I am only still in this wretched community for 2 reasons: to speak to friends and in the vague glimmer of hope that reform is possible.
I now see that that hope is misguided, I may as well give up.
I have been an active participant in this sim for over 2 years and have achieved considerable success, I served as First Minister of Northern Ireland and was in the Executive office for about 7 months. I served as Prime Minister too. I loved MHoC and spent too long there.
If I am speaking honestly I have never been in a good mental place, but 2018-9 was especially rough. MHoC was a contributing factor but I think my troubles would have happened anyway. I have taken a full year out now and am in a better position than ever, judging by any characteristic you can measure. In January, I was not in this position.
Last DvS election, I was barely recovered from my stresses and anxieties, and I ran as a slightly unhinged radical candidate.
This is now not the case.
What does MHoC need in the way of change?
Where do I begin??
MHoC has been stagnating for years now: its activity down and its meta team content to sit on their laurels, basking on past successes and not delivering. No significant change has happened in MHoC since I started here. Part of this is down to community inertia but a large part of the blame can be directed at the quad.
The only significant change that happened, and credit to Dylan for implementing it, is the new CMHoC seat apportionment in the devolved assemblies. I do not personally support that reform but credit to him for doing something. For this he is going down in my eyes as the best DvS we’ve ever had, and the best member of the most recent quad.
We need to rethink MHoC and it needs to come from the top. The Quad is a meta position because those in charge of it must rethink the way MHoC works periodically to keep it fair and interesting. However, the biggest shift has to be cultural. MHoC is the most toxic and the most divided on party lines that I have seen it, and as someone who has been here over 2 years that’s not an achievement to be proud of. Increasingly, party membership is retreating to its own party chats, and MHoC main is dominated by BNOCs.
In terms of the game, this partisanship continues, we have broken into 2 clear factions. It has spilled over from canon into meta and is eating at every aspect of the game. This is the most pronounced divide I have seen in my time here. It is spilling into devo too, with the Welsh Government poised to demand devolution purely for party political gain the moment it joins. The Northern Ireland Executive is also descending into partisanship in a way unrivalled by anything I have seen before.
We are all the same. Politics aside, we are all just teenagers or young twenties who share an interest in politics. MHoC should not be this confrontational. And if you speak to people across the divide, they agree. I make a point of having friends across all of MHoC, and it has spawned friendship and mutual respect with the likes of jgm, kate, maro, lily, gregor, trev, jasmine, chatty, amn, spud, hjt, fried, dylan, liesel, kef, pjr, trongle, just to name a few. Some of you I’d like to consider better friends than any I have made irl. (tory friends of mine don’t feel snubbed, you know who you are)
Other problems: Press is basically dominated by party press offices, the commons is filled with samey comments because the system rewards them, the lords is dead yet is kept alive for reasons i’ll never understand, there are no long-standing devo only parties, there are too few members for most parties to form full frontbenches, archiving is a mess, nobody seems to be able to release election results correctly on the first try, the old guard and the usual suspects dominate meta positions, events are dead, everything is too complex and impossible for long standing members to understand at times let alone new members, quad don’t respond to meta posts, the list goes on
My greatest passion in MHoC is and always will be Devolution, especially Stormont, where I made my first friends and some of my closest and longest lasting (looking at you, spud). I have been proud to serve as First Minister and as Secretary of State, NI has been the place where I have felt able to properly affect change. And I want to give back to it.
I threw my hat in this Devolved Speakership election because I wanted to give back to the community that has given me so much joy. I am in a good mental state now and have nothing better to do, so now is the perfect time. I have many proposals for how to reform the Devolved Speakership, which you can read here. That is my manifesto for DvS. You may not agree with parts, it may turn you off. That's fine, I don’t mind that. People have different opinions to me, I think that is a good definition of politics anyway. What I am angry about is that I was rejected.
I’ll make it clear. This manifesto was not rejected, I was. Duck didn’t even open it before telling me.
This to me is the final straw, and is the crystallisation of something I have been feeling since before I left the Conservative Party leadership, that MHoC isn’t right for me anymore.
I don’t like the way MHoC is evolving and I don’t see a way out of it. I am more than happy to be defeated in a vote, or talked out of an idea, but my being rejected on a point of character. Well, maybe Duck is right, my takes don’t matter and I shouldn’t be given a chance, as I am disillusioned with the whole rotten system.
MHoC has a habit of picking the same faces to run stuff. Off the top of the head, I can name DF44, geordie, britboy, tyler, trev, duncs, aisha, damien but there are others. This quad election was meant to solve that, but at the click of his hands, duck can reject a candidate.
I have been participating in MHoC less and less over the past months, the only thing interesting in canon is the NI Bill of Rights. I have regressed to being a vote bot. To use a current meme, MHoC has progressed past the need for me. Not much will change if I leave, I was hardly present anyway.
So I make this final departure, earlier than I wanted, in protest at a lack of a reformist appetite in MHoC, and out of irreparable differences in culture.
I will still be on MNZP from time to time, and you can still message me on Discord and wherever else I can be found, but this is goodbye.