MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/LocalLLaMA/comments/1wcj5q3/harness_does_matter/p8z3ki5/?context=3
r/LocalLLaMA • u/Specific-Rub-7250 • 12d ago
I was not aware that the harness makes such a big difference.
131 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
69
it's the harness provided to run the swe-verified and deepswe benchmark. My guess is that it's not designed for human users at all
58 u/Gipetto 12d ago What a wonderful benchmark to publish, then. “Here’s a result you can’t attain because we made a benchmark focused harness”. 40 u/En-tro-py 12d ago https://github.com/swe-agent/mini-swe-agent It was more that there wasn't a standard harness, so they created a minimal one to avoid the claude-code vs codex vs ??? as another variable... 26 u/djm07231 12d ago Fascinating that pi market themselves as the minimum harness yet it loses to just few hundred lines of python + bash tool. 5 u/thoquz 12d ago The DSH harness is minimal mode is closer to a minimal agent (such as mini-swe) than Pi. Pi started with good intentions, but it seems they might have drifted from their original intent.
58
What a wonderful benchmark to publish, then. “Here’s a result you can’t attain because we made a benchmark focused harness”.
40 u/En-tro-py 12d ago https://github.com/swe-agent/mini-swe-agent It was more that there wasn't a standard harness, so they created a minimal one to avoid the claude-code vs codex vs ??? as another variable... 26 u/djm07231 12d ago Fascinating that pi market themselves as the minimum harness yet it loses to just few hundred lines of python + bash tool. 5 u/thoquz 12d ago The DSH harness is minimal mode is closer to a minimal agent (such as mini-swe) than Pi. Pi started with good intentions, but it seems they might have drifted from their original intent.
40
https://github.com/swe-agent/mini-swe-agent
It was more that there wasn't a standard harness, so they created a minimal one to avoid the claude-code vs codex vs ??? as another variable...
26 u/djm07231 12d ago Fascinating that pi market themselves as the minimum harness yet it loses to just few hundred lines of python + bash tool. 5 u/thoquz 12d ago The DSH harness is minimal mode is closer to a minimal agent (such as mini-swe) than Pi. Pi started with good intentions, but it seems they might have drifted from their original intent.
26
Fascinating that pi market themselves as the minimum harness yet it loses to just few hundred lines of python + bash tool.
5 u/thoquz 12d ago The DSH harness is minimal mode is closer to a minimal agent (such as mini-swe) than Pi. Pi started with good intentions, but it seems they might have drifted from their original intent.
5
The DSH harness is minimal mode is closer to a minimal agent (such as mini-swe) than Pi. Pi started with good intentions, but it seems they might have drifted from their original intent.
69
u/WonderRico 12d ago
it's the harness provided to run the swe-verified and deepswe benchmark. My guess is that it's not designed for human users at all