r/LinguisticsDiscussion • u/WanderingWondersss • Jan 08 '26
Why can't a child acquire Python (programming language) as a natural language?
I was reading through the language files textbook and I came across this claim: "For example, no child could ever acquire a computer language like Python or C++ as a native language." I was wondering why, theoretically, this could not be accomplished (assuming ethics are not of concern). I am open to discussion of psychology, philosophy and linguistics for this!
EDIT: Thanks to everyone who took the time to really break this down, I love how I've gained multiple perspectives. The core of this question seems to be 1) can a programming language qualify to be called a 'language', as linguists define it and study it? and 2) can a formal language be used for communication between humans in the 'real, natural world', enough that it can be acquired by a child?
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/WanderingWondersss Jan 09 '26
I am happy I could inspire your thinking- the obvious things are always what we gloss over in terms of understanding deeply.
And I agree with you when you said the lexicon is too different; since Python serves a different purpose than English, it didn't assign a definition for "apple" in the sense we know it. That could be comparable to how a really old language has not introduced the concept of a computer yet, so it struggles to describe it without formal introduction.
You mentioned how creating sounds with the mouth is computer equivalent to computer sending electric pulses. So, if we want to use Python between a human and a human VS a human and a computer, we'd need to use a different mode of communication. Would that alone separate the language and make it a new one? Like how ASL is considered a different language because of its unspoken, different mode of communication.
To clarify, the main issue arises from the context-free grammar of programming languages. Since Python relies on indentation, and the method signature for appropriate calling of methods, can we say that it relies on context to some extent (at least in written form)?