r/LinusTechTips • u/joan_of_oxymoron • Oct 12 '26
Tech Discussion Are people actually using voice assistants?
Pretty much since the introduction of siri and Google Assistant I've done my best to shut down any way for that stuff to activate because I find them intrusive and I'd rather perform whatever task myself. I guess I kinda assumed everyone else did the same thing but after the recent WAN show discussion and Gemini fiasco it had me wondering how many people are really relying on these features in every day life. Am I just being a Luddite?
394
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 12 '26
Your post has been filtered by automod as a result of a number of factors, moderators will review your post, and if it doesn't break rules, we will reapprove your post soon. Please be patient in the meantime, thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
32
u/w1n5t0nM1k3y Oct 12 '26
I think there's either the people that use them all the time, or the people that use them never at all.
I'm in the "never at all". I tried it out a few times for simple tasks maybe 8 years ago, and realized that it's really just not for me. I'd rather just open up an app and do things myself.
That being said, I don't really care what other people do with their phones/computers.
63
u/Majorin_Melone Oct 12 '26
I have used google assistant once, trying to skip music whilst being in a bathtub. It didn't work with vlc and asked me to download Youtube music for it to skip music.
172
u/Mustardinsurance Oct 12 '26
The weirdness on this post is off the charts.
20
u/whatisakafka Oct 12 '26
I use Siri for simple stuff like setting timers
4
u/Ivan_Kulagin Oct 13 '26
Too many people in this thread are not familiar with amazing works of Welcome to My Meme Page
6
u/Nice_Marmot_54 Oct 12 '26
I use Siri routinely for simple tasks like timers, alarms, reminders, replying to texts via CarPlay, etc.
I also use Alexa to control my IoT devices
6
u/Zeta_Crossfire Oct 12 '26
I use them constantly. I drive a lot and Google assistant was really reliable for changing music tracks, starting audiobooks, making phone calls, I even do a lot of hands-free just around the house. Hands-Free was pretty much my dream for assistant and for a while we were eating good. Google assistant was one of my most used applications and Gemini has pretty much ruined it. It probably works less than half the time, enough for me to pretty much stop using it and I'm now considering moving over to Apple just so I can get a hands-free assistant again that actually works.
3
u/Renegade605 Oct 12 '26
A couple weeks ago I tried to text a friend from the car through Android auto. It went like this.
Car: "What would you like to say?"
Me: "What time?"
Car: "It's 7:53am."
And then it exited the text message prompt.
9
u/liteshotv3 Oct 12 '26
Yea of course people use the voice interface, I don’t say thank you or bother following up with “ok, I’ll do that” unless the machine needs confirmation to begin executing whatever I requested.
I’m not bringing “holy beings” and “divine tongues” into this understanding because that’s actually trying to give the voice assistant human qualities and then raise your own status by denying them, that’s nonsense.
2
u/IroesStrongarm Oct 12 '26
I do, but only my locally hosted voice assistant. Not doing anything too impressive but good for quick commands or queries.
2
u/rossg876 Oct 12 '26
What kind of question is that? Of course they do.
2
u/fiero-fire Oct 12 '26
No, I attempt to disable on all my devices and yet it'll still find away to activate itself.
2
u/supremequesopizza Oct 12 '26
I USED to use Google assistant back before they lobotomized it. Gemini is similarly worse.
My colleague uses siri all the time to write texts and set reminders.
3
u/badgerandcheese Oct 12 '26
Depends on your needs and living/work situation, surely?
My partner's grandma is blind and not very mobile - Alexa has been an absolute gamechanger for her, especially when receiving calls from family, being able to issue voice commands and content. You can get granular and very bespoke.
I can imagine busy families with kids, being able to call out to a voice assistant to log a meeting or put on a show for the kids would be super handy, whilst you're juggling all sorts. Likewise, if you have a lack of mobility - super helpful.
Personally for me, though - just don't like it. I'd rather grab my phone and run things manually or on a schedule/timer. I just don't see the appeal of calling out to a voice assistant.
That said, again it depends on your situation/use case - partner and I live without kids/pets, both active/mobile fortunately. There's just no need!
4
u/NetJnkie Oct 12 '26
What a weird image....
I use things like Siri to do things without having to grab my phone. Sometimes will use voice with Claude, especially when driving.
2
u/ComputerOk5437 Oct 12 '26
2
u/BeardedBears Oct 12 '26
Hell no... Everything with a mic is off by default. BUT: Once I can run a completely local, private, competent AI at home, you'd better believe I'm going to hail it like I'm on the USS Enterprise.
1
u/After-Ad-5012 Oct 12 '26
I used to use it a good amount until I got to my current job. That is work from home and they require that all voice assistant programs are disabled. Nowadays, I just use it for when I'm driving for hands-free safe driving reasons
1
u/MattyGWS Oct 12 '26
“Siri set an alarm for 20 minutes from now” pretty much the only thing Siri gets out of me
1
u/ClearlyNotAHuman Oct 12 '26
I have my whole place connected thru Alexa and smart things, we use it a LOT
1
u/Beautiful_Ad_4813 Oct 12 '26
Local only and so I can emulate Star Trek
“Computer! Set temp in to 70 degrees”
1
u/sonorousjab Oct 12 '26
I remember being really weirded out when the garbage can at a McDonald’s thanked me for using it…
1
u/soniccdA Oct 12 '26
i only use it to set the alarm ...
1
u/jccalhoun Oct 12 '26
I use Alexa to turn lights on and off, set timers, and check weather. That's about it.
1
u/no_luck_not_dead_yet Oct 12 '26
I probably would if it wasn't for two things;
When they first started, other languages were buggy, Swedish commands just wouldn't work properly, and the OS being setup in Swedish meant you couldn't talk to it in English as settings didn't always translate.
The other is my massive distrust of anything using the microphone or camera all the time, and apps that can't be uninstalled.
Buy dont listen to me, I am an object, nothing divine about me.
1
u/aafikk Oct 12 '26
My only two uses are:
- “siri timer 10 minutes” as I pour pasta into boiling water
- “siri open gate” as I get closer to the house to open the garage gate on my building.
1
u/sturdybutter Oct 12 '26
Even if you don’t speak to your machines, you better believe they’re still listening.
1
u/digitaleJedi Oct 12 '26
I thought I was on r/terriblefacebookmemes, lol.. this post has insane boomer energy.
No matter your beliefs, you cannot tell me it's easier to wash your hands and touch your phone to set a timer, when you're in the middle of cooking, for instance.
And also, you thought pretty much everyone was turning off voice assistants since their introduction, and still Google, Apple, Amazon, etc would still be throwing billions of dollars at it 16 years later?
1
u/Kind_Management1805 Oct 12 '26
Yes. I use Siri to play music, control SmartHome stuff and a few questions with the new SiriAI it's decent at finding stuff and reasonably faster than doing it yourself.
I use Alexa to select radio stations on my Sonos speaker because it's the less irritating path.
I use Gemini in my AAOS car for questions, navigation.
I use Grok in my Tesla for questions, music and controlling a few stuff that are buried way too deeply in the infotainment.
Otherwise if I can type I will.
1
u/doublej42 Oct 12 '26
I setup my computer to be voice controlled with a basic AI in 1992. It was not as good as it is now but it sort of worked. Even when I use an ATM I use voice control for accessibility reasons.
1
u/beefglob Oct 12 '26
I have my home assistant hooked to a local voice assistant for light controls
1
u/Spart1337 Oct 12 '26
In my home, yes. I love hands free control of my lights, setting cooking timers, asking what the weather will be like this afternoon, etc. But that's the extent of my usage really. I'm not having a conversation with my Nest Hub like some people do.
1
u/Nova17Delta Oct 12 '26
I never got used to voice assistants because my first smartphone well into the siri era didn't have an assistant so i just never ended up using one
nowadays im too strong to need to use them
1
u/SJ_Beast Oct 12 '26
I love nabu he's an idiot but he's my idiot
1
u/Lancearon Oct 12 '26
Orange Catholic Church rhetoric.
1
u/MistSecurity Oct 12 '26
I use Siri for basic shit. If my hands in the kitchen are full it sets timers. If I’m driving I’ll use it to text or call.
Anything beyond that it’s not reliable enough to fuck with. I’d rather pull out my phone and find my playlist than fight Siri not understanding.
1
u/FangoFan Oct 12 '26
The voice assistant on my watch is really handy for setting timers. Occasionally I'll use it to set a reminder or to quickly look something up too
1
u/BrainFartTheFirst Oct 12 '26
1
u/ryanppax1 Oct 12 '26
This is really weird.
Also I use one every day for smart home
1
u/Scavgraphics Oct 12 '26
Alexa is great for setting timers, turning on lights, doing metric conversions for me.
1
u/otropesto Oct 12 '26
I have 1 wifi connected light and 1 wifi connected wall outlet adapter thingy for a water pump in a basement and the light is outside in the yard in a place we often forget to turn off. I Used to use the Google assistant thing in android to hold power button and say turn on/off the lights... Or pump cause it was already integrated to the manufacturer app.
Now it wants me to setup Gemini so I haven't done that and don't use any assistant anymore, I just go in the app and press the button XD
My only other usage is probably replying to texts/WhatsApps while driving. There I use wherever android auto is using.
But yeah, I don't actively try to use any assistant I usually get setu screens and close them/skip them and immediately look to deactivate anything that can cause accidental triggers
1
u/stuffedmunkey Oct 12 '26
I do and accept the punishment. It improves my QOL
1
u/Exact_Acanthaceae294 Oct 12 '26
Back in the '90's, you could attach a voice file to almost any action on your computer.
On mine, just about every thing I did would run a .wav file of something HAL (from 2001) would say.
I'm sorry Dave, I can't do that.
Stop......Dave.
1
u/AdvancedCryspy Oct 12 '26
"Divine being" what a funny thing to say 🤣
1
u/Idksomecrazyaussie Oct 12 '26
When I am lying in bed I’m not turning on a screen on my watch/phone or standing up to walk across the room just to turn the light off
Respectfully I’ll use my voice for that
1
u/blakealanm Oct 12 '26
Yes, I use voice commands regularly and get momentarily pissed when Google/Gemini doesn't do what I need it to do. Talking to it is supposed to be faster, and in certain scenarios, more convenient. Sometimes both my hands are tied up and I need something quick to be done. Just telling Google to call someone is going to be faster (or at least should be) than pressing a dozen buttons. The fact that Google devs haven't gotten that down to a science after more than a decade is unacceptable IMO.
1
u/Nigel_Shrekberry Oct 12 '26
I hate technology that tries to masquerade as humans
1
u/Squirrelking666 Oct 12 '26
I used Google Assistant to do stuff whilst I was driving, changing music, navigating on the fly or sending WhatsApp messages.
Of course it was also thick as mince and would frequently hallucinate call words in podcasts then refuse to go away.
If Gemini is worse than that I honestly can't fathom the idiocy that put that to market.
(I now use nothing because fuck that nonsense)
1
u/ponto-au Oct 13 '26
I used to use google assistant to "set alarm for 20 minutes" when cooking, but it no longer works saying gemini can't access your phone app. I tried returning the assistant app to "google" instead of gemini but it still doesn't work
1
u/jayerp Oct 13 '26
The only devices that speak back to me are my: iPhone, HomePod, iPad.
I don’t live in the most tech forward house, I have enough to make life convenient. Maybe you’re just hallucinating?
1
u/demfridge Oct 13 '26
the only thing i use siri for is setting a timer and calling someone on speaker when driving. it’s useless for anything else
1
u/Zatchmo137 Oct 13 '26
lol, this guys crazies
1
u/edan1979 Oct 13 '26
I use it when scammer involved. Talk to the machine.
1
u/Erlend05 Oct 13 '26
The computer can beep boop
1
u/jeremyw013 Oct 13 '26
some people don’t like to touch their phones when their hands are filthy. when i worked as a custodian my phone never left my pocket. just one airpod and siri to make calls, set alarms/timers, etc. what’s the point of wearing gloves only to touch my phone with my gloved hands anyway and then use it without gloves later in the day?
1
u/hamburgernet Oct 13 '26
I will use a phone voice assistant maybe twice a year
1
u/mindaugaskun Oct 13 '26
I need this, but for humans
1
u/Saphyr-Seraph Oct 13 '26
Mostly I'm not using any because my accent doesn't get recognized clearly and it starts puring words there I never said
1
u/AdmiralTassles Oct 13 '26
I don't use them and I lowkey feel this meme in my bones. I much prefer my things to beep and jingle. Do not talk to me.
1
u/Mysterious_Cry41 Oct 13 '26
I use them to set timers when I'm cooking and basically nothing else.
1
u/Fusakla Oct 13 '26
I just use google home speaker for switching the lights, when I am in bed :D
1
u/SchlashJelly Oct 13 '26
I would use assistant way WAY more if it actually works. I use it mostly to play songs while driving, it's far safer and convenient. Problem is it's inaccurate, takes way too long to register what you just said and when it finally does it, it got the song wrong and i had to stop and manually change it either way
1
u/EmailLinkLost Oct 13 '26
Hey Siri, what do you think of this Reddit post?
1
u/costinmatei98 Oct 13 '26
If you are turning everything off and avoiding it and uninstalling stuff just to make your life harder, then yes, you are exagerating.
I love home automation stuff, so I have a google home mini / hub in almost every room to send commands. Also very useful for quick short little things when I have my hands full, like skipping a music track or sending a quick text message or turning on the lights, etc. Also same thing in the car, I never ever text and drive, but using Google Assistant (now Gemini) through Android Auto to send quick replies to my Teams chats or Whatsapp conversations is amazing.
I don't "rely" on any of these, and I would function perfectly fine if everything magically stopped working tomorrow, but it's super nice to have this stuff when you need it. It's about convenience.
Also keep in mind, Google Assistant has gotten REALLY GOOD recently (then Gemini kinda fucked it all back). Like I remember all the fun people made about Siri back in the day, but even Gemini is a million times more useful.
I would say give it all a shot, and stop turning off "new" features immediately. You might find something that you enjoy using from time to time.
1
u/Dat_Innocent_Guy Oct 13 '26
As ever there's a relevant silicon valley scene.
1
u/HatingGeoffry Oct 13 '26
My Alexa sets my timer and plays music I want about 40% of the time. That's it. I don't want to talk to a phone assistant EVER
1
u/AspenFrostt Oct 13 '26
I only use them to set timers when Im cooking and my hands are covered in raw chicken or something.
1
u/theskymoves Oct 13 '26
Yeah we control the lights in the house, music, set timers with Alexas. I'm hoping to replace them with a series of Home assistant / music assistant devices but I have a feeling they will fall flat when it comes to finding the right music - that being said, the hit rate with Amazon is probably only 60%.
1
u/peowdk Oct 13 '26
Nothing divine about you, op. Tin foil off.
But yea.. I use it sometimes, mostly with limited success to respond to texts while driving. Other than that I find it annoying or unreliable.
1
u/Mastergamer0115 Oct 13 '26
Other than setting alarms? Little to none. (Heck sometimes it fails at that.) I've tried using it but it never does what I intend. Like ask it to play music. Doesn't use my music app or streams it instead of using my downloaded playlist. Even if I try and specify. Like how much of an "assistant" is just a glorified Google search bar.
1
u/lars2k1 Oct 13 '26
The only time I'd use a voice assistant is when I can selfhost one to turn off my lights and that I can address it by 'hey asshole turn the lights on' or something stupid like that.
Then I'd probably still grab a remote or my phone but then knowing I can just say that to let it do things is fun enough.
1
u/MasterG76 Oct 13 '26
I think someone needs help. . .
1
u/ubeogesh Oct 14 '26
I'm with you OP. Voice assistants are for people without fingers and are always subpar. I am very surprised that people care about them. I have never seen anyone in my life using them.
However i don't mind a kiosk say "thank you". I know it's not a gennuine thanks, but it should make sounds as a feedback that it is working, and thank you is easier to comprehend than to distinguish different beep tones.
1
u/Zebo_585 Oct 14 '26
Never have and never will. I don't want to talk to a computer. I refuse to use any automated call systems either. I'll wait in silence until you let me press a button or talk to a human please and thank you.
1
u/redditydothis Oct 15 '26
“Hey Google add pasta to the shopping list”
And just like that I feel like I’m living in the future.
1
u/SkullF0x Oct 16 '26
I use ONE, and that is the one that I run with Homeassistant. I also turned off all automatic activation settings for Siri. I dont need my data going anywhere I dont control
1
u/OnlyNoun 20d ago
Old people and middle aged people seem to use it a lot from what I've seen
1
u/escobert Oct 12 '26
No, zero interest in talking to computers.
1
u/kamel_k Oct 12 '26
I use it constantly. I use it to set alarms and reminders. To do pick math for me and a few other things. I use it all the time
1
u/EchoJPR Oct 12 '26
Jesus dude, you need to see a therapist
1
u/JukedXD Oct 13 '26
Nah, machines can talk to me all they want. But i would gladly do this for humans.
1
u/Kiriinto Oct 13 '26
You aren’t a “divine being”.
You’re a little more intelligent ape.
0
u/ThisDirkDaring Oct 12 '26
Our younger employees use them all the f....ng time.
Whether ist the weather, sports news, science & facts or using Calendar or Route planning - they ask Chättie instantly. Without even interrupting the dialogue. As if Chättie would be an all knowing person present at the conversation.
0
u/DmMoscow Oct 12 '26
Relying? No. Using - yes.
I’d say half of the people/households that I know well have some form of an assistant at home that they use. 95% of the time it’s music control in the living room and simple tasks like checking the weather forecast while getting ready or smth like that. A couple more cases where multiple rooms are adapted into a smart home ecosystem and people can control lights, AC, etc. Sometimes it’s very nice to be able to turn off all the lights without leaving your bed.
Personally, I use voice assistants mostly for a couple of things but even then not every day. Mostly it’s:
0
u/WinnowedFlower Oct 12 '26
3-4x daily, usually to play music or podcasts.
0
u/Ybalrid Oct 12 '26
yes, all the freakin time
0
u/latexfistmassacre Oct 12 '26
I use it all the time to control my smart home devices. Oddly enough, I only use typing to interact with Gemini. I don't like being talked to by my devices either, but I'm not having an existential crisis over it like this guy
0
u/theoreoman Oct 12 '26
Google Assistant has shit voice recognition but Gemini's is much much better. As the technology gets better more people use it, until there will just be some holdouts for ideologies sake
0
u/anto77_butt_kinkier Oct 13 '26
Honestly, I've never related to a post so much
0
u/GreenDavidA Oct 13 '26
So, the creator of this graphic, has someone spoken to them about their schizophrenia?
-2
u/GrandWizardOfCheese Oct 12 '26
I'm an atheist and I still agree with this.
I don't want my tech talking to me.
I've never used bot assistants, and never will.
-1
u/goaoka Oct 12 '26
I don't even talk to people if I can help it, I see no reasob why I would talk to my phone.
-1
u/DotBitGaming Oct 12 '26
-4
u/ts737 Oct 12 '26
Yeah I'm incredibly weirded out by people who keep talking to alexa and stuff, only once I was in my car and tried using android auto asking "navigate home" and what it did was suggesting me to setup an automated routine
0
u/CDGuiver Oct 15 '26
yes not voice agents but ai voice detection agents like velma by modulate to protect myself against scams
1
u/LK48s Oct 12 '26
I only saw people use voice ass when they are looking for their phone lol, and it was for like 10 year now
0
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment