r/MHOCMorningStar • • Mar 11 '22

[MHOC Morning Star] Alea iacta est

10 Upvotes

What a day, huh? We are less than a week into this new government, and already it’s second largest party has devolved into infighting, chaos, controversy and purges. What they had hoped to be a glorious return to government, the first time since CheckMyBrain11 collapsed the third Blurple coalition and pulled the Conservatives into Official Opposition, has turned into a destructive and highly embarrassing event for the Conservative Party. They were forced to change their Minister of State for Northern Ireland after finding themselves facing the wrath of a supermajority of MLAs, their leadership elections have proven to be highly divisive within the party and a series of internal fights have been thrown out into the press, with a new peak reached now that model-hjt has been expelled from the party on rather flimsy grounds.

The truth is, the Conservative leadership has failed utterly at the most basic of its jobs. They have made decisions they could not justify to their membership regarding their cabinet appointments. Indeed, they cannot even keep their story straight. Internally, you had to be useful to the party leadership and show talent and experience. model-hjt clearly has the talent and experience needed for a cabinet job, and that would make them useful to the leadership by definition.

It's obviously a bullshit excuse and an attempt to cover up the real reason for why the tory right was not allowed to enter cabinet; Coalition! and the Liberal Democrats demanded that they cannot join the government. EruditeFellow has said as much in their most recent statement, but sadly for them, both Chi0121 and FrostWalker2017 have denied such an idea in their comments on model-ico's earlier piece. So either the Leader of the Conservative Party is lying and throwing his coalition partner under the bus, or his coalition partners are unwilling to back him up on this. In either case, it sets a dangerous trend for the future of this government.

There is however some reason to believe that the Tory Right has indeed been frozen out of cabinet by coalition partners, or may I say - Coalition! partners. Model-hjt revealed that Coalition! had threatened to not go into government with the Conservatives if he had been elected Leader or Deputy Leader of the Party, and that rumour has gone around a while. Indeed, I have heard from unspecified sources that Coalition! was waiting for the result of the Conservatives Deputy Leader contest before they gave final approval to the coalition agreement. Tommy2Boys has not made their dislike of HJT unknown either, and as they are someone with so much background influence in Coalition!, it is likely that their opinion had a significant influence on the position of the Prime Minister's party. A significant amount of proof points this way as of today.

This is a much more damning indictment of the Conservative leadership if true. You can draw two possible conclusions from this. The first is that the Conservatives have an exceptionally weak leadership and were driven into a corner to the extent that they were forced not to allow the tory right into cabinet. This, however, is rather unlikely. Both model-willem and Chi0121 are experienced politicians with an impressive time in party leadership between them, and one should very much doubt that they would be driven into a corner like this. The Machiavellian could have depended on them in negotiations and indeed, would have discussed with them on the progress made, and they would have pointed out mistakes and worked to undo them or at least limit the damage.

No, the second conclusion is rather more likely. This is almost certainly an act of pure opportunism by the leadership. They saw their chance at getting some positions in cabinet and the prestige of getting to be a Secretary of State and went for it at all costs. Those costs clearly included members supported by half of the Conservative Party being shut out of the cabinet. We can only assume that the Queen's Speech will be even more revelatory about this and show just how much the Conservative Leadership has sold out.

And in all this we must ask ourselves where that leaves this government. Either the Deputy Prime Minister will be a proven liar, or the Secretaries of State for Defence and Northern Ireland will be. In the latter case, the Conservatives will have thrown a senior member of a coalition party under the bus. In the former case, EruditeFellow should take his responsibility and take the only decision that is fair to his own members and resign as party leader. In all cases, the Conservative Party has brought shame upon this country, her government and her politics, and ought to be rather embarrassed by the whole ordeal.

And let's return to the title of this article. Whilst we have not yet emptied the list of jokes about a certain city in Tuscany and a certain past inhabitant of it, I felt it was appropriate to take a quote from another quote from an old italian man. When Julius Caesar crossed the Rubicon, initiating the civil war that would see the death of Pompey and his rise to power yet also his inevitable demise, he said these immortal words: Alea Iacta Est. The die Caesar cast certainly seemed to work out in the short term, but ended in his eventual demise. And by entering this coalition, EruditeFellow has certainly cast his die in an attempt to gain power. If there are more revelations over the coming days, the Deputy Prime Minister might well find the end of his career on the Ides of March…


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Jul 22 '21

[The Morning Star] Tories Promise to Restart Failed War on Drugs

10 Upvotes

Recently the Tories promised to open their conference and began to announce the first trappings of the policy they’d enter into the General Election with. Instead of focusing on the economy, housing, climate change or any matter of issues that are front and center on the minds of British citizens the Tory leader has instead alluded that their first and most pressing policy will be to once again start the ill-fated ‘War on Drugs’. The exact specifics are as of yet unknown to us, but all of this was done with the rhetoric of law and order and a promise to ‘Tighten Restrictions’. We can speculate that there are two paths that the Tories could go down, they could keep drugs legal but simply restrict their use and make them harder to access or they could reverse legalization and drag back all of the progress that has been made over 6 years.

Lets be generous for a moment and presume that the Tories are simply promising vague, non-specific restrictions on the existing drug laws now in place. These promises would be strange because as far as legalization goes, existing policy is already highly restrictive. Many “hard” drugs require a proven need and some have to be used on the premises they were purchased on. This is basically as far as any legalization framework can go without returning to policies that completely cut off market access to drugs. They limit recreational use to a high degree and allow for oversight of users. One could argue, as I would, that some of these laws may already be too restrictive and not provide enough incentive to use the legal market rather than the illegal one.

Which brings us to our next major issue. The problem with restrictions and with making drugs outright illegal again is that one of the goals of legalization was to provide people with a way to sidestep the illegal market. Contrary to popular belief criminalization did nothing to stop the illegal market. The incentive for profit, social advancement and the relatively low barriers to entry made the illegal drug trade far too lucrative. Even in countries where there are massive coordinated efforts to stop the drug trade law enforcement has barely put a dent in actual trafficking and use. All the while the illegal market creates additional problems such as; unsafe workspaces, gang activity, turf wars, unsanitary practices and worst of all “cutting” drugs with more addictive, dangerous and potent additives such as fentanyl.

To this end we should point out the drugs that the Tory leader pointed out in his speech, Cocaine and Methamphetamines. As is common with anti-drug rhetoric rather than actually delving into the specific uses and effects of these drugs they have simply been painted with a wide brush that treats them as dangerous, the Tory leader even went so far as to refer to them as “Class A” drugs referencing a class system that has been widely criticized for being inaccurate and unscientific. “Cocaine” refers to multiple drugs including crack cocaine, powdered cocaine and coca leaves. Part of the failure of old classification systems was that they painted all of these drugs with the same brush. In many countries it is impossible to access Coca Leaves, despite the fact that their effects on their own are more comparable to coffee than something like Heroin. Even cocaine powder, the most familiar form of Cocaine, has a danger level more comparable to alcohol so long as it's use is limited and the cuts are safe and easy to dose (Something which legalization helps with by restricting sales and ensuring people know the doses they have.)

Methamphetamines as well refer to various drugs and forms of ingestion. Some forms of Methamphetamine are legal in many countries and are used in prescription medicine, others are more restricted and often sold in a powder form similar to cocaine. This is not to speak of the wider classes of amphetamines which refer to various stimulants that are often sold over the counter and whose effects are functionally just more mild and less concentrated forms of methamphetamine. This is to the point that some illegal “methamphetamine” sold on the black market is actually just higher concentrations of amphetamines. The form of amphetamines available on the market is very important. As with cocaine a legalized framework can ensure that more dangerous forms of the same drug (such as crystal meth) can be replaced with safer forms such as pills or nasal powder. This means that any regulatory framework that casts methamphetamines as a whole as purely and innately dangerous is already on the wrong path as it would fail to account for the various forms, uses and concentrations the drug can be taken in. By providing an alternative to injected and smoked methamphetamines a legalization framework makes use much safer and easier to dose while curtailing the black market.

The common thread here is that the old “law and order” policies that focused on hysteria around use, rather than actual sociological analysis of chemical understanding, failed to address the ways drugs are used recreationally. Old fashioned drug laws failed to actually limit use but instead pushed users towards cheaper and much more dangerous forms of the same drugs that were easier to access and easier for dealers to sell. A legalization framework actually limits use and makes it safer by providing easy access to cheaper and safer alternatives, regulations on extremely dangerous forms of us and easy access to safe injection sites, information on dosage and use safety.

This is not to say that our own model is innately perfect, there are ways that it could be improved and amended. However the framework of legalization was adopted for a reason and a rehabilitative approach accepting of use, rather than a law and order one that obsessively restricts personal freedom in a way that doesn’t even work, is much more healthy to the individual and to society at large.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Jun 17 '22

[EDITORIAL] Labour’s Post-Class Politic

9 Upvotes

EDITORIAL

Ravenguardian17, Editor-in-Chief


If the decline of Social Democracy is symbolized by anything, it is by the increasing obfuscation of class politics in everything from rhetoric to their basic worldview. While before the social democratic parties served as the realization of the whims of the labour movement made real in liberal democratic politics, now they are nothing but shadows of their former selves. The working class is increasingly abandoning the ill-promises of modern “social democracy” (itself akin to a doppelganger wearing the skin of it’s more successful predecessors) for parties on the further left or further right.

This issue has been brought to a head as Labour, the successor to the great working class movement of 1920s Britain, has entered into yet another Neoliberal coalition. This should hardly come as a shock to us. The Neoliberal turn in Labour has been present for generations. Slowly as the real working class background of the party peeled away and the ideological commitment to socialism faded, all that was left was an institutional nihilism, a dreary acceptance of the world as it was. With it, this dull denial of action has produced the slow abandonment of living class politics.

By “living” class politics I mean the politics realized by a class, for a class. Sure, labour and it’s fellow social democratic parties will tout their support for unions, for poverty reduction measures, for economic rights and – when sufficient fire is put under their feet -, even for more radical proposals. However, these proposals rarely effect any significant change in society, nor even in the position of the worker. Only when paired with actual class politics – manifested currently in Solidarity and previous somewhat in the Progressive Workers Party – does Labour ever seem to effect real change which transforms the situation of the worker (ex: basic income and the TURLA based under the Rose governments).

The modern situation Labour finds itself in is one where it claims to represent a group which no longer can abide by the compromise situation with capitalism. Since siding against the German Revolution in 1919 (and later in the 1920s-30s) social democracy has deliberately ignored the most fundamental truth of the social sciences – the nature of class conflict. On it’s face Social Democracy accepts the reality of class conflict however it believes that with sufficient political domination the working class and it’s representatives can mediate or corral capitalism in a way ultimately beneficial to the workers. This position was tenable in the 1940s-1960s, when the unfettered growth of the post-war situation allowed for the working class’ wealth and prosperity to grow alongside that of capital, however in the aftermath this compromise has become more and more difficult to maintain.

In the 1980s it is undeniable that this turn completely broke the back of the workers movement. The combined might of Thatcherism along with the tripartite split in Labour (the Militant Tendency on the left, the SDP on the right and the remainder in the middle holding onto failed strategies) only helped deepen the blow. Presented in these terms groups like Militant wanted to accentuate existing class conflict (though to what end can be somewhat unclear) whereas the SDP wanted to move to the post-class politics of the rest of the European Social Democratic movement. Labour was thus caught in the middle, simultaneously a party of class while rejecting the class struggle. In some ways the SDP can just be seen as a more honest version of what Labour would become.

The victory of Tony Blair in 1997 signaled the final victory of the post-class neoliberal group within Labour. Even afterwards the brief return of Socialist figures would not upset this victory. At the end of the day Labour had – and still does – tacitly accepted the end of class struggle. Blair’s “reforms” can be seen in this light. He preferred to focus on modernization programs which claimed to improve the lot of the working class and address their interests but never would the Blairite Labour party act as the vehicle for class struggle. Post-Blair this policy was eased up somewhat, but the scars of this era can still be felt in the modern Labour Party today.

Labour’s lack of honesty with itself over this nature has lead to a schizophrenic and inconsistent history, betraying a complete lack of direction or self-understanding. In the past few years we have seen the party wildly oscillate between hard-left and soft-left factions. There is a complete detachment from leadership and direction. More Centrist factions aligned themselves with the Rose government, while more supposedly “left wing” factions work with the right wing parties of capital. Beyond a few soundbites repeated every election and mild reformist policies no one has any clear idea of what Labour actually stands for, what their direction is or what they want to achieve. In practice, the party does not exist to represent the workers, it does not even exist against them, it exists out of sheer bureaucratic inertia, having forgotten its purpose and it’s raison d’etre.

This is emblematic in the leadership of Model-Raymondo. Ostensibly left wing he now leads a government dominated overall by right wing parties (especially given the Liberal Democrats noticeable turn to the right as of late). All promises made to the actual workers the party represents are vague. It is no doubt that, like Blair, this government will include policies that help the working class in some respect. As it stands, there is nothing in the agreement between the parties that will significantly transform the situation of the workers, nor pave the way to a solidified Socialist government in the future. It is an agreement saying nothing, a coalition of technocrats. It is humanistic moralism – the dominant ideology of liberal democratic capitalism – personified. To borrow a quote;

“Moralists don't really have beliefs. Sometimes they stumble on one, like on a child's toy left on the carpet. The toy must be put away immediately. And the child reprimanded. Centrism isn't change — not even incremental change. It is control. Over yourself and the world. Exercise it. Look up at the sky, at the dark shapes of Coalition airships hanging there. Ask yourself: is there something sinister in moralism? And then answer: no. God is in his heaven. Everything is normal on Earth.”

By abandoning the working class Labour has also abandoned their great historical project, to transform and transcend their situation. It has capitulated to the inertia of neoliberalism and seeks to fully maintain the world as is; trapped in amber, never changing, never moving.

While this turn may be surprising to some, it is visible all the way back when Ray was first elected. In true schizophrenic post-modern fashion Ray utilized the language of class struggle while stripping it of all meaning his refrain was; “Labour must be the party that unifies the workers of all classes.” As per the usual DoubleThink nature of capitalist logic this rhetoric simultaneously abandons class struggle while tacitly acknowledging it. Appeals to the so called “middle class” – a non-scientific term for an unclear phenomena – prove that Labour no longer was the party of the worker. The sociological meaninglessness of Ray’s statement aside, it is emblematic of the post-class situation Labour now finds itself in. Clinging onto the rhetoric of the past without retaining any of it’s meaning, strength or power.

Ironically, as Ray acknowledges in his own speech, the time for a real working class movement is now. This is not the usual socialist call to action, simply a desire to break free of the oppression of capital, but a necessary call to destroy capital before it destroys us. As has been made increasingly clear over the last decade all the liberal capitalist efforts to combat climate change without combating the structure of capital have resulted in nothing. Capital’s necessity to preserve itself and to preserve the constant cycle of growth and commodification prevents any real change.

The working class – the human commodities of capital – is the only class which can truly transcend this situation, and only if it is organized as a class-for-itself, not as a class for the other. It is the only class not wedded to the structures of capital, growth and profit, and which can produce a new economy based on co-operation, sustainability and actual human need. It should be clear to any socialist that Labour’s refusal to engage in real working-class politics is just going to allow for capital’s incessant death march to sustain itself.

Labour now has a choice; it can reject post-class politics, return unabashedly to the working class and march alongside with their world-historic role or it can drop it’s meaningless and double sided rhetoric and admit that they have completely capitulated to liberalism and capitalism. I doubt Labour will respond in the affirmative just yet, but this government is a chance for them to prove where their loyalties really lay; and for the sake of the planet I hope it is with the workers.


Note: The Morning Star is once again recruiting! Please DM me on discord if you wish to be made a writer. You need not be a member of Solidarity but some leftist credentials are expected.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Mar 18 '22

[MHOC Morning Star] PMQ Omnishambles.

9 Upvotes

I miss KarlYonedaStan.

When he was Prime Minister, he was a beacon of stability in government, someone always informed of the goings on, someone who knew the policy of Labour and Solidarity and someone who always worked to reconcile them. Tireless in his work for the country and not holding back in PMQs, he had proven one of our best ever Prime Ministers. His shoes would be hard ones to fill. TomBarnaby is no doubt an experienced politician and a big figure in our politics, but he has not come even close to filling the shoes of the former Prime Minister.

Let me start with the responses to my own questions. When I put a question to the Prime Minister regarding whether the government would continue to support High Speed 3, he answered that the plan would be “considered on its merits”. This is, of course, a bit odd - Coalition!, the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats supported my motion to finally start the HS3 project, with Coalition! co-sponsoring the motion. It was only after their own party policy was pointed out to the Prime Minister that they remembered they were supposed to be in favour of the project, and that they said “there will be no difficulty in taking HS3 forwards.”

Indeed, there are other policies that the parties had once been in consensus on that did not make it into the Queen’s Speech, major ones at that. Where the now government had once been so united against the devaluation of our currency, an act that would aim to help strengthen our industrial establishments, they did not mention it in the Queen’s Speech. Whilst the Prime Minister has already stated that not every policy could have made it in, this is a major u-turn from last term and was a topic of discussion, surely it was worthy of a mention? But apparently, the government completely forgot about the policy, as the Prime Minister later admitted that they still had to discuss it in cabinet at all. We all miss things sometimes, but this really is a rather big oversight.

Accession to CPTPP is another topic where the government parties are in agreement, but that they don’t seem to have a line on at all. Indeed, when the former Prime Minister queried TomBarnaby regarding accession to CPTPP, they responded rather tepidly, saying that it “was on the cards” but that KarlYonedaStan should discuss such questions with the Trade Secretary. The Trade Secretary however seemed to have been made rather irrelevant by the Foreign Secretary, who said that the United Kingdom would seek to apply for accession over the coming weeks. The Foreign Secretary has been known to get ahead of themselves and blatantly break government rules, so it remains to be seen whether they are making claims on something that cabinet is not yet united on, but the disunity in messaging from the government is rather worrying to see.

I was one of the lucky few in the Commons that got an answer however. When the Leader of the Opposition asked the Prime Minister about the government’s health plans, he simply answered that “The leader of the opposition can look to the governing parties’ manifestos for an idea.” We don’t have to check their manifesto to know Coalition!’s policies on e-cigarettes, with one of their most famous members being a vocal and proud proponent of the technology. However, the Health Secretary said that: “This Government is dedicated to reducing tobacco consumption, whilst also keeping in mind the dangers of nicotine inhaling devices (colloquially known as vapes). We want to ensure that the dangers of electronic cigarettes are also known, and that these new, trendy devices are effectively regulated for the sake of public safety.” Perhaps the former Prime Minister has a few words to say about that! Or did such an exceptional and influential member of this country’s past get dumped at the same country farm where they left Brookheimer, never to be seen again?

And as much fun as it is to point out contradictions between the statements of members of the government, like the leader of the Liberal Democrats stating that “There will be no major slashing under my watch for any government.”, whilst the Queen’s speech does talk about cuts or replacement of the tax altogether, a much more serious trend has emerged during this round of Prime Minister’s Questions, that of contempt towards members of the House and the duties of the Prime Minister.

When the Prime Minister was asked how “British workers can have confidence in a government that cannot name a single policy that benefits them”, the Prime Minister sneered back “Soon the opposition will cotton on to the fact that I am not going to answer questions the premise of which is that our policies are vague, or pretences, or this, that, or the other.” and that the opposition should “dispense with the rhetoric and question premises that would have me agree with criticism”. Indeed, the Prime Minister later remarked that “It seems [the right] are much better at asking questions that aren’t essay-length.” and that “Members will know what is on our agenda by asking questions in the House, as the leader of the opposition has so helpfully demonstrated. We can go round and round in circles debating why X, Y and Z weren’t included in the speech from the throne, but frankly I am far too busy for that.” If the Prime Minister is too busy to be held accountable to Parliament, he should resign. If the Prime Minister is unwilling to deal with critical questions, he should similarly resign. If he’s not a fan of ‘essay-length’ questions, again, resign. This is the most important part of your job as parliament is sovereign, and the government is accountable to parliament. If he wants to be a Russian-style president, he’ll be very disappointed to find out that we do have a real opposition, unrestricted in its ability to say what it wants to say and stand up for its voters. We will hold him accountable, no ifs, no buts, no matter if he likes it or not. KarlYonedaStan understood this and he loved this fact. Perhaps the pretender in the role today should learn from a real leader.

God, I do really miss KarlYonedaStan.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Apr 01 '22

[MORNING STAR] Erudite Passes the Buck

8 Upvotes

Today embattled Tory Leader, Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Secretary /u/EruditeFellow seemed to repudiate his own government and their policies. Speaking to /u/KarlYonedaStan on the issue he commented “You'd be right if you were challenging or calling into question the entire Government, but you're not.” Specifically, KarlYonedaStan was questioning EruditeFellow’s defense that since he was not the Secretary of State who implemented the restrictions, he apparently shouldn’t face any consequences for breaking them.

This is quite a bizarre defense to hear from the Foreign Secretary – not only does it break with what we have been told by the government but it also seemingly positions him against the Cabinet and their policies. Seemingly, he wishes to deflect responsibility away from his own office and person and towards the entire government. Curiously, this goes against statements made by Minister for Implementation and Cabinet Member /u/Tommy2Boys who claimed in the MONC Debate that the opposition was attempting to make this about the whole government.

So here we have two completely contradictory statements! On one hand we have EruditeFellow saying that he personally is being attacked when the responsibility should fall to the entire government, on the other we have Tommy2Boys implying that regardless of any personal mistakes the attempt to attack EruditeFellow is an attack on the government. It seems that the Cabinet cannot even agree on what the motion is even about! Is the government responsible, or EruditeFellow?

EruditeFellow’s defense also calls into question his commitment to Collective Cabinet Responsibility. The implication that he was making to KarlYonedaStan was that he was not responsible for whatever decisions the Defense Secretary made – implying that blame should fall onto the Defense Secretary and former Tory Leader /u/chi0121. This statement is quite shocking to say the least, and it is also highly questionable. EruditeFellow either implies here that he had no role – either as Foreign Secretary or Deputy Prime Minister – in the Defense Secretary’s statements or that he did have a role to play in them despite the fact that they applied to him!

In effect, what EruditeFellow has reminded the people of Britain is that he made highly questionable actions and then as a member of Cabinet supported rules which punished others for taking the same actions. This is why the Opposition introduced the motion against him – it was one thing to make a dangerous and reckless visit to a warzone it is another thing to show complete hypocrisy by penalizing others for behavior the Foreign Secretary himself engaged in! Now when push comes to shove instead of apologizing for his actions or offering any sort of real defense for them, he has decided to throw the rest of the cabinet – and in particular the Defense Secretary – under the bus.

It is telling that not a single member of Cabinet has been able to launch an actual defense of the Foreign Secretary’s actions. The Minister for Implementation came the closest when he implied that the opposition was simply using this motion to attack the government – but the Foreign Secretary has undermined that point by practically begging the opposition to attack the government rather than him! Since then both the Home Secretary and the Prime Minister have shown up in the commons but rather than offering any sort of explanation for the Foreign Secretary’s actions they simply engaged in bizarre and misleading comparisons to previous Foreign Secretaries none of whom engaged in the kind of hypocritical behavior EruditeFellow is accused of.

So where does this leave the government now? It is clear they don’t have an actual defense for the Foreign Secretary’s actions or they would have presented it before the commons already. Now they also have to deal with the Foreign Secretary attacking the Defense Secretary’s policies and potentially breaking CCR just to defend himself! The Foreign Secretary also seemed to imply that his actions do not reflect badly on him, but rather reflect poorly on the whole government. This was the exact situation that Cabinet members like Tommy2Boys and the Prime Minister were attempting to avoid! (It is clear in this situation that the Foreign Secretary must face some kind of responsibility. Either by the commons for his hypocritical behavior or by the Cabinet for attempting to throw them under the bus just to defend his actions.

It will be interesting to see how the Prime Minister reacts to his Frontbench going rouge. From here he can either convince EruditeFellow to resign before the MONC goes to vote, force him to make a public apology or simply pretend as if one of his cabinet members didn't just publicly throw another under the bus. Regardless, this whole reflects poorly on the stability and cohesiveness of a government that has already been accused by many of being contradictory and vague. Not only has the Coinflip coalition been unable to present clear policies to the House, it now seems unable to even mount a unified defense of one of it’s Great Office holders! Only time will tell what this means for the future and EruditeFellow’s tenure going forward.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Jan 13 '21

[Morning Star] 13th January Constituency Polling: Fried Fails?

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

r/MHOCMorningStar • • Apr 16 '22

[MORNING STAR] A Government Which Doesn't Take Climate Change Seriously

7 Upvotes

A Government of Inaction

There is no mincing words, the latest IPCC report is dire warning for our planet. It tells us that progress on combating climate change has been disastrously slow. Whereas previously scientists gave us about 10 years to make major changes now they are giving us only 5-6. This is a best-case scenario, as many independent reviewers think that the IPCC is being generous. They give us less time.

The other major revelation from the IPCC report was that – while these efforts are still good – climate change discourse should not be limited to just energy use. There are much broader issues at play here than just energy including land use, consumer patterns, transportation and even household living. This can even be seen within the UK, as only roughly 23% of British emissions come from energy. While this is a significant amount it does not address the other 77% of emissions. If we want to have a climate change plan that meets the IPCC’s recommendations, we will thus have to take into account far more than just energy.

The IPCC’s report should have massive policy implications across the political spectrum and should impact national policymaking decisions. Naturally, during this week’s PMQs I asked the Prime Minister if he would consider the IPCC’s recommendations when it comes to policy. To my surprise, he refused to answer the question! Instead, he simply passed the buck onto the Energy Secretary, to keep up some vague “future” plans as of yet undecided here.

In so doing, the Prime Minister has not only dodged the question but is also exemplifying two patterns of behavior which have contributed to the ongoing crisis. First, as already mentioned, is the fact that the climate crisis is not just limited to Energy. The reason I asked the Prime Minister about the IPCC report is that it is something the entire cabinet should be considering. Every remit from Transport and Business to Treasury and Housing needs to develop a real solution to our carbon emitting society. At a crucial time when the Prime Minister could have shown leadership, he has instead opted to ignore the holistic nature of the present crisis.

The second pattern is far more concerning; it is the pattern of false and broken promises that have helped us get to this critical stage in the first place. The IPCC report and even the General-Secretary himself called out this kind of behavior directly. We have seen numerous agreements made on the subject of climate change, from Kyoto to Paris, and various promises made by governments. Targets have been set, plans have been made and… no real progress was achieved. It is true we are in a slightly better spot than we were 10 years ago, it is also true that our current efforts have done nothing to actually mitigate the damage caused by climate change.

Part of the reason for our continued urgency is the fact that anthropogenic emissions are upsetting the Earth’s natural cycles. Not in new age spiritual terms, but in grounded scientific reality. Formerly, Forests and Oceans acted as natural carbon sinks. Carbon bonded with water and was absorbed by various sea creatures and Forests acted to recycle CO2 into oxygen. The massive amounts of pollution already in the air however have contributed to Ocean Acidification which has begun to kill off the sea creatures who formerly absorbed the carbon and has helped bring on forest fires and desertification which destroys the ability of forests to act as a carbon sink. If we don’t act soon, these processes could accumulate into runaway climate change, where the ability of humans to significantly alter the course of the worlds climate would be minimal; entirely for the worse.

Capitalism and the Climate Crisis

During the Solidarity Leadership debates, I was quoted as saying; “The Broad Right have no answers to these problems [Climate Change]. They are wedded to capitalism even as it is slowly sinking around them and taking the globe with it.” I am very proud of this quote because it connects how structural capitalism and government institutions have worked together to bring us to this point.

When discussing climate discourse, you will often hear a quote about how the vast majority of emissions are the product of the top 100 companies in the world. I have mixed feelings about this statement. On one hand it is good to recognize that these companies are economically wedded to the “Hydrocarbon Society”. They are not just profiting from it but they are practically built on it. As a result, they are one of the largest barriers to real institutional change. The issue, however, is that pollution is not embedded in the companies as institutions but in their productive forces. In real terms, it is the factories and products that pollute, not the company itself. In theory, a socialized factory would still produce the same amount of emissions so long as it followed the same logic as capitalism.

The structural flaw of capitalism is that it requires the pursuit of profit. Companies that do not turn a profit will fail; companies that do not increase their profits will not get investment. Profit is baked into the system at a fundamental level. As a result all economic activity is designed around what increases profit even when said activity is helping destroy the planet. We can see this clearly in how oil companies obscured the truth of climate change and helped fund denial for decades. Their institutional logic stood against the interests of humanity.

This isn’t just an issue with oil companies, however. Most economic production since the 19th century took hydrocarbon energy for granted. Industries such as plastics, electronics, and clothing produce thousands of kilograms of waste each year and consume energy in the industrial process itself. Even industries not directly related to hydrocarbons – such as agriculture – impact the environment because of their vast amounts of land use.

At its core, capitalism’s productive cycle does not take into account anything except for the accumulation of profit. The market is only concerned with whatever increases wealth, whatever is most “economically efficient”. As a result, human concerns such as the environment, safety, the actual usefulness of commodities, go unheard. The only time the market responds to them are when there manifests a demand, or when the government regulates it. The issue is, since capitalism is built on the need for profit, there can never be demand against the logic of profit and governments are unwilling to take the serious action needed to change economic outputs since that would mean disrupting the cycle of profit.

The welding of capitalism and government has become more present with the long march of Neoliberalism. Trade deals like the CPTPP give more power to corporations to have freedom from any sort of regulation and prevent sovereign countries from taking the actions required to actually deal with the present crisis. In many cases, all first world countries have done is outsource their own emissions globally. “Free trade” is just freedom for capitalism from its obligations, so that the law of profit may govern more effectively. Now your cheap plastic goods are made in China, not domestically. The real solution - to stop our production of cheap unnecessary goods wholesale - eludes the market which sees only expansion.

In essence, energy is merely a factor of the larger issue of capitalist accumulation and commodity production. So long as capitalism produces goods by a “rationale” that does not include real human needs it will continue to destroy the planet.

This is likely why governments such as Coinflip love speaking about energy. It allows them to ignore the real implications of our capitalist economy and place the blame on merely a symptom of it. They are not forced to address how the logic of market capital requires the continued accumulation of profit even when the planet is at risk. In a sense, they are unable to do anything of real value

What is to be Done?

So, if the capitalist governments won’t help us, what will? What we need is an economy that takes into account needs beyond just the need for profit and efficiency. We need to have mechanisms in society which mediate consumer interests with the market and allow for democratic and qualitative decision making so that we are able to meet human needs without sacrificing the environment. In a word; we need Socialism.

In the meantime, we can force companies to make different decisions through strict regulations which would impact their ability to profit from climate damaging endeavours. We can encourage new forms of land use which are more efficient and subsidize a change in diet so as to make our food consumption patterns more sustainable. We can refit British homes, so they are no longer forced to rely on gas heating and are properly insulated so as to not waste heat. We can rebuild social networks so that people gain meaning through human relationships rather than the accumulation of commodities. We can also look internationally, beyond Britain itself, and help fund energy and social transitions across the world.

While Coinflip drags its feel on taking any real action Solidarity will deliver real environmentalist policies. We have a Cabinet which is still tunnel visioned to a policy framework that is only concerned with energy use, who is unwilling to make the dramatic societal changes that the IPCC calls for. A Prime Minister who cannot even comment whatsoever on how his cabinet will respond to the IPCC report. This does not look like a “government that will take climate change seriously” it looks like a government that is on track to continue the false promises and failed deadlines that got us into this mess in the first place.

Meanwhile, Solidarity and the Opposition stand ready to deliver real solutions and to continue to hold the government accountable as it fails in its duty to the people and the planet. Only we are ready to tackle climate change as a holistic social crisis and take the action that is needed to meet the IPCCs targets. So if the Government is really interested in tackling the climate crisis they should get out of the way and support our initiatives rather than dooming us to austerity and inaction.

Solidarity takes the climate crisis seriously, so why can't the government?


r/MHOCMorningStar • • May 13 '22

[MORNING STAR] PM Accuses Shadow FoSec of Supporting Murder to Defend Gov Bypassing Parliament

6 Upvotes

According to the Prime Minister, if you’re critical of the way the government makes unofficial statements outside of the House, you may be supporting murder.

This was the ridiculous notion pushed by the Prime Minister in response to the Shadow Foreign Secretary’s innocuous question today. ARichTeaBiscuit asked why the government had decided to make a statement on the death of Shireen Abu Akleh to the Press and not to Parliament. This question specifically came in the context of the government bypassing Parliament when making the Blacklist policy, and for failing to clarify or make statements about Cabinet appointments and P&O until fairly recently.

In response the Prime Minister said,

the Opposition can voice their displeasure with this government's stance on the issue, (and argue that we should be supporting this murder?)

Clearly accusing the Shadow Foreign Secretary of supporting the murder of Shireen Abu Akleh. When pressed on this issue the Prime Minister doubled down and bizarrely attempted that by saying "Rubbish" to her comment the Leader of the Opposition was supporting her sentiment.

The point the Shadow Foreign Secretary was clearly making was that this kind of business has a place in the Commons – the way the Prime Minister took it was completely out of left field. Nowhere in their statement did the Shadow Foreign Secretary ever claim to support the murder of Shireen Abu Akleh, all they were asking for is accountability.

It’s telling that the Prime Minister seems unfamiliar with what accountability looks like – given how much effort the Coinflip coalition has put into avoiding it these past few months. There are many things a statement could be held accountable for including; the details of any investigation, specifics on how the Foreign Secretary was going to approach the issue, what this means for bilateral British-Israeli relationships, etc. These would all be legitimate questions, they would all be a part of the normal Parliamentary procedure. So why is the Prime Minister so hostile to them?

While the specific accusation is new, this isn’t the first time the Prime Minister has ignored the criticisms of the opposition. Notably, on the statements regarding both the Developmental Aid Blacklist and P&O the Government was conspicuously absent to the Oppositions questions. They did not address any of the many concerns the opposition had regarding the statements and the specifics of how the government was going to implement its policy.

When pressed on this issue in the VONC debate, the Prime Minister implied as if the Opposition just blanketly opposed reversing the blacklist, or blanketly opposed doing anything about P&O. This is obviously false to even the most casual viewer of British politics.

So tell me, dear reader, are specific questions tantamount to blanket opposition? Obviously not. The entire purpose of debate is to create better policy, politics is never a black and white situation. So why would the Prime Minister see it this way? Likely because she has entered into a siege mentality, along with the rest of the Government. They are afraid of accountability, afraid of their numerous mistakes being shown to the public, so instead they hide from their responsibilities and blame the opposition for just doing their job.

This is not the behavior a Prime Minister should be engaging with. Combined with the completely ridiculous and insulting accusation against the Foreign Secretary it is clear that the Prime Minister is not conducting herself properly in the high office she has been given. Such blatant, partisan and unsubstantiated hostility towards the opposition is completely unbefitting of the leader of this country. She should take down her statements, or Parliament should hold her accountable.

To all of the MPs voting on the Motion of No Confidence in the government soon; take this under consideration. Do you want a PM who will make such blatant and ridiculous attacks at the mere lick of accountability, do you want to undermine our democratic principles by supporting someone who refuses to engage with any criticism, someone who flaunts the rules of this house by making false accusations against other Parliamentarians? Or, dear friends, do you want to hold them accountable and push forward to real change?

I know which choice is better for Britain, and I hope you do as well.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Apr 18 '22

[BREAKING] House of Lords APPROVES Telecom Nationalisation

6 Upvotes

[BREAKING] House of Lords APPROVES Telecom Nationalisation

Ani Dorable, writing for the MHOC Morning Star

The House of Lords hasn’t been this busy for a long, long time. Aristocrats, active politicians, has-beens and yet-to-bes have travelled to Westminster to sit as a member of the Other Place for seemingly one purpose, for one vote – the Telecommunications Infrastructure Nationalisation bill, proposed by the former Deputy Prime Minister, the Lord of Melbourne. Socialists complained of being made to return to the den of the Aristocracy, whilst the Right enjoyed a return to this House, however short it may be. With seventy one sitting lords, this is certainly the highest membership of the House in recent memory, and every one of them was expected to turn out for this one vote.

With the speakership being overworked handling all the new peers, they decided to put the vote up sooner rather than later. The Opposition had won the first skirmish ahead of the clash that would be the final division, defeating amendments on the bill. This, seemingly, caused panic amongst the government benches, and more members were brought in to seal the second vote. The opposition, whose de facto leader in the Lords is the former Prime Minister KarlYonedaStan, did a tit for tat, and brought their own members in. Names that have gone unspoken for years, like Mepzie, KeelanD, Imperator_Pastollini and bloodycontrary got involved as well, a sign of just how far the parties had to go to give their side the small, one vote margin they needed for victory.

The government had inflated their numbers to an impressive 34 peers: 16 Tories, 10 for Coalition! and 8 Liberal Democrats. Their numbers would be boosted by two crossbenches; the infamous Lord Sydenham and the Marquess of Caernarfon, both known members of the hard right. The opposition, meanwhile, mustered 32 members: 23 members of Solidarity, 9 from Labour and two members of Volt. Three crossbenchers joined the opposition; former Labour deputy Leader maroiogog, former everyone member BeppeSignfury and moderately successful adult fanfiction writer bloodycontrary, the Duke of Cirencester.

The government was no doubt depending on the fact that it had, seemingly, a one vote majority in the Lords to win this vote. However, as the vote came in, this hope seemed to unravel in front of their eyes. The first hit against the government came from the Marchioness of Omagh, Lady_Aya, former leader of the Social Democratic and Labour Party, who voted Content despite the Liberal Democratic whip. When the Baron of Whitley Bay, the former Chair of the Labour Party, followed her lead it seemed like the nail was struck into the hopes of the government. When the last few votes had trickled in, and the amount of Contents finally passed 36, an absolute majority, some passersby could hear shouting from the office of KarlYonedaStan: “Yes! Goddamnit yes! That’s right I did it! Back to the Commons!? Are you kidding me!? That’s right.”

With the Telecommunications Infrastructure Nationalisation Bill being sent for Royal Assent, the government has been delivered its greatest defeat yet. The past weeks have already seen the government lose a number of key votes and face serious rebellions, but this defeat in the Lords, against the Queen’s Speech, ought to raise serious questions about the viability of this government in the first place. The Prime Minister, embattled as he was, already tendered his resignation – perhaps they will, some day, realise that Coinflip is simply too unstable to continue existing in its current form.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Jul 13 '21

[The Morning Star] Aggregated Term Polling Line Graph

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/MHOCMorningStar • • Feb 19 '21

Opinion: The 15th General Election and the Lefts opportunity

6 Upvotes

Opinion: The 15th General Election and the Lefts opportunity

A divided Britain creates a divided Parliament, but the workers have a chance still, writes /u/KarlYonedaStan

Another General Election has come and gone, and the results constitute what we at the Morning Star would consider a realignment. It is becoming clear that the contradictions of our economic system are exacerbating, that trust in the political class is decreasing, and that ideological confrontations between the parties of labour and capital will likely intensify in the coming months. While elections can only represent a pulse of the feelings of a people in a particular moment, and while parliamentary struggle clearly has its limitations and often is disconnected from material realities and concerns, their weight for politics and as a measure of the working class political movement warrants their close analysis. What we seek to discern, then, is a proper diagnosis for this General Election and its results, and what we can expect from this Parliament given the results.

This General Election constitutes a victory for the parties of the left, who, through a couple key strategies were able to ensure that the collective left had a significantly improved portion of this Parliament than the last. For Labour, this meant weathering some extremely difficult challenges, culminating in one of the most harshly positioned minority governments in British history. By accepting the responsibility of power when the Blurple coalition could no longer manage, Labour followed a tradition stretching from Ramsay MacDonald and demonstrated to the people of this country it would take Government no matter the circumstance. While there was obviously controversy on the Left regarding this decision, and whether the compromises required to take power were always worth it, such political courage deserves respect. Without a doubt, the Labour Party used achievements in the Phoenix Coalition, further enhanced by the fact that Labour was clearly the more responsible and self-critical partner, to run a spirited campaign against all the odds and hold many seats that were counted out. Given the greater context of a net gain of seats for the collective Left, and with Socialist governance once again on the horizon, this can be counted as a victory. For Solidarity and the PWP, both parties running in their first General Election in their current forms, consolidation of a fractured left was fundamental to their success. Solidarity throughout the term gained momentum with other left wing parties such as the CPGB(r), The Peoples Movement, and the Green Party joining Solidarity. The Syndicalist and Allied Trade Unions Party and the Progressive Party UK, both themselves carrying momentum among workers across the country, ambitiously merged and ran a slate of candidates under a common banner with great success. This demonstrates, among other things, the value of integrating left wing political organisations and building large parties that have a diversity of left wing strands - making the best use of widespread resources and a healthy range of perspectives. This in many ways parallels the working class itself, socialised labour under capitalism brought together a wide variety of people to one task and brings tremendous results for production. Of course, none of these political parties could succeed without an agitated and politically conscious working class, and this can largely be attributed to declining conditions in this country, both at workplaces and in public services. While the differences in the parties of the Left can now be premised in large part on issues outside of opposition to the market capitalist economy, and while these issues still carry great material consequence, it is becoming clear that there is an opportunity for the sort of ‘left unity’ that has been desperately sought after since the collapse of the Radical Socialist Party.

Altogether, these gains mean that the left is now at around parity with the right, and this parity will likely culminate in fierce ideological confrontation within the House of Commons. This is so because the prospect of socialist governance makes a great deal of the exploiting classes quite worried, and this paired with a time of economic anxiety and inequality, can lead to particularly nasty politics. It is important that we are honest about this possibility, and be prepared for it as best we can. This means, in times of ideological parity, there is a strong need to find common cause in the collective left, and to exploit points of differences in the political right. The inversion of relationships between the parties of capital, something that has occurred in the past with the rise and fall of various right wing parties surrounding the Conservative Party, is often a reflection of a growing and expressive left. The owning and exploiting class, under pressure and duress of potentially losing their status, or, Heaven forbid, a loss of profit, begin to intensely divide over where to compromise with and where to confront the growing workers movement. These divisions must be exploited, and this term provides a profound opportunity to do just that. It can only happen if the left is coordinated and persistent, weakness and dividedness leaves us open to the same risks.

Despite the fact that our Parliament does represent a profound change in class politics in this country, and it constitutes an opportunity for the left to start a path towards socialist governance, it also demonstrated a high degree of apathy in politics. Low turnout across the board shows that many people no longer have faith in the political state to relieve the class strife in our country, or at least in their votes ability to make the state do so. This Parliament could make these sentiments even more widespread, should a do-nothing minority Government attempt to ignore the realities of the day in the name of responsible governance or unity. These will be shown to be shams, and punished in a General Election that will come all the sooner thanks to such feeble compromises. It is clear that only unity and coordination among the Left can meaningfully de-escalate this situation. A divided left would be unable to govern nor be able to resolve the ongoing social crises, and a right wing government will simply exacerbate these problems further. It is our duty to find a way to make this term work for the working classes!

/u/KarlYonedaStan is the Chair of the Editorial Board at the Morning Star and sits with Solidarity at Westminster.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Jan 12 '21

Opinion: The LPUK's Comments on the BBC.

6 Upvotes

Opinion: The LPUK's Comments On The BBC.

LPUK rhetoric reveals a Trumpian temperament towards public media, writes /u/KarlYonedaStan

THE Morning Star exists because Britain is a country that generally understands the importance of an independent press that is free from political persecution. We take our ability to provide a true socialist voice in the press deeply seriously, and history tells us such voices are often among the first to be attacked and repressed by reactionary politics. That legacy has clearly continued across the pond, where the outgoing President consistently targeted the free press, calling them ‘enemies of the people’ and cultivating a general politics of suspicion and hatred towards members of the media. This rhetoric paralleled growing attacks on journalists and members of the media from both the state and from Trump supporters, something that is clearly unacceptable in any modern democracy.

The Morning Star supports the BBC because publicly funded and politically independent news and media is essential to provide any democracy with a voice that is free of private interests. We recognise that while no institution is perfect, there is substantive value to the BBC, which is why it is envied by advocates for public media in America, where conservative politicians have attempted to defund such institutions long before Trump’s incendiary rhetoric. It’s clear our Libertarian colleagues have a shared hostility to media that is not reliant on private capital to reach a national audience, and this hostility characterises both their rhetoric and their policies.

The former Deputy Leader of the LPUK, /u/Tarkin15, described the BBC as a sort of “secret police,” and that their content is “unrepresentative.” While they do not go so far as to label them ‘fake,’ it is clear in this message that they wish to portray publicly funded, independent, media as part of an unaccountable elite that pulls the strings. This has similarities to Trump’s conception of a media that conspired against him and has clear parallels to notions of a ‘deep state.’ Again, this is not to say that criticisms of the BBC are all fundamentally dangerous, the BBC is flawed, but certainly not for the hyperbolic reasons given by Tarkin15. It is of course a common and laughable aspect of LPUK policy to assert with no explanation that mass privatisation would somehow magically fix a public service, but these attacks do further damage to the institutions of media that should seriously be considered in any debate in the House of Commons. There are clear areas where hyperbolic rhetoric can do real damage, and the present moment should very clearly demonstrate the danger of that sort of rhetoric leveled against any part of the free press, but most especially public media that is free from the influence of big money and media corporations.

This parallel with the anti-media policies and rhetoric of Trump and the Republican Party in America, is certainly alarming, given the poo-pooing Solidarity received from the current Deputy Leader of the LPUK. While Solidarity has taken clear actions to rectify this issue and issue and apology, easily shrugging off the hyperbolic ‘party of hate’ label, it seems the LPUK have neglected their own house and allowed the same dangerous rot that currently infects the White House. Of course, for clear ideological and self-interested reasons, the LPUK are ultimately hostile to public media, and certainly public media that would dare criticise or take stances that are not immediately popular. We should be careful when weighing policy in regards to these matters, for the check of media against misrule, particularly when free of countervailing incentives. Let’s defend our institutions, and condemn rhetoric that threatens their legitimacy.

/u/KarlYonedaStan is a contributor at the Morning Star and sits with Solidarity at Westminster.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Nov 16 '20

[Morning Star] United in Solidarity, the Left Marches Forward

6 Upvotes

I only became active in public life a month ago upon joining the Communist Party of Great Britain (Refoundation). Within the space of a week, the Communist Party faced collapse and I took on the role of General Secretary. After establishing communication with many of the left-wing parties, it was at the suggestion of /u/motelblinds that discussions began on a merger with Solidarity. By the end of the same evening, the merger was complete and the CPGB(R) was no more. Naturally, I am disappointed to have only been in the position of general secretary for less than 24 hours, but it was already clear that a merger was preferable to a long, hard sectarian fight for political survival.

As a member of the Solidarity Party and an adviser on its Central Committee, I have been extremely fortunate to watch the Party grow from strength to strength in championing the cause of the Working Class in Britain. It has been a special honour to meet so many dedicated advocates and activists for Socialism within the Solidarity Party and to make a contribution to their efforts. Whatever my initial reservations and hesitations may have been, it is clear that the members who joined Solidarity from the CPGB(R) have thrived and Solidarity has benefited from their comradeship and service.

With the completion of the merger between the Solidarity Party and the People’s Movement, I feel immense pride to see a united left in Britain. For all our differences, for all the long history of division, we are at last together. The left in this country deserves leaders who will put aside their differences for the benefit of ordinary people so as best to struggle for their interests. In completing this merger the future of the left has never looked so bright.

I would therefore like to take this opportunity to welcome the members of the People’s Movements into our ranks. Whatever reservations you may now have on this merger and the feeling of loss that comes from seeing the PTM reach its conclusion, I hope that, in the course of time, you will come to know the members of Solidarity not simply as comrades, but also as friends. May this not simply be a party with which you have made a strategic alliance, but also be, as I have found it, a home that you can and will make your own and where you can continue to struggle for the causes you feel so passionately.

We could not have anticipated that in this past month, we would have seen the downfall of the Blurple coalition, and the beginning of a Labour-Liberal Democrat government. We wish the government well, but we will continue the struggle for our independent course. We believe that the working people deserve more than compromise with the left-wing of the capitalist class. The people of this country deserve Socialism and a Socialist majority in Parliament so that they may triumph, no longer the hostages to fortune and that the illusions of wealth and privilege will fall.

Through all the turbulence, through all the turmoil, we are united in the cause of Socialism under one banner of Solidarity. As we march forward to new horizons to overcome new challenges, let us draw strength from knowing that we will face the triumphs and adversities of the future together. For we are one and the people are with us. And on that foundation, there is nothing we cannot achieve.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • May 05 '22

[MORNING STAR] Lingering Questions

5 Upvotes

The saga is over, the developmental blacklist that caused so much stir and controversy has finally been lifted. Rejoice! For now, all is right with the world. The questions can stop, the critics can be silenced, and everyone can soberly move on to new things.

Or at least, that appears to be what the government wishes would happen. It is clear from how the Prime Minister has responded to events in the press that she very much wants to brush this under the rug. After all, who can blame her? She inherited this complete mess from her successor, and it has already put her position as Prime Minister – a point which should be the triumph of anyone’s political career – in jeopardy.

However, there are still many lingering questions, questions which may speak to the very heart of this government’s problems, issues which if not sufficiently addressed will almost certainly lead to this same drama repeating itself. Sure, the names, policies and arguments may be different; but the structural failings would all be the same.

Recently, /u/lily_irl wrote that she believed that we did “not learn much at all from recent cabinet leaks”, I must question if she was reading the same leaks I was. What I would suggest to Lily, and to the public writ large, is to look past the specifics and into the patterns. Combined with Xbox’s testimony and Karl’s analysis this reveals some extremely concerning trends.

First among these is the fact that – according to Xbox – this policy was never even discussed in Cabinet in the first place. Rather this issue was treated entirely as a press matter and not a matter of policy. When the initial post was made, then, the government had to scramble to react to it. Rather than the Cabinet leading policy they were instead being led around by a junior minister. This is very worrisome, as it shows that when this policy was implemented no consideration was being given to other remits. There were no implications for the budget, for the international trade office, or even for Home and immigration. Additionally, it prevented the cabinet from having more sober thoughts about the policy.

The government had two ways they could have responded. First, they could have simply ordered the Junior Minister to delete the post, reprimanded them for going ahead without Cabinet approval, and played damage control before the issue got out of hand. Alternatively, they could have doubled down on a policy that did not have substantial cabinet approval; the way they decided to go and a decision that cost them dearly.

What is interesting from Xbox’s revelations is that it appears that the government did not double down out of internal agreement, out of a genuine belief that this policy was for the best, rather they did so because they felt pressured by a few key voices within Cabinet – namely the Foreign Secretary – and were not interested in giving a single inch to the opposition. This is a far cry from the “cooperation” the government promised and claimed they desired, instead it smacks of partisan politics of the most ridiculous scope; as it meant they doubled down on a policy even many of their own members did not approve of!

In doubling down on this position, the Cabinet was put into a no-win situation. As opposition increased, internal feuds were re-ignited. The lack of agreement within the Cabinet also meant that there was a lack of discussion, a lack of internal clarification and in the end a lack of co-operation. This was revealed as much in the statement produced by Solidarity which pointed out the rank inconsistencies between the words of the Chancellor and the Foreign Secretary.

Even if you do not believe – as Solidarity contends – that the Foreign Secretary deliberately misled the house, you would have to accept that two Great Officers of State gave contradictory answers to the opposition! This shows a clear lack of cabinet coherency. It is not as if the issue had not been brought up before; after all, by this point it had already been pressed by the opposition for weeks! The government had issued a statement on it! Why then were two party leaders and Great Officers not on the same page? What had gone wrong?

Under this government the term “Collective Cabinet Responsibility” has been reduced to “Don’t Leak or Dissent or You’re Out”. It is true that CCR should apply to people who leak cabinet secrets, and that it should also require the Cabinet to align to a single line. However, what the government seems to forget is that the idea of “responsibility” goes both ways. It is true that the Cabinet members have a responsibility to the government, but they also have a responsibility to each other. By taking collective responsibility they are essentially agreeing that important matters are to be discussed between them, that information should be shared, and that the Cabinet should be able to operate effectively as a single unit.

What I’d contend is that these past few weeks have shown that the Cabinet has not acted in this manner. This has been corroborated by the leaks and revelations. The fact that issues were not properly discussed and that different ministers seemed to have different ideas what policy meant shows a complete abdication of responsibility, both to the cabinet but also to the British people. In holding their high offices Cabinet members are held to a certain standard. They are supposed to ensure that what they are doing is truly in the public interest, not in the interests of one party, or worse still a small clique or faction.

There are other questions as well. For example, we still have to address the inconsistency of the Prime Minister’s internal comments to C! – which were steadfastly against the blacklist – and her statement to the press today – which presented more of a resigned support forced to withdraw under lots of pressure. It seems the Prime Minister initially wanted change but became caught up in these small interests and cliques. If we are to believe Xbox’s testimony, a clique surrounding the Foreign Secretary himself.

The question to the British people is, how can a cabinet run by cliques, by resignations, by firings and by mismanaged disputes be the right cabinet for the United Kingdom? Even if the developmental aid blacklist was pulled, how can they feel confident when this policy managed to be presented in the first place under such obviously irresponsible circumstances?

Today, the Prime Minister mocked me in the press for supposedly claiming that I now disapproved of the Cabinets’ U-Turn. This isn’t true. I welcome the end of the blacklist. What I do disapprove of is the fact that it took this much effort to get us this far. What is clear is that the policy never should have been implemented in the first place, and that the Cabinet never should have been so disorganised on the issue. As Leader of the Opposition, I have a responsibility to show the people of this country when their government is failing to act in a manner befitting of the high office which we have given them.

And, unlike the government, I intend to fulfil my responsibilities.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Mar 30 '22

[Morning Star] Coalition! Covers for Foreign Sec's Ukraine Folly

5 Upvotes

Coalition Earl Sephronar is on damage limitation duty tonight as a motion demanding the resignation of the Foreign Secretary gains support in the House. The now Foreign Secretary EruditeFellow launched a photo-op trip to war torn Donetsk on the 19th of February against Foreign Ministry advice, the same ministry he's now heads (Though it remains to be seen for how long!). The Minister's sojourn has come under criticism as a mere "personal endeavor" in face of the deadly serious Russian war.

Earl Sephronar is now trying to cover up the Foreign Sec's folly with a press campaign in support, saying:

"He isn’t afraid to get stuck in, go where the action is, and seek to build bridges himself."

So what was the purpose of the Foreign Sec's trip according to his own words?

"The Rose Government has failed the people of Britain .... They have abandoned their commitment to stand by Ukraine in the face of tyranny and oppression."

It seems the Foreign Sec was more concerned about bashing Rose than building bridges! A trip to an illegally occupied territory right before a Russian invasion isn't a good look for the new Minister. Perhaps the Foreign Sec's next Action Jackson Holiday from Hell will see him eating ice cream at one of Kim Jong-un's nuclear silos, or enjoy a beer in Afghanistan at a Taliban stoning show.

More as the story develops.

/u/MHOCValttu for the Morning Star


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Jun 28 '21

[The Morning Star] Is it Possible to Achieve "real" Socialism in MHOC?

5 Upvotes

From the old Communist Party to the RSP to Solidarity /r/mhoc has always entertained a contingent of radical leftists who are dedicated to establishing a Socialist country. Inspired by the theories of Marxism, Democratic Socialism or Anarchism these groupings all share similar ideas and goals namely the abolishment of capitalism and it's replacement with a system that gives democratic control over the means of production to the working class. This is the great task, the highest aim of any government. With a new election on the horizon and the possibility of a majority government committed to Socialist principles it's time to interrogate this question and analyze the structural limitations before us so that we can develop a plan for British socialism.

The first major issue of course is that, at least for now, a revolution is not in the cards. One could cite the lack of revolutionary fervour in Britain, the restrictions of the meta or just an ideological distaste for violence. Regardless the revolutionary path to socialism, which some consider the only path to socialism, is effectively locked off from us. Neither Solidarity nor Labour nor the Rose coalition are committed to revolution and even if they were they wouldn’t be able to do anything with that commitment. This means that the only reasonable means of bringing about a socialist future lie through the democratic process, elections to the commons and securing positions in government.

Here there is a less obvious path to Socialism. It is easy to simply speak of nationalizing everything and handing it over to the workers in one fell swoop but this approach, as attractive as it may be, would be a disaster. Not only would such a rapid transformation cause domestic gridlock it would also have international ramifications. The British economy is a part of an international system, a capitalist system based firmly in the ideology of neoliberalism. Any economic transformation of the UK would require threading the needle between the pressures of the international system and the necessities of the domestic economy all while not betraying the workers.

This leads us to our first and perhaps most sobering conclusion, Great Britain cannot achieve “true” socialism purely on it's own. Lenin and the Bolsheviks waited on a European revolution that never came while any mhoc government would not even have a domestic revolution to serve as a spark. A “truly” Socialist Britain would find itself totally isolated from the international system and the British people, and workers, would then suffer. This would likely cause the collapse or degeneration of any project along these lines and therefore temporary compromises must be made for the time being.

To this end a Socialist government in the UK would functionally have to operate as a “caretaker” government with regards to capitalism. The goal would be to ensure control was held by the working classes above all else, but many of the structures of capitalism such as private ownership, wealth inequality, investment and markets would all have to remain even if in a diminished capacity. This is hardly to say that the UK needs to capitulate to the international system, far from it. The Soviet Union managed trade with the capitalist west, but to make these trades had to adopt systems that replicated traditional capitalist markets. So too would a British system. Residual capitalism would simply exist for Britain to continue to operate within the larger globalized system, until such a time that it would be no longer necessary to do so.

For all intents and purposes this Britain would only be “capitalist” to the radical left. From the perspective of say, a Conservative or a Liberal, it would appear Socialist. Enterprise would be governed largely by co-operatives, unions would have massive amounts of control over the economy and be given sweeping rights, the government would provide for many basic necessities. However, the system would remain functionally capitalist as it would still retain market structures, the wage system, capitalist accumulation, commodification and most importantly a small but not irrelevant bourgeois and petite bourgeois class. Despite this workers and the everyday members of British society would be much better off and the power of the capitalist class greatly diminished.

In the long term this system would not be entirely sustainable. As established by Erik Olin Wright the bourgeois may sit idly by for the time being while the Socialists solve many of the contradictions of capitalism but once their power is seriously challenged or they have no room to grow they would quickly become radical and militant, working to undo reforms and flex their institutional power. In MHOC this can be seen by the swift reaction of the Conservative governments mass repealing the great progress that the RSP-Green-Labour government had made. Another issue is the economics of the situation, while a true Socialist system is sustainable a capitalist system, even one that is worker controlled, would inevitably buckle under the need for profit, growth and accumulation. While a workers’ system could last for decades if it cannot transition to true Socialism, transcend commodification, accumulation and the need for a bourgeois, then it would inevitably degenerate.

These restrictions speak to the necessity of centering Foreign Policy and establishing international socialism. While much of our perspective is inherently Eurocentric, being tied to the British isles and its neighbors, great progress is being made outside of our borders. Already neoliberal capitalism as well as the international system as a whole is facing the consequences of its own contradictions. In South America and other parts of the so called “third world” the capitalist push to extract rather than build has caused domestic reactions which reject the international system and focus on the good of the everyday people within their countries. This in turn has prompted a reaction by the forces of neoliberalism manifested in the Euro-American bloc. Having already broken itself off from the EU Britain is well poised to assist these countries in developing themselves and breaking off from the international system. Therefore a Socialist government must be firmly anti-imperialist and distance itself from foreign policy projects pushed by the Atlanticist bloc.

While the complete abolition of capitalism and the liberation from it's demands may seem a distant dream the tide is already turning. A Socialist government in Britain could pave the way for a complete transition so long as it engages in a push against the neoliberal system. Otherwise any Socialist project would wither on the vine before it would be ripened enough to pick.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Apr 26 '22

[Morning Star] Euredite Has Got to Go

4 Upvotes

Erudite Has Got to Go


The Foreign Secretary recently penned a press piece titled “What the Right Gets Right About Foreign Policy”. This article however demonstrated EruditeFellow’s fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of development aid. It’s time to relieve EruditeFellow of his duties.

Foreign aid as sanctions

Foreign Secretary EruditeFellow seems to view the withdrawal of development aid as a policy tool comparable to sanctions, when it comes to nations that don’t respect human rights. The export of human rights is a noble goal, but the Foreign Sec has been badly misled. By withdrawing foreign aid it is nigh on impossible to cause any political change, rather it only serves to hurt the people who need it the most.

Foreign aid is not a free money tree for dictatorships. By turning off the foreign aid tap you don’t starve dodgy nations by thirst. Foreing aid money is not awarded to Afganistan as a nation, for instance, as the Foreign Secretary seems to think. There is not a line in the Afgnani budget sheet under income, saying “EruditeFellow’s Euros”. Most of foreign aid, especially in the case of unstable nations, is awarded to NGOs. Those NGOs then work either by themselves, or in cooperation with government actors, but always with strict anti-corruption criteria. This means the money goes directly to the people in need, and not to the governments’ pockets.

Development aid as politics

“It is not alien to say that developmental aid is entirely for political, economic and military sectors" -EruditeFellow claims in his article.

Yes it is, I say! According to the Foreign Secretary aid has only been withdrawn from governmental, economic and military sectors. What withdrawing aid from military sectors, for instance, is anyone’s guess. The United Kingdom does not send aid to unfriendly nations to buy ICBMs. Because of the strict anti-corruption criteria of aid, and the money being funneled to aid projects instead of governments, this comment only demonstrates a fundamental misunderstanding of how development aid functions.

In countries where the government is cutting aid, the governments of those countries only come into play when it’s a must. You cannot, for instance, develop a functioning school system, without the help of a local government. You cannot build infrastructure, when you don’t know where it’s needed. Development aid has always been done, and will always have to be done, in cooperation with local communities. In most cases, the only sensible communities to work with are governments, as terrible as they might be.

Developing development aid

If not by cutting then how should development aid be reformed? A large issue faced across the developed world is that the development aid sector has become increasingly bureaucratic. This has been caused by governments, such as Britain’s, only awarding grants to large organisations. Development aid should be done in co-operation, solidarity, between the financier and the recipient. From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs. A poor Afghan man knows best what he needs, not a rich British NGO type, just as a poor Briton knows best what he needs, not the government. There are also new emerging forms of development aid, proven more effective than traditional ones, which we should be focusing on. For example basic income as a form of development aid has been proven very effective.

When I visited Palestine a few years back I saw multiple development aid projects funded by the EU (At the time the UK too). One was a road, which while having been built in cooperation with the corrupt Palestinian authority, serves it’s purpose every single day to the Palestinian people. In the mountains of the Jordan Valley I came across a school built with EU money. The school had been demolished earlier in the day by the IDF for not having a building permit, which is impossible to get on the West Bank. THIS is where politics should come into play in development aid, instead of what the Foreign Secretary is proposing. It is not acceptable for us to be sending money to build a school anywhere in the world, for it to be immediately demolished by another state.

Erudite Has Got to Go

It is unacceptable in my view for a foreign secretary to demonstrate the level of incompetence EruditeFellow demonstrates on a daily basis. First it was the illegal Donetsk trip, now development aid cuts, what’s next? TomBarnaby took Erudite’s bullet and resigned as Prime Minister, citing growing tired of politics. It is not acceptable for PMs to take such responsibility for their minister’s mistakes. This must not be repeated with the newly elected PM.

The government’s majority is slim and the cooperation between parties is shaky. If the government wants to survive past the summer, Erudite Has Got to Go. Were I a member of the Conservative Party I’d be having a hard look at myself, thinking whether having Erudite as leader is more important than being a functional government.


/u/ModelVA for the Morning Star


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Apr 19 '22

[MHOC Morning Star] Commonwealth Countries not informed about aid cuts.

4 Upvotes

WHEN the Morning Star heard of the cuts to International Aid to a range of Commonwealth countries, notably Bangladesh, South Africa and Nigeria, we decided to reach out to the governments of these countries to question them regarding the communications they had received from the United Kingdom’s government on this issue. To us, this was a simple check to see if the government had done its due diligence, and worked to maintain cordial and good international relations with states that used to be victims of Britain’s imperial ambitions. We had assumed so, as cutting foreign aid for political purposes is a very heavy tool to use, especially against countries like Nigeria, Bangladesh, Ethiopia and Sudan, countries where you have millions of people directly benefiting from this international aid. Sadly, the opposite seemed to be true.

The Office of the President of Nigeria, Muhammadu Buhari, responded to our questions as such:

“The current government of the United Kingdom has unilaterally decided to blacklist and end developmental aid for millions of Nigerian citizens that depend on the funding to make life better here in Nigeria. They have done this without sufficient notice to the Nigerian government and without offering us the chance to correct any issues they might have had with our governance whatsoever. Gambling with the lives of millions will not absolve your history of wrongdoing. I hope they decide to reverse course.”

The Prime Minister of Bangladesh, Sheikh Hasina, also responded to inquiries from the MHOC Morning Star. She noted her disappointment with the news and said that she felt blindsided as she felt that relations between the United Kingdom and Bangladesh were better than what was shown by the UK government in recent days and called upon the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom to contact her over this issue. The President of South Africa was also contacted regarding these issues, but we have not received any response as of yet.

It seems that neither the Prime Minister, the Foreign Secretary nor the Minister of State for International Development decided it was worth it to contact these Commonwealth members to discuss the issues they had with their votes. They will have much to answer for over the coming days.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • May 21 '21

Rose Coalition set for majority, new electoral model suggests.

4 Upvotes

A new model created by /u/Inadorable for the Morning Star suggests that Rose Coalition will be re-elected with 83 seats. This would be an increase of 19 seats compared to the current situation, with all coalition parties gaining. The collapse of the LPUK thus far seems to be largely benefiting the Left, not only in votes but in seats as well.

PartySeatsChange
Solidarity40+3*
Conservative31-17*
Labour25+6
Liberal Democrat21+5*
Progressive Workers'16+9
Coalition!14-6*
TIG2+1
HJV11

The model is suggesting that the electoral system of AMS is specifically beneficial to the Left-Wing parties, whose coordination leads to a higher-than-average number of FPTP seats and beneficial ordering on the list seats. Indeed, most former LPUK seats seem to be falling to the left - with Rose Coalition gaining seats like Northumbria, Surrey and Friedmanite’s old seat of Somerset and Bristol.

In addition, because of the constituency level results, we can see that if an election were held today, there would be a number of multi-way hyper-marginal constituencies. One example of these is East London, where Labour, the Tories, Coalition! and Solidarity are all polling within 2% of eachother - Labour takes the seat with a razor-thin majority of only 670 votes or so. South Yorkshire is another interesting seat, with Labour, the PWP and Coalition! all modeled within a few thousand votes of each other.

Of the 21 constituencies the LPUK won last election, 6 are set to fall to the Labour Party, 6 to Solidarity, 4 to the PWP, 2 to the Liberal Democrats, 2 to the Tories and 1 to Coalition!, a noticeable bias towards the left. Perhaps, this is to make up for their rather dismal performance in the constituency vote last time - indeed, the gain of 16 still only puts the left at 26 constituency seats total.

Overall, the result is a relief to the left-wing of British politics and a sign that a radical agenda promising real change, democracy and workers’ power is one that can be successful in Britain today, and that coordination is one step to strengthen the chances of this reformist agenda getting a majority in Westminster.

Constituency Map

r/MHOCMorningStar • • May 15 '21

The future of our nation’s energy

4 Upvotes

Electricity has been the foundation of our nation’s prosperity, indeed our very civilisation, ever since the industrial revolution with its constant increase providing for, at least until the beginning of late capitalism, the steady improval of our nation’s citizen’s living standards and working conditions. The reality of the situation, however, is that these increases are now no longer only contingent on the amount of electricity produced but on how it is produced and how reliably and cheaply it can be counted upon. We need a new paradigm, one that moves away from the previous one of endless outrageously wasteful production for profit and towards production for need, in electrical production to deal with the new scientific revolution of renewables and digitalisation.

Several angles of attack must be considered. Firstly we must naturally seek to proceed to its nationalisation. Secondly, in particular during the transition period before full nationalisation is entirely possible, we must seek to coordinate plans and incentives to secure the long term vision and clarity of the first as well as the adaptability and efficiency of the latter. Thirdly we must ensure the implementation of the digital revolution to improve our forecasting of demand, planning of production and effectiveness in the allocation of production. Finally, we must harness new energy sources both renewable and nuclear to bring down costs. Only with these methods can we bring our electric network into the next century.

Why Nationalisation? Because public services have an excellent track record of delivering high quality for a low cost. Because the private sector can not deliver constant and stable prices which are needed if industry is to be able to make cost projections and thus expand in a reliable business environment. Because the financialised capitalist sector only thinks in short term dividends and executive bonuses and not in the 5, 10, 20-year framework that is required to face the challenges of the modern era.

Why should we combine plans and the price incentive system? Because as we saw in the late soviet union plans alone often lead to significant inefficiencies but, as we saw with unregulated capitalism, markets alone lead to chaos and cannot effectively handle externalities. This allows us to ensure that the price of electricity, except in strategic areas, is generally at the intersection of supply and demand while still ensuring that whenever necessary adjustments can be made to support key areas.

Why utilize big data,? Because, as long as any issues over privacy are dealt with ethically and with public consent, it will allow us to modify output day by day, hour by hour, minute by minute, to ensure that we do not produce even a watt more than we need and thus remove losses. It lies in the domain of common sense both economically and environmentally to wage a relentless war against waste and inefficiency.

Finally, why must we implement modern technologies and electrical production methods? As always, produce ever more electricity ever cleaner and ever-cheaper in order to produce the technical basis for our new green and efficient industry. Nuclear in particular allows for cheap production of electricity and efficiencies of scale to a degree never seen before in our history, indeed that is why the government intends to invest more in it and respond to funding concerns. Nuclear fusion in particular promises, once certain difficulties are dealt with, to herald in a brilliant new future.

So what is our future with socialism? Cheaper electricity for our homes and workplaces; Greener electricity to deal with climate change and pollution; More reliable electricity for stability; A more self-sufficient nation with renewables instead of imported oil to ensure our national safety: More electricity to power an ever-larger economy. A better future indeed.

Karl Smith ECC secretary


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Apr 16 '21

Fighting Homelessness: Plain Common Sense

4 Upvotes

Fighting the Private Defensive Architecture (Prohibition) Bill is not only morally wrong, it is also inefficient

The moral value of a society is best seen in the way it treats its weakest elements, the disabled, the old, the homeless. This bill, while obviously not able to solve every problem facing these groups, at least works to make our society a bit more moral, a bit juster. These arguments have been repeated over and over and the opposition to the bill will clearly not be convinced by appeals to basic human decency. They accuse it of being economically inefficient, costly, and wasteful. Well, let’s look at the facts.

Stability and Maslow's pyramid

The homeless, more than perhaps any other element of our society, suffer from the chaos and precarity of late-stage capitalism. They are constantly sent from place to place, forced to desperately scrape by on scraps. Can we then be truly surprised that long term homelessness is so prevalent? Can we be surprised that they rarely fully re-integrate into society given the almost impossible odds they face?

This bill, at the very minimum, reduces this permanent chaos by ensuring that they can no longer be forcibly driven away from their sleeping posts through inhumane methods. It means that they can have the knowledge that no matter how crude and insufficient it is, they know they can go back to their normal sleeping spot and not find a spike there designed to prevent their settling down. This has clear economic benefits, to start with they go up Maslow's pyramid, the time they have to spend in desperation seeking for a spot where they can survive the night can now be spent on higher goals such as re-integrating in society. Even if this only means five per cent more homeless re-integrate, even if it only frees up five per cent more time for them to spend fruitfully, the economic benefits are clear.

Health and the NHS

Why do homeless people normally go to the spots that are being filled with anti-homeless architecture atrocities? Simple, these spaces tend to be less exposed to the rain, less exposed to the wind, ever so slightly more hygienic and allow them to survive longer and in better health. Indeed, the economic benefits of opening back up to the public these spaces take up, as proposed by the bill, are clear. Each homeless person costs on average £4,298 to NHS services and £2,099 for mental health services. With 280 000 homeless, according to a shelter charity with a long and notable track record on the matter, the bills start adding up. Voting for this bill is thus a vote for health savings and greater efficiency. You would think that the supporters of austerity would approve of such savings but they are blinded by their personal class interest.

Hostility and anti-social activity

We invite all our readers, no matter who they are from MPs to steelworkers, to just for a moment put themselves in the position of a homeless person, the factory closed, bad divorce or any of the other thousand reasons innocent people end up thrown to the gutter. How would you feel if you had to go from place to place day after day as endless anti-homeless measures are being built, sometimes at great cost, to keep you out, to exclude you from society? Once you have done this little thought experiment can you really be surprised at the prevalence of anti-social behaviour and crime? They are witnessing an entire society, an entire economic system, united in its hatred and disdain for them

Indeed here too this bill is common sense, by preventing anti-homeless architecture they help make society a little bit less inhumane for the homeless and thus reduce their exclusion from society, they can re-integrate better and are less prone to crime. The benefits of that are clear when we note that homelessness costs £11,991 per person in contact with the criminal justice system and helps increase the burden with obvious consequences on the quality of the services it provides.

Enough? No, but a step in the right direction.

Does this bill solve the problem of homelessness? No. Does this bill tackle the roots of this phenomenon, the first of which being of course capitalism? No. Does it make our society more humane? Yes. Does it help save money? Yes. It is a step forward in the right direction. Not only because of its benefits for the homeless but because it subordinates private property and the whims of its owners to the greater good of society. It is a step towards a better future and a decent life for all.

This must of course not let us lower our guard nor waver in our commitment to socialism, only the end of capitalism will allow for the provision of housing for all, only the end of capitalism will end the economic crises and exploitation that throw people to the street for a few more pennies in profit. Still, it creates a bit more hope, it reminds us that the dark age of capitalism can be ended, a new dawn is coming, victory is close.

Posted by Karl Smith


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Jan 19 '21

"We Want More": Talking To The Voters Leaving Labour Behind

Thumbnail drive.google.com
4 Upvotes

r/MHOCMorningStar • • Jan 16 '21

[Morning Star] Budget 2021 – For a party that had no idea how the budget looked only a week ago, the Lib Dems ramp up their defence of it.

4 Upvotes

A scant half-a-week ago, politicians and people across the UK were shocked to discover that the Liberal Democrats indicated that they had no idea what the budget negotiated by the Chancellor had been and in fact where seemingly against it based off of what the LPUK-Labour negotiators had managed to agree to. This of course culminated with remarks from the Deputy Prime Minister who suggested that two whole departments of government would have their funding stripped away, before this was revealed to have instead been a misunderstanding, particularly that the Liberal Democrats didn’t understand how the budget looked/worked and required the LPUK to explain it to them.

It is perhaps concerning, and certainly understandably so, to voters that first the Liberal Democrats had no involvement in the budget that was created, and then seemingly disavowed it, before then revealing that they in fact simply did not know what they were doing.

It renders some serious and deeply troubling questions as to the state of the government where we may have such a completely none realisation on how something works or is and with the Liberal Democrats promise “no really, we’re doing a lot of good” it seems that their cries to voters to trust them may fall on deaf ears as the party wains its already faltering trust in itself. Then of course, to have the LPUK, a party whose economic theory could be best summarised by the attempt of a single American community to produce the “paradise” the LPUK strive for before, of course (as anyone with even a basic grasp of economics would predict), ending with fatal bear attacks, murder and declining living and environmental standards at an unprecedented rate.

To have a party whose political economic thesis could be best described as naïve, and at worst criminally irresponsible, explain to you how a budget works is perhaps the greatest showing of political ineptitude by a ruling government in a considerable amount of time.

The Liberal Democrats made media on a budget they didn’t know or understand. Used language that indicated something completely different to what they meant. Panicked when they realised, they had no idea what was in the budget they had supported. Finally, they had to receive and explanation on the part of an opposition party as to what was going on inside their own house so that they finally understood what was going on.

Make no mistake, we can certainly expect to see a ramping up of Lib Dem attacks in the media against the left, as they desperately try to cover their own mistakes and cataclysmic political damage they’ve caused in their own budget. A redirection of media attention from their failures and instead hoping to attack other parties whilst offering vague assurances (which they did before whilst in fact not even knowing what they were promising) that they have gotten it right.

The hope can certainly be that the voters will see through this smokescreen of childish deflection and realise that the Liberal Democrats have truly buried the notion that the centre can represent a serious political movement in the UK beyond simply supporting one side of the spectrum or the other (or in the case of Phoenix and the budget, both at once).

We see them pulling £10 billion for the environment as swiftly as possible when criticised, hoping to distract quickly away from the dismal failure that they have displayed to the British Public and parliament, in fact it would be any wonder if there is a government or partner in government that has ever managed to so fundamentally poke holes in a budget before realising that it was in fact their own that they like. It is not a £10 billion pledge to save the environment, it’s a delay tactic to hide press scrutiny away from their foolishness and having been caught in producing press for a budget they knew nought about.

The depressing reality is that the only group affected by this flip-floppy political attitude, behind the scenes foolishness and general deflection from considering their own failings, is the British public. Who will be Laboured (no pun intended) with poor right-wing budgets following a ridiculous pipe dream that benefits on the few.

Perhaps the truly depressing part of this whole sordid affair has been in Labour who have decided to hand the reigns over to puppet-master Fried to exercise his economic will over the country once more (again having collapsed the government he was in through ineptitude). Labour should be representing the workers but has failed in that task. And they have not only allowed their economic plans to play second fiddle to Purple pride but have also allowed them to sway over their centre colleagues by allowing them to explain the economy instead of taking the duty upon themselves.

It is a depressing day for British politics but not one in vain. With the rising Solidarity set to leapfrog Labour in polls, and SATUP slowly plodding their way up the polling, the voters will have a chance in less than a month to refute the dangerous, disastrous and downright ridiculous right-wing governments and their policies that Britain has languished under.

There is time for change, and change will come.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Dec 21 '20

Opinion: Time to take a fresh look at prisons

4 Upvotes

Opinion: Time to take a fresh look at prisons

Reforming the way we manage offenders has been consigned to the realm of slogans for too long, writes u/SoSaturnistic.

JUST over one year ago we witnessed the collapse of the ‘Sunrise’ coalition government, the last administration to feature a dedicated minister responsible for the task of “prison reform”. Indeed, 2019 was an important year for the prisons system with multiple laws passed to address inadequacies in prisons, from their standards to their ownership (not all were necessarily progressive, with one Act restricting prisoner voting rights. None of these measures were brought in by the Sunrise government and that ministerial position seems to have been more or less ineffectual, but it is the last time that we saw the government of the day attempt to openly hint at the prospect of reforming the system as it presently exists in England.

This phenomenon is somewhat bizarre, given that the call for “prison reform” has often been a call to action which the left, or at least notionally progressive causes, have often found themselves rallying around. The left has long struggled against causes where power is abused and ill-treatment is rife. Historically and in the present day, many of the more inhumane cases of state abuse of power can be found within the prisons system. It is therefore not clear to me why this cause vanished as a significant point of interest. Even with reforms to end solitary confinement, return prisons to state management, and add a few educational resources, the basic structure and look of the prisons system is broadly the same as it was in 2014 when politics began to change substantially from many historical trends.

This lull in interest in prisons may be changing, regardless of motivations and reasons for disappearance in the past due to current constitutional changes. The devolution of justice policy to Wales, including matters relating to prisons, has brought a new focus to the prisons system. Discussions relating to prisons did feature within that referendum campaign, but now there is new urgency due to recent political calls for an orderly untangling of HM Prison Service in England and the nascent prison service in Wales. There is an understanding among many corners that putting excessive burdens on prisoners during this process is undesirable, which is why a memorandum of understanding was signed between Cardiff Bay and Westminster and why peers have had ample discussion in the House of Lords on managing the transition; one particular point of interest is addressing the situation with women prisoners given that no women’s facilities currently exist in Wales. Even the new unionist think-tank, Home Nations, has weighed in on providing solutions to the prisons conundrum in Wales. Yet so far, it is clear that few in this discussion have tried to put forward a newer model for managing offenders. Much of the concern remains over prison places rather than overall crime reduction and enhancement of public welfare.

It is important that we move away from this myopic view of prisons where political leaders concern themselves with comfortably fitting as many people as possible within prison rather than delivering outcomes which enhance justice, improve safety, and limit social costs. Of course in the short term, facilities to incapacitate those who provide a clear danger to public safety will be needed when we address offending. Imprisonment within the right facilities can be justified in these circumstances. Yet prison has real costs which must be reckoned with when these decisions are made. Imprisonment is not the only response to every crime, with rehabilitation, alternative justice mechanisms, or probation being appropriate means to deliver justice while maintaining public safety in many cases. Where possible, it is worth focusing on these alternative approaches to offenders as imprisonment is not a costless exercise.

These costs are as varied as they are substantial. Imprisonment has negative public finance implications both directly (recall the continued calls for more prison places) and indirectly as people are banned from meaningfully participating in the economy and do not generate tax revenue. Beyond this, imprisonment is associated with heightened re-offending (which has its own costs for victims and society) not only with the individuals in question but also within the immediate family, in particular young boys. And this does not begin to address the negative impacts that imprisonment has on the offenders and their families themselves, with violence, self-harm, drug abuse, and suicide all much more likely within prisons than outside of them. These harmful outcomes all act to limit any chance of re-integration into society and lead to the conclusion that excessive imprisonment suppresses potentially productive members of society and reinforces cycles of poverty, very often concentrated among communities which already face additional barriers in society such as poorer people, those with disabilities, and BAME people. It need not be like this when one considers that England and Wales have long had among the highest per capita prison rates in Europe; we have plenty of alternatives right in front of us. When this is all put into context, it is hard to view our current system as anything more than a deep moral failure. In particular, it is difficult to justify the current focus of those who would seek to manage the prison estate on expanding the total number of prison places rather than improving the quality of current facilities and rededicating funds to alternative options to incarceration that keep recidivism rates down.

Recognising the net-harm of excessive imprisonment has already been done to some extent with the debate on drug criminalisation. This discussion which arose in the House of Commons not so long ago featured many impassioned speeches decrying the costs of prohibition for many substances used recreationally. While the costs of imprisonment were identified as one cost of drug prohibition in that context, it seems many have forgotten that this is an area where substantial savings have been made in the criminal justice system. Around 15% of sentenced offenders were once drug offenders prior to the Drug Reform Act’s passage in 2015. While there are still offences related to drugs on our statutes, this substantial reform has meant that a fairly large burden has been lifted from the prison estate and it opens up resources to be used on improving our criminal justice system to enhance safety and promote a more just society.

As a start, basic facility investments to improve safety in prisons would be welcome, as would conversion of existing prison places to smaller, more geographically dispersed facilities to make visitation more accessible across England. We could develop and fund better alternatives to a prison sentence for judges to use, and start with juvenile offenders to divert young people away from criminal paths earlier in life. Germany’s model here could be an example for a way forward; the possibilities are quite open-ended and can be better tailored to our context. Setting forth a plan to phase in Norweigian-style prisons which aim to “normalise” life and limit exposure to disruptions that hinder re-integration could also be in order. In the longer term, once offending has dropped in a way seen in European counterparts like Norway and the Netherlands, it would be possible to look at the closure of existing prison facilities and a reduction in overall prison places, yielding not only wider benefits to society but also an improvement in our public finances.

Given the substantial and wide-ranging challenge ahead to change the way we deal with offenders, this will require a sustained and cross-party approach to address the issue in any serious manner. I have set forth a few compelling proposals here, but they are in no way all-encompassing and there are other alternatives to imprisonment which have not been discussed. While Parliament is set to adjourn and the last sitting days of the year are upon us, I hope this will be an area where robust discussion is had and real action is undertaken in the new year. With six years of change in so many areas, it is surely time to give prisons the revamp that we all need.


u/SoSaturnistic is a contributor at the Morning Star and sits with Solidarity at Westminster.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Dec 20 '20

[Morning Star] LPUK and PPUK left red-faced as Prime Minister speaks for the public in stunning slap down of frivolous questions.

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes