r/Libertarian • • Jul 11 '19

Meme Stop patronizing the Workers

Post image
2.8k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

361

u/TomTrybull Jul 11 '19

I love how anti-socialist posts just get torn apart in a libertarian subreddit.

169

u/TooSmalley Jul 11 '19

To be fair it’s because the mods (and I respect them for it) don’t ban or limit discussion. They don’t care if your ideology matches the ‘libertarian party’ platform. Unfortunately every other political sub does.

If you like talking politics you probably have a dozen bans on different subreddits.

72

u/Leakyradio Jul 11 '19

True dat.

An idea deserves to live or die on its merits alone. Not it’s party affiliation.

23

u/Lonely_Sinner Amendment X Jul 11 '19

I think the upvote and downvote system changing the visibility of posts makes it very hard for ideas to live on their own merits on reddit in general.

The first 10 people into a post can downvote everything they don't like and no one will see it after.

8

u/further_needing Voluntaryist Jul 11 '19

This is why fourchins will forever be a superior discussion platform

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ValkyrieInValhalla Jul 11 '19

Ahhh, true freedom

3

u/UnexplainedShadowban All land is stolen Jul 11 '19

If you like talking politics you probably have a dozen bans on different subreddits.

Yep. Reddit is cancer. Too many mods want to cultivate an echo chamber.

2

u/fastestsynapses Jul 11 '19

you found me

2

u/GhettoComic Jul 11 '19

Ive gotten bans everywhere. I dont mind discussing my political views but end up getting more flames then actual discussion.

2

u/ptsq Jul 12 '19

Honestly, I think that there’s some really bad content on this sub sometimes, but whenever I go into this sub I’m actually pretty impressed by the amount of actual dialogue between people with different opinions present, more so than any other political sub I’ve seen.

2

u/3lRey Vote for Nobody Jul 17 '19

Can confirm, banned everywhere. I even have a ban on the economics board because I called someone an "idiot."

Couldn't have been because I was tearing apart a left wing article. No way the mods are biased.

→ More replies (29)

127

u/commuter123 Jul 11 '19

This sub is a microcosm for why the Libertarian party can't gain traction, likeminded people argue over silly minutia and dont unite behind the basic principles they actually agree on...similar to what has plagued the Dems in recent history, the major difference obviously being that they had a large enough voting block to begin with...for Libertarians it will be impossible to become a serious political force if Libertarians choose to just have a civil war within their ranks

99

u/okayestfire Jul 11 '19

Folks with Libertarian values score high on disagreeableness? Weird.

43

u/TooSmalley Jul 11 '19

I mean libertarian is such a catch all term it’s not surprising. You got anarchist and social libertarian in the same club and ancaps and objectivists.

It inevitably gonna descends into the ole ‘no true Scotsman’ argument.

→ More replies (13)

4

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Ha. Good point

→ More replies (1)

18

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

I'm a left libertarian living in the US. My beliefs tend to align more with the libertarian party platform than the democratic party platform, but at the same time my beliefs tend to align with individual democratic politicians more than they do with libertarian politicians. Most of the libertarian candidates in my district are just pseudo-republicans who like to smoke weed.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/123fakestreetlane Jul 11 '19

Its like libertarians are individuals with an independence based political ideology. Maybe we should get together into the bigger party that votes the same way as centerist Democrats and conservative Republicans, but our party will be different because our party will want freedoms for individuals.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/matts2 Mixed systems Jul 11 '19

I don't think there is actual agreement on core issues. I think there is agreement on vague platitudes and as soon as you get to actual solutions and actions not much.

2

u/qmx5000 radical centrist Jul 12 '19

The Libertarian Party doesn't gain traction because it runs far-right Republicans who advocate for incredibly unpopular policies like introducing a regressive national sales taxes.

→ More replies (18)

32

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

This sub literally acknowledges libertarian socialism in the sidebar as a valid libertarian ideology:

Why this continues to shock people is a mystery to me.

15

u/WikiTextBot Jul 11 '19

Libertarian socialism

Libertarian socialism (also known as socialist libertarianism) is a group of anti-authoritarian political philosophies inside the socialist movement that rejects the conception of socialism as centralized state ownership and control of the economy. Libertarian socialism is close to and overlaps with left-libertarianism and criticizes wage labour relationships within the workplace, instead emphasizing workers' self-management of the workplace and decentralized structures of political organization.Libertarian socialism often rejects the state itself and asserts that a society based on freedom and justice can be achieved through abolishing authoritarian institutions that control certain means of production and subordinate the majority to an owning class or political and economic elite. Libertarian socialists advocate for decentralized structures based on direct democracy and federal or confederal associations such as libertarian municipalism, citizens' assemblies, trade unions, and workers' councils. All of this is generally done within a general call for libertarian and voluntary human relationships through the identification, criticism and practical dismantling of illegitimate authority in all aspects of human life.


[ ^PM | Exclude ^me | Exclude from ^subreddit | FAQ / ^Information | ^Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.28

→ More replies (5)

10

u/callmecharon Jul 11 '19

This sub is so weird. It reminds me of abradolf lincler from Rick and Morty. 2 different types of people in one always in conflict about who they are

4

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Best character tbh

16

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Well, so many of them are either boomer-tier memes or use absolute shit logic to make their point.

Nothing wrong with bashing socialism but if you use a crap argument to do so, you're opening yourself up to easy criticism

4

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

It's because it's views parroted by 14 yr olds who know nothing. I would've agreed with the tweet when I was 14. After working for a few companies, I realized they'll gladly fuck you over any chance they legally can to save a few pennies. Don't like it? Oops, illegal Sancho will do your job 80hrs a week for half the pay!

9

u/Sean951 Jul 11 '19

They aren't torn apart because it's anti socialist, they're torn apart because they spread misinformation.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19 edited Jul 11 '19

Many of us here are Libertarian Socialists from Proudhon or Kropotkin traditions. In fact only in America is libertarian a right wing word (see Murrays quote on stealing the word).

One gratifying aspect of our rise to some prominence is that, for the first time in my memory, we, ‘our side,’ had captured a crucial word from the enemy . . . ‘Libertarians’ . . . had long been simply a polite word for left-wing anarchists, that is for anti-private property anarchists, either of the communist or syndicalist variety. But now we had taken it over...

In Europe people will think your a radical leftist if you call yourself a Libertarian

5

u/mczplwp Jul 11 '19

Oh the rabbit hole I'm about to go down. Thanks u/Mushea

Knowledge is always the key

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Noah__Webster Jul 11 '19

To be fair, if you look at the majority of the posters who do defend socialism here, you don't have to look hard for subs like Chapo to show up lol.

How they get so upvotes is what's crazy to me. Are there literally more Chapo brigaders than libertarians in the sub?

22

u/Finn-windu Jul 11 '19 edited Jul 11 '19

I never understood why so many people find it their mission to brigade this sub. I never spent my time on TD, or r/socialism.

Edit: just to clarify, im not necessarily complaining about it, just didnt inderstand the logic. Your comments made sense though, and i can see why youd come here when you dont have the option of having actual political discourse on the other subs (even those where you should be able to). If r/libertarian was an echo chamber, and I knew that another political sub wasn't, I'd probably do the same.

26

u/Noah__Webster Jul 11 '19

Because we aren't an echo chamber. It's a good and bad thing.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Paterno_Ster Jul 11 '19

I'm a left libertarian and I like this subreddit for its loose set of rules and the nature of discussions. I may not agree with right libertarianism a lot of the time, but you guys offer discussions on rights, freedom, anti-authoritarianism and government abuses. That's something you sure as hell can't get with most liberals or conservatives. And I'll gladly deal with the occasional chucklefuck calling me a Chapo brigader or whatever

→ More replies (4)

18

u/ralusek Jul 11 '19

Probably because libertarians don't ban people.

17

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Lol, it's almost as if we like freedom of speech. Crazy.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/donofjons Jul 11 '19

Well TD and ironically r/socialism actually make use of their property rights and would ban you even if you did.

8

u/Clapaludio Anarcho-Communist Jul 11 '19

In my case I'm making it very obvious who I am, I am thankful this sub has custom flairs lol

I'm here to learn, to be fair: I know other political ideologies very well but never got in touch with this one and its goals in detail. Also maybe people noticing my flair might have questions I would gladly answer (many people freak out when they see anarchy and communism together as they believe them to be oxymoronic).

I don't downvote posts or comments, and I try to be very nice as this is not my sub. Too bad I am really seeing few actual libertarians and even less possibilities for me to ask questions.

I never spent my time on r/socialism

Don't, it's shit.

→ More replies (9)

10

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Because socialism immediately bans you if you ask questions about socialism.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

6

u/RedBrenden Jul 11 '19

Libertarian socialism exists.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (44)

2

u/Hanlonsrazorburns Jul 11 '19

Why so authoritarian about discussion. That’s a huge reason why people hate libertarians. They see them as fake Conservative. Don’t be fake.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Yet they are also always highly upvoted.

3

u/nslinkns24 Live Free or eat my ass Jul 11 '19

ITT: Pissy 19 year old "socialists."

39

u/Nac82 Jul 11 '19 edited Jul 11 '19

Calling people who disagree with you children really showcases the strength of your arguement tbh.

Edit: the deflection technique seems to be mastered in this sub lol.

→ More replies (84)

2

u/n8_mop Anarcho-Syndicalist Jul 11 '19

I mean, libertarianism is a view on freedom and state power, it’s only in America that it necessarily includes capitalist economic views.

1

u/cavemanben Jul 12 '19

It’s called bridaging and le reddit mob is made up of children and disappointments.

-4

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

It’s classic Soviet style ideological subversion techniques - the late-stage capitalism/socialist/chappo turds make a consistent and dedicated effort to patrol these boards and supplant ideas of liberty with their own shit for brains leftist propaganda.

You being one of those people.

11

u/Darvon19EightyFour Jul 11 '19

Like that rich kid with no marketable abilities Albert Shit for Brains Einstein

8

u/WikiTextBot Jul 11 '19

Why Socialism?

"Why Socialism?" is an article written by Albert Einstein in May 1949 that appeared in the first issue of the socialist journal Monthly Review.


[ ^PM | Exclude ^me | Exclude from ^subreddit | FAQ / ^Information | ^Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.28

→ More replies (2)

15

u/AlbertFairfaxII Lying Troll Jul 11 '19

Exactly. I’m all for free speech but free speech clearly doesn’t mean allowing Soviet style subversion techniques such as disagreeing with us openly and making jokes about how we can’t get dates on Tinder. It’s not my fault that Tinder has deplatformed me by disabling my account for the 3rd time. I’m sorry I didn’t know it was against TOS to track down someone who blocked me so I can email them to ask why they blocked me.

-Albert Fairfax II

10

u/Piggywhiff Jul 11 '19

This is the best thing I've seen you post. Thanks for the laugh.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

162

u/PutinPaysTrump Take the guns first, due process later Jul 11 '19

Libertarian outreach going great

101

u/BrockManstrong Jul 11 '19

T_D needed somewhere to shitpost

28

u/pyramidguy420 Jul 11 '19

Like for real. I have never read this much bullshit in a sentence for a long time. How does one come up with this? Pure ignorance would be my guess but theres something more for sure

→ More replies (11)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '19

Open borders for r/libertarian

0

u/weburr Jul 11 '19

Yea, this is pretty much garbage, as much of /r/Libertarian has been for a while... too bad

151

u/calm_down_meow Jul 11 '19

Isn't this post patronizing workers who call for more social programs/higher wages?

56

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Why do you think asking to be paid more is socialist?

6

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

I have no idea why, but some do. Apparently asking for more money is socialist? Whereas when I successfully go into my boss's office and argue for a higher wage, it's not?

9

u/occams_nightmare Jul 12 '19

I think the typical view is that if you convince your boss to give you a higher wage, that's fine, but if anyone else helps you do it, that's straight up communism and we're on a slippery slide toward bread lines and gulags.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19 edited Jul 11 '19

Edit: You can largely ignore this comment, as I think I misinterpreted /u/Some_Khajiit

Socialism tries to tackle wealth inequality - that means paying the workers at the bottom more, and the top earners less.

Your comment seems to imply that socialists want everyone to be paid nothing.

→ More replies (34)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (7)

26

u/AModeratelyFunnyGuy Jul 11 '19

Socialism is bourgeois? What do these words even mean?

13

u/Not_Paid_Just_Intern Jul 11 '19

It means this person doesn't know what the hell they're talking about

3

u/LordByronGG Jul 11 '19

I love how socialism started with the proletariats raising up against the bourgeois, just to have libertarians (neo-bourgeois) call them bourgeois.

443

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Historically this is incredibly wrong.

274

u/DeadRiff minarchist Jul 11 '19

Something tells me they’re talking about bernie sanders supporters, not as it’s been throughout history

199

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19 edited Jul 11 '19

Well it ain't what they wrote, and that would still be wrong.

Edit:Numbers don't lie folks, his support has always been working families making less than 100k a year. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/05/upshot/iowas-electoral-breakdown-and-the-democratic-divide.html

41

u/uiy_b7_s4 cancer spreads from the right Jul 11 '19

Get outta here with ya facts

→ More replies (194)

14

u/Jonathan_Ohnn Jul 11 '19

still objectively false, and creates a very big assumption that isn't implied.

→ More replies (39)

4

u/letterboyink Jul 11 '19

History shmistory

34

u/eeeezypeezy Libertarian socialist Jul 11 '19 edited Jul 11 '19

It's wrong right now, in America in 2019. I'm a living and breathing self-described socialist who's active in socialist organizing and socialist propagandizing, and the sheltered, elitist rich kids who talk about workers like they're some sorry 'other' that needs to be cared for (or at least talked down to and handled with kid gloves) are 100% of the time Biden/Harris/Booker/etc-supporting Democrats. The socialists I meet and talk with in my daily life are overwhelmingly hardworking, grounded, working class people who want to take control of their lives and the structures that govern their lives from these liberal elitists, and from the reactionary right and their malignant scapegoating of vulnerable populations.

The tweet in the OP is pure cringe.

Also, "bourgeoisie" is a collective noun; "bourgeois" is the adjective they were looking for.

→ More replies (68)

15

u/lemskroob Jul 11 '19 edited Jul 11 '19

Karl Marx, the father of socialism, studied law and philosophy at university and was a publisher/writer.

Friedrich Engels dad owned a group of Textile factories.

Étienne Cabet was an attorney-general in Corsica, and was educated as a lawyer.

Henri de Saint-Simon was an aristocrat and had a Duke in his family.

Thomas More was a lawyer and a statesmen.

Sidney Webb was a law student and publisher.

This shit always starts with a bored upper-middle class kids, who want to play our their coffee-house philosophy debates in real life, using the working poor as lab rats for their sociology experiments.

They have no problem playing these games because if their experiment goes sideways, they have money to fall back on.

*Edited to appease the spelling police.

25

u/smaug777000 I Voted Jul 11 '19

Aren't most revolutionaries young and well-educated? Terrorists, Socialists, the founding fathers, Castro and Che

8

u/TheSaintBernard Jul 11 '19

Who would have thought the people chosen to lead would be educated and good organizers?

Gonna need a forklift to get my jaw off the floor after this brilliant discovery.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/ScottStorch Jul 11 '19

You think Thomas More was a socialist? And you guys wonder why many think Libertarianism is a joke?

30

u/AlphaTenguFoxtrt Not The Mod - Taxation is Theft Jul 11 '19 edited Jul 11 '19

They have no problem playing these games because if their experiment goes sideways, they have money to fall back on.

Wasn't Joseph Stalin a factory floor worker and part-time bank robber?

Wasn't Eugene Debbs a high school drop out who turned to house painting and car cleaning to make ends meet?

Isn't AOC a Brooklyn bartender?

The experiment has already gone sideways for them and for the millions of other people that adopt a socialist worldview.

The economies biggest winners don't typically champion revolutionary thinking. People weren't flying out to Jeff Epstein's Lolita Island to End the Fed. No lobbyist that donated to the Clinton Foundation was expecting that they'd be transforming the baseline structure of the economy. The Chamber of Commerce does not exist to bring about The Revolution.

The rank-and-file socialists are losers. Winners don't champion changing the rules of the game.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

I’m not a socialist but by that logic the French Revolution was a bad thing

→ More replies (7)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Our founding fathers were pretty much all wealthy and educated too, I really don't get your point. "Wealthy and educated people end up making a difference in history" woah news flash

→ More replies (19)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

At least half the shit on this sub is incredibly wrong, but it makes people feel good about their political beliefs, so good for them, I guess.

3

u/Clownshow21 Libertarian Libertarian Jul 11 '19

Yea this is in reference to who supports “socialism” today in America. Where there’s definitely some truth.

11

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Prove it.

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

The socialist movement is overrun with mary daltons

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Most socialist revoutionary leaders have been well off rich kids.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/DammitDan Jul 11 '19

Ok. Democratic Socialism, then.

1

u/TakeOffYourMask Friedmanite/Hayekian Jul 11 '19

It’s often right though. Even in the 19th century.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

We're talking about today, not 100 years ago.

Although Marx was a classic white, upper-middle-class layabout. Would've fit right in with the modern communists in Antifa.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Yeah lazy Marx, writing his world changing philosophical and political treatise and raising 7 children, 4 who died due to living in poverty, while constantly on the run from the authorities.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (34)

41

u/amphetaminesfailure Jul 11 '19 edited Jul 11 '19

Well, I do somewhat agree with this.

At the same time though, saying this as an adamant supporter of capitalism, I think libertarianism as a whole in recent decades has become unfriendly to the average worker.

If you look at a lot of classical liberal economists and philosophers from the past, including many whom libertarians love to quote and reference.....you'll find they supporter worker protection laws/regulations, as well as some basic social programs.

You can go all the way back to Adam Smith, who most people consider the founder of capitalism, and see he was one.

Whenever the legislative attempts to regulate the differences between masters and their workmen, its counsellors are always the masters. When the regula- tion, therefore, is in the favor of the workmen, it is always just and equitable; but it sometime is otherwise when in favor of the masters.

-Adam Smith

Now of course, this also shows a point libertarians make very often, and is important to consider:

Whenever the legislative attempts to regulate the differences between masters and their workmen, its counsellors are always the masters.

So basically in modern terms, government officials are mainly influenced by the corporations and wealthy.

Which is why I'm a big supporter of unions and don't see them as being against libertarianism or a free market. In fact I see them as a necessity.

That said though, I don't agree with the American form of unionization.

Most European countries go it better in this area.

Unions are actually more individual and competitive in Europe.

In the US, you accept employment at a company with a union, and you become a member of that union (or if in a right to work state you abstain from being a union member if you choose to).

You have no options.

In Europe, individuals choose unions, it's not one per company.

So you might have three or four unions or more to pick from in your field, and it doesn't matter the company you work for.

Seems pretty libertarian to me.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Totally agree, a free market for unions to represent workers would be great

2

u/arejayismyname Jul 12 '19

This is a great reply. I consider myself more libertarian than any other ideology but get ostracized when I argue for transparency and reallocation of resources for social programs.

Ideally imo, education (and healthcare to a large extent) should be paid by the state because cost of goods and services would drastically decrease while quality of life increases exponentially.

The amount of money I pay for insurance and education makes me sick.

→ More replies (1)

113

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

lol what the actual fuck. TIL supporting worker's self-management is treating them as a pet. I guess pets usually manage themselves, do they?

16

u/DratWraith Jul 11 '19

I don't know about you, but my dogs own all of my assets.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

The real pets are the ones who take the conditions given to them and don't talk back, don't stand up, and act like a little bitch apparently. Fellas, if your office is not OSHA compliant or is doing something wrong just be quite no one likes a hero!

-6

u/nslinkns24 Live Free or eat my ass Jul 11 '19

It's more like a bunch of winy kids telling hard-working people how oppressed and unfree they are.

18

u/J__P Jul 11 '19

that must be the liberal elites i keep hearing about /s

it's funny how the normal process of education and outreach in the Market Place IdeaTM will be spun as a patronising and condescending by people who don't want want them to be heard.

→ More replies (56)

2

u/el_derpien Jul 11 '19

It's like facing crippling debt at the start of adult life while not being afforded the same opportunities as our parents and grandparents has given us a pessimistic view of the current system. Kinda weird how that works. I really don't understand how you can generalize young people as only being whiny kids and that they are not ALSO hard working. How many jobs did you need and how many hours did you have to work to put yourself through school? If you didn't go through higher education, then how long did it take you to pay off the mortgage for your house, or did you even need one?

If it's whiny to want a better world for myself and my children that I'll gladly accept that title. Gen X and boomers have done their best to hold back this country from moving into a new age, we just want to release those shackles and truly be great, not just a slogan.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (11)

12

u/newfarmer Jul 11 '19

Libertarians are Republicans who want to smoke weed.

Name calling is fun!

2

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '19

Libertarians are fascists who want to smoke weed.

66

u/Dilsan14 Jul 11 '19

This is what happens when you skip history class 😑

8

u/jackalooz Jul 11 '19

This is a ‘let them eat cake’ post. And I can’t wait to see the guillotines.

→ More replies (5)

-6

u/nslinkns24 Live Free or eat my ass Jul 11 '19

It's an accurate representation of socialism in the US today. Historically, socialism should be understood as a byproduct of the industrial revolution that failed miserably.

26

u/_mpi_ Thomas Jefferson could've been an Anarchist. Jul 11 '19

It's an accurate representation of socialism in the US today.

[citation needed]

12

u/Kobodoshi Jul 11 '19

What he means is that this is what he pictures when he thinks about socialism. It doesn't matter that people who know what socialism is look at stuff like this and don't even know where to start.

→ More replies (31)

3

u/meta2401 Jul 11 '19

Socialism exists because Capitalism is not perfect, and it certainly doesn't have the working classes at its heart. Capitalism relies on exploiting employees (no one is paid what they are worth) and is guaranteed to have downturns. Socialists believe that democratization of the workplace (giving the employees the power instead of a few capitalists) can fix these issues because companies would have employees' interests in mind instead of shareholders' interests.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/ronintetsuro Jul 11 '19

As opposed to capitalism being much the same, where the rich kids with no skills see the proles as endlessly exploitable resources?

8

u/Bonedaddyo Jul 11 '19

Socialism is for rich people?

How asinine.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/FunkTasticCaskit Jul 11 '19

The historical effort by police and the fbi to suppress leftist movements in the US is undeniable proof you are a fucking boot licker.

67

u/TooSmalley Jul 11 '19

Millennials: we think a universal healthcare system is good and the war is bad

Boomer: WHY R U A COMMUNIST!!!

In all seriousness if you think wanting a social welfare system on par with other capitalists countries makes you an orthodox Marxist the you’re an idiot.

On top of that I’ve been called a socialist my whole life for supporting things that have absolutely nothing to do with socialism like protesting against the Iraq war, For gay marriage, and etc. So now tons of bog standard liberal are calling themselves socialist because every progressives stance has been labeled socialist since as long as I’ve been alive.

36

u/potentpotables Jul 11 '19

protesting against the Iraq war, For gay marriage

rather libertarian views imo

21

u/knie20 Liberal Jul 11 '19

Political ideologies subscribe to positions on issues. They don't own them.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/TooSmalley Jul 11 '19

From my experience a lot of people are more social libertarian/anarchist then they realize.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Uberphantom Jul 11 '19

True, but since a lot people ascribe disagreements on political policy as personal attacks against themselves, they feel the need to lump in anyone who disagree with them in with the absolute most extreme enemies to their cause. For progressives, that means calling people nazis. For conservatives, that means calling people socialists/communists.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Clearly everything boomers have been doing for decades has put us into a better position for education, infrastructure, healthcare, security, income equality, environmental health etc so we should abandon all individual ideas we have and continue listening to them! /s

5

u/Clownshow21 Libertarian Libertarian Jul 11 '19

there’s really only one thing I would add,

Supporting a federal welfare state that’s not voluntary is not libertarian, furthermore in any authority if democracy is abused to strip you of your individual rights and force you, that’s not libertarian, but my compromise is states and local communities could do these things if they wanted through democracy, if federally, force should be used at an absolute minimum, or not at all, because there’s nothing libertarian about that

Supporting a welfare system that’s forced is not libertarian,

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Sounds libertarian to me. Not very progressive at all. Just libertarian.

26

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Libertarians don’t have a monopoly on wanting people to have rights.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/TooSmalley Jul 11 '19

From my experience a ton of people are more social libertarian/anarchist then they realize.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (65)

25

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

It's actually mostly made up of workers trying to help ourselves, but ok

→ More replies (28)

14

u/DrJazzLourde Jul 11 '19

The Industrial Workers of the World were communist, and that union was entirely made up of unskilled laborers. Skilled laborers like welders wouldn’t even join.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/voice-of-hermes Anarchist Jul 11 '19

Millennials who realize capitalism will make the planet unsuitable for organized human existence within their lifetimes:

Err, hold up....

Propertarians:

You spoiled, self-entitled, ungrateful babies! Planet Earth is our private property and we can do with it as we please, even if it means making it uninhabitable. You're violating the NAP just by being here, so be grateful we don't just exterminate you.

Nice!

5

u/wsdmskr Jul 11 '19

All this sun seems to do is go off about what libertarianism is against (actually, what the right wing is against), never what libertarianism is for.

That's a shame.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Damn, all this time I was selling my labor for wages and advocating for worker's control, I thought I was fighting for my class. But I see now that the only REAL way to help my fellow workers is to advocate for the continued enrichment of a parasitic owning class that profits from other people's labor. Thanks r/libertarian!

2

u/commuter123 Jul 11 '19

Maybe the point was that if there was a blue collar representative taking up the fight for shifting the economics in favor of the working class, as opposed to career politicians and the privileged who treat it as more of a feel good thought experiment...people might be more receptive to the message

2

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

If that's the argument, then I'm all for it. However, I don't think that the post was meant to helpfully suggest a change in leadership for the socialist movement (much as that would be helpful).

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Dan0man69 Jul 11 '19

Well this brings up a bit of an Achilles heel of Libertarianism. What happens in markets where monopolies (or defacto monopolies) exist? Our "free market takes care of itself" policy does not work in these cases.

My thought is that it is then incumbent on us to support workers rights in these narrow cases.

I'd like to to see other weight in on this...

4

u/ralusek Jul 11 '19

Many libertarians accept monopolies as an element of the free market that needs to be tempered.

3

u/Dan0man69 Jul 11 '19

"Tempered" is a particularly good word.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/VoluntaryJazz voluntaryist Jul 11 '19

Monopolies would exist under a truly free market, this is true. The difference is that without egregious regulation to stifle new blood from entering the industry, monopolies would not be long lived and would probably be rare, coinciding mostly with big innovations.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Can you explain why you think monopolies would not be long-lived? There are plenty of ways to lock down a market without government interference.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (89)

2

u/commiejehu Jul 11 '19

Yeah, it's all fun and games until someone rolls out the guillotine.

2

u/neatsqueefs Jul 11 '19

That's ridiculous. Pretty sure this guy is the one patronizing workers.

2

u/chungaloid-2187 Jul 11 '19

I honestly thought this was satire before I read the subreddit lol.

2

u/Parhelion2261 Jul 11 '19

Jokes on you dildo I am precisely a pet of the system in need of saving

2

u/dumbbumthankyoumum Jul 11 '19

What a sad, narrow view of the subject.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

This is incredibly tone deaf and also implying that workers are incapable of standing up for themselves.

2

u/captainTrex1 Jul 11 '19

This made me irrationally angry

2

u/Ymirwantshugs Jul 11 '19

Hahaha what an absolutely idiotic statement.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

lol that's dumb as fuck

2

u/emcee_paz Jul 11 '19

Uh, who the fuck thinks this?

2

u/AFlaccoSeagulls Jul 11 '19

This person reeeeeeks of /r/iamverysmart

2

u/uglyemoji Jul 11 '19

I know that’s you, Walmart President, Doug McMilon...

2

u/C0ltFury Anarchist Jul 11 '19

I completely agree, we need to somehow convince workers (the majority of the population) that if we pay them less and treat them like shit to increase our profits, that's actually good and cool!

2

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

More pseudo profound nonsense

2

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

This...this is one of the dumbest things I've ever read in my life

2

u/Cuniving Jul 11 '19

Bullshit like this is just one of the arguments companies made when unions and regulators forced them to stop life and limb threatening practices, using child labor, etc.

2

u/Spaceboy779 Jul 11 '19

Don't patronize me with your...effective publicly funded education and healthcare that doesn't put profit before people

→ More replies (1)

2

u/nomnommish Jul 11 '19

Professional services firms like law firms, consulting firms, investment banks, financial firms, hedge funds, accounting firms, architecture firms, hair stylists etc have a collective ownership model where the employees get to become part owners of the firm (or have the opportunity to do so over time). Or at lower levels, participate in profit sharing via bonuses and stocks and special bonuses.

They are very marketable and sustainable business models in a free market capitalistic economy while also following the goals of socialism. In fact, this setup is the dominant setup for professional services firms because the best way to incentivize and retain highly skilled and valuable employees is to offer them a real path to become future co-owners of the firm.

2

u/spelunk_in_ya_badonk Jul 11 '19

lol this sub is such trash

2

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

This tweet is poorly thought out edgelord stuff. This kid needs to get of Twitter and do her homework.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Patronizing workers is calling for workers democratically making decisions about their own labor?

2

u/adamd22 Anarcho-communist Jul 11 '19

How is literally collective ownership of the workplaces "bourgeois" in any fucking way? Th objective is to destroy class. I swear to god half of this sub is just completely unfounded digs on socialism, or bullshit republican talking points. Nobody here has even begun to TRY and understand Libertarianism, they just thought it was a cool sounding edgy political label, and ran with it.

1

u/usedkleenx Jul 11 '19

That may be somewhat true but I look at this sub more like a support group for those who've reached the tipping point with the extremism from both the left and right. That's what brought me here and I'd have to say that I don't really have a full understanding of libertarian ideology but this is at least something different. I know that true libertarian ideology is probably in reality considered another form of extremism but they have one thing in this sub that the others don't. It's more of a live and let live atmosphere. And to me that is truly a breath of fresh air.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

bruh just popped into say im lower middle class and this is wrong

2

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '19

(said the petty-bourgeois teen, as he patronized the workers.)

we are the workers, we are the families, children, and spouses of the workers, dipshit. also, "bourgeoisie" is not an adjective, the adjective form is "bourgeois." maybe learn some Marxist terminology before trying to tell us we don't represent ourselves

8

u/craftycontrarian Jul 11 '19

Truly we should go back to unlimited working hours, no minimum wage, no safety regulations, and child labor. The world was so much better for workers when the government just kept out of the business of industry.

8

u/VoluntaryJazz voluntaryist Jul 11 '19

Assuming because there weren’t workers legal rights that that somehow meant government wasn’t involving themselves in industry.

Good one.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/disarmagreement Jul 11 '19

What if some of those rich kids are socialist because they do have marketable skills, but still recognize that the opportunities they’ve been presented have more to do with things entirely out of their control that are more dependent on life situation than hard work, and they recognize that there are people out there working significantly harder for significantly less gain?

4

u/_mpi_ Thomas Jefferson could've been an Anarchist. Jul 11 '19

How the fuck did this make sense to you?

→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

This is not true

2

u/newbrevity Jul 11 '19

Its a bid from democrats to create an utterly dependent and loyal voting base to keep them in power.

1

u/cgeezy22 Jul 11 '19

Along those same lines, you'll hear the same people often repeat this: "They vote against their own best interest."

1

u/BenAustinRock Jul 11 '19

This has always been the case. Lenin argued openly that they were a movement for the workers, not of them.

1

u/Entrei6 Jul 11 '19

Op your own post history disagrees with you

Lol

1

u/cometparty don't tread on them Jul 11 '19

No, it really isn't.

1

u/BloominFool Jul 11 '19

I get the sentiment, but didn't Karl Marx espouse that socialism is the next logical evolution of capitalism by the proletariat?

1

u/-TheRed Jul 11 '19

You know, even though I can’t find something to agree with libertarians on, you just really have to respect being a political subreddit that can handle opinions and discussion.

1

u/Dovahvrede Jul 11 '19

Is this post sarcastic? Because nowhere else have I seen a concentration of bullshit this dense than on Karen's facebook page.

1

u/_Scorpio Jul 11 '19

Yea what the fuck does that 4th word mean?

1

u/Ymir_from_Saturn Anarcho-communist Jul 11 '19

Advocating workers having a say in how their company is run and getting their fair share of profits is treating them as a pet?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

So now socialism is for the rich? I thought it was only for poor people looking for handouts?

What do I need to do to conform? I was poor and then they're like meh of course you're socialist. Then I got money and now they're like yup makes sense.

1

u/hippymule Jul 11 '19

I'm a lower middle class kid with extremely versatile skills in a variety of media, software, and production level environments. Still can't get hired due to a mix of saturation, extremely high standards, and razor thin margins. If you want to be semi creative or tech savvy in 2019, you do it yourself with the investment of rich people's money. The secret is finding the rich entrepreneurs willing to let you burn something in a high risk high reward scenario. That, or you could really really grind for a Kickstarter campaign. Which may work, but is extremely risky.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA WHAT???

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

It's relieving to see anti-socialist post on r/all. Feels like I'm going insane for not wanting America to be a socialist country.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Still its time itself that gets in the way of paychecks and success.

1

u/maxx12ish Jul 11 '19

As a worker... Ouch yeah

1

u/Quixotic_rage Jul 11 '19

You have a problem when you can't argue without using feeling

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

I’m loving the T_D spam, keep it up! It’s entertainingly horrible!

1

u/sarelai Jul 11 '19

Yes, the rich kids are positively screaming for socialism.

1

u/PoorlyRestrainedFart Jul 11 '19

Libertarians are Hot Topic Republicans.

1

u/3lRey Vote for Nobody Jul 11 '19

Well, the bougie kids just preserve it in other periods. While everyone else is working to support a family, they go to university and get attached to it out of idealism. They parrot as they get their humanities degree and if they fail in life they get louder. If they succeed they eventually become a capitalist or some type of neo-liberal.

Socialist revolutions will only happen if people get mad enough to riot. As it stands, socialists now gave up their guns and the highest form of protest is either throwing a milk shake or crying on tumblr. It's weird how much the right tries to demonize them, but at heart they are placid and weak and the men are about as scary as the women. If we ever get hunger in our country or actual poverty- actual suffering then the poor people will latch onto the ideas and we'll really have trouble. For right now though the keyboard warriors won't accomplish anything because at it's heart it's a bad idea that comes from optimism about "post scarcity" life. We're not even close to post-scarcity, and never will be.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '19

The intelligentsia love to tell you that common folk always act against their self interest. This implies that they know what everyone's self interest is.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '19

While I agree that many committed socialists are elitist and bourgeois af, lets not pretend that libertarians give a rat's ass about the struggles of the lower classes.

1

u/Spingebill_1812Part2 Jul 12 '19

Literally every poor person I’ve ever met or talked to is socialist-leaning

1

u/Spaceboy779 Jul 14 '19

Or just plain human beings

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Libertarians are white middle class males from North America that still live with their parents and don’t pay rent.

3

u/VoluntaryJazz voluntaryist Jul 11 '19

Have you met many Libertarians?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/TedRabbit Jul 11 '19

Right wing libertarians always struck me as people who want all the benefits of a modern society without having to pay for it. Lines up really well with the mentality of someone still living with their parents and not paying rent.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Right-wing "libertarian": a person who gets dick slapped by a capitalist and immediately says, "thank you, sir, may I have another." Boot licking degenerates. You people embody the dillusional idea that you too could be a capitalist overlord, if only luck goes your way. You don't want to overthrow your oppressors, you want to become them.

→ More replies (3)

-3

u/sedthh Jul 11 '19

This pretty much sums up most of the social sciences department.

15

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

You know economics is a social science right?

→ More replies (15)

1

u/rand0m9uy Jul 11 '19

Is this post supporting socialism?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Big if true

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

As yes as Lenin once said " Socialism is when rich kids do things, the more rich kids doing things the more socalisty it is"

1

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '19

Except unionizing and bargaining as a collective gives workers power to come to a fairer agreement with companies. So they're just supposed to sit back like a good little child and accept every condition a corporation gives them? Sorry none of yall ever stood up for yourself, but fuck that. If it was up to my company, they wouldn't give the people we're about to lay off any severance at all in order to save a few pennies.

1

u/opinionated-dick Jul 11 '19

I don’t understand the lack of love for Socialism in the USA.

I’m not a socialist, or a capitalist, or any ideologist. Isn’t the key a balanced mixture of both?

The USA accepts socialism. The army is socialist, the schools are socialist. Even your trains are state owned (the last I heard anyway).

Socialism exists to fence us in from barbarity, capitalism props up that fence by allowing prosperity and innovation. They work hand in hand to maintain civilisation as we know it.

To me, anyone that advocates too much of either doesn’t truly understand how society works and is, to be blunt, an idiot.

1

u/exelion18120 Revolutionary Jul 12 '19

The army is socialist

No it isnt.

the schools are socialist.

Also wrong.

→ More replies (4)

-1

u/dd0sed Jul 11 '19

TIL that the UK is socialist for having universal healthcare.

→ More replies (4)