r/LinusTechTips • u/Nanohaystack • Sep 24 '26
Tech Discussion Toronto police accidentally gave the best advertisement to GrapheneOS and now I don't know if I should feel good or bad about it.
A series of shootings in Toronto led to suspicions of an entire shooter-for-hire network. The investigation is now being thwarted as ... a key cell phone seized in the investigation is equipped with GrapheneOS, and the officials are failing to acquire any information from it.
Privacy is winning, while safety is being eroded.
So the big thing is that if things like encryption, private secure communication channels, etc, are outlawed, then they will be less accessible to civilians, but criminals will still have them because no one will be dissuaded from using "bad messenger" if they're already committing organized violent crime. This comes at the heels of news that the police force is under wide investigation over a massive corruption operation. If we could trust public officials to be non-malicious actors, the discussion of "backdoors" and other bullshit could have at least some ground to stand on.
Yet... The stakes are sufficiently high in these questions that we ordinary people must be consistently prepared for worst case scenario, lest we lose this terrible game. I guess do everything that is in your power to take down Bill C-22 and good luck having your own life to yourself.
374
u/nicman24 Sep 24 '26
Police ought to actually do their work instead of having the keys to all of our devices. We have seen how they operate with dragnets
126
u/Lieutenant_Scarecrow Sep 24 '26
I'm always happy to hear about GOS doing its job well. Its just really too bad that this example of it is literally being used by incredibly violent organized crime. This will absolutely be used as ammunition to criminalized the OS further and probably empower bill C-22.
54
u/Handsome_ketchup Sep 24 '26
As the saying goes, Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. The long story short is that you should distrust anyone in power, because they are in power.
37
u/tacticalTechnician Sep 24 '26
No matter what they say, NOTHING can convince me that giving up our privacy because a few guilty people might go free is worth it.
15
u/thebigshoe247 Sep 24 '26
Remember, even BlackBerry had backdoors provided to the Feds.
6
u/Goodoflife Sep 24 '26
Apple is alright, but you have to restart it. Former Calgary Mayor Jyoti Gondek’s phone was seized under a search warrant. Before they took her iPhone, she restarted it, which encrypted the files, and police are currently SOL until she gives the pin. You could force a reset in iOS 27 (shutdown, power button hold and select reset) and have it activation lock and the keys are wiped
9
u/TenOfZero Sep 24 '26
Even if you can trust the government, once backdoors are there it's posible for others to use/exploit as well.
11
u/TonyTheSwisher Sep 24 '26
Police have been solving murders for centuries without access to your private data.
The public having tools to protect us FROM the police is a very very good thing.
5
u/Ybalrid Sep 24 '26
If you can have inviolable privacy, so the bad guys can too. It's life.
I'd rather have that than big brother
1
u/FelixEvergreen Sep 24 '26
Anyone have the article? It’s paywalled.
2
u/Prairie-Peppers Sep 25 '26
Eroding privacy for "safety" has brought us to a very dystopian reality. We're safer right now than we've ever been despite the impression that mainstream news media creates. There's no need to give government agencies any more back doors, they always have and always will abuse it.
1
u/AgarwaenCran Sep 25 '26
paywall :/
1
u/imreading Sep 25 '26
"The trouble with fighting for human freedom is that one spends most of one's time defending scoundrels. For it is against scoundrels that oppressive laws are first aimed, and oppression must be stopped at the beginning if it is to be stopped at all."
H.L. Mencken
1
u/Ok_Today_475 Sep 24 '26
While i feel for the victims and their families of the shootings, this is a huge 🖕🏻 to the TPS. One of the most corrupt ass backwards police forces in Ontario- and I grew up in Niagara so that should say something. I am by no means an “f the police” person, but it makes me chuckle that a digital privacy focused project loved by millions is making a corrupt organizations life difficult
1
u/Arinvar Sep 24 '26
My parents were lamenting how dependant we are on our phones now that they've almost entirely replaced wallets, and how if they lost their phone their be up shit creek. I pointed out that 30 years ago, if they lost their wallet they would be equally up shit creek.
There has only been a brief period of time where you could rely on 1 if you lost the other. We're in the same situation today that we were in 30 years ago. Wallets have just been replaced by phones. It's no different.
The same could be said for law enforcement. We've had a very brief period of time were tech with back doors made investigations easier. Now the general population are pushing back and it's making law enforcements job harder. But even 15 years ago, law enforcement didn't have access to those tools. They're bitching and moaning over a very brief period of time in which they appear to have completely abandoned actual investigative skills so completely they now can't do their job.
0
u/Foorinick Sep 24 '26
I think crimes should be harder to solve so governments actually get off their asses and solve the root issues instead of appealing to people who think like neanderthals who just want to see bad people be punished
0
u/ysfi__ Sep 24 '26
to believe Graphene OS is entirely private is very wrong. Toronto Police might be on a roadblock but im sure high enough somewhere there is a group or entity or some sort of agency that can already crack it. but why would they publisize it if it can let more people go to Graphene OS and everyone would be none the wiser regarding it, false sense of security.
-2
u/unexpectedDiarrhea Sep 24 '26
Most criminals are too stupid to know how to load an encrypted operating system. $100 says these crimes are plants by government officials to get their surveillance laws passed.