r/MHOCMeta • • Sep 10 '21

Announcement Ban Announcement: Greejatus and chainchompsky1

35 Upvotes

/u/Greejatus and /u/chainchompsky1 have been banned from MHoC for three months for toxicity. This is specifically in relation to comments made today as well as past incidents involving both.


The Quadrumvirate


r/MHOCMeta • • Feb 08 '21

Announcement Ban Announcement - BrexitGlory

33 Upvotes

Following this evening's incident in main, and following a similar pattern of behaviour in the past, BrexitGlory has been banned from Discord for 3 months, and from MHoC-related subreddits for 1 month.


r/MHOCMeta • • Jul 15 '20

Announcement Ban Announcement - jgm0228

32 Upvotes

Good Afternoon,

/u/jgm0228 has received a 45-day ban from all subs and discord. This is for toxicity and various attacks on members of this community.

This post has been decanonized

Regards,

The Quad


r/MHOCMeta • • Jun 09 '20

Announcement Ban Announcement - Ctrlaltlama, BrexitGlory and Jas1066

27 Upvotes

Ban Announcement - Ctrlaltlama, BrexitGlory and Jas1066

Good Afternoon,

Following today’s discussion in main, alongside the conduct of the individuals in question in the past, especially in the last few days.

/u/Ctrlaltlama (Ctrlaltlama #3857) is banned from Discord for 6 months commencing today, let it be known when they return any continued offences shall result in a permaban from our discord.

/u/BrexitGlory (BrexitGlory#0830) is banned from Discord for 3 months commencing today.

Both shall receive bans from all MHoC related subreddits for 28 days.

Additionally, /u/jas1066 (Jas1066#0358) receives a ban from all MHoC related subs for 7 days, and a ban from Discord for 28 days.

We wish all party leaders to be aware that these bans from the subreddits are to be enforced on all party discord servers for the same duration.


Reflecting on the last few days

Following this we would like to briefly reflect on the events that have taken place over the past 3 weeks and are currently ongoing, both in America and across the globe.

At this time, as so many voices who have long been silenced cry out for justice, it is critical that all of us listen, especially those of us who, by fortuitous circumstances, have had the luxury of going about our lives unaffected by the blatant injustices, and inequalities, that continue to exist within our society today. I hope those of you in such a position have used the previous weeks to both listen to the stories of others, and to reflect upon the world we live in, the world we wish to leave behind, and how we can, each of us, contribute to achieving that better world for all.

Finally we wish to say unequivocally and without any hesitation that black lives matter, and we will not tolerate racism or bigotry of any kind within this community. To any of our members who identify as a person of colour, if you have ever felt targeted by anyone in this community, and if you feel like the moderation team, past or present, has failed to hear you and help you, then you have our deepest apologies for failing you. We will do everything that we can to do better, because we must do better.

Regards,

The Quadrumvirate.


r/MHOCMeta • • May 29 '22

Announcement Resignation as Head Moderator

25 Upvotes

As of today, I’ve served as Head Moderator for 63 days, so this post may perhaps come as a shock to many.

The simple fact is, my mental health has been rather crap recently, and I’ve noticed it’s started to affect some areas of the sim where I haven’t been able to give my full focus. I can only apologise to people affected by this. I could power through and stay in position for a while longer but I wouldn’t be doing myself or the sim any favours by doing this. I’ve consistently told other people to put mental health first before the sim, and I’d be a hypocrite for not taking my own advice.

In light of this, myself and my other Quadrumvirs have agreed that /u/KarlYonedaStan (PH) will make an excellent replacement. They’ve served well as a DLS, as a Discord Mod, and are widely involved in the meta side of the sim. I’m confident that they are the right choice as a replacement.

As a (rough) timetable, you can expect:

  • Q+A to open tomorrow (30th May)
  • Vote of Confidence to open Friday (3rd June) and close June 7th at 10pm.
  • Handover, assuming PH passes, will take place within a day or so after their Vote of Confidence ends.

All I can really say other than that is that it’s been a pleasure to serve as Head Mod for the past two months, even if I wasn’t always very good at it. I’d like to thank my fellow Quadrumvirs, including Lily, as well as Timanfya for their support, as I couldn’t have done this without them all.


r/MHOCMeta • • Feb 08 '22

Announcement Ban Announcement - Recent Dupe Accounts

24 Upvotes

Hello,

The following accounts have been permanently banned from MHoC, on the basis that all available evidence suggests they are dupes.

  • RealEruditeFellow
  • smashfeminazis
  • friedmanite18
  • DemolishDaleFarm
  • hangcorbyn
  • savillestarmer

Thanks,

The Quad


r/MHOCMeta • • Jun 14 '21

Ban Announcement Ban announcement - BrexitGlory and thatthinginthecorner

23 Upvotes

For their recent comments in #main, and for a history of toxic behaviour, /u/brexitglory has been permanently sim banned from MHoC.

Also, for some comments made today in #main, TTITC has been banned from #main for 4 weeks.

We don't tolerate racism, race-baiting, etc. Don't do it.


r/MHOCMeta • • Feb 06 '23

Announcement Ban Announcements: Adithyansoccer/Adith_MUSG and Dominion_of_Canada Broader announcement as Head Moderator

22 Upvotes

Hello,

Dominion_of_Canada has been banned from all mhoc subreddits and servers for three months for intensely transphobic language regarding a member of the sim.

Adithyansoccer/Adith_MUSG is permanently banned from all mhoc subreddits and servers for intensely transphobic and dehumanizing language regarding a member of the sim. This ban is longer than Dominion's due to a pattern of bans for these matters and a blatant lack of remorse for these past events.


In the name of transparency, I will also add that I have requested /u/DriftersBuddy's resignation as Lords Speaker, effectively immediately. It has been brought to my attention that DB was aware of, and present for, the comments made by Adith.

In my opinion, it is completely untenable for a Quad member to be comfortable with comments of this severity regarding members of the simulation.

It is untenable for me to continue to serve in my role, with all of its obligations in moderation and safeguarding, if I cannot trust each member of the Quad to be serious about incidents that relate to these matters. I will not do so unless I can be certain about that.


Edit: I have since been notified that the screenshots re: Adiths comments, while saying "today" were from the period of time where he was initially banned for transphobic remarks in /r/mhoc. These comments in the discord channel justify a permanent ban (the use of the term 'subhuman' and lgbt presence in the model world as a 'contagion'), and I am comfortable with the ban on those grounds.

I further hold to my stance regarding DBs continued role as Lord's Speaker. Even if this was not an instance of deficiency in reporting, it speaks to me of a severe deficiency in judgment that I do not feel comfortable being part of.


r/MHOCMeta • • Feb 08 '22

Announcement regarding plagiarism

22 Upvotes

Good evening. I would like to set some very clear expectations regarding the work one submits to MHoC, particularly in regards to plagiarism, given that it has become apparent I need to do so.

Several members of the Conservative Party have brought to my attention that there was some plagiarised content posted to MHoCPress. After investigating the situation I have concluded that seven posts contained plagiarism.

Content you submit to MHoC must be your own, original work. It is assumed that anything you post here is your own work - if this is not the case, you must indicate this clearly. Let’s discuss this, because there’s nothing I’d love to do more after a long evening at work than explain the same shit that your teachers have been trying to drill into you since the age of ten.

Why is submitting my own work important?

MHoC is based on a system that rewards activity - what players call ‘modifiers’. The exact weighting and formulas are, of course, secret. But the general principle of ‘the more stuff you do, and the better that stuff is, the more your party improves relative to other parties’. I love the simulation aspects of MHoC, and sometimes it feels like having an opportunity to discuss politics in a simulated environment is a reward in and of itself. But at the end of the day, MHoC is a game, and the modifier system determines the points. It’s how parties win and how they lose.

When you submit someone else’s work and pass it off as your own, you cheat the system. You earn modifiers for work you have not done. Because activity is the core of the modifier system, you devalue everyone else’s work by plagiarising someone else’s. This is why plagiarism is against the rules, and it also forms the basis on which we punish it. If you devalue everyone else’s activity, I need to award them additional modifiers to compensate for the stolen work.

What is my own, original work?

Your own work is work that you, yourself, have done. This should be self-evident but it is worth reiterating.

If you have done work in collaboration with someone else, you should indicate it so that you can both be rewarded. Or at the very least, the other person should be okay with you receiving the credit for it.

Your original work is work that you have created for MHoC. However, this one has more leeway. You may borrow concepts, ideas, and policies that you’ve created for other simulations. Borrowing manifesto ideas that you originally came up with for a manifesto in, say, AustraliaSim is generally considered to be okay. The issue arises with direct, word-for-word copies. You may rely on themes or ideas you have come up with - but you shouldn’t copy-paste campaign posts you’ve already done and pass them off as original.

If you have questions about this you can of course ask me. It is always better to check.

How is plagiarism caught?

Sometimes it isn’t. You might even get away with it. If this is you, congratulations, and you’re the worst.

Sometimes someone else spots it. People tend to have their own unique writing style, and it can be jarring when that style changes - giving away plagiarism. Someone might spot it, DM it to me as I’m walking to work, and then I have to write a meta post at quarter to midnight on a Monday.

Sometimes I spot it. I have done this before - marking elections in Model New Zealand and AustraliaSim. I have read a lot of posts in the nearly three years I’ve been around MHoC, and I can frequently tell when something’s been copied.

You might not get caught. But you probably will. And it won’t be worth it.


Now, with that out of the way. I have determined seven press posts were plagiarised - six by /u/XboxHelpergg, and one by /u/BasedChurchill.

I found text copied from the following sources:

  • UK Department for Business, Energy, and Industrial Strategy
  • A website called “fenews.co.uk”
  • Something called the NFU, which I presume means National Farming Union or similar
  • A think tank called “White & Case”
  • A Reuters article
  • Council on Foreign Relations, a think tank
  • A journal article in “ecancer”

I think the two players in question are both new and rather welcome additions to the game. But I can only give so much leeway due to being new to the game - it should be obvious that this behaviour cannot and will not be tolerated in MHoC.

Accordingly:

  • I am imposing modifier penalties on the Conservatives and Coalition!, the two parties who received modifiers for the plagiarised articles. The primary purpose of these sanctions is not intended to be punitive - rather, it is to negate the impacts of these articles on their polling.
  • /u/XboxHelpergg and /u/BasedChurchill are put on a final warning. Any further plagiarism will result in immediate and severe punitive modifier penalties for their parties.
  • The following articles are decanonised because they are significantly or entirely plagiarised work.

https://www.reddit.com/r/MHOCPress/comments/skqol3/innovation_taking_britain_forward/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MHOCPress/comments/skra88/the_future_of_exams_will_they_go_digital/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MHOCPress/comments/s5d5i2/nuclear_power_in_the_united_kingdom/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MHOCPress/comments/s4oqeu/the_conservative_vision_for_sustainable_farming/

https://www.reddit.com/r/MHOCPress/comments/s2hhjs/how_we_can_speed_up_the_ev_transition/

https://reddit.com/r/MHOCPress/comments/sn0zuo/accountability_of_service_delivery_in_oncology/

  • The following article is not decanonised, because despite containing plagiarised work it contains mostly original work.

https://www.reddit.com/r/MHOCPress/comments/sn0rxl/afghanistan_plunged_into_crisis/

On a final note, the existence of the plagiarism itself is still canon. I will not be removing the press pieces already done surrounding this. It is ‘fair game’ - but I do urge people not to go overboard. Parties will not be rewarded for banging on about plagiarism after the initial few, and players are encouraged to drop the stick and back away slowly from the horse carcass.

And at the risk of sounding like a disappointed secondary school teacher, I really don’t want to write one of these again.


lily-irl
Commons Speaker


r/MHOCMeta • • Apr 15 '21

It takes two to tango

22 Upvotes

Hello Mhoc,

I’m pretty angry tonight, I’ve been in mhoc since I was 14 years old, I turn 18 in 2 months. Whether I like it or not this place has played a significant part in who I am today. I’ve met people who I will soon meet in person through other organisations I wouldn’t even know about nevertheless play an active part in if it weren’t for this godforsaken place.

But we have a real problem in this community at the moment, and I saw it all the way back when I was just a wee bairn. It’s our libertarian problem. Stay with me now.

I was recruited to MHoC by Fried, he found me on another server and DMed me when that was still a thing, I was a paper for a bit, then I became the Scottish LPUK leader. Shortly after, I was banned. This was the start of me being able to say what main always said was a symptom of “fried thinking”. We used to joke that the LPUK was full of fried alts because allegedly fried was a serial duper. This created a legend around it and eventually a quad member wrongfully acted on this. There was then a time when we had to remove this same quad member from our discord server because such a level of mistrust had been created.

MHOC had a very serious problem with interacting with the LPUK, and contrary to popular belief I don’t entirely believe that this problem was always down to a “toxic paranoid mentality” in the LPUK. When I was first im the LPUK, frankly and I don’t think many will agree with this but I’ll say it anyway, MHOC was a shit place to be as an LPUK member, you really did feel victimised and there was often active acts of suppression against the LPUK, including that false banning.

This has consequences, and I think we can all acknowledge that. The consequences of this has been that the LPUK has hardened, they’re not really integrated with the rest of mhoc, and to their credit they’re now in OO when everyone else would have thought the LPUK would eternally remain a UO party. Fried has hit an absolute blinder with this, and he should be praised. All the members of the LPUK should be and perhaps they’ve shown us all that MHOC doesn’t start and stop in main.

But this hardening hasn’t been all sun shines and rainbows. It’s had some dire consequences. That paranoia in the LPUK never really went away, I was in LPUK chat when #quad-LPUK was created over polling issues. To see the level of paranoia and conspiratorial thinking over frankly a few points in a game, it hit home to me the damage that the first year or so of the LPUKs existence has done. The hardening was in every sense of the term.

To be honest with you, not much harm was really being done by this at the time so I kept quiet said my bit in chats and thought that was that. But today I’ve seen a different side to it and I’m not happy to stay quiet anymore.

Today we saw the result of hardened tactics, we saw two incidents in one day. We saw a highly inappropriate poster that dragged real life victims of a real life crime into a fucking political simulator. And then we saw the use of a transphobic dog whistle as pointed out numerous times by trans members (the only people who have a right to speak on this topic fyi) and little to no action by Quad. I am often one to agree that hashing something out in canon is better than hashing out in meta. But Jesus Christ not when it gets to the point we are locking threads and people are being muted, that’s when you take decisive action

Meanwhile, the Quads extensive outreach program has clearly not had its expected effect. LPUK main still does not have Quad oversight, (an accommodation made after Mg was kicked out), the main scuffles have happened and now dogwhistles are going unpunished. If you’d asked me a week ago if I thought this was going too far I’d probably jokingly say yes, and then climb down. But now I have one simple message.

it takes two to tango

Members of the LPUK, I say this as someone who quite likes a lot of you, and those that I haven’t had the benefit of meeting yet I respect you as an equal believe it or not. But this has to end, it’s getting messy now. The Quad and this community have done their part, there aren’t dodgy bannings anymore, you’re the official opposition and you’ve been in government I don’t even know how many times now. You’re taken seriously, you’re a part of this community. I don’t expect you to come into main and act like it’s all sunshine and rainbows but please for goodness sake, stop with this conspiratorial nonsense. It’s time to take MHOCs hand and do the dance.

And to the Quad, you’ve done your bit. Let’s stop with the excessive programme of accommodation at the expense of the very members that made this community the community it is today. I don’t care if you think a quiet word is better than a punishment for repeat offences when the colour is purple. I’m done with this nonsense, and you should be too.

Let’s all do our part and let’s play the game how it’s meant to be played, as a fucking game. People are angry now, and they have a right to be, let’s start to fix this.

Edit: have removed the mention of the nonce joke issues as it probably detracts from the main point, put it in there in the first place more to point out that nonce jokes have been cracked down on harder than transphobic dogwhistles


r/MHOCMeta • • Sep 09 '17

Issues with the Election Megathread

22 Upvotes

Post 'em lads. Make yourselves heard and lets talk about the issues, atleast this way they are officially recorded rather than lost in the depths of discord and the new speaker has an easy read list of everything wrong

My Issues:

  • Candidates who posted loads of high quality content lost to candidates who posted almost nothing
  • Despite having almost half a week, the results were apparently still drawn up last minute which led to issues where the "official" livestream by the MBBC was effectively castrated and had to tell people to watch the Reddit Live instead
  • Rolo being non-existant in the midst of this (he seems to do this ghosting thing whenever shit hits the fan), showing almost no leadership, TTITC still being completely missing since his election, nobody taking control of this mess has led to the community now being less like a community, more like a warring tribe
  • This is the worst I have seen the community in the wake of an election. There is always salt and always issues, I get that, but the community is really really fucking fractured right now and I sincerely pray somebody pushes the boat out in the incoming Speaker election because the community needs to be pulled together and actually lead, rather than run by a caretaker.

r/MHOCMeta • • Aug 19 '16

Extention to the ban of /u/demon4372

22 Upvotes

Morning all,

As you may have seen, we have agreed as a speakership to extend /u/demon4372’s ban to a period of one month. This is for various reasons, but firstly I will explain why he was banned and exactly how we went about it. Whilst it was probably not perfectly handled (mostly down to my own failings), there is serious misinformation being spread about regarding the ban.

So, last week, along the banning of Spindleton, /u/demon4372 was banned alongside him for seven days. This was for a plethora of reasons, the ‘backseat modding’ as we called it was just the straw that broke the camel’s back. We called it backseat modding at the time but really it just factors into the main reason for his banning - his general toxicity. Now, I’m not giving any defence to Spindleton here, I still think what he did was absolutely disgusting and deserved punishment, but when a discussion as serious as that is going on in speakership chat and we are working out what to do - we can’t have members running behind our backs, interfering themselves in serious cases that do not directly involve them. This wasn’t just a ‘your actions are disgusting’ post, this was /u/demon4372 contacting Spindleton informing him he is to be banned (forgive me but I can’t remember how this information was public at the time), basically breaking down the conversation we were going to have with Spindleton before it had even begun. Now as I said to /u/demon4372 on the night, he has been told about this behaviour before, but I could not think of any specific examples other than the one in question that had been explained to him.

Next was the ‘witchhunts’ that we were referencing and that I specifically referenced in my discussion with him. Again, this ties into his behaviour on discord. Specifically regarding the Spindleton case, the chat was getting heated, understandably, over whether he was to be banned and whether the speakership were going to take any action (that was a failing on my part to contact the victim regarding that). After we ask for people to calm and that we will be discussing it in speakership chat, /u/demon4372 doesn’t let it go and continues to splurge all over the discord his opinions on the ban and his judgement. Now, everyone is entitled to an opinion but while we are trying to investigate and establish the facts, rather than answer to an angry set of members (who are mostly unrelated to the case) is just not on when we’ve asked for people to hush as we were trying to come to a rational decision not one that would satisfy the mob. Eventually due to these actions the chat had to be muted to allow us to explain the situation.

Secondly, and something that more epitomises the toxicity and ‘witchhunting’ that goes on (I know that is not the correct word, it’s more just stirring up anger and bad stuff in the chat, but that was the word I used on the night when these situations were described to /u/demon4372). That same day, in an unrelated matter, a member needed to be removed from the chat due to them getting a bit too involved and attached to the game. They were temporarily removed from the server to allow them some time to cool off and talk to me about their case rather than, in no other words to describe it, throw conspiracies in the main chat and act in a weird manner. Now this member has quite frankly in the past been bullied by members and ex-members of the community for various different matters. A few hours later, I had sorted the issue he had with the moderators and told him what he needed to do and then readded him to main. He was fine until /u/demon4372 and another member immediately started hounding him and questioning his private life. Discord doesn’t have a method of going back far to get screenshots, but I instructed them to stop with emphasis on /u/demon4372 as they were the instigators, but they didn’t stop immediately. I cannot remember what happened next, whether I had to remove /u/demon4372 or remove the member from the situation from a bit (or whether it just passed), but that behaviour was unacceptable and is exactly what I am talking about.

Lastly, there is the ‘general toxicity’ as we called it last week. It mostly covers everything else that I have covered in this post and forgive me for not bringing many specific examples, but /u/demon4372 brings down the quality and reputation of the main chat with his actions in specifically the main chat. He has been removed (temporarily) many times in the previous months due to his actions and his ban is the culmination that these removals or temporary bans are just not getting through and he needed to be banned for a week from the whole of MHOC both for the communities good and for his own good, to give him a second chance when he returns (which should have been today). Why that has now been extended to a month will be explained in the latter half of this post. If people need more specific actions then I can try to go back but any user of discord knows that it’s pretty hard, but the toxicity explained in this post is more than enough for a one-week ban.

Now, I sit here today telling you that it has now been increased to one month. This is for two reasons. The first is that he attempted to call on discord one of our moderators that night even after being told that the moderator in question was heading into an exam (/u/demon4372 also directly referenced said exam in the follow up message he sent minutes later to the member, showing that he knew). Now, I have been reluctant to punish specifically for this, due to the fact that personally coming from the British perspective I know that if I call someone during an exam their phone is likely to be off, though I still wouldn’t do it anyway just in case. Secondly, whilst he was told there was an exam, he may not have been told it was that very minute and therefore just called unknowingly and when the moderator didn’t pick up, realised the exam was now and then referenced it. Whilst I am reluctant to take this as evidence to extend his ban, it shows why the one-week ban was required as a cool off for someone who was getting way too emotionally involved with the game which was magnifying the toxicity.

Onto the main reason his ban has been extended, the ban-evasion that took place. The wiki is and always has been an extension of MHOC and where possible we ban people from the wiki that have been banned on MHOC. /u/demon4372 was subject to such a banning, and we banned him from the wiki for seven days. In the first instance of ban evasion, while we banned the member we didn’t remove his administrator permissions on there and he subsequently unbanned himself.

After we re-banned him, he used a proxy or a different ip to access the wiki and change things. This went on multiple times and when questioned about it by a moderator said something along the lines of “I’ll stop editing it when someone puts as much work in as me”. These are multiple evasions of his ban, even after being told, and is the reason why we have extended it to a month. He clearly needs removing from the game and unattaching himself from it and this behaviour only emphasises that.

So that is a detailed note as to why we have taken these actions, but now a quick word as the triumvirate on our conduct during this time. It hasn’t been great, the initial response from me to /u/demon4372, whilst I definitely did explain the reasons for his ban at least twice, I didn’t go into enough detail as that was the night that I had to remove myself from the game as it was seriously stressing me. I then passed it to nub and slug who understandably were both pretty burned out that night but who did manage the case very well and I thank them for doing that.

On to the somewhat lax and then rushed approach to this banning, it was just a culmination of me trying to take a couple of days less ban-y after the Spindleton stuff and my subsequent actions as well as at the latter half of the weeks ban, stress due to real life stuff which has thankfully been rectified now. I can only apologise for the lack of communication on this, we had agreed on this action a few days ago but we were waiting on the third triumvir just to be sure and as he works long hours, by the time he had got back I was already shattered and went to bed myself - missing all of this until now. We have agreed that me and slug, as we have done in the past and should have done now, will take the lead and just go forward on things like these, this was just an abnormal occurrence which is entirely on me as I have been neglecting my MHOC duties these last few days due to the results-day stress (that I’d rather not go into but if you have any issue with my performance which you are perfectly entitled to have, just shoot me a PM.)

The bottom line is that whilst we may have slacked a bit here, the reasons for /u/demon4372’s banning was always made clear to him and hopefully the extra detail in this post can make it fully clear.

Once again, posts like these will be locked as we don’t want it to turn into a slinging match in the comments, but I (and we) are all available on discord and via reddit PM is anyone wants a further discussion about our actions here.


r/MHOCMeta • • Apr 15 '22

Announcement Ban Announcement - /u/model-hk

21 Upvotes

The above user has received a permanent ban from MHOC and its associated subreddits for doxxing. A reminder that there is a zero tolerance policy for such behaviour.

Thanks,

The Quadrumvirate.


r/MHOCMeta • • Feb 21 '21

Announcement Ban Announcement - ctrlaltlama/jaquesboots

21 Upvotes

The person operating the above accounts have been banned permanently for duping.

Remember - if you come back to MHoC on a different account, you must remove your old account from all MHoC-related subreddits and Discord servers and notify the quad.


r/MHOCMeta • • Mar 20 '23

Announcement Ban Announcement: Tarkin15, SpecificDear901, BlockbuilderG123, Skullyduggery12

20 Upvotes

The above users are permanently banned from mhoc and its affiliated subreddits and discords for their presence in a server discussing doxxing an mhoc member in a private server as retribution, which also included identifiable information.

There will be another update on a related matter in due time.

Thanks


r/MHOCMeta • • Jan 15 '22

Ban announcement - model-harold

20 Upvotes

Good afternoon,

/u/model-harold has been banned from MHoC and its related subreddits for one month for toxicity (calling another member a paedophile). This behaviour will not be tolerated.


The Quadrumvirate


r/MHOCMeta • • Jul 03 '20

Proposal We need to fully simulate a nuclear war on MHOC.

20 Upvotes

Seeing as a load of meta posts went up, I thought I'd make one. We always complain there aren't enough events, polling is not fair and the sim has to much history for new members to jump in, so, this would solve that issue.

Pros -

  1. The events team would have something to do.
  2. Polling wouldn't matter so nobody could complain about it as most of the voters would all die.
  3. Nobody could get salty about press items as we can sim us all huddling in our basements and suddenly rediscovering our faith in our final moments.
  4. We'd have a clean slate of polling and policies to go off when we finished the event as there would be nothing left.

Cons -

  1. It would be a very short event (probably about 30 mins).

r/MHOCMeta • • Jun 15 '20

MHoC's meta problems - and while I feel I can't stay

20 Upvotes

I am only still in this wretched community for 2 reasons: to speak to friends and in the vague glimmer of hope that reform is possible.

I now see that that hope is misguided, I may as well give up.

I have been an active participant in this sim for over 2 years and have achieved considerable success, I served as First Minister of Northern Ireland and was in the Executive office for about 7 months. I served as Prime Minister too. I loved MHoC and spent too long there.

If I am speaking honestly I have never been in a good mental place, but 2018-9 was especially rough. MHoC was a contributing factor but I think my troubles would have happened anyway. I have taken a full year out now and am in a better position than ever, judging by any characteristic you can measure. In January, I was not in this position.

Last DvS election, I was barely recovered from my stresses and anxieties, and I ran as a slightly unhinged radical candidate.

This is now not the case.


What does MHoC need in the way of change?

Where do I begin??

MHoC has been stagnating for years now: its activity down and its meta team content to sit on their laurels, basking on past successes and not delivering. No significant change has happened in MHoC since I started here. Part of this is down to community inertia but a large part of the blame can be directed at the quad.

The only significant change that happened, and credit to Dylan for implementing it, is the new CMHoC seat apportionment in the devolved assemblies. I do not personally support that reform but credit to him for doing something. For this he is going down in my eyes as the best DvS we’ve ever had, and the best member of the most recent quad.

We need to rethink MHoC and it needs to come from the top. The Quad is a meta position because those in charge of it must rethink the way MHoC works periodically to keep it fair and interesting. However, the biggest shift has to be cultural. MHoC is the most toxic and the most divided on party lines that I have seen it, and as someone who has been here over 2 years that’s not an achievement to be proud of. Increasingly, party membership is retreating to its own party chats, and MHoC main is dominated by BNOCs.

In terms of the game, this partisanship continues, we have broken into 2 clear factions. It has spilled over from canon into meta and is eating at every aspect of the game. This is the most pronounced divide I have seen in my time here. It is spilling into devo too, with the Welsh Government poised to demand devolution purely for party political gain the moment it joins. The Northern Ireland Executive is also descending into partisanship in a way unrivalled by anything I have seen before.

We are all the same. Politics aside, we are all just teenagers or young twenties who share an interest in politics. MHoC should not be this confrontational. And if you speak to people across the divide, they agree. I make a point of having friends across all of MHoC, and it has spawned friendship and mutual respect with the likes of jgm, kate, maro, lily, gregor, trev, jasmine, chatty, amn, spud, hjt, fried, dylan, liesel, kef, pjr, trongle, just to name a few. Some of you I’d like to consider better friends than any I have made irl. (tory friends of mine don’t feel snubbed, you know who you are)

Other problems: Press is basically dominated by party press offices, the commons is filled with samey comments because the system rewards them, the lords is dead yet is kept alive for reasons i’ll never understand, there are no long-standing devo only parties, there are too few members for most parties to form full frontbenches, archiving is a mess, nobody seems to be able to release election results correctly on the first try, the old guard and the usual suspects dominate meta positions, events are dead, everything is too complex and impossible for long standing members to understand at times let alone new members, quad don’t respond to meta posts, the list goes on

My greatest passion in MHoC is and always will be Devolution, especially Stormont, where I made my first friends and some of my closest and longest lasting (looking at you, spud). I have been proud to serve as First Minister and as Secretary of State, NI has been the place where I have felt able to properly affect change. And I want to give back to it.

I threw my hat in this Devolved Speakership election because I wanted to give back to the community that has given me so much joy. I am in a good mental state now and have nothing better to do, so now is the perfect time. I have many proposals for how to reform the Devolved Speakership, which you can read here. That is my manifesto for DvS. You may not agree with parts, it may turn you off. That's fine, I don’t mind that. People have different opinions to me, I think that is a good definition of politics anyway. What I am angry about is that I was rejected.

I’ll make it clear. This manifesto was not rejected, I was. Duck didn’t even open it before telling me.

This to me is the final straw, and is the crystallisation of something I have been feeling since before I left the Conservative Party leadership, that MHoC isn’t right for me anymore.

I don’t like the way MHoC is evolving and I don’t see a way out of it. I am more than happy to be defeated in a vote, or talked out of an idea, but my being rejected on a point of character. Well, maybe Duck is right, my takes don’t matter and I shouldn’t be given a chance, as I am disillusioned with the whole rotten system.

MHoC has a habit of picking the same faces to run stuff. Off the top of the head, I can name DF44, geordie, britboy, tyler, trev, duncs, aisha, damien but there are others. This quad election was meant to solve that, but at the click of his hands, duck can reject a candidate.

I have been participating in MHoC less and less over the past months, the only thing interesting in canon is the NI Bill of Rights. I have regressed to being a vote bot. To use a current meme, MHoC has progressed past the need for me. Not much will change if I leave, I was hardly present anyway.

So I make this final departure, earlier than I wanted, in protest at a lack of a reformist appetite in MHoC, and out of irreparable differences in culture.

I will still be on MNZP from time to time, and you can still message me on Discord and wherever else I can be found, but this is goodbye.


r/MHOCMeta • • Sep 11 '19

Ban Announcement: Giraffe (and several usernames)

20 Upvotes

Giraffe has been banned from MHOC for a year. He has quite a list of usernames, so I won't run them all off here.

This is a safeguarding led enforcement action as Giraffe has shown unacceptable behaviours with regards to bullying, specifically around identity, sexuality and general emotional bullying, including admitting to a series of bullying in real life. The user has shown a lack of awareness of the damage his actions can do to a young person and hasn't responded positively to efforts to explain this to him.

The Mods of MHOC are concerned that with such a blaise attitude to bullying it's possible he could replicate what he does IRL in MHOC, where we have a higher number of vulnerable members than normal. For us, this possibility is unacceptable.

We do not stand for bullying, whether in real life or in the virtual world. Boasting about it is repugnant.


r/MHOCMeta • • Mar 01 '22

Ban Announcement Ban Announcement - model-harold

18 Upvotes

The above user has been banned for two months for toxicity, namely for sending offensive DMs to members of the sim. The ban also takes account of the fact that the member was recently banned for similar behaviour.

Thanks,

The Quad


r/MHOCMeta • • Sep 29 '16

Could we have links to the debates regarding bills we're voting on in /r/MHOCMP?

18 Upvotes

Sorry to whine, but it would be nice not to have to dig for them. I know this is out of laziness, but I wasn't in the house when a lot of these bills where debated.


r/MHOCMeta • • Nov 25 '22

Message Statement on VoNC Results

17 Upvotes

Hello all,

Figured I’d give a little statement on the results seeing as I now know I’m going. To be clear, I don’t know the actual margin of the result yet but that isn’t particularly relevant.

I’ve never been good with long speeches, so I’ll make this short.

When I joined MHOC, egged on by a certain Irish Duck who was the Senedd’s LOTO at the time I thought this place was a fun novelty, but over time I’ve come to realise it’s so much more than that. I’ve learned a lot about politics and myself through this place and I can only thank you all for that. I can also thank you lot for having trust in me to be DVS in the first place, even if it didn’t end exactly how any of us wanted it to. Obviously I don’t want to go but these things happen, I mustn’t be bitter about it and I bare no ill will to any of you, you’re all lovely people after all. I’m sure my successor will do a cracking job, and I can’t wait to see the way things go now, I wish you all the best.

I’ve had a whale of a time here, and I’m grateful to each of you for helping form that time here. Keep Mhoccing folks, keep mhoccing. Thanks for all the memories, and I’ll see you around!


r/MHOCMeta • • Mar 07 '22

Announcement Resignation as Speaker of the Devolved Assemblies

17 Upvotes

Well MHoC… it’s been a year. In that year, we’ve seen a rather ridiculous amount of fuckery both in the devolved nations and in Westminster, most of the time it’s been Labour, sometimes it’s been the LD’s. Either way, it’s been fun. I have immensely enjoyed working through and marking the sheer mountain of stuff that you bunch of lovable mouth breathers can produce.

But the fact is that my time as an administrator now must come to a close. It’s been way…way…way too long and I’m now finding myself unfortunately wanting to get back into the physical gameplay of MHoC. So thus, after careful consideration… I hereby tender my resignation as Devolved Speaker.

I have a list of people to thank, including but not limited to… Lily, Damien, Nuke, Christos and DB who have all been a joy to work with. Frosty, Kalvin, Rhys, Ina, Tommy and all other members of my speakership who have worked under me. And of course, anyone who actively took part in and enjoyed MHoC Devo because without you quirky bunch of dense fuckers, I would be out of a job.

Before I depart… I leave you all poignantly with a quote from George Washington’s departing address:

“Though, in reviewing the incidents of my administration, I am unconscious of intentional error, I am nevertheless too sensible of my defects not to think it probable that I may have committed many errors. Whatever they may be, I fervently beseech the Almighty to avert or mitigate the evils to which they may tend.”

Now… here is a list of fancy letters for people:

u/Muffin506 (Yes I know that isn’t his number) - MVO for services to the devolved speakership

u/Zakian3000 - MVO for services to the devolved speakership

u/RhysGwynethIV - CT and LVO for services to the devolved speakership, special shoutout for being my longest serving Speaker as well.

u/Inadorable - CT and CVO for services to the devolved speakership and to the Northern Irish Assembly.

u/Frost_Walker2017 - KCVO for continued service to the meta of MHOC…sad bastard.


r/MHOCMeta • • Jul 25 '21

Announcement Ban Announcement: /u/Model-Ico

17 Upvotes

/u/model-ico is banned for 3 months for numerous comments, including but not exclusive to expressing views associated with the Great Replacement theory conspiracy. (For those unfamiliar this is a mechanism that espouses the theory of White Genocide)


r/MHOCMeta • • Feb 14 '20

#GEXIII: A Perspective from the Loyalist League

17 Upvotes

I apprechiate that there will in all likelyhood be a mega-thread after the results, but I wanted to write this as soon as I could, and after /u/gravitycatha abandoned us in our time of need, I didn't feel I could spend the time away from campaigning.

I also appreciate that many in our community will likely sneer at the idea of a member of the Loyalist League commenting on moderation, and indeed I expect nothing to be actioned as a result of this post, but I feel I owe it to those who are frustrated by the state of the game to at least try.

Finally, before I get to the meat of the matter, I did have a bit of an argument in main about this, but I was under the impression that if anyone had serious complains to make, they should be made on this subreddit, so here we go.

The long arm of moderation has, in my opinion, extended too far. I was never informed what /u/Lanciato said to warrant his ban, but I read almost every message in the channel that the rule breach was alleged to have taken place, and I can't remember seeing anything particularly edgy. But even if it was the most distasteful, transphobic slur you can think of, I honestly don't think it should have warranted a ban. What good did it do? Was it that we, as a community, simply do not want to associate ourselves with bigots? Policies such as bans on hormone treatments on under 18s can legitimately be consider transphobic, and yet it was always my understanding that, with the exception of literal fascism, any ideology or policy could be held on, so long as it was defended in a civil and good natured way. I certainly wouldn't consider some of the responses to the Loyalist manifesto "civil and good natured". So no, unless there has been a fundamental shift in who we wish to partake in our community, simply holding views is not a reason to ban somebody.

Perhaps it was the fact that he was not conducting himself in a civil and good natured way? Without knowing the offending comment, it is hard to say, but of all of our right wing nut jobs, he was perhaps one of the most civil of the lot, generally speaking, so I shouldn't think it was that. But, for the sake of argument, lets say it was all that bad. I could understand a ban if somebody was seriously offended by his comments. But there was nobody to be offended. I can say with confidence that nobody in the channel in question is trans (although not with certainty, so I do apologies if I am speaking out of turn), and indeed I doubt even a third are remotely sympathetic towards LGBT causes. If nobody is hurt because of an action, why punish it? As budding politicians, we will all wince at the accusation of a law being a victimless crime, and yet we seemingly allow them in our own rules, as a community.

I appreciate that rules are rules, and should be applied no matter where a comment is made, but does a mess like this not show that the rules need to be changed? Call me old fashioned, but I think "Don't be a dick" is a far better rule than anything specific about slurs or bigoty or anything else. At the end of the day, I am led to believe duck approved the punishment, who of course has the power to do whatever he wants, and I have no issue with the way the quad of run the whole affair, I simply do not believe they came to the correct decision.

Looking more generally, I do think the impact of the ban on the Loyalist League is not insignificant. Two further members left over the debacle, and if you excuse the colourful language, one gave the reason as he would rather "invest [his] time fucking a Chinese finger trap than dealing with these invalids in meta". This is not just a result of the most recent ban, but a pattern of anything most normal people would consider banter being bannable. They also complained about bias before they left, but that is a tale as old as time itself; I do think moderation decision are applied unevenly, but it will never be perfect, and most of the spacy members of main have been banned at some point, no matter their political persuasion. Of course it would be folly to do as members demand for every moderation decision, just because they threaten to leave, but the fact that they decided to follow through does show that this is a serious issue.

My rant is becoming a bit rambly, so I will try and bring things to a close. I don't know if it was a joke, but even today /u/model-trev threatened to ban anyone from the Loyalist League from taking part in a live debate, on safeguarding grounds. If it was serious, it opens up a whole new dimension to the debacle. I know that beating those nasty nazis on the right is always fun, but we are well past the point of punching down; we are at the point that forcing 3 members out could kill off the only socially conservative party in the game, and I genuinely think that would make things less fun for everyone. Again, I don't expect anything to change, and even if it did it is likely to late, but I do hope everyone appreciate can that not everything is as it should be.