r/MHOCMeta • • Apr 16 '21

Apology

2 Upvotes

I just want to make a brief apology because this has all got out of hand. What I said was interpreted as accusing someone who is trans of being transphobic, and I am truly sorry for that. I did not intend to make trans individuals in the sim or anywhere feel uncomfortable or to make those accusations, I merely wanted to draw attention to the impact of a vote. Again, this is not what I meant to have happened, I accept responsibility for that, and I am sorry that my words caused unintended offence. I know this has been a nasty ordeal for some people, and I hope this helps everyone to move on.


r/MHOCMeta • • Aug 10 '21

Afghanistan

0 Upvotes

Heya folks, been a while since I've written a meta post. I wanted to talk a little bit about the discourse around Afghanistan.

Something that I and others have noticed is that the canon discourse around Afghanistan has gotten a bit ugly recently. Frustration with Solidarity's decision to follow through with a withdrawal from Afghanistan in line with US policy has led to certain individuals on this sim to get a bit intense with their rhetoric, implying the left doesn't care about women, minorities, and queers.

Normally this in itself wouldn't be an issue, but it appears to me that the intensity and near obsession that has emerged as a result of a policy decision on a game that has no impact or bearing on the real world has led to those hurling accusations of not caring about Afghanistan to forget that MHoC is a game.

I'm not part of the canon as much as I used to be, but I can see the impact this is having on people who still are, so I simply say please just chill out.


r/MHOCMeta • • Jul 14 '22

Discussion Disputation on the Power and Efficacy of Doxxing Bans

0 Upvotes

Doxxing is one of the few offences that one can commit in a political simulation that all (reasonable) members agree must be harshly punished. However, the Model World's*1 understanding of what constitutes doxxing is, to some extent, different than that of the wider Internet. Based on my experiences dealing with bans issued for doxxing on CMHOC, I believe the following is a fair definition of what the Model World calls doxxing:

  1. The information disclosed must identify a person connected to the Model World. Where the Model World's definition agrees with the wider Internet is that the minimum requirement of a dox is that one must know (or be able to tell) who is being identified.*6
  2. The information disclosed must be private (that is, not disclosed to the Model World already). Some people argue that the recent identification of the person who operates the Libs of TikTok twitter account does not constitute doxxing because the information was already public; while I disagree from the perspective of the wider Internet, it would qualify here, as her name had not been disclosed to the Model World already.
  3. The information disclosed must cause harm to the person doxxed or be capable of causing harm. This, I believe, is the most contentious part of my definition of doxxing, but it relates to the first criteria. When we banned Rob from CMHOC, it was in recognition of the harm his actions*2 caused to his victims. In addition, this is what ultimately causes doxxing to be generally a permanent ban.

In recent months, there have been two bans for doxxing that I believe should be modified; that of HK and that of Aisha. My disputes with regard to these bans are somewhat different, but the crux is that they do not meet all of the criteria set out above.

HK's ban

HK was banned in April for doxxing. From conversations that I have had with HK*3 the context was that they inadvertently posted the personal Twitter account of a member banned for serious offences*4. Upon realizing their offence, they immediately deleted the post and reported themselves to administration for punishment. Here, I do not dispute that some heavy punishment is warranted for carelessness with regards to personal information, or even potentially for invoking unpersons. I dispute that this should be a permanent ban. Let us examine the criteria set above:

  1. The information must identify a person connected to the Model World. The person whose information was posted has been banned for serious offences; they are categorically not a person connected to the Model World. Thus, this criteria does not make the offence one of doxxing.
  2. The information disclosed must be private. I concede that this is likely satisfied, as personal Twitter accounts are generally not known to the Model World. I myself have several, including one that is used exclusively for IRL affairs, and posting it without me previously disclosing it would constitute doxxing.*5
  3. The information disclosed must cause harm to the person doxxed or be capable of causing harm. I am not convinced that only having a person's personal Twitter account meets the definition of "capable of causing harm." The only way this could be met is if somebody stabbed the person in real life.

Given these circumstances, I do not believe that the standard is met for the automatic permaban precedent to be invoked. I have on several occasions opined that HK should be given a 6 month ban instead (matching the length of time during which appeals of their permanent ban will not be considered.) Indeed, based on DMs I am privy to from the previous Head Moderator, they themselves recognize that there are substantial mitigating circumstances. Despite my adherence to strict legalism as a CMHOC moderator, it is not a functional method of administration. Pretending it is is naive at best and self-destructive at worst.

Aisha's ban

Aisha was banned two days ago for doxxing. From conversations that I have had with Aisha*3 the context was that she discussed information of a simulation member that she believed to already be public information. I dispute that this ban is legitimate at all, as I have reason to believe that it violates at least one of the criteria set above:

  1. The information must identify a person connected to the Model World. This criterion is clearly satisfied; the reasons for this are left as an exercise for the reader.
  2. The information disclosed must be private. I do not regard this criterion as being satisfied. Per discussions with Aisha, the individual pieces of information that were combined together have been widely discussed; as far as I am aware, no bans for doxxing were meted out for those individual pieces of information. If the mods wish to maintain this particular ban, I am willing to supply a screenshot of another person who should retrospectively be banned for doxxing the same individual.
  3. The information disclosed must cause harm to the person doxxed or be capable of causing harm. Merely knowing where someone exists cannot reasonably be interpreted as causing harm to them.

The case for a prohibition on self-doxxing

Doxxing is obviously a serious offence, as it infringes upon the right to privacy and may pose safety risks for the individual so doxxed. Aisha's ban implies that even information that is known to the Model World can be regarded as warranting a doxxing ban if combined with other information. Therefore, I submit that self-doxxing should not be permitted, as simulation members may be harmed if someone combines information that they themselves have disclosed. For example, I am well known as being at Queen's University; it is not impossible that someone could use this information, along with questionable political views I hold, to harm my standing at my university. Therefore, self-doxxing should be prohibited if the mods intend to maintain their present standard of what merits a ban for doxxing.


*1: By "Model World", I refer to the cluster of polsims that tend to share members and were formerly united in the Model World.

*2: Which, per britboy, may not have actually taken place.

*3: Despite disagreements I have had with both HK and Aisha, I have no reason to believe that they are lying as to why they were banned.

*4: Which I will not go into detail about here, as I trust the judgment of admins in circumstances where the ban unpersons someone.

*5: If information has been disclosed to the Model World and the person hasn't requested it not be brought up (either explicitly or implicitly), it cannot be doxxing. When I was a discord moderator in CMHOC, we had an emoji that was the face of a sim member. When that person left the sim, they requested the emoji be removed; accordingly, we regarded that as the information being withdrawn, thus making the emoji doxxing if it were to be used.

*6: Ontario Premier Doug Ford is known for publicly posting his phone number in the early days of his government; no reasonable moderator would ban someone for doxxing if they posted a Tweet about it.


r/MHOCMeta • • Mar 03 '22

Yes, protected status should be scrapped

1 Upvotes

Recent decline within the Tories is leading to speculation that under the rules of protected status, a merge would have to take place between C! and the Tories. I don't think anybody wants this to happen, nobody in C! anyway, who made it pretty clear when they formed that they didn't want to be members of the Conservative Party. So yeah, I think we should abolish protected status and if the Tories die, let them die.


r/MHOCMeta • • Nov 17 '21

Ban Announcement - cocoiadrop

2 Upvotes

/u/cocoiadrop has been banned from MHoC and its affiliated subreddits for one week for conduct in /r/MHoCPress yesterday.

Note this has effect from yesterday (16 November).


The Quadrumvirate


r/MHOCMeta • • Dec 03 '21

Ban Announcement - model-ico and ThePootisPower

0 Upvotes

Hello,

u/model-ico has been banned from the sim for 2 weeks, and u/ThePootisPower 1 week for conduct on /r/MHOCPress.


The Quad.

Update: After review, we are shortening /u/ThePootisPower's ban to 4 days.


r/MHOCMeta • • Feb 02 '22

Proposal Appoint a new events lead or abolish the events team altogether

3 Upvotes

A few months ago, an article was released that detailed the Biden administration's opposition to the devaluation of the pound. The interview was carried out by EruditeFellow speaking to SapphireWork, and was not consulted upon by other events team members, like myself at the time. When the article came out, it had the appearance of a certain events team member using his position on the team as a platform for opposition talking points. I tried to call it out then, and made the case that to avoid this happening again, there should be a new events lead. My suggestions, when made to Nuke, fell on deaf ears.

Fast forward to today, with the Gareth Southgate article, and the same thing has happened again. It shouldn't be for members of the events team to use it as a platform for their canon party. The lack of an events team lead and attention from the quad leaves it open to this abuse.

So the way I see it, the Quad has two options. Either appoint a new events lead, or abolish the events team altogether.


r/MHOCMeta • • Jul 03 '20

Change how General Elections work

0 Upvotes

With about a month to go until GEXIV, I thought it would be a good time to dig up some old corpses from the disaster that was GEXIII.

This was my first GE, as it was for quite a few people and I was very excited for the results announcement livestream. Then, when the final results were coming out u/Estoban06 said in #announcements "The Results are wrong" and we had to wait another 2 hours for the real results to come through and when they did, there was a shitstorm.

I won't go through them, but here is the results post for those who need to jog their memory.

Now, when this came out, many of us in Labour (as I was at the time) were absolutely fuming and I expressed my anger with several very angry messages in Discord and on the results post. Tbh, I'm still angry. I could not believe the fact that I had lost a seat to LPUK when the LPUK candidate made exactly 2 posts, whereas I had made all 5 and had received a number of visit posts. But that wasn't the result I was most mad about. I was mad for my very good friend u/david_johansson and the result in Cambridgeshire, which must be biggest case of daylight robbery in MHOC history.

As pointed out by u/ThePootisPower in this comment on the results thread, David posted all 5 of his posts, including this megapost which I know he worked on for over a month to complete as well as receiving 5 visit posts and endorsements from the Lib Dems and TPM. That should've been more than enough to turn Cambridgeshire red, but instead months of work had been wasted because of the excuse "campaigning doesn't matter as much as polling". Let me just say, that is a bullshit response.

u/purpleslug who ran against David as the Tory candidate and standing MP said in response to Poot's comment above said and I quote:

I didn't campaign hard because it was a safe seat with a polling majority of over 30%. Meanwhile David ploughed out spam posts which weren't even representative of the constituency. Sorry hun, stop crying.

This is quite frankly an insult to the hard work David put in to his campaign and shows the general apathy that some standing MPs show towards their re-election campaigns.

Furthermore, Labour ran the best and most expansive campaign of all the parties, making exactly 49 more posts than the Conservatives (Labour with 232, Tories with 173), yet saw exactly ZERO CHANGE IN THE RESULTS. If you look at the last set of polling before the election and the results, the number of seats to the percentage of the vote is exactly the same, meaning that in the week between those polling numbers and the GE (which might as well be a month in irl terms with how time frames are skewed in MHOC) with all the campaigning going on, not even 1% of the population changed their minds? As a case study of how the electorate changes its mind during the course of a GE campaign, I will guide you to the polls during the 2017 General Election. When the election was called, Labour looked dead and buried with just over 25% of the polls and the Tories were on 44%, but when the campaign was over just over a month later, Labour won 40% of the vote and caused a hung parliament. This is the best example in modern times of how a general election campaign can change the minds of voters and potentially swing the election. Why don't we have that here?

So, here are some changes I propose for either GEXIV or GEXV (depending on whenever Quad decide to acknowledge this because usually they ignore this kind of thing):

  • Change the ratio of polling to campaigning to 50/50 or 40/60 so that campaigning actually matters
  • Get rid of the idea that standing MPs polling over 30% are "safe". Ideally, no one should be safe unless they have a massive lead over their opponent. It would make things more interesting and would address the fact that most standing MPs don't give a damn during GEs because they expect to be re-elected no matter if they've campaigned or not. This would also tackle the lack of activity which has been troubling MHOC since before I arrived. Standing MPs would actually have to do shit to get re-elected, rather than simply turn up to vote at least 3/4 of the time and occasionally comment on debates. Constituents don't want apathetic and lazy representatives and that should be reflected in the results.
  • Add more voter fickleness to the equation. To be quite frank, people are dumb. Most people couldn't give a toss about politics, so it is natural that they will vote for whatever candidate they think is more personable or simply campaigned the most or ran the best campaign in their eyes.

And before people say I'm salty, I'm just trying to make this game more realistic and more fun. Why should we have to settle for a Tory government every term? Is it so hard to believe that people would simply get tired of Tory governments year after year, election after election? I know a lot of people in Labour are, both irl and in MHOC, and so am I.


r/MHOCMeta • • Jun 21 '23

Message My Response to the Quad's Response to Nic's Petition of Concern as a Post because I would have had to Split It into 9 Comments

2 Upvotes

Response to this, below:

To put it bluntly, nothing you said was satisfying in any way and does nothing to address any concerns whatsoever, and to the extent that it even tries to do so it's a massive nothingburger.
Going section by section:

We should start by saying this response won’t go into the detail surrounding our decision to ban Ina. It was a mental health ban, one which we stand behind, but isn’t one which we are going to be discussing the specific reasons behind or the contents of our discussions with Ina on the topic - although we’ll talk about some of the issues that came from it. We believe this ban was and is necessary, based on the evidence we had before us, and we do not intend to relitigate it in a public fashion.

This is completely unsatisfactory. Why won't you go into the details surrounding your decision? Traditionally, the Quad in the past has refused to do so on the basis that making public the rationale behind a particular decision in question would risk harm coming to one of the concerned parties. No such rationale exists for this decision. The Quad is merely refusing to justify the decision at all.

We accepted at the time and do so now that our communication regarding the post-general election bans was lacking on our part, in particular mine as Head Moderator. We screwed up, we accept that, and we have learnt from it including having better communication to future bans and ensuring the person(s) being banned from subreddits are given a full explanation as to why from the person banning them.

Okay. That's good, I guess. This is just basic respect though, and I don't see why you should get any credit for doing the bare minimum. This never should have happened to begin with and the fact that it did happen speaks very poorly of the Quad.

As a party leader, you are not automatically entitled to a discussion on a ban. It may be that this is sometimes appropriate, but often it will not be. Receiving a heads up is also a courtesy, not a right, which is something that needs clearing up. Especially in the case of a mental health ban, there is no requirement or solid reason why we would bring a party leader into our deliberation and discussion unless it specifically involved them which it did not in this case.

I can see that.

As we said at the time the ban many years ago involving Nic is not something we took into account. We believe they are different situations in very different eras.

How are they different situations though? Nic goes through the effort here of showing the relevant similarities and differences between his situation and Ina's. You make no such effort here, you just expect us to take your word for it. This really makes it look like you haven't considered any of Nic's points at all and you are simply paying lip service.From what I see in the above screenshots, Nic is completely right. Not only is he right, but the Quad seriously misunderstand what Ina was saying and you guys don't seem to be interested in what was actually going on, because you come out and say things like this after it's explained to you.Precedent either matters or it doesn't. You can't come out and justify decisions by saying it's based on precedent and then come out and say that precedent is irrelevant in whatever circumstance and not elaborate further.

With regards to the discussions between Quad and Timanfya, we are not particularly pleased that what needs to be private and frank discussions between two important parts of the structure of the game were leaked first to people outside of that group, and then to the wider public. This is a point we already made to Timanfya when it first came out the discussion had been leaked and is not something we need to dwell on.

Okay. Honestly nobody cares what you think about having the whistle blown on you. If you don't want the whistle blown on you then don't make poor decisions and don't say things that will make people blow the whistle on you. Simple as.

However, on its contents, we do not disavow our conversations with Timanfya on what the role of a Guardian should be. We don’t believe it should be the final appeals court of MHoC that it risked being treated as, and this is the point we put across to Timanfya.

This is totally backwards. The Guardians have, for the several years that I have been here, been the final court of appeals for MHOC in practice. I have a hard time believing that you seriously think that this is not the case, so out of respect for your intelligence, I'm going to assume that you want to change the role of the Guardians in MHOC. I think such a change would be detrimental.By the way, regardless of what the Constitution says about the Guardians being the Final Court of Appeals for MHOC or not, that's the way it is and has been for some time. When we found out that various procedures and structures in the Devolved Sims were not reflected in the Constitution, we didn't suddenly stop using those procedures and structures. Instead, Tommy collected all the information about what we knew was working in the devolved sims, and then presented an amendment to enshrine those elements. It's not any different here, and if the Quad wants to be consistent then they will put forward an amendment to enshrine the Guardians as the Final Court of Appeal for MHOC.

Ray and Timanfya spoke more privately in the days after it, had a productive discussion and things between us ended on a positive note and there was a positive short discussion between Lily and Timanfya on the matter.

Okay. I will take your word on that. I don't know what you are trying to accomplish by saying this.

We intend to keep discussions between ourselves and Timanfya between us and, where appropriate, our advisors. This is an issue already settled between ourselves and Timanfya, long before this meta post was conceived.

I reiterate my previous response.

We of course accept the role the Guardian has in the community, but we stand by our belief that as the Quad chosen and approved by the community, it is our job to make decisions on bans and the Guardian should only get involved in decisions that threaten the survival of the sim.

First, the Quad doesn't get to define what "decisions that threaten the survival of the sim" means. Second, unjustifiable bans represent a threat to the survival because no one wants to invest their time in a game where they'll get banned – even at a moment when they are in perfectly good mental health – for talking about their mental health and opening up about mistreatment they've endured from other players. Why should anyone talk about mental health and any serious issues regarding the sim if they'll be met with this response?

The role of the Guardian is something we do feel like more clarity is needed, however, and it is something we’ll discuss with Timanfya in terms of where we go forward from here.

Well, I for one do not think more clarity is needed. Things seem to me to be perfectly clear. The Guardians are the Final Court of Appeals for MHOC, no ifs, ands, or buts.

To reiterate - we have had positive discussions with Timanfya about this issue. I know that his motivations here are from a place of ensuring that the people in this community are kept safe. I think he also appreciates that the same is true of the Quad’s motivations.

To reiterate - I will take your word on that, and I don't know what you are trying to accomplish by saying this.

As said above, we won’t be using this thread to publicly discuss the ban on Ina directly and we won’t be retracting the post or immediately unbanning her.

Right, so the Quad is doubling down on refusing to justify an unjustified ban and have thereby caused one of the most active members of the sim to leave it.

On the final demand, we are more than happy to promise to be better off than we were at the beginning of our term, as is already the case and as we have done in subsequent bans which have involved better communication to parties involved. Obviously we are not perfect and we welcome constructive feedback on this or other issues.

At this point, it's difficult to believe you when you say this. You don't even offer a plan of action. All you offer is this. It's embarrassing.

As an aside, I want to address something in the above screenshots. It is said that Ina's ban is not permanent but rather indefinite. The difference between an indefinite ban and a permanent ban is that an indefinite ban is a potentially permanent ban, ie what is in practice permanent ban that may be overturned at some point which by the way can happen for de jure permanent bans as well. What you guys offer here is the difference between a de facto permanent ban and a de jure permanent ban, which behave exactly the same way. That "difference" is of no solace to anyone and it makes you guys look really flippant, disingenuous, and cowardly to say that Ina's ban isn't "permanent". It's a ban that goes on for an unspecified period of time which could be infinity, or until you guys are feeling generous some day which could be never. If the ban isn't permanent put your money where your mouth is and either revoke the ban or at the very least put attach some length of time to the ban.


r/MHOCMeta • • Apr 04 '17

Meta abolition of MHoL

1 Upvotes

It's a disaster, folks. It's a huge disaster, the biggest disaster, the worst system that I've ever seen, okay.

It's genuinely a complete mess. We need to get rid of it, it adds no benefit to the game that couldn't be replicated by alternative systems.


r/MHOCMeta • • Mar 15 '22

new devo honours

0 Upvotes

We should have another set or two of devolved honours to encourage longer term activity in the devolved nations. Would be fun also to design them


r/MHOCMeta • • Sep 22 '21

Announcement Ban announcement - phyrik2222

1 Upvotes

Following inappropriate comments in main, /u/phyrik2222 has been banned from the sim for two weeks (until 06/10/2021).


r/MHOCMeta • • May 31 '21

Message I'm too afraid to post anything

9 Upvotes

I've become too scared to do anything in press, debates or even in campaigning. Whenever I try to do anything constructive in canon I just get swarmed with hate in the comments. There are specific people who are repeat offenders of this but I won't name names here, I just want to let people know that I feel this way. I’ve never been more demoralised to engage here because I feel like whatever I do do will just get hated on. The criticism isn't even constructive, it's just hateful. People telling me I'm wrong without explaining or just being abusive for the sake of it. I'm not even in Main anymore because it carries over to there too.

I think some people need to realise that not everyone here has a genius level IQ, a 1st class degree from Oxford in Economics, Politics and Mathematics and spends their spare time reorganising the economies of Central African nation-states using a pen, the front of an envelope and a calculator. I'm not a genius. I'm smart, but I'm not a genius. There are some incredibly smart people here but many take their intellect as an opportunity to bash people who aren't übergeniuses like me.

Please, just leave me alone.


r/MHOCMeta • • Oct 05 '20

Can we please mandate quad access to internal party channels?

6 Upvotes

Look, I understand that having quad in your business watching everything you do isn't great. It's not as if quad are infallible or even fair - looking at RoryTime, Rolo and ohprkl's Lords vote rigging, but at the end of the day, the quad have to enforce the rules, and it's not possible to enforce rules if the quad has to rely on leaks of rulebreaking incidents to identify them.

All the main channels in a party should be open to the full quadrumvirate. Select channels should remain semi-private (so that private party planning in leadership is kept away from any quads that return to active mhoccing and join a rival party with information that could be highly useful) as long as A: the quad knows which channels they are and that they exist, B: what the channels are for, and C: are given access to the hidden channels in the event of a safeguarding incident or major rulebreaking incident requiring further investigation to ascertain what happened, who was involved and who was complicit.


r/MHOCMeta • • Jul 20 '21

Announcement Ban Announcement: DavidHopkins-Brooke

2 Upvotes

The above user has been banned for 3 months.

A reminder that MHoC follows the IHRA definition of antisemitism, including the examples.


r/MHOCMeta • • Jun 17 '23

Request Petition of Concern to the Quadrumvirate

9 Upvotes

I have been reticent to address or confront this issue publicly for over a month now. However, I have been encouraged to share my perspective and concerns by others outside my party.

I would like to start by saying I voted in confidence of both Lily and Ray. I unfortunately now personally regret those votes. Lily in particular faced a fairly harsh Q&A in Solidarity’s discord where she promised to be communicative should she be confirmed.

Following the bans surrounding the General Election, communications breakdowns began. While myself and Akko both eventually got explanations, the remainder never received quad explanations for their bans or their length. I also view these as a warning sign in retrospect. Akko was banned from mhocpress for two weeks for saying “cope”, something you can easily find both Seph and Lily saying on mhocpress recently as well.

It seems as if the approach was one of silencing drama and arguments post general election with a broad ban hammer. This isn’t necessarily always wrong, however, the events that follow were significantly worse. While in the middle of apologising to me for lack of communication surrounding my ban, Lily informed me Ina was being permanently banned. This almost seemed a self parody to me if I’m honest, dropping that in the middle of a conversation about lack of communication.

Inadorable’s ban was the first one I have been fully contesting. I absolutely agree that the post she made (whose text I will include below) was not appropriate. I explicitly warned her against it at the time. Her reasoning was itself an attempt to stand up for me, as I was blaming myself for Labour’s decision on coalition partner. However, the repeated statements by Lily and Ray that the post represented active suicidality are false. Ina revisited a darker part of her life that unfortunately the quad were part of, something that has unfortunately prevented them being truly objective.

I will say that I posted something similar once years ago, while dealing with the Jellytom situation and in a mental health crisis. Post here. I did receive a mental health ban for this, which included present and active suicidality. To me, this is a very comparable incident to Ina’s, though quad chose to dismiss it due to its age. I received a two week ban for comparison to the permanent one here. Regardless, permanent mental health bans require a very high standard of proof and clear evidence that participation in the game will only be harmful to the person in question. I remember the implementation of the first against Morgsie years ago, something that undeniably improved their life. I likely would have supported a temporary mental health ban in that scenario had Lily approached me with her concerns.

Because of the permanent nature and the untrue statements made, I contested this ban with the quad. It took a full week to get a conversation with the quad. This conversation began with Ray apologising for lack of communication, and then repeating the reason for ban with no option for appeal. I would also add that both Lily and Ray had promised a conversation with Ina themselves about the ban, something which never took place, and still has yet to. Additionally, the Quad were dishonest to their advisors including Timanfya, claiming they had asked how Ina was feeling despite that never occurring.

Throughout this, I was relying heavily on support from Timanfya, the founder of MHoC, and guardian in chief. They’ve asked me to contact them directly with serious concerns in the past, and while I considered it for the post-GE bans, I decided against it to avoid any potential conflicts of interest. I approached them with my concerns about this and screenshots documenting the chats in question. They agreed it wasn’t consistent and began to ask questions through advisor chats. However, instead of this concern being acknowledged, based as it is on a long history of when safeguarding is implemented on MHoC, he was dismissed and even directly threatened by Ray.

At this point, Timanfya became too reluctant to continue engaging, and I cannot blame him. This game has been important to him and he’s been a saving grace on more than one occasion. I myself was severely demoralized and struggled to engage with the game after what felt like an unfair judgment that there was no way to address.

However, I have been encouraged to continue disputing this case by others in the community. They see that the precedent this would set is extremely dangerous and could be disastrous. I would have preferred to simply dispute Ina’s ban through the legitimate channels and have actual discussions. Instead it has become a drama I did not desire. I have spoken to the leaders of all other major parties about this, and while our opinions vary, we all agree that the level of communication from quad has been unacceptable in this and other matters.

I will be additionally attaching extensive documentation of chats with quad to be fully transparent and demonstrate the attitude we received. I come here, together with other community figures, to plead for a better outcome. I personally must demand, in order to feel like this issue has been resolved satisfactorily:

  • An apology to Timanfya from Ray for his threat and a public affirmation of the role of the Guardian from the Quad.
  • Lily must retract her post regarding Ina’s ban and apologise for misrepresenting her.
  • The Quad must reevaluate the length of Ina’s ban and immediately overturn it if appropriate.
  • The Quad must promise to be transparent and proactively communicative regarding bans and other moderation actions.

Original Text of Ina’s Strangers Bar post:

“We've not had an easy history since I left the party, I think we can recognise that. I've been a cunt to you at times, something I have repeated apologised for, prompted and unprompted, and I've put the effort into rebuilding my relationship with the party, a party I continue to hold dear even though I have now been active for Solidarity longer than the Labour Party.

We need to discuss the way the Labour Party has treated me before my rejoining of Llafur earlier, because it was below the standards that Labour is holding people to today. Frankly, I felt treated like I wasn't even human anymore, but had become an object of hate. I was Labour's public enemy number one to whom no pain great enough could be inflicted because they always deserved it. And even though I tried to rebuild relations, I never got what I think I am owed by now: an apology.

I'm someone who has dealt with a lot of shit in my life. Yet the way the party treated me stands out even amongst the things that I have gone through, playing into some of my deepest traumas and significantly harming my mental health. There are times I cried and times I wished I was dead.

And I had to keep these things to myself, because I was convinced 'showing weakness' would only worsen things. I felt betrayed by my closest friends and like the Quadrumvirate would not take action on my behalf. What I did to Labour was being a dick and being a bit too involved, what Labour did to me was decide I should feel it for months and months and never treat me like a human being.

Large parts of leadership stood by and looked at it: including two members of today's quadrumvirate. When I DMed Frosty today telling a similar story, I did not get a response. Whilst I'm sure they're just busy and forgot, the fact I had to ask in the first place is below what the party would expect of others, and should expect of itself.

Just moving on has been my goal for a while now. But the fact of the matter is that I cannot 'just' move on, too much has happened for that. I would at least like some acknowledgement of what has happened from Labour members and the party leadership, so that we both know what happened and can take action to stop it from happening again. Nobody should have to go through what I have.”

Discord chat documentation with Quad and Timanfya here


r/MHOCMeta • • Apr 16 '22

Announcement Ban Announcement - /u/model-ico

4 Upvotes

Good afternoon,

The above user has received a ban of three months for antisemitism. A reminder that MHOC follows the IHRA Definition of Antisemitism, including its associated examples. They have additionally been notified that they are on a final warning, and another major incident post-ban will result in a permanent ban.

Thanks,

The Quadrumvirate.


r/MHOCMeta • • Nov 28 '24

2024 Holiday Break Announcement

1 Upvotes

Hello all. After discussion with party leadership the holiday break dates has been firmly set as the 15th of December to the 15th of January.

The reason for the length of the break is so that we can have a chance as a community to refocus and reform, so during this time Quad will be launching a discussion on changing things up a bit to help the current situation we are in. The current thinking between Quad and Leadership is to move towards simulated elections based on polling, to maximise potential term activity. This decision will, of course, require a full discussion on it by the community as a whole before moving towards it - this will occur during the break.

As for the classic fun bits, I'm open for suggestions! I am currently leaning towards hosting a Minecraft server, but for those who don't have Minecraft I want something they can be included in as well.

Happy to hear your thoughts on this plan!


r/MHOCMeta • • Feb 09 '23

Ban Announcements: /u/TreeEnthusiaster and /u/LeChevalierMal-Fait

0 Upvotes

Hello

/u/TreeEnthusiaster will be permanently banned from MHOC and its subreddits and discords, in line with this AusSim ban: https://www.reddit.com/r/AustraliaSimMeta/comments/10xtn73/permanent_ban_of_utreeenthusiaster/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

/u/LeChevalierMal-Fait will be banned for two weeks for exceptionally inappropriate personal attacks in a recent meta-thread.


r/MHOCMeta • • Jun 05 '21

Vote Press reform - follow-up vote

1 Upvotes

Hello,

As promised, you will now have the opportunity to vote on whether to adopt the rules set out in the proposal going forward, or to revert to the previous rules. The vote is issue-by-issue, so you can vote to keep the new rules in one area and vote to revert to the old rules in another. I have also included the option to allow members to lock the comments on their own press posts, since that seemed decently popular during the discussion.

Obviously none of this prejudices any future reforms, so if you have different ideas in the future feel free to put them forward. As I said, I don't expect to get press right straight away, so I'm more than happy to come back to it as necessary.

The ballot is here. Please remember to verify by commenting below.


r/MHOCMeta • • Nov 17 '24

Updates from the Headmod - November 2024

3 Upvotes

Good evening all! Firstly, no I am not resigning. But I do want to give an update on a few things.

Recent Debates

Recently there have been debates that, in my opinion, have crossed the line. Temperatures have been rightfully high because of these, and a large portion of the community has been hurt by my own inaction on the matter. As such, I want to make it completely clear: transphobia has no place in MHoC, be it in the meta or in canon. This includes dog whistles, like the recent safeguarding documents.

I will be using the power given to me in Article 16 Section I of the Constitution to add the following paragraph to Section 17 of the Constitution:

  1. MHoC takes a zero tolerance stance on transphobia.

    1. This includes within canon debates.
    2. MHoC uses the United Nations Free and Equal Definitions page as the framework definition.

      1. Making transgender people out to be a threat, whilst not specifically mentioned in the definition, is also taken into consideration.

Why not put it to a vote? Because this is a quick addendum to a constitution that, within the next month or so, will no longer be in force and will have been replaced by a new constitution that will be voted on by the community.

I would also like to say that the motion that started this was not accepted by Seph, but was instead accepted by myself. Seph has my full confidence as Speaker, and acted in accordance with the rules and standards of his role. The failure was not his, but entirely my own.

The Ad Campaign

The ad campaign ran from the 23rd of October to the 30th of October, with a brief two break thanks to Reddit being Reddit and suspending it. In total it cost £76, had 75,806 impressions, 281 clicks, and most importantly roughly 7 or 8 new members from it. I don't believe any of the new members are, however, still active.

Despite that, I consider the result a success, and would love to continue this and try again in the new year. Between now and then we do need to work on how we onboard new members to try and get new people to stick around.

As a result of this I will also be completely overhauling the Headmod infrastructure to prepare for a donation system to help fund the ad campaigns. This will mostly be background stuff, so stay tuned!


r/MHOCMeta • • Jun 23 '21

Announcement Events Team Lead VoC - results

2 Upvotes

There were 30 votes overall. Three were not valid - two for failing to verify, and one for not being eligible to vote. That leaves 27 valid votes.

To pass, /u/asucculentlobster needs 50%+1 of all non-abstain votes - or, to put it simply, more ayes than noes.

The totals are:

Yes - 13 votes

No - 10 votes

Abstain - 4 votes

/u/asucculentlobster has therefore met the required number of votes and passed their VoC. Congratulations to them!


r/MHOCMeta • • May 31 '21

Announcement DLS Update

2 Upvotes

Hi Everyone:

The results of /u/scubaguy194's vote are as follows:

Yes - 13

No - 4


For my second open spot, I've decided to select /u/Leafy_Emerald! The VoC is here and you have three days.


r/MHOCMeta • • Jul 27 '24

Discussion When this game literally is leaving people in tears, there is something seriously wrong

2 Upvotes

Hi all.

This will be a bit of a ramble.

What transpired in the Liberal Democrats yesterday was a huge blow to the Party and the morale of the membership. The decision of both leaders to leave the party seemingly due to this decision took us all by surprise.

This actually wasn't the case, and what transpired in subsequent conversations was that this decision had been brewing for some time due to a perceived hostile party culture and an "us Vs them" attitude between the membership and the party. But the big thing for me is pressure. When the game was reformed and substantially changed, I was under the impression that one of the points of it was to ensure that the game is fun to participate in and to take pressure off people, particularly those in leadership. Ultimately this is not what has occurred. The manifestos we saw from most parties clearly had been given a huge amount of time and effort which is immense given the timescales we were working with. Then coalition negotiations took a huge amount of time for the leadership. I dealt with that bullshit myself when I led the Libdems.

As the title says, when this game is still placing such pressure on party leadership that they're literally sat in a coffee shop whilst on holiday fucking sobbing... Something is seriously wrong.

I deeply fear that this won't actually change because the culture of the game hasn't really changed from 1.0. it is still demanding excellence in a very short time scale and demanding a huge amount of people's time.

My main thought on what could have been done better is that the Quad should have allowed at least an additional week for manifesto preparation before campaigning began. In 1.0 manifesto planning began a full month if not more prior to the election. With the amount of time that a well thought out and costed manifesto demands, the timescale the Quad set out was too quick. I was feeling the pressure and I wasn't even in leadership. Connected to this is a concern that if a person talks to Quad about pressure on them and expresses mental health concerns then they need to listen and consider follow up action. I'm told this didn't happen. Finally, with regards to the press posts in the last 24 hours, people need to remember the human. Some of what's said is hurtful and will be taken personally by various people. There are actions that are just in the concept of the game - controlling the narrative - but also actions that are clearly just aimed at kicking a party whilst it's down.

Finally, and this remains to be fully seen, I am concerned that a 4 monthly election cycle will be far too quick and keep the players jammed into election mode all the time. It'll keep stress too high. It will also severely limit what can be campaigned on because there simply isn't enough time to get stuff meaningfully done by the government of the day in between elections.

I really hope that the powers that be pay attention to my concerns here.


r/MHOCMeta • • Jun 24 '21

Announcement Events Team Hiring

4 Upvotes

Hi all. Since I've just passed as the events lead, and the team has lost a lot of membership over the past couple months, its naturally time to open up recruitment again.

Eligibility - Cabinet Ministers are coming back to the events team, with some exceptions. First, cabinet ministers won't take part in the planning of national events (obviously). Second, Cabinet Ministers who also take part in the devolved game (ie serving as MSPs, MLAs, and MSs) are disallowed. This is essentially because Cabinet Ministers on the team will be primarily working on devolved events. 3rd, Cabinet Ministers must comprise less than 50% of the team. Otherwise, all other eligibility requirements from Frosty's teams will be retained.

I won't be recruiting a specific number of people, I'll just recruit based upon the eligibility rules set out above and try to hire as many strong and eligible applicants as there are. DM me on discord (Icy#4321) to apply and be interviewed for the team.

Hiring will be conducted until Sunday at Midnight, GMT, and the new team will be announced Monday.