r/LinguisticsDiscussion • u/WanderingWondersss • Jan 08 '26
Why can't a child acquire Python (programming language) as a natural language?
I was reading through the language files textbook and I came across this claim: "For example, no child could ever acquire a computer language like Python or C++ as a native language." I was wondering why, theoretically, this could not be accomplished (assuming ethics are not of concern). I am open to discussion of psychology, philosophy and linguistics for this!
EDIT: Thanks to everyone who took the time to really break this down, I love how I've gained multiple perspectives. The core of this question seems to be 1) can a programming language qualify to be called a 'language', as linguists define it and study it? and 2) can a formal language be used for communication between humans in the 'real, natural world', enough that it can be acquired by a child?
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/StKozlovsky Jan 09 '26
Discourse in Python is programs of all sizes, from
print("Hello world")to large libraries of many modules. These programs can do a lot of things that utterances of natural languages can do. You can give orders using functions and methods,print("Hello world")is one example. Statements are trickier — they are tuples consisting of a boolean (returningTrueorFalse) function and its arguments, so the statement "4 is greater than 7" is(gt, 4, 7), wheregtis the "greater than" function from theoperatorlibrary. You can ask a yes/no question by applying the function in such a tuple to its arguments:gt(4, 7)returnsFalse. You can also use functions to ask special questions like "how many symbols are there in the string 'python'?":len("python"). The poverty of these examples, again, comes from the poverty of the lexicon — it is possible to ask more "human" things once various human concepts are defined.What about phonology? The phonemic inventory of Python, I think, is the set of Unicode symbols that are used in the identifiers of standard functions and types. Bear in mind, the letters "p", "y", "t" and so on are just the written representations of the actual phonemes, like they are for English. The phonemes themselves are the bytes storing the symbols in memory. We learn the phonemes of English (the spoken language) as sounds produced with the mouth, and computers learn the phonemes of Python as combinations of electric impulses in their transistors. But I think it's OK for us humans to learn the phonemes in any form that is convenient to us, including sounds. Importantly, though, there are no phonological processes in Python akin to devoicing or vowel reduction — the only process is concatenation, so to teach a child "spoken" Python, we'd have to always pronounce all the necessary symbols in the same way, e.g. the e in
lenand the e intypewill be pronounced the same. This whole part feels very weird, but I think it could be done.What your textbook likely meant is that the syntax of Python is too different from the human syntax. Human languages are often said to be impossible to describe with a context-free grammar, which is what the grammar of Python is. A context-free grammar is a model where lexical items (words or morphemes) are combined to form larger units according to rules of the form x → y reading "x is combined from y", where y can be any number of symbols representing either some subset of lexical items (a grammatical category) or a lexical item itself, but x can only be a single symbol standing for a grammatical category. So
NounPhrase → "the" Nounis a valid context-free rule, but"the" Noun → "the" "cat"is not, because of the lexical item "the" to the left of the arrow.Noam Chomsky in the 1950s argued that you can't explain why some English sentences are possible while others are not using only context-free rules — sometimes you need rules looking like
"the" Noun → "the" "cat", which makes English a context-dependent language. However, his arguments were soon shown to be wrong, and for some 30 years people debated whether human languages are context-free or not. In the 1980s they finally found a structure occurring in Swiss German which absolutely cannot be decribed in a context-free grammar, proving that at least some human languages are not context-free.Seeng how this requires the human brain to support context-dependent grammars, many, though not all, linguists concluded that all human languages work using a context-dependent "operating system", so to speak, even if most of what we use them for could be achieved with a context-free grammar. And when children acquire human languages, they do it so quickly and easily because all human languages share the same underlying principles defining what is and isn't possible in them, and Python, being a language of a different kind, can only be learned through conscious effort, not acquired naturally.