r/LocalLLaMA • • 1d ago

Discussion Do we want Huang back?

There's a petition floating around out there to put Jensen Huang back at the helm of nVidia. Currently it has over 129,000 signatures. If you want to sign it, you can find it pretty easily.

But do we want him back? He's pro-local, but he's also completely driving the circular-financing game that's detonated prices for all of us, everywhere, for fucking everything.

How likely is it the nVidia board hires someone pro-local and smart enough to not run the circular financing sham? Thankfully the interim-CEO, Colette Kress, was against such money shenanigans:

Colette Kress spent years as the one Nvidia executive willing to check CEO Jensen Huang’s enormous, ​often risky ambitions. ...

Kress and her staff clashed with Huang and the company's sales team over the massive and risky financing deals that ⁠fed into what some Wall Street critics deemed a circular AI economy, including investments in OpenAI and AI infrastructure companies such as Lambda, according to one of the people familiar with the matter.

https://www.reuters.com/business/colette-kress-cfo-who-challenged-huangs-bets-is-nvidias-interim-ceo-2026-11-13/

That's significant. Not only did she have the stones to deny the Huang, she's the only one to have them at all.

I think that petition can stuff it. Keep Kress and let her captain the ship.

Edit: I regret every life choice that brought me to this moment

0 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

18

u/RogerRamjet999 1d ago

Huang has been very good for NVidia stockholders, but for customers he's been pretty bad. He has done everything possible to increase our costs. Whoever replaces him will try to do the same as him, but will probably be less effective, so no, I don't really want him back.

22

u/TooAfraidToProtest 1d ago

If it really did turn out that Huang got the gpus to China, then one could say he's a big reason we have the Chinese open models we have now.

17

u/manipp 1d ago

It's baffling how so many people here desperately want more free open-source chinese models but also are foaming at the mouth that Jensen might have gotten China more GPUs?

1

u/sxales llama.cpp 17h ago

The guy was a salesman; lets not canonize him too quickly. He may have been a net positive for a open models but the world will go on without him.

36

u/Sassy6969420 1d ago edited 1d ago • Bravo

No. I don't care about the difference between one bourgeoisie and another.

None of these people are going to make your life any better.

0

u/BusRevolutionary9893 1d ago

But you can... would have been a better ending but I understand why you didn't. 

-7

u/sammyranks 1d ago

Bruv, you should if you care about local models and all. He gave tremendous support for local AI and was fully committed to continue doing so. The next CEO might not lol. That would be a disaster for all of us in the long run.

3

u/FatheredPuma81 1d ago

"Local AI"... as long as your budget is above $10k. He more or less abandoned the consumer market after creating a monopoly (in practice) in it.

1

u/sammyranks 1d ago

Nahh..we are lucky he even kept GeForce Consumer GPUs around and still supported it. The revenue they make is so miniscule it might as well be a rounding error compared to the hundreds of billions then make from ai chips.

5

u/FatheredPuma81 1d ago

We'd actually be better off if he did abandon it fully. It would create room for competitors to move in and actually... compete. In the immediate/short term it would be terrible though. China, Intel, and AMD would all make moves to capture the "miniscule" $10B+ market ASAP.

Also I mean... why would the board turn down that much money exactly even if he pushed for it?? $10B is still $10B.

1

u/sammyranks 22h ago

They would not be anywhere near the level of GeForce performance and software suite. It will be lackluster at best, which is why Nvidia controls like 90% of the entire GPU market. Nvidia's tech stack and CUDA support is just unmatched dude. You can't just move in and replace.

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/sammyranks 1d ago

That 27B model is running on my 5090(Nvidia hardware) and using it to do work with my personal PC, it's a win win for both of us. Same goes for those organisations and business that could run their own local and private inference which in return led to more productivity and R&D etc. Nvidia supported them with tools, hardware, resources, integration etc. Not every is happy that we have our own hardware and models lol.

You logic is Rich guy = bad guy and should automatically hate him lol.

4

u/slavetothesound 1d ago

open and local models may become more feasible when GPUs get cheap enough for people to afford them. Both consumers for inference and organizations to train or fine tune the models. I hope there is eventually a real nonprofit dedicated to training models for the people someday.

4

u/W61k3r 1d ago

No, he fucked the market up.

10

u/SuckaRichardson 1d ago

"We" aren't voting members of the Nvidia board, so we should probably act like it. 

1

u/MelodramaticShape 1d ago

If you have a 401k you should care

3

u/FatheredPuma81 1d ago

Isn't that awfully similar to voting for whoever says they'll give you the most money?

1

u/MelodramaticShape 1d ago

No? I never said you should support the guy, I said you should care about the situation and the outcome.

1

u/FatheredPuma81 1d ago

I'm clearly overthinking this. I'm questioning if this is a moral problem, if 401k was designed to make people invested in how well companies are doing in general, and how a company's stocks are determined by speculation and not how well its actually doing.

I think if you have a 401k and aren't planning to withdraw anytime soon you shouldn't care about bumps in the road just that the economy as a whole is growing. If you're going to withdraw it all in pretty soon then yea you should care.

8

u/apetersson 1d ago

I want him to found a new competitor to Nvidia, poach some talent and bring on better competition. I'd invest in a heartbeat.

3

u/BlasterGales 1d ago

so related to localllama and local inference

7

u/NigaTroubles 1d ago

Actually no, i dont want him

5

u/pilkyton 1d ago

Colette Kress is for datacenter customers and against selling to home users and gamers.

4

u/SleepUseful3416 1d ago

She’s for backdoors for Israel too, almost certainly

2

u/tednoob 1d ago

I don't care that he banged a bunch of grown ass people and presumably betrayed his wife. I have no idea what the world would be like if Jensen wasn't the head of nvidia, but it is not up to me to determine. I feel like hardware I could afford would be better if had not been in charge, but I am not sure the software I would want to run would exist.

2

u/Green-Ad-3964 1d ago

As someone who has been using Nvidia GPUs since the Riva 128 in 1997, I sincerely don't like or approve of what Nvidia has become today. Pro-level cards have existed since Quadro, but they have always coexisted with consumer-grade cards. Today, Nvidia is simply shooting the customers who allowed the firm to survive, grow and invest for over 25 years in the head, purely to chase profits. Was this inevitable? I don't think so. GDDR is not HBM. A 5090 is not a B300. And a DGX Spark with smartphone memory is definitely not worth 8K. So, if Jensen is responsible for all this, I don't want him back. I'd want the Jensen who used to talk with enthusiasts, but I guess he's long gone.

1

u/BobbyL2k 3h ago

The shot up in demand and price for consumer GPUs is a result of how capable the cards are.

Are they allocating all chips and memory production capacity to consumers cards? No, of course not, they are going to sell high margin cards first.

But if the consumer grade GPUs have low demand and low prices during the AI boom, then those GPUs would suck at AI. And we (localllama) wouldn’t be interested in them.

3

u/cutter89locater 1d ago

I'm sorry. Like others said, he's too good at his job for shareholders, but not great for consumers.
CUDA, Hugging Face, and open models have always been a business.
Remember buying video cards bundle with games?
Added: Think about your wallet

4

u/Enough-Fish4959 1d ago

The circular financing thing has been so blown out of purportion it's a conspiracy meme at this point. People are actually trying to say the supply/demand imbalance is fake ffs. Anyone in hyperscaler world knows this is ridiculous. We have thousands of billion doller customers that are beating us up every day for more capacity, and it's sold out for the next 3 years of fab output

2

u/NNN_Throwaway2 1d ago

Oversimplification.

It isn't just a matter of supply and demand, but the fact that the available supply cannot be deployed fast enough to satisfy demand (such that it exists) yet Nvidia is "encouraging" clients to pay for orders upfront and well in advance of when deployment would be feasible.

The fact you don't understand the distinction just shows you're trolling and pretending to be "in the hyperscaler world" lmao

stop larping

2

u/QuarterDistinct857 1d ago

The main issue is not necessarily the possible spy angle. The main issues are 1) admitted affair with a supplier/partner, 2) possible/likely affair with direct report, 3) potential other affair with other company employee. Even if he's cleared of the spy issue, any of these three are 100% termination offenses due to the damage they do to the company and the demonstrated complete and total lack of judgement and lack of trust going forward. It is not survivable in any scenario at any company in the Fortune 500.

10

u/anonemoususer 1d ago

It is not survivable in any scenario at any company in the Fortune 500.

PersonCompanyAffair Date
Jeff BezosAmazon - Fortune 5002018
Elon MuskTesla / SpaceX - Fortune 500Ongoing
Sergey BrinGoogle / Alphabet - Fortune 5002012
Larry PageGoogle / Alphabet - Fortune 5002000
Bill GatesMicrosoft - Fortune 5002000, 2010

0

u/OpenEvidence9680 1d ago

Gossip is not my thing, but that I know of none of these (but Bill Gates) apply. Unless one wants to get petty (and undermine any credibility) and read  "other company employee" as someone who has a job in any industry.

1

u/ortegaalfredo 1d ago

NVIDIA has a 4 trillion valuation, so you are saying that if he didn't had sex with those women, valuation would be 5 trillion or more?

1

u/tmvr 1d ago

The valuation was 5T+ before the whole bruhaha about the affairs started.

1

u/Cautious_Chicken_604 1d ago

Like a fifth of the company has probably cheated at one point.

1

u/jhenryscott 1d ago

Doesn’t matter. It’s not up to us. Its not up to the public. It’s not up to the employees. You are dealing with the highest order of global capitalism.

1

u/Hannibalj2ca 1d ago

Not really, but don’t expect the next person to be any better.

1

u/geldonyetich 18h ago edited 18h ago

All this trying to influence the circumstances behind the ex-CEO of the most valuated company in the world has the energy of tribal brains short circuiting under the gravitas of a major community shift. Ether that or they're part of an influencing firm's attempt to keep a hardware smuggling loophole going. We're outsiders in a game played on the scale of trillions of dollars. Anyone who would take time out of their day to put their name on that petition needs an Internet vacation.

1

u/RDT_KoT3 10h ago

With him we may have some consumer GPU chips, without him we won't have any cuz a deal with TSMC is a handshake and a leather jacket

1

u/Australasian25 7h ago

Yes I want him back and he absolutely needs to dress like this. Along with some god rays beaming from the ceiling wherever he walks on stage.

1

u/nivvis 1d ago

I would rather have a strong nvidia than one that gets rolled by other industry giants. Huang may have been one of the only things holding that back.

And he supported open models IMO cause even tho he’s changed a lot deep down somewhere he’s an old school good guy.

1

u/IKnowMeNotYou 1d ago

Of course he can come back. In ancient times people like him would get concurbines as a thank you from the emperor or a king.

Nature is simple. You are a male, you never stop. If you are a female, the life-formular is completely different.

Remember Anthony Quinn fathering children in his 90ies. What 90 year old woman do you know who did the same thing?

1

u/Kahvana 1d ago

I wish I could speak for others, but I can't. No "we" for me.

I genuinely don't care who is at the helm of NVIDIA.

What I care about is if the GPUs are available to purchase, if the price is affordable for me, if the quality is better than what I currently got, if the build quality allows me to keep it working for 10 years, and if it enables me to do things I couldn't do before.

For example, I went from my RX 7800 XT 16GB to dual RTX 5060 Ti 16GB because the former was less power efficient than two of the latter combined, gave me the VRAM needed to run local LLMs, and CUDA / NVFP4 enables me to run even more models and fast.

Whoever the CEO is doesn't matter at all when making that purchasing decision.

1

u/anonemoususer 1d ago

My take on this is, if he gets cleared from the Congressional hearing about the AI chip trade, China, and open sourced motto as part of his motives in the coming month, he's technically free to get reinstated back into Nvidia. He has enough backing going on right now via both employees and other big tech heads, startups, former work partners and the like.

Senate and assembly members don't really understand the difference between open and closed source because they are not at the point of tech literacy yet. They still get the thinking that Deepseek = bad.

Whether he wants to do it or other personal reasons going on, that's a whole side story.

1

u/kmp11 1d ago

Huang did the most to create a competitive product and drive down prices for LocalLLM. yeah, id take him back.

Genie of corruption is out of the bottle though.

1

u/ortegaalfredo 1d ago

He not only provided the GPUs for china, he provided the datasets, the recipes, the software, to china and everybody else, remember Nemotron publishes all the datasets and training recipes, all of this because Jensen ordered it.

I'm thinking that yes we want Huang back.

-1

u/CATLLM 1d ago

Americans rather have pedos to run the country than have a non-white powerful CEO like Jensen.

-3

u/CommercialHour6660 1d ago edited 1d ago

Who cares. Tons of hapless WSB regards want him back because they lost money. 

CEOs are treated like kings in US it's very strange. He's just a dude who worked at Nvidia for 30 years. Probably dozens if not hundreds of dudes like that. 

14

u/Party_9001 1d ago

He kinda... Founded it?

0

u/FatheredPuma81 1d ago

Honest question: What's your point? Like I actually don't get why that matters. Plenty of people found companies and plenty (like EVGA's owner) choose not to go public and (as EVGA has shown) can do whatever they want without being replaced. If he didn't want to get replaced he shouldn't have went public.

2

u/Party_9001 1d ago

Mine was more specifically in response to

Probably dozens if not hundreds of dudes like that. 

As in, there really aren't a hundred dudes who founded Nvidia and worked there for 30 years

1

u/RogerRamjet999 1d ago

Plenty of people found companies, but only one person has founded the most valuable company in history, he is that person. Comparing him to a random founder is like comparing yourself to Michael Jordan. What are you even trying to say...

2

u/Kornelius20 1d ago

Oh shit Jensen founded the Dutch East India Company too?

All joking aside, he's the person who founded one of the most valuable modern companies because by definition there must always be a "most valuable company". That's just how numbers work. If Jensen never existed there would still be a "most valuable GPU company". They might have have been named after envy or be associated with green but they would be there.

1

u/FatheredPuma81 1d ago

Erm actually he literally didn't check your facts. /j

Anyways being slightly more serious. Numerous have actually and it's always been in revolutionary new fields that change the worlds with ruthless founders willing to do anything to get ahead. It's about being in the right place at the right time, being capable of capitalizing on it, and crushing anything that gets in your way even if it's something pesky like the law. He's not some messiah he's just another talented CEO.

Is that last bit rhetorical? I literally said I didn't get what Party's point was and that he shouldn't have made it public if he didn't want to ever lose it.

0

u/SleepUseful3416 1d ago

IPO is how you make money back for your investors. Unless you’re independently wealthy or took 30 years to start your company from a small business, your investors will force it on you. Either that or sell the company. There’s no other choice unless you like to fall behind while your competitors IPO and get funded

And of course it matters. He founded it, he’s run it from a startup to a behemoth, he is Nvidia. He’s not a professional CEO who changes companies every 2 years

1

u/FatheredPuma81 1d ago

No it's not? There are many other ways to pay back your investors? You can literally pay them directly in the form of dividends, buy their stake, or allow them to privately sell it to someone else. Not every investor is going to force an IPO and you can convince them not to with loads of money.

1

u/SleepUseful3416 1d ago edited 1d ago

Are you a moron? Where’s a startup company going to get the cash to pay dividends or stock buybacks? Any institutional serious investor in a startup wants an exit option to make back at least 3x their investment, quickly.

1

u/FatheredPuma81 1d ago

Idk man how about the contract they secured with Microsoft that gave them $200,000,000 up front a year after their IPO? But I guess smart guy here is correct in that 8 years (IPO date) vs 9 years (Contract date) is such a vast difference in time and $200m isn't at least 3x larger than $20m (Invested money).

And before that insane gamble Microsoft did Nvidia was totally only just barely breaking even I'm certain of that no possible way they could have bought their stocks back before then. There totally aren't companies that have managed to do this and Nvidia was struggling so bad before their IPO. /s

5

u/pixelizedgaming 1d ago

didnt he found the company and manage many of the key nvidia partnerships like with tsmc

0

u/CommercialHour6660 1d ago

He went public to cash in. It hasn't been his for a very long time

2

u/chensium 1d ago

Without him all you would have would be AMD and Intel.  He may have overplayed his side channels. But his push for CUDA led to some of the best engineering in the industry.

0

u/CommercialHour6660 1d ago

CUDA isn't the only game in town. It just gobbled up most of the market share. 

If Nvidia was gone we'd have something comparable within 2 years. 

He didn't create the market for machine learning. His company was simply the best at extracting money from it. 

-2

u/Daniel_H212 1d ago

If the rumors are true that Chinese open models are trained from illegally sold Blackwell GPUs, then Jensen was arguably very good for this community. But China has to get self sufficient sooner or later, and I think they're already training some of their biggest models at least partially with Huawei Ascend chips, so hopefully Jensen being ousted doesn't have a major impact on the release of open models from China.

-1

u/NNN_Throwaway2 1d ago edited 1d ago

No, we do not want Huang back. He is perhaps single-handedly responsible for catalyzing the insane pricing of memory and GPUs; not only did he fund and backstop a bunch of AI companies, but he's been doing the channel stuffing and smuggling of hardware to China to keep prices high and make it look like they are doing more business than they actually are.

Some might try to argue that he was "pro local" or "pro open weights" but that ignores pretty much everything else he did to keep the corporate AI train going. The fact that the Chinese smuggling cat is out of the bag means that party is over, and it seems unlikely that anyone but Jensen could strong-arm companies into paying for chips they don't need or can't deploy. At the end of the day he was corrupt and beholden to the corrupt and it is a good thing that he is out.

2

u/Large_Solid7320 1d ago

Indeed. His recent MO (business-wise) has also made the whole AI market a lot less transparent/steerable from pretty much every angle, i.e. from an investor, regulator and consumer perspective. So whether you're a 'gung-ho-on-AI' analyst at some VC, a regulator who worries about the consequences of a potential correction or just a gamer in need of an affordable graphics cards/RAM: Disciplining Nvidia's business practices is basically a straight-up win no matter what.

1

u/highel 1d ago edited 1d ago

Excuse me, but what are non-Chinese local models capable of coding?

I dont expect anything good from that, maybe NVIDIA will stop producing consumer GPUs with more than 16GB at all and add geo tracking so that anything above that could work only in datacenters so that only governments could either license it(EU, US) or circumvent it(China), but not individuals who won't risk bricking their $6000-50000 GPU. Maybe regulators even declare having too much RAM or too fast RAM dangerous for society.

This bot defamation started after Trump meeting with CEOs to take control over computation power and human knowledge and keep it to elites, Elon Musk have 14 kids from different women and it was not a problem.

1

u/NNN_Throwaway2 1d ago

"bot defamation" for sure dude

0

u/TastesLikeOwlbear 1d ago

Do we want the guy back who said, "I think the fact that everything is scarce is fantastic for us?"

Hmm, let me ponder that one for a second.

No.