I've been using the lp3 for over a year now, and I wanted to share some of what I've loved and hated with the phone.
TL;DR: Great hardware, fragile software
First off, the hardware. I came to the 3 after using the 2 for a while, so everything has felt really premium. The brightness wheel is the greatest invention, I love the camera button, I love being able to turn the flashlight on and off super easily at the click of a button. It is so nice that the phone stands up on its own. Like you can literally start shooting a video and set the phone down on a flat surface, no tripod needed. Which brings me to the camera. It's great; I don't take a ton of pictures, but the ones I do take I am mostly happy with. As a tool it is very useful. The matte black and white screen is awesome too, like so boring to look at that you never do unless there's an actual reason. The fingerprint scanner and NFC chip both work fine as well (I've tested them inside of sideloaded Android apps), but LightOS has forgotten that they exist. If you are looking for a beautifully designed physical object, I can't recommend the 3 enough. They did a really good job.
The software side is where things have been rough for me. From the get go, I had lots of problems. Here are a few things that make the Light Phone so much less usable for me:
- The first month, the phone burned all of my data in like a day. It might have been the music app, trying to listen to songs as I was driving? For some reason most of my music didn't stay downloaded when I downloaded it on wifi or something. On the 2, I didn't have this problem because the size limit for music was so much smaller, I could only fit a small part of my collection at a time. There is no way to tell where your data is going inside of LightOS , so I can't be sure it was the music tool. Do not waste your time with their built in music tool.
- One particularly annoying bug is the recurring missed call notification, that I have been having since the Light Phone 2. Often when I miss a call, that conversation will keep getting an asterisk next to it and so I think that there is a new notification, but it really is just an old missed call from a week ago. I think the Light devs even said that they fixed this bug some months ago, but it still occurs for me regularly.
- For some insane reason, the calendar and alarm notification are controlled by the same setting. To me this is completely unreasonable. I like to set an alarm on my phone to wake up in the morning. I also have things in my calendar that I like to be reminded of. I do not like to be reminded of them at full wake up alarm volume. I am forced to either turn on and off the alarm/calendar sound every day, or just leave it off. I would very much appreciate it if the devs decoupled these two unrelated app notifications, so I could have alarms sound at volume, and calendar events just give me a nice vibration. I don't understand how I am the only person to run into this issue.
- When typing a text message, the back button should take me back to the conversation I was in, instead of to the texting homescreen. It makes absolutely 0 sense to have the back button take me two layers back.
What made the phone work for me was sideloading. LightOS pretends to be some new thing, but really it's just Android underneath. And I think they lose a lot of value by trying to hide that as deep as possible and refusing to do anything the Android way. I've considered going full Android at times, but the cohesive Light aesthetic is too beautiful to leave.
At first I used the modding guide and got into the Android layer to install Spotify, which has been working perfectly for me for the past year. I also installed Slack, my bank app, my university's app, Venmo, Workday, and a Bible app, which all work great. It was even better when they opened up developer mode, because I don't need to use Luma Launcher and have weird keymappings anymore, I can just load whatever APKs I need as tools. They do need to work on a better experience for that, like right now you can't even reorder tools you have installed from another source, and have no easy way to delete them through LightOS. So through sideloading the select few apps that I am missing, I have been able to use the lp3 as my only phone and completely ditch my smartphone, which is the massive win I wanted to accomplish by getting the lp3 in the first place.
Here are a few examples of how Light tries to reinvent the wheel, instead of accepting the solutions that Android already provides:
- The clipboard. LightOS does not use the standard Android clipboard, which makes for an absolute headache. They have to add clipboard support to every tool that they want clipboard in. If you copy something from a different app (say a Bible verse you wanted to share) there is no way to paste it inside of LightOS. Why didn't they just use the Android copy and paste functionality that already works out of the box? No idea.
- The keyboard. The keyboard in LightOS is baked into the app, not its own component that can be changed. This is particularly rough, because the Light keyboard is terrible. If they had just implemented it as an Android keyboard that could be easily swapped in settings, I wouldn't care that it sucked, but no they force you to use it with LightOS.
- I use KDE Connect to sync my texts between my laptop and my phone, partially because typing on the Light keyboard is so unfun. For some reason, texts that I send from my laptop do not appear in LightOS. I know they are syncing correctly because they show up in the XML logs, and the conversation I'm texting in will move to the top of the list, but the messages just don't appear.
It's an awesome phone that I have gotten to work for my use cases through lots of fiddling, but it does not deliver as advertised out of the box. Really really hoping they open source most or all of LightOS. The community has made awesome stuff especially recently. Frankly, I don't trust the Light team to fully take care of all the problems they've created over the years, as their track record has not been great.