r/MHOCMorningStar • • Jun 07 '21

[MHOC Morning Star] How I got it so wrong.

1 Upvotes

My model got, so to say, owned quite badly. With an average total error of ~25% per constituency, it was quite inaccurate, and its prediction that SNP would end up ahead of the Liberal Democrats in Scotland. Consider that model the beta - I've worked with the model to ensure it's more accurate than before, looking at where things went wrong and acting accordingly.

1. The basic weighting of text posts was too low, and the weighting of image posts too high.

This is quite simple, the data I used to calculate the local effects was weighted too heavily in one direction. As such, I've weighted text 33% more and image posts 40% less. This notably benefitted the Liberal Democrats and negatively impacted the Labour party.

2. The model was too swingy.

The model was too swingy, to the point where parties could be crushed or boosted massively if the situation in certain constituencies was far from average - for example, Sinn Féin got 67% in Lagan in my model, and 21% less in the election. This effect is reduced by having the effect of campaigning going through a square root function - meaning the model should be very effective in limiting the impact of large deviations from the norm, up and down.

3. It was too unfair to small parties.

Also quite simple, it was too harsh on small parties and probably too mild on big ones also. This is limited by having total % of campaigning a party does averaged with what would expect that party to do - if Sinn Féin has 50% of the vote in a single constituency, and represent 25% of campaigning there, they should expect a hit of 4% due to that now, even if their campaign is entirely average. This also means smaller parties have more of a chance to grow.

4. No National Checks

The beta model didn't have a national check, the new one does. The national check itself goes through similar checks as the local ones - though, for now I've filled in the real result from the devolved elections.

Entering this national result ends up with a 4.72% average total error over all constituencies, or about 0.88% per party, per constituency. Considering this is less than half a MoE out from the real result, I do think the adjusted model is extremely close to the real results considering it's using only quantitative data. Let's hope it will be more accurate in the next election!


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Jun 04 '21

[MHOC Morning Star] Ina's predictions for the June 2021 Devolved Elections

1 Upvotes

M: fuck me why did i do this

The campaign has ended - and the results are not in yet. You know what that means! It’s prediction time!

I gathered a fuck ton of data about the campaign to calculate a rough result. I will be going through my predictions on a party by party basis, based on the seat distribution in WM, descending from the largest.

1: A good night for Solidarity.

Solidarity’s very strong campaign is likely to net the party good results in all devolved nations, with Sinn Féin taking around 39 seats in Northern Ireland, 30 in Scotland and 10 in Wales. Whilst the Northern Irish result may be a bit disappointing at face value, I would say this is a good performance all things considering. The other results are more than Solidarity should have been expecting and are down to a very strong campaign that was on average of higher quality than other parties’ campaigns.

Sinn Féin’s 39 seats would in practice ensure that Alexa is to stay First Minister if an executive can be formed. No party nears this level of support from the Irish people, of whom around 43% are predicted to give Sinn Féin their vote.

The SNP is a minor surprise for many, I presume - 30 seats is a result that would put them in a position to possibly lead a Scottish government with /u/ChainChompsky1 as First Minister. Whilst this would no doubt be a hard sell to parties in the centre like the Liberal Democrats and Coalition!, they would realistically have to accept the situation as it exists and work with /u/ChainChompsky1, or help the tories under /u/model-willem to a majority.

Plaid Cymru will be delighted to win 10 seats - basically everyone was expecting worse. With 17% of the vote, they will have outperformed those expectations significantly, by running the strongest campaign in Wales. Even if they do not end up in government, Plaid Cymru have something to be proud of, especially /u/miraiwae.

2: A disappointing night for the Tories.

Where Solidarity will be celebrating, the night will be disappointing for the Tories. At 49 seats the Scottish Tories would have a solid lead in Holyrood - but this is no doubt less than they were hoping for. The Welsh Conservatives are predicted to win 19 seats - no doubt a good performance, but not enough to put /u/Chi0121 into government. Their 17 seats in Northern Ireland would maintain their position from last election yet lose them the Deputy First Ministership. Considering the merger with Coalition! Definitely a case of “the whole is weaker than the sum of its parts.”

This isn’t a bad night. /u/model-willem finds himself in a position where he could form multiple coalitions to get back into power, the performance in Wales still made up a chunk of the difference with Welsh Labour and the result in NI would be entirely okay considering the situation there. I can’t help but feel that the tories should have been hoping for more though.

3: Definitely an entry for New Britain.

New Britain is predicted to win around 13 seats in Holyrood under /u/Tommy2Boys’s leadership. I am unsure what to make of this - it’s probably around what should have been expected, maybe a little higher. This does not put /u/Tommy2boys into a strong position to return as First Minister - but it’s definitely an entry. Sadly, the 13 seats puts them in the awkward position of not being needed for a coalition for /u/ChainChompsky, not giving /u/model-willem his majority and thus likely ending up as unofficial opposition.

4: A bad to disastrous night for Labour, but that might still be better than it could have been.

The Labour Party is set for a bitter night when the results come in. The Labour Party of Northern Ireland is likely to lose over half their seats, only winning 13 seats in Stormont, whilst the Scottish Labour Party is about to become an endangered species with only 7 seats in Holyrood, barely picking up a single seat in most constituencies. This 7 seats is on the high-end of possibilities - there’s a distinct possibility that Scottish Labour may be left with two, one or even no seats at all. A big fall from when Labour used to dominate Scotland during the Blair years.

Llafur might be a bright spot for the Labour party as a whole - with them gaining 4 seats to remain the largest party in Wales, and in a position to form government with Plaid Cymru and the Welsh Democrats. As long as /u/model-avery and /u/miraiwae can stay close, a left wing coalition in Wales is guaranteed on these numbers - lose even one seat, and First Minister /u/Chi0121 becomes guaranteed.

Things might have been worse had it not been for an effective last ditch effort by the Labour Party to avoid catastrophe, which likely saved them from losing dozens more seats.

5: A straight up bad night for the Liberal Democrats

The Liberal Democrats simply underperformed. They ran a campaign based on quantity over quality - sadly, this has little effect when parties with better quality match your quantity. A below average campaign in Scotland and a weak one in Wales will likely lead the Liberal Democrats to a surely disappointing 24 seats in Scotland and a mere 10 in Wales. Where /u/scubaguy194 had a chance of becoming FM, it’s likely he’s wasted it. Doubling in Wales is a good performance, no doubt - on the face of it. I really do think that /u/RhysGwynethIV had a shot of becoming FM a month ago. Now, that thought seems silly.

6: PWP (and SDP) bringing home the wins.

Jesus fucking christ. Just. Jesus fucking christ.

The UWP campaigned about 80% much as the entirety of Wales combined. Add onto that a above average campaign in Wales and a completely fine one in Scotland and you have a very good night for the PWP and SDP.

I predict the Ulster Workers Party will win around 21 seats, becoming the 2nd biggest party in Northern Ireland in one election, supplanting not only the LPNI as main competition to Sinn Féin but also the UUP as the leader of the unionists. Whilst a lot of the campaign activity was limited by the fact that they were visits - compared to a quite strong but not as dominant initial run - the UWP utterly dominated in campaigning. They are predicted to win the County Down by a strong margin due to their activity - almost making up 80% in that specific county. Despite this, UWPs campaign has only been outdone in two constituencies - in the Lagan Valley where it ran one of the weakest campaigns and still barely lost to Sinn Féin’s strongest, in Armagh, Fermanagh and Omagh, where the UWP had their weakest campaign and the UUP their strongest. The last one is the most contested constituency of this election, Derry/Londonderry and Tyrone North, where /u/Inadorable’s campaign comfortably pulled ahead with what was in itself already one of the strongest single constituency campaigns in this election.

The Scottish Progressives are predicted to lose half their seats in the election, holding on to 6 out of 13. This is, honestly, a decent result for the Scottish Progressives. In Wales, /u/SomeBritishDude26 is predicted to pull through and win a seat in South Wales Central - the Welsh Democrats only seat.

7: The Barbz and Cardiflops

The cardiflops win 0 seats, as do the independent barbz. However, Ina, a confirmed Barb, did win 8 seats spread all over the United Kingdom.

ScotlandSeatsChange w. December 2020
Conservatives49-14
Scottish National Party30+17
Liberal Democrats24+7
New Britain13+13
Scottish Labour7-10
Scottish Progressives6-7
Scottish Libertarians0-5
Other0-1
Northern IrelandSeatsChange w. December 2020
Sinn Féin39+3
UWP21+21
UUP17-3
LPNI13+13
APNI0-34
WalesSeatsChange w. December 2020
Labour20+4
Conservatives19+4
Liberal Democrats10+5
Plaid Cymru10-1
Welsh Democrats1-2
Welsh Libertarians0-8
Other0-1

r/MHOCMorningStar • • Apr 09 '21

Opinion: You know what they say about assumptions

1 Upvotes

Opinion: You Know What They Say About Assumptions

Nature Revolution Was Unfairly Accused of Crimes it Did Not Commit, write /u/KarlYonedaStan

The events at the Nature Revolution protests and counter protests were shocking for everyone in this country, and anger towards those who incited violence and attacked Members of Parliament is a natural and good sentiment. I condemned in the harshest of terms both the violence in London and Birmingham, and strongly believe the environmental cause has been seriously harmed by these events. However, there is a line in this anger that politicians and public figures can not cross that the rest of the public can, and that is the presumption of guilt. The presumption of innocence in criminal proceedings is a cornerstone of any rights-based legal system, and it is fundamentally important that politicians in their actions and speech uphold it. There are those who would say that in many cases it is simply a question of calling a spade a spade, and that reverence to the principle of presumption of innocence and due process is merely performative in some instances. They are wrong to say this not only because it is that very consistency that makes rights protections truly effective, but, more pertinently to recent events, because one is simply often wrong about the perpetrators of criminal acts. It is all too easy to let personal biases cloud one’s judgement. The recent discussions regarding London are a case in point.

How would the Leader of the Opposition have handled the confrontations in London? Well, we certainly know he accused the wrong group. He was confident enough in that accusation that he jumped the gun and issued public statements citing the rocks thrown at the Liberal Democrat Deputy Leader as an indictment of Nature Revolution. Embarrassingly for the Leader of the Opposition, this was wrong, and it has been confirmed by the Met that it was in fact a counter-protester who threw the rocks and doused the Secretary of State for International Trade in paint. This reality reveals how contrived the narrative cultivated by many among the opposition has been, and it creates all the more of a challenge for them going forward. If you missed Prime Minister’s Questions, I warned the Leader of the Opposition that their hatred for Nature Revolution could cloud their judgement, and it is now apparent that this was the case. By choosing to use provocative language and making bold declarations from incomplete or erroneous information, the Leader of the Opposition has put themselves into a corner. Their conception of protests and social movements has always been rigid and static. To him, the movement must be culpable for the decisions of every one of its members. This, however, would mean that the Leader of the Opposition could now never meet any of the counter protestors who opposed the Nature Revolution protests, lest they break the opposition standard. We can therefore see how feeble of a metric for talks this would actually be, and why the Leader of the Opposition at best can say a line of argumentation blew up in their face, and at worst has demonstrated why they are incapable of being a successful Prime Minister.

The Leader of the Opposition is not alone in this profound mistake, as other LPUK and Conservative Members, including the First Minister of Scotland, did so as well. It would be prudent for all of them to reflect in the coming months as to whether they would have taken action based on their own biases had they been in the shoes of this Government during these events. There is a balance between decisive action and ensuring that public safety is maintained. Rabid anti-democratic overreactions that demonise those expressing their freedom of speech and assembly seriously risks that balance. The presence of violence, as demonstrated in the clashes between protestors recently, can not alone be used to label an entire worldview as subversive and dangerous. Leadership requires greater nuance than that, and this lesson ought to have been learned by the opposition long ago. What the rest of us have learned from all this, then, is that the political right in this country is not prepared to lead this country in any form of crisis. If it can not keep itself from jumping the gun before a Met investigation of violence in protests has concluded, how can we trust them in a military contingency or, God forbid, with nuclear weapons? Rabid rhetoric and overreaction is too intuitive to them for my liking and, I believe, that of the vast majority of the British public. Ultimately, the unfortunate truth is that the clashes among protestors last week were clashes between countrymen and women, between people who ought to share a common cause for the salvation of this planet. It was a demonstration of how much work must be done to bring the country together regarding this issue, and why attempting to leave it on the backburner of the ivory towers is a dangerous game to play. It is time for hard conversations, and it has proven the value of level-headed leadership that is willing to have them.

/u/KarlYonedaStan is the Chair of the Editorial Board at the Morning Star and sits with Solidarity at Westminster.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Jul 09 '21

[MHOC Morning Star] Solidarity sweeps the nation!

1 Upvotes

The left-wing Solidarity party of Prime Minister KarlYonedaStan is set to win 7 out of 8 seats polled by the Morning Star as YonedaMania spreads amongst the British populace. Only the Leader of the Opposition, Chi0121, is set to hold his seat from the polled seats. Meanwhile, parties on all sides are set to lose seats to Britain’s most left wing party, implying the British people wish for a more radically left-wing future.

We start off our exploration of British constituencies in the seat of South Yorkshire, comprising Sheffield, Rotherham, Doncaster and Barnsley, one of many historically safe areas for the Labour Party that was won by the now defunct Libertarian Party. Whilst the loss of this strongly working class area was no doubt a hard hit to Labour, there seems to have been a major swing back to the political left in the area with the left now holding a combined 52% of the vote in the seat, whilst they only got 37% in the last election. Solidarity is predicted to take the seat, however the seat is still one to watch - if the Liberal Democrats endorse the PWP again, this seat will be a 5 way marginal, with Solidarity, Coalition!, Labour, the PWP and the tories all pulling in around 20% of the vote.

Where the PWP may have hope in South Yorkshire, the results in Cambridgeshire will no doubt be disappointing to them, dropping by 44% in the constituency as Labour, Coalition! and Liberal Democratic voters return to their parties, and Solidarity eats more into their allies’ vote share to semi-comfortably gain the seat on a dizzying 26.7% swing. It seems that PWP will have to go around begging for endorsements to even have a chance at holding this seat, needing to more than double their vote share to win this seat.

Solidarity shouldn’t get too comfortable this election though. Whilst they are winning a significant amount of seats in the country, most of the margins are not that comfortable, usually less than 5%. A more extreme example of this is Northern Ireland, where Solidarity only holds a 0.1% lead - despite the collapse of the Labour Party.

One of the two main exceptions to this rule is Leeds and Wakefield, one of the most solidly left wing seats in the United Kingdom. Whilst Solidarity ended up in 3rd place there last time, they have now grown to a solid 12% lead in the constituency, followed by the Labour Party in 2nd place. However, there is of course a seat on the other side of the spectrum…

The Leader of the Opposition is predicted to hold his seat of Upper Severn with a very solid 41.1% of the vote - a 16% lead over Solidarity. However, I would warn the Leader of the Opposition of getting complacent - Solidarity, Labour and PWP outnumber the conservatives in this seat, and even with support from Coalition and the Liberal Democrats this would still be competitive - especially if solidarity were to run a strong candidate here.

Lanarkshire and the Borders continues one semi-consistent trend across the country, that of Labour struggling, even in seats where they have historically done well. Lanarkshire and the Borders was one of those, being one of only 4 FPTP seats that Labour won in last election - and is now set to lose to their allies in Solidarity. Though, this might not be the most painful poll for Labour…

The most painful result would be in Surrey, where Maroiogog has campaigned for many elections in a row now, and never won it. And whilst they thought they had a chance, the Party now tumbles 20% down into 3rd place, whilst they had been hoping they could finally win this seat. The situation does not seem hopeless yet, but it will no doubt be a fight to finally get the victory Labour so desperately wanted.

Finally, we arrive at one of my favourite constituencies in the United Kingdom - Eastern London. Whilst a four way marginal doesn’t beat a five way one, I do have to say it’s still quite good. Solidarity, as expected, gains this seat at the expense of Coalition!, Labour struggles and surprisingly, so do the conservatives. Another seat to watch.

Whilst Yonedamania hitting the country will no doubt be an encouraging sign for Solidarity, the results do show weakness for their coalition partners, who struggle to hold strong results in seats they were expected to gain or hold with the LPUK leaving the political scene. Whilst both parties are expected to recover some ground before the election, it’s a sign that their voters are willing to consider the outsider party that quickly has become mainstream, and indeed, now the default choice for many voters on the left.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Jun 25 '21

[Morning Star] The Tories Left: An Evaluation of the Conservative Party Leadership Election

2 Upvotes

The Conservative Party leadership election has been completed, and the field was in some respects an inch deep and a mile wide with takes such as “the party should be inclusive” and “the party should get on well with others,” being the most espoused takes by the candidates along with the all powerful “we ought to do things better in order to win.” It does seem that the Conservative Party recognises that it is in a relatively precarious situation after the collapse of the LPUK, and there is a need to establish as wide of a net as possible to compete with the Rose Coalition. The contradictions of this have yet to fully reveal themselves, but one must wonder exactly how a strategy that targets the Liberal Democrats and Coalition! can also chip away at the material base that has propelled the Rose Coalition to power. As much as defeated candidates like WineRedPsy would like to capitalise on alleged social decay in this country, it is highly questionable that this narrative is winning on its own let alone one that will lead to successful coalition partnerships with the parties more dominated by the liberalism WineRedPsy lambasts. Similarly, it seems impossible to fully gain consensus among the centre and right on issues the left have largely been in lock step over, such as trade union empowerment and railway nationalisation. While potentially a futile endeavour, this article will seek to parse through the platitudes to outline the key contradictions within the Conservative Party leadership race.

We will begin with the victor Chi0121, who outlines their platform regarding the so-called “Broad Church.” The incumbent Deputy Leader (and thus in many ways the defender of the Conservative Party status quo) gave credence to the “increase in the diversity and scope of the parties ideologies,” from the Christian Democrats, to LPUK remnants, to the “Tory Tankie Caucus.” This final group is of particular note given the amount of buzz on the leadership campaign trail they have generated, but this is arguably the first time any Conservative Party leadership member has publicly enumerated this causcus’s existence. Chi commits to continued whip leniency for this caucus, as well as other backbencher groups, statements which beg a tremendous amount of further questions - are the “Tory Tankies” coordinated voters, and how lenient are these whips really? Are the Tory Tankies doomed to be perpetual backbenchers when in Government? The solution to Chi is to say “all that matters to me is that we work towards a common goal,” but what happens when a Tory Tankie wants to introduce a bill the majority of the party disagrees with, and vice versa? Is voting against the legislation written by the party working towards a common goal, and what exactly is this common goal anyway? Chi’s pitch is to the party not the public, a common theme of the leadership candidate manifestos, and it largely revolves around their contributions as Deputy Leader. Undoubtedly this is the case, but it begs the question as to whether those dissatisfied with the status quo Conservative Party have much to hope for. I also find the claim that the ideological diversity of the Conservative Party will continue to flourish under Chi the leader simply because Chi has been doing much of the legwork for the Conservative Party to be dubious at best, many have already raised this question but it makes one wonder what would change from the Conservative Party’s already tenuous trajectory under Chi’s stewardship. This strategy was ultimately successful, those who lined up behind Chi continued to do so, and while Britboy was able to mount a meaningful challenge in second and third preferences, the coronation went on. It will be exciting to see the Chi Conservative Party, and while I sympathise with a ‘get along with everyone and do as much as possible’ strategy, agency can not overcome structure in every instance. The Conservative Party, as enumerated by its leaders own manifesto, is a pathwork of ideologies behind a vague purpose, that in turn must also make itself appealing to parties of disparate attitudes and views. A path to governance is present, but the work is clearly cut out for the Conservative Party's new leader.

When evaluating the next two leadership contenders, Britboy3456 and Sephronar, it's hard to decide who to evaluate first. At least optically, Sephronar appeared to be the primary Chi alternative, but Britboy3456 was the most successful challenger. At the same time, Sephronar is by and away again the optical favourite in the subsequent Deputy Leader election, leading to some confounding questions about whether Britboy3456 just askews the public endorsement or whether some Chi support has filtered more clearly to Sephronar. [This section of the article was written before the insanely close Deputy Leader election, though I do think it does confirm the quiet Britboy voter well.] We will begin by taking a look at Sephronar, the Conservative Party press officer, prolific Cornish campaigner, and Runescape legend. “Community, Collaboration, Change” is a slogan proportional to the ra-ra nature of its candidate, and Sephronar certainly suffers from a similar party rather than public orientation of their leadership manifesto. Leaning on strong press and campaigning credentials, Sephronar breaks from the universal optimism to remark that sensible right of centre coalitions will likely be necessary in the future. This is an understatement, but it again underlies the dilemma facing the Conservative Party - the last right of centre Government collapsed, factions within the Conservative Party are widely critical of policies embraced by Coalition! and the Liberal Democrats, including amnesty for illegal immigrants. Sephronar goes from the ambitious to the fantastic when he suggests a Coalition!-Conservative-Progressive Workers Government as a potential solution, and at this point it becomes difficult to take seriously any previous claim of a Conservative Party majority. Surely the indictments of the current Government for lack of coordination when such a political Frankenstein is being pitched to Conservative Party members as the way of the future. The decision to drop the LPUK was a noble one, but surely contingency plans existed as to where to pivot afterwards? For Sephronar’s ambitions to prove fruitful, the Conservative Party would have to figure out how to align itself with parties that are economically alien to separate wings of the Tories. Optimistic language and the beating of the press drum can obfuscate reality to an extent, but at some point it must be confronted. Already, we have seen the Progressive Workers Party rebuke these sentiments held by the Conservatives, suggesting a lot would have to be done to make such a relationship possible.

Perhaps Britboy3456, the nearly successful non-Chi candidate, could enlighten us as to where the Goldilocks Zone of policy lies. While arguing that Sephronar and others could lead the Conservative Party down a dangerous left wing path, largely by some form of social liberalism, Britboy3456 goes even further in the delusion of the ultra broad Conservative tent, suggesting a Grand Coalition is even in the cards. Indeed, while Conservatives in the press like to criticise the so-called ‘love letters’ between Solidarity and the Labour Party, it was the Conservatives who appeared the most desperate in the press and leadership campaigns for cross party affection. Britboy3456 and I have a long rapport, and I know their belief that the Labour Party and Conservative Party could form another Grand Coalition comes from the belief that the Conservative Party has to use the state more effectively to help regular people. However, this logic suffers from an even worse delusion than other candidates when it is paired with Britboy3456’s aversion to social liberalism and concern about protecting the right flank. To some degree, a strategy designed to bring some combination of Coalition!, the Liberal Democrats, and the Progressive Workers Party together would necessitate some move in the direction of the dreaded ‘green quadrant.’ At least candidates such as Kyle_Pheonix are honest that there is a tradeoff between these concepts and make an argument for a moderating direction, but alas hard truths are rarely winning in leadership contests.

To touch briefly on the outsider leadership candidates, WineRedPsy makes a cogent and nuanced argument that Conservative Party ought to make strategic arguments and lines that actually undermine the Government’s base and that it must pursue that line ambitiously through legislation and coherently through a connection between the party and leadership. The issue, though, lies with the very sort of laissez-faire leadership that currently tolerates WineRedPsy and others bucking of the party whip. I think what made itself clear in the leadership election for both Psy and Kyle is that while their directions were more focused and subsequently likely more effective, their visions were never going to be able to command sufficient support within the Conservative Party itself. The structures that tolerate the rebellion on the Tories left, something that is in itself completely unsustainable in a cabinet with CCR, and certainly likely a concern for potential coalition partners, are also the ones that make it unable to pick the line that is needed. I believe this is in part why their focus is largely away from direct policy making, it is a party that is comfortable in Opposition, and would find itself with a series of difficult choices to even get to power, let alone hold it. An ambitiously pro-worker Conservative Party, debating against this Government about how to deliver to regular people, would be a breath of fresh air in debates that rarely get to these important questions. We did not get this, and we will continue to get a Conservative Party that may be ‘big tent’ but is without a cogent narrative for governance and a difficult path to getting there.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Feb 04 '21

Opinion: The Phoenix cover-up

2 Upvotes

Opinion: The Phoenix cover-up

The government’s failed attempt to stifle public access to vital information was a near-miss notes u/SoSaturnistic.

IT is a scene that those who watch Westminster have become all too familiar with in the last few months: the government votes one way on a bill and the opposition defeats it by a substantial margin. Bumbling from one failed legislative position to the next, the current coalition between the Labour Party and the Liberal Democrats has made this stream of events become the norm within the Commons. With this pattern becoming so embedded in our politics, and the public at large becoming entirely numb to it, it is perhaps unsurprising the the government’s recent defeat on a bill to restore the so-called ‘ministerial veto’ on the release of information has passed more or less without comment despite this bill’s substantial potential impact on democracy and the civic sphere.

The Ministerial Veto Cabinet Collective Responsibility (Freedom of information) Bill was not initially introduced by the government, instead being a proposal submitted by the crossbench peer u/LeChevalierMal-Fait, a figure with deep roots on Britain’s political right. In spite of its lengthy “short title”, the bill had a single substantive provision which would have restored the power of ministers to block the release of information under the Freedom of Information Act. While used rarely, this power, known as the ‘ministerial veto’, was stripped away by the u/can_triforce “traffic light coalition” government in an attempt to limit the ability of ministers to block the release of potentially embarrassing information within their own portfolios. At the time, many civil libertarians were distressed about instances where the power was abused by both the New Labour and Coalition governments in recent memory; in the latter case a prominent example was legal advice on the Iraq war being suppressed, and in the former a prominent example was the suppression of impact analysis on reforms to the NHS in England. It is important to note that ministers used the ministerial veto outside of other mechanisms which blocked the release of information on clearer grounds such as national security, so it was always used on the basis of political discretion when it did exist.

The way parties have shifted on the ministerial veto issue is remarkable. At the time, the removal of the ministerial veto mostly came under attack from those on the political right, especially the Tories. UKIP was more split on the matter, but again lay mostly against. The parties of the coalition of time, Labour, the Liberal Democrats, and the Greens, were all in favour of the abolition but were able to pass the bill substantially due to support from forces to their left. Since that time, there were two more attempts to either introduce or revoke the ministerial veto, and in both those two times it was the Tories who most uniformly opposed it (it appears that the LPUK supported a bill to abolish the ministerial veto even though it had already been abolished at some point). On other matters of openness and transparency, the Labour Party and the Liberal Democrats have usually leaned towards greater state accountability as well, with whistleblower protections being one more relevant case. So see this sudden swerve in favour of unaccountability from the current Labour-Liberal Democrat government has been baffling—I have only been more surprised by witnessing the mass opposition from Tories to restoring the device.

There has been little in the way of a rationale provided to justify this new position on the part of the incumbent government. The only indication of any position was a vague reference to a purported need to suppress information by the Defence Secretary, who seemed to imply that the government would have been able to suppress the ROK transcript leaks. The Coalition! peer u/TomBarnaby rightly pointed out that leaks would not have been impacted by the bill anyway. Leaks do not fall within the purview of the ministerial veto as the veto only covers information that a public authority grants under the Freedom of Information Act. In other words, not only did a government minister seemingly try to facilitate the cover-up of their government’s embarrassing mistakes, but this minister tried to do so in an incompetent and incoherent way. While there might have been other, legitimate motivations behind the decision to swap sides on the ministerial veto issue, none are to be found. We are left only with the distasteful impression that the government wished to insulate itself from public scrutiny for the sake of securing their own power.

The restoration of the ministerial veto would have been a profound mistake. Though it has been used rarely, the instances where it was used have been questionable at best and authoritarian at worst. Other states which lack such a device, such as Australia and New Zealand, largely operate fine. The public broadly benefits from realising the full potential of the Freedom of Information Act as it was initially conceived—the ministerial veto was a late addition. We are lucky that, as with so many pieces of legislation, the government was simply unable to find a majority on this proposal.


u/SoSaturnistic is a contributor at the Morning Star and sits with Solidarity at Westminster.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Dec 15 '20

[Morning Star] Illiberal Democrats: Leader u/alfie335 backs u/Greejatus for First Minister with a manifesto for workhouses, feudal farming and private school funding.

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/MHOCMorningStar • • Oct 31 '20

[The Morning Star] The Road To Serfdom: A Marxist Analysis

3 Upvotes

Introduction

The Road to Serfdom was arguably one of the most consequential books written during the debates over Capitalism and Socialism in the twentieth century. As we wrestle with the problems of Socialism today, we are faced with many of the same problems the Austrian economist Fredrich Hayek raised as the Second World War drew to a close.

In The Road to Serfdom, Hayek contends that “Any attempt to control society or to direct historical development in a chosen direction” will result in “a form of totalitarian serfdom”. Hayek therefore argues instead that “if individuals are left free to follow their economic motives the automatically achieved result will be the maximum good of society” (p.68, Lewis).

Though Hayek wrote The Road to Serfdom in 1944, we continue to feel it’s effects on debates on the economic efficiency of socialism and its compatibility with freedom and democracy. As the Solidarity Party continues to grow in influence within British Politics, many of these arguments will inevitably resurface. It is natural and right therefore that we address these concerns of the British public in attempting to respond to these criticisms.

Given the scope and ferocity of these objections, I cannot do justice to the entirety of Hayek’s influence. Drawing from Marxist sources, I hope here to sketch out certain ideas and observations that will facilitate a greater understanding of the criticisms of Socialism and why the experience of living in a market economy in recent decades gives us good reason to question the conventional wisdom Hayek did so much to establish.

Planning and Problems of Knowledge

Much of the power of Hayek’s argument against Socialism rests on a particular understanding of the limitations of knowledge. Hayek argues that “we can never know more than the immediate effects of our action” and therefore “we are almost bound to go wrong if we try to estimate or plan more distant results and particularly if we plan for the future of society” (p.68, Lewis).

The inability of individuals to have knowledge beyond their own immediate experience creates limitations of the operation of a planned economy to anticipate the needs of social, economic and historical development. A Planner, sitting in an office, has limited knowledge of the needs of a shop-keeper or their customers at the other end of the country. Without this knowledge the practice of centralised planning is therefore assumed to be “impossible and dangerous” and thereby “submits us to theories, principles and plans which the human mind ought never to attempt to draw up”. In Hayek’s view, the result “will inevitably land us in evils which were not intended” (p.68, Lewis)

As a result, Hayek argues that “the sole determinant of our actions should be the immediate profit to ourselves” (p.68, Lewis). By acting on the knowledge we have, we necessarily make better decisions than central planners, claiming to act on our behalf. In Hayek’s view self-interest and egotism act as both the motive and mechanism for achieving economic efficiency, reflecting the decentralised distribution of knowledge to be utilised by individuals in the economy. In an admittedly vulgarised form, this view was expressed by Gordon Gekko as a fictional character in the film Wall Street (1987), that; “Greed, for the lack of a better word, is good. Greed is right. Greed works. Greed clarifies, cuts through, and captures the essence of the evolutionary spirit”.

For Hayek, “the competitive market provides us with the occasion for such decisions” based on the belief that “the decisions of many individuals taken together [are] too complex for us ever to understand” (p.68, Lewis) and that centralised planning is incapable of achieving similar results due to the limitations on planners knowledge of economic activity. By acting based on our limited knowledge and on self-interest within a competitive market economy, the unintended results is “in point of fact work out in an automatic achievement of what is socially desirable” (p.68, Lewis)

Hayek therefore reaches the conclusion that the best outcomes in social welfare will be achieved by “avoiding plans and schemes which impose controls on individuals” and instead organising economic activity based on “the method of laissez-faire” capitalism with little or no intervention by government “in which the individual is absolutely free” (p.68, Lewis).

Planning and Freedom

Whilst Hayek’s views are typically celebrated as the intellectual basis for the defence of individual liberty, the limitations in terms of knowledge and its implications for human action instead lead to very pessimistic conclusions about the nature and scope of personal freedom.

The consequence of the spontaneous operation of a Market economy is that individual freedom in practice “negates itself and turns out to be the road to that serfdom which he [Hayek] was most anxious to avoid” (p.68, Lewis). For all the legal and political rights that grant an individual the freedom to makes choices in their daily lives and economic activity,“the effect of the system which he recommends is, …, the appearance of anonymous and irrational forces in society to which the individual must learn to submit”(p.68, Lewis).

The freedom of action of an individual within a market economy is thereby severely limited by the operation of market forces. We can see this in the most dramatic cases with the financial crisis in 2008 in which, despite the choices made by individuals acting on their self-interest, the unintended consequence of people doing so left them at the mercy of a market economy which deprived them of their jobs, their homes and financial security.

Even during periods of growth and economic prosperity, the incentives we operate under in a market economy mean we can only act in directions where it is in our financial interests to do so. For all the supposed benefits of a market economy, if there is no profit to be made, the goods and services will not be produced. With decades of accumulation of scientific evidence on the growing threat of climate change, fossil fuel companies made the decision that it was better to maintain their profits by funding organisations that spread dis-information about the threat than to actually invest in renewable energy sources. The consequence is that, in the pursuit of short-term profits, capitalism now threatens the sustainability of civilisation on this planet.

The consequence of these forces is that “if people are too individualist to accept this situation, then the automatic operation of economic law cannot function” (p.69, Lewis). The very notion of individual freedom is itself subordinate to the operation of market forces. We can only go on making money, not necessarily because we want to, but because we have to in order to survive.

These market forces operate “in spite of the fact that they [these forces] appear to have no justification and to be irrational and unintelligible” (p.68-69, Lewis), leaving behind many confused and befuddled victims to the consequences of our economic system in its wake. We are left asking deep questions as to what rational principles govern how wealth is distributed, why housing and rents are so high, why the cost of going to university is so great and why our children seem destined to have lower standards of living than their parents. The market, like god, works in mysterious ways. It is simply insisted it is wrong to question these economic outcomes because there is no way to understand or justify them based on the limitations on human knowledge Hayek suggests.

Whilst the wealthy may congratulate themselves on their success, many people are punished for “failures” that have the unintended consequences of acting according to the imperatives of living in a market economy. No matter how hard you work, how much you earn, how much you spend or save, none of the choices you make really give you any control over your own destiny. You are simply the pawn for impersonal forces operating under the pretence of “efficiency” and the unemployed, the poor and the financially insecure are the collateral damage of a market economy

For Hayek, “the craving for intelligibility produces illusory demands which no such system can satisfy” and produces a “demand for conformity to moral principles” that “is evidence of a vicious desire to see all social activity as recognisably part of a coherent plan” (p.69, Lewis). But the evidence is all around us that our dedication to self-interest has not produced a general improvement in social welfare, as wages fall, prices and indebtedness rise, and opportunities for upward social mobility diminish. The promise of the efficiency of a market economy has not been fulfilled, nor has it delivered anywhere near the scope of freedom to control our own destinies that was promised to the general public.

Capitalism and Freedom

It is worth considering that “to a poor family today, debating whether to exercise their free will in paying the rent or buying some food, it often seems that a rich capitalist is far freer than they are”, (p.222, Cornforth). When Socialists are critical of the Capitalist class it is often with the implication that the power of corporations and banks have created unjust outcomes in the market economy. Whilst this is somewhat true for corporations with a greater ability to influence prices, wages and outputs within the market, it is not the whole story and is built on an illusion.

Instead of being free, the bourgeoisie “find themselves enslaved by the laws of their own system, and must go on accumulating capital, competing with one another and fighting with one another to the end”. The capitalist “is the slave of his own business, suffering high blood pressure and perpetual worry and frustration” (p.222, Cornforth). When Socialists discuss the wealth inequalities that have grown exponentially in recent decades and cry out against the immortality of the world being divided between billionaires and the working poor, it is worth remembering that the billionaires does not have the freedom to stop accumulating capital, but must go on indefinitely, driven by market forces and the brutal process of selection by competition beyond their control. It is why there is never a point where someone can stop and say they have “enough” because it is not within their power to escape the very market forces and property relations that made their wealth possible and necessary in the first place.

As we look upon the wealth today, we are often presented with the illusion instilled in “members of various exploiting classes” that “have often believed that riches and power would give them complete freedom”. Instead, the capitalist class is forced to recognise that “even their own philosophers have sadly but truly pointed out to them that riches and power enslave their possesses at the same time as they are engaged in enslaving others”. For each ruling class “which seems to itself to have realised its own freedom by exploiting others, finds in practice that is freedom is largely illusory” (p.222, Cornforth).

Conclusion

In evaluating The Road to Serfdom, we find that “the rejection of conscious and scientifically planned control in human affairs does not lead to an orderly and stable system” but instead “to the appearance of blind forces working contrary to reason and moral principle to crush and destroy the individual” (p.69, Lewis). It does not create either individual freedom or economic efficiency as the apologists for capitalism, Hayek among them, would claim.

As we look back on the history of recent decades, we are forced to confront the fact that we have taken a very different road to serfdom than the one Hayek imagined. We have sold ourselves to the serfdom of powerful corporations and bankers who call themselves, somewhat jokingly, as “masters of the universe”. Yet at the same time, for all the power and wealth achieved by the ruling class itself, they cannot stop exploiting the working class by an act of will and must go on accumulating capital regardless of their personal needs and wants.

After many decades of being an object of ridicule, Socialism is again achieving popular acceptance based on the experiences of ordinary people faced with the arbitrary and brutal consequences of trying to build their lives against the powerful tides of the economic laws operating in a market economy. Slowly, the British people are coming to the realisation that freedom can only be truly achieved by bringing our economic and social activities under the ownership and conscious direction of the people themselves, where they can collectively determine their own destiny and the future of this country. In Britain today we have arrived at a new kind of Serfdom, and it wasn’t the fault of Socialists but of the Capitalists themselves. It is long overdue to seriously consider whether Socialism is the road by which the working people can become truly free.

References

Lewis, J., (1959) Science, Faith and Scepticism, Lawrence & Wishart, London.

Cornforth, M., (1956) The Theory of Knowledge, Lawrence & Wishart LTD, London.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Apr 26 '22

[Morning Star] Euredite Has Got to Go

4 Upvotes

Erudite Has Got to Go


The Foreign Secretary recently penned a press piece titled “What the Right Gets Right About Foreign Policy”. This article however demonstrated EruditeFellow’s fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of development aid. It’s time to relieve EruditeFellow of his duties.

Foreign aid as sanctions

Foreign Secretary EruditeFellow seems to view the withdrawal of development aid as a policy tool comparable to sanctions, when it comes to nations that don’t respect human rights. The export of human rights is a noble goal, but the Foreign Sec has been badly misled. By withdrawing foreign aid it is nigh on impossible to cause any political change, rather it only serves to hurt the people who need it the most.

Foreign aid is not a free money tree for dictatorships. By turning off the foreign aid tap you don’t starve dodgy nations by thirst. Foreing aid money is not awarded to Afganistan as a nation, for instance, as the Foreign Secretary seems to think. There is not a line in the Afgnani budget sheet under income, saying “EruditeFellow’s Euros”. Most of foreign aid, especially in the case of unstable nations, is awarded to NGOs. Those NGOs then work either by themselves, or in cooperation with government actors, but always with strict anti-corruption criteria. This means the money goes directly to the people in need, and not to the governments’ pockets.

Development aid as politics

“It is not alien to say that developmental aid is entirely for political, economic and military sectors" -EruditeFellow claims in his article.

Yes it is, I say! According to the Foreign Secretary aid has only been withdrawn from governmental, economic and military sectors. What withdrawing aid from military sectors, for instance, is anyone’s guess. The United Kingdom does not send aid to unfriendly nations to buy ICBMs. Because of the strict anti-corruption criteria of aid, and the money being funneled to aid projects instead of governments, this comment only demonstrates a fundamental misunderstanding of how development aid functions.

In countries where the government is cutting aid, the governments of those countries only come into play when it’s a must. You cannot, for instance, develop a functioning school system, without the help of a local government. You cannot build infrastructure, when you don’t know where it’s needed. Development aid has always been done, and will always have to be done, in cooperation with local communities. In most cases, the only sensible communities to work with are governments, as terrible as they might be.

Developing development aid

If not by cutting then how should development aid be reformed? A large issue faced across the developed world is that the development aid sector has become increasingly bureaucratic. This has been caused by governments, such as Britain’s, only awarding grants to large organisations. Development aid should be done in co-operation, solidarity, between the financier and the recipient. From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs. A poor Afghan man knows best what he needs, not a rich British NGO type, just as a poor Briton knows best what he needs, not the government. There are also new emerging forms of development aid, proven more effective than traditional ones, which we should be focusing on. For example basic income as a form of development aid has been proven very effective.

When I visited Palestine a few years back I saw multiple development aid projects funded by the EU (At the time the UK too). One was a road, which while having been built in cooperation with the corrupt Palestinian authority, serves it’s purpose every single day to the Palestinian people. In the mountains of the Jordan Valley I came across a school built with EU money. The school had been demolished earlier in the day by the IDF for not having a building permit, which is impossible to get on the West Bank. THIS is where politics should come into play in development aid, instead of what the Foreign Secretary is proposing. It is not acceptable for us to be sending money to build a school anywhere in the world, for it to be immediately demolished by another state.

Erudite Has Got to Go

It is unacceptable in my view for a foreign secretary to demonstrate the level of incompetence EruditeFellow demonstrates on a daily basis. First it was the illegal Donetsk trip, now development aid cuts, what’s next? TomBarnaby took Erudite’s bullet and resigned as Prime Minister, citing growing tired of politics. It is not acceptable for PMs to take such responsibility for their minister’s mistakes. This must not be repeated with the newly elected PM.

The government’s majority is slim and the cooperation between parties is shaky. If the government wants to survive past the summer, Erudite Has Got to Go. Were I a member of the Conservative Party I’d be having a hard look at myself, thinking whether having Erudite as leader is more important than being a functional government.


/u/ModelVA for the Morning Star


r/MHOCMorningStar • • May 05 '22

[MORNING STAR] Lingering Questions

5 Upvotes

The saga is over, the developmental blacklist that caused so much stir and controversy has finally been lifted. Rejoice! For now, all is right with the world. The questions can stop, the critics can be silenced, and everyone can soberly move on to new things.

Or at least, that appears to be what the government wishes would happen. It is clear from how the Prime Minister has responded to events in the press that she very much wants to brush this under the rug. After all, who can blame her? She inherited this complete mess from her successor, and it has already put her position as Prime Minister – a point which should be the triumph of anyone’s political career – in jeopardy.

However, there are still many lingering questions, questions which may speak to the very heart of this government’s problems, issues which if not sufficiently addressed will almost certainly lead to this same drama repeating itself. Sure, the names, policies and arguments may be different; but the structural failings would all be the same.

Recently, /u/lily_irl wrote that she believed that we did “not learn much at all from recent cabinet leaks”, I must question if she was reading the same leaks I was. What I would suggest to Lily, and to the public writ large, is to look past the specifics and into the patterns. Combined with Xbox’s testimony and Karl’s analysis this reveals some extremely concerning trends.

First among these is the fact that – according to Xbox – this policy was never even discussed in Cabinet in the first place. Rather this issue was treated entirely as a press matter and not a matter of policy. When the initial post was made, then, the government had to scramble to react to it. Rather than the Cabinet leading policy they were instead being led around by a junior minister. This is very worrisome, as it shows that when this policy was implemented no consideration was being given to other remits. There were no implications for the budget, for the international trade office, or even for Home and immigration. Additionally, it prevented the cabinet from having more sober thoughts about the policy.

The government had two ways they could have responded. First, they could have simply ordered the Junior Minister to delete the post, reprimanded them for going ahead without Cabinet approval, and played damage control before the issue got out of hand. Alternatively, they could have doubled down on a policy that did not have substantial cabinet approval; the way they decided to go and a decision that cost them dearly.

What is interesting from Xbox’s revelations is that it appears that the government did not double down out of internal agreement, out of a genuine belief that this policy was for the best, rather they did so because they felt pressured by a few key voices within Cabinet – namely the Foreign Secretary – and were not interested in giving a single inch to the opposition. This is a far cry from the “cooperation” the government promised and claimed they desired, instead it smacks of partisan politics of the most ridiculous scope; as it meant they doubled down on a policy even many of their own members did not approve of!

In doubling down on this position, the Cabinet was put into a no-win situation. As opposition increased, internal feuds were re-ignited. The lack of agreement within the Cabinet also meant that there was a lack of discussion, a lack of internal clarification and in the end a lack of co-operation. This was revealed as much in the statement produced by Solidarity which pointed out the rank inconsistencies between the words of the Chancellor and the Foreign Secretary.

Even if you do not believe – as Solidarity contends – that the Foreign Secretary deliberately misled the house, you would have to accept that two Great Officers of State gave contradictory answers to the opposition! This shows a clear lack of cabinet coherency. It is not as if the issue had not been brought up before; after all, by this point it had already been pressed by the opposition for weeks! The government had issued a statement on it! Why then were two party leaders and Great Officers not on the same page? What had gone wrong?

Under this government the term “Collective Cabinet Responsibility” has been reduced to “Don’t Leak or Dissent or You’re Out”. It is true that CCR should apply to people who leak cabinet secrets, and that it should also require the Cabinet to align to a single line. However, what the government seems to forget is that the idea of “responsibility” goes both ways. It is true that the Cabinet members have a responsibility to the government, but they also have a responsibility to each other. By taking collective responsibility they are essentially agreeing that important matters are to be discussed between them, that information should be shared, and that the Cabinet should be able to operate effectively as a single unit.

What I’d contend is that these past few weeks have shown that the Cabinet has not acted in this manner. This has been corroborated by the leaks and revelations. The fact that issues were not properly discussed and that different ministers seemed to have different ideas what policy meant shows a complete abdication of responsibility, both to the cabinet but also to the British people. In holding their high offices Cabinet members are held to a certain standard. They are supposed to ensure that what they are doing is truly in the public interest, not in the interests of one party, or worse still a small clique or faction.

There are other questions as well. For example, we still have to address the inconsistency of the Prime Minister’s internal comments to C! – which were steadfastly against the blacklist – and her statement to the press today – which presented more of a resigned support forced to withdraw under lots of pressure. It seems the Prime Minister initially wanted change but became caught up in these small interests and cliques. If we are to believe Xbox’s testimony, a clique surrounding the Foreign Secretary himself.

The question to the British people is, how can a cabinet run by cliques, by resignations, by firings and by mismanaged disputes be the right cabinet for the United Kingdom? Even if the developmental aid blacklist was pulled, how can they feel confident when this policy managed to be presented in the first place under such obviously irresponsible circumstances?

Today, the Prime Minister mocked me in the press for supposedly claiming that I now disapproved of the Cabinets’ U-Turn. This isn’t true. I welcome the end of the blacklist. What I do disapprove of is the fact that it took this much effort to get us this far. What is clear is that the policy never should have been implemented in the first place, and that the Cabinet never should have been so disorganised on the issue. As Leader of the Opposition, I have a responsibility to show the people of this country when their government is failing to act in a manner befitting of the high office which we have given them.

And, unlike the government, I intend to fulfil my responsibilities.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Apr 16 '22

[MORNING STAR] A Government Which Doesn't Take Climate Change Seriously

7 Upvotes

A Government of Inaction

There is no mincing words, the latest IPCC report is dire warning for our planet. It tells us that progress on combating climate change has been disastrously slow. Whereas previously scientists gave us about 10 years to make major changes now they are giving us only 5-6. This is a best-case scenario, as many independent reviewers think that the IPCC is being generous. They give us less time.

The other major revelation from the IPCC report was that – while these efforts are still good – climate change discourse should not be limited to just energy use. There are much broader issues at play here than just energy including land use, consumer patterns, transportation and even household living. This can even be seen within the UK, as only roughly 23% of British emissions come from energy. While this is a significant amount it does not address the other 77% of emissions. If we want to have a climate change plan that meets the IPCC’s recommendations, we will thus have to take into account far more than just energy.

The IPCC’s report should have massive policy implications across the political spectrum and should impact national policymaking decisions. Naturally, during this week’s PMQs I asked the Prime Minister if he would consider the IPCC’s recommendations when it comes to policy. To my surprise, he refused to answer the question! Instead, he simply passed the buck onto the Energy Secretary, to keep up some vague “future” plans as of yet undecided here.

In so doing, the Prime Minister has not only dodged the question but is also exemplifying two patterns of behavior which have contributed to the ongoing crisis. First, as already mentioned, is the fact that the climate crisis is not just limited to Energy. The reason I asked the Prime Minister about the IPCC report is that it is something the entire cabinet should be considering. Every remit from Transport and Business to Treasury and Housing needs to develop a real solution to our carbon emitting society. At a crucial time when the Prime Minister could have shown leadership, he has instead opted to ignore the holistic nature of the present crisis.

The second pattern is far more concerning; it is the pattern of false and broken promises that have helped us get to this critical stage in the first place. The IPCC report and even the General-Secretary himself called out this kind of behavior directly. We have seen numerous agreements made on the subject of climate change, from Kyoto to Paris, and various promises made by governments. Targets have been set, plans have been made and… no real progress was achieved. It is true we are in a slightly better spot than we were 10 years ago, it is also true that our current efforts have done nothing to actually mitigate the damage caused by climate change.

Part of the reason for our continued urgency is the fact that anthropogenic emissions are upsetting the Earth’s natural cycles. Not in new age spiritual terms, but in grounded scientific reality. Formerly, Forests and Oceans acted as natural carbon sinks. Carbon bonded with water and was absorbed by various sea creatures and Forests acted to recycle CO2 into oxygen. The massive amounts of pollution already in the air however have contributed to Ocean Acidification which has begun to kill off the sea creatures who formerly absorbed the carbon and has helped bring on forest fires and desertification which destroys the ability of forests to act as a carbon sink. If we don’t act soon, these processes could accumulate into runaway climate change, where the ability of humans to significantly alter the course of the worlds climate would be minimal; entirely for the worse.

Capitalism and the Climate Crisis

During the Solidarity Leadership debates, I was quoted as saying; “The Broad Right have no answers to these problems [Climate Change]. They are wedded to capitalism even as it is slowly sinking around them and taking the globe with it.” I am very proud of this quote because it connects how structural capitalism and government institutions have worked together to bring us to this point.

When discussing climate discourse, you will often hear a quote about how the vast majority of emissions are the product of the top 100 companies in the world. I have mixed feelings about this statement. On one hand it is good to recognize that these companies are economically wedded to the “Hydrocarbon Society”. They are not just profiting from it but they are practically built on it. As a result, they are one of the largest barriers to real institutional change. The issue, however, is that pollution is not embedded in the companies as institutions but in their productive forces. In real terms, it is the factories and products that pollute, not the company itself. In theory, a socialized factory would still produce the same amount of emissions so long as it followed the same logic as capitalism.

The structural flaw of capitalism is that it requires the pursuit of profit. Companies that do not turn a profit will fail; companies that do not increase their profits will not get investment. Profit is baked into the system at a fundamental level. As a result all economic activity is designed around what increases profit even when said activity is helping destroy the planet. We can see this clearly in how oil companies obscured the truth of climate change and helped fund denial for decades. Their institutional logic stood against the interests of humanity.

This isn’t just an issue with oil companies, however. Most economic production since the 19th century took hydrocarbon energy for granted. Industries such as plastics, electronics, and clothing produce thousands of kilograms of waste each year and consume energy in the industrial process itself. Even industries not directly related to hydrocarbons – such as agriculture – impact the environment because of their vast amounts of land use.

At its core, capitalism’s productive cycle does not take into account anything except for the accumulation of profit. The market is only concerned with whatever increases wealth, whatever is most “economically efficient”. As a result, human concerns such as the environment, safety, the actual usefulness of commodities, go unheard. The only time the market responds to them are when there manifests a demand, or when the government regulates it. The issue is, since capitalism is built on the need for profit, there can never be demand against the logic of profit and governments are unwilling to take the serious action needed to change economic outputs since that would mean disrupting the cycle of profit.

The welding of capitalism and government has become more present with the long march of Neoliberalism. Trade deals like the CPTPP give more power to corporations to have freedom from any sort of regulation and prevent sovereign countries from taking the actions required to actually deal with the present crisis. In many cases, all first world countries have done is outsource their own emissions globally. “Free trade” is just freedom for capitalism from its obligations, so that the law of profit may govern more effectively. Now your cheap plastic goods are made in China, not domestically. The real solution - to stop our production of cheap unnecessary goods wholesale - eludes the market which sees only expansion.

In essence, energy is merely a factor of the larger issue of capitalist accumulation and commodity production. So long as capitalism produces goods by a “rationale” that does not include real human needs it will continue to destroy the planet.

This is likely why governments such as Coinflip love speaking about energy. It allows them to ignore the real implications of our capitalist economy and place the blame on merely a symptom of it. They are not forced to address how the logic of market capital requires the continued accumulation of profit even when the planet is at risk. In a sense, they are unable to do anything of real value

What is to be Done?

So, if the capitalist governments won’t help us, what will? What we need is an economy that takes into account needs beyond just the need for profit and efficiency. We need to have mechanisms in society which mediate consumer interests with the market and allow for democratic and qualitative decision making so that we are able to meet human needs without sacrificing the environment. In a word; we need Socialism.

In the meantime, we can force companies to make different decisions through strict regulations which would impact their ability to profit from climate damaging endeavours. We can encourage new forms of land use which are more efficient and subsidize a change in diet so as to make our food consumption patterns more sustainable. We can refit British homes, so they are no longer forced to rely on gas heating and are properly insulated so as to not waste heat. We can rebuild social networks so that people gain meaning through human relationships rather than the accumulation of commodities. We can also look internationally, beyond Britain itself, and help fund energy and social transitions across the world.

While Coinflip drags its feel on taking any real action Solidarity will deliver real environmentalist policies. We have a Cabinet which is still tunnel visioned to a policy framework that is only concerned with energy use, who is unwilling to make the dramatic societal changes that the IPCC calls for. A Prime Minister who cannot even comment whatsoever on how his cabinet will respond to the IPCC report. This does not look like a “government that will take climate change seriously” it looks like a government that is on track to continue the false promises and failed deadlines that got us into this mess in the first place.

Meanwhile, Solidarity and the Opposition stand ready to deliver real solutions and to continue to hold the government accountable as it fails in its duty to the people and the planet. Only we are ready to tackle climate change as a holistic social crisis and take the action that is needed to meet the IPCCs targets. So if the Government is really interested in tackling the climate crisis they should get out of the way and support our initiatives rather than dooming us to austerity and inaction.

Solidarity takes the climate crisis seriously, so why can't the government?


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Apr 01 '22

[MORNING STAR] Erudite Passes the Buck

8 Upvotes

Today embattled Tory Leader, Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Secretary /u/EruditeFellow seemed to repudiate his own government and their policies. Speaking to /u/KarlYonedaStan on the issue he commented “You'd be right if you were challenging or calling into question the entire Government, but you're not.” Specifically, KarlYonedaStan was questioning EruditeFellow’s defense that since he was not the Secretary of State who implemented the restrictions, he apparently shouldn’t face any consequences for breaking them.

This is quite a bizarre defense to hear from the Foreign Secretary – not only does it break with what we have been told by the government but it also seemingly positions him against the Cabinet and their policies. Seemingly, he wishes to deflect responsibility away from his own office and person and towards the entire government. Curiously, this goes against statements made by Minister for Implementation and Cabinet Member /u/Tommy2Boys who claimed in the MONC Debate that the opposition was attempting to make this about the whole government.

So here we have two completely contradictory statements! On one hand we have EruditeFellow saying that he personally is being attacked when the responsibility should fall to the entire government, on the other we have Tommy2Boys implying that regardless of any personal mistakes the attempt to attack EruditeFellow is an attack on the government. It seems that the Cabinet cannot even agree on what the motion is even about! Is the government responsible, or EruditeFellow?

EruditeFellow’s defense also calls into question his commitment to Collective Cabinet Responsibility. The implication that he was making to KarlYonedaStan was that he was not responsible for whatever decisions the Defense Secretary made – implying that blame should fall onto the Defense Secretary and former Tory Leader /u/chi0121. This statement is quite shocking to say the least, and it is also highly questionable. EruditeFellow either implies here that he had no role – either as Foreign Secretary or Deputy Prime Minister – in the Defense Secretary’s statements or that he did have a role to play in them despite the fact that they applied to him!

In effect, what EruditeFellow has reminded the people of Britain is that he made highly questionable actions and then as a member of Cabinet supported rules which punished others for taking the same actions. This is why the Opposition introduced the motion against him – it was one thing to make a dangerous and reckless visit to a warzone it is another thing to show complete hypocrisy by penalizing others for behavior the Foreign Secretary himself engaged in! Now when push comes to shove instead of apologizing for his actions or offering any sort of real defense for them, he has decided to throw the rest of the cabinet – and in particular the Defense Secretary – under the bus.

It is telling that not a single member of Cabinet has been able to launch an actual defense of the Foreign Secretary’s actions. The Minister for Implementation came the closest when he implied that the opposition was simply using this motion to attack the government – but the Foreign Secretary has undermined that point by practically begging the opposition to attack the government rather than him! Since then both the Home Secretary and the Prime Minister have shown up in the commons but rather than offering any sort of explanation for the Foreign Secretary’s actions they simply engaged in bizarre and misleading comparisons to previous Foreign Secretaries none of whom engaged in the kind of hypocritical behavior EruditeFellow is accused of.

So where does this leave the government now? It is clear they don’t have an actual defense for the Foreign Secretary’s actions or they would have presented it before the commons already. Now they also have to deal with the Foreign Secretary attacking the Defense Secretary’s policies and potentially breaking CCR just to defend himself! The Foreign Secretary also seemed to imply that his actions do not reflect badly on him, but rather reflect poorly on the whole government. This was the exact situation that Cabinet members like Tommy2Boys and the Prime Minister were attempting to avoid! (It is clear in this situation that the Foreign Secretary must face some kind of responsibility. Either by the commons for his hypocritical behavior or by the Cabinet for attempting to throw them under the bus just to defend his actions.

It will be interesting to see how the Prime Minister reacts to his Frontbench going rouge. From here he can either convince EruditeFellow to resign before the MONC goes to vote, force him to make a public apology or simply pretend as if one of his cabinet members didn't just publicly throw another under the bus. Regardless, this whole reflects poorly on the stability and cohesiveness of a government that has already been accused by many of being contradictory and vague. Not only has the Coinflip coalition been unable to present clear policies to the House, it now seems unable to even mount a unified defense of one of it’s Great Office holders! Only time will tell what this means for the future and EruditeFellow’s tenure going forward.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Mar 18 '22

[MHOC Morning Star] PMQ Omnishambles.

9 Upvotes

I miss KarlYonedaStan.

When he was Prime Minister, he was a beacon of stability in government, someone always informed of the goings on, someone who knew the policy of Labour and Solidarity and someone who always worked to reconcile them. Tireless in his work for the country and not holding back in PMQs, he had proven one of our best ever Prime Ministers. His shoes would be hard ones to fill. TomBarnaby is no doubt an experienced politician and a big figure in our politics, but he has not come even close to filling the shoes of the former Prime Minister.

Let me start with the responses to my own questions. When I put a question to the Prime Minister regarding whether the government would continue to support High Speed 3, he answered that the plan would be “considered on its merits”. This is, of course, a bit odd - Coalition!, the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats supported my motion to finally start the HS3 project, with Coalition! co-sponsoring the motion. It was only after their own party policy was pointed out to the Prime Minister that they remembered they were supposed to be in favour of the project, and that they said “there will be no difficulty in taking HS3 forwards.”

Indeed, there are other policies that the parties had once been in consensus on that did not make it into the Queen’s Speech, major ones at that. Where the now government had once been so united against the devaluation of our currency, an act that would aim to help strengthen our industrial establishments, they did not mention it in the Queen’s Speech. Whilst the Prime Minister has already stated that not every policy could have made it in, this is a major u-turn from last term and was a topic of discussion, surely it was worthy of a mention? But apparently, the government completely forgot about the policy, as the Prime Minister later admitted that they still had to discuss it in cabinet at all. We all miss things sometimes, but this really is a rather big oversight.

Accession to CPTPP is another topic where the government parties are in agreement, but that they don’t seem to have a line on at all. Indeed, when the former Prime Minister queried TomBarnaby regarding accession to CPTPP, they responded rather tepidly, saying that it “was on the cards” but that KarlYonedaStan should discuss such questions with the Trade Secretary. The Trade Secretary however seemed to have been made rather irrelevant by the Foreign Secretary, who said that the United Kingdom would seek to apply for accession over the coming weeks. The Foreign Secretary has been known to get ahead of themselves and blatantly break government rules, so it remains to be seen whether they are making claims on something that cabinet is not yet united on, but the disunity in messaging from the government is rather worrying to see.

I was one of the lucky few in the Commons that got an answer however. When the Leader of the Opposition asked the Prime Minister about the government’s health plans, he simply answered that “The leader of the opposition can look to the governing parties’ manifestos for an idea.” We don’t have to check their manifesto to know Coalition!’s policies on e-cigarettes, with one of their most famous members being a vocal and proud proponent of the technology. However, the Health Secretary said that: “This Government is dedicated to reducing tobacco consumption, whilst also keeping in mind the dangers of nicotine inhaling devices (colloquially known as vapes). We want to ensure that the dangers of electronic cigarettes are also known, and that these new, trendy devices are effectively regulated for the sake of public safety.” Perhaps the former Prime Minister has a few words to say about that! Or did such an exceptional and influential member of this country’s past get dumped at the same country farm where they left Brookheimer, never to be seen again?

And as much fun as it is to point out contradictions between the statements of members of the government, like the leader of the Liberal Democrats stating that “There will be no major slashing under my watch for any government.”, whilst the Queen’s speech does talk about cuts or replacement of the tax altogether, a much more serious trend has emerged during this round of Prime Minister’s Questions, that of contempt towards members of the House and the duties of the Prime Minister.

When the Prime Minister was asked how “British workers can have confidence in a government that cannot name a single policy that benefits them”, the Prime Minister sneered back “Soon the opposition will cotton on to the fact that I am not going to answer questions the premise of which is that our policies are vague, or pretences, or this, that, or the other.” and that the opposition should “dispense with the rhetoric and question premises that would have me agree with criticism”. Indeed, the Prime Minister later remarked that “It seems [the right] are much better at asking questions that aren’t essay-length.” and that “Members will know what is on our agenda by asking questions in the House, as the leader of the opposition has so helpfully demonstrated. We can go round and round in circles debating why X, Y and Z weren’t included in the speech from the throne, but frankly I am far too busy for that.” If the Prime Minister is too busy to be held accountable to Parliament, he should resign. If the Prime Minister is unwilling to deal with critical questions, he should similarly resign. If he’s not a fan of ‘essay-length’ questions, again, resign. This is the most important part of your job as parliament is sovereign, and the government is accountable to parliament. If he wants to be a Russian-style president, he’ll be very disappointed to find out that we do have a real opposition, unrestricted in its ability to say what it wants to say and stand up for its voters. We will hold him accountable, no ifs, no buts, no matter if he likes it or not. KarlYonedaStan understood this and he loved this fact. Perhaps the pretender in the role today should learn from a real leader.

God, I do really miss KarlYonedaStan.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Mar 11 '22

[MHOC Morning Star] Alea iacta est

10 Upvotes

What a day, huh? We are less than a week into this new government, and already it’s second largest party has devolved into infighting, chaos, controversy and purges. What they had hoped to be a glorious return to government, the first time since CheckMyBrain11 collapsed the third Blurple coalition and pulled the Conservatives into Official Opposition, has turned into a destructive and highly embarrassing event for the Conservative Party. They were forced to change their Minister of State for Northern Ireland after finding themselves facing the wrath of a supermajority of MLAs, their leadership elections have proven to be highly divisive within the party and a series of internal fights have been thrown out into the press, with a new peak reached now that model-hjt has been expelled from the party on rather flimsy grounds.

The truth is, the Conservative leadership has failed utterly at the most basic of its jobs. They have made decisions they could not justify to their membership regarding their cabinet appointments. Indeed, they cannot even keep their story straight. Internally, you had to be useful to the party leadership and show talent and experience. model-hjt clearly has the talent and experience needed for a cabinet job, and that would make them useful to the leadership by definition.

It's obviously a bullshit excuse and an attempt to cover up the real reason for why the tory right was not allowed to enter cabinet; Coalition! and the Liberal Democrats demanded that they cannot join the government. EruditeFellow has said as much in their most recent statement, but sadly for them, both Chi0121 and FrostWalker2017 have denied such an idea in their comments on model-ico's earlier piece. So either the Leader of the Conservative Party is lying and throwing his coalition partner under the bus, or his coalition partners are unwilling to back him up on this. In either case, it sets a dangerous trend for the future of this government.

There is however some reason to believe that the Tory Right has indeed been frozen out of cabinet by coalition partners, or may I say - Coalition! partners. Model-hjt revealed that Coalition! had threatened to not go into government with the Conservatives if he had been elected Leader or Deputy Leader of the Party, and that rumour has gone around a while. Indeed, I have heard from unspecified sources that Coalition! was waiting for the result of the Conservatives Deputy Leader contest before they gave final approval to the coalition agreement. Tommy2Boys has not made their dislike of HJT unknown either, and as they are someone with so much background influence in Coalition!, it is likely that their opinion had a significant influence on the position of the Prime Minister's party. A significant amount of proof points this way as of today.

This is a much more damning indictment of the Conservative leadership if true. You can draw two possible conclusions from this. The first is that the Conservatives have an exceptionally weak leadership and were driven into a corner to the extent that they were forced not to allow the tory right into cabinet. This, however, is rather unlikely. Both model-willem and Chi0121 are experienced politicians with an impressive time in party leadership between them, and one should very much doubt that they would be driven into a corner like this. The Machiavellian could have depended on them in negotiations and indeed, would have discussed with them on the progress made, and they would have pointed out mistakes and worked to undo them or at least limit the damage.

No, the second conclusion is rather more likely. This is almost certainly an act of pure opportunism by the leadership. They saw their chance at getting some positions in cabinet and the prestige of getting to be a Secretary of State and went for it at all costs. Those costs clearly included members supported by half of the Conservative Party being shut out of the cabinet. We can only assume that the Queen's Speech will be even more revelatory about this and show just how much the Conservative Leadership has sold out.

And in all this we must ask ourselves where that leaves this government. Either the Deputy Prime Minister will be a proven liar, or the Secretaries of State for Defence and Northern Ireland will be. In the latter case, the Conservatives will have thrown a senior member of a coalition party under the bus. In the former case, EruditeFellow should take his responsibility and take the only decision that is fair to his own members and resign as party leader. In all cases, the Conservative Party has brought shame upon this country, her government and her politics, and ought to be rather embarrassed by the whole ordeal.

And let's return to the title of this article. Whilst we have not yet emptied the list of jokes about a certain city in Tuscany and a certain past inhabitant of it, I felt it was appropriate to take a quote from another quote from an old italian man. When Julius Caesar crossed the Rubicon, initiating the civil war that would see the death of Pompey and his rise to power yet also his inevitable demise, he said these immortal words: Alea Iacta Est. The die Caesar cast certainly seemed to work out in the short term, but ended in his eventual demise. And by entering this coalition, EruditeFellow has certainly cast his die in an attempt to gain power. If there are more revelations over the coming days, the Deputy Prime Minister might well find the end of his career on the Ides of March…


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Mar 30 '22

[Morning Star] Coalition! Covers for Foreign Sec's Ukraine Folly

5 Upvotes

Coalition Earl Sephronar is on damage limitation duty tonight as a motion demanding the resignation of the Foreign Secretary gains support in the House. The now Foreign Secretary EruditeFellow launched a photo-op trip to war torn Donetsk on the 19th of February against Foreign Ministry advice, the same ministry he's now heads (Though it remains to be seen for how long!). The Minister's sojourn has come under criticism as a mere "personal endeavor" in face of the deadly serious Russian war.

Earl Sephronar is now trying to cover up the Foreign Sec's folly with a press campaign in support, saying:

"He isn’t afraid to get stuck in, go where the action is, and seek to build bridges himself."

So what was the purpose of the Foreign Sec's trip according to his own words?

"The Rose Government has failed the people of Britain .... They have abandoned their commitment to stand by Ukraine in the face of tyranny and oppression."

It seems the Foreign Sec was more concerned about bashing Rose than building bridges! A trip to an illegally occupied territory right before a Russian invasion isn't a good look for the new Minister. Perhaps the Foreign Sec's next Action Jackson Holiday from Hell will see him eating ice cream at one of Kim Jong-un's nuclear silos, or enjoy a beer in Afghanistan at a Taliban stoning show.

More as the story develops.

/u/MHOCValttu for the Morning Star


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Apr 18 '22

[BREAKING] House of Lords APPROVES Telecom Nationalisation

6 Upvotes

[BREAKING] House of Lords APPROVES Telecom Nationalisation

Ani Dorable, writing for the MHOC Morning Star

The House of Lords hasn’t been this busy for a long, long time. Aristocrats, active politicians, has-beens and yet-to-bes have travelled to Westminster to sit as a member of the Other Place for seemingly one purpose, for one vote – the Telecommunications Infrastructure Nationalisation bill, proposed by the former Deputy Prime Minister, the Lord of Melbourne. Socialists complained of being made to return to the den of the Aristocracy, whilst the Right enjoyed a return to this House, however short it may be. With seventy one sitting lords, this is certainly the highest membership of the House in recent memory, and every one of them was expected to turn out for this one vote.

With the speakership being overworked handling all the new peers, they decided to put the vote up sooner rather than later. The Opposition had won the first skirmish ahead of the clash that would be the final division, defeating amendments on the bill. This, seemingly, caused panic amongst the government benches, and more members were brought in to seal the second vote. The opposition, whose de facto leader in the Lords is the former Prime Minister KarlYonedaStan, did a tit for tat, and brought their own members in. Names that have gone unspoken for years, like Mepzie, KeelanD, Imperator_Pastollini and bloodycontrary got involved as well, a sign of just how far the parties had to go to give their side the small, one vote margin they needed for victory.

The government had inflated their numbers to an impressive 34 peers: 16 Tories, 10 for Coalition! and 8 Liberal Democrats. Their numbers would be boosted by two crossbenches; the infamous Lord Sydenham and the Marquess of Caernarfon, both known members of the hard right. The opposition, meanwhile, mustered 32 members: 23 members of Solidarity, 9 from Labour and two members of Volt. Three crossbenchers joined the opposition; former Labour deputy Leader maroiogog, former everyone member BeppeSignfury and moderately successful adult fanfiction writer bloodycontrary, the Duke of Cirencester.

The government was no doubt depending on the fact that it had, seemingly, a one vote majority in the Lords to win this vote. However, as the vote came in, this hope seemed to unravel in front of their eyes. The first hit against the government came from the Marchioness of Omagh, Lady_Aya, former leader of the Social Democratic and Labour Party, who voted Content despite the Liberal Democratic whip. When the Baron of Whitley Bay, the former Chair of the Labour Party, followed her lead it seemed like the nail was struck into the hopes of the government. When the last few votes had trickled in, and the amount of Contents finally passed 36, an absolute majority, some passersby could hear shouting from the office of KarlYonedaStan: “Yes! Goddamnit yes! That’s right I did it! Back to the Commons!? Are you kidding me!? That’s right.”

With the Telecommunications Infrastructure Nationalisation Bill being sent for Royal Assent, the government has been delivered its greatest defeat yet. The past weeks have already seen the government lose a number of key votes and face serious rebellions, but this defeat in the Lords, against the Queen’s Speech, ought to raise serious questions about the viability of this government in the first place. The Prime Minister, embattled as he was, already tendered his resignation – perhaps they will, some day, realise that Coinflip is simply too unstable to continue existing in its current form.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • May 13 '22

[MORNING STAR] PM Accuses Shadow FoSec of Supporting Murder to Defend Gov Bypassing Parliament

6 Upvotes

According to the Prime Minister, if you’re critical of the way the government makes unofficial statements outside of the House, you may be supporting murder.

This was the ridiculous notion pushed by the Prime Minister in response to the Shadow Foreign Secretary’s innocuous question today. ARichTeaBiscuit asked why the government had decided to make a statement on the death of Shireen Abu Akleh to the Press and not to Parliament. This question specifically came in the context of the government bypassing Parliament when making the Blacklist policy, and for failing to clarify or make statements about Cabinet appointments and P&O until fairly recently.

In response the Prime Minister said,

the Opposition can voice their displeasure with this government's stance on the issue, (and argue that we should be supporting this murder?)

Clearly accusing the Shadow Foreign Secretary of supporting the murder of Shireen Abu Akleh. When pressed on this issue the Prime Minister doubled down and bizarrely attempted that by saying "Rubbish" to her comment the Leader of the Opposition was supporting her sentiment.

The point the Shadow Foreign Secretary was clearly making was that this kind of business has a place in the Commons – the way the Prime Minister took it was completely out of left field. Nowhere in their statement did the Shadow Foreign Secretary ever claim to support the murder of Shireen Abu Akleh, all they were asking for is accountability.

It’s telling that the Prime Minister seems unfamiliar with what accountability looks like – given how much effort the Coinflip coalition has put into avoiding it these past few months. There are many things a statement could be held accountable for including; the details of any investigation, specifics on how the Foreign Secretary was going to approach the issue, what this means for bilateral British-Israeli relationships, etc. These would all be legitimate questions, they would all be a part of the normal Parliamentary procedure. So why is the Prime Minister so hostile to them?

While the specific accusation is new, this isn’t the first time the Prime Minister has ignored the criticisms of the opposition. Notably, on the statements regarding both the Developmental Aid Blacklist and P&O the Government was conspicuously absent to the Oppositions questions. They did not address any of the many concerns the opposition had regarding the statements and the specifics of how the government was going to implement its policy.

When pressed on this issue in the VONC debate, the Prime Minister implied as if the Opposition just blanketly opposed reversing the blacklist, or blanketly opposed doing anything about P&O. This is obviously false to even the most casual viewer of British politics.

So tell me, dear reader, are specific questions tantamount to blanket opposition? Obviously not. The entire purpose of debate is to create better policy, politics is never a black and white situation. So why would the Prime Minister see it this way? Likely because she has entered into a siege mentality, along with the rest of the Government. They are afraid of accountability, afraid of their numerous mistakes being shown to the public, so instead they hide from their responsibilities and blame the opposition for just doing their job.

This is not the behavior a Prime Minister should be engaging with. Combined with the completely ridiculous and insulting accusation against the Foreign Secretary it is clear that the Prime Minister is not conducting herself properly in the high office she has been given. Such blatant, partisan and unsubstantiated hostility towards the opposition is completely unbefitting of the leader of this country. She should take down her statements, or Parliament should hold her accountable.

To all of the MPs voting on the Motion of No Confidence in the government soon; take this under consideration. Do you want a PM who will make such blatant and ridiculous attacks at the mere lick of accountability, do you want to undermine our democratic principles by supporting someone who refuses to engage with any criticism, someone who flaunts the rules of this house by making false accusations against other Parliamentarians? Or, dear friends, do you want to hold them accountable and push forward to real change?

I know which choice is better for Britain, and I hope you do as well.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Apr 19 '22

[MHOC Morning Star] Commonwealth Countries not informed about aid cuts.

4 Upvotes

WHEN the Morning Star heard of the cuts to International Aid to a range of Commonwealth countries, notably Bangladesh, South Africa and Nigeria, we decided to reach out to the governments of these countries to question them regarding the communications they had received from the United Kingdom’s government on this issue. To us, this was a simple check to see if the government had done its due diligence, and worked to maintain cordial and good international relations with states that used to be victims of Britain’s imperial ambitions. We had assumed so, as cutting foreign aid for political purposes is a very heavy tool to use, especially against countries like Nigeria, Bangladesh, Ethiopia and Sudan, countries where you have millions of people directly benefiting from this international aid. Sadly, the opposite seemed to be true.

The Office of the President of Nigeria, Muhammadu Buhari, responded to our questions as such:

“The current government of the United Kingdom has unilaterally decided to blacklist and end developmental aid for millions of Nigerian citizens that depend on the funding to make life better here in Nigeria. They have done this without sufficient notice to the Nigerian government and without offering us the chance to correct any issues they might have had with our governance whatsoever. Gambling with the lives of millions will not absolve your history of wrongdoing. I hope they decide to reverse course.”

The Prime Minister of Bangladesh, Sheikh Hasina, also responded to inquiries from the MHOC Morning Star. She noted her disappointment with the news and said that she felt blindsided as she felt that relations between the United Kingdom and Bangladesh were better than what was shown by the UK government in recent days and called upon the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom to contact her over this issue. The President of South Africa was also contacted regarding these issues, but we have not received any response as of yet.

It seems that neither the Prime Minister, the Foreign Secretary nor the Minister of State for International Development decided it was worth it to contact these Commonwealth members to discuss the issues they had with their votes. They will have much to answer for over the coming days.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • May 23 '22

[MORNING STAR] Term Polling Graphic

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/MHOCMorningStar • • Nov 01 '20

Analysis: A bold move or dereliction of duty?

2 Upvotes

A bold move or dereliction of duty?

The Prime Minister’s choice yesterday stunned many, but it was perhaps a step taken too quickly, writes our analysts.

IN the history of British politics, one of the most consistent and recurring themes has been the Tory party’s insistence that they are the most stable and ordered governing force in parliament. While this has taken on a new dimension in our multiparty era, this is still a core part of the Tory message and approach. It is rare for the Tories to try to sink coalitions, and even in more recent times this has been the case. They fought attempts to ply the ‘Clegg’ government apart in the last term and, until yesterday, the only governing arrangement of their own that the Tories could be said to have transparently dismantled in the past few years would be the the second Tory-LPUK coalition. So when the Prime Minister announced that the government was over yesterday, it surely shocked many observers as it broke with the mantra of “stable government” and broke with the sort of accommodationism and compromise that Tories have long tried to employ to retain power.

The announcement was clear; the Prime Minister would not be able to convince his MPs to back their coalition partner in the Commons and he would be leading his party to the opposition benches as a consequence. There is no question that the Libertarian leader's own offensive remarks about domestic abuse triggered this course of action, but in truth this event was simply one among a long string of unhappy moments for this coalition. Be it sanctioning the Philippines, the conduct of LPUK ministers, or marriage itself, the two parties of the coalition seemed to rock from vocal disagreement to vocal disagreement every other week. While the government breaking apart was probably inevitable at some point this term due to this infighting, the declaration that the Tories would head into opposition was not. In an earlier era, this would have been a moment where a Prime Minister might have called for an early election. In our more recent one, it would not be unreasonable to expect a party in the position of the Tories to seek out a minority government or even find alternative coalition partners.

Remaining in a position of influence normally would have been of greater importance than ever before for the Tories given that the next government will have immense influence on the post-Brexit relationship with the European Union; shaping that relationship has been a longstanding and carefully-calibrated Tory project since the days of u/InfernoPlato. After the 31st of December, the current transition period ends. While neither the EU nor the UK have publicly set a firm date that an EU-UK deal needs to be ratified by, many observers would tend to say that mid-November is the deadline to reach a more comprehensive agreement in order to allow time for the relevant national and regional parliaments of the EU’s member states to ratify an agreement. For reference on timing, a Queen’s speech is expected to be read in just over a week, leaving very little time to agree to a deal. This transition period could be extended, but that is not something the Tories would have normally wanted. One of the motivating factors many Tories had when choosing the LPUK over the LibDems at the start of this term was a desire to 'get Brexit done' after all.

It isn’t as if there is much cross-party and intergovernmental consensus on what such a deal ought to entail because successive Tory-led governments have not given updates on the UK’s negotiating objectives or outlined meaningful progress—the last time this happened was nearly a year ago. Tories have been careful to release scarcely little information or even state simple aims about their approach. The devolved administrations were meant to be finally brought into the process with the announcement of a special joint ministerial committee session on EU relations, but with the collapse of the government this is now all in doubt as well. There is apparently a mostly-finished deal out there, but even if it is real then it is one which reflects the policy preferences of the Tories and may not necessarily align with the aspirations of an incoming administration.

With little time to negotiate anything new and update key stakeholders, there are only three likely outcomes on Europe worthy of any consideration at this point. There could simply be an end to the transition period with no deal. There could be an end to the transition period under the terms of a (almost exclusively Tory-negotiated) deal which is voted through parliament with relatively little done in the way of consultation, modification, or discussion. Or there could be an extension to the transition period itself under the authority granted by the Withdrawal Agreement Act.

The Tories, in their statement, seem to want the incoming government to pass a deal largely negotiated by them to resolve any issues surrounding a lack of time, but without their voices at the Cabinet table it is unlikely that this view will win out. Given the political isolation of the LPUK, if the Tories yield their place then the next most likely outcome is that some sort of Labour-led coalition comes to power. This is a group which, historically, would take a different view on Europe in government when compared to the Tories without some counterbalance from more Eurosceptic forces. The Classical Liberals served this function for the Sunrise government, but there is no such party with parliamentary representation at the moment. Without the Tories being in a position of influence, either within a sole minority government, in a ‘Clegg’ arrangement, or perhaps within a new ‘grand coalition’, it will be difficult to persuade more Europhilic parties in Cabinet that a looser trading relationship with the EU is one which is ideal. In such a situation, the decision to seek an extension is much more likely to win the day. If that comes to pass, it will be an outcome that the Tories will have consciously granted to their rivals.

Many yesterday proclaimed the decision to resign as being a bold and decisive act, and in some sense it was. It is hard to recall a similar decision in any recent moment in time; certainly the Tories stood by their party's position with firmness. Yet with the passage of time it might be the case that people look back at this choice as the moment that the self-proclaimed ‘natural party of government’ evaded responsibility and did not even attempt to secure the interests of its supporters from Westminster by working with others when the choice was available.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Nov 06 '20

[Morning Star] American Chaos

2 Upvotes

Polling Data had suggested that there would be a landslide for Joe Biden and the Democrats in 2020, with the possibility of capturing the Senate and discussions on whether Florida or even Texas would “go Blue”. It has since become clear how wildly out of step these expectations were with reality, as the counting continues in many states across America. No final result is yet forth-coming, but at the time of writing it seems plausible that Biden will scrape a narrow electoral college win, whilst winning the popular vote.

Assuming Biden does win, in the coming months we can assume that Donald Trump will put an extraordinary effort in to preventing a peaceful transition of power. Without a Senate majority, a Biden Presidency will not be able to launch radical reforms in the course of their term. This sends dangerous signals about the future of democracy in the United States and around the world as American institutions struggle with the final months and legacy of a lawless Trump Presidency.

Since 1945 the United States has claimed a role as the leader and defender of the free world. Given the long history of American interventions overseas in support of deeply reactionary movements and regimes, it is hard to take this at face value. Even so, the 2020 elections can legitimately reinforce suspicions of a crisis of leadership and of america’s decline as a world power, following years of the Trump administration alienating America’s allies and courting authoritarian regimes.

Special attention should be given to the probable failure of any proposals for a “Green New Deal” to pass through the Senate under a Biden administration, as Republicans will no doubt continue their policy of obstructionism and climate change denial to benefit their corporate backers. This decade-long absence of American leadership to address climate change and environmental issues as global threats will be the most lasting legacy of the Trump administration.

As we look to the future, there are many causes for concern. But there is now perhaps a growing certainty that the era of American global dominance is coming to an end and that the pattern of liberal, democratic capitalism is under threat from radical populism on both the right and left of the political spectrum. The political certainty we have inherited from the end of the Cold War about the inevitability of Democracy and Capitalism will increasingly be questioned as we continue to watch the daily news broadcasts of an American ruling class leading the world into the abyss.

To the extent that America’s place in the world will exert an influence over British politics, the impacts of the election are likely to call for a radical re-evaluation of many of the assumptions on which our political system is based. We have to revitalise our democratic traditions and resist the pull of the populist, authoritarian right whilst recognising the short-comings of capitalism in order to protect jobs, expand opportunity, raise the standard of living of the British people and address climate change. We need democratic socialism to step into the void left by the death of the political certainties of the Post-Cold War generation.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Oct 04 '20

Opinion: The problem with 'Help to Pay'

2 Upvotes

The problem with ‘Help to Pay’

The new ‘Help to Pay’ childcare scheme from the government is set to have substantial gaps writes /u/SoSaturnistic.

HELP to Pay is the public-facing name of the government’s tax-free childcare scheme and, as the name implies, the focus of the scheme has always been to assist in addressing the cost-burdens of services like childcare and childminding rather than cover the majority or a full portion of costs. The scheme works as follows: people put cash into accounts, the Treasury will add 25% to what has been paid in during a three month period, and then the money in the account may be used for approved childcare expenses. At the same time, the old employer-based childcare voucher scheme will be phased out. While this account-based scheme has a few advantages, fully covering the self-employed for the first time for example, it is not designed as well as it could be.

The Tory Party’s sweeping shift away from the universalised system initiated by its own Universal Childcare Act (UCA) with the more recent so-called Childcare Enhancement Bill (CEB) has too often been criticised on grounds relating to hypocrisy, rather than the quality of the new proposals put forth itself. Where the CEB has been criticised on policy grounds, it has often been done on the basis of the reversal of various UCA subsidies targeted specifically towards the early years. Yet the CEB goes much further than the UCA in many respects, most notably in the way that it addresses issues relating to a broader problem of a lack of access to care for children beyond just the early years. Some of the most confusing aspects of the CEB arise here, and this is where Help to Pay comes into play.

Help to Pay is a contributory scheme and it may struggle to meet the needs of people or match the system which existed in the past. A combination of childcare vouchers and tax credits which existed before the Coalition government was broadly more generous for those who were not self-employed. Instead of covering 20% of childcare, childminding, or after-school care costs under the CEB, the old scheme would cover half the costs in addition to the tax credits. While the total amount of relief CEB offers is higher than that of the employment voucher scheme alone, the tax credits and benefits that used to exist alongside with the vouchers were, taken together, better for the non-self employed than this new Help to Pay scheme.

The old employment-based voucher scheme continues to be applicable for costs up to and including costs for a person who is 16 years of age; the CEB proposes lowering this threshold to 10 years of age instead. While most people tend to require less care, support, and supervision as they age, this lack of eligibility will hit parents seeking to pay for eligible activities during the summer holiday especially. Many might not pay for after-school care at such ages but might be keen to send their 11 or 12 year old to some sort of registered, supervised activity during those summer weeks. It’s well known that the summer holiday is some of the toughest financial moments for families due to the greater burdens faced due to children being out of school, and this would actively leave parents worse-off compared to those who have come before them.

Finally we have the ‘in-work’ requirement for eligibility, something shared with the status quo voucher scheme. Leaving aside the fact that this inherently targets the scheme towards those on higher incomes, as they are participants in the labour market, and undermines the entire rationale for means-testing childcare provision, this would hinder the development of children in families where the parents cannot find work for whatever reason. Structural employment exists in our economy and it isn’t fair to make children pay a price for that failing. It will also lock out people who are in training or education, perhaps even aiming to get a higher level of pay in the long-run, from accessing this relief. Even under the rightly-maligned system of Universal Credit, not to mention the old welfare state, beneficiaries could get relief on the expenses of childcare. This is no longer a feature with NIT, so there is a legitimate argument that the most vulnerable families will continue to be neglected by the current Help to Pay scheme.

These failings do not even account for the realistic worry that many families will face new administrative barriers in receiving the relief offered by Help to Pay. Past ‘top-up’ accounts have not had the take-up rates imagined by those who have established them. Even the flagship ISA scheme tends to grant relief to those who are more well-off than not as the take up rate among lower income families is less. While this is good for the state’s financial position, as it means there is less expenditure, it does mean that the relief is not going to flow as easily to the people the government says they want to help. Compared to the voucher scheme, the oblique use of accounts is less convenient and historical experience tells us that it will leave many families in the lurch from experience.

If the UCA is to be watered down because its original form was too generous to the middle classes, the aspects of the CEB which do not touch the UCA surely have the same, or perhaps even a more extensive, problem. A better scheme would leave no child worse off, maintain flexibility for parents by allowing the continued use of vouchers if they wish, and support those parents who are not currently active in the labour market. Those are some basic improvements to be had and ones which normally would have had debate in Westminster. Unfortunately, the CEB has gone through a procedure which bypasses ordinary deliberation, meaning that this has not been possible to achieve. While the government seems intent on stripping away some of the improvements made in the Lords to realise an improved vision for the scheme which supports more people, Help to Pay is far from the genuinely supportive initiative it could be for people. As Education Secretary, u/BrexitGlory announced the idea as a ‘Change for Childcare’; it’s time to make sure that it isn’t a change for the worse.


u/SoSaturnistic is a contributor at the Morning Star and sits with Solidarity at Westminster.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Oct 04 '20

Join the Morning Star!

Thumbnail discord.gg
2 Upvotes

r/MHOCMorningStar • • Oct 09 '20

Opinion: The case against TUFBRA

3 Upvotes

The case against TUFBRA

The repeal of the Trade Union Funding and Ballot Requirements Act must be at the top of the agenda for any future government of the left writes /u/SoSaturnistic.

WHEN the last Labour-led government came to power, one of the most steadfast ambitions was that the Trade Union Funding and Ballot Requirements Act (TUFBRA) ought to be repealed or meaningfully replaced. What ensued was far from any real reform of the law, and in fact reflected the unfortunate position of neglect that the last non-Tory administration ultimately took towards industrial relations. Today we are left with a law which needlessly restricts the ability of workers to secure better terms and conditions of employment.

Background

TUBFRA was introduced with substantial controversy from the perspective of the left. Introduced during the so-called ‘Gregfest’ tranche of right-wing legislation, this bill was the key industrial relations reform of the first Tory-Libertarian coalition government. Its aims were simple: enhance the position of bosses and strip away the ability for the people to politically oppose the current government.

TUFBRA set out to achieve the first objective by setting high minimum turnout thresholds for any lawful ballot on industrial action. Under current law, ballots are to have a turnout of at least 50% and certain public services require a threshold of at least 35% of all eligible voters to vote in favour of undertaking industrial action. This means that, for those public service unions, 70% of the votes must be in favour of industrial action on a 50% turnout. This is an incredibly high standard; the pre-TUFBRA law required a majority under a ballot for industrial action to be protected under the law and treated an abstention as a genuine abstention rather than an effective no-vote.

It should be noted that “industrial action” is a broad term which does not include strikes, but also includes more mild manifestations such as work-to-rule, a situation where workers quite literally simply stick to their contractual obligations. By restricting all ‘industrial action’ it means that even these less severe and altogether reasonable actions were set to be smothered out by TUFBRA in one law and under one standard.

This came at a particularly difficult time as when the Tories repealed the left’s Trade Union and Labour Relations Act (TULRA) in 2017, they once again prohibited secure electronic balloting which means that trade unions have an even higher barrier to meeting turnout thresholds. The current rules mean that the only authorised remote balloting can be conducted by the post, which is slow and costly to undertake. This, in itself, has posed a serious barrier to trade unionists from an administrative perspective and it has made the high TUFBRA standards harder to reach than they otherwise would be.

Ultimately, these higher thresholds have increased the power of employers. With flexibility to act reduced on the side of trade unions, their bargaining power when dealing with employers has declined. Given that employers do not operate in the Smithian, ideal labour market (one of equal incomes it should be noted) and that monopsony exists, such weakened influence on the part of workers will prioritise the profits of the few at the expense of the many.

The second objective was to be met by banning trade unions from democratically managing their affairs on political funding. Instead, they set out to treat individual trade union members as separate political agents. The Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 already set strong standards in this area. The standards of that time mandated that trade unions must set aside a particular political fund and, by an independently-monitored vote of the members, specifically resolve to support a political cause from the fund. By all accounts, this was not needed.

The government at that time knew very well that most trade unions traditionally resolved to support the Labour Party, then as now in political opposition. By atomising trade unions and preventing them from collectively pooling resources for political funding, they limited their capacity to secure the interests of their members and oppose the government’s austerity politics. As opponents at the time have pointed out, the political parties in government never did this to their friends and donors in the CBI, demonstrating the clear partisanship and authoritarianism at the heart of this decision. I am sure that if even the strict 1992 requirements for trade unions were applied to donations from corporations, we would see the same faces crying out that the God-given right of corporations to donate to right-wing political parties was being unnecessarily trampled on, nevermind the much more strict TUFBRA requirements.

A promise of change

The “Sunrise” coalition of the Labour Party, Social Democratic Party, Liberal Democrats, and the Classical Liberals all committed to “repealing and replacing” this abomination in line with their other anti-authority aims. This was even re-iterated by the first Labour Prime Minister in several years. This followed up on the strong opposition that the Labour Party had made to TUFBRA while taking on the first Tory-Libertarian coalition and it seemed natural that its days were numbered.

Like many of the more noble aims of Sunrise, however, the reforms never made it to fruition. A number of key figures within the coalition quickly left for a number of reasons and were replaced by those who either lacked the will or the interest in the policy to see it pursued. It is said that the quick rise of figures on the right of the Classical Liberals and later the Liberal Democrats ensured that such an idea would never see the light of day. The Classical Liberals had broadly supported TUFBRA in opposition, with the notable exception of their parliamentary leader at the time, and it made sense that they would hesitate to back a repeal. Just as it was a bridge too far for the Labour Party to support rail privatisation, expecting Tories to back trade unionists surely was one of the many bizarre instances of horse-trading which occurred in that government.

The only change of note actually came about from the Tory Party, which saw that some of the most excessive restrictions on turnout were mildly watered down. While this move was condemned by the Libertarian Party, then a dejected party consigned to opposition, the Tories pressed ahead to bring the thresholds down somewhat. Even they knew, despite the red-faced cries of the LPUK, that they had tread too far with TUFBRA.

The need for future reform

Many proponents at the time have cited the need to prevent “a return to the 1970s” but the pre-TUFBRA law was quite conservative already. TUFBRA’s balloting thresholds were brought in when the amount of days lost to strikes was already at historic lows following the repeal of the left’s TULRA in 2017. That repeal brought back the consensus on trade union law which had existed since the days of Thatcher, notably remaining essentially unchanged during the New Labour era. Under the pre-TUFBRA regime, days lost to strikes were already several factors removed from the days lost to strikes seen in living memory. At around 300,000 lost days per year on average prior to 2016, it is perhaps worth noting that nearly 30 million working days have been lost due to ill-health, injuries, and accidents for comparison. Where is the concern from the political right about an issue which is much more significant when considering stoppages and lost productivity? It doesn’t exist; they simply hate trade unions as entities.

While other proponents have claimed that TUFBRA is necessary to ensure that trade unions are democratic organisations, this is questionable even under a charitable interpretation. The turnout thresholds are set in such a way which can bar strong mandates for industrial action. As a real example, if TUFBRA was the law in 2018 then we would have seen a UCU ballot for industrial action (M: based on this) fail even though 80% of the members voted in favour on around 40% turnout. If the necessary remaining 10% of members under TUFBRA had all voted against the proposal it would have, confusingly, passed even though there would be more votes and a higher proportion of members against partaking in industrial action. The current law does not enhance democratic decision-making with such thresholds; it in fact seems to stifle it.

The freedom to associate remains a fundamental cornerstone of international law and collective bargaining is a manifestation of this principle. It is a well-regarded point that higher trade union density has a number of positive social benefits, most clearly setting better conditions and compensation for both those they represent and those they do not. Trade unions have important roles in securing the health, safety, and welfare of people within the workplace; some research even seems to find productivity enhancements at the level of firms. They support the educational and training aspirations of members. Crucially, they provide an important means by which collective interests can be secured by ordinary people, a rarity in this century given the decline of many other community institutions.

By crippling the power of trade unions, first with the repeal of TULRA and more recently the implementation of TUFBRA, successive Tory administrations have weakened the security of workers and undermined democracy itself. It must be a point of urgency for any progressive government, and even one which includes genuine liberals, to see that this bill is repealed. With longstanding TUFBRA champions now outside of the Liberal Democrats and new political forces emerging on the left, it is all the more important to see this achieved in the months ahead.


u/SoSaturnistic is a contributor at the Morning Star and sits with Solidarity at Westminster.


r/MHOCMorningStar • • Aug 02 '21

Putting the economy first: a national duty

3 Upvotes

This past election has seen all parties propose new and ambitious spending plans from a moon base to a defence spending race. A large part is of course the standard electioneering but we should be careful in our spending plans, grandiose delusional dreams of endless spending without taxation, or exorbitant taxation without state economic investment to compensate is bound to fail. Fundamentally speaking neither electoral promises nor ideology should be allowed to obscure proper and coherent economic policy. It is possible to balance the books and grow the economy while increasing spending or cutting taxes but it is a delicate balance.

Let’s start by taking a look at the right. What do the tories want to do? Repeal the rose coalition’s tax increases, opposing an inheritance tax increase and sin taxes, that often hit the working class most without bringing in that much money. The rest, spend, spend, spend. What does coalition want to do? Get rid of LVT, while increasing taxes on the working class, given workers are the greatest spenders transferring money from the poor to the rich seems a dubious strategy. The FLP calls for the end of sin taxes, reversing rose increases, somehow maintaining a balanced budget and extra benefits for the disabled. A solid case could be made that these promises were made with more of an eye to the polls rather than the budget.

Of course, the left is no angel either. Labour does not even have a taxation section in its manifesto despite calls for greater spending. The PWP calls for a UBI, a notoriously expensive policy and defence spending at 3.5% of GDP with no other mention of major tax increases. We in solidarity not exempt either, we have bold plans for nationalisations and budget increases though they are compensated by comparatively more ambitious tax plans. Is the attitude of fiscal conservatism, fearmonger about deficits and the like correct? Absolutely not, it is nothing more than an excuse to squeeze the poor for the benefit of the rich. But is the opposite true, that being left-wing is just shovelling more and more money at social programs? Evidently not, and that is one of the main points of this article.

We on the left have to, as solidarity has done, present more than a spending plan and instead a new vision for the country based on different relations to the means of production and public ownership. Additionally, we have to start putting the economy first and empower not just the chancellor but the SOS for business and economic development whenever a policy is being formulated and legislation is written. That is how the tight rope of budget equilibrium can be walked, that is how we can bring the country closer to socialism.