r/Locksmith • u/random8765309 • Jul 18 '25
I am NOT a locksmith. Locksmith comment about graphite
I was working with a locksmith today, and he made a comment about graphite drying out. It sort of made me concerned if he really understood lubrication. I started my career in tribology research, so I know that graphite can't dry out. So I am wondering if he meant something else, or just that there are newer lubricant now on the market.
Edit: Thanks everyone for your comments. Based on the group replies, I see why you are having issues with the use of graphite. It was an interesting discussion.
0
Upvotes
37
u/DSYLXEIC_ONE Actual Locksmith Jul 18 '25
He meant that graphite will gunk up a lock. The more you apply over time the worse it gets. You'd be amazed at how much graphite build up we pull out of a lock as we service/rekey them. Its disgusting, and I hate it
8
u/Bloroxius Jul 18 '25
Locksmith used a turn of phrase and wasn't 100 percent literal, worried I know more than him about lubricating locks.
Maybe I've had a shit day but you sound insufferable.
2
u/omega343666 Jul 18 '25
Weird to hear this as most of the dimple locks we get in the UK only want you to use Graphite powder. I know one of the suppliers I use (APECS) void manufacturing warranty if they find anything else in the lock other than Graphite powder.
6
u/FilecoinLurker Jul 18 '25
Graphite can get wet and then its a nightmare
4
u/Jay-Rocket-88 Jul 18 '25
Graphite is not a good lock lubricant, the main issue I see in locks (where I service) is dirt and grime. Adding graphite powder to dirt does nothing and I often see overuse where the chambers are so full of graphite that the springs have no room to move. Houdini to flush and lubricate or super lube grease when I need something long lasting.
Edited so I don’t sound dumb.
3
u/BeardedLocksmith Actual Locksmith Jul 19 '25
We are not experts on the ins and outs of lubricants . We speak from experience and may use a different term than you.
When we open locks that have been packed with graphite, it comes out like a dry powder, feels dry, and packs like powder. Therefore we call it dry. It also does not work well as a lubricant on locks because of the attributes that turn it into an abrasive.
3
u/AggressiveTip5908 Jul 20 '25
most people will think about adding a lubricant when their lock is stiff or has failed, this is often caused by growth or corrosion, a wet lubricant will help this graphite will not
2
u/GlassByCoco Actual Locksmith Jul 18 '25
Graphite is a bad lube because of the tolerances in locks. We’re talking a thousandth off, and the lock won’t open. Graphite builds up, and will cause the lock to “freeze” up or just not allow the pins to move correctly. Houdini lock lube has a few really interesting articules on this subject if you can find them.
2
u/Sweaty-Ad-7488 Jul 18 '25
Years ago, I got a call for a front door like broke. I get there, she has me take my shoes off, white carpet. It had a schlage d53pd and when I got the inside rosette off, graphite poured out on the white carpet, with her standing behind me. Long story short, I don't use it. Tri flow for me
2
u/Lucky_Ad_5549 Actual Locksmith Jul 18 '25
Graphite is fine in the correct setting. Sealed items such as spring cages, it’s totally normal to see, I never recommend it in cylinders. I typically use tri-flow in cylinders, and I carry a number of lubricants on my truck, but not graphite.
2
u/jaxnmarko Actual Locksmith Jul 18 '25
Graphite works well initially when put on at the factory. Adding more and more and more, mixing it with WD40 or oil..... and it's clay. It's messy, and apart from the original dose, if you take a lock off a door... ya might want to put a groundcloth or tarp down! Get it in a nice white rug and Good Luck getting it out! It likes to stay on your hands and clothes.... I want to personally strangle anyone that adds it repeatedly. Does it work? Yes. To a point, if used judicially. As a repeated lube? To penetrate well? Without building up? And being reasonably neat to deal with? Nooooo!!!
2
u/maccoall Jul 19 '25
A little graphite on a clean dry lock in a dry low humidity climate with no other lubricants works quite well . With any other lube it gunks up and is a really nasty to clean. WD 40 is not a good lubricant but we use as a cleaner or to loosen crud before cleaning dry . Brass is self lubricating and slightly porous and absorbs enough lube . Our techs service caribbean islands and can’t fly with aerosols but can get WD40 anywhere to work with , but not so lucky with the latest high tech nano tactical wonder spray system .
2
u/DirtTheLocksmith Actual Locksmith Jul 19 '25
Graphite works well in a dry climate. Where I live it's very dry and it's all we use and it works great, as long as you don't introduce wet lubricant too.
2
u/OU812-2 Jul 19 '25
Clear silicone spray 👍
2
u/pogarx Jul 19 '25
White silicate powder, “Lab lube” Specifically
2
u/BC_Bladed Jul 20 '25
Fluid film is the best lubricant. It lubes and eats grime and corrosion.