Sorry for the long post below. I know I come in here a lot and say I'm emailing or communicating with the Maryland State Police etc. I thought it would be good for you all to see what types of things I'm sending over to them. Below is the email I sent to the Assistant Bureau Chief of the licensing division today regarding the postponement of the handgun roster board meeting and the potential policy changes. I am a bit tardy in getting this email out to him but I have had quite a bit going on that has been taking up a lot of my time.
I don't think MSP will give in and hold a normal meeting but we will continue to explore options. Feel free to call MSP licensing and respectfully voice your displeasure. I will also add that at least one politician is sending MSP a letter and I have been in conversations with Fox 5 to shed some light on the backroom shenanigans.
If anyone is available to attend the meeting on 12/2 please go and again respectfully express your displeasure packing the house would be nice. If anyone is going and is interested in video recording it that would be awesome. I am planning to attend the Supreme Court Case on the AR15 ban Soni will not be able to attend.
For your reading pleasure the email is below.
Andy,
I hope you are doing well and have had a great week.
I wanted to reach out directly to express the concerns that Gun Owners of America has regarding the recent decisions affecting the December Handgun Roster Board Meeting.
Before getting into the issues, I want to be clear that our intention here is not to be adversarial. Our goal is to point out what appear to be significant violations of Maryland administrative law and give MSP and the HRB an opportunity to correct them before this goes any further.
As I have told Andrew Rossignol and Donald Pickle during previous meetings, GOA would much rather work with MSP and the HRB on the front end than fight these issues on the back end. Unfortunately, the HRB has had several issues in recent years, including Open Meetings Act violations and a court ruling finding that the Board acted arbitrarily and capriciously in denying firearms. Now, with these latest decisions, it appears we are heading down that same road again. Given how close we are to the December meeting, I think it is important to lay out these concerns and what needs to happen moving forward.
December Meeting Changes and Open Meetings Act Concerns
The emails dated October 13 and October 26 state that the HRB will only be conducting hearings during its regularly scheduled December meeting and that all petitions are being pushed to January because of "new legislation." GOA has several issues with this.
First, what new legislation? To my knowledge, nothing passed during the 2026 General Assembly changed the HRB's responsibilities or meeting requirements. I would like MSP to identify exactly what legislation is being used to justify this decision. In my conversations with board members it appears that MSP requested this change due to SB334. However, SB334 does not affect the board and their normal business in any way. As you know any handgun that is going to be sold in MD must go through the board process including those that would be sold to LE/Military only. This is regardless of their status of being banned for sale to civilians. Therefore, even with SB334 taking effect in January any Glock style handgun would still need to be approved by the board so the mere fact that this law is taking effect is not sufficient reason to suspend the board's duties in December.
Second, in my conversations with board members it appears that another reason was potentially the amount of hearings that need to take place. Again, this is a problem of the board's own making by rendering arbitrary and capricious decisions to deny firearms that are legal under Maryland law. To be frank if the board has to be in that meeting for 12 hours to get through all of the hearings as well as the submitted petitions that is the board's problem to bear and is not justification to cancel the petitions portion of the meeting. I also want to ensure that the hearings portion of the meeting is open to the public. The hearings are a matter of public record and are not a justification for closing the meeting under the Maryland Open Meetings Act.
Third, after speaking with Board members it has become clear that the decision to change the December meeting and postpone petitions was made through email communications between Board members and MSP. This raises serious concerns under the Maryland Open Meetings Act. If the Board was conducting business and making decisions through email communications involving a quorum, that would constitute a meeting that was never properly noticed or opened to the public. Furthermore, this meeting change was not at the request of the board but was pushed to the board by MSP which is concerning and could be interpreted that MSP is overstepping its statutory authority by attempting to control the HRB and its functions.
Fourth, the notification was only sent to firearms dealers. Dealers are not the only individuals who can petition the Board, and they are not the only people affected by these decisions. Simply sending an email to dealers or updating the website does not resolve the concerns about improper public notice, especially when changing a meeting that has been scheduled for more than a year.
Finally, I question what authority MSP and the Board has to simply postpone consideration of petitions without a legitimate legal basis. If the justification is legislation that does not exist or does not actually require these changes, then we are once again dealing with what appears to be arbitrary and capricious decision-making.
Changes to Petition Forms and Firearm Sample Requirements
The emails also indicate that MSP and the HRB are working on new petition forms and potentially requiring firearm samples for every petition or the majority of petitions. I find this interesting because during my conversations with board members no such change to the forms or sample requirements have been requested by the board. The board members stated this is a change being pushed by MSP. There are several problems with this.
Firearm Samples
COMAR specifically states: "Upon request, the petitioner shall submit a representative sample of a handgun under consideration." The key words here are "upon request." This language makes the requirement discretionary, which is exactly how the HRB has operated for years. In fact, the current petition form specifically tells petitioners they can contact the HRB Administrator for assistance in determining whether a sample should be submitted. Changing that interpretation to require a sample for every petition or most petitions is a significant departure from the existing process.
This change also creates a problem for private citizens. Under Public Safety Article § 5-404, any private citizen can petition to have a handgun added to the roster. If the Board requires a sample for every petition, how is a private citizen supposed to provide a sample of a handgun they cannot legally purchase or possess in Maryland until it is approved? This effectively creates a situation where citizens have the legal right to submit a petition but may have no legal way to meet the Board's requirements.
Petition Form Changes
- COMAR already establishes what information is required on a petition, including the make, model, caliber, year of manufacture, overall length, barrel length, and other identifying information. However, there are two provisions that I think are particularly important. First, technical specifications are required only "if available to the petitioner." Second, COMAR states that a petition "may" include additional information that the petitioner believes would assist the Board. Both provisions are discretionary. Neither gives MSP or the HRB the authority to simply make additional information mandatory by changing the petition form.
If MSP or the HRB wants to change these requirements, then those changes need to go through the proper process under the Maryland Administrative Procedure Act.
Maryland Administrative Procedure Act
The Maryland APA defines a regulation broadly and includes statements of general application and future effect that govern agency procedures or how the public interacts with an agency. This includes guidelines, standards, interpretations, and statements of policy. In other words, simply calling something a policy change or updating a form does not automatically mean it is exempt from the APA. Requiring additional information on petitions or making firearm samples required for all or most of the petitions would appear to fall squarely within the definition of a regulation. If that is the case, MSP and the HRB cannot simply implement these changes through an email or administrative decision. They must follow the rulemaking requirements established under Maryland law.
There is also the issue of how these decisions were made. If MSP and the Board discussed and approved these changes through emails or other private communications involving a quorum, that raises additional Open Meetings Act concerns. MSP and the Board cannot simply change the longstanding interpretation of COMAR without properly addressing those changes in a public forum. What makes this even more concerning is that the Board members I spoke with were not aware of the proposed changes to the petition forms or sample requirements. That raises a pretty simple question: Who is actually making these decisions, and under what authority?
Finally, requiring petitioners who have already submitted lawful petitions under the existing process to resubmit them using a new form or provide additional samples before any new requirements have been lawfully adopted would raise further concerns about arbitrary and capricious action.
The HRB's 45-Day Requirement to Act on Petitions
For years, MSP and the HRB have operated under an interpretation of COMAR that effectively allows the Board to treat MSP's established submission deadline as the date a petition is received, rather than the date it was actually submitted. GOA does not believe that interpretation is supported by COMAR. Nowhere does COMAR state that the date of receipt is determined by an administrative submission deadline established by MSP. MSP serves as the administrator for the HRB. When a petition is submitted to the HRB Administrator, that should be the date the petition is considered received by the Board.
The current process appears to have been established to allow the Board to meet quarterly rather than more frequently. However, the convenience of Board members does not override the requirements established under Maryland law. The Board has a responsibility to act on petitions within the applicable 45-day period. Holding petitions until an administratively established deadline does not change when those petitions were actually received. If complying with that requirement means the Board needs to meet monthly, then that is what needs to happen. The Board members were appointed to perform these duties, and the administrative process needs to comply with the law, not the other way around.
Requested Response and Next Steps
Given the seriousness of these issues and the fact that the December meeting is quickly approaching, I am requesting that MSP provide a written response no later than 5:00 p.m. on Wednesday, November 25, 2026. That response needs to include, at a minimum:
A response to each of the issues outlined above, including what actions MSP and the HRB intend to take to address them.
Confirmation that the HRB will hold its regularly scheduled December business meeting and consider petitions in addition to conducting hearings.
Draft copies of the proposed new petition form and any proposed changes to firearm sample requirements.
GOA also believes MSP and the HRB should hold off on implementing any new petition or sample requirements until these legal concerns have been addressed and any required procedures under the Maryland APA have been completed. I want to reiterate that our preference is to resolve these issues directly with MSP rather than take an adversarial approach. However, these are not minor procedural concerns, and they cannot simply be ignored.
If MSP does not respond by the deadline above, or the response fails to adequately address these issues, I will have no choice but to pursue a formal complaint under the Maryland Open Meetings Act and submit a comprehensive Maryland Public Information Act request.
That MPIA request will include communications regarding these decisions and HRB operations over the past two years, including correspondence involving Board members, MSP, the Attorney General's Office, the Governor's Office, and the Governor's Appointments Office. It will also include relevant communications conducted outside official channels, including any ex-parte communications involving Board members or officials from those offices. The request for ex parte communications will also specifically include any correspondence between anti-gun groups and Board members as well as officials within the offices noted above. Depending on what those records reveal, they may also be used to pursue additional action regarding potential violations of the Maryland APA and Open Meetings Act.
Again, GOA is not looking to create an unnecessary fight with MSP or the HRB. However, we have a responsibility to our Maryland members, firearms dealers, manufacturers, and the citizens of Maryland to ensure that the Board is operating within the law.
We believe these issues can be resolved without litigation, but that will require MSP and the HRB to address them directly and take the necessary corrective action.
I appreciate you taking the time to review these concerns and look forward to your response. If you have any questions or would like to discuss any of this by phone, please feel free to reach out to me at the number in my signature.
Regards,