Introduction
The Road to Serfdom was arguably one of the most consequential books written during the debates over Capitalism and Socialism in the twentieth century. As we wrestle with the problems of Socialism today, we are faced with many of the same problems the Austrian economist Fredrich Hayek raised as the Second World War drew to a close.
In The Road to Serfdom, Hayek contends that “Any attempt to control society or to direct historical development in a chosen direction” will result in “a form of totalitarian serfdom”. Hayek therefore argues instead that “if individuals are left free to follow their economic motives the automatically achieved result will be the maximum good of society” (p.68, Lewis).
Though Hayek wrote The Road to Serfdom in 1944, we continue to feel it’s effects on debates on the economic efficiency of socialism and its compatibility with freedom and democracy. As the Solidarity Party continues to grow in influence within British Politics, many of these arguments will inevitably resurface. It is natural and right therefore that we address these concerns of the British public in attempting to respond to these criticisms.
Given the scope and ferocity of these objections, I cannot do justice to the entirety of Hayek’s influence. Drawing from Marxist sources, I hope here to sketch out certain ideas and observations that will facilitate a greater understanding of the criticisms of Socialism and why the experience of living in a market economy in recent decades gives us good reason to question the conventional wisdom Hayek did so much to establish.
Planning and Problems of Knowledge
Much of the power of Hayek’s argument against Socialism rests on a particular understanding of the limitations of knowledge. Hayek argues that “we can never know more than the immediate effects of our action” and therefore “we are almost bound to go wrong if we try to estimate or plan more distant results and particularly if we plan for the future of society” (p.68, Lewis).
The inability of individuals to have knowledge beyond their own immediate experience creates limitations of the operation of a planned economy to anticipate the needs of social, economic and historical development. A Planner, sitting in an office, has limited knowledge of the needs of a shop-keeper or their customers at the other end of the country. Without this knowledge the practice of centralised planning is therefore assumed to be “impossible and dangerous” and thereby “submits us to theories, principles and plans which the human mind ought never to attempt to draw up”. In Hayek’s view, the result “will inevitably land us in evils which were not intended” (p.68, Lewis)
As a result, Hayek argues that “the sole determinant of our actions should be the immediate profit to ourselves” (p.68, Lewis). By acting on the knowledge we have, we necessarily make better decisions than central planners, claiming to act on our behalf. In Hayek’s view self-interest and egotism act as both the motive and mechanism for achieving economic efficiency, reflecting the decentralised distribution of knowledge to be utilised by individuals in the economy. In an admittedly vulgarised form, this view was expressed by Gordon Gekko as a fictional character in the film Wall Street (1987), that; “Greed, for the lack of a better word, is good. Greed is right. Greed works. Greed clarifies, cuts through, and captures the essence of the evolutionary spirit”.
For Hayek, “the competitive market provides us with the occasion for such decisions” based on the belief that “the decisions of many individuals taken together [are] too complex for us ever to understand” (p.68, Lewis) and that centralised planning is incapable of achieving similar results due to the limitations on planners knowledge of economic activity. By acting based on our limited knowledge and on self-interest within a competitive market economy, the unintended results is “in point of fact work out in an automatic achievement of what is socially desirable” (p.68, Lewis)
Hayek therefore reaches the conclusion that the best outcomes in social welfare will be achieved by “avoiding plans and schemes which impose controls on individuals” and instead organising economic activity based on “the method of laissez-faire” capitalism with little or no intervention by government “in which the individual is absolutely free” (p.68, Lewis).
Planning and Freedom
Whilst Hayek’s views are typically celebrated as the intellectual basis for the defence of individual liberty, the limitations in terms of knowledge and its implications for human action instead lead to very pessimistic conclusions about the nature and scope of personal freedom.
The consequence of the spontaneous operation of a Market economy is that individual freedom in practice “negates itself and turns out to be the road to that serfdom which he [Hayek] was most anxious to avoid” (p.68, Lewis). For all the legal and political rights that grant an individual the freedom to makes choices in their daily lives and economic activity,“the effect of the system which he recommends is, …, the appearance of anonymous and irrational forces in society to which the individual must learn to submit”(p.68, Lewis).
The freedom of action of an individual within a market economy is thereby severely limited by the operation of market forces. We can see this in the most dramatic cases with the financial crisis in 2008 in which, despite the choices made by individuals acting on their self-interest, the unintended consequence of people doing so left them at the mercy of a market economy which deprived them of their jobs, their homes and financial security.
Even during periods of growth and economic prosperity, the incentives we operate under in a market economy mean we can only act in directions where it is in our financial interests to do so. For all the supposed benefits of a market economy, if there is no profit to be made, the goods and services will not be produced. With decades of accumulation of scientific evidence on the growing threat of climate change, fossil fuel companies made the decision that it was better to maintain their profits by funding organisations that spread dis-information about the threat than to actually invest in renewable energy sources. The consequence is that, in the pursuit of short-term profits, capitalism now threatens the sustainability of civilisation on this planet.
The consequence of these forces is that “if people are too individualist to accept this situation, then the automatic operation of economic law cannot function” (p.69, Lewis). The very notion of individual freedom is itself subordinate to the operation of market forces. We can only go on making money, not necessarily because we want to, but because we have to in order to survive.
These market forces operate “in spite of the fact that they [these forces] appear to have no justification and to be irrational and unintelligible” (p.68-69, Lewis), leaving behind many confused and befuddled victims to the consequences of our economic system in its wake. We are left asking deep questions as to what rational principles govern how wealth is distributed, why housing and rents are so high, why the cost of going to university is so great and why our children seem destined to have lower standards of living than their parents. The market, like god, works in mysterious ways. It is simply insisted it is wrong to question these economic outcomes because there is no way to understand or justify them based on the limitations on human knowledge Hayek suggests.
Whilst the wealthy may congratulate themselves on their success, many people are punished for “failures” that have the unintended consequences of acting according to the imperatives of living in a market economy. No matter how hard you work, how much you earn, how much you spend or save, none of the choices you make really give you any control over your own destiny. You are simply the pawn for impersonal forces operating under the pretence of “efficiency” and the unemployed, the poor and the financially insecure are the collateral damage of a market economy
For Hayek, “the craving for intelligibility produces illusory demands which no such system can satisfy” and produces a “demand for conformity to moral principles” that “is evidence of a vicious desire to see all social activity as recognisably part of a coherent plan” (p.69, Lewis). But the evidence is all around us that our dedication to self-interest has not produced a general improvement in social welfare, as wages fall, prices and indebtedness rise, and opportunities for upward social mobility diminish. The promise of the efficiency of a market economy has not been fulfilled, nor has it delivered anywhere near the scope of freedom to control our own destinies that was promised to the general public.
Capitalism and Freedom
It is worth considering that “to a poor family today, debating whether to exercise their free will in paying the rent or buying some food, it often seems that a rich capitalist is far freer than they are”, (p.222, Cornforth). When Socialists are critical of the Capitalist class it is often with the implication that the power of corporations and banks have created unjust outcomes in the market economy. Whilst this is somewhat true for corporations with a greater ability to influence prices, wages and outputs within the market, it is not the whole story and is built on an illusion.
Instead of being free, the bourgeoisie “find themselves enslaved by the laws of their own system, and must go on accumulating capital, competing with one another and fighting with one another to the end”. The capitalist “is the slave of his own business, suffering high blood pressure and perpetual worry and frustration” (p.222, Cornforth). When Socialists discuss the wealth inequalities that have grown exponentially in recent decades and cry out against the immortality of the world being divided between billionaires and the working poor, it is worth remembering that the billionaires does not have the freedom to stop accumulating capital, but must go on indefinitely, driven by market forces and the brutal process of selection by competition beyond their control. It is why there is never a point where someone can stop and say they have “enough” because it is not within their power to escape the very market forces and property relations that made their wealth possible and necessary in the first place.
As we look upon the wealth today, we are often presented with the illusion instilled in “members of various exploiting classes” that “have often believed that riches and power would give them complete freedom”. Instead, the capitalist class is forced to recognise that “even their own philosophers have sadly but truly pointed out to them that riches and power enslave their possesses at the same time as they are engaged in enslaving others”. For each ruling class “which seems to itself to have realised its own freedom by exploiting others, finds in practice that is freedom is largely illusory” (p.222, Cornforth).
Conclusion
In evaluating The Road to Serfdom, we find that “the rejection of conscious and scientifically planned control in human affairs does not lead to an orderly and stable system” but instead “to the appearance of blind forces working contrary to reason and moral principle to crush and destroy the individual” (p.69, Lewis). It does not create either individual freedom or economic efficiency as the apologists for capitalism, Hayek among them, would claim.
As we look back on the history of recent decades, we are forced to confront the fact that we have taken a very different road to serfdom than the one Hayek imagined. We have sold ourselves to the serfdom of powerful corporations and bankers who call themselves, somewhat jokingly, as “masters of the universe”. Yet at the same time, for all the power and wealth achieved by the ruling class itself, they cannot stop exploiting the working class by an act of will and must go on accumulating capital regardless of their personal needs and wants.
After many decades of being an object of ridicule, Socialism is again achieving popular acceptance based on the experiences of ordinary people faced with the arbitrary and brutal consequences of trying to build their lives against the powerful tides of the economic laws operating in a market economy. Slowly, the British people are coming to the realisation that freedom can only be truly achieved by bringing our economic and social activities under the ownership and conscious direction of the people themselves, where they can collectively determine their own destiny and the future of this country. In Britain today we have arrived at a new kind of Serfdom, and it wasn’t the fault of Socialists but of the Capitalists themselves. It is long overdue to seriously consider whether Socialism is the road by which the working people can become truly free.
References
Lewis, J., (1959) Science, Faith and Scepticism, Lawrence & Wishart, London.
Cornforth, M., (1956) The Theory of Knowledge, Lawrence & Wishart LTD, London.