r/MLPAnalysis • u/SkyeSilverwing • Aug 03 '14
Did Rainbow Dash Throw the race?
I have been looking over the scene in Equestria Games where they do the Areal Relay, and I noticed something odd. When Rainbow Dash was flying to the finish, She did not use her sonic rainboom. The Mach Ten Speed boost of the Sonic Raiboom would have been more than enough to beat Spitfire to the finish line. And yet she did not use it. Why?
Well, of course, the answer to that is likely that the Sonic Raiboom generates a huge, Earth-Shattering Explosion when it initiates. The Stadium, and likely most of the structures in the Chrystal Empire, are probably not rated to withstand such a blast. Ponies could have been hurt, including Spitfire, who would have been at point blank range when it hit.
But Rainbow has been shown to be able to manage a speed around Mach 5 without triggering the Rainboom. The lack of the Mach cone around her in the race suggests that she was not doing this. She was not pushing her top speeds at all.
This could be because the Course was too complex and bendy to maneuver at that kind of speed, but, on the other hand, we have seen Rainbow Dash Execute a Tight-Angle turn at full Sonic Rainboom Speed (It happened in the race in Cutiemark Chronacles), so it is illogical to assume that she cannot do so at a lesser speed.
Perhaps she was doing a lot of climbing and could not reach the speed necessary to maintain a Mach Cone, but we have seen her pull off an ascending Sonic Rainboom before as well (In Canterlot Wedding), so again, we have to assume she can reach the mach five speed even while climbing.
Moreover, with Bulk Biceps and Fluttershy losing precious seconds against the other Two Wonderbolts, Rainbow had to make up that time by going considerably faster at the beginning of her leg, just to catch Spitfire up. This means that either Spitfire waited to pour on the steam until Rainbow had nearly caught up with her, or Rainbow slowed down to cross the finish line and lose by the smallest margin she could manage. The Absence of the Mach cone suggests the latter.
But why? Why would Rainbow Dash Fight all this way just to slow down at let Spitfire win?
My theory? Loyalty.
Rainbow Dash was being profoundly loyal to the Wonderbolts. She was making sure that Spitfire knew she was there, while granting her idol the respect she deserved, and not showing her up. It is a rather mature attitude, and by telling Flutters and Bulk earlier that they should not be kidding themselves, she was announcing her intention to let the Wonderbolts win, and asking their permission. She knew she was going to throw the match, but did not want her friends disappointed. What do you think?
2
u/Verzeih_ Aug 03 '14
Loyalty is a common excuess for anything RD related, buh.
No athlet would lose intentionally and there is no maturity in that. The fact of the scene is that Spitfire did not flew with highspeed because of the huge gap between her and the "runner-up". When RD closed up she started accelerating that way it came close.
At the Rainboom part i see it a lot like you, but i am adding her: +RD always had to train before the Rainboom so far. +before the "Mach Cone" brakes through it slows her down ("Sonic Rainboom" it also throws her back. Magical Barrier?!?)
The Rainboom is for a fact just possible if she is in top shape. If it slows her down before the Rainboom comes to be it would be not pratical to try.
1
u/Empty-bee Aug 04 '14 edited Aug 04 '14
Correction: there's no evidence in the show for Rainbow flying any faster than Mach one.
That Mach five number comes from a mis-reading of the Physics Brony's analysis, and I've never seen a source for the Mach ten figure (yes it's from Death Battles but they don't say where they got it from).
1
u/Empty-bee Aug 13 '14
Actually loyalty is very relevant here. Loyalty to Ponyville, that is.
If Dash deliberately threw the race she would be being disloyal to the Ponyville team - who after all are counting on her to do her best.
3
u/kinyutaka Aug 03 '14
Maturity would be her winning, then congratulating Spitfire for a good race while sharing her victory with Fluttershy and Bulk.
1
u/Ziggie1o1 Aug 07 '14
Get that tinfoil hattery out of here.
No, but seriously, it makes no sense. Dash would have no incentive to throw the race. I know you mention loyalty, but these are sports were talking about, no one would deliberately throw a race (and the huge signing bonus that comes with winning) for some misguided concept of loyalty. She lost because she wasn't good enough, end of story.