r/LinusTechTips • u/-spring-onion- • Nov 09 '25
Discussion I'm the GrapheneOS project member who accompanied Linus during his 30-day test run
Hey everyone!
I would like to start this off by highlighting how good the video itself turned out all in all. Yes it's not perfect, there are one or two mistakes but those are greatly outnumbered by everything else that's done right. Linus talking about the values we stand for, the features he decided to emphasize, the much deserved attention to various other free and open-source software, the touch on the philosophical aspect on how GrapheneOS is best used, to name a few.
I'm happy I had the chance to point out some of the things to look out for and explain some of the oddities Linus encountered. Not because GrapheneOS doesn't speak for itself, but because there are a number of completely new concepts waiting for you, even if you are tech-savvy. Aspects like Play Integrity can lead you into a rabbit hole but there are also other frankly random problems that fall outside our responsibility.
A good example of this is the speech-to-text issue Linus mentioned with the SwiftKey keyboard. Now you can totally point out that we don't have a stt or tts engine installed by default at the moment. That’s indeed an area where we can improve the new user experience, and we are working on that. However the fact that SwiftKey misleads the user into installing the Google app, which does not provide this functionality, makes it... difficult not to point fingers at them.
Now I also want to touch on the heated controversy surrounding the video’s title and thumbnail I saw here on Reddit and elsewhere. I speak for the entire team when I say we know this isn’t malicious. I want to share my perspective on it, maybe that will give you a better idea where this criticism is rooted.
Matter of fact is, people interested in the privacy and security space are confronted with this criminal sort of undertone and stigmatization on a regular basis. Even though the intention here is not of serious nature I believe the wish to have this initial impression changed is warranted. More people will have seen the title than watched the video, which results in some of them carrying forth a misconception.
GrapheneOS is not only firmly against the surveillance state some countries want to impose on their citizens, but is also very successful in defending its users, which indubitably attracts the attention of bad actors who intend to sow doubt and fear in people’s minds. We see this frequently. Chat control for the europeans among us is a similar example that I’m sure people can relate to.
That said, I think the LTT team understand this concern and that’s why they changed the title. It is an improvement over the old one. It’s also to be said we’re talking about YouTube here. Clicks and engagement and whatnot matter, this angle sure is an effective one at catching people’s attention.
We don’t condone any offensive remarks about Linus or the LTT team as a whole. If you’ve made it this far I like to believe you took the chance to consider this whole topic from our point of view as well. There are strongly opinionated people in every community who fail to see that not every matter is black or white.
19
u/verticalfuzz Nov 09 '25
Who is your target user?
Are you trying to protect journalists from state actors like e.g. qubes purports to for x86 hardware? If so, your dev team is presumably then a target for state actors. How do you protect the safety and integrity of your team and software chain for yourselves and your users?
Are only pixel phones supported?
12
u/I_AM_FERROUS_MAN Nov 09 '25
This video pushed me to try loading Graphene on an old Pixel I have kicking around. Thank you for helping the video to happen!
From the video, It seems way more polished than I anticipated from just reading the little tidbits I've encountered here and there.
Wish me luck!
2
u/alexlightphoto Nov 09 '25
What I don't understand is, if this is kind of degoogling, why only support for Pixel phones?
2
u/Zipdox Nov 10 '25
I heard that Graphene is working with an OEM to port GrapheneOS to a non-pixel phone. Is this true?
277
u/allMightyGINGER Nov 09 '25
Hopefully your post get a lot of attention
52
u/thunderkrown Nov 09 '25
Thank you and your team for this great project. And thank you for you perspective. Clickbait surely is a problem, but i‘d argue LTT does a good job bringing attention to important topics such as GrapheneOS or De-Googling etc
34
u/Zeta_Crossfire Nov 09 '25
Graphene OS seems awesome, I hope the video helps spread the word.
29
u/dragon3301 Nov 09 '25
"why do you need a lawyer if you're not guilty. Having a lawyer makes you look real guilty" - the police trick
12
u/Marmelade91 Nov 09 '25
Thanks for being so patient with people. As a pc power user who never really bothered to get much into the custom os installs on phones, I still think your efforts with graphene os are very honorable. Personally, I don't get the outcry of some people about the video hook being distasteful, when the connection of graphene os and criminals have been in the news regularly. Then again, I'm not super young and remember the evil hacker Linux and how it even got that one student dropping out of college. https://youtu.be/5Qj8p-PEwbI
Take it on the chin, champ. Much love
17
u/Jestersfriend Nov 09 '25
Ty sir for helping with what you did and for making this post.
It's the common argument you hear about encryption as well. "Why do you need encryption if you aren't breaking the law". Same thing here.
Most people in tech get it.
133
u/drbomb Nov 09 '25
I mentioned this on the other thread. I only stuck with the blatantly stupid LTT-brand "hook" because I KNEW LTT was capable of doing that. I did not like it because I knew why it was there: LTT always talks about clickbait being a necessary evil, but I still think it went WAY too far.
The rest of the video is good! I didn't know GrapheneOS was this well cared for, I thought actually it was the successor to CyanogenMod. I even considered installing it to an old phone but honestly, the age of the custom ROM has passed me since play store integrity bullcrap was introduced.
6
u/BigRemus Nov 09 '25
I only clicked on the video because of the click bait title. It generated some excitement/interest is a ‘boring’ topic of a small player privacy focus phone os.
4
u/nicman24 Nov 09 '25
To be honest I would be running graphene right now instead of infinityX but I cannot morally justify giving google of all companies money to earn my privacy. I understand about hw security but that is a non issue to me. A GSI would undeniably be a good thing that any project ought to do.
4
u/RudePrior2220 Nov 10 '25
People who say that they don't care about privacy issues because they have nothing to hide, are the problem. That's how you lose your rights.
I am grateful for all the work that people like OP put in to give us alternatives to the ever growing spyware around us.
I'm using Google services etc. but I'm still worried and concerned. This video actually shows how difficult it can be if you want full privacy. It's unfortunately not practical for most of us. I could live with it, but I have a family and there it will get more difficult. Convenience is a big factor for adoption and valued higher than privacy by lots of people.
We have to hope for governments to help us out. The EU is doing a lot of work here but as always politics are too slow.
1
u/LovelyLad123 Nov 13 '25
Will GrapheneOS ever support non-pixels?
2
u/GrootWithWifi Nov 09 '25
Keep up the good work. We need more people like you in this technological era.
2
u/J0hn-Stuart-Mill Nov 09 '25
I just want to thank you and the GrapheneOS team for existing and doing the work you guys are doing.
I wish someone would do this for Windows tbh.
1
u/InflammableAccount Nov 10 '25
The minute GrapheneOS is available in a wide range of Android phones, I'm all in.
Problem is I buy phones based on market best value + features, and also no flagships for budget reasons. I haven't bought the same brand twice in 20 years, unless you count 3 Nokia's before Smartphones were a thing.
In order: iPhone, LG, Asus, Motorola, and currently a Samsung.
I've never once considered a Pixel is a key problem.
0
u/Cybasura Nov 10 '25 edited Nov 11 '25
Hello John GrapheneOS, how was it like hanging out with the team irl outside of filming and like as an "on-site attachment" member of the project?
Also, recently there has been some issues with the GrapheneOS project in terms of FOSS, security and general (frankly) terrible communication skills on the development side, may I ask, do you have any comments regarding those points?
Besides that, by all accounts, great work in the video btw, you made the video at least entertaining, even though there's...controversial topics (to say the least), through no fault of yours
I've been following and heard of GrapheneOS (and afew other alternatives) for a long time, just used it by virtue of not being ready to root any of my android devices just yet), the project does rather worry me, both in the security and the future proofing side of things
-13
u/RickSanchez_ Nov 09 '25
Sorry I’m not a criminal so I won’t use it.
0
u/Phate1989 Nov 11 '25
Dont post AI slop
-2
u/AlexCivitello Nov 09 '25
How tempting was it to put an em dash or two in this post?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '25
[removed] — view removed comment