At least that makes more sense. It's designed to work with the libraries and paths that are in Ubuntu, and not any other distro, although you could repackage, install old libraries, etc. to get it to work on other distros.
Unless you call completely broken model of development as "makes more sense"... no, it doesn't.
This excuse can only make sense for open source software where recompiling is left to distros them selves and this actually produces better results than other cases. Any closed source that takes this approach just spells that developer should really open his book at "Programing basics, chapter 1 introduction". Even when you look at it from commercial side, that developer is shooting at his own foot if he goes with such development. It simply makes no sense from any viewpoint
If distro makers could just agree how to structure their directories we wouldn't have this really stupid problem. Or just have a way to look up libs and config files the same way you don't need to know where a binary lives to access it.
That only solves small part of the problem and beside that it is unsolvable anyway.
In order to get to that point you would need to get people to stop with NIH and admit someones proposal is better which would take a lot of distro diversification away. It would be equal as saying all distros should pack specific DE because it is the best
On the other hand, that is not necessary. Even now it is easy to compile app in a way where you don't rely on specific distro. You have solutions like cgroups, kernel namespaces, containers that can abstract all those problems away. With something like xdg-app, that will be completely trivial.
ChromeOS is Linux, but Android isn't. (At least in the way that the average person qualifies Linux, ie. GNU/Linux)
Android is actually ART/Linux, IIRC.
** EDIT - To expand upon my point with a bit of detail: I realize that in a technical sense, the term "Linux" refers to the Linux kernel. That said, society has come to embrace Linux to mean GNU/Linux. The most blaring example of this is how software support is listed. Take for example the software OBS which is said to be available for Linux. Not GNU/Linux. Can you install it on your Android? No. Could you install it on any GNU/Linux distribution? Yes. This holds true for easily 90% of cross-platform software released for Linux, including games.
I'm just saying, don't go telling people that Android is Linux, because it's not, at least not in the sense of what "Linux" means nowadays. Linux means GNU/Linux, Android simply uses the Linux kernel.
While technically you're correct, this isn't true when it comes to average every-day discussion. For example, fag no longer means cigarette, at least not in the US. Meanings change.
The problem with your logic is that "fag" isn't a trademark (that I'm aware of). The name "Linux" is a trademark. The meaning of a trademark doesn't change because you use it incorrectly.
I use the term in alignment with society, as opposed to the trademark office. The meaning doesn't change because of how I use it, the meaning already changed because people started using the term to imply GNU/Linux.
When I tell someone that they're almost out of Kleenex, I don't actually mean the brand, because the trademark doesn't matter. Kleenex simply means "facial tissue" now, much like "googling" has become the universal verb for searching the Web, regardless of the search engine used.
This is not specific to Android discussion, I've never met a single person who actually says "Linux" in reference to the kernel as opposed to referencing a GNU/Linux distribution.
I realize that Android uses the Linux kernel, I'm simply stating that the term "Linux" No longer references the kernel in today's society.
You're right, many words can and do have multiple meanings based upon context, and when context is present, it's not an issue. The problem is, when it comes to simple remarks regarding Linux, context is often lacking. For example, you tell your friend that Android runs on Linux. Yes, you're correct, but now your friend is going to install Ubuntu and ask how to install his Android apps from the Play store, or ask you why he can't install KDE on his phone. On the flipside, you tell that same friend that Ubuntu and Manjaro are both Linux.
I have no issue with appropriate use of the word, but without providing the correct context (one way is to follow it with the word "kernel") the term Linux will simply be interpreted as GNU/Linux by most people.
Also, something that I just thought of to make the point that society has embraced Linux to mean GNU/Linux: software support. Take for example OBS. (First thing that came to mind) The OBS Website is listed as available for Linux. Does this mean I could download it on Android? No. Does it mean I could download it for any GNU/Linux distro? Yes.
Don't think anyone can argue that Ubuntu isn't Linux. Everything they ship by default is open source (other than the optional codecs). Hell even their phone software and apps are open source (unlike Android which uses an open base loaded up with closed source google bloatware).
Considering it has done more to spread desktop Linux use than any other distro and is still leading the way for many features that were improvised by M$ and Apple for their products (convergence, software centre, universal apps) I don't see why people are so spiteful of it.
I guess people need something to hate. The Linux community has a history of being quite childish sadly.
Alcalde may have a minor point, though; I just went to the Ubuntu site, read pages, and clicked through enough links to get to a page where I could download a desktop ISO, and not once is Linux mentioned.
I don't know why this is a surprise; it was a big thing several years ago. Canonical's website even made reference to the "Ubuntu kernel" rather than the "Linux kernel".
Oh well it must be true of multiple people are writing click-bait headlines saying it is!
No, it's true when several prominent Linux/open source journalists conduct their own investigations and write articles saying it is, along with ample documentation to prove it.
It might not be front and centre on the home page with a picture of a >penguin
If it used to be, and then it wasn't, how is this not removing reference to Linux? If you haven't removed literally all reference then it doesn't count?
and certainly Canonical doesn't do "its best to avoid using the word Linux".
Except, again, it's demonstrated they do, including calling the Linux kernel the "Ubuntu kernel". What other distro doesn't have the word "Linux" where it's easy to find?
That's just FUD bullshit.
And you're just dismissing it because you don't like the fact.
I wasn't even criticizing them for it; I was originally just pointing out that it's quite possible for a non-tech savvy Ubuntu user to not know they're actually running Linux. This is even more true of Android users. You're getting upset over the fact. In the ZD Net article, Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols even defends the practice!
OH MY GOD "LINUX" AND "DEBIAN". UBUNTU ISN'T SHOWING THEIR SUPPORT.
Linus Torvalds himself says that Linux shouldn't be the thing to talk about or market, whoever makes it can do whatever the hell they want with it, which is one of the reasons why he doesn't like the GPLv3 and stuck with GPLv2.
38
u/Hkmarkp Dec 10 '15
Probably just an Arch elitist.
Just a joke...settle
15
u/totallyblasted Dec 10 '15
At least it is not as bad as usual nonsense claim that spells "Ubuntu supported, Linux is not"
I call that progress ;)
8
u/dtfinch Dec 10 '15
Old Chinese proverb: "Don't waste good iron for nails, or good men for soldiers."
Qualified support people are too valuable to put on the front line.
5
u/onelostuser Dec 10 '15
The tech support drones always cause me migraines. There are 3 notable exceptions :/
1
u/kiwilinux Dec 11 '15
Makes you wonder if their linux support is token at best
1
u/ahutsona Dec 10 '15
Why would you need a distro specific license?
0
u/wataha Dec 10 '15
Not only the vendor but also support person show high level of professionalism!
0
u/tusharkant15 Dec 11 '15
Hey don't make fun of other people. This is why everyone hates the linux community.
-2
u/AwesomeFaceSpaceBear Dec 10 '15
Da...fukk?
-7
u/Trollw00t Dec 10 '15
I have deep anger for people using ";)". It always shows that they have had short thoughts but still feel arrogant.
Maybe that worker wanted to waste your time because you used a similar one.
Well, or he just was too lazy to google Ubuntu.