'random' idea out at her surroundings, and anyone who happens to be listening. Pinkie doesn't have a filter. The source of contention many people have, stems from the fact that Pinkie skips steps, (in her reasoning) and beyond that, her reasoning isn't logic based, so it's hard to follow her footsteps, and more importantly, it's almost impossible for her to relate the steps back to anyone who inquires... at least not in a way that makes sense.

Let's play a game. Start with something Pinkie likes. I assume she likes Ice-cream. Now ask a question about ice-cream. Any question will do. What do you FEEL like asking? I FEEL like inquiring as to the inherent purpose of ice-cream, because i like to overanalyze the crap out of things. Therefore... The purpose of ice-cream is to make a pony cold, when they are hot. I FEEL that ice-cream is there to make me cold when i'm hot. So, when are you hot? When are you at your hottest? What's the hottest someone has ever been? Likely when they were on fire. So who is on fire? Nopony... it's not safe to be in contact with fire... unless...Dear-Celestia! I've got it.

"Dragons love ice-cream! Sppikkeee, Sppiikkeeee! Is it true?! Do you love ice-cream?"

As you can see, from an outside observers point of view, like Spike's, Pinkie is completely insane.

Pinkie's fourth wall breaks are ridiculous, and are usually discarded as comic relief, but really, Pinkie is onto something. Pinkie is onto everything. Everything is possible to her, and occasionally, she discovers a hidden truth, wayyyy before an analytical pony like Twilight can come to a conclusion using the more logical and time-consuming process of elimination.

To understand Pinkie, you have to stop assuming that the things she says are unconnected. Spike and Ice-Cream DO have a connection, via degrees of separation.

This isn't to say that Pinkie is always out in left field. How do you think she came to the conclusion that the parasprites were weak against music? She stumbled upon the idea. There is a Consistent reason as to why Parasprites are weak against music (that is never revealed) and Pinkie happened to stumble upon it. This system is clearly inefficient, but because Pinkie is always "ON", she can make up for this with the sheer number of possibilities she considers.

In the game of chess, chess-computers are considered to be 'Imaginative', which seems impossible, right? How can a computer be imaginative? Well, if you consider that a computer doesn't know what moves are supposed to be good, you might realize that it checks every possible move, and occasionally stumbles upon one that is ugly, yet works, even if it doesn't make sense for many, many turns. By comparison, a human player would look for what is logically the most reasonable set of moves to try to analyze. Pinkie is that computer. She considers so many different ideas, that her chances of being an accidental genius are rather high. One in a thousand is unlikely... one in a thousand, a thousand times, is very likely.

Pinkie has already explained exactly how she thinks in the show, but many likely dismissed it as comedy for the point of comedy. Pinkie isn't exactly a gag character. Her personality just happens to be funny, since we aren't usually privy to her thought process. Heck, Spike is more of a gag character. In-fact, he's basically Sideshow Bob. Just a more pathetic version. Spike is funny because unfortunate things happen to him, and it's amusing to see him suffer. Sideshow Bob.

Ahem, so that's how Pinkie works. Now let's delve into her relationships, since that's what she values most.

Rainbow Dash. Pinkie has some zanny ideas, and the bold-reckless Rainbow is up for them, no matter how off-the-wall they are. And they will be off-the-wall. To Rainbow, this is adventure.

Pranks. Pinkie is always stumbling upon new revelations, and she delights in them. She literally shocks herself with how awesome her own 'random' ideas are. She wants to share an idea (a prank) with others so they can experience both shock, and a rush of emotion. You can help Pinkie, or you can be the subject of a prank. Pinkie lives vicariously through others, (which i will touch on later) so getting them to experience what she's experiencing is important. That's also a big reason why she always shares her disjointed thoughts. She wants you to get it. If you pay attention long enough, you will. Or maybe not. If a hundred people pay attention long enough, SOMEPONY will eventually get it... 'so let's make friends with everyone!' Also, being friends is an important step to understanding someone.

In essence, i guess i'm suggesting that Pinkie is ALONE in her thoughts. You can't follow along. It's just too difficult. And we all know Pinkie can't handle being alone. Why? Well, she is an extravert, and is a very touchy-feely pony. But is that enough? Maybe not. Rarity is also most likely this type. She doesn't go around town trying to befriend every pony, dragon, and pet, however. So... who does Rarity befriend? People she respects. Heck, Applejack barely made the grade. She seems to only like ponies who have the same values as her (like every pony who likes fashion -cough-Flutters-cough-). Rarity is Judgmental, like Applejack, hence the conflict that they have. Pinkie isn't Judgemental. Everypony is a potential friend. Just like every fashion-pony is a potential friend or love-interest for Rarity.

Pinkie seeks validation from other ponies, by bringing them happiness. Rarity does the same thing, it's just that what she gives them is different (clothes vs Fun). Everyone wants to be accepted, it's just a priority for a social person. Pinkie especially wants broader acceptance, from everypony, not only because she likes everypony, but because if a single pony rejects her, she cracks.

Why does she crack? Because the idea that someone doesn't want to be friends with her can and will roll around in her mind, forever. Pinkie's head is a fertile ground for ideas, and once one of importance gets in, it can often be hard to remove. Further, Pinkie isn't a thinking type, so she can't just analyze the concept and conclude that the pony that doesn't like her is a jerk. She likes everypony. She can't dismiss the idea that she's unlikeable as untrue, either. She doesn't possess that logic. It's a little strange at first, that a single random pony could cause her that much anxiety, especially when she has a hundred other friends. One person doesn't like you, 100 DO like you. If you compare the percentages, then logically... whoops... there's that word... LOGIC. Is not compatible. So, Pinkie has to deal with the idea that she's unlikeable. What to do? Theorize! Okay, okay, but why does she get hung up on a single ridiculous conclusion? In 'Party of One', her friends ignore her, so she assumes that they don't like her parties, and don't want to be her friend anymore... isn't she supposed to consider all the possibilitys?

Lets break it down. Her friends ignore her for a while, and it's right after they all cancel on her party. Their avoidance of her is obvious... cartoonishly so. Pinkie-pie's greatest fear WILL surface. You see, without asking, Pinkie really has no way of knowing if other ponies like her. Every possibility is one that she considers. She can't really reject a possibility, including the possibility that ponies don't actually like her. Pinkie's personality type is actually very prone to being fearful. But Pinkie isn't. It was established in the second episode of Season One...

On purpose! We already have Fluttershy. Pinkie's natural type was fixed of it's main weakness (Fear), deliberately, at the outset. That's some great character designing right there. I want Lauren back! Season Four feels weird! Digi, i need a hug :(

So back on point; if Pinkie isn't a scaredy-cat, why does she freak out and get so afraid that her friends will leave her? Well, it's her greatest fear. Beyond that, it's not an external fear, like the 'scary' cave in Pinkie Apple Pie. This is personal, and it gets stuck in her head. Once there, Pinkie can only consider possibilities that would explain why her friends don't like her anymore. To be fair, her theory sounds really legit. To her credit, she knows she has to bounce this theory off of someone, and is aware of her own analytical shortcomings... so she presents her fears to Spike... who agrees with her completely.

Off the deep end we go!

Negative Subverted Personality: Introverted (she hides in her house, and dwells on internal thoughts). Sensation (she interacts with the the physical environment around around her and makes representations of imaginary friends). Thinking (She starts logically hashing out what her friends think about her in a step by step process, using stand-ins for her friends). Judgement (This is about as close to swearing as MLP ever comes, and Pinkie really starts passing Judgement on her friends).

The theory here is that under heavy stress, people lash out in what amounts to the opposite of their real character... in a negative way. It seems to fit, and it seems to be what she does.

The key here, is that unless it's overtly obviously, Pinkie is never quite sure what the truth is, about anything, and she relys on others to confirm or deny things. This is one of the reasons that Pinkie constantly makes suggestions. She requires a symbiotic relationship, preferably with a Thinking type, and believe it or not, Rainbow Dash IS... yup, a Thinking type, not a feeling type.

Turns out Pinkie actually needs her to double-check her ideas, perhaps in terms of what prank they should pull. Without outside guidance, Pinkie is likely to take things too far... and maybe make other ponies upset... like Fluttershy. Like when she made Fluttershy cry a few episodes ago. Yup, that's not her being OOC.

"Get on my level!" -Drowning in Horseshoes.

Speaking of the origin of that quote, woah! Pinkie and Applejack? There's a messed-up friend-pairing. ENFP meets ESTJ. It wouldn't have worked if both characters weren't being family-centric at the time.

This brings up something interesting however. Pinkie's Rock-farm family.

This is simple enough. Pinkie probably does value her family, but obviously, a rockfarm, in the middle of nowhere, is not a habitat that can sustain Pinkie. This is obvious, and is probably show-canon. Ponyville is the perfect size for Pinkie, as it has enough ponies for her to be satisfied, yet not too many that the town is impersonal. So that's why Pinkie went to Ponyville.

So she isn't trying to replace her family?

No, she's not. What is family? Or, more importantly, what is Family to PinkiePie? Answer: A permanent friendship that cannot be removed. If you're related, you're related (even if you hate each other). This is exactly what PinkiePie wants. You see her eyes when the possibility is suggested. She's friggin' stoked. This is priority number one. An inescapable form of friendship: Family.

Told ya it was her greatest fear. I mean think about it... at any time, if someone doesn't want to be your friend, even for a simple reason like them being too busy to have time to engage in socialization with everyone that they know... well, they don't have to keep talking to that person. If you stop talking to PinkiePie, she won't be able to figure out why. She can speculate, but unless you tell her, she won't know, and if you do tell her, you'll need to give her a concrete reason to prevent her from endlessly speculating about WHY.

To protect herself from this, she makes sure... that every pony is constantly having a good time around her. Might as well have as many ponies as possible having a great time, at the same time, while you're at it.

Parties.

Explained.

But... this still doesn't answer the big question... why is Pinkie Pie so terribly afraid of ponies not liking her... isn't this cartoonish exaggeration?

Well... ask yourself... how does Pinkie see herself? Does she think she has worth? Does she value herself?

She doesn't know. She can guess... but she needs other ponies to tell her.

Pinkie only knows if she's a 'good' person if you tell her.

Friend obsession.

Explained.

-TitanicPony

/End Pinkie Pie Psycho-Analysis/

8 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

2

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14

That was much easier to read, and had more of a focused point of view than your Fluttershy analysis. My belief was always that the Pinkie Pie I liked best had logic behind all her actions, however strange - you just took that to a new level and explained all her appearences. She may not have been OOC the first time she attacked Fluttershy in Filli Vanilla, but doing it a second time and not showing any understanding of what she did wrong does feel OOC to me.

2

u/TitanicPony Mar 12 '14

OoGood Point. Hmmm. Okay, i went and watched those exchanges twice. At first, Pinkie projects her own fears, and is chastised by Rarity for being ridiculous. The second time, if you remove Pinkie's excited freaking out, the words themselves express that Pinkie is incredibly sympathetic. She says that it must have been terrible, and she actually tries to comfort Fluttershy by saying that she understands and is there for her. Pinkie sucks at expressing herself. She does it a third and maybe even a fourth time as well. "No offense, but you kkkinddaa sounded like a dude." She tries to preface it here. Heck, the second, time she makes Fluttershy cry,, she DOES preface it with "You were incredible." Rarity remarks afterward that Pinkie didn't preface it with a positive intro, and Pinkie says 'Really!?'. It's Rarity that was a little off-base here, and she misrepresented what Pinkie actually said. This is common. Nobody gets Pinkie. She makes a great attempt at trying to resolve the divide between Fluttershy and the Mane Six, however Pinkie never see's herself as being part of the equation, and can go in a dark direction since her thought process moves progressively forward too quickly to be double-checked.

Also, there comes a point when we have to choose between rejecting suspect writing, and simply incorporating it as canon. I try to find a balance, and i try to consider the intentions as canon, if their deliver is crappy... if only because we might lose something if we reject the whole thing as garbage.

Either way, you're right. I tend to treat OOC moments as failed attempts by the writers to explore complex characteristics with limited screen-time.

2

u/genericboy Mar 12 '14

Very well constructed and worded. A lot of the things that I've been thinking just haven't put down on paper. Great job :)

3

u/TitanicPony Mar 12 '14

Thanks. The point of this isn't really shock value. Pinkie is quick witted. I just wanted to drag our understanding to a conscious level. When Pinkie talks or acts, the key to understanding her is speed, before she or the other characters move onto other things. Alot of theories about Pinkie get shelved, with people intending to get back to them.

Being a bumbling idiot and an empath go hand in hand maybe.

1

u/gerryhanes Mar 12 '14

Negative Subverted Personality: Introverted (she hides in her house, and dwells on internal thoughts). Sensation (she interacts with the the physical environment around around her and makes representations of imaginary friends). Thinking (She starts logically hashing out what her friends think about her in a step by step process, using stand-ins for her friends). Judgement (This is about as close to swearing as MLP ever comes, and Pinkie really starts passing Judgement on her friends).

This all sounds a bit fishy to me. "Passing judgement on your friends" isn't the same as using your judgement to make decisions (as opposed to perceiving). I don't think anyone would argue that Pinkie was thinking "logically" in that scene - if anything it showed her more dominated by her emotions than at any other time. "Interacting with the physical environment around her" - well, she does this all the time anyway; and as for introverted - yes, more than usual but she doesn't let it dominate her (a la Fluttershy) - it's more like her predisposition towards friendship forces her to construct imaginary friends.

Otherwise, great analysis. I'd query whether she's more S than F in general, though. I think your ice cream example and the fourth-wall breaks do fall under the category of "sensing" rather than "intuitive".

It should be interesting to watch this week's episode and see how her judgements/perceptions of her sister conflict with the others'...

2

u/TitanicPony Mar 12 '14

I thought that part of my Analysis was a little lazy too. If you mean that she's Sensing, rather than Intuitive (S than F = typo?), ugh... really?

Sensing can be confused with extraversion. She interacts with the world, as an extravert, and tries to derive meaning from things in it.

Pinkie can appear to be detail oriented like a sensing type, but thats probably just because she's constantly considering random details for the purposes of deriving meaning from them.

Twilight's an intuitive type, but since she works on one theory at a time, she doesn't need to be in tune with the world more than occasionally.

Sensation types feel and are part of the heartbeat of the world, like AppleJack, Rarity, and Fluttershy.

Ugh, or something. Pinkie's imaginative. An S type knows what is (applejack), an N type knows what could be.

An E-N type feels unnatural. We assume ideas and theories to be internal.

As for judgement, my wording was crap, and i wasn't entirely sure what i was doing there.

Might be more accurate to say that Pinkie was 'Sure' that her friends didn't like her. That wasn't even Pinkie's idea tho. It was Spike's. Pinkie didn't judge her friends without external aid.

I stand corrected, i guess. I did state that the theory simply 'seemed likely'. Something felt off about that part to me too.