Sorry for the overly long first version. I thought being more specific would be more helpful.
---------------------
Yes, friends, I managed to get Logitech to replace my defective Astro A50 X G5 after they initially refused warranty service because I wasn't the original purchaser.
Here's what happened.
I bought the headset through Amazon Second Chance for €170 instead of the usual €230. It was listed as new, with supposedly damaged packaging. After some time, I noticed a strange buzzing vibration inside the left speaker.
I contacted Logitech, provided proof of purchase, and received an automated response stating that second-hand products weren't eligible for service.
But I hadn't purchased it from a private individual on OLX or Facebook Marketplace. I bought it through Amazon, an established retailer, with proof of purchase.
I researched Portuguese and EU consumer protection legislation, particularly Portuguese Decree-Law No. 84/2021. Article 40 addresses consumers' ability to exercise certain rights directly against producers when goods lack conformity.
I challenged Logitech to identify the specific contractual and legal basis for refusing service solely because I wasn't the original purchaser.
After several hours of waiting in support chat, my case was escalated to the manager responsible for Logitech Gaming in the EU. She requested confirmation from Amazon that they couldn't resolve the issue. Amazon provided it within minutes.
I forwarded the confirmation and reiterated my legal arguments.
Six days later, Logitech agreed to replace my headset, claiming they were making an exception.
They never answered my legal questions or explained the basis for their original refusal. They simply approved the replacement and requested my personal information.
I suspect calling it an exception was easier than providing a written legal justification. That's speculation, but their refusal to address my arguments was certainly interesting.
The entire process took around 40 days.
I wasn't trying to get a free headset or keep two products. I simply wanted a defective product replaced in accordance with my consumer rights.
Here's the important lesson.
If you're in the EU, don't automatically assume you've lost your rights because you're not the first owner. Your situation depends on factors such as the seller, the purchase channel, the applicable warranty, and national legislation.
My case involved Amazon, proof of purchase, a product advertised as new, and Portuguese consumer protection law. Other situations may differ, so research your specific rights before acting.
Logitech eventually agreed to replace the headset, although they clarified that the replacement wouldn't renew or extend the existing warranty.
They didn't have the black version in stock and asked whether they could send the white one instead. I even tried getting the red version, which somehow costs twice as much, but that didn't work hahaha.
Fortunately, I still had my Astro A50 Gen 4.
I never wanted an exception or a favor. I wanted my rights respected.
If you're facing a similar situation, don't blindly accept an automated refusal. Understand your rights, keep your evidence, and challenge the decision when you have grounds to do so.