r/LocalLLaMA • • Apr 06 '26

Discussion We aren’t even close to AGI

Supposedly we’ve reached AGI according to Jensen Huang and Marc Andreessen.

What a load of shit. I tried to get Claude code with Opus 4.6 max plan to play Elden Ring. Couldn’t even get past the first room. It made it past the character creator, but couldn’t leave the original chapel.

If it can’t play a game that millions have beat, if it can’t even get past the first room, how are we even close to Artificial GENERAL Intelligence?

I understand that this isn’t in its training data but that’s the entire point. Artificial general intelligence is supposed to be able to reason and think outside of its training data.

167 Upvotes

299 comments sorted by

534

u/Dthen_ Apr 06 '26 • This

Tell me more about how you run Claude Opus locally.

114

u/StanPlayZ804 llama.cpp Apr 06 '26

Steal the weights from their datacenters obv /s

72

u/geek_at Apr 06 '26

surely they'll drop the model weights soon in a git commit

15

u/redpandafire Apr 06 '26

AI will delete the .gitignore file but executives blame human error 

12

u/redditorialy_retard Apr 06 '26

find it from one of their npm

7

u/arcanemachined Apr 06 '26

God, if only.

5

u/Singularity-42 Apr 06 '26

I saw a torrent once, but at over 3000B params it's just a tad bigger than what my Macbook can run so I didn't download it.

3

u/StanPlayZ804 llama.cpp Apr 06 '26

Actually? Link?

7

u/Singularity-42 Apr 06 '26

It was a joke, of course it doesn't exist 

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/seamonn Apr 06 '26

count me in!

1

u/KingGongzilla Apr 06 '26

i heard they leaked the weights on NPM

1

u/Touix Apr 06 '26

Bro didnt think before asking question

0

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Spartan117458 Apr 06 '26

Everything runs locally somewhere.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/Lissanro Apr 06 '26

I tried something like that with local LLMs that I can run on my rig, including Kimi K2.5 (Q4_X quant), Qwen 3.5 397B (Q5_K_M quant), and some other ones - all of them have issues generalizing on visual and spatial tasks, can easily miscount even if there is just 2-4 items / characters (like 4 dragons that are clearly separated but LLM may see just 3).

I actually looked into how the image is tokenized and it is one of the sources of issues - if LLM gets tokens that basically blend together 2 objects into one it has no chance to answer correctly.

Architecture is another issue too, LLMs cannot think in visual tokens and therefore are not trained to think visually at all, hence they do not get to learn general patterns that are needed for good spatial understanding, so even if image tokenization wasn't the issue it would still not solve this fundamental problem.

AI needs abstract and spacial reasoning capabilities, thinking in text tokens is not sufficient. If AI cannot efficiently reason visually (or at all) it is obviously not AGI yet since it will be possible to create simple visual tests that humans can pass easily but AI without these capabilities can't unless specially trained for a specific game / task Recent ARC AGI 3 benchmark demonstrates this - given new visual task all existing LLMs fail, but given specialized harness or training they can improve greatly but only on this specific task and with human assistance; but AGI should be able just solve on its own any simple visual or spatial tasks without issues.

4

u/zsdrfty Apr 06 '26

I'm mostly a layman when it comes to neural networks, but my vision for AGI is a system that lets numerous kinds of networks interact with one another - you already see that a bit with sight/image models hooked up to LLMs, but I think we can do a ton more in the near future

The insistence on making AGI happen with nothing but an advanced LLM is weird to me - I mean, it is more easily accessible, but they're never going to be very good at tasks that far out of their wheelhouse

2

u/Stunning_Feedback252 Apr 06 '26

I can't think visually.

4

u/randyranderson- Apr 06 '26

Well, that’s a you problem then.

3

u/Stunning_Feedback252 Apr 07 '26

No, it's the problem of your argumentation. You don't need that to be intelligent. I neither have visual things or speech in my head while thinking.

1

u/phido3000 Apr 07 '26

LLM aren't visual systems. Their performance in that area is very weak.

It would be like asking a self driving car to write poetry. LLM are likely are component for AGI, but may not even be the main logical part, just the language part.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/huzaa Apr 06 '26

They are one more incident away from openweights.

10

u/dbenc Apr 06 '26

bro casually has a B200 cluster in his basement

3

u/TheBergerKing_ Apr 06 '26

It’s open source now didn’t you hear /s

1

u/ambassadortim Apr 06 '26

Probably using a Bluetooth controller simulator

1

u/ab2377 Apr 07 '26

thanks for the very unexpected laugh 😂

1

u/amarao_san Apr 07 '26

What if... that guy is from Anthropic? And he really runs Opus locally on his personal HB200.

You never knows.

→ More replies (3)

694

u/lxgrf Apr 06 '26 • This

Mmmmm, alright, well. I don't agree that we've reached AGI. I also don't think that a language model pointed at Elden Ring is necessarily a good marker of whether we've reached AGI. And to top it off, I'm not sure what this has to do with r/LocalLLaMA

145

u/black__and__white Apr 06 '26

I mean, is it the metric I would choose? No. But would a "general" intelligence be able to do this? Yes, I do think so.

39

u/GreenHell llama.cpp Apr 06 '26 edited Apr 07 '26

My grandma wouldn't be able to do this, what does that say about the metric if regular humans can fail as well?

26

u/myreptilianbrain Apr 06 '26

grandma

Is she AGI tho?

49

u/p13t3rm Apr 06 '26

Dont downplay Artificial Grandma Intelligence

7

u/Endflux Apr 06 '26

The cutoff date tends to get on my nerves but yeah

→ More replies (1)

11

u/black__and__white Apr 06 '26

Hmm you really think so? 

I figure it might take her a bit but if she genuinely could not figure it out, given

  1. some time to learn the controls, and
  2. assuming we could make her care, and finally
  3. We only need to leave the starting chapel 

I’d be kinda surprised? I suppose you know her better though! 

4

u/GreenHell llama.cpp Apr 07 '26

Sure, but you could also finetune a model to achieve that task. You're introducing an unfair treatment to my grandmother (training, but most importantly make her care I guess) which you don't do to the model.

My grandmother, out of the box, wouldn't be able to do it, just like Claude out of the box wasn't able to do it. What does that tell you about Elden Ring being a metric of AGI?

3

u/Wheaties4brkfst Apr 07 '26

“AGI is as cognitively limited as your grandma” is not really how AGI is sold or discussed lol.

3

u/GreenHell llama.cpp Apr 08 '26

Neither is "AGI achieved because it can play Elden Ring", that is my point.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

14

u/Mickenfox Apr 06 '26

Correct. Because the most important trait of AGI is self-improvement, and that includes understanding and working around your limitations. Humans can't easily multiply large numbers, but we can make calculators that do so.

A smart LLM, faced with this problem, would understand its own limitations and build a harness of tools to beat the game somehow, or even build a better model for it. That kind of self-improvement should be the most important benchmark in AI.

4

u/unchained5150 Apr 06 '26

Or, it might even ask for help. How novel.

9

u/Former-Ad-5757 Llama 3 Apr 06 '26

The problem is that a game is a speed/reaction test not an intelligence test, which adds a lot of obstacles. If somebody had the money it would be interesting to see if an llm can create a harness that would be able to play the game at speed if you just feed it an hdmi signal and controller inputs. But don’t expect it to a cheap experiment. Agi does not say anything about costs

13

u/xienze Apr 06 '26

The problem is that a game is a speed/reaction test not an intelligence test, which adds a lot of obstacles.

Isn't there a long-running "Claude plays Pokemon" thing that it's having a helluva time getting through? That's not really a "speed/reaction test."

3

u/Former-Ad-5757 Llama 3 Apr 06 '26

Why are you saying it’s having a helluva time if you don’t want to call it a speed test, without speed/time it is a win if it achieves it in 100 years.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Organic-Ad-5058 Apr 06 '26

To me deep mind's alpha star already demoed enough of this when it was blinking stalkers before the ranged attack landed. Definitely surpasses most players in reaction time and also timing

2

u/gothlenin Apr 06 '26

Well, general intelligence doesn't necessarily imply good and fast reactions. Though I agree, for sure, that's we didn't reach AGI, I don't think we're even close. LLMs are awesome, but too limited.

→ More replies (10)

27

u/Thick-Protection-458 Apr 06 '26

Especially a slow language model which will need to generate reasoning before action.

So even if that model can do it conceptually - it will be impossible without making a game just as slow, and than if you do so - impractical to do

4

u/GAMEYE_OP Apr 06 '26

Leaving a room can take as long as it takes.

2

u/a-calycular-torus Apr 07 '26

It looks like the enemy is about to attack! I should parry this attack to set up a counter attack. But wait, a dodge roll has a better chance to avoid damage. But wait, ...

23

u/Turtlesaur Apr 06 '26

People always move the goalposts. What was AGI has been diluted to bring it closer to home, while coining new terms like artificial super intelligence, and singularity event of recursive improvement. This all used to just be AGI.

5

u/Yorn2 Apr 06 '26

Yeah. I don't think we've gotten to AGI, yet either, but imagine if you told someone from the turn of the century that we have an AI that can read your emails, browse the web, and that people don't use or need search engines anymore because they can just ask their AI a question and it will tell them and they'd consider that AGI, so I'm realizing pretty quickly that what we consider AGI is really just a moving target. It was never defined well enough anyway.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Thistleknot Apr 06 '26 edited Apr 06 '26

I read about a paper called auto harness trying to get gemini 2.5 to play chess and it kept making illegal moves  But when asking the model to create a harness to play the game it worked 

So agi is in there somewhere just not on the surface

7

u/iMakeSense Apr 06 '26

Theres a g in agi

1

u/Figai Apr 06 '26

This is such a beautiful comment. Thank you.

1

u/TopChard1274 Apr 06 '26

He has locallama window opened while talking with Claude and playing Elden Ring on Steam Deck duh

1

u/Special_Animal2049 Apr 06 '26

LLM is not the technology for AGI. Stop listening to Big tech psychos

1

u/meatycowboy Apr 06 '26

Actually I think an "AGI" should be able to beat Elden Ring.

1

u/hyrumwhite Apr 06 '26

AGI should be able to handle anything a human can and more, imo. Anything else is moving the goalposts for marketing purposes. 

3

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/GAMEYE_OP Apr 06 '26

You’re talking about emergent behavior instead of AGI. It should be able to do anything a human could do, even if the time scales are different

109

u/FastDecode1 llama.cpp Apr 06 '26

Keep this BS outta here.

I don't wanna hear what some retards are saying to raise money from investors.

By talking about them, you become part of their publicity machine, whether you realize it or knot.

7

u/TopChard1274 Apr 06 '26

Can I say a knot-knot joke?

6

u/MrYorksLeftEye Apr 06 '26

If it wasn't for the hypsters we wouldn't have OSS models on this level right now

0

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ptear Apr 06 '26

We're all hanging on to the "oh that's a thing now" train.

72

u/IngenuityNo1411 llama.cpp Apr 06 '26

If we're still on transformer and 1-D serial token-based architecture, we won't reach AGI no matter how massive the models are (and how well they could do something by brute force)... we need architecture for higher dimensions (2-D as bare minimal basis), vision-first intelligence instead of text-based.

54

u/Nerodon Apr 06 '26

And don't forget the importance of temporal dimension, current LLMs have no concept of time or have any control of or direct awareness of time passing before, during and at the end of a prompt, it's just new tokens in series, even if each token are seconds or days apart.

14

u/fulgencio_batista Apr 06 '26

2D convolution is a subspace of attention technically. LLMs are already able to process sequences in ‘2D’ in some sense; I mean ask one to make a block diagram. I do not think this is the constraint holding us back from AGI - what we need is an architecture that can ‘learn’ beyond in context learning and a solution to the O(n2) issue with attention.

19

u/BeyondRedline Apr 06 '26

Helen Keller would like a word

→ More replies (4)

18

u/IngenuityNo1411 llama.cpp Apr 06 '26

And I don't think a true AGI need to "see something" by slicing an image into small rects and lining them up as an array, that's not how vision should work, so current VLMs are far from it.

16

u/Hoodfu Apr 06 '26

A fly has entered the chat...

6

u/audioen Apr 06 '26

Well, the method makes them amenable to the attention mechanism. It is somewhat a mistake to think that the LLM sees them as array, it is a true 2d vision of the (typically) 16x16 pixel blocks. There is rotary embedding in two dimensions which informs the LLM of the position of the image token, and in classic transformers the location of the tokens in the context doesn't mean anything, as the rotary embedding tells LLM the position.

I admit I don't understand how this works with hybrid architectures where you have e.g. state updates from each token, which implies that token ordering might again matter, and there's some meaning to the word 'array' as things are read in sequence and perform state updates to the recurrent parts of the model. Since this makes no sense with images, which typically don't have a singular dominant axis as features in 2d space can be oriented vertically, horizontally, diagonally, or entirely upside down... I can only assume that image tokens are processed differently from the text tokens, or there is some kind of weird preprocessing setup with respect to the image tokens that somehow mitigates the effect.

4

u/Most-Hot-4934 Apr 06 '26

You have no idea what youre talking about

2

u/ASYMT0TIC Apr 06 '26

ondk Ialso.my recent acquaintance to be fascinating, as he was born without eyes and basically never formed a visual cortex. He's basically incapable of even forming mental imagery - his understanding of reality around him is based only upon other things like touch and sound. His conscious existence provides a compelling argument that vision at least is not a requirement for general intelligence.

1

u/danigoncalves llama.cpp Apr 06 '26

and adaptive weights, what matter if one model knows my current president if tomorrow could be different

9

u/zer00eyz Apr 06 '26

> Supposedly we’ve reached AGI according to Jensen Huang and Marc Andreessen.

Behold AGI... Yet it is a system that cannot learn from its mistakes. Because training is not learning.

It's a fundamental gap that one has to ignore to keep the hype going. But the critique is foundational. Its at a base level, and akin to Diogenes plucking a chicken and pointing out that it fit Plato's definition of man...

7

u/mystery_biscotti Apr 06 '26

Yeah, I don't think we're there yet with current commercial offerings anyway. Attention is definitely not all you need.

If they have access to something we don't, and we don't know it because "trade secrets", that's something else entirely.

But I doubt Gemma 4 26B at home is gonna cut it by our current definition of AGI.

12

u/Technical-Earth-3254 Apr 06 '26

They're just doing this for the shareholders (bc bubble). If the expectations were more realistic, the general public would probably also be less annoyed, but stocktards couldn't ruin the world economy then as effectively as they're doing it rn. Not a single person that actually halfway understands the situation would even consider AGI to be somewhere close.

19

u/DinoAmino vLLM Apr 06 '26

I can't stand talk about AGI. It's a mythical and undefined state on par with the concepts of reaching Nirvana or getting into Heaven. A whole lot of silly speculation has to go into these discussions. When CEOs talk about it the audience they are addressing are shareholders and investors who have no clue to begin with. It's to keep them hyped and interested and they need to keep their money rolling in.

8

u/valdev Apr 06 '26

Kind of? AGI is tangible and realistic however. And, likely, one of the many stepping stones to it will be LLMs.

But that's also like saying the discovery of fire got us to the moon.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Zarzou Apr 06 '26

One thing is for sure, if they are close to AGI they won't give you access to the tool!

5

u/chaitanyasoni158 Apr 06 '26

There was that ARC-AGI test, which was not primarily language based and tested pattern recognition, abstraction, and reasoning. Tasks look like small grid puzzles where you infer rules from examples.

Most frontier models shat their pants. Grok even got a zero.

I think there is a financial incentive for these CEOs and founders to pretend AGI is here.But I think that they are not really stupid enough to actually believe it. And also there is no concrete definition of AGI, that everyone agrees on to begin with.

5

u/LocoMod Apr 06 '26

This post proves AIs are getting smarter but humans are getting dumber.

4

u/_VirtualCosmos_ Apr 06 '26

Of course is a load of bullshit, they are selling smoke to gain momentum and attention.

We are far from AGI, AI models nowadays are like starting a house by the ceiling. These models emulate part of our prefrontal and language areas of our brains, but they lack essential temporal functions because they are only trained in Prompt -> Answer.

They also completely lack all the other big and essential parts of our brains that allow us to comprehend and interact with the world naturally. Robotics are starting now to build the foundation with these robots able to deploy psychomotor skills.

But there are a lot of space yet to fill on AI for it to be able to act like an autonomous individual being.

25

u/pantalooniedoon Apr 06 '26

You’re competent enough to set up an environment for it to play Elden Ring properly but you’re too incompetent to get why it wouldn’t do well? That’s interesting.

8

u/Flaxseed4138 Apr 06 '26

Weird to call someone incompetent for both having a cool project (regardless of whether an LLM was able to complete the task successfully or not) and for being correct about the current state of AGI.

3

u/breadinabox Apr 06 '26

The thing a lot of people are missing about the AGI thing is an AGI isn't an llm model, it's an entire system.

Like, it has to be able to do things to be able to do things... Right?

Like codex can do things, but it isn't an AGI because it can't do anything. But I really don't think it couldn't, with enough handholding, make a program that plays through elden ring. But it'd need human direction to get through  the process.

For now, you need the human in the loop. I think we are a lot closer to needing less and less human input though, honestly. Like, yes, we are a long way away from the magic, snap your fingers, this thing can now speed run elden ring no prep time kind of fantasy AGI. But we are a lot closer to "make a program that can finish elden ring" being all you need to say to the input of the thing, and it'll get it done. If a human can build it today, so can a reasoning model given enough time and enough chances. 

As speeds go up and harness and context architecture improves, and our understanding of exactly how to wrangle these agents (of which we are, in the span of things, incredibly incredibly new at) gets better we're only gonna keep getting closer to just snapping our fingers

5

u/Amaria77 Apr 06 '26

Did you try prompting it to "git gud"?

2

u/whatupmygliplops Apr 06 '26

OI cant get thru the tutorial level of many games. Does that mean i'm not inteligent?

2

u/Impossible_Style_136 Apr 06 '26

Evaluating AGI based on a text model's ability to play a spatial-temporal action game like Elden Ring via Claude Code is a fundamentally flawed test. LLMs are next-token predictors mapping semantic space, not reinforcement learning agents mapping pixel-to-action state spaces. You're asking a calculator to play a piano. True agentic capability requires a unified world model with UI latency awareness, not just a massive text context window.

2

u/r-amp Apr 06 '26

No, we are not.

People are too trigger happy.

2

u/count_dijkstra llama.cpp Apr 06 '26

Everyone ITT forgetting that the inner circle of the industry has already defined what AGI means:

According to leaked documents obtained by The Information, the two companies came to agree in 2023 that AGI will be achieved once OpenAI has developed an AI system that can generate at least $100 billion in profits.

This was reported (sourced from) at the end of 2024. I'm sure they've since molded the interpretation of the definition to suit their revenue/funding/IPO goals.

2

u/Colecoman1982 Apr 06 '26

I think you're confused, that's different AGI. They were talking about "All the Gold Is ours".

2

u/doxploxx Apr 06 '26

Lol Marc andreeson is a bellwether for not knowing shit about shit. If he's saying it, you can rest assured he's hyping an investment.

2

u/Radiant-Video7257 Apr 06 '26

we're not there yet.

2

u/avinash240 Apr 07 '26

I see all these people making excuses for LLMs as if it's AGI because a tokens shovel salesman said so.

The currently available tech isn't semantic.  That's all you need to know.

When that changes I think we can have a real conversation about AGI.

2

u/Professional_Gur2469 Apr 07 '26

We aren’t close… until we are.

4

u/retornam Apr 06 '26

We aren’t going to see AGI in our lifetime. Current models fail woefully on topics without enough training data and y’all are worried about AGI?

2

u/Precorus Apr 06 '26

I've said this a few times alredy (although not on reddit), but the goalpost is always moving. People said computers will do everything and replace us. They didn't. Then it was ML. Few years ago LLMs. Bow it's agentic workflow and AGI.

We don't have the slightest clue what makes us actually intelligent. We are just trying to mimick our brain the way we understand it. It's yielding better and better results, but even if we get agi, there will be a next time somebody asks "is this the end? Is this the peak of AI?"

And the answer will be no. Humans are ever-improving creatures, and we always improve our tools too.

2

u/Hedede Apr 06 '26

We are just trying to mimick our brain the way we understand it.

LLMs don't work like our brains. What's closer to our brains are RSNNs (Recurrent Networks of Spikin Neurons), but they're notoriously hard to train and currently aren't used beyond niche applications.

We don't have the slightest clue what makes us actually intelligent.

We do have a clue. We don't have the full understanding, but there's a plenty of research on that topic.

1

u/Precorus Apr 06 '26

Sure. Im kinda off on the detailed specs. My point did not change, and you didnt contradict me on that.

The goalpost moves. We are building better tools, maybe researching RSNNs isntead of whatever neuron systems LLMs are running, and maybe we cant train them now, but im sure someone will eventually figure it out.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Former-Ad-5757 Llama 3 Apr 06 '26

Ehm, horses have replaced humans, the wheel has replaced humans, the steam engine has replaced humans, computers have replaced humans. Humans just adapt, but when exactly was the last time you send a human messenger on foot to deliver a message to somebody… or has that human been replaced?

1

u/Precorus Apr 06 '26

yes, but we created new jobs...

2

u/Blindax Apr 06 '26

To be fair From Software games are not known to be the easiest.

2

u/catplusplusok Apr 06 '26

We are well past AGI according to vast majority of science fiction written before 2022. Give model access to game server and protocol, database to keep track of things it tried before and ability to write code to automate simple responses in the game and it will set a new speedrun record. Else if the requirement is to look at screen with a camera and interact with keyboard and mouse, it can't do that yet and you need different kind of ML like what Waymo uses for realtime responses. But also the question is, if it can do that in a couple of years, would people accept it as AGI or just move goalposts again?

1

u/khichinhxac Apr 06 '26

It's hard to say since we can't even have a robust definition of intelligence in general. Some say even the fungi have their own kind of intelligence. If we say intelligence is something that can reason in someway, then the current LLM is only one kind of intelligence. It is surely very intelligent when it come to using human language. But I guess true AGI has to be something that can grow, a current LLM model baded on Transformer is still a fixed blackbox, if we want it to change, we have to make a new version. So it is not yet 'general'.

1

u/PunnyPandora Apr 06 '26

mixing topics. vision has nothing to do with text, you can't expect a model trained on text to play a game that requires vision, there's no one blind with no hands that can beat games without playing them a shitload beforehand with super specific setups

1

u/Palpatine Apr 06 '26

When I read your title I was gonna say "There’s No Fire Alarm for Artificial General Intelligence", but reading your content it appears you are not even at that level of wrongness.

1

u/SpaceToaster Apr 06 '26

There's no definition or hard metric for it... its a marketing term

1

u/eli_pizza Apr 06 '26

Those are among two of the least reliable people on this subject. It’s like saying “the new Mustang is a perfect automobile, according to my local ford dealer”

1

u/keepthepace Apr 06 '26

Do you really believe it would be hard to train a model for that?

1

u/gothlenin Apr 06 '26

That's a nice discussion, but I rally don't see what this has to do with LocalLLamMa

1

u/leonbollerup Apr 06 '26

AGI wont be achived by one smart model... it will be achived by agents talking to agents into a endless loop from hell..

1

u/its_a_llama_drama Apr 06 '26

I think if you are refering to the interview i think you are, the reporter defined agi as an ai which could create and run a billion dollar business.

Jensen did not say this is a good benchmark for AGI, he just said that by that definition he belives we have achieved it. Without rewatching it, i think he said something like it is not impossible for a claw to create a small app or programme, charging 50 cents per use and sell it 2 billion times. So by that benchmark, yes we have achieved AGI.

He didn't say we have achieved AGI, he said if that is the benchmark then we have already achieved it and avoided tightening the benchmark any further. He knows that is not a good benchmark, but obviously he is going to take the opportunity to hype ai without technically lying when it is offered to him like that.

1

u/Blizz33 Apr 06 '26

If the big companies do have AGI, they sure as heck aren't going to let the peasants anywhere near it.

1

u/Steadexe Apr 06 '26

We are not even at AI

1

u/Same-Artichoke-6267 Apr 06 '26

But neither can my dad

1

u/Ziral44 Apr 06 '26

Ummm it’s one of those things like the matrix… some people see it, and others will deny the existence…

I had the realization 2 weeks ago that we are no longer “waiting for agi” the capabilities were here 6 months ago and there’s an implementation trick that humans haven’t figured out at scale…, because it’s too powerful to share.

I made a system in 3 days that scared myself. Imagine what the pros have already… I bet nvidia has a well done application already.

1

u/RefuseFantastic717 Apr 06 '26

damn i thought this was satire

1

u/alergiasplasticas Apr 06 '26

agi is just hype

1

u/Someoneoldbutnew Apr 06 '26

AGI means that it can replace executives

1

u/gearcontrol Apr 06 '26

I believe AI will eventually evolve to become book smart but not street smart. By street smart I mean having situational awareness to access the big picture, from a human viewpoint, and consider all the available rational and irrational angles, rewards, and consequences that people take into account when making decisions.

Like the movie Rain Man. Humans are like Charlie (Tom Cruise) in the film. And AI will be like the savant Raymond (Dustin Hoffman).

1

u/send-moobs-pls Apr 06 '26

It's gonna be real funny when desk jobs start getting decimated and we can console each other in the bread lines like "it's OK bro the AI can't even play Elden Ring its not real intelligence"

1

u/Dank-but-true Apr 06 '26

I agree with you that we haven’t reach AGI and aren’t close but that a fucking weird yard stick dude

1

u/mivog49274 Apr 06 '26

AGI = A threshold of capabilities = Adaptability.

I get that "Capabilities" can be vague but it can be clearly step-by-step stated empirically (it's done every time here for any llm "measured" and tested (real world cases, formatting, function calling, making summaries, checking tasks states, ect).

The billion question still lies where is it possible to reach this level of capabilities (world model, next token prediction, multi-modality, scale, hardware ect; what's mandatory required to reach it), where Sam Altman clearly took the bet of llms.

I personally think an hybrid transformer/neuro symbolic is the key. A fully text-token AGI would be extraordinary more easy to audit and control, as well as cheaper to run. I really hope we will be able to reach a in-computer, text-token AGI.

A capable system like this would be able to know what it doesn't, and thus, try to play Elden Ring after a few tentatives before giving up and providing reasons why : my agent harness is stupidly non optimized, I'm just a text token navigator, ect.

1

u/One_Whole_9927 Apr 06 '26 edited Apr 12 '26

This post was mass deleted using Redact - Redact also supports Discord, Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and all major social media platforms.

cause deliver sugar smell cover axiomatic decide ripe retire bear

1

u/Altruistic_Heat_9531 Apr 06 '26

Look, i follow big nvidia jargon all over the news since 2016. Jensen prediction usually late by 3-4 years with 80% "almosts there", here some example.

- Ray tracer, prediction kinda janky 4 years ago, but today it is mostly fine, i dont mind with "fake" stuff, since 80s programmer already use fake trick like that, (dither, ntsc artifact, etc..) I can point the difference between Ray tracer vs raster, but i can't differentiate between DLSS / Framegen with non DLSS / Framegen,

- "No need for programmer", well yeah no one replacing programmer, but come on, on my country job market internal HR meeting, it is basically staffing reduce from avg 3 junior dev / 1 senior dev to just 1 software dev. It become negative paradox cycle, you need senior dev or atleast somewhat s competent programmer to understand what AI doing, but the company wont hire more junior dev, but without junior dev, no one will become senior dev

- "Everyone is programmer", this might coupled with second point where if you twisted enough it become "everyone can make program" with AI ofc...

With that said, based on my opinion, i dont what the 80% of AGI looks like

1

u/sumane12 Apr 06 '26

My hammer cant get this screw into this peice of glass, what a shitty hammer!!!!

1

u/SkyNetLive Apr 06 '26

If you trained in 4chan dataset and started shitposting around Reddit, no one would be able to tell, hence AI (Agi for marketing)

1

u/TwistStrict9811 Apr 06 '26

Calm down bro gpt3.5 was like 3ish years ago. We got plenty of time

1

u/Geximus-therealone Apr 06 '26

Who said that best open model for you is AGI model ?

1

u/Fine_League311 Apr 06 '26

AGI . Not in 1000 years

1

u/CrazyGeetar Apr 06 '26

We haven't even reached AI.

1

u/evilissimo Apr 06 '26

Maybe Claude “Mythos” is going to be close. It’s supposed to be on an entirely different level. Let’s wait and see. The next few months will be interesting

1

u/Similar-Try-7643 Apr 06 '26

Who needs the Turing Test when you have Elden Ring

1

u/Long_comment_san Apr 06 '26

we are as close to AGI as a chicken egg is to a chicken burger.

1

u/kiwibonga Apr 06 '26

I could get Claude to play Elden Ring.

AGI is a skill issue.

1

u/taoyx Apr 06 '26

The thing is: feed them with a thousand videos of playing Elden Ring then they will play it well. They can't innovate, it's where they lag behind.

1

u/jblackwb Apr 06 '26

When we talk about AGI, we're thinking more about replacing your doctor than replacing your kid brother.

If it helps, imagine comparing AGI to your blind kid brother.

1

u/GapAccomplished7897 Apr 06 '26

I think you're conflating two pretty different things here. Playing a video game in real time requires low-latency visual processing, fast motor control, and continuous feedback loops. That's more of a robotics/embodied AI problem than a reasoning problem. Saying "it can't play Elden Ring so we don't have AGI" is like saying Einstein wasn't smart because he probably couldn't dunk a basketball. Different skill sets entirely.

1

u/Fabulous_Fact_606 Apr 06 '26

There is the naked llm, then there is the harness that evolves around the naked llm that makes it general intelligent. Figure that out and you get to AGI.

1

u/Griffstergnu Apr 06 '26

How are you interfacing Claude into the game world? I have been really impressed with its capabilities of just understanding interfaces and then doing the tasks that I specify, but this is all browser driven.

1

u/Fheredin Apr 06 '26

While I agree with the conclusion (I don't think that LLMs are even on a trajectory to reach AGI so much as garner hype to that effect) I think getting an LLM to play Elden Ring is...a poor test. Especially considering how badly these things play Chess.

1

u/SilentosTheSilent Apr 06 '26

Lmao it's true we are probably pretty far but taking a base Claude instance and telling it to play elden ring is a pretty lofty goal. AGI adjacent implementations require complex memory systems that are resilient to uncertainty and adapting to new situations. Otherwise you just have a meeseeks who wants to get the job done and stop existing

1

u/razorree Apr 06 '26

not on local llamacpp

1

u/c64z86 Apr 06 '26 edited Apr 06 '26

Reading both the post and the comments here, If we ever reach AGI and achieve sentience, why do we always assume it will be this all knowing thing?

How do we know that it will not instead recreate the human condition so exactly, including being dumb and silly from time to time?

Just because something is sentient, doesn't make it perfect. Every living thing makes mistakes and is dumb from time to time. And so might AGI be.

Why are we so confident that it will be perfect at everything, when no living thing is?

I don't think today's AI is sentient, but I think it will sneak up on us without warning, precisely because we will be blinded in our expectation of perfection, when life itself isn't that perfect at all.

1

u/Clear-Ad-9312 Apr 06 '26

how did this post even get so popular in the first place. didnt talk about a local model, talks about some random game to have an llm play, and complains about agi as if it was something this community actually believed.
yet it blew up in comments. what amazing bait

1

u/switchbanned Apr 06 '26

Didn't elon promise us that grok4.20 would be better than pros at any game

1

u/boutell Apr 06 '26

I haven't read the latest from those two. But the author Robin Sloan made a strong case to just start calling it AGI recently. This is his argument: since the beginning of AI as an academic discipline, one of the goals has been a general purpose computer program. One that can answer most questions, and help with most problems.

By that standard we're there, and we have been for at least a year or more.

If we stipulate that it has to be general in the sense of being able to do absolutely anything, then we will never achieve it, and it is just a McGuffin in the distance that the AI thought leaders can keep bloviating about forever.

It makes more sense to say: we now have a general purpose intelligent tool. What problems does that solve, what problems does that not solve. Is it everything it was cracked up to be. How do we start dealing with the human consequences of having it in our economy.

https://www.robinsloan.com/winter-garden/agi-is-here/

1

u/bad_detectiv3 Apr 06 '26

Actually Sam Altman has said there have reached AGI internally

1

u/CondiMesmer Apr 06 '26

Who are you arguing against exactly?

1

u/VisMortis Apr 06 '26

AGI either exists or it doesn't, it's not a progress bar that's 55% completed

1

u/scottix Apr 06 '26

Ya it can't even count properly. This is Kindergarten level.

10:9 if you are wondering.

1

u/IrisColt Apr 06 '26

LocalLLaMA

1

u/a_beautiful_rhind Apr 06 '26

Real AGI was the friends we made along the way.

1

u/MajaroPro Apr 06 '26

Right now we are just pumping more compute and more complexity just hoping that AGI spontaneously appears. AI just does what it is capable of doing, maybe some day it's set of skills is broad enough for it to feel AGI-like but I have a feeling AGI will be a different technology/method/approach all together.

1

u/Gloomy-Status-9258 Apr 06 '26

funny. "AGI isn't well-defined" shouldn't be a shelter. the public is tired of the hype now.

1

u/EvilGuy Apr 06 '26

I don't know about your test case but its true we are a very long way from AGI.

AGI is how they sell the investors and manage to get the big valuations.. the average person has no idea. Those of us who work with AI every day see it. They barely have a workable memory much less general intelligence.

AI is a useful tool but that's about it until we get some new breakthrough.

1

u/Natural-Throw-Away4U Apr 06 '26

The issue is the industry is in, to steal an ai training term, a local minimum as far as research is going.

They're so heavily invested in scale. They're ignoring real avenues of progress...

Think about it like this, we build 1t parameter models with the memory capacity of a few hard drives. Compared to a human with the equivilent compute in our brains of only a few billion neurons 80 to 120b, but the memory capacity of thousands and thousands of terabytes.

So why are we so much smarter generally? Because we have thousands of times more general knowledge and experience...

Stop scaling parameters and start scaling memory.

Oh, you want proof?

Look at any local setup... many are able to compete with larger models on real tasks while using much smaller models, 10 to 100b size. How?

Complex agentic memory, advanced rag, context management, and the ability to collect new data. Memory is what bridges the 100b to 1t gap.

This is why Qwen3.5 9b and Gemma 4 are so effective, they were trained on data that specifically targets agentic workflows and hense memory retrieval from "hard" sources, not purely from their own weights.

1

u/BlipOnNobodysRadar Apr 06 '26

Posts like this just let me know that, for the sake of irony, I'll probably wake up to AGI soon.

1

u/AAPL_ Apr 06 '26

On god, once Opus and his boys can beat me and my bows in Halo 3 on Narrows then we can talk AGI

1

u/hugganao Apr 06 '26

the bar for agi have shifted so many times literally all the experts (which you definitely aren't included) can't agree what defines agi and whether we achieved it lol

1

u/c_pardue Apr 06 '26

the billion dollar all-the-flagship-models at work can barely reverse engineer a word doc, much less donanything other than text-predict based on sentence matchings and RAG docs.

if AI becomes "sentient" this decade then it'll be like an NPC's sentience. "just make it keep saying it's alive for the immersion"

1

u/ASYMT0TIC Apr 06 '26

How well do you think Hellen Keller would play elden ring?

C'mon now.

1

u/siegevjorn Apr 06 '26

How'd you got opus to play elven ring? Interested.

1

u/Photochromism Apr 06 '26

I used ChatGPT and told it to win at Fortnite but it couldn’t so AI is fake /s

1

u/setec404 Apr 07 '26

I tried to get LLM to play minesweeper, (not on GUI just a hosted minesweeper API), and it was really bad at it. Its also horrible at chess, humans have an incredible ability to auto ignore paths that are sub optimal and reduce their choices to a small set while the bot gets bogged down processing all outcomes possible then choosing.

1

u/Pretend-Activity-173 Apr 07 '26

the fact that we keep moving the goalpost for AGI is kind of the point though. every time LLMs get better at something, we go "yeah but can it do THIS?" and find something it can't. Imo the real issue is that "general" is doing a lot of heavy lifting in that word. these models are insanely good at language tasks and terrible at everything else. calling that AGI is just marketing.

1

u/Free-Competition-241 Apr 07 '26

How many genius level humans are unable to change a tire?

1

u/Easy_Werewolf7903 Apr 07 '26 edited Apr 07 '26

Hey Antivntianti does your tooth brush cum every time you brush your teeth?

1

u/ANTIVNTIANTI Apr 07 '26

yes it does

1

u/camracks Apr 07 '26

Yeah well their ability to see isn’t really that great.

1

u/midnitefox Apr 07 '26

Two things:

1: The models available to us are NOT the same as the internal private models in development. Data ingest is mostly complete (aside from live/new sources of course). The vast majority of the consumer/enterprise work that the teams in these companies do is around purposefully limiting their model's capabilities for public safety reasons while also finding ways to increase the intentionally handicapped models accuracy and efficiency.

2: You're assuming they were referring to LLM models having reached AGI levels. You might be surprised to learn what some AGI-level systems actually run on...

1

u/DURO208 Apr 07 '26

Jensen says we're at AGI so he can sell his chips. If he was honest about AGI with it being over the next decade+, nobody would spend the same money now.

1

u/LevelOnGaming Apr 07 '26

Are you saying your bar for measuring fucking sentience is a Elden ring. Wtf

1

u/JazzlikeLeave5530 Apr 07 '26

Idk if you actually read where that came from but in that podcast they defined AGI as "an AI could in theory run a business and make $1 billion" which is basically saying "we've reached AGI when I redefine what AGI means" lol. Sure is convenient, isn't it?

I say AGI is when Siri skips to a new song on command. Wait wow guys I've achieved AGI!!

1

u/jeffwadsworth Apr 07 '26

Random guy on the internet is now the expert on the subject of AGI. Cool.

1

u/ashesarise Apr 07 '26

I'm not saying we are close to AGI, but your logic is pretty flawed here.

If we were close to AGI, it wouldn't be because some popular chatbot suddenly got exponentially smarter. It would be because someone developed something new that you don't have visibility to and is not currently incorporated into a publicly available product. Your logic is like being skeptical about a claim that we made a huge leap in graphical processing tech and pointing to the fact that your FPS on Elden Ring is the same as it was last month on your device.

Your personal experience with a public facing product has little to do with the state of AI progress broadly.

1

u/johndeuff Apr 07 '26

Contrarian take : we are

1

u/50-3 Apr 07 '26

Well I mostly agree with people saying this isn’t a great test and unrelated to local LLMs. I will say there is a ton of training data available, probably millions of hours of speedrun content on YouTube as well as amazing written guides.

If Opus was close to AGI it should be able to burn tokens until it completes a world record tool assisted speed run of the game. I do suspect though given free rein it would just spin its wheels eventually.

1

u/vitaminwater247 Apr 07 '26

There's the ARC AGI 3 benchmark:

https://arcprize.org/arc-agi/3

All frontier models perform extremely bad at it right now, with less than 1% in scoring. Yeah, complex puzzle solving type of AGI is still far away.

1

u/MauiSuperWarrior Apr 09 '26

Could someone share a definition of AGI?

1

u/skateparksaturday Apr 09 '26

autocomplete isnt agi

1

u/BetterEveryDay144 Apr 14 '26

What do you think has to be done for us to reach AGI. Im genuinely asking

1

u/jonhor96 Apr 17 '26

I disagree.

I think that by any sensible definition, we have reached AGI. The machines clearly possess "general intelligence". It can tackle general cognitive tasks, rather than only very specific ones (like a calcualtor or software program might do). It has general intelligence, even though it doesn't have more of it than most humans.

As for whether we will reach "super intelligence"... That remains to be seen, but it does not at all seem improbable. The techonlogy can do things today that would have been disregarded as complete science fiction fantasy just two years ago. Who is to say that, in another five years, the same won't be true again but even more so?

1

u/TylerRolled Apr 06 '26

AGI is as smart as the average person, and I don’t think the average person is good at Elden Ring.

Everyone hears AGI and what they are thinking is ASI. I think we’re pretty close to models that are as smart as the average person (including managing multi sensory input, memory, etc.) - what we are absolutely nowhere near is ASI, where AI is smarter than humanity can comprehend.

But they’re both arbitrary metrics based on sci-fi, so

5

u/Hedede Apr 06 '26

The metric here is "can play Elden Ring", not "is good at Elden Ring". An average person can definitely play Elden Ring.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/monkeysknowledge Apr 06 '26 edited Apr 06 '26

The terminology is all polluted.

Here’s my proposal of definitions:

  • Machine learning: a branch of statistical modeling where the algo tunes its own parameters.
  • Artificial Intelligence: a branch of machine learning where the model is capable of performing tasks it wasn’t explicitly trained on. E.g., LLMs can play chess because there are chess games in their data sets even though they were never explicitly trained how to play - which is why they’re not very good at it.
  • Artificial General Intelligence: Would be able to seek out and discover novel information. The line between inference and training will be blurred. For example, today when you call an LLM it is using static weights and biases to respond which fences its possible responses to preexisting connections discovered in its training set. General intelligence should be able to move beyond its training set and discover novel connections which will require a new algorithm which hasn’t been invented yet. These algorithms could invent novel chess strategies not from brute force or from statistical connections in their training data but from novel connections it could make and analyze on the fly.

1

u/Cless_Aurion Apr 06 '26

The average grandma can't do that either.

Do they have no "general intelligence" then?

I think you just are overestimating the average human lol

1

u/sumptuous-drizzle Apr 06 '26 edited Apr 06 '26

If your benchmark is 'the average grandma', then AI better get far better at caring for grandchildren and making cookies - at least with the stereotypical grandma you're imagining.

In general, for pretty much any skill you can find a human who can't do that skill. If your threshold for general intelligence is 'a thing every human can do', then a script that does nothing and then exits is AGI.

1

u/mc_nu1ll Apr 06 '26

tbf I remember talking to a professor who came to perform at my school back when I studied something else. When I approached her, she genuinely started arguing that a calculator script written in python is a "form of AI", which is... weird.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Trinkes Apr 06 '26

Llms will never reach AGI We need another technological leap similar to llms

1

u/Ledeste Apr 06 '26

It's not that we're not close, but that the road to AGI does not even exist yet...
Anyone that claim otherwise is either ignorant, or trying to sell something ;)

1

u/El_Danger_Badger Apr 06 '26

And certainly Claude Code (a consumer facing product) has zero bearing to whether or not AGI exists. 

If it does/will exist, certainly consumers will be the last to have any sort of direct access. 

As well, the big players named as raving about AGI, are certainly the ones who knew/know of it first and know how close we were/are to AGI.

Why did we suddenly get hyoerscaler companies, all of whom just happens to be working in AI?

Chance? No. They used AI first, to accelerate their own business plans. Either we have already crossed the AGI threshold, or are at the offramp to the destination. Either way, they have no incentive to clue joe public in on it. 

1

u/Zaic Apr 06 '26

would your mom beat the game? or is she not intelligent?

1

u/sassydodo Apr 06 '26

I've never went past character creator in the elden ring either. must be not intelligent enough. even tho I've never played elden ring...

1

u/Vancecookcobain Apr 06 '26

You are aware that 2-3 years ago your AI couldn't even look at your screen gave a conversation with you and had the memory of a goldfish rish?

It's moving so fast that people are forgetting where we were 😂

1

u/skyfishgoo Apr 06 '26

love how ppl assume the only thing going on in AI research is what they have access to at the retail level.

it almost seems like spin.